Social deduction, "getting to know you" games (guest: 1 Minute Board Games) | Ep 129
Transcript
hey everybody Welcome to the GL analog podcast the show where board game industry guests bring their own topics and games to discuss so I'm Christina your host and we often talk about how board games can bring people together or tear them apart so to test that we've done some intense social gaming lately and our main guinea pig Partners were Raina and Phil from one minute board games hi Rea and Phil hi how's it going they are definite board gamers Raina works in the industry as the marketing manager at pandasaurus games and she is one minute board games a Tik Tok YouTube and Instagram channel for bite-sized board game info where the snappy videos give you a quick entertaining overview of a game you can get recommendations funny little board game related videos um Phil Pops in often um and and a lot yeah I saw some exciting laminating going on with Phil recently on your channel this is uh this is Christina basically not knowing what Phil does for one minute board game you can tell no he was on the YouTube CH YouTube channel a lot you guys haven't done that much on the YouTube for a while right yeah he's my emotional support and definitely my guinea pig um anytime I need to film a video I just interrupt his workday and be like can you just stand in front of this camera and do this for me please so like okay here I am see and it's great um you have over 360,000 subscribers on Tik Tok right now so uh that's really exci exciting is that many holy crap good job you thank you good job Raina and sometimes
fil so welcome back to our podcast we always love having you on and we've been purposefully playing a lot of these very specific types of games that I'll let Shu introduce and that's why we invited you on again so well what's been our our experiment with Phil that's why you invited me on again them sho's here too as usual of course so this was actually late last year we've been getting a lot of pitches from companies for these games and I'm like oh there's kind of a theme here they're all kind of like party games but they're a little bit more altern like more Indie a little bit uh not as popular and mainstream as some of the ones we've covered we covered tons and tons of party games uh but these are all we found out there are a lot of games that are just about getting to know other people like kind of discovering their personalities kind of getting to diing to Old stories they might have so uh yeah so our topic from going analog today is uh getting to know you games and they're not all party party games but most of them are party games so we'll talk more about some of these games that uh yeah we got to get to know Raina Phil really well we got to hear a lot of stories that I don't know if we would have known otherwise right because one thing about board gaming is like it's very social you're hanging out and you're talking uh but it's not the same as like I don't know if you're going to a bar it just just pure pure talking so these games are kind of getting us to just talk talk talk which was a lot of fun even even like last night we went out to dinner and played one of these games and then we were just this was like causing all the conversation at the table for throughout the dinner so we'll talk more about that MH and at the same
time we've been also playing a bunch of social new to us social deduction games which is maybe your topic what's your topic one one one minute board games yeah that's what we wanted to talk about we've been on a few different you know group outings and trips recently so when it comes to Big groups social deduction games one of the games that get the most played so I just want get everyone's opinions on whether or not you like social deduction games if it's situational um if you do like them what are your favorite ones and those are the most dangerous that could uh break some friendships I don't know yeah one brings us closer together the other topic kind of pulls us apart so before we dive into those we like to talk about more games of course um we're each going to highlight a game as an icebreaker and for our our game we wanted to talk about Great Western Trail New Zealand um so I did actually play that with Phil during our snow Retreat um it was snowy but uh Phil and I never left the cabin with a whole bunch of other people she did she was so athletic and and went snowboarding it was great one day one day oh yeah that's true only one day and I got to hung over to go out the second day so yes but that was partially Phil's fault too my fault yeah yeah you were you kept me up till like 4:00 a.m. the night before we're just like hanging out there was five of us there not not just us two so so 20% due to him yeah that's fair I'll take it yeah that's fair yeah so I was super excited about Great
Western Trail New Zealand because I love the original Great Western Trail and this is the third in the series so there was Argentina uh with new cows and then in New Zealand um you have a lot of the same framework as the original Great Western Trail which is essentially a super big Rondell type game where you build out um like this Trail to go and deliver cows essentially so there's a deck building aspect as you're trying to get a really good hand of cows to turn in at the end and sell and then um as you're playing the game you're building out new buildings that make that trail longer and more interesting and different um so in New Zealand we're instead trading a lot of sheep which I I mean both are pretty cute but you know sheep are fluffier so that there's that going for it then um I think there were some really interesting choices made that that add lean more into the deck building part so there's some bonus cards that allow you to uh when you draw them get a little bit of a a boost in some way and then you get to draw to replace it so it feels a lot more like a deck builder for me um and they added in a couple other interesting aspects we don't have necessarily the same slight I felt the original game had a slightly awkward um how much to pay to reach a certain railroad station that was difficult to explain to new players and I feel like that part's a little smoother in the new game for New Zealand um although now they add in this extra board where you can sail around and deliver wool and sheep um by by sailing
instead so um I really really liked this New Zealand version what did you think Sho uh yeah I really like the lot so we briefly mentioned it on the last podcast so I'm like I don't know if I could go back to playing the original Great Western Trail anymore but part of that also like I've played that a million times this is very fresh and new I said the same thing about Argentina but I feel stronger about that for New Zealand because it just was really cool like you said that there's more deck building to it there are many more cards you can put in that aren't you get a sheep dog so cool uh and then there's like uh it's just it's streamlined and it's more at the same time if that makes any sense I feel like it's a smoother game there a bigger stream sure did you both feel like it was uh like there was more money in that game like more Len yes I think so I think it was not quite as punishing where you're sometimes you're like oh I'm one coin short I'm two coin short that happened a few times I think but because you could lean into the wool strategy so instead of just turning in your sheep um for the final amount at the end of the trail along the way you can Shear some sheep and uh get money just for their wool for a different sort of uh way to supplement and I think that really helped yeah because in original there's ways to get a little bit money along the trail but in the original game it's not until you reach the end before you cash in your cards and your cards have to be you have to hope that your hand is uh diverse to turn in all these
cows you don't hope it you have to you to have it yeah so you you and then it can limit your money and then you have to pay money immediately for the railroad thing you talked about uh but in this game yeah you can like along the way I'm going to share some of these sheep get some money uh I didn't lean into that strategy so I was still poor when I played it but I could see other players playing where they're like piles of money I'm like oh my God like yeah you I agree with you Phil there's like you've never seen that many coins on the table for players in the original Great Western Trail it definitely felt like you could just do all of the actions and just like barely have enough money for everything but just being able to take off um the hazards or being able to buy bonus uh tiles that help you it just feels like you can do everything hot take this is actually my least favorite of the yeah I see why people like it I feel like one of the reasons I love Great Western Trail so much is in my top 10 board games of all time is because the economy is so tight and I like that puzzle of having to figure out um where to get your income from where to spend it the best and I feel like it also sort of limits the number of options you have in the game when you have less money cuz I only have $2 so I can only do X Y and Z MH and yeah very hot takes I see that all three of you prefer New Zealand well I think Raina thinks this is New Zealand is a baby game I get it so it is it's a it's a game for
babies wait uh uh Raina Phil you've both played have you both played the second game Argentina you great Argentina so everybody's rankings yeah so Raina you first how do you rank them um Great Western Trail OG then Argentina then New Zealand so the order of publication okay I'll go next because mine's the exact opposite but but again with the caveat that I've only played New Zealand once so it's very fresh and exciting uh so like uh I don't know if I played it as many times as the original that's some more Fairway to R but based on that uh right now New Zealand number one Argentina number two the original number three I still love them all like number the original is still a fantastic game and i' play that any time uh but I I'm just excited about all this new the new changes and Phil I think I would prefer number one uh original and then New Zealand and then Argentina I felt like Argentina didn't add like if I'm remembering correctly it didn't add that much and the whole shipping track where you're trying to um sell it to a ship before it leaves the port like it felt a little difficult to get all the way to the uh harder ones before it ships and it just didn't feel great even having to ship to the last ones and stuff like that I think the only thing that I really well not
the only thing but one of the main things that I really loved about Argentina was your ability to kind of like shortcut uh to get to the to sell your sheep um I thought that was really cool um in Argentina but yeah cows yep um but the yeah original still the best for me New Zealand because of being able to do different things and just have abundance of money and then just Argentina last I'm I'm having a tough time putting AR like the original and New Zealand because I'm still always really excited to play the original but I think again it's like the novelty probably of New Zealand I put Argentina last so um I I enjoyed it when I played it I just never felt like o I have to play that again immediately and I felt that about New Zealand so maybe it's just the Sheep I'm into animals so cute that's cool we all have different rankings but no one uh has Argentina number one yeah and what game did you bring for us today Phil and Rea yeah so we decided to talk about Dune Imperium Uprising published by direwolf and designed by Paul dennon and I'm going to let Phil take away the little explanation because he played it three times in one week I will try and do my best to talk about it but basically Dune Imperium is well Dune Imperium Uprising it's kind of like a V2 version of Dune Imperium uh which is a deck builder uh worker placement game uh where you're trying to manage a lot of
your scarce resources uh trying to I guess get good cards build your deck correctly and then fight in an opportune moment to se the victory it's like a race for points um but yeah just the new mechanics that were brought into Uprising I feel like were done very well um and the cards that replace the original feel a lot more powerful um but I do feel like in this version there's a lot more focus on combat which I'm not sure that I like because in the original you definitely could win without participating in combat and just going up the different political tracks and then buying Spice in order to get points and race up that way uh in this one with the new mechanics you're able to bring in sandworms which is also really cool um but whenever you win with sandworms you can double the rewards of combat Victory and some of those can give you like four point swings so that part was really cool because I was the one that did it but I don't know how my friends felt when they were on the receiving end of a four or five point swing on the receiving end of your stand and we're talking just 10 points to end the game so four or five points is a lot yeah yeah I feel like I've Duna perum is also my top 10 games of all time and after
playing Uprising I wasn't sure about why I still prefer Dune Imperium more than Uprising I think you really hit the nail on the head when you said it's more combat focused I'm very combat averse so was not um the biggest fan of the new focus on combat um and also when I play Dune Imperium I prefer to play with the two expansions that they have um so I think I like that whole experience better but in terms of Imperium versus uprising like just the base game I would probably prefer Uprising because it's more gamery you would prefer the new one if it's just Bas just Bame but I think can't you I I Phil you read the rules can't you add those old expansions to Uprising as well you can you can um it does some change some things which I didn't really read but it definitely allows you to use the previous expansions with it um but yeah I don't know how you actually have to change things um and we haven't actually played with the expansions with um Uprising yeah yeah you uh so we brought it to the that same snow weekend and then uh I think it was like 12 like midnight and you're like hey do you want to play D Imperium Uprising and I'm like sure and then it was like 3:00 a.m. and I was going snowboarding the next day I was like you weren't no no that day that was the first night that day the next day I did go and I was like exhausted like getting up uh early but uh uh yeah I
liked it I I do like the changes like like things like the spy uh which is a new mechanic that lets you if you wanted to use a space that is already taking uh elsewhere so that gives you a little bit more flexibility in areas uh the game we played the sand warm didn't come up a whole lot so we didn't have those big kind of like oh this is a huge this really sucked because somebody else got three four points in one shot uh which is really hard to do in the original game so uh yeah I I think I like the changes but I I I that one more than the Great Western where Great Western TR like today I'm like no I would absolutely want to play the new game versus the original game where uprising like if someone's like which one do you want to play I'm like I could go either way um if you want to do something new I think if it's a new player I would stick with the original one first because it's a little more less complicated and there's less involvement there yeah it so I when I got to play the new one I like immediately wanted to play it again um because I had like this fivepoint swing and I was just like does this normally happen and I need to try it again just to make sure that wasn't some kind of fluke um but yes it definitely feels like the power level of the cards that you can obtain has gone up compared to the original base game um yeah yeah I feel like a lot of games
uh like of especially board games like the sequels or expansions always give you more power cuz I think that's like how they reward or give people who play the more excited because I like now I could do even more you want to feel more powerful when you get expansions and new things so yeah and it was weird uh I don't remember if we talked about this but the first time we were at Christina and I were at Beach gcon and then uh convention and then at the exhibitor hall I saw the box I'm like oh Dune Uprising and then uh Dune Imperium Uprising and I picked it up I'm like why is this box so big cuz I thought it was an expansion uh and I had no idea that it was a Standalone game and not an expansion it's just like a pure sequel but I'm like and I love the original game so much I'm just going to buy it anyways and see how it goes and when I started to read the rules I'm like this feels like the same game there's like very few changes to the new one so uh I do wish even though it's has changed I do I think calling it V2 is kind of a good way to put it cuz it doesn't feel like a real true true sequel It's like 90% the same game as the as the original I honestly really thought it was just like a new board with a team mechanic built in with other cards and stuff like that and so when you were telling me that it was a standalone I was just like what what do you what do you mean so now we all know do I need to pay play Uprising I don't think you need to not like yeah not like Great West we're talking about them back to back it it's
it's uh it's very very very similar to the original okay good to know so let's dive into our first topic which is what sh as a reminder so uh these are getting to know you games uh and then so we received a bunch uh from different Publishers and then there's some older games we want to talk about as well uh but basically over the past few months like we've been taking our one of these games I actually got two packs unplugs ago so like I've we've been sitting on it for a year and a half and I hope when they listen to this they're not they're like it's about time like we gave these guys a game and then they finally play but they're all all these games that we're about to talk about is like just the idea is like you get to know uh the other players a little bit deeper a little bit better uh beyond the average party games so um I'll start with one uh and then we had some weird ones in here as well uh but the one uh I'll start with you think you know me um it's a really colorful box very rainbowy colors and then so last night and it's easy it's just a it's just a box of cards and then so last night we played play this and then the basic setup is you deal seven cards to every player and then you uh ask a question and you're going to answer it for the person you're directing this question too uh so an example might be I pull some examples out here says I know one food you'd want on a deserted island is blank so I would say maybe I'll look at Rea and ask this question but I'll answer it for her and then Raina will
tell me if I'm right or wrong so what's your guess one food that Rea would want on a desserted New York style cheesecake that's a food I would like on it I don't think it's the food but yeah I'll accept it I'll say yes and the only reason I know that is cuz playing this game last night like we we uh I discovered she loves New York spell cheesecake um and then you you know you the the game scoring is just very like you discard it and get a new card if you got it wrong you discard it if you got it right and the first one to get rid of all their cards I am the champion yeah but like a lot of games like it the point isn't the scoring or the mechanism or who wins or loses it's just like the stories that came out so as we're playing these games like we're trying to get and we made a rule amongst the four of us like not to direct questions to our significant other because it'd be one too easy and then I think we would all just def default to that because that's way easier uh but uh like even if I had no idea what kind of desserts like Raina eats it's like the the point of the game was just like all right I might just take a blind guess and then she might I I might get lucky and then that'll spark a conversation it might get unlucky and then she'll explain why and then we'll have a disc like oh you like that you like this better than that there was like a question about cake versus pie uh one there many more questions that are not about dessert all the ones I remember yeah so um or like what didn't you have one like uh like unicorn would you rather would
you rather be a unicorn or a mermaid yeah and again you don't ask the person this question you answer for them I guessed wrong that one which I think is kind of a Twist on the game than some of the other ones we'll talk about but uh yeah so what did you like uh like Phil what did you think of this game I thought it was good it definitely sparked a lot of conversation for us I feel like with just four of us and US limiting uh our significant other one of the directed questions um yeah I kind of had to just throw out guesses for a lot of the majority or I mean out of the seven I chose the ones that I pretty much knew exactly for you either of you two um but it was a great conversation starter um like we talked about the unicorn and the mermaid I was like for quite a lot while which uh which section of the mermaid are you are you a fish uh top or a fish bottom and then you know you you only talked about no one thinks of a mermaid I mean it's a fish top have you there there are definitely some cartoons where you know the the fish top really awkward and you got legs this is the type of stuff FS into so it's fine yeah we learned a lot I think about these things you know yeah we learned about what kind of fan fiction that Raina has written in the we will not divulge to The Listener so you have to get to know Raina yourself EXA
yeah the thing that I liked about this game is because I feel like a lot of getting to know you games are people talking about themselves but with this game you get to see how you're perceived by other people which I thought was really interesting yeah yeah for sure yeah and it it was uh also I think it's also interesting I think this works better with people you already kind of know like I think versus an icebreaker because then you're BL you're always blindly guessing and then the conversation with spr from there which is fine but I think part of the fun is what you just described R is like this is my gu or is what I think of you or this is what I'm assuming you're going to get so I think having some familiarity uh is probably better for this particular game but it happened to be the last of the getting to know you games that we played together so it was good it was uh we already knew some stuff surprising stuff from the other games that we learned about each other too so we could build off of that yeah so that's uh you think you'd know me by pink tiger games uh then uh next one you want to talk about uh this Dungeons and feelings yeah this is a crazy one yeah so so that like actually Raina was the first one to notice on the box what does it say as the quoted time let me see I get the box right here 40 minutes per player or something 40 minutes per player 40 minutes per player and we thought like oh it'd be a cute little dungeon themed getting to know you game U and it's a very fun idea and uh concept but it is literally a Dungeon Crawler so you're building out a dungeon
with these tiles we have these different characters who have slight asymmetrical powers and it's a race to big victory points and you're you're leveling up your characters you're going along um and it has like a retro video game kind of pixelated art but then we saw that quoted time we're like What are we getting into why um but it's because it's trying to include this sort of feeling aspect so um it's interesting because the only time it really comes in is when you need to craft certain Goods which is important to the game so you cannot finish this game without crafting stuff so when you take a turn to craft you're picking two different Goods Goods cards and um when you flip them they actually have sort of a random topic or word on on them so if I wanted to craft something that required a grain and a glass and they say one says bucket list and the other one says song on the bottom then in order to craft I'm going to roll a die to see who I ask this question to and I sort of have to formulate a question about um like bucket Listen song could be so I have a question oh s so it if you're going to kick the bucket what song do you want played at your funeral that's what I would say not where I thought I was going yeah sing any song I mean you could that's not what a I mean it could be but I it makes me think of death either way oh my God I'm a little more maob I guess but I I
thought of a question of like before you die what's a concert you would like to see or something like that you know that's what's cool about the the cards there's a lot of flexibility in terms of the questions um there are sometimes where it didn't really work out but for when it did it was interesting yeah I agree I think part of the fun of this game for the question for this getting to know you part of it the the specific aspect of this game is that you craft the question and you could be creative with it and and inter how you want versus like a lot of these other games like the questions are written for you and it's like very direct and it's so it's a different vibe like that one like Christine and I just came up with two different interpretations of how you can do that but it's up to you how you want to ask it and then you could uh kind of customize it for the group or the person you're directing it to you can like okay I don't know like but you can just change the question of how you want and there's a like a ton of these cards and so mixing and matching you could just figure out like okay I I can invent the question and the game does say in instructions like if you're crafting multiple items on your card on your turn uh you don't have to ask all the question you can just ask one question and then the rest you don't worry about to save time but I we all ended up kind of I didn't think I thought we would want to shorten the game but then I think as you Rea first was like I'm just going to ask all the questions I'm going to ask three different questions to different people and then we stopped rolling to die even cuz we're like we're just going to ask questions evenly throughout the group and then so it was kind of fun because the Dungeon Crawler
game is like pretty simple pretty straightforward uh and then this was like a like Phil you said it it's like it kind of shoehorned in this whole feelings part of the game uh but it did I thought it was like a nice uh kind of break it's like okay we're dungeon crawling we're Gathering resources we're trying to fight monsters and it's like now I'm going to ask uh Phil about what song he would like to hear before he dies or something like that and then uh and then he continues so it's a very strange game I don't know I was definitely surprised at how just combining two words can really generate a lot of conversation and whatever question you do ask it ends up like everyone wanting to answer their own part of it um so yeah yeah and the interesting thing is too when you ask someone a question you're crafting these items with these resources they actually as a award for opening up get one of the resourc sources so like that yeah yeah so everyone's like it it didn't feel weird because at first I'm like well why would you do this in this game but because uh like the other person gets kind of a half resource in a way uh then it helps them as well so it's kind of weirdly semi-cooperative in that way um even though it's competitive overall so yeah we didn't finish a full game because uh we had a lot of gaming to do uh but Phil did kill his personal Dragon so that was a big deal yeah so yeah it's a ultimately a
race for victory points but it's a very Str like the box is uh on the tagline say a social SL strategy hybrid board game and again it's Dungeons and feelings which like as soon as you see that name it's going to people are going to be like what the heck is this game about I and it's been we've also had this sitting here for months uh from uh sent To Us by Gwen games gwi M and uh but uh yeah like every time people have seen this at our house they like immediately pick it up and they're like what is this game and I'm like I haven't played it yet but this is what the concept is so uh I do like the tagline it's open up dig deep yeah I really wonder how this was Pitch like I really love dungeon crawling but I really really need to like get to know all of my friends but also it's a dungeon crawling and you're not cooperatively killing things as a group getting to know each other I you know like that's what I assumed like we were all in the dungeon together and we're fighting things getting to know each other every time we like fight or something like that yeah I felt I felt that was a little desperate feel very passionate about Dungeon Crawlers so he has a lot of opinions about those oh yeah I love them it it was a very strange game very strange mix it does feel shoehorned in but like when it I did enjoy when I'm like okay I'm going to craft now and I got to come up come up with the question first of all with these words I'm giving and
then uh and then ask the questions and then go from there so I I really like that break it's like all right we're dungeon crawling dungeon crawling and then like oh let's stop for a moment and have a conversation in the middle of this game very strange very strange but really interesting M quirky and unique MH yeah uh so a quick change of pace uh another game I wanted to talk about uh I've seen I think I saw uh you do a video of this Reena uh priorities right it's like you want to talk about it yes so priorities is actually me and my girlfriend's favorite game um so on a turn this is a Cooperative game um you're going to deal out five cards face up and they these are the most random out of-pocket things like it'll be like the patriarchy a $6 latte cats um wet socks and the matriarchy and on a player's turn they are going to write on their board how they would prioritize them whatever that means to you whether it's like how much you like it which is generally what they're going for and then the rest of the players try to predict how they're going to answer and for every one that they get right you flip the card over it has a letter on it and whoever spells priorities first whether it's you or the computer when you lose cards um wins and yeah it's a lot of fun we had a lot of fun with that too it's been a while I think yeah we had this a long time ago yeah but sorry oh it's just like yeah trying to figure out
how somebody would order something is like an interesting Peak into their brain um and sometimes you're super right and sometimes like why would you put that higher than that you know it's also I think go ahead s go ahead I think it's really I KN I knew this was going to Happ okay I I'll go first um a lot of the funs like I said there's a lot of just random outof pocket things in there that you would never even think about to talk about yeah and I I'd love it similar to where z uh for the first game you think you know me uh you get insight into how people view you right and it's really fun because you watch this discussion amongst the group happening they're like like I remember one was like well she was very clean and organized so he's going to want this and but someone's like no but he also hates this thing and they're all arguing what order they should go in and it's just like really fun to watch this discussion about you and so everyone kind of gets their turn to feel kind of special for a moment like you're in a spotlight and the whole group gets to talk about you and you're just kind of listening and watching and then uh and you get it's like celebration if you get it right or then uh you have a quick discussion afterward about why they're wrong about the or why you pick the order that you picked but yeah and it's really simple to play too yeah and did you like it Phil have Phil been very quiet yeah I mean I I don't know what more I can contribute to this conversation since you guys really hit
all the points that I thought about this game um so well done to you guys y us yay all right uh another game uh for our list is it's kind of a fun Story by pop house Collective uh this is the one they they gave me uh a year and a half ago and I'm like I later I'll s him my notes like sorry it took so long but we finally covered it um this is a strategic this is the tagline on a box a strategic storytelling game that lays all your cards on the table uh and it's a really cool looking box it's just like this rainbow kind of like uh almost trippy technol kind of Blass of music of colors and stuff at uh you but uh so basically you get a bunch of cards uh and they're all story cards and the game is about encouraging people to tell stories uh that about things that happen in their life uh and then the game G play is sort of like uh there's things where you can either uh ask a neighbor you can uh play a card if like let's say I asked Christina a story about something and then uh about a particular subject matter and then Phil's like oh I have an even better story then he could play a card to sort of also add his story to the mix and then everyone could kind of decide or the person who played the card kind of decide which story they like better uh but here's an example a couple examples like one what story from your life comes to mind when you hear fire uh like the word fire and so you can tell like I don't I don't think I have a good story for that but it's like some might
have been like oh yeah like I once burned down my house when I was a kid or something like that did anyone do that here I think I had a neighbor like two doors down their house was like burning down it was crazy the whole house burned down I don't think the whole house but it was on fire and there was like fire trucks and I was like a child I was like I have no idea what's happening right now I mean I did but I don't yeah but why that happened yeah I and some of these cards are like everyone gets the answer uh like tell us the worst gift you have ever received or uh this one is uh tell us about a time you heard someone gossiping about you and like you think back like I have a story about that I was like standing right behind the person there talking crap about me and I totally called them out on it uh but but so it's like it's fun so we the four of us played this one night and it just led to a ton of stories like we're just all thinking back so I think these story cards seem really well written and really well thought out because it's like oh yeah this did happen to me or I know someone that this happened too or hey we experienced this thing and you start relating stories and you start hearing all these stories from all your friends uh and things that happened in the past they're like oh my God it's like and then because there're stories not just like an opinion on something uh so the first game like you think you know me you're when the the mermaid versus uh unicorn story like that's a fun conversation one way but these
stories are like actual events and it's a lot of T you're like oh wow like I can't believe you went through that and then you start sharing stories like that so and that's the whole point of the game so yeah the great thing about this game is the mechanic where like you said when someone tells a story someone else can say oh I have an even better story because a lot of the times with games like this some else gets asked a question and you just think like I want to talk about that question too but I don't want to make it all weird it's not my turn so the fact that this game gives you the space allows you the space to do that I think was the the best part of it for me yeah and then they also have what what's kind of cool is there I forgot what the card is called but there's a card in there that you could play that's sort of like almost like a safe word if you're like you someone asks you a question and it's like very triggering and it's like a bad time in your life and you're like I don't really want to talk about you can just play it and it's like no explan needed we just move on and pick something else all together so uh I thought that was kind of a cool I don't think we needed it right for our group but uh but it's good I think it was a couple times oh was it oh yeah okay yeah I don't really I'm trying to remember the game play of it the the game of it um but I really just remember that it was just it sparked a lot of stories from all of us and we didn't really use the the card that was like oh I have a better story to try to to try to get this card I think we all just wanted to like talk about what that's that conversation or that um card was
talking about um so they really did have really good questions in there that you wanted to talk about these things yeah I think in general like a lot of these these getting to know you games like the it's it's just there to like I hate using the word lubricate but like lubricate Christina somebody was using it the other day and now it's stuck in my head like a social lubricant um anyway I like then don't use it it's up to you whether you want to use that word or not I can't help it um and so it's like you know it's it's a nice to have some guidelines a little bit or like you know some rails that you're following so you know it Sparks things that you wouldn't typically think about and that leads to sort of more interesting discussions but game playwise I don't know if any of them I would call like a game they're more like activities and that's perfectly fine too you know they're just I was never in any of them trying to like really win you know so dungeon feelings is the out of the ones we talked about is the only one that has like a a proper board game built into it where the other ones like I think all of them we eventually stop playing by the rules and just start reading more cards like just to like extend the conversation and stuff you know and to lubricate everything uh get things running nice and smooth and sexy W yeah do you take that too far Sho too far
okay and what is your topic Phil and Raina so today we wanted to talk about social deduction games CU we did a lot of social games recently and social deduction is such a big and popular genre not just in the tabletop space but just in the general board gaming space um and I wanted to get y'all's opinions on whether or not you like them if they're for you cuz for me personally I'm not the biggest fan of them so at this snow treat that we've been talking about um typically those are the games that get played later in the night because everyone's winding down it's not very gamery and most of the time I will just say you know what I I love you guys I think I'm good and then I just go to sleep on the couch which is impressive because everyone's screaming and shouting she's just like out I don't know how you yeah I don't know how you could relax with everyone playing games in the same room oh feels a loud snore but um I will say though so I sat out of a game of Blood on the clock tower which is I'll probably let one of you guys explain it better but it was really entertaining for me to watch and that was probably one of the first times I got fomo from not doing a social deduction game which is crazy yeah well let's talk about that one first then uh so our friend Brian at the our snow Retreat we call it snow kind but it's just like a like a group of us like 17 of us I think went um and it's it's similar to the old uh werewolf or Mafia style of games where there's a narrator uh and that was Brian and then he has this giant grimoire this book of like where he's hiding all this
information and then they give you uh a menu and then on this menu is like all the possible roles that are in this game which I thought was a really cool Edition because I never when we used to run werewolf that we never had anything like that so then you're looking at all these possible roles and then people are like you know you close your eyes at night you'll get a assigned a chip or you draw a chip and then you find out what your role is and you're either on the majority kind of town folk team or you're part of the evil team which is like a small portion of the overall group and they're trying to stay hidden and then it's like if you haven't played these games before there's like a dis during the day you're discussing who's suspicious who knows what and then you vote to execute somebody hope the towns people are trying to execute the hidden evil team the minions and the devil uh while the minions and devil are trying to stay hidden and they're hoping they'll execute an innocent person instead and at night the evil people wake up and the devil will pick someone to kill and things like that but there's more powers like you find out which of your neighbors are evil or if one or two of them are evil or you might be protected from the devil or you get a free shot to kill somebody in the game uh and things like that so that there all the roles will have different little powers that give you hints of information but a lot of is just like just talking and discussing trying to figure out so so who's lying or so but yeah so it's definitely like a way more gamery version than of werewolf um I typically don't like social detection games either you know um because especially when we play we used to play
werewolf a bunch with our group long time ago like over 10 years ago and it just never felt like a game to me it just felt like lots of yelling uh based off of nothing and then I'm like ooh I see this in your face so you know we're g to kill you and it was just not like a game to me but I what I did like about blood on the clock tower is because everybody H has a potential role you know all the possible roles and there's a logic behind it then it then it adds to that sort of deduction part which I really like um it's very clever in how it's designed because even when people know something like um there's a fortune teller who can know that like um like I think or was the empath whatever one of them they know like their neighbors like what how many of them are evil or something like that right on the evil team but but there's always one towns person that the narrator has decided will appear evil to you even though they are good so there's always a little bit enough doubt that you can play on depending on what team you're on so um it's really fascinating I really enjoyed my first two plays of it and the third one was too much for me so I discovered I have a limit on how much Social deduction I can do in a day so two in a row was too much for me personally I'm trying to remember cuz I've only only played it once but I I can't remember what the difference is between Mafia and blood on the clock tower was it just there were more roles and there was also a narrator that kind of dictated the flow of the game or was like what what
did Blood on the clock tower add that Mafia didn't have I think the narrator the Storyteller um is supposed to be like the dead body that dies for there's a lot more control on that person to like make the game fun right they they don't participate but they can like they decide like oh if somebody is a drunk they're getting bad information cuz they're drunk and then they can decide what kind of bad information to give to make it a more entertaining scenario so there's a lot of shaping of the game that happens where in Mafia in Mafia and normal werewolf um the narrator is there just to like tell people when to go to sleep and stuff like that and They Don't Really control the type of information that people are getting so a good Storyteller can really really make this game really fascinating and interesting uh we played it three times with our friend Brian as a Storyteller and evil always WS so I don't know what that says about him but that happened yeah yeah and I think uh the story teller could balance the game right if it's like oh one team is clearly dominating and they're on the role sort of like a GM uh in a role play more GM where they like okay I'm going to alter things and I'm going to shape it versus yeah in werewolf when I was narrating it I was just like I'm just kind of speeding things along and helping keep the pace of the game going which this person in Clock Tower does as well but and I think the other thing is like that menu that sheet of like here are all the roles in play helps a lot because then uh it's
easier for people to be like oh I if I need to pretend to be somebody else I have a list of what's possible versus the old games this is a simple little thing but it's like oh they have to remember what roles are in play uh versus this is all like on the paper and every role is unique like in werewolves too there's normal werewolf and I I think Mafia is the same way where there's just some generic PL vanilla villagers that have zero Powers uh uh and but this one like every evil person has a unique power every Town's folk has a unique power some are more interesting than others some give you more things to do than others some are very passive but you have something where yeah that's not true were like some just sometimes you draw a plain Village in werewolf Li and you're like okay now I'm just lying or or or trying to figure out who's lying and you have nothing really to do or to go off of other than what other people are saying and in this game like everyone has something yeah it's so surprising that just like one player sheet can make a huge difference on the game like being able to know every single role and lie about any role in the game possible even though role might not be included um and it's also just like great cuz it's a full sheet so you can just like cover your face if you ever need to you have no Poker Face yeah yeah this so the first time we played at the CL like our snow trip basically we all stayed pretty much in our seats and we're just talking to neighbors and like you know talking across the group it was
a really big group of like I don't know 10 11 people um it really interesting cuz the next time we played it um we played with the mostly the same group a couple new people here and there and uh there were a lot more like sidebar conversations where people were getting up and like oh can I talk to you and like specifically and ask them about like you know what they might know what they might be so it was a very different sort of feel um but the the sheet is still super helpful like I I had to be evil um that first time of the second play and you can still logic out really weird events like through the deduction of it because uh in that game our friend Henry was the demon first and he just got executed the very first day cuz he sucked at being the demon let's just be real he was really bad at it and so Shu and I were the Minions on the evil team and we were like oh crap what do we do right um so Shu was the backup minion basically if the demon dies he immediately becomes the demon so that happened the game still went on we're like going I'm like chilling because I'm this minion whose power is just that oh when I'm in there's these two sort of weirdo independent Outsiders that come into the game I didn't have to do anything so I was like okay cool she's the demon no big deal then the very next night he started being real suspicious and then in the night I find out that like he's dead he and then I became the demon somehow and I was like how did this happen and so I had to look at the menu and I figured out the only way that happens is if the demon self-sacrifices
and kills himself then any remaining minions becomes a demon that was the only way that would happen and by the end of the game somebody else on the town's person side had figured out the exact sequence I still won but it was like pretty amazing that they figured out that's actually what happened so so the goal of the game is to just kill the demon right if you just kill the demon and no specific minion power makes it so that a demon gets resurrected then you actually just win right you just need to find the demon yeah so like or the the demon they want to win by basically killing off most of the time spoke uh and so like in this situation like TR said there's a logic to it where now they know uh the okay if we killed Henry and we think he's a demon but the game is still going on that means the either the demon woman I think or the Scarlet woman was is in play because that means a new demon is now in play so you kind of start to logic some of this stuff out which is way more interesting than normal world yeah I was just mad at Shu because like I got left by myself being on the evil it was a smart smart play by me I really like that cuz um I the first time we played it I was convinced one of the guys was just evil he might not necessarily be a demon but like as the town folk people you just need to kill off some bad people so that you're left with more good people than bad and yeah
being able to just even if you execute and the game continues it still feels like you're you're making progress as Town spoke um which I thought that actually is one of my favorite things about blood and the clock tower that even when you die you're still in it you can still discuss you can still talk about what you know and you get one ghost vote that could really be important to you know swinging the vote in a particular way so I think all of that part is done really well but I just can't play it twice in a row I discovered because I get real aggravated and uh PE the Ugly Part of Me comes out so yeah I was evil two games in a row and it was basically 4 hours of lying to all my friends and then I was I didn't enjoy that part I was like I I I need a break from this game because it's like it was emotionally taxing for me to lie that much I don't like lying to begin with I'm like 4 hours like an entire night of just lying to everyone looking in their eyes and trying to pretend to be something but all right we'll move on to another game uh another new game we just got recently that's new to the genre is uh from skybound games Invincible Escape From Mars uh so this is based on the Invincible comic book which has also turned into an Amazon Prime animated series about the a kind of a more realistic take on superheroes which we've heard before for like the boys and the Watchmen but this is like Ultra smart writing Ultra gruesome and violent uh really cool we love the show uh and then so in this there are heroes or astronauts that are trying to
accomplish some missions and then there's these seids which are these kind of alien parasitic uh things that might infect some of us so there's not necessarily like a seids character they're just normal characters who get infected by seids and then so each turn you're either playing a card to help with the group Challenge and then uh like other games you might have played like secret Hitler or Battle Star Galactica you could put in fake because these cards are played face down and shuffled so if there's a wrong card in there that doesn't help the challenge uh you might not uh you won't know exactly who did that who messed it up uh you might you'll know suspicions and you kind of have an idea from this group of players someone in there got infected uh but basically the seid players the seids might grow in power that more and more of them might come out and then uh you will they're trying to sabotage these missions whereas the astronauts or hero players are trying to succeed in these missions and if neither one wins by the seventh round then you enter a rocket ship and then Escape Mars and then if all clean people are on the ship they win uh if any seid gets on the ship then they all lose because then they all get infected that this a basic premise um but each C what I like about this game uh and this game was really divisive because I I I know Christina has a very different opinion on this but every card you have has three purposes so you get a a hand of four cards and then one top of the card can help you complete the challenge the symbols and color match uh
the next part of it is a there's a picture of a resource that you can play face down to help a character get the supplies that they need to get onto the ship at the end of the game and then you can lie about those you can put fake ones in for both of those things and at the bottom of each card is a power like look at a random card on a player's hand so you can try to sus out who's a seid uh you can uh maybe look at a face down resource card and see if they're the right resource so it there's constant powers that give you an idea so rather than traditional social deduction games where specific players with specific roles have specific Powers everyone now has a chance to discover little bits and uh parts of the information so that's the part I really like but I'll let Christina talk about why you did not like the game so much um yeah I mean my main issue is your motivation when you are either a non seid or a seid like it's it's very easy like every round instead of like an execution phase or whatever you would accuse or point fingers at somebody think is a seid and that person gets cleansed like if they have any seid cards you they discard them and now they're human again or heroes or whatever if they have any in their hand and they have a KNE in their hand um the way that it's it's designed there's always almost always at least one seid card that's still out there because there's always going to be reinfection in each round so you may have been clean before and then you get infected in the next draw basically so there's there's a
baseline seid somewhere out there but at the same time it's like well what's my motivation like I yes I'm supposed to be sabotaging things but if I'm suspicious enough then I get cleaned and now now I join the like big human team right so it was hard for me to really get into it um I was I was playing a hero this last time who got an extra draw in the beginning of the round um which means a higher chance of becoming the segid again so I became the segid like two times got cleansed both times and uh it's just like while I was a seg I guess I was trying to sabotage and I played it true to that but it just never felt like it made sense to me um in the big picture so that's my issue with it yeah it definitely feels like even if you are a seid and you choose not to sabotage the mission you can then kind of claim yourself as the seid and just ask to be cleansed and just try to become on the more winning team I don't know if it was specifically because of our game that we played we cleansed a lot of the seid team out um but it feels like if you are a seid and then you play corre like you go ahead and allow the mission to complete um and then you're just like cleanse me please um that felt interesting um I don't know if that's like the intended part of the game play if you want to do it that way
or if um what am I trying to say I don't think it's intended maybe it's one of those things where you know just for the sake of playing the game don't play it that way you know just if you're a SE with just cuz if you start being like cleanse me cleanse me that takes the whole point out of the game like why you playing this game then yeah but I understand that like if you that as a mo that's not your motivation so it's hard to get behind it gameplay wise yeah cuz I still trying to play it true to it but I wasn't really working super hard to protest because I was like well the human team is doing a really good job cleaning things so I would rather join that team you know so I don't know yeah and the last game we played we uh I I had uh this power my power for my hero was that I get to draw a random card and look at it and then our friend n from somebody's hand yeah from somebody's hand again they could have face down resource cards that also have hidden Sid powers and in which casee they don't even know seid until the last phase of the game um I drew from our friend nam's hand one of four cards and I drew the one seid card so I got super lucky one in four chance I caught him and then immediately cleansed him and then I did the same to fill a couple rounds later one in three chance I think of catching him and I caught it so I got two Super Lucky draws where I happen to see the exact carard I needed to see true so the astronauts slh hero team was doing
really well in that game cuz I I was like imediately just by pure random chance found the seids and then I became a seid right at the very end before the astronauts won so then I lost and I was like what I was like I was doing so well so the switching of the teams is a weird thing because we we've also had other friends who are like this is kind of strange like the game play I think was good but it's just the switching of the teams and not uh and possibly being like now all of a sudden you're clean again or now all a sudden you're seid uh by random chance was uh that was what kind of was weird to a lot of people I mean thematically it makes sense because it's like this parasite spreading so sometimes you're unlucky you know um but it it takes away some of the the decision and the strategy so um yeah yeah well real quick we're going to we're running out of time but I just want to let's do some rapid fire other uh social dedu notable social deduction games uh Raina do you have any others that you particularly like I think my favorite one is um n of the Ninja which is published by I believe otherwise games um it's like classic you have one house versus the other and you also have a ronin who's trying to survive and I I like the gameplay aspect of it there these power cards that you can play so you can get more information but then each round um your alliance changes so I think it keeps things nice and fresh IO you Phil um I'll just talk about the OG that I know it's uh the resistance um like the cyberpunk version there's also an Avalon version which is like medieval um but that was the first
uh social deduction game that I played and I just like fell in love with it I love like lying maybe not necessarily lying but I like figuring out what people are and trying to read people and what roles they are um but yeah that that game plays very similarly to the uh Invincible game so when I got introduced to Invincible um I was just like oh yeah this is basically like the resistance where you are trying to sabotage missions and when I was the seid I was like oh maybe I'll just like try to let this go to pretend that I'm good but that was what kind of threw me off was uh just even though you're bad you can try to pretend to be good to like be in the good team and then sabotage in the end um but yeah that's what I build up to it yeah mhm shoot uh real quick the uh ones we love talking about uh there's two games that are basically like 20 Questions meets where W that's the one I was going to say I I'll let you talk about the two those two uh and then the other one is two rooms and a boom uh which is it's a bit harder to organize because you need a certain size group and you kind of need people who are know how to play these games but now in separate rooms but basically there's a blue Team and Red Team blue team has the president on its team red team has the bomber on its team you mix them all up
you're assign these and then you're put into two rooms so each room might have a mix of blue and red teams uh and you go through several rounds where people are voting and trying to get the mayor of each room to send people to the other room so you're trading people back and forth there are other powers and other roles but uh eventually after five rounds what you're trying to do the blue team wants the president not in the same room as the bomber where the red team wants the bomber in the same room as the president because they're trying to kill the president uh and so uh it's it's really cool because it's very energetic uh everyone's standing up and talking and having secret conversations and trying to gang up and form different majorities and then at the end there's always this exciting moment of reveal of like all right where's the president where's the bomber and then like half the group will cheer you uh but again you need the exact right group in circumstances to get that working right but that's a really cool game is that game just kind of like one round and you're just talking to everyone and then at the end you decide which room to go in I've never multiple there's a m there's multiple sendings of people to other rooms so you know when even like you each group decides who goes into the other room so there's more information gathering well there's a mayor each room has a mayor who gets to decide like okay round one we're sending two people over their mayor is going to send two people over to our room and then so everyone should but then uh you can overthrow the mayor like if it's like we don't want this person to be a mayor let's vote and overthrow so there's lot all this manipulation to kind of get your
situation right and then you're like telling people like I'm on a red team but you might be lying to try to get information there's neutral roles as well that are just kind of in there they're TR like there's one where I think they're trying to find their partner in this whole group there's a sniper who's trying to kill somebody in the group so uh we should play it sometime it's like such a fascinating interesting uh take on this genre yes please uh and then the one that I always feel happy to play which which is rare for me for a social detection game is uh werewords I really really like werewords um I feel there's a simpler version called The Insider that I'm not sure about the timing they say they both came up with it around the same time but essentially it's like werewolf mixed with 20 questions and The Insider or in were wordss um the werewolf they know who what this magic secret word is however they don't want it to be obvious that they know what it is and they're trying to sort of guide the rest of the group maybe with some like um confusing questions to guide them away from correctly guessing the word while the town wants to guess the word um so it's like a very interesting little take on it where there's more of a game to it there's more like figuring out this word and then like who has been asking sort of weird questions that or like taking up too much time or things like that so um I like the structure of having a game um outside of the social deduction so I really like were words yeah you two are big fans of were wordss too right for the same reasons that listed I think the big reason I don't like social deduction games cuz I am
such a horrible liar so it's not fun for me I'm out quickly I remember when we were playing Invincible um Christina and I both played a card to play play to a mission and I was seid so I sabotaged it and when it was all revealed Christina said well I did the right one so Raina must be the seid and I just looked at her and I just smiled I can't even I can't even defend myself right now yeah I feel like the word games she's a bigger word game than I am I'm terrible with words and reading and all that but being able to like lie to people I feel like is an easier time for me or like reading people don't look at me like that being a not necessarily lie but just like lie and yeah maybe maybe maybe you have a better poker face that's what it is yeah I I also love playing poker so I think like being able to read people and hiding your own role is like my favorite part of it and I also just in those games I like to talk a lot so um that helps uh yeah so Phil's like I don't know the alphabet but I can lie yeah exactly I lie about reading knowing about about knowing so thanks so much for joining us Phil and Reena where can people follow you and what you're up to yeah you can follow us on Tik Tok atom aboard games that's the only um social media platform that we're really active on right now and I'm bringing Phil into a lot more
videos so if you want to see more Phil like someone that we saw to teacha con they were like more Phil please a that always felt nice yeah and a you know a lovely grateful courtesy to our editor Mike Zipkin um and if board game trivia is your jam and you haven't tried our board game quiz show back from BG gcon it is up so you can give it a try I forced our whole cabin to play it one morning also so Phil and Rea had a fun time with that I hope they're also Veterans of the game show of the borgan quiz show the actual quiz show yes they like dressed up for it they were ready it was it was a good showing yeah exactly and so please give us a like And subscribe if you haven't already now you can stop listening and go play a game bye bye bye