KeyForge House Rankings (10-1) | My Personal List Based on Fun, Theme, Balance, and More
Transcript
hey how's it going carlo here from aycb and today i'm bringing you a fun kind of more laid-back video which is going to be ranking the 10 current key forge houses um a couple things i want to mention before we get into the list i want to be very clear this is not at all supposed to be a ranking in terms of just like the worst to best houses i'm not here to talk about like necessarily the win rates of the houses for me it is a personal list of not only the houses that i find the most fun to play as or against but also just kind of how the houses are designed in terms of the health of the key forge as a game so we're talking like um you know if there's a house that's either way too strong sometimes or way too weak i might even push it further down the list because ultimately this is my list of kind of the houses that feel the most fun and that i think do the best job of fitting into key forge so again there's going to be some i know there's definitely some picks that some of you don't agree with for sure but that's that's also the fun in some of these lists i also want to thank all of you are here who have watched our last key forge video i did not expect that type of response um as i mentioned there i kind of fell out of favor with key forge for about a year during worlds collide which was the third set right around when the pandemic started and i've been really enjoying getting back into it lately um so keep in mind also while i'm ranking these that uh the sets i've played the least of would be mass mutation and dark tidings which are the two uh newest ones um but with that said uh let's get right into the list starting with house number 10 which is brobnar so it's unfortunate because i i do like brobnar in some ways there's a lot that i liked about them in the first set um they're kind of the mad max style
fighting at all costs kind of a house like they have a lot of cards that encourage them to fight they haven't been in the last two sets now um they were pretty weak i found in worlds collide out of the first i opened five or six worlds collide decks i think four of them had brobnar i didn't really enjoy playing them all that much it wasn't specifically that they were weak it was just that they also weren't as interesting it feels like the the houses hit a bit of a stale point around that second and third set um and yeah there was a good thread actually for anyone who's not familiar with the key forge subreddit if you go to reddit.comr keyforge game someone started an awesome series recently called forging futures talking about the futures of houses and there was a really great thread on brobnar talking about how they can improve going forward maybe focusing more on stuff like um you know the card burn the stockpile which makes your opponents uh you can make people like lose amber you know there's a lot of houses that focus on board presence and fighting um it's not just broadner you know obviously sanctum and saurian do as well but bromnar has some unique mechanics again with the the always incentivizing to fight and maybe destroying your opponent's amber could be another direction they could go in the future but i did feel like they're a little bit weak and a bit stale right now i'm excited to see where they can go later but they definitely seem like the house that needs the most work right now so for now i have to leave them at my number 10 spot unfortunately but i do have to say like the artwork and the theme you know the theme behind the cards and the house and itself uh is really cool so i think it's a great house for the game but just uh right now needs a lot of work on to my number nine which is going to
be untamed so untamed came out the gates uh and called the archons as probably the fastest house for gaining amber there's a lot of cards that just like just give you amber bonuses and like like the bonus icons in the corner just for playing them or there were cards that would give you two or three amber a lot of ways to spike amber you had cards like key charge and chota hazary for kind of key cheating so that's always been a thing and untamed also has the kind of they also kind of have liked having a bit of a board presence as well like i was mentioning with brobnar but usually weaker creatures that sort of power up the other creatures that were there was the um or they called panpaka anga and panpaka jaga i think it was from age of ascension which you put on the opposite ends of your battle line and they kind of uh buff all the uh all your your other creatures which was cool they've had some other really cool cards like mimicry um all kinds of cool stuff was untamed but i just feel like overall it's kind of in that it's not quite i wouldn't put it quite with brobnar in the terms of it being stale um i'd like to see some new stuff from it and i think the last couple sets where i've had decks with untamed i felt they're maybe not always the most interesting lately and i think they've also i'm not mistaken i think they've been in the set since the uh very in the game since the very first set so yeah i just overall it's not my favorite play style and and i find that some of the cards are just you kind of just play them in the game amber and you don't always have to figure stuff out and then other ones are sometimes feel a little situational i don't know maybe not too many complaints but it's just i kind of like all the hoes it's kind of hard to rank these to be honest with you but uh yeah untamed does fall at number nine
for me it almost made number eight is actually going to go to sanctum i previously had sanctum as my number nine i kind of waffled back and forth on these sanctum to me it's it's very beginner friendly especially from call of the archons it felt like the easiest maybe not the easiest house to do well with but i mean having the cards that you know all the creatures that have armor and ways that they don't take damage and you can heal and there's you know creatures with taunt that can protect other ones um you also had cards like gorm vom for destroying artifacts uh stuff like cleansing wave where if you had a big board and a bunch of creatures that take it down just play cleansing we've gained a bunch of amber so it felt like maybe one of the easier houses and i think it it was good that they had a house like this in the first set where it felt like most of my decks that had sanctum the sanctum wasn't tough to play around it was fairly easy but it was just a reliably good house after age of ascension um they didn't do too too much to change it up i it still didn't get super interesting but has one of my favorite artifacts which was uh proclamation 346e uh just the theme just the artwork everything is just awesome and it's a very very good artifact um and but i kind of fell out of favor i think part of it too is i think most of my decks like have had sanctum in them it's the deck or the house i've had the most of and especially because i'm not super fond of them and i don't find them the most fun um after a while i just got tired of seeing them but um they would have been lower on the list if it wasn't for the recent set dark tidings which has had some other new interesting cards and i got to play
a couple games with them recently and that's why they moved up i think they did a good job of um you know they got sanctum out of there for one set brought them back and now i think they're a little more interesting so excited to see what they have going forward uh and of course they had the you know four horsemen uh in the first set which everyone went crazy about when the game first came out um so yeah lots of lots of cool stuff still but just not my favorite most interesting house on to my number seven which uh let's see i'm almost forgotten here okay seven for me seven and six i waffled back and forth on two but i kind of fell with seven being shadows so shadows is actually a very good house again i'm not ranking these in terms of good and bad they are necessarily shadows especially in the first set was probably the best or second best house they've they've been there again since the beginning i think they've been in all sets yeah um the thing about shadows for me is that again so like some of the other ones they're getting to the point now where maybe just a little bit stale is maybe too harsh of a word too i just want to see some new stuff right we think of shadows as the house that has obviously steel is the main mechanic uh which is just so strong we saw you know bait and switch getting nerfed or having the errata in the first set um basically any card those cards that's gonna steal you two amber it doesn't seem like a lot but you gain two the opponent loses too that's a four amber swing so stealing is so powerful and the other main thing they're known for obviously is um they're kind of elusive creatures they have a lot of creatures that have like one or two health only but maybe they're elusive or they have a really powerful ability like a diagnosed spymaster which lets you it's that omni ability lets you activate another creature
so they you still have these creatures on the board that make your opponent want to get rid of them but mac the knife is another one i just thought of that's really good for that but i just feel like again in the last little while a lot of my you know especially last couple sets that i've seen shadows in a lot of it just still comes down to the same stealing and stuff and uh i guess for me too it's more that i like the houses that have a little more intricacy to them a little more decision making a little more complexity that aren't that don't just sort of play themselves and i'm not saying shadows does all the time but because some of these cards have that steel effect it just feels like a house that's very reliably good almost all the time and fairly fairly easy to do well with so again to me i just don't think it's the most interesting house but if i was talking about strongest houses it would definitely be much higher to the top so uh yeah that is oh one more no two more cards i have to mention for shadows that i love actually from the first set uh master plan and the sting one of my friends has both of those in the same deck uh amazing amazing artifacts there's all kinds of really cool cards in this in shadows overall so yeah i think they're just maybe a victim of having been in all the sets i think maybe if they had been out a little more i'd be uh maybe a little higher on them so now we'll go on to my number six i believe we're on six now yeah six which is unfathomable so this is the newest house from dark tidings and it's hard to say i mean if they had been in more than just the one set so far i might rank them higher they they are really interesting uh i've been lucky enough to get them in two of my decks so far from dark tidings they've got some really cool cards um i
guess before i get into specific cards we'll talk just more about their theme but they're the underwater house and they've replaced this as like the main kind of control house i guess in dark tidings and it's basically like you're fighting them underwater so not only has this tied mechanic come into play which we'll talk about more in another video some other day but basically they have a lot of mechanics where they're exhausting enemy creatures or saying that enemy creatures don't actually ready on their next turn so it's like you're being slowed down fighting through water um the tide mechanic that i just mentioned there like you can gain chains and stuff so it is something that is there to slow you down i really like that um and some of the new cards that i've seen i was so i felt so like i opened a deck the other day that had uh omnipus in there which is that big eight power creature that has all the tentacles that come in there super cool card really enjoyed playing with that already um kaup which i mentioned in my other previous video where uh it allows when it's in play your opponent can only play one card of each type on their turn there's all these very restrictive things tough to play against it's a house that i could see going higher up on my list i do think they're more interesting overall than shadows i don't know yet how strong like how powerful they actually are but yeah they're definitely a fun interesting house the theme is good and i just think it's a great addition to the game of key forge in general uh so yeah that's unfathomable number six so now on to my number five which is saurian um i have a feeling i'm gonna get some flack for this because not only are they obviously a very powerful house but i know people just love them
and i have to say if you would have asked me months ago or when i around when i stopped playing the game you know a year ago i probably would have had them higher up on my list i love the idea of the saurians these kind of like this society of um sophisticated uh dinosaurs and there's they've got philosophers and senators in their whole political system and uh the exalt mechanic that they brought in we're putting amber on them to you know it's like it's almost something to offset how good a card is sometimes you'll have an exalt ability where you put amber on the creature as well so that when it dies your opponent's gonna get the amber but there's all kinds of tricky stuff you can do where you gain the amber or use it for forging keys so i love i really like what sorian does for the game unfortunately i found that in worlds collide when they first came out they were maybe a little bit too strong i felt like all the decks with saurian were just were so maybe not all but a lot of them are so good and once you get that board going once you have four five six creatures out for saurian if your opponent doesn't have a board wipe card like a gateway to dis or um you know even something like a red alert for star alliance or one of these cards it just sometimes felt almost helpless like what am i supposed to do if i can't get rid of this board once these creatures get out there but there's that risk reward style of if you can get rid of it you might actually get back a huge amount of amber so sorian to me felt like it the more cards that are on the board too it almost slows down the game because you're trying to figure out okay like even if you have a card that just kills one creature you're trying to figure out which one of those saurian guys is going to do the most damage so this is one of those ones where they're just not higher up on the list because i think
at first they were almost too good and it also sometimes slows the game down makes for really long games so um i mean the artwork on them is absolutely amazing the just the theme of the house the flavor text on the cards you know again falafosaurus um status raptor uh you've got so many so many cool cards and i just love the idea of these dinosaurs but yeah overall there's just again and part of it is just that the houses that are ahead of it i just like a bit more so yeah sorry unit number five could go up a lot more in the future but that's where they sit for now so number four is dis uh this is another one that might have been higher up on my list if it weren't for the fact that i've had very few decks with dis i think the first like 15 20 decks i opened i maybe got like two decks that had this um yeah they're they're such a great house i feel they they have this niche in the game that i know unfathomable is kind of creeping in on that a little bit with that control aspect and slowing them down and they've always this has also kind of shared some uh characteristics with um with shadows since the start in some ways but they also have their own unique things and i just love how especially from a design perspective i'm just so impressed with this because they have all these cards that seem like broken like completely unfair like you remember from the first set control the week and restauranguntus um and even lately there's like in furnace um there's other cards that like let you take stuff back from your discord like get a bunch of creatures back in your discard policies all these cards that sometimes feel like how is that even like that seems too strong but there's a
lot of other cards in the house that kind of offset it by not being as good or that are more situational and the other thing you realize after a while is that this does not do a very good job of gaining amber so they're not an easy house to play well like again they have some of these really crazy cards sometimes i guess i should mention the seven sins uh which i haven't actually seen myself yet uh they they came out around when i wasn't really playing key forge much um but yeah they just have this i love the aspect of making your opponents like discard random cards in their hand or you can like look at your opponent's hand do stuff or you know you got lash or broken dreams from the first set which makes their keys more expensive to forge uh you had drumble preventing people for like all these very cool cards um i just think that again part of it is just a victim of i like the houses ahead of it a little more but i think even just thematically too the artwork i think this has a really really good spot in the game and i think it is definitely one of the best houses uh overall not only in terms of power level but just like the fun of playing it and kind of having its own unique niche spot in the game that i feel like a lot of other houses can't quite match so yeah that is dis and if i have some more decks then in the future they could move higher up on my list number three is star alliance uh this is another one that i really really like such a cool house i i love the idea of the kind of um humans and aliens working together kind of thing like you can see the kind of like human technology and like going out into space you got all the like some of these um you know uh characters
are all wearing all kinds of crazy space suits and you've got these cards like uh encounter suit and quad recorder and all these like i should mention they're kind of the upgrade house right star alliance uh by far the most upgrades which are the ones that you attach to your creatures to power them up just two i mentioned right there quad recorder and encounter suit having those both on the same creature is just crazy because yeah i don't need to get into what the cars do you probably know um they also have a lot of stuff with activating other houses so like there's a lot of um you know you use a card's ability and it says like play a non-star alliance card for your hand this turner use a non-star alliance creature in place so i love that they they kind of feel the closest to logos um yeah it's the closest comparison i can think of to logos because they feel almost like a support house where they're there to help your other houses in the in the deck and your other cards in the set or in the in the deck work better so especially like if you get out a bunch of upgrades and they stay out and play you're going to cycle through and now there's not as many cards in your deck so the star lines feels like it's kind of powering everything else up you have all these cards too that have like a play slash fight slash reap abilities so they're ones that can trigger it multiple times which i really like um just so many cool cards too like scientific officer kin can uh crash muldoon um just i really like what it does i think of the two houses that got introduced in worlds collide i did like star alliance a little bit more they're power level too it just feels like they're they can almost do everything um again i mentioned red alert is like an amazing board clear um oh i gotta mention one of my favorite star alliance cards here
actually is peace accord it's an artifact that i got in one of my decks super cool card it's one of those ones like this is the kind of thing i love about keyforge it's not necessarily an amazing powerful card it's not one that's like always going to be good but it's just a very cool thematic card and something that just makes both players have to think differently when they're playing um and it just gives that game a unique flavor when that card comes into play so yeah i really like what i've seen from star alliance so far and i hope to see some other really cool stuff from them going forward my number two i know this is controversial uh my number two is mars um they're i know they haven't been in the last three sets i know a lot of people say they're the worst house i've gotta disagree um and again remember this list isn't talking about just what which houses are the best or worst in my opinion first off mars is either the most or second most fun to play and that's that's again for me the unfortunate thing is that they are very inconsistent and it's very hit or miss like i i know the feeling i've had people say like oh this deck the mars is so bad that the deck is almost unplayable and i've had some decks like that where sometimes the mars felt like you have so many of these situational cards like and that's the thing they do have the most situational cards i would say of any house but they have that aspect of if you can get them out on the board and you can actually get those synergies going it's so satisfying so rewarding it's so fun all the abilities that they do are very thematic um if i think back to some of my favorite mars cards from the very first even in the whole game of key forge really like oops licks the zookeeper where you um you can reap and you can archive one of
your enemies uh creatures and then imagine having like a john smith on the board with an ux licks which i had which i had one of my decks where you use you know use the ux looks to do that then use the john smith to ready the uxlex's zookeeper to do it again and then you've got things like soft landing and squawker which can make those all activate again so there are games where you feel like your mars does nothing and then there are games where you feel like your mars is almost broken and unfair um i've had games where i have like that john smith oops licks thing putting out with soft landings i'm just archiving my opponent's creatures doing all kinds of stuff and sometimes people are like what am i even supposed to do against that and sometimes it almost feels unfair but i i love the thematic like there's so many cool cards with like again abducting people putting stuff in your archives there's um deep probe from the first set looking your opponent's hand and or you call out a house and they have to discard all the creatures from that like there's just so much cool stuff and i'm so sad that they haven't been in the last three sets i'm i believe someone mentioned in our last video that there was a podcast recently with one of the designers who mentioned that mars is coming back in the next set apparently i hope that's true really excited to see what they do um and i just hope it's a little more consistent across the board so that you know they don't get all those negative feedback saying the house is broken or unbalanced and i really don't want to see it go away and i think it's such an interesting house for the game and fits into this niche that no other house really has and i just i yeah martian generosity and age of ascension was also awesome anyways get carried away here all day talking mars they're so fun and they would probably be my number one house if they had been around for longer or if they were just a little bit stronger
so yeah that leaves my number one which you obviously know by now is logos i don't know how much disagreement there's gonna be on this uh to be honest it's such a good house it's so much fun to play and i feel like i've never ever ever had a deck where like i've never had a deck with logos where logos is the weakest of the three houses it feels like the logos is there i kind of mentioned this in my star alliance section there logos feels like a support house they're there to draw cards archive cards you know you're basically cycling through your deck you can you have cards like mother that allow you to draw more cards at the end of your turn uh i love cards like sloppy lab work is just an interesting design because you have to archive and then discard but depending when in the turn you play it if you've played enough cards you might not have to resolve the discard part there's all these really cool cards that have like timing things i mean in the first set we had library access which obviously ended up being nerfed um and and help from future self and time travel and that kind of thing strange gizmo one of the most interesting cards in the entire game for me i had it in one deck in the first set it's that artifact where when you forge a key destroy every other creature and artifact and play super situational right like you might not want to do that but once the artifacts in play once you forge that key that's going to happen super interesting card to play around and then recently i got a deck from mass mutation that has the archivist archiving is one of my favorite mechanics in the game because okay so we talk about the game has the obviously the unique deck aspect and sometimes you have these decks that feel like they don't work i found that even my low sas ranking
decks decks that are tough eventually if you have logos or ways to archive cards i find that i can usually find a way to make those decks work i've had decks where i lose the first like eight or ten games but after a while i realized okay when i'm playing i gotta be archiving certain cards because in this game you're always discarding cards that you can't play or the timing doesn't make sense and logos i don't wanna say it fixes a lot of potential broken decks but i feel like that's part of the reason why they haven't taken it out of the game yet is like there's a lot of these decks where you have that one board clear card and you know if you get that at the beginning of the game when there's nothing on the board and then it goes into your discard pile that might be a waste but if you're able to archive it and then pull it out right at the right time or same with these uh these key cheating cards you can forge on your own turn logos just lets you kind of break the game it almost feels like it lets you break the rules of the game more than anything and just tweak the way your decks work and again it's just one of those fun reliable ones and thematically speaking like it's kind of like that there's no ethical uh moral kind of uh ground that they won't sort of trod over right i mean they're they're it's almost like the pursuit of knowledge and experimentation at absolutely any cost uh you know fusing humans with robots and all kinds of weird stuff i love this house love what it does for the game i think it's uh yeah just it's a it's a great beginner friendly house in many ways but also has a lot of room for kind of like some higher level strategy and it's one that i honestly don't think should be going anywhere anytime soon unless they kind of have a house that's going to replace that because i mean there's other houses that kind of
dabble in the archiving a little bit you know this has the odd card that can archive something like your discard pile mars i think has a bit of archiving like i mentioned i think there's the odd one and maybe is it star alliance i don't remember now um but if they get rid of logos something else has to you know one of the other houses has to adopt that archiving or maybe drawing cards more to replace them but yeah that is it that is my ten to one keep in mind again this was just my personal ranking in terms of how fun they are how much i enjoy playing the houses there's a bit of how powerful they are in there but for the most part this is just kind of what i enjoy i'm curious to think what you or hear what you guys think um am i totally off base here am i have i got the list completely backwards compared to you how close am i to your picks let me know your how you'd rank the 10 in the comments below and also keep an eye out um i want to say thank you again to everyone who watched our last key forge video the one i put out the getting back into keyforge in 2021 i really appreciate all the feedback and all the comments and suggestions was not expecting that but thanks to you guys i do have some other stuff planned uh for the for the future if you saw our channel update video we're going to be moving studios so there might be a bit of a lag in the next week or two or coming weeks but uh eventually i do want to put out a video that looks more in depth at dark tidings as a set i'm also going to do a video on the just mulligan aspect of key forge basically key forge went to mulligan kind of thing so yeah if you guys have any other requests any suggestions let me know in the comments below otherwise thank you as always for watching and i'll see you next time you