Skip to main content
Loading video...

2016 Spiel Des Jahres Board Game Awards - my thoughts!

Transcript 12:56

today which is the 18th of July 2016 the Spiel desz and Kenna Spiel Des yarz awards were announced for 2016 uh and I thought this would be a good opportunity for me to share my thoughts my very early thoughts on those Award winners uh and round off my series of videos which have looked at previous winners of the award previous nominees for the award previous recommendations and games which I felt should have been nominated or won in the past but haven't so if you want to look at any of those videos go back you'll find them on my previous Vlogs over the last couple of weeks but the winner today the the the big winner was Vlad shatel with his game code names this one the SPI zarz main award which is the the family style sort of gaming award um I was surprised I thought it was going to be uh emot now you may think I'm foolish because code names has been uh doing extremely well I mean it's it's a massive seller it's being played everywhere it's been extremely popular over the last few months but I felt emot was more in keeping with uh what's won in the past and what makes a good sort of family weight sort of game um and I'll talk about that a little bit more uh as we go as we go further through this video the winner of the kenes bille was Isle of Sky Alexander fista and Andreas Pelicans game which is a tile laying sort of auction style fairly um uh it's I mean

it's got some neat ideas in it but it's a Euro game uh you know and it was up against such Innovative games with time stories and pandemic Legacy um so again an interesting result uh because pandemic Legacy and time stories really brought something new this idea of a a sort of a disposable game a game which you could play through once but then you're kind of done um so so that was an interesting thing again but before we go on let's have a quick look at what code names is all about in code names players play in teams one player on each team is a clue Giver a selection of cards form a grid on the table and each card is allocated to either the red team the Blue Team neither team or an assassin and only the clue givers on each team know which is which the clue Giver attempts to direct their teammates towards the cards which match their own color they do this by saying a single word and a single number the number indicates how many cards they're trying to point their teammates towards and the word is linked in some way to the words on the cards often this is extremely tenuous if the teammates guess correctly they Place one of their markers on the card if they guess one of the opposing team's cards then they place a marker for that team and they score if they choose a card belonging to neither team then they place a neutral marker and if they choose the Assassin card then the team loses immediately the first team to play all their markers wins so that was the big winner uh today

uh code names and and the reason I found it a little bit surprising is not because I don't think it's a good game I do I think it's an excellent game but I think it's only really a good game with six or more players and the reason that I say that is because you've got one player who's the clue Giver now they're pretty much silent they have to sit in silence um you've got their team uh and then you've got another clue giver and another teammate so this is a four player game we're talking about now now at the moment the two people who are guessing they don't really want to talk to each other because they don't want to give too many Clues to each other and the two clue givers are silent pretty much throughout so it makes for a very quiet sort of studious party game not really a party atmosphere at all you introduce a couple of teammates into this so suddenly you have a a clue giver and two people discussing why they think this is the correct answer or that's the correct answer and the game comes alive the more players that you add to these teams the more heated the discussion get and the more convoluted rots people go down when they try and explain why this thing is linked to that thing and it becomes very funny it's the sort of thing that I see being played and people gradually add themselves to the game and join in mid game um and it does become a party atmosphere at that point but only in the large player accounts which makes it a bit odd as a choice for a sort of family game award I think the other thing that's strange about it is how successful it has been in such a short space of time not because it doesn't deserve it it does but this hasn't come

from Hasbro or Mattel or something like that this is a game that's been produced by Czech games editions now that's not small fry by any means they've had very successful very popular games in the hobby market in the past but this game has come through that hobby market route even though essentially it's a Mass Market Style game that's not to do it down there's some very good Mass Market party games you know we're talking boulder dash articulate those sort of things um and really this fits into that genre the other thing is I think the packaging is really boring there sort of clip art style picture on it um so so what's led to its selling it's not the it's not the the look of the game when you lay out those cards it doesn't look fantastic the new code names pictures now they're on to something now they're starting to make it look quite beautiful um it's a cheap package doesn't cost much uh to buy I think that's really helped it vad shattil is a name he's made some great games in the past or very popular games at least they not always been to my taste but Galaxy trucker dungeon pets dungeon Lords pctto Mania Space Alert um you know these are these are Mage Knight these are all games that have G garnered a huge amount of respect in some quarters and very diverse you you know Tash kalar Arena of Legends he he seems to be able to design in all these different fields and you can't really pin him down on being of one genre or another um it's good to see him win the award it's not the first

time he's won a Spiel Zara Space Alert won a special award some years ago um so a worthy winner but just I was a little bit surprised the one that I thought was going to win was emote from Phil Walker Harding so let's have a look at that one in emot players attempt to score points by building Egyptian monuments pyram mids temples burial Chambers and obelisks on a player's turn they may add blocks to their supply move a block from their supply to a ship or move a ship to a site and contribute to the building some sites offer special action cards some offer in-game scoring others offer endgame scoring for majorities but each site has a unique mechanism for its scoring and the game offers a selection of variable boards which you can mix and match to shake up your experience over multiple plays now I was a bit disappointed for Phil Walker Harding because U I really really like emot but i' I've been a huge fan of sushi go for a number of years now it's been something I've played a lot with all sorts of different groups and this year Phil also brought out susho party has just arrived which I'm very much looking forward to getting hold of uh kaca was a really good Tire laying game similar style to sort of kazon great game you know really fantastic and then there was a reprint of his archaeology card game which I've heard good things about too so he's having a Stella year and I really wanted to see sort of this newcomer Rising through with these great games win the award I thought that would have been lovely um Otep is is exactly in line with the sort of games the Spiel

has awarded in the past um and it it has it feels like it's from the same designer as Sushi go just because of those different it feels like Phil is exploring all these different types of uh scoring mechanisms you know and he's he's finding a few that work well together but all but both these games susho and emot are infinitely expandable you know you can come up with new ways of scoring for each thing and Slot those in as you see with emot you can flip the tiles over and change the scoring categories similar to what you can do with sushigo party where you can slot in different cards and have a different play experience I like that and I was looking forward to all the massive different emote expansions that were bound to come with a SPI as yarz win uh maybe we'll still get them I don't know um the other game that we haven't talked about yet is caruba from Harbor games now uh karuba was a a great little uh game from rudig gor and rudig gor has produced many of you know fantastic games I really love his game Arcadia and I really love Las Vegas um and rudiger is known for one particular mechanism using that sort of manala mechanism where when you move you leave something behind doesn't particularly feature in his game karuba um but karuba was one of the first strategy games for Harbor who are known for those children's games those games in the yellow boxes so it's nice to see a range of strategy games and it's nice to see them actually um establishing themsel in the US as well as uh in Germany so karuba deserves some

respect but it's not as good a game unfortunately as emot or code names in in my view it's great it's lovely though it's a lovely game well worth looking at um so uh who's lost out this time round we've got Phil Walker Harding Matt lecock he's been unfortunate with the spiers yarz awards previously he's been nominated with roll Through the Ages he's been nominated with pandemic he's he's he's failed to receive a nomination for his Forbidden Desert Forbidden Island games even though they're they're very much of the right weight for SPI zarz so I think he's been unfortunate with pandemic Legacy uh not winning this year the time stories guys total newcomers um but the publisher of time stories uh the is are new but the publisher they've again they keep just just missing it um elisium was nominated last year for the Kenna Spiel Splender was nominated for the Spiel dear's main award a couple of years ago so time stories a new company admittedly a sort of offshoot of Asma day and a bunch of the people there were significant figures in Asma day and probably still are um so uh time stories is uh I mean Space Cowboys is by no means a small outfit but they are new and they just keep missing so so one day I'm sure they're going to get there sometime soon um pandemic Legacy and uh time stories I'm not particularly surprised that they didn't get the award because of that disposable nature of the game once you've played it you've with pandemic Legacy you've pretty much wrecked it

because you've written all over it you've stuck stickers on it I haven't played the game uh time stories admittedly you can package it back up and pass it on to somebody else but you're not going to want to play it yourself because essentially it's it's like reading a story neither of these games are to my taste because of the commitment involved you need to sit down with the same group of players over and over again to work your way through these stories and that's not really how I play games I have too many games for that I I I tend to play one game put it on the shelf for a few months come back to it and I don't want that continuing exercise there's not many games that I play that have that sort of campaign mode in them um I tend to avoid those games there are a few that I make exceptions for but not many um I'd like to give those games go but I don't know quite how I'm going to fit it into the way that I play games um so anyway that's my that's my immediate thoughts on the award uh I'm sure I'll have more thoughts over coming weeks uh but it's good to see um uh Alexander fista he's he's won two years in a row now is of Sky won the kenes spel this year the previous year himself and Andreas Pelican won with broom Service uh there's not many times that people have won twice in in two years I think clous Tober did it back in the 80s 90s and wolf Kang Kramer who who still is at the top of the list of people who won the the most Spiel Awards he's wolan cramers I think won five different awards at this point um but it's nice to see Alexander fisa uh come up there um

and I think he's one to watch in the future anyway uh interesting day uh I I enjoyed following the the the sort of buildup to the awards it's a bit like the board game Oscars isn't it so uh I think it's worth getting excited about for a little bit but basically a Good Year great games all around anyway thanks for watching uh I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming Vlog uh if you want to follow me on Twitter I'm at boardgame Wales and if you want to look me up on Board Game Geek I'm adam78 uh please subscribe to my channel and watch some of my other videos and uh I'll see you next time all the best

Progress saved