Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Board Game Design Even Worth It? | Your YouTube comments... and my responses.

Transcript 26:10

I want to start a business making board games. Is it worth it? I've been working on a game for months, but it's not fun anymore. Should I shove it? I like your ideas, but you always bang on about sales. There's more to games than that. I'm Adam Porter. I'm a board game designer. My games have been published all across the world over the last uh the last few years. And in this video series, I like to go back through uh YouTube comments that have been made on my channel on previous videos and respond to them in more detail than I'd be able to do in text alone. So, the first comment today comes from my video Designer Diary: Emberart took us 10 years to create, which was a video all about how myself and Rob Fisher designed the worker placement game Emberart. I'm not going to show you a clip from the video as I normally do because maybe the the comment isn't specifically related to Emberheart the game. The comment is, "Sir, I also want to start my business in Euro board games. I'm yet learning and improving my board game making skills. Will it be worth it?" So, I thought this was an interesting place to start. Is it worth it? I I I guess my basic instinctive answer is I wouldn't be doing it if it wasn't worth it. Right? I've been doing this for 10 years now. 10 years plus, I think about 12 years since I seriously started trying to design games. And of course, it was another 3 years before any of them actually hit the market. Has it been worth it? Well, absolutely. I

mean, I love it. I absolutely love it. It's an incredible hobby and it generates some income. And perhaps that's the sticking point here is that this person has indicated that they are learning and improving their board game making skills and they want to start a business making Euro style board games. Now, I earn money from my games, but I don't earn enough to run a business, right? Maybe I could if I devoted myself to it full-time. I have no intention of doing that. I have a full-time job, so which I love. So why would I? You know, board game design is a nice um added extra and it generates a bit of income uh and increasing income as I produce more games and as those games have achieved more success over recent years than perhaps some of my earlier designs.

But the income is still relatively small. It's not enough really to to to live on. I think if you're going to generate enough money to run a business, then you've got to create really big hits, you've got to take all of the risk on yourself. You're going to have to self-publish those games. Um and and and that includes a whole load of skills that I don't have and and and maybe you do. Okay. So, you've got to be a publisher first really. Um but then you've also got to create great games. So, I suppose you got to be a designer first, too. You got to do both or you create or you publish games created by somebody else who's able to do the design work for you. If you're going to be licensing games to publishers, of course, it is possible to do that as a as an individual and I suppose you are essentially a business yourself. You're a soul trader at that point, aren't you?

Um, and I certainly know people who do that and we've talked about that many times on this channel. But you need a constant stream of releases and they've all got to be hitting time and time again. So either one big hitter or episodic releases of a a game that you can just bring new content out for over and over again and that's how you make it a business. But again, I've got run off into this idea of this commercial thing in terms of is it worth it? Well, if it gives you satisfaction, if it gives you joy, then absolutely. There's all sorts of reasons people design games. And frankly, I I I I can't stop if I even if I want to, right? There are several times over the last few years where I've thought, oh, do you know what? I might put a stop to this because it's eating up too much time. It's taking time away from spending time with my family or, you know, it's inconvenient traveling to Germany to go to the Essenal convention and so on. But the truth is, I just love it so much that I can't I can't stop.

Um, I guess that's what's called an unhealthy uh relationship with your hobby or an addiction, isn't it? Um, I hope it's not that. I think it's a positive thing in my life. So my answer to this person is absolutely, you know, go for it. It will be worth it. It will be worth it. Even if you make very little money, as long as you're not risking your house, you're not risking your family, you're not risking your livelihood, you're going to have a blast. So yeah, great. It it will be worth it. Next comment comes from my video. Safe space cozy mode is not good board game design. And again, the comment doesn't really relate to the video specifically, uh, so I won't show you a clip, but the comment is, "I've been working on a board game for months, and I've put a lot of work and play testing into it, but the idea is not seeming so good anymore. I've noticed holes in the rules, and despite fixing them, they still seem to be there. Also, the game is becoming less fun. My dad told me to shove it and work on a different game. What do you say?" Well, I suppose the first thing that I'm thinking here is this person, it sounds like this is a child. if they're saying their dad told them I maybe that's an assumption on my part. So um but irrespective of that you know the first thing to do is reflect on why you're doing it. Are you doing this for fun? In which case if it's not fun anymore then I would say yeah absolutely move on to something else. There's that saying the the the sunken cost fallacy. Is that what it's called? where you know you you you've put in so much work, so much effort that you can't let go. Even though you can see that every bit of effort you're putting in there is

achieving very little. At a certain point that that there's time to say, "Well, okay, I've I've I've done what I can with this and it's it's probably time to move on." And also in that period of reflection, you can look back on what you've learned from that process and bring those learnings into your next your next project. When you move on from a game, you're never truly leaving it behind, are you? You can put it on the shelf. you make sure you've written out the rules. Make sure you've got a document so you can revisit that game at a later point. I've made that mistake many times where I've, you know, I've set aside a prototype, thought, I'll come back to that. And then months pass, years pass, and then I do eventually come back to it and I realize, oh, I never actually wrote down the rules. I can't remember how to play it. And really, everything that I learned from that design has kind of been lost. So certainly make sure you've got everything documented. You're able to revisit it so you don't feel it's completely wasted. And then absolutely, I think your dad is right, put it on the shelf and try and work on some other things and you can always come back to that game later. You'll find that inspiration will suddenly strike. You know, when you're least expecting it, when you're doing something else, usually when you're playing another game or shortly after you've played another game, something will leap into your head and you think, "Ah, that's what I was looking for." That's what makes that game fun. The other thing I would say [snorts] is going back to why you started. You know, if you've been designing a game for some time, it's not really working. it's not really fun anymore. Ask yourself, what was it that I loved about this game in the first place? What was the thing that excited me about it? What specific element?

Like, what was my starting point? Was it a thematic thing? Was it a certain mechanism? Was it something exciting that I wanted to do? Well, refocus the game around that. Strip everything out. Go back to the basics and go, "Right, let's start again from there." Okay? because then hopefully you can refind that that joy and excitement that you had at the beginning. So, the next comment came from the same video and it says, "I've used an entire sticky notepad just writing down points from your videos so that I can reabsorb them later." I appreciated that comment. I appreciate all the really positive comments that people send me. Um, I appreciate the negative feedback too sometimes, but the positive comments particularly, you know, I I I I thought that was lovely that somebody's writing these things down. And it just it came at a similar time to another comment from somebody which really connected with me and I thought I want to write that down cuz that's a really good quote that that actually I'm going to revisit.

And this was a comment on a video called Dyson Not the Answer Revisited. Let me show you a quick clip from that video. In this particular video, I wanted to talk about the pitfalls that people hit when they're firsttime designers. And uh specifically, I want to talk about dice and randomness in first time designs. So, this was a very specific issue that was coming up a lot in our play testing group at the time. Um, and I have seen it since, but at the time it was a it was quite a big deal. It felt like a big deal to me. Um, very frequently people would be turning up with these games that would be absolutely rammed full of randomness despite being quite a large complex game. And so I was trying to direct quite a specific problem here uh which is you know firsttime designers people coming with their first design making it mega complex and actually having quite a lot of promise in it and then just ruining it by ramming it full of these random uh number generators.

And the comment was from somebody called at levelwithme8535. Um I hope that's not a bot. It's got a lot of numbers after their name, but I like their quote anyway. So the uh the statement was the principles of level design are only meant to be followed for as long as we don't understand why they exist. There's nothing wrong with utilizing dice at all, but if you don't understand why there's a stigma surrounding dice, best to avoid them until you do understand. I thought that was a great quote. The principles of level design are only meant to be followed for as long as we don't understand why they exist. So this reminds me of so many art forms. You know, if you're creating, if you're a painter, you're a fine artist, you might go to art school and learn how to do fantastic, you know, photo realistic paintings where everything is um, you know, is created perfectly and and and you look at it and it's it's barely distinguishable from real life, right?

And only then do people start to go on and to develop into creating these expressionist things. People like Picasso, right, was this incredible realistic artist before he went on to do things which were much less traditional. Okay, I'm I'm not a great art historian, so I might be completely off the off the wall there, but one thing I do know about maybe is Shakespeare, right? I used to be an actor. Shakespeare started out his career writing very standard verse which just followed the meter as every playwright before him had done. Da dum dum dum dum dum. Right. And then later in his career he started to break that down and make much more complex forms of um of meter and poetry and verse because he understood it and he understood what breaking those rules did, right? and and how they could make things um uh deeper and richer and and more emotional and and connect with people by breaking the rules. But you have to understand the rules before you can break them. Now, of course, there are no rules in board game design, but there are some sort of accepted sort of um ideas around, you know, randomness and complexity and what people enjoy and what they don't. And it takes a master, somebody like Richard Garfield, to break all of those rules. And one thing people keep telling me in the the response to these videos is, "Yeah, but Magical Athlete breaks all of these rules." And that's absolutely right. Magical athlete does, and it's wonderful, but it's created by an absolute genius. This is

the guy who created Magic the Gathering, and he's done it before, right? We're always telling people, try and avoid player elimination because we don't want to leave anybody out. But King of Tokyo does it, right? Richard Garfield knows his craft and so he's able to then break these rules and and do it in an effective way that connects with people. So my advice is not, you know, never do this stuff. My advice is start out when you're first designing by trying to stick to the rules, learn the rules, learn why we try and avoid some of this stuff before you start to incorporate it deliberately to achieve a desired goal. Another comment from that same video, dice are not the answer, was maybe the answer is actually math. You need math for designing all games. I think even rock paper scissors.

So that's interesting. I know that there are a lot of designers who who approach their games as a mathematical task, a mathematical puzzle. Um, but I think many many more designers do it on intuition. And I'm probably more one of those, right? I don't tend to math everything out in spreadsheets. It's all done on feel really. It balancing games. I think, frankly, I think it's difficult. There's so much complexity to these games that actually doing the mathematics is is is tough, right? It's ext these things are extremely complex from a mathematical viewpoint. So, and even if you get the maths right, it can feel very wrong. Something can mathematically be perfectly balanced but feel way off, right? Because of the theme or because of how other games approach it and so on. So, a lot of it has to be done on instinct and intuition and feel. So, I'm not sure math is entirely the answer. Although, I think it can be helpful and I think it's a skill that I I lack and [snorts] I think it would be good if I did have that.

Maybe that's something where I need collaborators who are able to do some of that stuff for me. So, I'm not sure math is entirely the answer. There was another comment on this video which said, "Rolling a single dice is chaotic. Rolling a 100 dice is fully predictable." which of course is a mathematical viewpoint and has some truth to it. But the reality of the situation is you're not going to roll a 100 dice uh in a single turn. Maybe in a game of Warhammer 40,000 or something like that. I certainly remember when I played that 20 years ago or however long ago it was rolling buckets of dice every time that you attacked with your unit and then picking out dice and rolling another bucket of dice afterwards to see how many of those hits got through armor and so on. buckets after buckets and it was fun rolling these huge handsfuls of dice. But you don't see that in many games. Most games you roll very small numbers which means you get quite a chaotic outcome. If you roll hundreds of dice throughout the entire game, then the the results are not predictable, are they? Because they're going to come out in all sorts of different orders. And so yes, you might get uh an even distribution of results, but if they come out in different orders in every game, then the outcome of that game is going to be totally different. Um, and of course, if different players are rolling the dice, then they're having different outcomes and so on. So, I'm not sure how helpful this idea of Well, no, that's not true. It's worth thinking about. I do think this is helpful.

We're going to meet somewhere in the middle, aren't we? You roll one dice, it's extremely chaotic. If you roll multiple dice, then we're mitigating that chaos to some degree. But how far can you go before it becomes unwieldy or too predictable? That's a judgment call for the designer, isn't it? How much do we mitigate this luck? Is that constant uh that constant struggle for the designer? We want a bit. We want a bit of unpredictability. Not in every game. Some games of course entirely deterministic. But in a lot of games we want a little bit of chaos, a little bit of unpredictability to add to the tension. And the job for the designer is working out how much how much feels right, how much feels satisfying. The next comment comes from a video called the aspects of your game that really matter, the dice model. So let me show you a quick clip.

Designers often spend months perfecting things that players barely notice. A rule gets rewritten 20 times. A scoring mechanism is endlessly refined. A moment of brilliance results in an elegant resolution to an irritating edge case. And then the game gets played and nobody bats an eyelid at any of your hard work. Maybe the players obsess over the theme, the characters, the stories, or they give loads of feedback about presentation and graphic design. They're not looking at the game as a designer. And why should they? They're players. They don't purchase a game because it's perfectly mathematically balanced or utilizes a clever mechanism to minimize downtime or has a unique new rule to prevent a runaway leader. Some parts of your game matter far more to players than others. And the challenge is identifying which parts. And that's what the dice model is designed to do. And the comment is, I like your ideas, but I don't like that you always present them in economic terms. there's more to games than the game market. And I think that's a fair comment. I do focus on games as products. Um, and I suppose that does mean economics. I don't care all that much about the money, but I do care about my games reaching many, many players because that's kind of my purpose in creating them. I want to firstly, I want to challenge myself in terms of seeing how far that reach can be. I'm really interested in what publishers want. I'm

really interested in what customers want. Um I I f I I I try to be an empathic person. I like to, you know, think about what people want, what people need, how I can satisfy that, I suppose, with my games. That's a starting point for me. Um that doesn't feel like a particularly ruthless starting point. it feels quite a positive starting point really to think about am I creating something that's useful to people not just something that interests me but something that's going to interest a lot of people. So that's my starting point is to create games as products and I talk about that a lot in my videos. That said I do talk about a lot of things in my videos. So hopefully um you know where he says there's I don't like you always present them in economic terms. I'm not sure that's true. I make a lot of videos about lots of things. Um, lots of videos about mechanisms, for example, that aren't really presented in economic terms, but it is a big focus of the channel. So, I think it's a fair comment. That said, you know what else is there? Numerous different things. He's quite right.

There's more to games than the game market. I made a whole video about the different motivations of designers. You know, why people make games. They might make games to educate people, to advocate for a certain world view. They might do it because they enjoy fiddling around with puzzles for their own satisfaction of of engineering a system. Um, they might do it just because they're driven. Like I mentioned earlier, I just I can't stop myself. I'm doing it because I've just got this constant urge to do it. They might do it because they're an artist. They want to create something beautiful or something with some deep meaning. So, there's all sorts of reasons people create games. And I'm certainly not denigrating any of those other things when I say that my focus is on creating products. And there are many other channels that talk about game design. This one does have a particular focus on on product design.

Um, as do my many books about board game design. They do tend to focus on that idea of of of creating games as as products, commercial products, things that people are going to um find and enjoy. Um, so I think it's it's fair comment. It is a focus of the channel. I'm sorry that it's a aspect of my channel that this particular viewer doesn't enjoy. Um, but it's not going to change because frankly that's who I am as a designer. That's what I like to do. Um, and it's not to denigrate anybody else and their motivations as a designer. I meet people who design games for all sorts of reasons all the time and I think that's wonderful and I fully respect them. Next comment then, designer diary. How I designed my own abstract strategy game, Surakata. Just show you a quick clip. Hi, I'm Adam Porter. I'm a board game designer from Wales. And several years ago, you may have seen I made a video about how to design an abstract strategy game or a combinatorial game as they're sometimes called. And this video is all about how I went on and did it. And so I have my first abstract strategy game coming out at Essen Spiel uh in the next couple of weeks actually in October 2025. And it's called Surkata. is coming from Ghart Spiel and Design, a small German uh publisher of handcrafted wooden abstract games. And the comment was, "Looking at various titles, Garts usually only credits designers on the part of the sticker that wraps over the side of the box rather than the top or front of the box. Was that a specific request by you?

If so, well done." And it's true that what this person has observed, which is that the author's name, the the designer's name is often on the side of the box and on the back of the box, but not prominently on the front of the box. Um although on some of the games it is, so they're a little inconsistent in that regard. And many of these hobby games behind us, the stuff that's sold in the hobby side of the market, the designer's name is prominent. And a lot of those uh associations that support game designers are pushing for that, right? That's how we got our names on the front of the box because game designers before me and previous generation of designers going back the last 30, 40 years have pushed for it to get recognized as authors and I fully support that. I'm not that bothered about whether my name is on the front, whether it's on the side, whether it's on the back or whether frankly it's in the rule book. The most important thing to me is that I get some credit from it that I can take forward and I can say this game is mine, right? I I contributed to this. But I think of these games as collaborations between a large number of different creative people. The publisher puts a lot into it in terms of money, in terms of risk, but also in terms of creative input in a lot of cases, the development of the game, not just the way it looks, sometimes in terms of the rule set as well. Um, and so I I think these are often we get compared to authors of books. And I understand why, but it's not quite like that. You know, a novel really does have one creative input. Okay, there might be an editor who takes a little bits out

and says maybe you want to rewrite this little passage and so on. But basically, there's one creative [snorts] person at the center of that. Designing a game, there's so many more creative people. And so it feels, I don't know, a little too precious to me to get too upset about, you know, I need to have the most prominent billing and so on. That said, I totally understand why previous generations have pushed for it because in the past some of these older games that, you know, I've got lots of old MB games and Milton Bradley games, Parker Brother games, they're not always credited and sometimes they're credited completely inaccurately. the wrong person's being being given credit for a game that was created by somebody else. So, I get why people have pushed for it and I get that there needs to be solidarity industry in the industry from designers to make sure that this continues to happen that designers are getting prominent credit. But I also think the illustrators deserve credit, the graphic designers, the sculptors, you know, the writers, the numerous different creatives that uh go into a game. and and they can't all be on the front of the box because that is prime real estate for selling the experience to the players and frankly the players don't care about very much of that stuff. It's a tricky one as a designer.

You want to build a name. You want to build a profile. You want to become recognizable. You know, if I'm looking at a game and I see Ryan Kitzia's name on that box or Phil Walker Harding's name on that box or Bruno's name on that box, that's a bit of a seal of quality for me. I'm more likely to buy the product. But my name's not that. Not yet. And maybe it never will be. You know, somebody sees Adam Porter written on the box. I don't think they're going, "Oh, there's a seal of quality. I'm definitely going to buy that." It's basically wasted real estate from the point of view of the publisher in terms of selling the game. All it's really doing is stroking my ego a little bit, but also, I guess, building my profile so that in the future I might become a recognizable name. I need to clarify my own thoughts on this a lot more, I think, because I know that it's it's really important to a lot of designers.

And I'd really like to hear in the comments why it's so important to you that your name is prominent on the front of the box there. For me, as I say, side of the box, front of the box, back of the box, I don't really mind. G Hartfield, I should address this because they're wonderful, right? There are this lovely family who create these games that get sold in craft fairs and schools in Germany. They and I'm doing them a disservice. I I think they they don't have wide international distribution is what I'm saying, but but they create these beautiful handcrafted products and they're created with love and they work with the authors really effectively. Um and I don't think they would have a a problem for a second input in a designer's name on the box if it was important to the designer and they requested it. And frequently they have done as I didn't request it. My name's on the box there. I don't know why I haven't asked. Um, but the name is always on the box. It just might be on the side. It might be on the back. So, yeah, none of this is to to to to denigrate um Gartfield in any way.

They've been wonderful to work with. Um, and they do sit very much more in the mass market than they do in the hobby market where it's a bit less common to have the designer's name on the box at all. Now, this is something that you can stress in your contracts in those negotiations when you're signing a game with publisher. You can let them know what your expectation is there. And often the the standard contracts that they give you will state very clearly where your name is going to be displayed. And the vast majority of them will say it's going to be displayed prominently on the front of the box. Um so that you know if that's your expectation then certainly make sure that that's written into your contracts. Um and and that might be a a deciding factor between whether you go with a publisher or whether you don't. And and that's down to you as a designer to decide. Okay. So we've got through another few questions there. Um, there are lots of other of these more conversational videos on the channel, so I'll put a link to a couple of those that you might want to check out. And I'll see you on the next video very soon. Until then, all the best.

Progress saved