5 GAMES I Would STEAL from Carlo's Shelf | Shelf of Shame EXPOSED!
Transcript
hey how's it going everyone carlo here from all you can board and as always i'm here with my cousin dylan although if things look a little different to you if you're familiar with the channel it's because this time we are finally at my house for the first time ever dylan has brought his equipment over because this is part two of our uh five games you would steal video so this time dylan has come over to uh theoretically steal five games theoretically well yeah we're talking about our last video he's not actually stealing games but it's just five games he would steal yeah um yeah welcome here thanks yeah my first time here my first time in your games room ever yeah right but i did vacuum the cat hair off the uh felt table here because the cats are always sprawled out on this thing that's commitment to the craft yeah exactly when you vacuum the cat hair off the felt not for when we when you have friends who are playing games that's not worth it but for this specifically yeah i'm excited to steal games off your shelf i like being on this side of the the coin rather than the other ones i'm a little nervous to see what you steal but uh i'll tell everyone what's the uh cri are you looking at the same way as me i know when i went there you were talking about like how you didn't expect me to take into account like the financial aspect you're like financially sound with your decisions i did not take into consideration financials at all but i also don't think that there's any small ones or inexpensive ones on my list i honestly didn't i didn't look at price at all that's my guess okay um i i debated very briefly uh just stealing agricola as the first one just so that you couldn't have it in your collection and then you'd have to buy another rosenberg game and i would just convince and then for your birthday or something i'd buy a feast from right right yeah i briefly considered going that route with
my uh with my criteria but you know there's other games i want from your collection so yeah no i just picked the games that like i really really want and that i might even at some point buy my like myself one day okay that it would just be easier without me having to buy them just to steal them from your shelf so okay fair enough yeah i was going to propose something before i made i have a white board here where i wrote down my five guesses okay as to what you're gonna steal and i was gonna suggest that if i somehow nail all five that you would have to admit on camera that agricola is better than a female rodent okay um because i think you mentioned that of the ones i stole from you in the video that you were expecting about i think you saw three of them coming but two are a huge surprise yeah if i nail all five like there's like 100 plus games here right like that's pretty crazy so if i get four out of five i think you should still have to at least admit that they're at least equal i don't expect anything for three correct guesses okay than that here's what i'll propose if you nail all five i'll admit that agricola has a better game than feast froden but anything less than five you have to admit anything that's the way the stakes work if i go over five maybe no no if you go over five over five two one or zero and you have to admit how confident how come i'm already done no i'm not that confident that's the thing i second guess myself it has to be zero or maybe no i don't like this weight okay fine fine wager's off then just but i do want to see your picks at the end okay yeah i will hold them up hold them up okay it sounds good okay i'm gonna steal my first game okay you ready because it's one that's super close to me so it's might even hit you in the back of the head as i steal it so the first one i would steal is uh oh wow right here which is i wasn't sure if you
were games on this that were you haven't even played yet well why not it's no that's fair i would go buy a game i haven't played and i get to steal what i haven't played horror yeah so okay the reason it's on my list is because i've actually wanted to play this for uh a while can we like get our heads in here with it for at least a little bit um yeah and so it has a bunch of different aspects that i really like i honestly like have never actually sat down and read the entire rulebook to know exactly what i'm getting into i just know that the mechanics the look of the board the theme everything checks all those boxes i love the polyamino type pieces that they have on there i love i think this is the one that has that really cool resource system where you get um trolls and like this pyramid um structure where like your resources water fall down like how you collect the murder which i think is super super cool uh there's just a whole bunch of elements i love about it and i have like literally thought about buying this multiple times when the kickstarter campaign was on for the um fall of the mountain king i briefly considered getting in and doing the fall and the hall just as a way to like like finally just take the plunge uh so yeah it's it's been on my list for a while as soon as you got it i knew i was gonna at least play it at your place yeah uh but if i was we're talking stealing games like why wouldn't i just steal it there's one that i want to play have you have you played this no i haven't it's been one of those i've been here for maybe at least six months go and you buy you go and buy a game that i really really want just to keep it on your shelf and your shelf of shame this is just like you should just give this to me i don't even i shouldn't even have to steal you just be like i don't know what the deal would have been i love the box art too and yeah just like everything about it is uh is really really cool so yeah um it's got
the shared interactive board that you're building on there's a lot of other exactly the table presence of the entire thing is super cool like i just love everything about it so from based on what i've seen and i haven't even played it it's just one of those ones that like i buy games all the time i haven't played um from you know online orders and stuff like that this would definitely have been on the list uh and now if i'm stealing games from your collection it can just end up on my collections fair enough well we'll have to play it soon then yeah sounds good that is my first one nice ball of the mountain king um i'm going to put yeah you can just set it aside for now it's easy to try to squeeze it back in there okay next game i'm gonna steal is uh also on this shelf and that is isle of cats this one you might have guessed i was gonna steal another polyamino yes exactly another polymer game uh i'm gonna have a bunch of poly i'm gonna give you a bunch of uveros and bridges in your collection um so i love cats we've talked about i think uh i think you've talked about it more so than me but or no i include this in my polyamorous top five um so we talked about this on the channel a couple times uh it's a really really good polyamino game i'm really a big fan of polyamide games i have a ton in my collection and so it's a genre that to earn a spot in my collection and for me to want it it really has to do something to either either do something to set it apart from the other ones or just do what it does so well that i prefer to play it over once i already have right it's the reason that new york zoo doesn't do anything wildly different than other polyamory games and yet i want to play that one all the time because it's almost replaced other games in my collection because how good it is i love cats with building your polyaminos out on that ship with the different colored cats and
everything and the different rooms i just love that i love how they integrated the cards uh into it as well and how you select your cats and everything uh you know i i i love the theme i'm not i'm not i'm more of a dog person than a cat person uh which is like we should do a video i can't come into my house and say that yeah you should this is why you put your cats outside you can't hear the other thing they would definitely be up there scratching your face but like the the artwork and the way that they've implemented the theme is super cool there's like the storyline that kind of like is even explained in the rulebook and ties into stuff like that like i i just like ali the little polyamino pieces we'll put i'll put up some some b-roll we've taken of this too for you guys to see but um i'm just a big fan of the game every time i've played it i've thought about buying it myself but again whenever we have a game between us in our collection it's always one of those reasons we're like well i could buy that but i'll i can i know i'll also just play it at carlos i'll play the dylan's or whatever there's enough games out there that we also want to play that we don't have between us that it's like i just yeah play when you go to whoever's place but for sure it's a it's a great game yeah that's a really good pick this would have this would be one that i would just steal for the sole purpose of basically being able to play um in game game groups so you you're not coming i can ask you to bring it essentially right like i could bore it but it'd just be easier to steal it and have it like shelves so that's why it's on the list um and it's it's like i wouldn't say it's uh i was going to say it's a heavier polyester i guess that's accurate like a little bit heavier than like a patchwork yeah because not only does it have the card drafting like you mentioned but it's like the lesson cards where you have private and public like objectives that you can get that like either all players will score for if
they're public or private you reveal them at the end so you're there's a lot more of like strategy and planning it's like a lot of other polyamory games you play are more like tactical where you're just when it comes around you're taking the one that fits best on your board or something right this is an actual like polyamino strategy game and i think it even says 60 to 90 minutes yeah yeah on the side of the box so yeah it's not the heaviest poly like it's not as heavy as a feast for odin yeah polyamides but it's definitely one of the heavier ones like you grabbed two games off my sort of polyamino shelf here and this is probably the heaviest polyamory along with probably the whole in the whole amount and what i like about that and i think it's interesting in general for anyone wanting to build boarding collections especially with like genres that they gravitate towards is that if you have multiple uh games that have a certain genre let's use polyamino as an aspect or as an example um and they they have like scaling complexity like you just said feast froden and isles isle of cats on one end and the other end being polyamino that's such an easy way to introduce people to board games because like say you introduce someone successfully with patchwork right it's so much easier to say remember how the poly almond system system worked in patchwork well now let's take that and try it in cottage garden because they'll already understand some of the rules right you can almost scale them up to a game like feast rodent which is like my dream right um by playing games that are identical or similar in genre right so there's you know some people might say like why do you have so many polio no games on the shelves i think it's kind of a good a good little pathway you could have as a sort of a gateway all the way to the heaviest games in the genre sure isle of cats would fit in there perfectly because i feel like i'd need a stepping stone between feast froden and like
my next most complex would probably be like new york zoo so put something else in between there right so yeah yeah it's good pick i love cats and yeah just the production value too it's such an awesome game very nice artwork and the box says on the insert says you can put i have a cat so i'm sure it does the very first time i opened the game put the box lid out to punch the pieces my cat jumped right in the box immediately uh the next one might surprise you maybe not um it surprised me that i was picking only because i forgot that you had it uh because i don't even know if you played this yet but uh i don't i don't know we'll see what you say but uh the next one i'm gonna pick is uh oh wow kingdom i did not see this one coming yeah so winter kingdom's on here because i thought about backing this was when this was having a campaign because kingdom builder which is i guess i should specify this is sort of a follow-up standalone follow-up to kingdom builder using the same type of mechanics but like new came out and then gameplay long ago i played kingdom builders so many times um both physical and digital i i love it and so when this was announced uh i recovered it and when the kickstarter was up i considered back and it was just too expensive with shipping couldn't justify it um so when you got it it was one that i eventually thought i might own at some point or my at least want to play at some point when i figured out that you bought it and i didn't remember until i was looking at the photos you sent me of your shelf i was like oh yeah right he got he got winter kingdom um immediately i was like well yeah that would be for sure one that i would still cause i haven't played it i know i want it um and you know price was sort of that barrier for me i don't know what it
cost like for twitter from the store compared to the kickstarter way cheaper because i was thinking the same i think with the kickstarter shipping we were looking at it would have been like 80 90 bucks canadian almost 100 and i think i got this for like 50 52 bucks or something right so like way cheaper yeah so i haven't even played it yet actually either yeah exactly you have all these amazing games that i want you don't play amazing it has to be amazing no but like all these games that i want you're just buying and putting yourself just to taunt me essentially myself part of the reason this is sad here is because there's one person i know who has played as much kingdom builder as me and it's you yeah so i want to play this with you so that we can do a comparison video on our channel one day comparing this to kingdom brother you have a way i'm realizing that you have a way richer shelf of shame than i do oh yes because i've gone i used to have a really bad shellfish rich shelf of shame um and now i think the only game on my shelf that i haven't played it's both of ours um is that we haven't played yet is uh coffee coffee traders um and where i'm like i was looking at yours i'm like i feel like there's a bunch of games here that i either want or want to play and i'm pretty sure he has played yeah okay so i think i looked at my collection of the day i think i have about 100 and 510 games right now and i think there's about 30 that i haven't played i know and that's been over the last year and a half or more over the pandemic i keep thinking like oh well eventually yeah we'll be able to get back to having game nights and all this stuff just host shovel of shame game nights and we'll just like knock off two to three every night yeah and the rule is you have to pick games from the shelf of shame that you haven't
played so we're still helping you trip away at it i'm all gay yeah it'd be great yeah but anyways yeah winter kingdom is on there because i know i i love kingdom builders so much i'm fairly certain that even if i don't like this as much as kingdom builder um i will enjoy it is just from the angle of like a new way to experience a classic that i love so um i yeah that's basically why it's on here it's tons of curiosity and i'm fairly certain i will enjoy it yeah i just don't know on what level that's fair and i think it's got a little more uh complexity to it than kingdom builder there's a little more to explore i think the rules are gonna take a bit more to get into kind of thing but uh yeah i'm very curious to play it yeah that is my third one that is winter kingdom um these are all new games too these old games all came out within the last two or three years are you guys still in the old games i don't think so okay the next one i'm gonna steal this one might also surprise you maybe not okay is uh summoner wars this is the second edition right yeah yeah so uh another one on the shelf machine yeah i might i think everyone i think everyone except for isle of cats i'm gonna choose you haven't played okay it's pretty funny well you'll have to tell me how they are someone has to play these um so this is on here because i honestly didn't know about summoner wars until you mentioned it to me and then even i think after you mentioned to me it took me a while to actually like look it up and look into it and when i did i it's a two-player um you know card dueling game with this with a sort of a board setup that you can um you know move positions in the cards and or the characters and everything that's on the map and you and me obviously grew up playing magic the
gathering and i we were playing card battling dueling games in general i'm still due to this day i play hearthstone and you know anytime a new one comes out i'm usually like at least interested in because of my history with it right so this one interested me because of how popular it is um the way it plays is super unique in comparison to the other ones i'm used to um and it the way that it sort of um in the same way vein is like marvel champ is where they expand on it by introducing heroes it's it's expandable but from what i understand you don't have to buy everything in the same way that you might have to like imagine the gathering to keep up with standard or whatever it is right like i think there's six uh base like heroes or whatever in the in the base game but you can buy i think there's like up to 12 or 14 or maybe even more if you go buy the expansions or whatever right and this is the second edition which means like all they've all been released in the first edition but i'm sure they're going to re-release them in the second edition but um yeah so i've just been wanting to get into this for for a long time um it's a two-player games in general obviously are very accessible if you are more accessible than a four-player game because you only have to have one person come over right right the theme is not something that everyone's gonna necessarily gravitate towards right like it's you're gonna have to have someone that enjoys battling enjoys competitive games enjoys that sort of fantasy-esque thing but um i know enough people who would be interested in it that i could easily get this to the table just like someone coming over to catch up be like throw in a game of summoner wars yeah i don't think it takes very long to play either and it's one game it's a type of game you want to come back to obviously try different heroes combinations the replayability the theme um the gameplay like everything speaks to me so when i found out you bought it i was super
eager to play it yeah carlo didn't invite me over to play it so i'm gonna just steal it from this is one of the ones i on my shelf machine that i want to play the most and like the soonest because yeah i've heard it described a lot as like card based chess right because you have the board where you're moving stuff around but you're only moving stuff around when you play cards that let you move your units and some can like summon other units that come out and move around the board so yeah it's a very like a chest like game but based on the cards that you play and because you have those asymmetric powers yeah it just seems really cool i i can't wait to try this out with you yeah so that's why it's on the list i i i'm fairly certain i'll like it even if i don't get like fully into it like in the same way i got into marvel champions i know that i'm going to enjoy it enough that i want to come back to it the same way that like i even go back to hero realms to play and that's a that's a like that has expanded like expansions and heroes you can add on to it and everything but even that simplistic style of like to a two-person card battler like interested me because of my history and everything with it right so well and i'll say one thing quickly about this as well is that there's an online i don't know the website if i remember maybe we'll put it in the description of the video but there's somewhere online where you can buy the base game i think it's literally like three dollars to play this online apparently it's a really well implemented i've heard tons of people have tried the game mode on there and then you can pay like you know another two bucks to get a couple more heroes unlocked factions or whatever so if you're looking to try this out before buying i know it's maybe been out of stock some places too uh definitely check out the online implementation for this because i've heard it's really really good yeah it's out of stocks people like this guy buy them and put them on the shelf and don't play it right deprive actual players from experience
yeah but i'm culling games too i'll have another curate in my collection video eventually are you ever going to call games that you haven't played just because no no i buy them to try them and some of them i know i'm not going to keep long-term but i just need to try them out a bit first but yeah oh man just arrest me on these shows i'm kind of so the fifth game is one that uh yeah this i think you might be surprised that i'm picking it but you're also gonna be like oh that makes total sense so uh the last game that i'm gonna steal is legacy of dragon holes uh and that's because i am obviously a huge fan of narrative and campaign style games uh uh there's no uh question about that gloomhaven's one of my favorite games if not my favorite game my kickstart there's i'm weighing on kickstarters for frost haven as well as uh oh sworn into the deep wood um i will likely and almost certainly back tons more because it seems to be something that's not going away any time soon these campaign style games um legacy of dragon hold is one that i had looked into um i think when you first told me about it but before you bought it um and was super intrigued the only reason i i hesitated was because i think i got spoiled with gleamhaven having so much content right i think this one only has like i think like six adventures or like a smaller amount but i thought like i'd love to get into this but like i almost like to know that i'm getting into something that has legs and it's gonna go for a long time because i like to meet regularly with people um and because i didn't know if there was gonna be a follow-up a sequel
whatever i didn't want to like say i'm going to have a campaign getting together for this and then after six sessions be like and that's all i have for you kind of thing right so that's literally the only reason i didn't get into it so when you bought it i was immediately intrigued being like okay is uh either one witness carlo's gonna host a group for this and get us together regularly or two um at some point i want to board from him to be able to either play it solo or you know get a group together as well um i don't even know and with campaign games like this is the case i don't like to know a lot about like what i'm getting into with a campaign game i like to know some of the new systems that are coming into play or things i can expect but i'd like to sit down with a rule book for the first time and and really just start to like uncover what this campaign game's going to put me through so i i don't know a lot about even like the gameplay mechanics or the way it plays which i didn't even know a lot about gloomhaven before i like got into my hands i just know that with campaign games especially with fantasy settings um i'm usually like all in like i love it so uh yeah that was one of the this was actually the first one when i sat down to pick the five this is the first one i picked when i looked at the photo because i knew i knew without a doubt it would end up on the list yeah um but uh yeah but just i'm you either better uh hosts a group for this uh sometime soon or you better just relinquish this with the other ones to my collection so yeah this is another one on the shelf of shame you know i haven't played it it does i thought it was one to four players it's one to six i bought this mainly hoping to play it solo because for anyone who might be watching the channel for or might not have heard me say this recently on any other videos um i recently became a dad i've got an eight and a half week old now and
basically i bought this as one of the ones knowing like i want to have a bunch of solo games on hand this plays apparently the bgg says it's best at either one or two interesting and it is apparently like it's it's very much a story based game like a narrative game it's i think it says around the box a cooperative narrative adventure so a big thing is just you pick your character and you go through there's like multiple books where you're like reading stuff and you make choices that then affect your character and you meet people um and i remember being sold on this by hearing it on the uh so very wrong about games podcast um and i don't normally like gravitate towards like you'll know that i don't really have i don't think any other games on my shelf that i can think of that are like primarily like story based games like narrative games yeah but i heard so many good things about this one i've just been really wanting to play it for a while so uh yeah you know what i think i'm going to start checking it out solo and if i feel like you know there's something missing and i'd rather play it with someone then i'll just stop where i'm at and wait until like you and i can play through it together yeah and if not i'll play through it solo i'm sure once i get into it like once you play these narrative games they tend to hook you and then you're kind of like i have a feeling once i open it up and get into it i'm just gonna want to play through it i'll leave it set up on the table until it's done yeah so if i do then i'll just pass it off to you and you can play it solo afterwards i'm i'm i'm picking games that are already collecting dust and there's dust on legacy of dragon hole oh you're killing me like this has been my low key way of actually doing a shelf of shame video for carla or just like the roast the roast of carlow on aycb is what this is okay well i've been knocking on quite
a few from the shelf of shame recently just playing solo so yeah next time uh yeah if you come by there'll be even more uh but yeah those are my five picks the the only the one that i came very close to including and it probably would have bumped off either uh winter kingdom or um like or maybe i'll cats i don't know um was res arcana okay uh that one the only reason i didn't put on there is because i play i played a lot of it on bga and i know i still i know i still can but i would really like that physical copy i actually really enjoy res arcana um so that's the only reason i didn't include that one they like very briefly came close to including that one so check it out i'm gonna grab my predictions now yeah let's see what we got here number one res and i knew right away it was a risky pick because it's on board game arena um you know yeah before i can see yeah number two is babylonia okay which i remember when we played it you seemed to really enjoy it but i knew it was kind of a risky pick i came closer to including blue lagoon than i did babylonia okay okay fair enough but but like that i thought you were i thought you might be thinking after i did mine based on like the finance like blue lagoon you could buy for 30 bucks babylonia's like 60 i'm not talking about the financials i'm just like yeah you buy two little girls you have to understand i'm just i'm just focusing on my own happiness and how much pain it'll bring to you to have it out of your collection number three was legacy of dragon hole oh so you did have that one on there okay number four isle of cash oh nice number five relics of raja vihara which
is another one i know you remember i remember you saying in a previous video that like as soon as i'm done with it you want to play it because it's the solo and i think that's why i didn't include it is because i i i know that i'm gonna get to experience the whole game um if i want to um kind of thing whereas the other ones um i guess if you invite me over for legacy of dragon hold then i wouldn't have to opponent but the other ones you know i could play endlessly and just still get a lot of them so so i guess i only guessed two of the five legacy of dragon holding the owl of cats but i did have two maybes at the bottom oh yeah something rewards i thought it was going to be maybe on there yeah the davalier was a risky pick i remember when we played it on board game arena you seemed to really enjoy it but i knew this and res arcana were both gambles because you can play them on boarding arena why would you come over and steal it from me right yeah exactly yeah good good predictions i i i like that you got like i said dragon hole i thought that was going to be a tougher time you know what no it's i think i i hesitated because i thought i remember that you were interested in when i first got it and i thought maybe he doesn't and then as soon as i remembered oh no it's got a campaign dylan's going to watch the campaign of course anything with a campaign i'm hooked like i'm basically the guy who's who should be so ridiculously into dungeons and dragons and yet is into every other implementation of like that that owes the detention and dragons that they exist and i'm not actually that into dnd but uh anyways those are my five picks uh good predictions and uh yeah let me know in the comments uh which ones of those five you think i shouldn't have uh stolen or which ones you would agree with i'm surprised by some of your picks but honestly they all make sense when you put them that way cool but yeah i think the oldest game you picked was from 2019 what can i say it's like every
other this whole industry is about all the brand new board games constantly i guess someone's picking from yours but yeah yeah thanks for watching see you guys next time