Film influence and playfulness in game design (guest: Phil Walker-Harding) | Ep 149
Transcript
okay I'm excited for our next guest because we're experts uh for Australia now yeah we've been watching alone Australia and we know everything there is so hence Our Guest this week is Australian hey everybody uh welcome to the going analog podcast in which three board gamers each bring a different game and topic to discuss I'm your host Christina and we are thrilled to introduce you to our Australian guest today prolific board game designer Phil Walker Harding praise be um board game content yes it follows you everywhere right so this is from the board game content creators the brothers murf they started praising Phil whenever his name was mentioned so it stuck um so now everybody has to do it that's what I hear you don't have to you really don't but it was great to be here and it just emphasizes I think the breadth of games that Phil's designed the now classic adorable card drafting Sushi go the Egyptian Stone moving surprisingly competitive imotep arguably the best polyomino game Baron Park I would say uh some of our favorite flip and rights silver and gold super mega Lucky Box the list literally goes on and on and so you know as the brothers murf said Phil's absolutely The Undefeated king of family weight games so uh next up for you will is also the AG published Misfit Heroes that's pre-launched on Kickstarter so we're very excited for that and so welcome to going analog Phil thank you
that was a lovely introduction um and it's great to be here thanks for having me and Phil you're more than your Australian background so just so you know that's not the my life looks nothing like alone trust me I thought all of Australia was like that okay but you know it's fine uh so what is the topic you're going to bring for us today well I've been thinking about um this thing I'm seeing more and more in game design which I love which is playful in game design so when the game designer gets a little bit Whimsical or quirky with what they're doing so I thought that would be fun to to chat about okay very excited to talk about that and joining me as always is Shu hi Shu hello and in the course of preparing for this episode I discovered that Phil studied film at Uni right so uh you know I was curious about how that will what's our topic for for Phil today you came with the topic you tell the Audi but I let you I let you participate sometimes so oh well we just basically you wanted to with your film background we wanted to see how that impacts game design for you or maybe for others so maybe some of your peers uh but just they're they're both huge entertainment businesses so we're just wondering what that crossover is like from a designer's point of view yeah so well we'll talk about it in a bit we'll we'll get to our topics in a bit he's very excited to actually use it for once now we like to start things off by
highlighting a recent game so for us we wanted to talk about a game published in Stateside by pandasaurus um the English pronunciation may be rivages in French rage I don't know I'm very bad at French but you took French how would you pronounce that shoe uh rage okay rage there you go and uh yeah so we received a copy of this from pandasaurus so thank you and uh we enjoyed it it's like a it's like a quick little filler type game where you are doing a flip and right but the Twist on this is like you're exploring different Islands you can explore more than one Island and they are different um dry erase Island boards that you get bonuses on as you explore but it's up to you how quickly you want to explore them do you want to go to more islands and get less bonuses or focus on specific scoring bonuses and be a little bit slower on the number of islands that you visit and then extra twist is the cards that you're drafting you choose one line of exploration and then you hand the rest of it off to the next person so you know that if you don't claim this particular card the next person will so there's a little there's definitely a little bit more interaction in that way too yeah so these cards will show you the different terrain that you get to mark off but you have to explore it by foot so you have to you can't just cross off things wherever you want on an island you have to like draw a path from where you landed on the island to where you're going to exit the island but like you said like I want to I just want to be thorough and explore all of an island and then there's different games to yeah
so on each bat they'll tell you like you might get bonuses if you could do this or if you could complete certain regions and things like that so and every map has different sort of criteria for scoring points uh but again or you could just beine it to the next boat marker so you could just get to the next map and then move on and find out what new bonuses are so I like the variety and I like the kind of player in action because yeah you could see like I could look over to you if you're about to pass the next rain card to me I'm like okay what is Christina going to cross off so that I'll know what I'm going to get or Christina might look at my map and say I don't want to give him more trees so she might just like I'll take that row of marker of terrain so that Shu doesn't get that so yeah so it's just like never spite you half the time yeah so it's a fun little like uh flip and right game that has a lot more interaction than what you would expect a typical flipping right so yeah mhm and what game did you want to highlight for us today Phil well I always like to talk about the classic Sid Saxon Masterpiece acquire mhm and there's a new edition about to come out this year an anniversary edition which looks amazing so it's sort of been on my mind again and so what sticks with you about it yeah I mean for me like I think a lot of game designers feel this way about acquir it's sort of like this lesson in modern game design but 30 years before or every other modern game design kind of came into being so if you think about the mid90s as the time when sort of the
German Renaissance was happening and all these amazing new designers were making things like settlers and El Grande and all those Classics I mean aquires 30 years earlier in 1964 and it showcases so many uh of the design tenants which I think modern board game design is still kind of influenced by so it's just one of those things it's almost like out of place in the history of of how game design developed and so I just find it fascinating for that reason also it's just a really fun game that I think holds up today lots of people still play it and it's one I have a few different additions of um and it's one I like to bring out every now and again and it has certainly some Nostalgia as well especially when you bring out the 1960s uh bookshelf edition of it which who you have that original one yeah yeah yeah for those not familiar can you tell them a brief synopsis of what the game's about of course yeah so imagine a sort of grid board and it's got the coordinates of letters and numbers for each space and you all have grid you'll have tiles which are going to be placed on those spaces um and basically by placing tiles on the board you're building and expanding chains of hotels so imagine different clumps of tiles growing and each Clump is a hotel and in the game you're allowed to buy stock in different hotels so if one uh Clump is building really nicely you might get in early and buy some stock in that um you might try and get in on something as soon as it's formed and try and start
building your presence there so basically people are kind of buying their like majorities in these clumps and the really cool thing is the players are the ones adding the tiles to the board so everyone's kind of controlling how the different hotels will go um and when two Hotel clumps touch they merge and the bigger Hotel buys out the smaller hotel and it becomes an even bigger Clump and so there's all this timing and planning about when you sort of buy into different hotels and which ones you try to merge and which ones you try to keep away from each other um so it has this really great combination of like tile laying and then like majorities and of course they're two things which became so important as mechanisms in the '90s and 2000s um and they come together here in a really interesting way um the biggest thing for me about it is just that it's the first game I can really think of where the players are building the board essentially through tile Lang and every game's different because of the way the players kind of contribute to this emerging kind of map uh and that's what's so fun for me and allows it allows some amazing planning and strategy there's also a little bit of tactics and um yeah that's a quiet yeah very cool it's been a while since we played that but yeah with the new addition I can see that that hitting pretty soon that's one of those games that feels like uh I don't even know what addition to get if I were to buy it today uh cuz it feel I'm like every other year there seems to be a new
version of this ging out yeah like there been some good ones and some bad I think the the new ones that Renegade is doing both of them look excellent you I don't think you'll go wrong with either of the the more recent ones so let's start things off with talking about our topic so remind us what okay no I'm talking about the topic this time so we were curious because of your film background Phil um you know how that influences your game design is it more in some designs or others and uh first tell us about your film background like why did you decide to study film back in the day well yeah when I was finished high school and it was time to go study something the main thing I was into was movies and and film making so got into a film making course and uh I probably studied film at like the worst possible time in history because it was like the very early digital age so I missed out on doing much work on actual film and then all my digital knowledge got outdated in like a month so but it was still fun um and I also did screenwriting so for my honest thesis I wrote a feature script and so I focus mainly on screenwriting um throughout the course and and yeah I mean I I never went into it as a career after that but it definitely shaped me um creatively in a few ways I'd say mhh yeah how so like
maybe would you say that even before board gaming or do you do you mean directly impacting your board game creativity well I think both for sure so doing four years of like one particular medium doing lots of collaborations with other students you I sort of figured out how I like to work when I'm doing a creative project I think that's something that carried over into lots of other areas of life um but certainly film the two things I think that most carry over into games for me are first of all the focus on audience so when you're making a film like the audience of that film is very much in your mind as a as a Creator you know you you have to choose from the very outset like who is this for you know what is the what is the audience I'm shooting for and in you know Hollywood that's that's seems to be all they they're talking about these days is which demographics is this film kind of we're trying to hit and so when it came to board games I think I very quickly um developed this approach of kind of going audience first and thinking who is this specific design for what does that little portion of the hobby really need or want out of my game and how can I try and deliver to them in a fun way so that audience thing which is very front and center in film uh I definitely think about a lot and not all designers do and you don't always have to make that front the front of your vision but for me I found it's really helpful to think I'm
producing something and I want to really make these people enjoy it over here uh what's missing in that genre what's something they would love to see um and putting the audience in that position so that's a big thing I think I naturally kind of brought with me um from film can you give example of that kind of dialogue that you had with yourself in in one of your games like a Baron Park or sushi go and then how that kind of came to fruition yeah well Sushi go is a good example because when I designed that I didn't even I had like a specific line of games in in mind which was the the old game RI uh small cardboard box card games so things like Loot and Ratatat cat and Sleeping Queens which are very much for like you know um six seveny old kids and their families and I was designing for that line so it was really cool when game right picked it up that was a really great moment but it really helped me kind of frame the game and go okay I love drafting I've seen it in a few other games and I'm now trying to hone it in for like a seven-year-old so what is too much for a seven-year-old what things would a seven-year-old find particularly fun um and is there enough here to keep the adults engaged as well well so that's probably a good example where I had the audience very much front and center as I okay and I do find that that's true with a lot of your designs they're so consistent in like this works for this
group there's some games that I play that I enjoy we like uh I'm going to find it hard to find people to play it with because maybe it's like a little bit too complex here but the theme would be great for somebody a little bit more casual or and it doesn't quite diive but I found like yeah does seem very intentional the way that you've designed for that yeah I think I'm almost allergic to that one extra rule that will mean you know a family who's not that into games will trip them up like I'm always trying to shave those things off um obviously in still present a game with some really meaningful decisions but not a game that exactly it's going to trip someone up cuz I oh we thought we would be able to play this but we can't figure out this whole system so yeah do you feel like a lot of seven-year-olds play eat sushi I think so I mean definitely in Australia they do Sushi's really popular here um and kids love sushi so and I Love Sushi which is why I chose which is fair fair even the kids that I've seen who don't like sushi they'll play the game because it's so cute so there's that art does definitely help you put those cute faces on any food kids will probably have a have a go up playing yeah do you feel like sometimes like that sort of screenwriting I know you've done so many different games and like the Venture game series from Cosmos and stuff like that does that feel like certain parts of that background come in to play even more on certains yeah totally so when Matthew Dunston and I created the adventure game system we were talking
with Cosmos about it and they wanted this was after time stories was a big hit and they wanted a narrative kind of Series where they could have all these different little releases with different uh stories and we we designed that system and then it was time they were like okay now you need to give us the first first one like the first complete story and so I went away and designed the dungeon which is the first one and it's basically an escape from a medieval dungeon kind of game uh but it was honestly like writing a screenplay because the game takes place we decided already the game would have three acts basically so three kind of points where you can stop and save and then come back later and pick up act two and then act three and of course the three act structure is a very big thing in screenwriting and film making so I I I already like oh it's like I'm writing a movie um so you have to escape from this prison and then you meet someone are they good or are they bad and then you have to solve a puzzle to get into the next level and then something surprising happen so all these things you learn in screenwriting about turning points and twists and things uh very much like came back to me and I was like oh yeah and so I pretty much approached it like I was writing a movie I mean obviously there's not much dialogue and things things like that but in terms of those beats in the plot um I was very much thinking of a film and um I think when that Series has been its best it's when we've managed to find that kind of quite simple approach to the storytelling where you almost feel like you are living through the
three acts of a movie um so yeah that would be the the series that it most helped me and um certainly Cosmos helped out a lot with the pros and the writing uh but in terms of structural decisions I think me and Matt were thinking a lot about movies as we did that okay cool does that just working on like those adventure games with that's so story driven do you feel like hey I'm just one more step from here to an actual movie script or anything like that do you feel like I want to take this world and this stuff that I built and carry it over to a bigger medium well it was interesting so all of the kind of plots we've gone with the adventure games are incredibly I won say cliche but they're like movie tropes you know so there's a fantasy one a Sci-Fi one an Indiana Jones kind of one the ghosts one and so I think it wasn't so much we felt like we were creating cool new worlds um where we were like inventing new things and new characters and new places it much more felt like we were taking sort of our favorite movies and our favorite genres and just letting the players kind of play in those M kind of cliches almost so in Grand abidon Hotel it's kind of like a horror but a bit funny so like a Ghost Busters kind of thing and you get to do all the things you want to do you know you get to discover ghosts you get to go through a haunted hedge maze you
get to um open a portal you know all these like fun movie moments you get to do so I think we saw it more like that that we weren't really making new worlds we were just letting people play in some of those places we know well yeah yeah is there a game where it was like surprising how much of your film background went into it that we wouldn't have expected I don't I the other game so coming out this year also uh from mojito that I designed is a game called Sinister Institute and it's like a pretty straight up Cooperative game where you're working together as kids who are training to be Wizards um no copyright infringement of course and um and that is quite a straight for it's kind of in the Realms of something like a um Forbidden Island style Co-op okay and I realized when I designed that how co-ops much more than I think competitive games often do have a narrative Arc to them if you think about pandemic and particularly the pandemic Legacy games where you're playing through multiple games in a scenario of you know this big story co-op games often have these simple narrative turning points as well and so when I was designing that you you wouldn't think of it as a sort of a cinematic game really but certainly the events that happen and the way the characters change and progress was also very something I remember thinking about you know
plotting out a narrative in a screenplay so that would be the other game that sort of pops into my head where that happened yeah yeah and that makes a interesting point because I remember the first time I mean the only time I've played pandemic Legacy season 1 I'm not going to play it again but when I played it I was like this has been the most cinematic experience I've ever had at a game at the time and it was like just blew my mind so um I feel like that really opened things up I think yeah and there are a couple of plot points I I won't say them in case people still haven't experienced the game but there's a couple of things that happen in the plot that you I still remember you know and I played it what almost 10 years ago now I think yeah yeah and those plot points I think come right out of TV and film storytelling the way Matt got them in there um yeah very memorable for me too yeah yeah same I I remember specific points in that game but a lot of it was group generated it's like how we reacted to something that was happening in the game so that's a very good point about Cooperative like narrative kind of popping up in Coop games was there any other game that comes to mind for either of you that's like felt this feels like a like cinematic as a as a game experience besides that I always feel like um the closest I think I've felt to like I am in a movie in a game is probably betrayal at house on the hill um it's not my favorite game but the first sort of half hour while
you're exploring that haunted house and all those event cards come up um it does a really good job of making you feel like you're experiencing a horror film with plot twists and surpris things that's probably the one I think of first yeah do you enjoy games that are very are designed to be narrative focused like uh uh some of the plat Hat games that have narration and a full plot and someone's written out like mice and Mystics like here's the story and you're literally reading the story uh to immerse you in the world or you get it narrated to you do you enjoy those types of games actually not really which is which is odd cuz I've done the adventure game series maybe it's because the adventure game series sort of burnt me out on that much Pros like when you're writing that much text for a game it really just when you do a few you know these are like some of them have up to 100,000 words in them it's like you're writing a book every time and and I think that process kind of made me as much as I enjoyed that working on that series it also when I finished it kind of made me think there has to be another way to get narrative into games into board games that isn't just reading you know so like if you think about role playing games I guess there's some reading depending on how you're playing and what you're doing but often it's the players who create this narrative together MH and it's trying to think I wonder how board games can get
there as well without just relying on mostly on pros and Al there's many many great games that use Pros in that way don't get me wrong but just with betrayal for example it doesn't have it has little bit tiny bits of Pros you read but most of it is just the combination of uh the the pieces and the cards and when and how they come up that sort of creates the The Narrative and then there's that one twist moment where you do read some pros and the game shifts but yeah I I think a lot of people um when they're playing a game together to kind of stop and listen to 10 minutes of of Pros is often not quite what's happening at the table and so I wonder if yeah I'm always thinking about this actually and and thinking what are some other ways board games might get better at developing narrative umh yeah is that something you're actively working on like you have do you have a project now that's like if I can get this figured out then this is a game that I'm going to make yeah so I think for like probably at least a decade I've I've had a few game design white whales that I'm trying to um defeat and one of them is it's it's this game I've just called I haven't done any work on it because I can't figure out how to do it but it's called story it's called story Quest that's like the page that's like the page in my notebook every time I
write notes on it it's story Quest because it's how do I get an adventure game that creates this amazing story but through player interaction and just a developing emergent kind of play around the table rather than essentially going the Chooser and Adventure style of play MH um so it is something I'm always thinking about I haven't cracked it yet I may never crack it but it's one of those designs I keep coming back to and thinking oh how could I do this um yeah be CU I I feel like cuz I mean obviously some people would say just play a tabletop RPG you know but for me like that's not my preferred way to play I do want that table aspect somehow too so I'd be fascinated by that um and be more more of what I would be looking for if I am your audience I guess yeah I often think about that like people who aren't into RPGs like one of the big barriers is you need a DM you need someone who's really skilled at running the game and that's really what makes a great group kind of coher and gel but for most people who are in just into tabletop that feels almost like a whole different hob H like how would I find one of those people and so finding a game that yeah just the pieces on the table and the RO book that's all we need and we feel like we've lived a story that that's what I think is the really the big thing to aim for yeah mhm okay so story Quest coming to Kickstarter next year may do not do not hold your
breath which I think leads to well into your topic though I'd love to talk about um what was your your topic again if you could remind us Phil so playfulness in game design mhm and what does that mean what you your original when we were talking about this in email you wanted to call it Whimsy in uh game design but you purposely change it to playfulness yeah so I I often when it comes up when I'm playing a game and one of these mechanisms happens I think oh that was Whimsical so that's why I thought of that word um but actually what I'm trying to get at is I'm seeing I mean this has always existed but I'm seeing a little bit more in the last few years some cute smaller games do some incredibly clever things that as players I think you go like wow the game designer really had fun with this like they put something cute into the game um that maybe isn't essential to the mechanisms but they put something there that creates this fun sense of quirkiness or silliness or Whimsy around the table and I think it's this lovely little moment of the the players and the game designer sort of having a wink and a nod at each other so the best example I can think of is there this little card game which has just come out uh all play have put out called fairy and it's just a tiny deck of cards and the entire game is simply
someone flips over a card and then before the next card is flipped over everyone is basically betting if they think the next card will be higher lower the same suit or one of three special fairy cards in the deck so it's this super simple betting kind of game what's the next card going to be almost so slight it's you know it's just a silly little thing however the designer made this amazing decision which is that the way you bet is with a hand signal right so you point up for higher you point down for lower sideways for the same suit and if you think it's a fairy you make a catching motion with your hand okay also because this fits in a tiny little deck box the way you keep score is on a single card which has a score track on the card but where you are holding it with your index finger and thumb indicates where you are on the score track so that's how you get so everyone's sitting around a table holding a silly card like this remembering how many points they're on and then making these silly hand motions and it just brings you into the space the silliness of what you're doing in this really fun way especially when it's late in the game you know there's two fairies left in the deck and everyone's grabbing like this trying to grab that fairy and then one player's pointing up it just creates so much visual like interest and tension and um and that's the game that made me
start really thinking about this now lots of people are going to bounce off that game because it is so silly and simple but I think if you're in the right mood it feels like um this amazing combination of gambling for one of a better term and like play acting that we're catching fairies it's so silly um and and all of that stuff could have been done didn't need to be in the game right there could have been a regular score track you you could have just indicated your bet with cards or tiles to show what you're betting rather than hand gestures but I think the designer understood that this sort of game the more playfully you approach it the more fun you'll have and so I think those extra rules signal that to the player say hey this is a bit silly so let's be a bit silly and that to me is an example of yeah the game designer being playful themselves um and wanting to increase that level of playfulness in the game and so did you bring this up in the is it the idea that you want to introduce more of it or to your own designs or is it just something like you're impressed with other people doing it but it might not be something for you I think definitely I would love to think about what this could mean for for my designs I think the thing I'm really picking up on with it though is it's something I don't think I've intend
thought about before much as a game designer so as a game designer like a lot of us when like the the classic example of a r a playful rule that we all hate is having to say uno in Uno right you know it's so silly I mean of course when you're five it's really fun but as a game designer you're kind of thinking often I think we're sort of expected to think like mechanisms only what does this game need to function other things are that are peripheral to that are kind of silly and not important and your your job is just to make this machine work as a game designer so I think this has just made me rethink some of the moments where a game can invite the players to do something a little more silly um another great example is the card game cabanga which came out a couple years ago I don't know if you guys have played cabanga yeah we did yeah we have um people are playing out cards on the table in different colors and if and if if there's two cards of the same color on the table and there's a gap in the number between them so let's say one is a five and one is a 10 if you play the 10 down you create this range of 5 to 10 and anyone else at the table who has a a number that fits within that range can call out kabanga and give give and and they they
get to trash that card which is good cuz you're trying to get rid of cards so it creates this funny thing where every time if you watch people play cabanga um after they're a little way in you'll see people put down cards like they're wincing you know like they close their eyes and they slowly they just are about to be hit with this flurry of other players going kabanga kabanga and throwing their cards down and again you didn't have to have that a word was said mhm you know and I'm sure someone in the development of that game said oh let's get rid of having to take a bang that's just silly but it like triples the tension of when you're putting the car down cuz you're waiting for the whole table to just shout cabanga at you and I think um it's a really important part of that game as simple as that game is so um and that was another game where I played I was like oh the that Choice seems silly but it actually does so much to orient you towards the type of game it is the spirit to play the in which you're playing and just that moment of like surprise and tension it generates so yeah that's another one I think of a lot this is fascinating for me because uh Christina is a more of a stickler for like the literal rule like it's like if it was in a rule book that designers as you to do it show kind of enforce play yeah do it I want to see what this feels
like for me I'm like like I sort of those things that like clearly aren't important or vital they doesn't change mechanic uh I might just skip over or kind of like take a more casual approach to it but then Christina's like no we have to do this like the the only example I know there's some where you have to say something and I can't think of I I I can remember this in the past that there games where Christine is like no you have to say this word that was we instructed to say in the rule book uh another one you do is the party game blob party so this is a game where it's a Cooperative like uh there's a couple of prompts on the table and then it's Cooperative party game and then everyone will write one answer and then if your answers match anyone else's you join together and the goal is by seven rounds that everyone is now one team one blob one blob uh so and so you're just trying to hope that you're always matching then so for example if it's a two people on one team five on another team that five will have one answer the team of two will have one answer if they match then they join and they win but with the game comes a little container of clay like Play-Doh clay uh without the trademark issue but yes pretend did it come and it came a googly eyes to put on them with different colors so then you just break off a piece of this clay you put your color your player color on your own little blob super adorable or ugly whatever you want to make completely unnecessary like like no use for this whatsoever and then but Christina's like
the first time I played it with our friend Grant lion he didn't play with the clay so that's how I learned it I'm like you don't need the clay Christina's like you need the clay so she'll make everyone break out the clay make a little character and then when you join with another player or players their clay gets clumped together into a bigger blob and then you can sculpt that new hybrid blob of course which is another part of the fun so yeah to me it's like a distraction but it's like a fun yeah like Christina will enforce this kind of stuff so I think she's with you Phil it it adds for like yeah and I feel like a lot of the sort of lighter games oh sorry yeah the lighter games sort of adding those extra aspects gets you like you said into the right mindset to enjoy the game more and then also like it just adds this little memorable quality which is what I want from a game game perspective even this very small card game from Elizabeth Hargrave tussy musy so you're just um you know giving people a basically a cut choose choice I hand them two types of flowers one's face up one's face down whatever they accept I get the other one right but whichever one you give them it's like this Victorian practice of giving people flowers that had different meanings and they have the meaning very very small on the bottom AAL size but I make people read what that is basically like you have cut me deeply or I am in envious of your life whatever it might be and so it just adds this little aspect that I find very fun to it so yeah that's a lovely little example because of course it feels like you're you know that game is about giving
giving you know it's like giving flowers to someone but what am I communicating with my choice you know it's such a simple game but the theme is like perfect for it um one more that occurred to me is um like sometimes these things can absolutely be integral to gameplay as well so an example of that would be from I mean oink games are the master at playfulness I think in their games but poter I don't know if you've played that one where you've got different objects in your hand you didn't play that one oh I have so there's a ghost who's haunting you and you have these five weird objects in your hand and you flip over a card and it tells you which ones you need to drop out of your hand without looking right so it's this very silly dexterity game but the genius thing about it is um if you win around you get a victory point which are represented by these tiny little bells M like Jingle Bell kind of bells yes and then you have to add that to your hand so you now have a victory point but you also have one more thing in your hand to control and so when you get to three or four or you win at five but when you get more bells in your hand it's you you're playing twice as awkwardly as everyone else and you're jingling so you're like I'm waking up The Ghost and I think the choice of the victory points being Bells is when you first read it you think well this is silly they could have just been chips or have a score track but it absolutely makes the game because it balances the game in this really interesting way as you get better but also the fact that you're ringing and
whenever a bell drops out of your hand it hits the table and goes ding um and you think about waking up the ghost um yeah it just makes the game come together entirely and I don't think the game would be anywhere near as good if it was Victory Point chips um mhm yeah so there's another one it gets really hard I've played it once my friend's copy and I was like ah this is nothing you know just add a couple like Bells here and there like H they're much smaller than the other things in my hand and they fall out very EAS the Bell gets stuck in the ring and then the ring PS out with the belt yeah yeah ridiculous yeah there are a couple of examples like the uh mysterium game and we just played the other night uh Phantom Inc where the the theme of the game is like one person is usually a spirit or a ghost of some sort communicating with other players and it's mysterium is the same way or that a cored game where Phantom Inc is a team based team versus Team game but in Phantom Inc there's a one part where uh people are writing Clues one letter at a time and then the spirit will knock on the table to indicate right is that am I thinking it's correctly if they're guessing correctly you knock they knock on the table they don't talk they just like that's how they communicate is this noise and mysterium I don't remember the exact rule but there's something along those lines and then so that was a little bit more fun because it does immerse the room into this idea that these certain players are actually spirits and operations and not real people who should be talking to you in a
normal way yeahh but one last example for me I don't do you know the name of the game where you wear these little cat fingers oh katsuki katuki I've seen this all over Instagram but I have not yeah I think I think there's another aspect of this where that this kind of these fun kind of gimmicky novelty things now makes it more Instagram worthy as well um but this is just uh you lay out some cards and everyone's going to decide which one they want and then you put your finger on it uh and then if two more than one person match like picks the same card then no one gets that card so you're trying to guess what other people can pick very simple game it's like everyone wants this card but you know you can't go for that because other people might but the the Whimsical part about this is like everyone has this little finger puppet that looks like that makes your hand your finger look a catw and there's different patterns it's not there's like I think five or six of these in the box and they're all different kind of cats there's like a tabby cat and an orange cat and stuff like that and it's just absolutely like unnecessary but unnecessary but it would it makes the game it's like these cats are trying to grab these fish in a fish market so like yeah that's one where you don't need it but I don't know if I would play the game without it yeah no you have to play it it it's a good I think it's whole thinking about this topic this way just reminds me that oh yeah a game designer like I am creating play for people you know sometimes we
think about game designs these very serious thinky um complex machines but actually at the heart of what we're doing is getting people to play I mean that's that's what games are and sometimes these little things I think are a nice reminder for the designer and the players that hey that's what we're doing like we're pretending to be cats and we're trying to grab cards so why not you know throw in some finger puppets like yeah it's something that's I just found a bit refreshing as like this little uh I'm seeing it a bit more often and I find it refreshing because it reminds me of like why I got into game design to begin with and why we all started playing games to begin with which is to play yeah I guess I think you know thinking on the other end of those sort of heavier more Euro game type games like I it's sort of harder to see the like little playfulness but I always think of the uve Rosenberg like rule books where there's always a little picture of uve on the side and he gives you a little detail about like yeah beans are great nutrition and whatever it might be and I really enjoy those aspects too like so I'll share it as I'm teaching the game too but it's very different type of of playfulness but I I like that some thought went into that and it's not just here's a machine and you're pressing levers and see who presses levers best you know so yeah I definitely think you can get even in very heavy serious games the designer's personality will come through to some degree and I think um that's a good
example and also just the artwork he often chooses for his games is often like belies the heaviness and an interesting choice as well yeah yeah I do like those uh when they kind of have more fun in the rule book like there's one um was Peter hayward's game A Time to Kill oh no that time you killed me that time you Ked there's some winky moments in the rule book explaining like yeah if you're I can't remember this is I read this a while ago but it's something referen hey if this happens in real life you might want to be careful because the game's a 2v 1 V one abstract time traveling game where you could kind of almost like a sort of Chess like not that it's not as complicated as chess but it's sort of like you're battling over three different time periods and what you do in the past could have impact something in the future but in this game in the rule book they made a reference like hey if this thing happens in real life you maybe want to be careful because it might be your friend from the future trying to do something to you it's something along those lines but it's like very cleverly written uh and it's just kind of a fun little extra touch that and I remember that thing from that I read years ago H yeah even just the title of that game it could have just been called time chess you know but time that time you kill it instantly makes you okay we're having a bit of fun with abstracts as well when when we're playing this game yeah maybe you could draw some inspiration for that for your story quest
game that's a sad ending though be a Twist be a twist for sure yeah uh so thank you so much for joining us Phil I had so we had a lot of fun talking and we know we have uh quite a few things to look forward to for you um you mentioned Misfit Heroes coming up um and I read about it can you just do quick description for what to expect from Misfit Heroes since that's coming out for you soon so yeah Misfit Heroes is the result of me I'm not a big ccg person um but I really got into key Forge when it came out and it made me start thinking all about the design principles around ccgs and so I thought I'm going to make a game in that genre not collectible but in that kind of genre with lots of cards that do different things and I started thinking about how you would make a thousand different cards and I realized maybe instead of me having to come up with a thousand cards I could get the game to create the cards for me so the game comes with 100 cards and 100 transparencies and before you play the game you put the transparency on top of the character card and the transparency changes what the character is so um you might have a flying Goblin and then the next time you play you might have a cosmic goblin and the way the transparency interacts with the card changes what the card does as well so it's a big experiment it's kind of a a tableau building game at its core but anytime you want you can swap out the
transparencies and change the deck so we've called this a mutating deck and so you never know what cards are going to be in the deck uh you never know what new combination you'll find um and we play tested it for years it was a lot of work it was a lot of work um but if it's it is quite playful actually now that I think about it in the sense that it's kind of showing you the nuts and bolts of game design in a strange way and that you can see by sliding that transparency in how a card changes and shifts and how it gets balanced um so yeah I hope I really hope it goes well uh it's probably the game I put the most hours into that I've done um and it feels pretty original um but it's also really strange so that's that's M it's the Phil Walker Harding magnum opus so far in a way in a way it is yes that sounds awesome because I I really like small world which has a bit of a you combine one power with One race then so you might have flying goblins one time and then other times you might have uh Hill goblins that completely act differently and then I know AG loves they have a lot of the card crafting system in a lot of their John declair games like dead reckoning has that and I love that where now I could customize each card in my deck building game so yeah I'm looking forward to yours very exciting and where can people follow you
on social media somewhere and see what you're up to or your website sure yeah so I'm Phil Walker harding.com and that has quite a lot of information about my games and little designer notes for them as well and then I'm not that much on social media that days but I am on uh Blue Sky mhm so I'm just for Walker Hing on Blue Sky as well perfect we'll be following you we'll be following you there and we hope everybody enjoyed our show today thanks to our amazing editor Mike Zipkin and uh please give us a like and a rating if you enjoyed our shows now you can stop listening and go play a game bye everybody bye thank you bye