Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Mists Over Carcassonne Better Than The Original?

Transcript 15:04

arcanova wingspan Evadale is anybody there what is this game it's terrifying what is all that racket if you really wanted to play this tile placement board game all you had to do is ask oh blimey

g'day everybody it's Danny here from board game sanctuary I'm a board gamer from Australia if you love sharing my passion for this hobby especially with beginning players with my friends my family and of course you I am in love with carcassoon it's probably one of my first gateway games that I ever purchased and because I came from a background where I was really into fantasy maps and the idea of building a different map each time in a competitive puzzle experience was something that I really loved about the original game I have a strong Affinity with the original game because at my wedding it was like my guest book where I bought a brand new box of carcasson tiles had all my guests write their messages at my wedding and every time I get it out to play I can relive that special day but also build cool maps at the same time now when Miss of Carcassonne kind of hit my radar I was like hmm can you play Carcassonne cooperatively I always saw it as a competitive game and I think I entered this with a sense of trepidation but before we start let me explain how to play and I'll let you know my thoughts when I go to sleep there's often a game that pops into my dreams or should I say my nightmares the fear of drawing tiles in Carcassonne unknowingly aware that my fate will completely rest in it is truly frightening each time you place in Carcassonne should continue the shared landscape in some way whether it be extending a windy road or expanding the

next piece of the castle whatever happens you can always choose to dedicate a meeple to that feature and when completed in the future you'll be able to score it Mists over Carcassonne has helped me to overcome my fears as it's a fully Cooperative game phew yet it is instead replaced that fear with anxiety hear me out as I introduce you to these ghostly fiends as you work together with the other player Mists will appear on the tiles that you draw and that you place that feature these transparent looking ghouls each time you place a tile with mist on the map you'll place the number of ghosts on the tile as shown if you ever run out of ghosts to place you immediately lose the game oh by the way did I mention that there's only 15 of them that's literally like eating one strand of spaghetti and calling it a full meal there are ways to hose away the ghosts in the game without calling Ghostbusters that is to seal off the Mist if you can seal off the Mist you can remove all of the ghosts contained within it giving you room to breathe a little for now additionally each time you connect or expand a Mist you put out one less ghost sounds easy doesn't it that is until the cemeteries appear looking for a castle strategy oh my goodness it's a second turn and I drew this triple ghost tile and I've already got five ghosts out on my field I really have no choice but to expand

the Mist because that's going to mean I'm only going to be able to put two ghosts out instead of three Brew tool this is brutality symmetries are a new type of tile that attracts ghosts each time you would place a ghost anywhere on the map you must also Place one additional ghost on the cemetery this accelerates your rate of Doom so quickly it's like watching flies at a funeral that hasn't even happened yet to seal the Symmetry off you need to place tiles on all four sides and then bury one of your meeples from the map right into it I know this is getting a little bit morbid right

that pink meatball is probably one of the best moves I made in the entire game may your soul rest in peace I can't go on sorry all right everybody I think we have a little bit of a problem here oh my gosh so the weirdest thing happened to me I drew literally all of the ghosts and I needed this one tile to surround the cemetery to clear the six ghosts they're currently haunting it and guess which tile I drew this one this is the piece of D resistance it's gonna go right next to the cemetery and I'm back in this game baby right here and now that symmetry surrounded orthogly I'm also going to drop a little meeple here just school that region later and then I will take all these ghosts so satisfying A Haunted House Works similarly to the monasteries from the original game except they help you score based on how many missed tiles are surrounding it however they don't do anything to help you with the ghost infestation finally the game is now separated into six different levels of difficulty easy and super super super super hard future levels introduce hounds which help you to clear tiles of ghosts there is also another version where the amount of tiles that you have in a stack is a timing element where you need to score certain points by a certain moment in the game other levels amplify the power

of the cemeteries by making you place flipped over carcassone tiles preventing you from building on certain edges of the main map to win the game of Miss over Carcassonne you need to work together to earn a certain number of points this is a ghastly game of ghostly decisions that may not seem as transparent as it might first seem day one and I've just unboxed myths over carcassoon I know this is going to be a fun and enjoyable experience hi everybody it's um day three of playing Miss over carcassoon and I'm really enjoying the multi-lay level of strategy I love the nice Nuance tweaks between each of the different levels including those cemeteries and how crazy they can get so it's day eight and I haven't been outside in like over a week now uh the reason being is this game I'm so addicted to it there's just something about it but the challenge is so high that I just can't stop playing it who knows when I'll see the daylight next is this my life now uh so it's like day 25 and people are wondering like where I am I've been trying to squeeze in as many of these games as possible just because I really just want to beat it um it's like a game of Mario when there's a level which has really tricky

obstacles you just go at it and try and try again just until you get that win I unfortunately haven't had that win yet not for a couple of weeks now it's like day 50 of playing myths over Carcassonne and I don't know if I can count how many times I've tried to beat this game is it possible to win a game of Miss over Carcassonne someone out there please tell me can you do it I've been trying for days weeks months I just give up all hope The Cooperative nature here feels really intuitive it actually really works so well it really takes the game and something familiar and goes you know what how about we bring you together and have you work against this common goal it does have a small pandemic like feel about it with all the ghosts kind of appearing everywhere but I love the fact that these ghosts appear in these regions called Miss and the fact that if you enclose those myths you can really clear entire groups of ghosts it has a very strong tug of wall effect where you feel like the game pulls you in One Direction and each and every piece you draw matters so much because not only do you decide whether to use that piece to score place the piece next to another Mist expanding the mist and hopefully getting

the ghostly discount meaning that you pull out one less ghost out if you connect it to an existing Miss but also how is this going to really change the landscape for the next phase of the game I mean as soon as a symmetry comes out I think my heart kind of drops because I'm like oh my goodness the ghosts are already overriding the board how we're going to manage the cemetery and if I can find a spot where the cemetery can be placed where it's wedged between two other orthogonal pieces then I've already done half the work already and so these new changes really add some nice levels of tension to the game that probably didn't exist in the same way in the original game I know the monasteries kind of similar to the castle but the castle key doesn't allow you to remove any of the ghosts yes it helps you to score you know a big load of points but it does nothing to the fact that you've got this overrun of these uh spiritual creatures taking over your map uh is this Ghostbusters I think I might have a job for you and this brings me to one crucial point if you're someone who loves Cooperative games and wants something really easy to learn but really challenging to play then miss over carperson is a no-brainer I would totally get this even if I own vanilla Carcassonne there's something explicably interesting about the pressurized nature of these ghosts really thwarting the plans that you're

trying to make and I actually really enjoy it now some people might say there is a luck factor to which tiles you draw and that happened to me on several games where I drew a tile two tiles in a row and they had three ghosts so that was a total of six ghosts that I had to deploy out of the 15 and some were already out on my map that proved um quite frustrating in the moment but then I thought you know what how can I best exploit this situation how best can I use it in my advantage so I started connecting them together to other myths and then that gave me a small little discount a little bit of leeway to kind of work with the game a little and I think if you're not really happy with that level of pressure or that level of Randomness you could easily play a variant where you draw two tiles per turn give one to your partner and use one right now I love how because this is a Cooperative version of the game you can potentially scare I mean score the same area multiple times provided that you set it up well I've set this move up pretty nicely because if I can find a piece that fits in this area I'll be able to score this region twice well they really discovered in this game is that planning is everything every piece you place down expands the landscape in some way creating little weird Nooks where there's three sides that you need to perfectly match up it's not a really good fit for the future pieces that you're going to acquire on your turn I'm sure that the way that the pieces are designed the different landscape

combinations are going to vary from tile to tile and no two tiles are ever the same also thinking about how you're going to score by placing your meeples in those big city regions and multiple of them means that you're going to be able to accelerate that score really really quickly you'll also want to dabble in roads here and there to try and get that ability to clear three ghosts off a tile and having that little simple rule of being able to choose to score or clearing goes really helps for you to pivot your game strategy at certain points in the game it's like oh we're in a really good situation now I'll take the point I'll know we're in Dire Straits everybody quick hold on to your horses because we're gonna need to clear some ghosts right now another day yet another loss in a game of Miss over carcasson except this time I used every single tile and I managed to only get 51 points brutality so in considering my final verdict I've had an absolute blast with Miss over carcass soon I'm usually not someone who really enjoys a lot of Cooperative games especially ones in a fully Cooperative nature um I must say that the game also can be used as a module expansion for the base game which means you can play Miss over carcasso competitively if you combine it with the original game which I absolutely love giving me that option means that I can not only play it cooperatively on its own or I can use it to play competitively with my friends Miss over carcasson for me is definitely

a step up from the original game I love this version a lot and I would probably say that this game would be an 8 out of 10 for me now if you really like this video and the entertaining skits they do and sharing my thoughts and experiences then please consider giving this video a like and subscribing to my channel also if you want to have a little bit more Savor the direction of the Channel please head over to my patreon page and and I love to have a chat with you over there otherwise this is Danny signier I hope your next game of carcassoon is not a spooky one but an amazing one see you next time

Progress saved