Impressions - Anno 1800, Hallertau, & Mercado de Lisboa
Transcript
welcome to the jungkook's games impressions vlog where today i'll be discussing three games that i was able to play for the first time recently now i'll be covering them in alphabetical order and i would like to point out that if you'd prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you can do so by searching for the john games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts i'd also like to ask that if you end up enjoying this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel in addition to that if you'd like to directly support the channel and the creation of future vlogs like this one then please go to junglesgames.com there you'll find a bunch of ways that you can really help things out and some of them come with nice bonuses like voting on a few of the videos that i film each month alright let's now start talking about games and the first of these is anno 1800 now this is a brand new release from cosmos currently it's just in a german version there's an english version coming out next year but fortunately the german version is essentially language independent uh now this one is designed by martin wallace of many board game fame in particular brass is the one that sticks out to me the most and i have been pretty interested in playing this one for a while the basic idea of it seem to be supply chains like i make some buildings and then my opponents can use my buildings which helps me out and then i can use their buildings as we make more and more complicated stuff that seemed pretty neat and then i was able to watch part of a playthrough that came up on the jplay youtube channel i highly recommend that youtube channel by the way i've been watching him since before i started this channel but anyway it really looked exciting like watching the game being played
it looked like everything i wanted in a eurogame so i read the rules and then i was able to get two and a half games of this play now i'm going to talk about my impressions in just a little bit i want to talk about the mechanics of this game first so essentially each player has a board in front of them with a bunch of little square buildings and you have some cubes in different colors now these cubes are technically your population and when it's your turn you just take a single action and the main thing that you are doing is utilizing your population cubes to get various goods in order to do the action that you want so for instance on your very first turn maybe you say i want to be able to make soap but i can't yet so for my entire turn i'm going to take a soap token from the middle of the board put it into my area and then i have to pay for that well the soap costs pigs and it costs coal well fortunately i can look at my board that i already have and there's a coal area and it says i need red population which is i think craftsman to activate that to give me a coal they don't actually take a token for the coal it just exists you just know that there is a coal and then i would send a farmer over to the pig spot on my board now i have a coal and a pig made up in the ether and then i can consume them to make this soap building it's now flipped over on my board and for the rest of the game i can now send a blue person over to there which is i think a factory worker to make soap so that was my whole turn it was really simple i just utilized my population it's easy to think of these cubes as workers but this isn't a work replacement game so thinking of them as an action population potential is is significantly better so i do that and then the next person
goes and let's say they have a card in their hand that they want to play out and it requires soap well they could go through all that effort to make their own soap factory if they want to or they could just use my soap factory now the way they do that is they spend these trade tokens that they have and you get them from ships and the number of tokens that you spend is going to go up as you trade for more expensive stuff fortunately soap is very cheap so they can trade for that for just a single trade token and then i magically give them an ether soap in the air and they can use that to play their card and then as a benefit for me i just gain a gold from the supply gold is definitely a good thing to have every three gold that you have at the end of the game is worth a point so they got the soap they needed i got a third of a point and there are other ways to use gold which i'll talk about soon so they have now played their card out and that card is going to give them some sort of bonus it might give them some upgrades it might also let them discard cards from their hand or it might give them new population cubes that then go down onto their board now this is where the game gets kind of strange for a euro game because so far everything seems pretty you know elegant streamlined i think now every single population cube that you have is effectively having its demand represented by a card in your hand at the start of the game you have four green three blue and two red population on your board and you start with four of the green then blue type cards plus three of the green slash blue type cards because green and blue together four and three is seven so you have seven of those cards plus two of the red purple teal type cards which are the
more advanced ones so at the start of the game you have an equal number of cards in your hand to the number of population cubes that you have in front of you well in that example my opponent played a card out which gave them another cube maybe they got two more blue cubes well they take the cubes from the supply and they put them onto their board where they can now use them for the rest of the game and they have to draw two more cards one card each representing the relative demand i think that that population needs now this is kooky because the only way this game ends is as soon as any one player has played all of the cards in their hand so what that means is at the start of the game you have nine cards in your hand and it takes a full turn to play a card and as you play through the game you're gonna be playing cards and uh some of those will give you more cubes which let you do more stuff but then you take more cards which is going to delay you actually ending the game uh there are some other things going on where you can spend exploration tokens from your ships in order to explore the old world and the new world and the older world spots give you more locations that you can build on and a nice bonus while the new world area gives you uh different things you can trade for from the new world like cotton or rubber or tobacco but you take three new world cards which go into your hand and once again you cannot end the game until you've played all of the cards in your hand now there are other ways to get cubes you can just spend an action to make up to three cubes which cost various resources which you spend cubes to make more cubes and then you of course draw some more cards so what this means is the overall pacing of this game is you are trying to play these cards because they're good all of the cards that you play are also worth victory points in fact they're going to be worth the vast majority of the points that you have at the end of the game
but by playing stuff out you are invariably going to be drawing some more cards so there's this um this feeling of like trying to play cards and almost like getting more cards than the cards that you were playing especially as you were going through the first two thirds or so of the game now the reason you actually want more cubes is because you can spend an entire turn doing a stockfest which is i think german for a city festival or something like that but we've been saying stodfest because we have a german version that we're playing um where you return all of your cubes back to the supply so you can use them again to your own supply and you return all of your trade tokens and your exploration tokens back to your ships so i said that we're spending trade tokens to trade with our opponents well they're not going away you just don't have them until you spend an entire turn to do a full city reset so the more cubes that you have that means you can go longer without spending your entire turn effectively doing nothing so having more cubes is certainly a good thing although doing a stodfest action is also great because it gets you those trade act tokens back so you can spend them to trade for other people's stuff again now um what this means is there is a very strange feeling in this game where technically this game could go on for like six or seven hours and that's because if people are just playing cards getting cubes which gives them more cards to play cards to get cubes to give them more cards to go to the new world to get some more cards it's very possible that you just have way too many cards to actually play out in a reasonable period of time now fortunately the player who ends the game the player who puts the last card down is going to get seven victory points as a bonus and um from my two full games i could say the winning
scores were usually around 120 so seven points is definitely significant and what this means is there's going to be a group think uh situation that happens here now the two games that i have played i have been the one that ended the game and the reason i did that is because a i didn't want the game to go on forever and b because i wanted those seven extra points and while you're playing through this game you have all these cards in your hand and odds are very good for the vast majority of the game you will have cards in your hand that you cannot play they require a specific resource that does not exist yet you have not built it yet and maybe someone else hasn't maybe you can't build it because it requires access to a specific new world good that you do not have and i'm not going to go into the specifics of why you might not have it but there are definitely situations where near the end of the game suddenly someone builds something across the table for me and you say okay that's it that was the last thing that i needed now every card that i have in my hand can be played and in my opinion that's the moment you have to slam on the gas pedal and just start playing cards as quickly as you can again one per turn in order to try and run the clock out the reason for that is because every card you play is points and in that moment there is a reasonable chance that your opponents do not have everything that they need in play to actually get all of their cards out so if you race them out you should hypothetically be able to get more points than them but if no person does that if everyone is just enjoying the city building and playing cards to get things to make more things to get play cards to get more things um this game could easily go again like hours and hours longer than it should i've seen reports on boardgamegeek people playing like five or so hour
games of this now in my experience i've played a full three-player game and a full four player game the three player game was uh i think three hours pretty much on the dot and the four player game uh that one took i think it was three hours as well so we actually got it um the same amount of time but with an entire another player and the scores were about the same which leads me to think that we did about the same amount of things i think we were just getting a little bit more comfortable in that four player game actually three of us were familiar with it already because i did say i played this game uh two and a half times and the very first time we played we just played for about an hour and a half um we only had an hour and a half available but i was so excited to play the game that we decided to just play until we hit like three o'clock or whatever it was because one of us had to leave and um that left us about halfway through the game but all of us were kind of experienced with it already so i've talked about the mechanics of this game quite a bit and now i want to talk about the reality of this game for me and the reality is after i played half a game i was borderline obsessed with this game like i could not stop thinking about it especially stopping halfway through a game and it was another couple days until i got to play it again at a full three-player game i then played that three-player game and at the end of that game i was absolutely smitten with this game i i loved it it was so much fun and all of us really enjoyed it a couple days later we sat down and played the full four player game and i again had a great time and it's worth noting in both of those games i ended the game and in both of those games i won by a pretty sizable amount so take my opinion with a grain of salt i do have some winner's bias going along here but i will say that after that four
player game i'm starting to have concerns about the game overall um the heart of this game the mechanical heart um thrills me to no end i have played so many euro games lately and the the current theme for eurogame design is just more complexity more modules more interconnectedness more fiddly side rules more bonus tokens uh it just kind of drives me crazy to a certain extent especially being the person who usually teaches games and then anno 1800 walks in and this is a game that you can reasonably teach in 30 minutes hypothetically i feel like you could teach this game in 20 minutes to people who are familiar with modern board gaming everything is just so elegant it's so streamlined you just you want to build that thing you just pay the resources and you pay the resources with the cubes and there's no asterisks or anything like that you just do the thing and somebody else needs that thing and you have the thing they spend a trade token and you get a gold congratulations you get something they get something and the game just keeps going on and on so i love how simple it is but at the same time there's some weird things going on there are cards in this game you draw randomly from the top of the deck where card a and card b will have the exact same result but card a has significantly easier resources to acquire than card b well that seems a little bit weird like isn't card a just better because you can play it earlier there are also situations where card and card b have effectively the same cost on the top but card b's result just feels significantly better than card a's now i've only played the game two and a half times so it's you know a little silly to stand
up on a mountain and say this game is imbalanced but there are some parts that really do feel like genuinely intentionally unbalanced which bugs me because i don't like intentional uh imbalance in games for instance when you get new uh old world uh tiles you put next to your board so it gives you more ocean space for ships and more uh factory building spaces you always get a bonus as well it's random and i like random bonuses as long as they're somewhat balanced but in this game one of the things that you can put out there will give you two of the blue workers which means you of course have to draw two of the blue green cards and another one gives you two of the green workers which means you draw two of the blue green cards well i can tell you right now blue workers are just better than green workers this game as you're playing through the game you're essentially working your way out of the green workers it's likely if you don't upgrade your grain workers into better workers then you will end up just not using them for the last third of the game or so so you don't need those and so it seems like a bummer moment when you see an opponent draw something which gives them like an exploration ship which is perfect for the thing they needed and then you draw two green uh workers and you're like great two workers i probably won't even use that come along with two more cards that are now gliding up my hand and i'm trying to play these cards so that i can try to trigger the end of the game to get that bonus so that feels a little bit weird and then the final thing the real thing that's that's kind of sticking in my side with this game is the way the trading works now as i said i i on a high level i love this you spend trade tokens in order to trade to get stuff from your opponents i love how um uh yeah a win-win that is
like they're happy you're happy cool the problem is that you spend more trade tokens for the more expensive stuff but no matter what you always just give that person one gold from the main supply so what that means is there are situations near the end of the game where someone almost feels disincentivized to spend their turn and a lot of you know expensive resources and infrastructure to build something big like the steam car like so that's one of the harder things to construct you make a factory that makes steam cars so let's say i you know spend a couple turns getting the infrastructure to build that down because i have a card in my hand that wants the steam car and then suddenly like two people around the table like pump their fists like oh thank goodness some finally someone made a steam car on their turn they trade with you you get a gold which is a third of a point and they play a card that's worth eight points to them and the next person gives you a gold which is worth a third of a point and they play a card that's worth eight victory points to them that's a feels bad moment for me because i wanted that steam car and i had to build a steam engine to make it happen or maybe somebody else had a steam engine and i used theirs but i spent effort to try and get that thing down and it almost seems like i made like two-thirds of a point more than my opponents because they both traded with me once that just feels so strange like why isn't it the number of trade tokens that you spend equals the number of gold that that person gets um that uh steam car for example costs four trade tokens uh whereas the soap again costs just one trade token so i feel like if somebody spends four trade tokens on their area to use my steam car factory i should get four gold that's one in a
third point which still honestly does not feel that great in comparison to the eight points with the card that they were able to just put down but at least it feels like it would be better this is a part of the game where the more i think about it the more issues i have with this and again i've only played two and a half times so i don't want to stand here and say this game is clearly broken but the uh groupthink situations that we've had has kind of stalled the game out there are definitely situations where i've been sitting here with my cards and i look across an opponent and i can't take it anymore i'm just like will you please build your cigar factory you've had tobacco all game long and you just you have a card in my hand that needs a cigar and you just so desperately want them to do it and they look back at me and they're like i didn't draw a card that needs uh cigars so why would i do that that's going to help you more than it helps me and that just puts me in a really rough situation where now i need to maybe try to spend turns to explore the new world more to maybe find tobacco it's random and every time you explore the new world you draw three more cards which makes it harder to actually end the game so there are these really frustrating moments in the end of the game where it seems like people are just not incentivized enough to build the expensive stuff uh to a certain extent where there's almost a group think situation of a bit of a stalemate now in the games that i played again like three or so hours at the three and four player count with people getting more experience so it's not like the game dragged on forever but i don't understand why a the trade token thing works the way i just said or b why don't these tiles actually give you victory points now there are five mission cards that you draw randomly at the start of the game that
will give you conditional end-game victory points as well as potential bonus actions you can take in the game and some of them do give you points for having a building like one of them says get i think six points if you have a penny farthing building and a steam car building and a gramophone building or six points for each of them so you're incentivized to build those specific ones in the game where that card comes out but when that card does not come out then the incentive to build the steam engine is a lot less i don't understand why the tiles themselves don't come with points on them already it could be an increasing amount of points also it's worth noting there are two of each factory type no matter what the player count is so you could have a situation where the first one bot is going to be worth twice as many points as the second one that's bought you could also change the rules around and house rule it so that when somebody uses your factory you also just generate victory points or maybe even more victorying points now i know that gold is a third of a point and i do want to mention that the other reason you want gold is because as a free action you can spend your gold to pay your worker population and it's more gold depending on how more complicated the worker is to refresh that one specific cube to then use them again and free up a spot so having gold is good in that way as well it just something feels a little bit funky with the end of this game and i feel like if everybody's super experienced with this game these issues might just disappear perhaps because people are becoming much more focused on just trying to play their cards and if they have a card that needs a steam car and they have the ability to make a steam car while they'll just make the steam car so they can play their card and they're hoping their opponents don't also have cards in their hand that require a steam car now i've talked about this game a lot
already and there is genuinely one more thing that i want to mention um even though i'm talking about this really long and that is the most prestigious of the population cubes which is the investor now this is a teal cube and it is very difficult to get these made you can upgrade cubes which makes it a little bit better you can upgrade from the purple which upgrades from the blue or you could just make them outright but it's a lot of resources to make even one of these investors and these investors are important because they are required to be used in order to make the most complicated factories if you want to make a steam car factory or an artillery factory you need an investor to actually make that happen which thematically makes a lot of sense my problem is that at least in my very tiny uh experience set of two full games it takes so long and so much effort to get one of these investors that by the time you have an investor the end game stuff the cool shiny end game stuff it's it's really hard to actually get much use out of those things like maybe even just one use um there is uh for example uh better ships that you can buy and the best chips require these investors and i've never seen the best ships made in two and a half games or i guess two full games because by the time you have an investor those ships almost don't even matter anymore you probably have an amazing fleet and you'd rather not spend your turn building more ships so there's many different aspects to this game where the more i play it the more i feel like was this designed in an echo chamber of people who understood how everything worked so well already that it got refined to be best with that certain play group but then for people who are just kind of stumbling into this game trying to figure it out and being like ooh cool shiny toys it just doesn't
quite mesh together and if that's true then i'm great you know i'm going to give it the benefit of the doubt that it is balanced at um expert level play but at the moment with beginner level play it just doesn't seem like it it just seems like more incentive needs to be made for buying those later game stuff i feel like the cost to get the purple and the teal population is a little bit too high i wish that was lower so you could get to them earlier and better use them as the game went on and i feel like just from a fundamental perspective this game is so elegant and simple at its core why does it have to be three hours for three or four players you know why can't this have been designed for like a 90 to 120 minute play period i feel like you could have just cut some things out like you know made the card draw a little bit less start playful with off with maybe a little bit less cubes or just i feel like there are ways to develop this game that i don't know the specific answers to that could have made this a 90 to 120 minute game and i'm telling you if this was like a two-hour game that did not have this funky stuff at the end this would potentially be my favorite game ever like i love the beating heart of this game the mechanics are so simple and the win-win of the trading is so amazing so i am really frustrated that the more i play it the more i'm seeing these weird clashes and issues like gears that are just supposed to go together and they're just kind of not for our play group now again this could be entirely play group dependent for some people maybe they won't have these issues at all but i can tell you right now that there are several forum threads on board game geek already talking about how the way this game ends is funky and strange and is just not
connecting well with a lot of different play groups um for me you know i've been pressing the gas to actually end these games in a reasonable amount of time i feel like there are certain subsets of my friends if i put them together to play this uh this game would go twice as long because none of them would want to end it because they would be enjoying building up their sand castle so much and not thinking about you know trying to end the game and actually win the game overall so okay i should probably start talking about uh anno 1800 i will wrap this up by saying that i purchased a copy of the game after i played it uh one and a half times and i'm still happy about that because man this game is so cool but at this point i just find myself wishing that a no 1800 norwegians expansion comes out and i say that in quotes because the norwegians expansion came out for a feast for odin and it turned a feast for odin from an excellent game into one of the best games i've ever played and i feel like anno 1800 needs that because it is so close to being one of the best games i've ever played but it's not there and that really frustrates me and will it get that expansion it seems unlikely but for now i have a copy that's heading my way in probably about a month or so and i am looking forward to playing this one more for all of the potential faults that i'm seeing in it um and uh that's where i currently stand i will play this game more all of our friends my friends are intrigued to play it more but i'm worried about it staying power because of the potential issues that i've already talked at great length about okay let's now move into the second game i'll be discussing today and that is haller tau now this is another uh medium to heavyweight a brand new euro game this one coming
out from famed designer uve rosenberg now uve rosenberg has designed tons of games i'm not going to rattle all of them off but i will say that the last big box game that he has designed was a feast for odin which is one of my favorite games ever since then i think uve rosenberg has designed or at least had published many like almost 10 um lighter games a lot of them are polyamino based and now here comes hellertown which is the next big one now in this game thematically you are farming in the i guess hollertown region of i think germany i haven't done my research too much here but you are going to be sewing and harvesting crops and it seems like the crops are very beer oriented you have hops you have barley you have rye and you have flax which i don't think has anything to do with beer but those are different things that you are harvesting and uh you are also going to be cultivating sheep and then getting milk from the sheep and you can slaughter them for meat and get hides you're doing lots of stuff that ufe rosenberg games often have and the central mechanic for this game is work replacement now i'm going to start this off by saying i actually played this one on tabletop simulator with a private mod that i made i have purchased a copy of this game i purchased it like three weeks ago but it still hasn't arrived yet fortunately i was able to gain access to scans of the game's components and i spent about seven hours cutting this up in photoshop and building a mod so that i could play with friends before my copy actually arrives and so i have done that i played one game at four players and before i talk about the impressions let's cover the basic mechanics of this game now in the middle of the table there is
a worker placement board and it has 20 different locations on it now in this game workers are actually neutral they're all a dark blue color cube and in the action phase of the game you are going to be sending your cubes or i guess the neutral cubes that you have you send them out to the board to activate various actions now every action on the board has three or two rows on them and the number of cubes you have to spend is going to increase as you go up in those rows that means the first person to activate a specific action will spend one cube to do that action and the next time somebody does that which could be that same person on their next turn it's going to cost two cubes and finally the third time will cost three cubes once the third row is full then no one can do that action until those cubes are cleared up now the actions themselves are very straightforward it might be get some sheep it might also be something like gain a field or sow some crops now those two things lead me to the other central mechanical heart of this game and that is the actual fields that you have in front of you now this is a long skinny board that has essentially five ish rows the bottom one doesn't really count and a bunch of columns and you're gonna put a field down into a column and the location on the row of that field is gonna dictate how fertile that field is so if you have the field in the three row overall that's a value three fertile field and whenever you do a crop sowing action you actually take one of your crops and you consume it and you put it onto that field so if you had two flax then you now have one flax and one flax is on that field that's in the three row now later on after the
action phase you are going to harvest all of your crops and the way you do this is you simply take the crop from the field you slide it sideways to the end of the row and you leave it there so that means that one flax was planted into a value three field and then when it harvested it went over to the three spot so that one flax now counts as three flax so you just gained flax by obviously sowing it and then harvesting it now here's the catch that field that you just harvested from will drop down so in the next round it will be in the value two row so if you sew a crop into it you're only going to get two out of it now when you actually before you do the harvest phase every single field that does not have any crops on it so fields that were left fallow will actually go up the next row and in fact you get a bonus bump of one of those fields if you like so as long as at least one field is open you will get a bonus bump which is good so what this means is mechanically is you have an incentive to use a field and then maybe not use it in the next round so it goes up to so it becomes more fertile in the next round maybe even a couple of bumps with that bonus and then maybe you use it again in the next round the problem is that this game is only six rounds long so if you just you know use a field one round and then not and then use it and then not if you just do it half the time is that really worth leaving your field empty for half of the game well i don't know i've only played this game once but it's definitely an interesting decision to make now the reason you are trying to do all these things you're doing work replacement to be able to get fields and plant crops and then sow the crops and harvest the crops is because on the bottom of your player area every player has like four different boards in front of them
you have this large community board and it has a big house on it with a window and a number shining through that window that number is the amount of neutral workers that you get at the start of each round and to the right of your house are five different craft buildings now those buildings have various icons on them that represent the different resources and near the end of each round of the game you are going to be spending the crops as well as the non-crop things like clay and meat and milk and that kind of thing to actually move those little craft houses over and the amount of resources that you have to spend to move the craft house over is equal to the round number so that means in round one it's just one of any of the matching symbols in order to move that craft house over but if it's the fourth round of the game it's going to cost four resources for one move over of that craft house so you are incentivized to try and move them earlier on in the game but obviously you don't have much of an engine built to actually do that now the reason you want to move these craft houses over is because once all five of them have been moved over essentially clearing a column your house is going to shift over and now the number in the window of your house will go up uh from six to seven now it will keep going up until it maxes out at 12 and from that point on it stays at 12 but you just get more and more victory points so that's kind of the cycle of this game you do work replacement to gain stuff and also the ability to sew stuff to then harvest stuff later to then spend that stuff to move your craft houses over which moves your house which gives you more workers for the next round to then do all of that stuff again now there are other things going on in particular this game has a funky card playing mechanism where
it's very simple you're gonna have cards in your hand and there are many different piles that you can drive draw from and card playing is a free action that you can do at literally any time so that means it could be my opponent's turn and i could just play a card even though it's their turn and they're doing something so playing cards as a completely free anytime action seemed a little bit funky but it worked out in reality and for the most part these cards require you to spend various stuff to gain a benefit or just have a threshold like have ate milk okay i have eight milk i play the card i get the benefit but i don't have to spend that eight milk now some of these cards actually give you income which will give you bonuses at the start of every single round so you obviously want to get those done earlier on in the game but these cards will also give you a bit of a direction beyond just trying to make those craft houses it gives you some direction for trying to get x number of this or a y number of that to try and play these cards to get the benefits that are on the cards now i guess the last thing i should say mechanically about the game is that you have tools that you can acquire now in the work placement phase you can send these workers out to activate these spots or you could remove a worker to gain a tool and that is a permanent tool you will have it for the rest of the game unless you decide to get rid of it or if it's the sixth round which i won't talk about the specifics of the sixth round um now these tools are important because going back to moving your little craft houses over there are all these pesky boulders on each of these different rows and once a craft house runs into a boulder it can't move anymore you could spend a tool token to move the boulder over one space to then free a spot to then move your craft house over once boulders kind of run into other boulders you have to spend two tokens to move the both of the
boulders over to get one move and then this funny thing happens where i was calling it the boulder elves near the end of uh every single round i guess the pretty much the last thing of each round is you move every boulder so that they are two and four spaces away from the craft houses respectively so that means just spending a tool to move a boulder doesn't actually make sense if you don't move the craft house over the boulder is going to magically come back because the boulder elves come in the rubric does not say anything about boulder elves but that's just me being silly but it's definitely it's it's funky what it effectively means is the first bump of a craft house is free of tools in the round the second bump costs one tool and the third fourth fifth etc bumps cost two tools each every single round because of the magical moving boulders so that's the basis for the game and we got to play a four-player game of this one i think the rules teach took me probably around 40 to 45 minutes but i think i could probably get that down to 30 minutes based off of my being inexperienced with the game and then we played the full four player game and when the dust settled it was essentially two and a half hours long which is not bad at all for what seems to be a medium to heavyweight euro style game with the full player count of four players i was a little worried going in with four but it actually flowed really well now every single round of this game there's six rounds total every round has 10 steps but 8 out of those 10 steps are fully asynchronous you can just do them without having to interact with anybody else one of those steps is the action round where you're going in turn order placing your workers and another step is simultaneous where
technically everybody's spending all their stuff to move all their buildings over so what that means is down time was really not bad in this game um the only time it really crept up was in the middle of the work replacement phase but even then it wasn't too bad the main part where we were really crunching with our brains and spending our resources to move our crafting houses that was all simultaneous so that definitely helped things out and there was this funny thing where it seemed like it took us a full hour to play the first two out of six rounds but then like an hour and a half to play the last four like we almost accelerated as the game went on and i think that's because we just got more familiar with the flow of this game there's definitely it's a bit of a rube goldberg machine of mechanics kind of falling into each other and once you see a couple paths of it you're like okay i get it and that lets it flow better and it takes a little bit less time even though near the end of the game there can be an incredible amount of crunching to do now in this game i came dead last which wasn't great i thought i was doing better than that i didn't think i was going to win but i didn't think i was going to come last however i will say that there are many different ways that you could play this game and i saw several of those ways in this first play so i have a friend who decided they their goal for the game was to max their house out to move their house all the way to the end so it couldn't move anymore because that reveals 70 points seven zero points in that window which is huge so that was her goal for the game essentially and the last two rounds of the game in particular the final round was incredibly stressful for her because it was the sixth round of the game and every single bump cost six resources i didn't mention it but you actually get discounts later on in the game if you
use multiple different types of resources so it's not technically six resources for each bump it could be five or even four resources if you're using two or three different resources for each of those craft bumps so her brain was just spinning steam coming out of her ears i expect i mean we were on discord but trying to figure out a way to make sure that she didn't get into the crafting phase and realized she was one flax shy of getting that 70 points because that would just feel awful fortunately she pulled it off and she had i think two or three excess resources at the end which is impressive considering i had like 23 excess resources which probably part of the reason i lost but it was cool to see that and she came in second place the person who came a close third place uh got zero points for the house about halfway through the game they said you know what i'm being so slow i didn't get tools to move these boulders i'm just not going to worry about the house anymore at all i'll stick with my eight i think or nine workers and they just played cards like crazy at the end of the game they scored at 69 points in just cards in front of them because a lot of the cards that you play give you victory points so one person got 70 points from maxing their house out another person got zero points for their house but got almost the same amount of points for the cards in front of them and then they also got points for some other things and they came in third the person who won i think threaded this needle the best they got i think around 54 points for their house they got quite a few from that they also got a bunch of points for their houses and they got a decent amount of points for playing a couple of cards that just give you a raw amount of points and i think they genuinely did end up playing the game best and that friend wins so often so i wasn't surprised when that particular friend
won for me i essentially sat in a room with a bunch of buttons and i just kept pressing buttons to see what they did and by the time i realized that wasn't turning into a cohesive strategy you know i guess it didn't put me in a position to win but i still really enjoyed it i enjoyed pressing all those buttons and i'm actively interested to play the game next time to try and maybe maximize the house or go crazy on the income or or maybe go heavy on sheep i haven't really mentioned sheep much at all but they have a bit of a mechanism where they can kind of breed and they can make ongoing milk and and you could definitely get a lot of benefits out of having a lot of sheep in the game and the last thing to say last thing i'm sure it's not the last thing i'm going to say but the last thing for the moment that i'm going to say is the fact that in this game every time you play you have the same point deck and bonus card deck but there are two other decks one is a gateway deck and the other one is a farmer deck and when you play you can swap those out there are actually four different gateway decks and four different farmer decks now the gateway decks every card in those decks is a threshold card so you don't have to spend anything for them they just give you a goal to get to to play the card to get the bonus and a lot of these cards that you play actually let you drop bonus cards which you have to spend stuff or have a threshold to play out to gain income so you can play cards to get more cards if that makes sense now there are four different gateway decks beginner expert advanced and then master level and then on the farmer decks instead of being skill oriented they are focused on what kind of stuff you're going to need to do well with them the first one that's recommended to play with is hops so many of the cards in that deck gave you benefits if you had a lot of hops not all of them it seemed like maybe a quarter to a third of them were
hop heavy another one we haven't played with is sheep heavy another one is field heavy just having a lot of fields and the last one is jewelry heavy i haven't mentioned jules just yet but you can spend a jewelry token to auto build one level of a craft house no matter what round it is so there's a lot of variety there the next time i play the game we're certainly not going to use the beginner deck not that the beginner deck was bad but i just want to try some more variety and we'll definitely pick a different uh one of those other decks and what that means is combining these in different ways is going to give i haven't done the math but many many many different perturbations to add some variety from one play to the next so it doesn't feel super samey now at the end of the game all of us really enjoyed it um i think maybe there was a nitpick here or there nothing's really sticking out in my brain beyond that one player who maxed out their house saying that was really hard and kind of stressful at the end and the rest of us were like well i didn't max out my house and the last couple rounds were fine so if you want to go on house maxing like you are definitely setting yourself up for some some higher level math than the other players but beyond that we all really enjoyed it and we are all actively interested in playing this one more i'm really happy that i have a copy coming my way and i'm curious to try this one out at different player counts i haven't talked about the specifics but the cubes the work replacement cubes in the middle they are uh removed every single round or at least the top level of them are removed all of them go in a four player game but less than all of them go in a three or a two player game so i'm curious to try other player counts to see if it's maybe a little bit quicker not the two and a half hours for four players is particularly bad and yeah this just seems like a cool
system it uh is a lighter teach than a feast for odin at this point i think i probably still prefer a feast for odin but that is one of my favorite games with the norwegian expansion but i'm quite intrigued to see more plays of hallertau it was just very satisfying i didn't really um dig into the field mechanic all that much the player who put out 69 or eight points worth of cards had maxed their fields out they had so many fields they were just sowing so many crops and getting so many resources every round whereas i had like three or four piddly little fields so there's a lot of things that i haven't explored yet in this game that i am actively looking forward to explore um but i do want to end this by saying that i also know other people who have played this game and they were a little bit less impressed um as far as innovation is concerned there's not a lot of it in holler town like there's not a lot that makes you go wow that's totally brand new realistically the only thing that sticks out to me is the crop rotation mechanic i think i haven't seen anything quite like that and i really enjoyed that but beyond that you're doing work replacement which is pretty straightforward the craft houses and your your community house moving might seem innovative at first but realistically it's just a means to spend the stuff that you are making from your fields and you know when you move the house over you just get more workers to do the work replacement a little bit more so i don't think this one is necessarily going to light a fire under everyone i i i wonder if anyone's going to sit here and play this game once and say this is the best game i've ever played but so far in my experience the people that i played with played it and actively enjoyed it and really are looking forward to playing it again well again i know some people who played it and felt a little bit like
about it because it didn't seem like they seemed like they were doing very standard euro things with standard euroway bits and i don't necessarily agree with them but it would not surprise me if many people also feel that way about haller tau so yeah my copy is in the mail i don't know when it's actually going to be arriving if it arrives in the next week or so i will actually be doing a tutorial for that one because it's tentatively winning the poll for november i just have to have the actual copy to film it so hopefully that one happens because i'm looking forward to digging into this one more not just with filming a tutorial but also playing it with friends again well we've now reached the third and final game i'll be talking about today and that one is mercado de las boa now this is a design from uh vitella cerda and i think julian pumbo i think it's a combination design and the uh the idea of this game is it's essentially a mechanical spin-off of part of the board game lizboa that was designed by vitola serda now i think i covered liz boa years and years ago uh it's a a game that has a bunch of wonderful ideas that did not quite connect and jive with me in the best way but part of the game my favorite part of the game involved the city building mechanic in lisboa and in mercado de lesboa they took that city building mechanic out of lisboa and they made it shine in its own small game like it's not not a very large game overall the rules are very simple to teach and it's actually a quick game to play i played a three player game of it and it took less than 30 minutes probably about 25 or so minutes although one of the three of us was very experienced with the game now um the reason i love this mechanic
is because essentially the way it works in both mercado de las boa as well as the big game liz boa is that you have a grid and you are going to be constructing various buildings in the middle of the grid that you own you put your token down on top of it but then there are outside forces that affect demand that go around on the various rows and columns around the outside of that grid that will then pay you off for the various things that you make in the middle now mechanically they're not identical between the two games but let's now just focus on mercado de las boa because the way it works is on your turn you're just going to take one action from four different options the first option is you could just take a money and at the end of the game the person with the most money wins so if you can't come up with anything else you just take a point and that's your turn the second thing that you can do is you can actually place one of your stalls down onto the board and you have three of them in front of you at all times now there are i think four or five different types of goods in this game and they have you know like like fish or uh meats or grapes and you put those down onto the board but then you have to pay for them the amount of coins you have to spend which again are victory points is equal to the number of uh the buildings that are in the row or the column where you put that new one down and you pay the higher amount so that means if you put it into a row and you're the first one in the row but in that column there's another stall of anyone's color then that's actually going to be two stalls so you have to pay two because that's the more expensive of the two so you are spending your victory points in order to place these out here on the board and that leads me to the third thing that you can do which is you can
actually i guess fulfill demand by sending out various people to the rows and columns around the outside in order to satisfy demand now the number of people that are on a tile is going to be uh equal to the number of markets in that row or column that you put them next to and the more people the better because you simply count up the number of faces on the tile and you multiply that by the number of that associated matching type of good that you have in that row or column where you put the person so what that means is if you have a face tile with two faces on it and they want fish and they also want grapes well if in that row i have a fish market and a great market then each of those is worth two points because there are two people who want that so even though they're two different types i can still do that so that's two plus two or four money that i then take because i put that token down now it doesn't cost money to actually place that token down however by putting that uh demand token down you might actually give your opponent's points because you might have that grape and that fish market but then an opponent might also have a great market in that same row and they will also get paid coins even though it's not technically their turn so you can actually get a decent amount of victory points if you plan this right when it's not your turn which always feels good in like any game the fourth thing that you can do is you can actually place a restaurant down now the restaurants are these circular disks and you gain them whenever you cover them up with any other token and they hang out in front of you and they are a modifier for all of the adjacent buildings so if we go back to that example where i have two faces over here a fish and a uh grape spot if i then put the sushi restaurant next
to the fish adjacent orthogonally adjacent then that essentially adds one power to every single one of the fish markets that are adjacent to that sushi market whether or not that's yours so in this case they these two people want fish that's two times two or four just for the fish and then of course there's still the wine over here the one wine for the two so now you got six points instead of the four points or coins uh because you had that sushi market so this game is definitely about trying to place your markets in the right places early so you pay less victory points to put them down and then you want to cash out as many points as you can by putting the different demand tokens in alignment with it there are four different demand tokens that can be lined up with every single cart on the game and of course you want to place these restaurants out to help you more than they help your opponents because they are neutral now at the end of the game you lose a point for every restaurant you didn't place so you want to be careful about how many of those you actually take into your hand but that's essentially the game i might have missed a thing or two here or there but you're just going to keep playing until one of two conditions happens the first is if there are just four empty spots in the middle of the grid and the other is if there are just four empty spots with the demand spots all the way around the outside so you're just going to keep playing and once the end game trigger is hit i believe the game just ends immediately i can't remember the specific of it but then you just reveal how many money you have and the person with the most wins now going back to things i've said before uh i won this game by a pretty decent margin uh so maybe i have some winners bias here but i thought this was a really sharp game like talk about a super filler
because it's um again took maybe about 25 minutes for ex for new people well one experienced person who taught it and two complete newbies uh if i played this again at three players with three people who knew it i could see it being more in the 20 minute range but it is stinky and it is uh potentially punishing like you can definitely do a thing and then be like no why did i do that that was way better for someone else and there are also many moments where you desperately want to place a certain person down but somebody else takes a different person and puts it into the same spot because they'll score way better and now you just kind of lost out on that so on every one of your turns even though the options seem rather simple there's a lot to think about and you can really put together some great combos i think i kind of lucked into some really good combos with my restaurants and my various market stalls and the way things worked out i had an 18 point scoring turn at one point and uh yeah i won by a relatively sizable amount which felt good but you know that's just one play i wouldn't surprise me if the next time i play i come dead last because things don't kind of accidentally work out in my favor so much now that there's randomness in this game there's essentially no randomness but um i think i just kind of did the right things without a whole lot of uh thought behind it so i was really impressed by mercado de las boa this is a game i would definitely not mind having a copy of although um one of my closest friends does have a copy so i don't have to worry about not being able to play this one again but it's just so sharp it reminds me of those many games that are designed these days that are two player only to try and be like a thinky euro experience in about 30 minutes but in order to pull it off you have to have
two players if there's a third player then maybe it's a 45 minute or even a 60 minute game so they design it for just two players well mercado de los boa is a four player game but it still plays in about that time frame so it's much more likely to get played in the future now it's possible people aren't always going to be looking for a brain burner 20 to 25 minute filler style game but i'm looking forward to playing this one more i think mechanically it's ingenious uh once again it adopts the ideas from my favorite part of the big game lisboa and lets them all just really shine in a simple to teach but complex game to play and i just love seeing that uh i think my soapbox lately in the last year or two is just seeing euro games that have just way too many rules and too many mechanics and too many uh exceptions and bonus tokens and all that and then here comes just a great example of what you can do when you don't have all those exceptions and all those superfluous rules and extra bonuses and everything it's just a really honed elegant design and i'm super impressed with it so yeah i think that's going to wrap up my thoughts about mercado de lisboa all right that has brought me to the end of this impressions vlog even though i only talked about three games i think this was a very long one uh i i honestly did not go into this with a outline of what i wanted to say about any of these games i actually never do i just kind of turned the camera on and let my mouth go and i hope that i was structured enough especially about anno i think i talked about that one longer than i've talked about most games but um these games are are great like i'm playing so many great games and even though some of them that i might love like anno 1800 seems to maybe have
some problems that i hope are not fatal i'm still really enjoying playing them and it's that time of year you know spiel just kind of sort of happened and so many euro games come out around then so this is kind of my favorite time of the year for new releases to come out and i'm happy to be enjoying so many of them that are showing up i'm not sure what i'm going to be doing the next of these impressions vlogs uh we are still working our way through that uh uh rise of queensdale campaign uh but i have a couple of the games that i would really like to get played like um uh new york zoo that one arrived recently and cafe that one also arrived recently i actually built a private mod for new york zoo that plays up to four players i know there's a tabletopia version but i wanted to make my own and i'm gonna make a mod for cafe for us as well so hopefully i can play those soon and actually cover those soon as well but time will have to tell on that one all right i think that's going to bring this vlog to a close as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer-level patreon supporters if you would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos like this one then please go to johngetsgames.comport also if you enjoyed this video please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching