Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Rolling Realms Worth Playing Solo | I Don't Usually Play Solo #2

Transcript 19:48

No, I don't play board game solo, but I keep buying ones that say you can. So, it's time to roll solo. I'm Roll for the just the road.com. I don't usually play solo, but I tried Rolling Realms. In Rolling Realms with multiple players, you compete to earn the most stars across three rounds of mini games. At the start of each round, three realm cards are randomly selected. Each player uses the same three realms. Each round lasts nine turns. On each turn, one player rolls two dice and shares the results with everyone. All players then activate their realms simultaneously. Each dice can be used once in a different realm. So, you can't use the same dice more than once, and you can't activate the same realm more than once each round. Each realm is a mini puzzle based on a familiar board game, and each has its fairly thematic rules for how you use the dice to fill the cards and earn stars. Resources, which are pumpkins, hearts, and coins, are earned through the realms and let you manipulate the dice.

Spend pumpkins to adjust the dice values and hearts and coins to create additional dice and things like that. And all the resources are tracked on a resource card. Resources can also be spent to activate some spots on the realms themselves, so save some for them. After nine turns, the round ends. You note any stars, and the unspent resources are worth 0.1 of a star each, so nothing is completely wasted each round. You erase your cards, randomly choose three new realms, and start a new round. After three rounds, the player with the most cumulative stars over those three rounds is the winner. You might have seen that I held the box for Rolling Realms Redux at the beginning. This is the stand-alone expansion. I do have both. The Rolling Realms box is in a box in a storage box under a load of boxes in a cupboard. I couldn't get it. Uh so, just know that I'm looking at both of the games.

Rolling Realms, the the main one, the one that came first, has a mini golf solo mode, which is a kind of a score attack style game based on golf. Each hole gives you the realms that you're going to play in that hole and the additional rules and features for that hole, and tells you what you need to achieve in order to complete that hole. Fail it, and you get to try it again. And again, until you complete it. Succeed or fail the fourth time and you fill your sheet in depending on how many attempts it took you to beat that hole, depending on which difficulty you're playing. And then you do that for all 18 holes in the game. So, that means you'll be playing up to 72 games, four per 18 holes, if you're really bad. And each attempt you make at hole is one stroke for that hole, and just like in mini golf, you're trying to get the lowest number of strokes or scores or attempts over the 18 holes to get your best score.

So, getting started in the mini golf game was very easy. I of course watched my 5-minute how to play as a reminder of how to play the rules. It's a very good idea, and I think everyone should do that. Each of the whole cards tell you exactly what to do. So, you start with hole one, obviously, and you follow the instructions. It says to get those three realms shown there. So, here they are. I've got Charterstone, Scythe, and Tapestry. And it says you play seven rounds instead of nine. So, you cross two rounds off the round marker as a reminder that you're only playing the seven rounds in case you forget. Now, normally this is something I wouldn't have done. Of course I can remember to play seven rounds instead of nine. Who What kind of fool would forget a simple rule like that? But if any of you watched the first video in this series where I played Neko Syndicate, you will see I made a fair few mistakes by just doing things a bit too fast and not taking care. So, something I've learned from that I've brought into this is just to slow down a bit, follow the rules exactly, put those two crosses in just so I don't have to worry about playing too many rounds, and then get on with the game. But first you need to learn what all these realms do. So, just a quick run through of each of these work.

When you get this number here, you cross off the relevant number and you gain the resource. Then you put the number of the other dice here, and then eventually you can use the numbers in this box. So, say you've got three fours in this box, you can use a four to mark off the three fours and get three stars. So, you're trying to get the same numbers in these boxes so you can get as many as you can in one go. In Scythe, it's pretty straightforward. 1 2 3 4 5 6 to get the the relevant resource on the top, and then 1 2 3 4 5 6 on the bottom to spend the resource to get a star. So, that one's straightforward, seems nice and easy to complete. And then Tapestry, I don't know why I put them in this order not the same order I had them when I'm playing the game, but it's cuz I'm recording this bit after I've played it because I forgot to go through the rules, but anyway. So, Tapestry is a bit different. You're putting these shapes into this grid. When you fill one of the squares, you get the resource in that square. And when you complete a line or a column, you get a star. So, that's how you get stars on these three. And now it's time to play even though I technically already played it because I'm filming this out of order.

That's all of them. I don't know about you, but like this Charterstone was hard to read. And but luckily, you would do have the rulebook and the rulebook has all the clarifications and expanded text on how they work as well. And if you have Rolling Realms Redux, you do have the compendium that has all the holes from the the first game, the second game, and any of the mini expansions or promo expansions or whatever they're called that you can buy as well. So, that's handy if you can't actually read the text on the cards like I struggled with with Charterstone. And of course, the goal for hole one as it says on the card in easy sort {slash} normal mode, I'll get into more of that later, is to score eight stars across all of the three realms. And like I said, you've got seven rounds to do it. So, you need to get more than one star in one round at some point and work out how to do that. So, after the seven rounds, if you haven't got enough, you just restart the whole again. But for each attempt you make, it's like another shot on this mini golf hole that you're playing. So, the fewer attempts you take, the better your end score is going to be. So, you want to try and get it done as quick as possible. I don't know about you, most mini golf courses I go to, they have six strokes as your maximum. If you take more than six strokes, you pick up your ball, you move on to the next hole mostly to keep a queue moving if there's people behind you. And just like that in this game, if you fail the fourth time, you write down five as your score and you move on to the next hole. And like I said earlier, trying to get the lowest score over the 18 holes, just like mini golf. Okay, I know it's been a while since I've played this and I've never claimed to be very good at it, but I needed eight in order to pass this first hole. First attempt, I got four. So, I'm I'm I'm only halfway there. So, I need to go again and do much better. I need to do at

least twice as good. What the solo game adds more than the multiplayer game is those different rules per hole. Other than that, you're just rolling and playing in the exact same way as you would if you're playing a multiplayer game. There is a whole new bunch of components just for the mini golf with the scoring card and all the different hole cards. And that's just for the mini golf game in the main box. And if you got the stand-alone Rolling Realms, you have a arbor tournament, which is a bit of a different style of game. So, this solo version is played like a football tournament across five leagues with promotion and relegation. You're playing the same game system, but you're playing against bots. And bots have preset scores. And the stars that you gain against those bots will be converted into goals. You're trying to score more goals than the bots. And this is a great way to play against the bots without the fiddly scoring system. The problem we've had in Necro Syndicate where you have to score a dummy game at the end just to see if you've beat the bot. Here, the bot has a score. You're just trying to beat that score straight away. And in the occasions when the bots play each other, obviously, you don't want to be playing a full game of Rolling Realms just for two bot players.

So, you just roll two dice. It's done very simply, very quick. It's a much simpler way, a smoother way of getting through the game when you're not actually playing it yourself. Now, I haven't played this version of the game for this video, but it does look like a good option for playing Rolling Realms solo. I like the sports theme. I like that you've got goals. You've got promotion and relegation, all the things I like in sports. So, that's all good. But what both solo modes are doing is allowing you to play the game normally as you would play it normally just with little things to think about as you're going. So, it just changes the game up solo enough that you have a target to aim for rather than just trying to beat the other players. One thing I do find annoying with this is obviously these are nice cards cuz these are obviously dry wipe cards. Cuz you write on. You get the markers in the box, which is good. Uh and all these, you know, they they write well. They rub off well. It's fine. Except the the thing they give you to score the mini golf is it's cardboard. So, I can't I can't write on this because it won't come off.

Uh why they didn't have like a double-sided card with eight or nine holes on one side and nine on the other so that you could use this uh, and then wipe it off and you know, mark your scores score somewhere then wipe it off. I don't know, but um, I'll have to find a way to to do the scoring somehow. Yes, it is pretty much the same game. Like I mentioned with Neko Syndicate, it is very much multiplayer solitaire. But when you're playing solo, you do have those different challenges every hole for the mini golf in order to keep the game fresh. Multiplayer is just three rounds three times because you have a ton of combinations keeping things different. Solo does add an extra layer, but it makes me think of the game in reverse. This makes sense in my head. I'm not sure I'm going to be able to explain this well, so just bear with me.

When I'm playing Rolling Realms multiplayer, I see the realms out in front of me. I see what I need to do and I sort of work out how can I use what I've got in front of me in order to get the most amount of stars. But in solo, I see right, I need eight stars, these are my three rounds, and I work back from those eight stars and try and work out which realms are going to get me the stars to get to that goal. Whereas in multiplayer, I wouldn't think, oh, let's do it that way. I wouldn't think of how many stars can I get and go backwards, but I do in solo because that target's already there and that target that I need to aim for is in my head. So, while the game is played exactly the same, I find that I am approaching it differently. Okay, attempt number two at hole number one and uh, a close. That's a Chart Stone. I got two, uh, you can see there, and then with Tapestry, I got one, and Scythe, I got three. So, I got 7.3 cuz you get 0.1 for each leftover resource. So, I was much closer, but look at this. Look at the rolls. 5 5 5 5 2 2 2 2. So, I was kind of restricted in what I could do cuz I got all these fives and twos. I was going between Chart Stone and Scythe for a bit, then I had to go to Tapestry.

Uh, I think the secret here is to nail Tapestry and then use the resources for Tapestry to hit Scythe or try and get all of these numbers the same and then hopefully roll that die and cross multiple off at the same time because you need eight points and there's only seven turns which means you need to get at least a star a turn on more than one star in a turn. I'm struggling a bit but I'm going to keep going. I've had the second attempt. I've got two more attempts left so let's see how the next one goes. Yes, it is. Set up is very quick especially once you know what you're doing. The games themselves each attempt is very quick if you know how to play it like you say you're only playing seven or nine rounds in the in the earlier holes so they don't take very long. Each round once you know what you're doing may maybe takes 10 15 seconds each so you're not taking too long to play a game at all.

It's very easy rules so the mental load is low. You only need to remember the three realms that are in front of you. You don't have to remember the rules for Charterstone for example if Charterstone is not in the game you're playing so just as long as you know what you're doing with these three realms then you're fine. And even then each realm itself is fairly straightforward. You don't have to worry too much. Some are a little bit more complex than others but none of them are so difficult that you're going to struggle to remember what you're doing once you've read the compendium or the rulebook and remembered what they do. And it is fun to fail and then improve even if it does mean that you're getting an extra stroke from that extra failure. When you see the improvement as you go through it's quite satisfying. It's especially fun when you succeed. Uh legitimately my first roll in the next game was five two so I'm switching to the other dice. I've had enough. So excuse the dodgy writing but the change of dice seems to have worked. So you see I did keep the original five two. I didn't actually I kept the original five two. I didn't roll another five two with these green dice later on and then as you can see one two three four five six fours so Yeah, but this time was much better up here. I know my cards are a mess but I got two stars from Charterstone, two from Tapestry and then five from Scythe giving me 9.3 which was almost enough to get hard difficulty for 9.5 but I did beat the easy difficulty. I can move on to the next hole after three attempts.

You are playing with the same realms of the same challenges each hole, but it is like playing the same golf course. It's thematic. For example, if I'm teeing off on my local golf course, I know to aim down the left cuz I've got water on the right down the first fairway. And then when you get to the green, you need to aim to the right of the green cuz it slopes right to left. And you hit the right of the green, it slopes down the hill. Whereas this game is more about mini golf than it is actual golf. It's more like waiting for the windmill's red arm to get to 3:00 and then you hit the ball through the door. That sort of thing. But on the other hand, you do lose the randomness of all the different realms and the combinations you get and the realms you've got available to you to play with. For example, mini golf only uses the 11 realms that come in the box of the first game, which makes sense because the designers know that you've got those 11 realms, so you need to put them in the game so that you've got all the components you need to play it solo, which makes perfect sense. But it does mean things like Terraforming which is my favorite game as I mentioned a lot, I can't use the Terraforming realm when playing Got Mini Golf, which is a shame because I want to be able to play this one. And if I do want to play it, it means I have to play it multiplayer. And then hope it comes up randomly in the nine that we're playing that game. So just to give you an idea of how things get. So this is hole three. This will be the next hole I'm playing. I need Charter Stone, Tapestry and Euphoria. So I've got those three ready there. And then it says you need one pumpkin, one heart, one coin. So you start with one of each resource. But it says you need exactly three stars in one realm, exactly four stars in another, exactly five stars in another. So you need to work out what you're going to get and how you're going to get them there in order to achieve this goal. But it is exactly three, four, and five or four,

five, and six if you're playing on hard. Uh so that, you know, it starts to get quite difficult. And then as you go up to the further holes, you see this is hole 17. This hole two sides of rules to it. So let's look at 18 as well. Because this with 18, you need all 11 realms. You basically pick three, and then every time you put three stars on one of them, you get rid of it and put it to one side. Now, you're going to take 22 turns and you're trying to get three stars on every single one. So, basically, you'll have three and when you get three on one, you'll kick one out and you replace it with another one. You get to pick which one that is. Uh so, you're trying to you're cycling through them all. So, that is going to be not as straightforward as hole number one, which I failed failed several times. So, uh it's going to get difficult.

Yes, I would choose this solo. If you get all the realms you need, the golf cards, you get the dice, the cloth, the pen, you can put them all in a little bag or something. You can take it with you and play wherever you like. But, because it's a small footprint and the cards are plastic, wipeable board-type plastic, you can play it in most locations as well. Rolling Realms Redux comes with this travel box and this holds everything that you can use to play golf. And if you don't believe me, let's look inside. And here it is. That is everything you need to play the golf game, all the way up to hole 18. Just like most games though, I do wonder about long-term re-playability. With actual golf and mini golf, you can use those same skills that you've developed, the swing and your putting everything, and you can take them to a different course, which has a different completely different challenge. Whereas here, you've only got the one course. Now, near me, there isn't too many mini golf centers, but every single one of them has at least two courses for the variability. So, it's got real life has more golf courses than you have in this game. Of course, it always pays to read the rulebook and I just noticed is this say easy, normal, and hard, but of course, these only say two difficulties.

So, I was trying to figure out where the third difficulty comes from and it's in the rulebook, of course, where you would expect the rules to be. And it says that if you're playing on easy mode, whenever you fail an attempt, you start with one of each resource on your second attempt, you start with two of each resource, which I didn't do. So, I didn't actually pass on normal difficulty, not easy difficulty, which makes me feel a little bit better. Well, it's rated a very good 7.1 from over 5,000 reviews, which is really good. Moves verb rated it five. It said I was overthinking everything during the entire game. I found absolutely no fun in the process. And this was a solo review only. And it is true because with so few turns, you need to min-max every single time. And like I said earlier, thinking about that game backwards, it really restricts your creativity and freedom of how you're going to get to those stars. There is sort of a route you need to take and a way you need to do it. And once you find out what that is, you get sort of railroaded down that route. You lose that sort of beautiful thing where you can just try different things because you can't, you'll just fail. You have to go for the min-maxing route. Super Cooper Hobbies and Bronze Beard both rated five and both complain that there is no interaction and it's better solo. Like I've already mentioned, like I said in the Neko Syndicate video, this is very much multiplayer solitaire. You're doing your own thing when you're playing the game.

And you might say something like, "Ooh, four. I'm going to put that in between two cities." And somebody else saying, "Oh, no. I'm putting my six in between two cities." And then changing my four to a five and putting that in viticulture. And that's really nice interaction you have with other players around the table. Feels like you're empathizing with each other and really discussing about how you're going to get around this puzzle that you've chosen to sit down and do together, which is nice. But it doesn't affect the game anyway whatsoever. Looking at the tens, the excellently named Kurt Wang says, "I almost never play my game solo. Most of the time it feels too tedious. But this solo mode is so much fun." Which is a really good review of the solo mode. And there's quite a few decent reviews of the solo mode on BoardGameGeek. It's definitely for roll and write fans and it is a good roll and write game in its own right. It's for puzzle fans, people who want to look at these three realms and decide, "Okay, how can I get the most out of these three realms no matter what my die roll is going to be?

Which one do I focus on? Which ones do I use to help other realms, which is something you can do?" And which ones can I completely ignore? It's for people like a bit of sports element in the game. When you play mini golf, you've got that mini golf feeling when you're playing the arable, you've got that sports feeling with different leagues of promotion and relegation. So, if that's your kind of thing, that's there for you. And it's for min-maxers, people who want to definitely get the most and squeeze everything out of each die roll every round. Actually, yes, this one did make me want to play solo games more. I'm filming this in July. It is very hot. It's very sweaty in this room. I need to have the window closed for the sound. I need to have the studio lights on for the light, and it is very hot in here. I couldn't sit for a long time with the lights off while I was playing because the heat the room up too much, which is why the video, especially the GoPro video, does look a bit dark, and I apologize for that, but it was the only way I was going to survive.

The challenge for the mini golf itself is fun. It is sort of annoying when you have to redo a hole when you felt that you did enough, but there what are you going to do? That's That's mini golf for you. I like the sports theme, as I said. I am a golf and a mini golf fan myself, so having that as a theme around a game that's already very good, that's pretty cool. And the variety in the holes themselves is good. Hole to hole, you're getting a decent challenge and a different variety, which is cool. But like I said, though, while every hole is completely different, you've only got the one course in the box. So, I don't know how long that would last overall playing the same course every time. And something I always think about solo games is, will it ruin multiplayer for me if I get too good? I always think of the Puzzle Strike example. I played this with multiple groups, and I got good at the game. I understood how to win. So, long story short, with Puzzle Strike, if you have too many chips in your play area, you lose the game. But I, as somebody who knows how to play it quite well, will tell you you need to not get rid of your chips and have quite a few in your play area. When I tell people that, they look at me as if to say, "I'm not falling for that. I'm getting rid of all my chips." And then they lose. My advice sounds sub-optimal.

They don't believe me, and they lose because of it, and that's because I know what I'm doing. What happens when I play Rolling Realms too much solo? Do I just get so good at it and would able to look at the three realms and go, "Right, I know exactly what I need to do to get as most stars out of these and then just hammer everyone." That's not fun for me. But, I do recommend Rolling Realms as a solo game because I don't usually play solo, but I tried Rolling Realms and Rolling Realms Reloaded. If you played this one solo, let me know what you think and let me know if it worked for you. And make sure to subscribe cuz next time we're going to be playing a game that's kind of infectious. If there's a game you think I should be trying solo, let me know what it is in the comments and I'll see if I can give it a go. And thanks for watching. You can follow me on Insta and YouTube and all that good stuff. Remember to like, share, and subscribe and thanks for watching. I'll be Rob AKA Jest the Rogue and I'll see you soon.

Progress saved