Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror Core 2026 Mystic Legacy Review

Transcript 50:42

Hello everybody and welcome to the review video here at Playing Board Games. We're joined by Russ today. Look at that. Wow. Uh so how this works is we're going to be reviewing these out of five uh depending on how uh their strength uh and viability in the Legacy format. So with that said, Legacy is the entire card pool. So like all of these cards are going to be competing against all the other stuff that exists. So don't expect like a lot of like you might be like this card seems good and it's definitely probably going to be good in like limited collection situations, just general play, but I think realistically like a two out of five is like what most cards exist in in the Legacy format especially with the size is. That's just kind of how uh formats like this work when it's the entire card pool. So don't get too upset, but there are some bangers here and some old favorites, so it should be a pretty good corset review. We're starting here first with Lucky Charm. This is a two cost accessory slot. Soaks for two horror.

Uses four charges as a lightning bolt. Spend one charge and exhaust Lucky Charm. Move one damage or one horror from a card or your location to a card you control with health or sanity.

that they felt the need to clarify that.

Yeah, um like it does have to be able to take damage, okay.

Yeah. You can't just put it on your You [snorts] can't just put it on your Relentless.

Sandy Sandy is going to hold my horror for me. Um I think this card is like the to me like the epitome of a card that's just like fine. I see where it exists. I see what it does.

Yeah, I'd give this card like a three I think because there's a couple I mean it's not great. There is a lot of competition for the accessory slot in

[clears throat]

in Mystic, but there is a couple like neat niche things where I think it's quite good. Like you can get extra charges out of um Agnes, extra damage there. You can get uh you can do some things with uh Sister Mary like her she's got her Holy Angel her signature. You can remove damage off that to keep it alive.

Yeah.

Um you can use this to abuse like uh Stana Espinoza do damage to herself?

No, I think she spent secrets. She spent secrets. She spent secrets, yeah. Yeah, I know I also also think that she kills herself on the third time.

Apparently not.

Uh yeah, you can use this to abuse things and it like beat cop or field agent. Like there's definitely like some things I could see playing this for and there aren't a ton of other options for the cards that do that.

Yeah, I think that's a good point. Kind of this is more like a uh in legacy this is more of a combo card. Like in current you're going to use this to try to like maybe stay alive and have it take the horror off of you. Or like an asset that I'm pouring but in legacy you're more likely to use it to

[clears throat]

make your plan better or your weird combo work. Yeah. Like we do we do have like a couple of pieces for like a weird purple tank damage for your friends. But that's mostly like a blue thing.

Yeah.

This card doesn't specify that the horror has to come from a card that you control.

Yep. Yep.

Which is kind of uh like the part that makes it uh makes it like good to me.

Yeah, so you can take it off someone else's stuff and put it on yours.

Yeah, we can use it to like

You make your relentless worse, yeah.

You can take it off monsters.

Yeah. Yeah, you can take it off monsters.

You can take it off monsters?

Like that jewel that's jewel thing we have, you can take the health off that.

No, but like it's actually like that is like one of those weird cases where it's like I don't like when enemies die and you don't want them to die too early. Like um can you use this in the uh um longest night in Hemlock to keep the guys in the middle safe?

I mean that's that's like a card actually. It's a card yellow location so like probably.

Like that

Uh-oh.

Yeah, I mean I think that that's like those are those things that are like I think I mean I love when you can find very niche tech like that. I think that's really cool. Um but I yeah, I think this is most of my play with this one and maybe this is tanning a bit as I've been mostly been playing this in like chapter two. Uh where I'm kind of like it's fine, but I think you guys have sold me on it in legacy. I think it's stronger in legacy.

like applications, right? Like there are there are there is a non-zero number of decks that I can see myself playing this choosing to spend my accessory slot on this card.

Yeah, yeah.

And only one of them is one where I'm cheating a chess and moving the charges onto something good.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah, the only time I I I think this card gets worse the smaller I mean, yeah, it definitely gets worse the smaller collection is. Like if you're playing with just chapter two stuff, I'm probably looking at this and I'm like, man, I wish you were Holy Rosary.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah. That's that's pretty true.

Yeah, but when you can do like just when you

When you get to play with everything, like even even if we're just playing like Agnes, I think I play this over Holy Rosary most of the

We've already got the five brain.

Yeah. Yeah. 100%.

We've already got the five. We don't need We don't need to get the five.

You just like you're like, I'll take it I take a [ __ ] I do a damage to the guy. Here you go, Pete.

Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. Pete takes the [ __ ] and then Pete's healed. Like that's that's really good.

so there there's there's decks that I can see I can see this being good in. I think this card is like a one outside of those decks, but like a four in those decks. So I think like a two and a half three is a pretty fair rating for me.

This moving the [ __ ] counts as like healing the card it was on and and damaging the card you're playing on.

It's just like you're just doing

just changing how the game state is represented. Uh I think.

Yeah, do you want me to put a three on this?

Yeah, give me give me a three.

Yeah. Good job.

Yeah. As far as As far as I know, as far as I'm aware that like that is its own specific thing. That is like moving and placing as opposed to taking or dealing or healing.

the even with like

know it wasn't healing cuz then like Hank stuff wouldn't work with him, but I wasn't sure if it was doing damage.

Yeah. Even if we got like one of our friends is playing a guard dog or some garbage. That's still perfectly fine.

Yeah. Yeah, I think that also

is good. Guard dog is real good.

Yeah, cuz again even in like in when I'm playing a lot of my experience with Lucky Charm was two-handed. But yeah, like at our table the the Mystic just plays this and it's like the you'll be surprised by the number of like possibilities that can open up with it.

And then my player is just like bless you.

This also seems like possibly really good in like Dexter Drake files.

I don't you you mean it's an it's a Mystic asset.

Yeah, I mean so I it is like a Mystic asset but also like in a Dexter Drake file we can like lightning bolt this out in the middle of our turn.

Yep.

Change where damage is.

Yep.

Add lightning bolt in the middle of our turn. And then when it's out of stuff

Just turn it up. Turn it

We just we just trash it for a different thing.

Yeah, and it takes one of the one of the horror on itself as well in that process. And then like new Dexter can bounce it to hand and then just pick it up and reset it.

Yeah. So like if we're trying to abuse it we can abuse it even better.

Yep. Yeah.

I don't know.

All right. Next one we got here is Jim Culver, our first investigator turned ally. And this one's actually good. Four four cost two two soak takes up the ally slot. You get plus one willpower plus one brain. As a reaction if you take damage and a horror exhaust him, draw one card. Doesn't have to go on him. It can also go on your investigator, other assets you control, which is uh makes it a lot better than it would if it was just on him. And honestly even just on him would probably still be pretty like playable but this version is much better.

I think I I'd give this guy like a three and a half four-ish. Uh if for no other reason than he's a level zero ally who gives me plus one brain. Which is not something that like I mean you got David Renfield I guess.

Yep.

But he doesn't stick he's not here for a long time.

Yeah.

Here for a good time.

I give him a three I think.

I think you Oh,

He's also like kind of a and a half a little bit, but I I I would trend down mostly because I think there's lots of other cards in uh Legacy that do similar things. Uh like if you want the brand, you can you were you can get it from right in front of you. You can get it from other places like Holy Rosary. Uh if you want card draw, you can get for so much cheaper with um like Arcane Initiate.

But that's only spells. I think that does open it up quite a bit where it cuz to me that was what I found when I was playing with Jim. I was like, I can now explore the mystic card pool in ways that I was like not as easy before because the card draw was really the spell card.

I think there might be other cards with the hidden upside Travis of if you are including this deck in this in your deck and Justin hasn't decided on Frank and play Jim, no.

Yeah.

It's not wrong.

Um I mean, no, he can. I just can't ever play this.

Yeah, but if he does, he's griefing you.

Yeah. Well, no, I think like

Like in a way beyond just playing Jim Culver at the table.

If I wanted to use my ally slot for card drawing purple, I think I would still probably play Arcane Initiate for most decks because how many mystic decks are you not playing like a third of your cards again end up in spells?

Yep, that's very fair.

Right? Uh maybe in some of the off-class mystics, this might be better uh or more playable.

Mhm.

Um but I think that depends a lot on like who you're playing that opens up with to a lot more competition as well.

Yeah, I think a big thing for how good Jim Culver is depends on law a lot on how much can your investigator specifically trigger damage or want to trade damage and horror, right?

Mhm.

Cuz like um Marie Lambeau, the new version from her from the Evergreen sets, like she wants to be taking damage, so Jim is just like more goodness, right? It's kind of like one of those things where I think he's less uh ubiquitous you have to include him in legacy. Like in the way like I think like if you're not taking Olivia's Rogue, you kind of like have to like why are you not taking him? Right? Cuz he's

Yeah, it has to be like because I'm upgrading to a different ally.

Yeah, and yeah.

Because I already met Leo and we're married.

Yeah, it's like separating our finances is going to be a god damn nightmare. Yeah, cuz like if your plan is to not take damage and horror, which is I mean a lot of it's a lot of players plans, like especially in mystics. But like if you are trying to be like suicide mystic and just like try to kill yourself, this guy is really good for that.

Yeah, he has he has his place. I mean he's he's obviously a good card he's a three. I think he's just he's not super ubiquitous. Um, he does also cost four, which is a little bit tough for mystic compared to other like you compare him to like for example Dr. Milan. Um, even in taboo they're they're quite similar. They give you plus one to stats, your care about. They cost four, they give you like uh economy. Um, once per turn. But like myst- seekers can get away with spending four on their ally and cuz like what else are you buying? Magnifying glasses? Like who gives a [ __ ] But like if you're playing mystic you're you need to pay for at least one other thing.

Yeah, like assuming like you're going to use for example a fight spell, that's going to cost you seven resources. If you're going to play clue spell, that's eight resources, right?

things usually have limited uses. Either that or you're playing events, which can get expensive.

Yeah.

Um and and even if you're doing doom stuff like the the assets aren't they're they're one-time investment, but they're not cheap.

Yeah.

So, you're

I um I'm I'm on like the 3.5 area as well, but I'm not having a good day, so I'm going to also round up. But I think 3.5 like we all kind of agree like 3 3.5 is like perfect, but we don't do .5s here, so

don't we don't do that.

Yeah, but uh yeah, I I I mean it's

Russ, come on the table.

Yeah, I think it's a still just a good card. Next up we got our damage spell here for the set for the new core rather. Cosmic Flame three cost takes up the arcane slot uses three charges. As an action fight if you succeed you may spend one charge deal plus one damage for this attack. If you reveal a skull token during this test, remove one charge from Cosmic Flame. If you cannot take one damage and discard this card.

I think it's a cool it's a cool take on like magic is dangerous [clears throat] and like sometimes it doesn't work out the way that you want it to.

Mhm.

I think it's like an interesting way for purple to be able to fight with brain.

Mhm. Mhm.

That being said, I think I still pick Shrivelling over this most of the time.

I think I take this over Shrivelling like if I had to choose one I'd do this 100% of the time because

Shrivelling's earlier in my binder.

That is fair. That is fair. Yeah, no that's a great point.

I draw it first.

Yeah, yeah.

And I'm then I'm like what do I I'm I going to put this away?

Yeah.

Like

Uh to me it's that it's you don't need to spend charges to fight with it if you want to do that third damage but I think they're pretty like I think like there's like I won't blink if someone brings Shrivelling. I think these are to me both like I'd give Shrivelling a three and I think I'm giving this a three as well.

Yeah, it'll forever bother me being that mystic so like allowed to do things with their brain without some kind of risk or penalty.

Mhm.

Well, there's risk or penalty. It's just like very small.

Yeah.

Yeah, I I think this could I think this could prove to have you have an more symbol like icons on it. Like not just skull. Like even if they didn't want to like they could do like the the the baseball bat approach and do skull and auto fail so that there is even the risk of like you auto fail you're like oh I don't spend a charge nothing happened, right? But like then it's like the auto fail still takes the charge or the asset.

like be more dangerous the campaign went on as well and like have it be the not skull tokens.

Yeah. Yeah, I think I think like this probably should be like if you reveal a skull token do both.

Yeah.

Then if you can't remove a charge throw it away. Yeah, but Yeah, I definitely think it could have been pushed it. Yeah. Yeah, like I think I think it's just it's just like a fine card.

Yeah.

Yeah, I I do think this is like a happyish medium between uh spells being dangerous and like people being risk averse.

Yeah, definitely like a better spot than some of the other recent stuff that we've seen or like even something not even recent.

Song of the Dead.

Yeah, oh yeah.

I mean that one has the most risk it does nothing.

Yeah, it doesn't have any downside.

It has no upside. It actually has no side. You look at it from any angle and you're like this thing's just a floating a sphere. Uh Bruno you three?

Yeah, I'm good I'm good to give this one a three. Like I don't care about it. Like it this card is good in like if we're if I'm playing like an underworld connections pile and I need different named spells to do things. Yeah, like this is probably an auto include. But outside of that it's kind of like whatever just pick one.

Yeah.

Pick the one the differences are kind of negligible.

The down pick the one that has the downside you care about the least. Do whatever.

Let's keep this going. We we let's do the mystic video. We got to talk about spell assets. Those are the rules. Uh second side four cost asset takes the arcane spot uses three charges as an action investigate with your brain. If you succeed you may spend one charge discover one additional clue at your location. If you reveal a cultist token during this test remove one charge from second side. If you cannot take one horror and discard this card. So basically the same effect as the cosmic flame but just a different token for this one.

Yeah, this one's actually more egregious to me. This is just like this tick ball [ __ ] 6 cents to to

Yeah.

one of the other like the normal mystic spells.

Mhm.

Um I I really don't think they should be allowed like mystic should be able to just investigate with brain for free.

Yeah, I think fighting is like okay cuz that's how you not you don't lose the game. But like being able to win the game indefinitely is a little bit of a I agree. Kind of a shouldn't be happening. I'm actually move these dice for us.

Oh god.

No.

Yeah, I understand why the symmetry between them but again this could have more tokens.

Yeah, I thought

for one especially the cultist token like

Yeah, some campaigns don't even have them.

Yeah.

Why? Yeah, I think that that I think me that's the biggest problem like a big problem for me as well is that I think that uh skull tokens there hasn't been a campaign without them. But there's a lot of campaigns that do fluctuations on the tablet cultist and squid and I think that this kind of now brings up the thought of what the hell? This now brings up the thought of what or can we not include these in our campaigns? Like is that are we going to care about that for second sight that they can just spend the three charges and then investigate forever? I think there's a bigger

Yeah.

Like these could have at least bare minimum also had auto fail token on them.

Yeah, or like when if this has no charges on it discard it?

Yeah. Yeah.

So like I don't like I don't like the art for this one. What the hell is a second sight? It's just like I like they had a picture and then they put some guy's hands on it.

Like

There are six hands in this hands hands hands.

they had the art in the back they're like no we need something to make it look like so you can know that you're like looking from a point of view. So it's like sight.

What I think they really needed What they really needed was a fourth car a fourth investigating car with an eye on it. Now, that we just need to do more of those.

Yeah, why

Yeah, no, I agree. I agree.

Like a sick piece of art like an eye just with like another eye inside the pupil. That would be really cool.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. I agree. I think I think this one's like a four. For me, if this isn't the option you choose if you're looking for one of these, then I have to question why.

Yeah, I also give this one probably a four.

I think the the other ones all have like actual downside to them.

Uh does the upgrade this one get you a free clues at level five?

Uh that is not until our other ones. So, I don't know, but let me check.

That would affect my evaluation.

Uh you spend one charge to discover an additional clue or one clue at a connecting location. So, still just one clue, but you can grab from an adjacent connection.

Okay, I give this a three then.

The fact that it doesn't upgrade as well?

Yeah. It's especially like in especially since we play with three people so often. Um this is like a little bit So, and then it is more of a three or four players. Uh it's probably a four if you play like exclusively with two investigators. But at at three or four, it's like not getting the extra clues is tough.

If you play with one the like single-handed, uh the uh the upgrade is like even better cuz you can just grab the clue at your place and and like another place the place before and grab that that too. I Yeah, I mean, I do appreciate that the design isn't just like crazy cuz I think like the the Cosmic Flame upgrade that we're going to talk about later I think is a little bit like a little pushed. Um but this one I think it upgrades in a much healthier way. But I think like the level zero version just being able to get like a a book the shroud to mystics to just basic investigate is a little problematic. He's having a great time. He's happy he's in the video. Uh I'm going to give this one a three.

Yeah, the like the upgrade one sounds like it's a lot more it's a lot closer to six cents or than it is to the level four of the other versions. Clairvoyance and stuff or the level five clairvoyance I guess.

All right. Next up, we got Cloak of Resonance. This is a three cost asset takes up the body slot.

Dustin, where's my evade spell?

Uh that's coming up in the evergreen starter decks. Worry not Travis, we'll be talking about those in a few weeks.

core set?

No. Well, it is in the evergreen set technically cuz those are like it's like it's expanded core core plus if you will. Uh yeah. Uh three soak as a reaction when Horus placed on Cloak of Resonance exhausted deal one damage to an enemy or location. It's a they turned they skinned Agnes, put her on a coat, and I think it's like

Yeah.

Uh I think it's a tiny bit expensive for what you like really want from the effect, but I still think it's like I could see it played in a in a good number of decks. I think I'm going to give this one a two.

Yeah. That's where I think about where I am too. This this card is like slightly worse guard dog. But it is like slightly worse in many of the ways that matter. Like it does not just beat a cultist.

Yeah.

Uh it doesn't do that.

Yeah.

Uh it actually does nothing to cultists. Uh A lot of one health enemies just do one damage.

Yeah.

Yeah. This doesn't interact with that very well.

Yeah, yeah.

That being said, if you can play both you can do a lot of damage.

a lot of damage with no actions and no tests. Yeah, yeah.

I think I would give this a one. I don't really see a lot of use like good use cases for it.

Mhm. Uh I could see it playing it in like a uh

Jesus, Rose. Sorry, Rose.

It's okay.

You were bad, buddy.

Yeah, you go get those boxes.

I could see playing it

Uh I could see like maybe playing it in um like a Carolyn Fern deck or something like that potentially. Uh but I think there's better options to do damage for her if that's what you want. If I want this effect in Mystic, it probably like if you're not going to play this for the soak, three money for three brain soak, like Mystic can do better than that.

Mhm.

Uh especially if if it takes up a relatively useless slot for Mystic, but still. Uh and then if I want this effect, I'm just going to play Agnes and like build around it.

Yeah, but you can't. Cuz they skinned her. They turned her into a coat, Travis. She's dead.

Not in Legacy.

Yeah, in Legacy she's dead. It's like Jenny. We ripped We didn't complain. You didn't complain when we ripped Jenny up.

Yeah, cuz Jenny isn't having any [ __ ]

No, I I think I think all that assessment is pretty fair. Yeah. For me, I just like um I I have the I I'm doubling down and I'm betting that like the kill yourself Mystic is going to be really big in the future, so. I think that this card has It's I think there's a lot of like moving pieces and this is going to be a part of that deck, cuz I think for me.

Or we So you you think you're you're valuing it based on speculative

Speculative and also I think that there is a lot of good pieces there. Like now with like Jim Culver, I see a world like where Mystics try to play a bit more like Rogues, where it's like you get all the combo pieces together and you're dealing damage to enemies, drawing cards, getting clues all at once. And I think that I think there's a lot of it's all a lot more potential for that in Legacy already, and I think it's just going to even get better. But still only a two. Like, I'm not saying this card is going to get like to a three, but like I think that this card does have

Yeah, that's fair.

a place, yeah.

I I I I This card's mostly binder fodder right now.

All right. Next up, we got Spirit Oh, frick. One. One. Uh uh Travis, I know you're also a one on this one. Oh, I don't even need to change it.

Wow.

Uh Spirit, I don't want to speak for Brink, cuz sometimes he gets a little bit spicy with these talents, but

you want to pay money for something you can get for free with Blood Pact?

Uh so, like, no.

Yeah. So, this one is spend one resource to get plus one brain uh or fist, and if it gets plus two instead of it's on a spell or a ritual card. Yeah. Like, I mean as far as Legacy goes, yeah, like, I'm never I'm never playing this card. There's better I got better choices to get plus brain and plus fist, like Cat Mask.

Yeah. Yeah. And Blood Pact.

And Blood Pact, yeah. Yeah.

Yeah.

Which is honestly one of my favorite cards. No.

It is a cool

That card is awesome. Dexter Drake loves that card.

Yeah. Dexter Drake is the only

Again, both Dexters, too. Both Dexters, too, yeah.

Yeah.

It is kind of I mean, I think that like of the core investigators and like reimaginings we've seen so far, I think Dexter does a cool thing of being the same but different enough that he like can look at like the same card and be like, "I'm going to do something [ __ ] up and different with each of them, you know?"

Yeah, yeah.

But nothing with this one. This card's bad. Don't play it.

Mhm.

Uh Mask of Silenus. This is a three cost, one experience, item, mask, relic, curse, takes up the hat slot. Milady. Uses three charges as is when you reveal chaos tokens, spend one charge, reveal one additional token, choose one of those tokens to resolve and ignore the other. If you resolve a token with a symbol, take one horror. This is the Grizzly Totem reimagined. Now it has a cheaper experience and a little bit of a downside. Actually has a downside for which token you choose to resolve.

How come I can wear this mask and also other masks?

Because the original masks were designed a little bit bad and also we can wear two masks in real life, Travis.

They should just errata the masks. Think of how that's so

I agree. I think they should be I think that would be a good use of errata to just have it all work like that.

But you guys know who in Legacy can play this card? Ursula Downs. It's a wild

She can play this. Can she do anything with it?

You can use it

Archaic Glyphs? Can making sure you're getting a good hit on that?

Yeah, like you could try and abuse You could be putting experience into this instead of steady hand to try and get your science stuff to work. Your precision stuff to work.

[gasps]

Yeah, you're right. You could do that.

Yeah.

You could play it alongside Gaze of Ourax.

Yeah, you could you could. You could do this with Yeah, what if like some curse shenanigans? Can't she do anything with Flute of the Outer Gods?

No, no one can.

I I know that's not true. Ursula can. The only time I played Flute of the Outer Gods was in Ursula when I had to play every card in a year and I got all 10 curses on it and do you know what it did? It moved me once.

Wow.

Yeah.

If only Ursula had a way to move once, that would be a completely outclassing her.

She doesn't. Unfortunately, the it was like slim pickings and I was like, you know what? This actually makes Ursula playable.

I mean like I think this this effect is fine, but it's not something that I'm looking for most of the time. Like I don't know, maybe if I was playing some sort of weird snowmobile like shotgun Sister Mary

Mhm.

pile or something like that, trying to fish for a better token.

Mhm. Mhm.

I feel any of them for your shotgun attacks, I think you have better options, but

No, there are no other options.

I give this a two, Justin.

Yeah, I think I'm two as well.

I'm I'm on a one for this.

I think it does have a niche where you're like, I want Grizzly Totem, but I'm broke.

I think Yeah, I think I think like if this is the type of effect that I want, I just want to be playing like Premonition effects instead.

Yeah, that's fair. I mean, I I I to me I view this pretty similar as Grizzly Totem, where it's like I don't want this effect. I I don't want the card in my deck that much, but when it's there, I'm like, oh, this card actually performs. And that's kind of what Mask of Sanity does. Like, at the time I've seen it played, it it did its job, but I don't think his job is necessary most of the time. And I think that to me is where it's I kind of falters a bit. But, yeah. I mean, taking up the hat slot's good, cuz that is the the freest slot that exists right now, so

It's not real.

Yeah.

No, it's not. It's the Tarot's slot.

No, the freest slot is the footwear slot.

Yeah.

That's not a slot.

Yeah, it is.

It's not.

It will be.

No, we're still

time this video comes out

All right. Uh Cosmic Flame level five, three cost, five experience, four charges, fight. You get plus two brain, and you deal plus one damage with this attack. If you succeed, you may spend one charge to deal one damage to any location. If you reveal a skull token during this test, remove one charge from Cosmic Flame. If you cannot, take one damage and discard this card.

They fixed the problem with firearms by making it into a melee weapon. That's crazy.

I was about to say, they did such a good job making melee weapons like more balanced in chapter two, and then Cosmic Flame is just like

Yeah.

Eat my That guy You can't see it, but he's like flipping off into the void where like all the guardians are looking back being like, "What the hell?"

Yeah, it's a little bit strange cuz I do think the melee and firearm balance is really good. It's so good in chapter two. And like this kind of just like Yeah, yeah. And I mean like it is 5 XP, so maybe you can bend the rules a bit, but I do think that it needed I think like what you're saying, Travis, like if this card had more of a downside from the get-go, this would feel a little bit less egregious, right?

Okay, so but like if we compare this to I don't know Cyclopean Hammer.

Oh, you still swing the hammer. Yeah, like this this is this suddenly seems fair.

Yes, yeah, that is true. That is true.

Yeah, but I mean like the kind of hope is that when they like when like we're going to put everything in chapter one in the closet, we don't have to worry about that anymore, but it is That is a Yeah, it is a fair point.

I think this one should have mirrored uh Mirror Traveling and had the downside scale up, too.

I agree. Yeah, I agree.

Um Yeah, it should [snorts] have been like if you draw a skull

Maybe maybe this one is the like

If you if you draw a skull, you do both and the the other one's like pick.

Yeah. Maybe that maybe that is how that should have been. Whatever, it doesn't matter. It's not how they are. Uh I'd probably give this one like a five for what it is. Uh like if I'm putting a combat spell in my deck for 5 XP

Cyclopean Hammer.

Yeah, I mean like it's not going to be a spell, but like assuming it has to be a spell for the to make my deck work.

Do you know what's crazy? In Legacy this costs two [ __ ] experience.

That's Okay, that's a five. Sorry. Yeah, I'm going to say that's a five. Yeah, no, that's That's actually nuts.

Yeah.

No, this card is like a pretty

Like for for what it is.

bad design.

I think this card is like kind of goated.

I I think this card is unfortunately similar to the hammer.

Mhm. Yeah. Just like like I mean like again, thank god that like the fighting one is the broken one here cuz if this was like the Kluver one was this good, that would be

Why would you play other classes?

Yeah. Mhm. But that crazy card uh Yeah, two experience in legacy is disgusting. That's so

not allowed to have it till scenario three. Scenario

two

two yeah yeah okay.

Yeah, the first one costs two and then the second one would cost four. So like you could buy both but you're going to pace it out, right?

Yeah.

Yeah, I mean like paying paying six to have have 10 XP with

Actually right, it's still pretty good reduction. Yeah, it's still pretty good reduction. Yeah, like on on

on scenario two.

Yeah. Like you're telling me that I can take the XP

YOU'RE YOU'RE YOU'RE YOU'RE RIGHT.

I CAN TAKE THE XP that I won playing the playing the My House piece of the first starter campaign and I can go into Midnight Masks with two of these.

Yeah.

Like No, you're right. I'm sorry.

Yeah,

yeah you're right.

Well, you have to have three brain damage really though.

Yeah, if only there's a way to like potentially remove two of it off of you with a card we saw earlier.

You can get there faster if you take in the thick of it, too, to buy the first one?

No, because you're not upgrading at that point. Like you're still building your deck in the first part.

get to start with one. One level three.

Uh no no, because the first one would cost five, right? Like it always would.

So there's no in between for these?

Um

level three cosmic flying?

No no, it's just it's just yeah.

Oh okay.

Yeah yeah.

That's the piece I was missing.

Yeah. But yeah, I mean if they ever do print one, you never know. But I don't think I don't think this cycle needs it. I think like uh this is already I mean we gave it three [ __ ] fives. We don't need to like make it more efficient in legacy.

There's kind of inevitable I think we're likely going to see a lot of spells that are very strong in

And when they when they cost a fraction of their XP.

Well, yeah, cuz they're not doing the like experience reduction isn't really a thing for Mystic in chapter two. So the cards are going to be costed at what they should be, but then you take them to legacy and you're like you cost two.

Yeah. Yeah, no, I think that's yeah. So that's yeah, that's one of the things where like in [snorts] like this is the most appropriately they could have costed this with legacy like with the ramifications from legacy.

Yeah, this could have been exceptional.

Yeah. No, it's cool and like

Like you only need the one copy of

In legacy they can just chain it to cost three extra XP.

Yeah.

We have two separate two separate

We have to see events and skills still, Russ.

Yeah, so we need Sorry for interrupting you. I should have talked to you while you were cleaning your weiner. Next up we got Will of the Cosmos. This is a zero cost event. Then place one doom on a player card you control, then discover one clear location and one clue at another revealed location.

Oh, this card's

This card is actually kind of sick, yeah.

[snorts]

Oh, I don't even have to change it.

I'm also there. This was in my in my video I list video I did of the top 10 strongest cards in chapter two and this one's in it. It's so good, man.

I was a while ago I was like making different This is like two years ago that I was making a bunch of different Luke decks to play for various things and there were so many different Luke decks you could play and there was just even more now. Like now you don't even like I I had my deck that was like we do book we do and then we do brain. We don't have to do anything now. You don't have to use any skills. You can just get clues off adjacent locations without being at those locations without making

Yeah, you can you can even be like I'm going to do it at this location over here and

I'm going to like I get my gate box I'll get the clue that's like three locations away from where I was and then also another one from over here and now I go back to this

You know, what you say is like you say, "I'm going to play this at the connecting location, so then I discover a clue at that location, and then I use the connecting location from that to discover a clue at my location." Then you play it again, you say, "I'm going to play it at my location, discover a clue from my location, and then the connecting location I'll grab from the connecting location." Then everyone's like, "Why are you talking like this?"

Yeah, like it doesn't matter if it's connecting or not.

Yeah, it's just It's just revealed.

Uh Brennan, were you also in five?

And then like I'd probably give this like a four, I guess. Um Discovering clues is not important.

This is like two times. You don't have to make a book for each shroud.

Yeah, you're right.

It's also an event. Wouldn't you love to have this in your Norman deck?

Here's the thing. You I don't have to play this, someone else will.

But you know what's Do you know what's really good? Is that he's already played and used this card in Dexter very well.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Cuz it is You know what it's very good with? It's very good with Dexter.

Yeah, like I probably should be playing it in my current Dexter deck, but like [ __ ] that.

No, no, you don't need to get clues. You're here to You're here to shoot people with a cannon.

Yeah, we have a we have a gun.

Yeah. Yeah, we have a Mandy with an illegal card in her deck, so like

Yeah.

Yeah, it's pretty illegal.

Yeah.

Um but like I think Drawn to the Flame is always been a stellar card, and this is like

It's just better.

Um yeah, a more free Drawn to the Flame.

it's an It's an easier downside to manage.

Yeah, yeah.

Yeah, like you can't get two two off the same locations.

Yeah, and you do need to get You do need to like have an answer for the doom, probably.

But like that's not that hard.

No.

No, it's yeah.

Yeah.

Uh it's just not a strict upgrade, I don't think.

Yeah. All right, good job, Well of the Cosmos. Next one we got here is Ward of Protection. It's back, baby. Uh

Five. I love this card.

I don't even need to change it.

Yeah.

Um I'm going to be a little bit of a hater. I'm going to go four.

Okay, I I I don't play this one.

You play the old one?

I play like two.

You play two?

I play I play like ward two, ward one. I'm kind of like, what is my guy like weak as hell? Can I not solve my own problems?

So, if you play ward one, then uh it makes your ward two is free.

Yeah, but like I don't need to do that.

So, putting this in your deck is like putting ward two in your deck.

Yeah, I'm not going to buy those though. I'm going [snorts] to pay I'm going to pay XP for my

Yeah, bro. He wants the premium. He wants

Just Just give it a five cuz you like us playing ward two or whatever.

Actually, I don't.

Oh, okay.

I'm like figuring out how to solve my solve my my problems and then Travis is like, that's not a problem. And I'm like But I was already halfway down the avenue to a solution.

That's because we're the team Yeah, cuz you're like, I need I don't need three cards to solve this problem. And I'm like and then

Like and then it just be gone. He solved everything. You're like, well, now all the cards I have in play are in my hand. But if I draw two cards and take the attack of opportunity.

Like yeah, I might be able to loot.

It's just going to work. Uh yeah, no. I I'll give this guy like a four. I think this card card is like quite good.

Yeah.

I'm glad they didn't change the art on this one. It's It's good art.

Yeah, I still play the one from the real corset.

I I do too. I do too and I think it's just

It's cuz it

It really is.

It's just It's just different. Just hits different. Uh another classic, Premonition. I do like this in a core environment. I think like that's like I I'm glad they kept ward of protection cuz I think it's just such a staple mystic effect. And I think Premonition is really nice.

It's a very nice addition.

Yeah, cuz I think it it does a thing where it's like it gives you security, but then as you get better at playing Arkham and you understand lightning bolt windows more, it gives you a lot of power. So, it becomes less of like a I'm using this for security, but I'm I'm to use this to uh like we can like position our turns. We can I can find out I can use this card to see if I need to commit a skill. That's one of my favorite that I picked up from you for premonition, right? Where you do it during the lightning bolt window before you commit skill cards and then you're like I'm going to just not commit any of this stuff because I don't need it, right? Which I think is is very nice.

I think I give this card like probably a Let me just say four. I won't get like a three and a half. That's not really an option.

Okay. I'll give I'll give it a three then.

Okay, that's fair.

There you go. That's like a three and a half.

Yeah.

I'm also three and a half, but once Russell almost knocked my entire box of Marvel Legendary cards on the floor, my mood soured. So we're going to go down for this one. Um one thing that is a neat interaction that I'm going to share with players here who might not know. Will of the cosmos is just a card you control and when premonition is in play, it's a card you control. So you can actually put the doom on premonition, which is kind of neat. Yeah.

Can I put a doom on it to make it cost three less if I'm playing the

Amina? That's a trick question, Brett. You're never going to play Amina.

It doesn't matter.

Yeah, you can't trick me with that.

is no cuz it's not an asset.

But it could be.

It's not.

Yeah, it actually couldn't be. It's very it's fixed in the game.

Yeah, like it can't you it can't.

Yeah, but no, great I love this card in the core environment. I think it's very strong.

be a crazy mystic card where you get to like change a card type?

That would

Like on Sorry, like a card type like listed on a card.

Yes, that would be that would cause I mean

Don't do that.

Yeah.

But I mean there is an asset that's this.

You know, but I mean like just a card that was like you could change uh like do or die to be able to get back skills and stuff events or something.

Like the like the painter's servant or whatever it is from Magic that changes colors, but changes like that text and like that.

Yeah, don't do that, but like

Yeah. Yeah.

Your your rules framework can't handle it.

Yeah.

Well, I mean like magic's rules framework can't really handle it.

It does struggle.

So.

Like it can, but like it's just not pretty.

Uh augur of Elexos, this is a two cost three experience event. Investigate with your book and add your brain to your book for this investigation. If you succeed, discover one additional clue at your location. If you succeed and a token with a symbol was revealed during this test, you may discard a terror or hex treachery from any investigator's threat area.

Like this is two. Two. I play read the signs. It costs zero experience.

read the signs over this.

And then also costs two and then also is free, whereas this always costs three. You're garbage.

Yeah.

You're not free.

Yeah. I think that's like a I think it's uh two fairly costed, right? And like it's you can see that you can actually see this across a lot of their clue getting stuff in chapter two. They're um

They're responsible.

Yes, yeah. They're responsible. And it's like one of those things that it's like when if we were reviewing these cards with that just in mind, it'd be like, "Oh, this is like the this nice. This is healthier design." But like in legacy, you just play uh read the signs zero and you're like "I'm going to get this." Um I think I'm going to give this one a one for that reason, but uh I think that maybe it'll maybe one day it'll impress me. Um

I give it a two cuz like there's a world where I want copies three and four of read the signs and I just have a bunch of experience flowing around cuz my spells don't cost me anything.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I mean that's the that's the thing, right? Like if you're saving on the XP on like you go to read the signs like two when you're doing like a token fishing deck.

Mhm. You might as well then also just like grab this down the road and potentially use it specifically for terror or hex management cuz I think that is a relevant part of the card in the right deck. And mystics are pretty good at fishing out symbol tokens, so

Yeah, I I think this makes something like a like a clue over um parallel parallel Agnes a lot more viable, too.

Yeah, I know I think you're right. I think you're right. I think there's like uh if it's just like you want an if you want more of this, it's not bad to have.

Yeah. All right, so if there is a terror or a hex in the deck that does damage or horror, is that healing? Can you play this?

No. You know what? You know what? We should send in an email.

Cuz like it could be

It could be. Yeah, like this. Who knows? Is there a terror or a hex that has a parley action on it?

Oh.

And it's And which case discarding would be like resolving that action which you do.

Yeah, which is kind of like Alexandra can run this.

Yeah, it kind of is.

Um yeah, anyway. Like I think I think I think this is like it's not a one because there is a world that it exists in. I think. Uh I think there are some campaigns that have terrors or hexes in them that are

Are you sure?

actually a thing that you might want to discard. Yeah, no. I think I think that I think that sometimes they use I think that sometimes they use that trait.

Yeah, I've never Could you imagine if it was like terror or like fling flong and we're like, "What?"

What the [ __ ]

Yeah, I think I think I think like this one's a two. Yeah, like it could come out of the binder.

Mhm.

Yeah, I think just for more I think that's a that's a pretty reasonable assessment of it. It's also like really good if you can if you can't play skill cards in your deck and you want stuff to throw at tests. We got to revisit Norman Withers. This is pretty all right to have more of that. Pick up your level zero purple slots either. Yeah, let's go. So, that's really cool. All right, we're on to our last two cards starting with our skills. We got Soul Link here, three wild icons. This is as additional cost to commit it, take one horror. Yeah, so like I'm going to go out on a limb and say that Justin likes this a lot because it means he doesn't have to bring out extra tokens. It is very nice. Just in case somebody's committing a skill for more than two wild icons out of purple.

I think it feels much fairer.

Yes.

Than Promise of Power.

So, it's like it's it's a power level below Promise of Power.

I'm also Yeah, [snorts] I'm also going to say that Travis likes it a lot less because it's not practiced, so.

But as we did see with with Travis play, it is a spell. Yeah, you can fish it out with Arcane Initiate. Um but as we saw with Travis, just having like four Promise of Powers in your deck is pretty good and he did that in chapter two. Now, imagine in just legacy just having six Promise of Powers in your deck. Turns out it's also pretty good. I think this one's going to be a three for me.

Yeah, it's got three wild icons on it. So, it's got to it's got to be a three.

Yeah, like Promise of Power is a five and I think that this is enough below Promise of Power. Like if I had to choose one, I would take Promise of Power cuz it's free, right? But if I'm looking at like again, talking about that earlier, like the Cloak of Resonance, the Jim Culver, like this is a piece where that becomes more relevant. But I think just this is an easy card to put in a mystic deck, I think. Just like Promise of Powers.

Yeah, like I'm pretty much always playing Promise of Power over this. Um I guess except in but there's like places where if I'm playing this and I want more copies of Promise of Power, which is pretty fair. But and it does have some niches over it. Like if you're playing a not so heavy spell deck and but you want to dig out spells like you might want this over promise power for additional arcane issue hits. Um, I think it plays it's a really nice addition for Patrice just to have another wild

Yep.

skill or wild icon skill. Uh, yeah, I also give it a three like it's I'm not like oh, thank god we got this or like this is crazy but it's it's good.

Yep.

I can see playing it.

I think that Agnes actually did very well in the new core. I think she cuz she's been so I think she was like she's such a solid investigator and then she never really [clears throat] got a lot for a long time and I think she's got like

Well, yeah, I mean they printed Pete in the starter deck so like what else she need?

Yeah. But just like having more ways to trigger horror in different phases can be

You just roll up to the game you're like I got six brain four foot and can't die.

Can't ever die.

Yeah, what you got again?

Like I I give this one a three like it's just good. Um, but you don't have to play. Yeah. Yeah. And when we get to the mystic starter deck we'll have another promise of power to talk about which is also pretty good. Last card here we have fearless two. This one's also a reprint. Uh, two brain icons two experience. If this test is successful heal one horror two horror instead if it succeeds by two or more. Uh, this was brought here for uh, Izzy was like the it's an easy include for for Isabel Barnes here. But I think this is also just a nice card for mystics to have in an evergreen environment. In legacy I don't play this one too much cuz like there's a lot of other ways to manage it. Um, so I'm probably going to give it a two for that reason cuz I think that's what I would give the it in legacy cuz it already existed so that's what I'm going to put that for this here. Yeah.

I'd give it a I I'd give it a three like it's uh, I actually like this card a fair bit.

[clears throat]

Um, it's healing that doesn't cost money.

Mhm.

Um, it's easy to upgrade with down the rabbit hole. Uh

it is like a very solid defensive card not just for you but for your teammates as well. Um it's not blowing the doors off or anything and like we already had it before but it's just it's just a solid card. If I'm if you know me and someone else are hurting for horror trauma, I mean I will be if I'm playing Mystic and

uh legacy but if if someone else is also struggling with their their horror damage, it's pretty solid to include if I can't don't feel like I can support those spiritual that's the edge of the earth healing thing.

Earthly serenity?

Earthly serenity or like another one of those big

Yeah. Yeah, big bursts of the healing.

Yeah.

Mhm. Yeah. Yeah.

Just just solid.

I'm also going to just say if you're a Silas fan, this actually is playable on Silas. He can he's a survivor he can pass any test and it's a good way to just heal horror. So do that. Yeah, I give I give this one a two if it's in my deck. I give it a four if it's in somebody else's deck though.

Like leadership?

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Like if this is in somebody else's deck, then this goes from uh like cool this is a way I'm going to manage the numbers on my sheet to uh holy [ __ ] I'm not dead.

Yeah.

So like one of those things is awesome and the other thing with the other one's just like a thing that I could fix any number of ways. So like we'll give it a two cuz I suppose I'm probably rating it as like would I play it not would I try to bully Travis into playing it.

Yeah.

Yeah.

You don't need to bully me to play it.

To like fix my problems for me.

I see you also have lots of horror damage cuz you play fearless and I'm like yeah probably.

Sweet. All right.

I like it.

Well, that is our Mystic review in the books. I think overall classes is very solid. Um, the guardian and seeker were a little bit under but rogue and mystic have been good and survivor's also

Yeah, I mean like rogue is good cuz they just reprinted the good cards.

And then added cards that were also

some other broken [ __ ]

Yeah, yeah, so

So, like one broken [ __ ]

But then they made up for it by having

That's other.

Yeah, then they made a up for it by having a pretty awful evergreen deck which we'll get to when we when we get there as well but

Yeah, when we get there.

Yeah, mystics are definitely eating pretty. Their evergreen deck is also really good but survivors will be coming up in the near future everybody. I want to say thank you for watching. I hope you enjoyed this and you know, you maybe agree, disagree, let us know down in the comments. If you want to support the channel, like, comment, subscribe. If you like Russ, say Russ in the chat. Otherwise, thanks for watching. Have a good one and as always, a GG's.

Progress saved