Earth, Footprints, Empire's End Reviews - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm going to be sharing my thoughts on these three board games we have Empire's end we have Earth and we have Footprints but before I get started on my quick reviews of these games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor Kender do.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so let's start with Empire's end this is by John declair and illustrated by konai Moria it takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play and accommodates two to four players now generally speaking I've not been a huge fan of any John declair designs but when I heard that he was making a larger strategy game all built around a mechan mechanism made famous in a game called no thanks which is one of my favorite filler games of all time and although I love that mechanism I was a little bit skeptical if a a more involved game could really be built off the foundation of such a simple idea where each round something negative will come up for auction if you want to put it that way and you as the players are bidding not to take that particular punishment and in this game that punishment comes in the form of your city being burnt down so each round um one of these buildings in depending on the row or the order in the row that um You're Building sit in one of those will be destroyed set on fire and you'll potentially be losing victory points so you actually start this game with most
of your victory points and as the game progresses you are losing them unless you can keep them alive essentially and you're going to do that by placing these tokens on these um on these negative um punishments and as soon as you put a token down onto it it'll go on to the next player where they can do the same but the twist is that as people are bidding not to take these punishments the kitty will build up to a point where the resources on that particular punishment more inviting than taking the punishment itself so you know you are actually taking the resources and getting it for yourself and in this game unlike the original no thanks you don't just have one currency you have three different types of tokens that you are using which have their own uses in different phases of the game so for example you get these hammers that can be used to repair your building so sometimes it has enough hammers on there where you can actually afford you can afford to just rebuild that building anyway but bearing in mind that you only have a certain amount of opportunities to do that throughout the game so you cannot take too many of them or you can even get these kind of um War axes which you're using in this kind of blind bidding system to get some bonus points so I do like the fact that you know you have more than one currency here that you need to consider and of course with everything you're giving away you are putting on the lap of your opponent to use against you later which could actually be used for something even worse for them or or better for you so you need to be careful about when you um when you use these tokens and sometimes
you have to be prepared to take that punishment um to avoid taking a worse one later on and because as the game goes on you actually have potential to move these tokens around in an order that suits you because the actual positioning of these can matter and based on adjacency bonuses sometimes you can take um take the hit on a building that isn't worth too many points that is worth but in your opponent's Arrangement it could be worth a hell of a lot of points uh to them so I really do like that kind of multi-use system and the way that you start the same you end up in completely uh different um kind of positions so yeah definitely um kind of mechanisms within mechanisms here without being too um too confusing I suppose um I suppose if there's any kind of criticism I have about this game is that it can be a little bit repetitive um because you are pretty much Start stopping doing the same thing you know passing on these buildings or the sort of these these punishments um but another thing I do like about this even if you do take a punishment and have to burn one your buildings down they do come with these little bonuses that you can tuck in beneath beneath another building so that is a somewhat of a Bittersweet decision you're making because even though you're taking a punishment you can get a kind of a reward by tucking it under another card which can increase your engine to do other things such as giving you more passing power um or giving you even endgame points or in-game points or even like improving your economy by getting more resources so yeah lots of different things going on here based on the foundation of that um simple mechanism I
generally like blind bidding mechanisms as well as I mentioned when it comes to that combat phase you are you know blindly selecting a a number of um tokens in your hand you are aiding them at the same time and potentially getting some bonus points and of course sometimes you can be overspending on that sometimes you can be under spending um so you need to be sure not to be wasting um too many of those um blind bids so all in all um this game definitely um worked for me I thought it was a lot of fun but again I am a big fan of the original uh no thanks anyway which is kind of a boiled down version of this game which really gets to the Crux of everything going on here but it is um again it's a game in its own right but you can definitely see how it is been inspired by that original one now another thing I would say from an objective standpoint I think some players might find this game a little bit demoralizing and maybe a bit punishing at times because again you are starting with pretty much all of your points point and you're getting battered um from or throughout the duration of the game now I personally like that because it makes the game feel different but if you don't like that or you know you want to have constant positive feedback then this might not be the game for you so you know for example if you don't like games like in the EUR the dragon you probably won't like this one either for that same reason but apart from that and again apart from that maybe a little bit of a repetition factor and maybe going on a few rounds too long I I think this is a really enjoyable and fun game that um again uses that mechanism to a high standard
and elevates it really um while I still believe there is a place for the original no thanks in the collection because it is such a pure uh filler game this one again takes it to that kind of lightweight medium lightweight Euro feel uh but it still stays true to that war core mechanism with a few other things built on that foundation so I can give this one a soft recommendation I would give it a accommodation of around seven out of 10 um again if you like that no thanks mechanism then I'm pretty sure you are going to like this one next up let's talk about Earth by Maxim tardif published by inside up games this is a one to five player game that takes 45 to 90 minutes to play uh on average and I'm certainly late to the party on this one this was one of the Colossal hits from 2023 it is a card driven engine builder this kind of Tableau building Style game as you are building a grid of 16 cards this 4x4 grid here and all these cards work uh in different ways you're trying to score as many points in a ton of different ways here so this is definitely a point salid cell game where you are given so many options and unlike the um aforementioned game um Empires end this game is all about kind of positive feedback no matter what you do in this game it feels good because you're always getting drip fed points and actions so we'll go into the cards in a bit but what I do like about this game is the core mechanism where on your turn you'll
choose one of four actions which are all very simple in their own right such as drawing and playing cards um taking more resources to P those cards in the first place um getting these kind of um Sprouts that you can put onto cards to get points as well as getting growth or drawing cards any kind of combination of those actions but whenever you take an action everybody else will get a slightly weak version of that action so if you're familiar with games like Puerto Rico like race for the Galaxy um then this game has that in space and I really do like that mechanism and it adds a lot of player engagement into the game where when even if it's not your turn you get to do stuff and following on from that what I love about this is that because you can see all these actions are colorcoded whenever you take that specific colored action all of the cards in your existing Tableau with that color signature on it will be triggered so as the game goes on you can imagine you're taking longer and more grandiose turns getting more and more bang for your buck now what I do like about this game as well is this kind of struggle of keeping everything balanced because again even if when it's not your turn you're getting stuff you want to be making sure that you have that room to expand into for example as I said if you're getting these Sprout tokens which are essentially just points you need to have empty slots on your cards in order to take those Sprouts or risk losing them so you want to be as efficient as you can and be making sure that you are you know
stocking up every opportunity you can because every Sprout is going to be worth a point and you do have this multiuse card system as well where you can kind of um compost these cards and put them on a scoring pile and basically um do away with the abilities on the cards uh themselves and within the cars themselves there is a lot of forward planning and doing things in the right order knowing which cards you can hold on to which are going to synergize with each other knowing which ones to get rid of and all this time you are working towards so many different objectives going on at the same time so you have public objectives like these here where you are you want to be the first player to achieve that and get more points than the people who follow you and you've also got kind of um objectives that are not based on a sense of urgency but will score you points at the end of the game uh you've got personal objectives which are on your own player sheet personal abilities and powers and so on so every game here feels very different because you're always aiming towards uh different things and the variability in terms of the setup is absolutely huge I believe there are thousands of combinations that can pop up just through randomization which again will completely dictate the feel of the game and might change the way you approach it so yeah it's all in all it's um a very uh again game that gives you a lot of positive feedback that again that piggybacking mechanism of following up on other actions is a very it offers a very satisfying um experience with lots again lots of positive feedback lots of options and even conflicting things uh
that you need to consider because sometimes one objective might work against another objective and some of the cards themselves have objectives on based on the orientation of the grid itself so some might say well you get x amount of points if it's adjacent to this card or this card or if you have these particular types of cards in a particular row or column you'll get more points which as again more conflict into the different things going on and it's all about squeezing as many points as you can out of the game as possible now that being said um I do think at times especially if you're playing with less season Gamers who haven't played so many games um the amount of information that's thrown at you can feel overwhelming at times because sometimes you just have a huge hand of cards and you just don't know what you want to do um so bear that in mind if you don't want to have so much information dumped to you um at once and another thing that's probably more personal is that sometimes I feel the game is a little bit loose at times it feels like it's just giving you constant points and you it's quite difficult not to do well um at this one now I understand that if you're going to play it more efficiently you're of course you're going to beat somebody who's not doing that um but sometimes I feel like I'm just playing cards because I can I'm going to get a bunch of points anyway I could have played this card to get an extra point or two but am I that worried about it when you're going to score know hundreds of points at the end um of the game so maybe for my own personal taste I would have liked it to be a little bit of a tighter um engine and maybe the decision space a little bit more brought in but I do certainly
feel this is um an enjoyable game and I can certainly see why so many people have got so much out of it so you know these last couple of years games like um Arc Nova have done really well for me this is one of well when I played this game I was instantly well instantly brought back feelings of our Nova but I think I prefer Earth um I think the gameplay is quite similar in terms of its quality but I think the reasons I like Earth a bit more is because it is so much easier to um set up it's actually a really quick setup in this game H it plays a lot quicker you know you're looking probably at least half the time in order to uh to play this one which is nice so you get a lot of game played here in around 90 minutes maximum which is always a good thing and you know if you like games such as the aforementioned I race for the galaxies or terraforming Mars Aries Expedition you know there's a lot of games like that I think this one is probably the best one out of the bunch so that goes to show that it's you know a really good uh design now for the um you know the Loosey gooiness of it I'm not sure if it's going to be a long-term keeper for me but I certainly do not have any reservations to give it a recommendation and it's definitely going to get a a Chairman's Commendation and I can certainly see why it has been such a big hit for so many different Gamers and the final game I'm talking about today is Footprints by chili fox games this one accommodates one to six players and takes 30 to 60 Minutes to play now this actually reminds me of a
game of years past really it's such a simple game and a simple concept where you will be trying to Traverse this board made up of all these hexes and different terrain types now you're going to start on the left hand side of the board and as the game goes on generally speaking you'll be going to the right hand side of the board and by playing these cards which will let you move across different types of terrain now you're going to get rewarded by reaching the far end quicker than your opponents because if you do it faster you are going to get more points however there is an incentive to do other things whilst on Route such as collecting uh these resources unlocking these abilities on your player board and even unlocking endgame scoring criteria um which can be a huge factor in determining who wins the game or not now the cards in cards themselves in this game are quite interesting because it will show you which terrain types you can go through however the amount of terrain types of that type you can go through is dictated by your own player board which you'll be upgrading as the game progresses so for example you might be able to move through two of these ice spaces but as the game goes on you can up it up to you know 10 spaces so you're really flying through that particular terrain type but because the bord is modular um you need to decide when to use those particular cards but this game has something I don't think I've ever seen before is that often on these cars you are given more than one terrain type um and you can actually split them as you see fit so it might say you know go
through your ice type and then you can go through one uh grass type and then carry on with your remaining movement on your um ice type so you can actually subdivide those cards which can be quite difficult to track but I do think mechanically speaking it's a really interesting um concept and it's a you know it's an interesting decisions to try and map out especially because each card in this game has a dual purpose because not only can you use it for the movement itself you can discard that card and up your engine on usually another terrain type so there's a bit of give and take here you know which cards you want to keep hold of in order to move which cars you want to discard with hope of moving on a different train type a bit later on and because the deck in this game is so finally balanced those decisions can really matter and can determine whether you're going to reach the end of the track or not so I I do love that consequence of your early actions really mattering uh in your later uh actions and you always feel like you're moving forward here and building your engine up but again the the sense of urgency is important because you want to get to certain spots before your opponents do so I generally like games that have a race aspect to them but that race aspect isn't the be all and end all in the game and you do actually have free reign to do different approaches here because although again the race aspect is a big part of the game I've seen players win this game without making the end at all or even getting anywhere near it so again you're not pige and hold to do what the game
tells you to do you can win in lots of different ways uh here there's some good variability as well as not only is the track modular and you have variable endgame objectives which just plug into the board itself and again will massively change the way that you approach to the game and each player is also given a unique set of cards which only you will have in that game which will give you quite a game breaking power and all of those are really interesting in their own rights and you'll just kind of have to take my word um at face value um in Con well concerning uh that so yeah I like the forward planning here you know mapping out your hand I'm not being overwhelmed by decisions but still having interesting decision decisions to make and because you only have a small hand of cards at any time you know some you might be forced to take a route that you weren't really planning to do so um simply because you do not have the cards in your hand in order to do exactly what you want so um that actually helps the game rather than hinder it um because again you have to work with what you have and make some tactical decisions as well as strategic ones there's also some kind of more more short-term sacrifice for long-term game in terms of hitting at these fire tokens so sometimes you might want to divert off track and collect these fire cards which will really give you powerful options to piggy back off your simple basic actions as well so again very pure game here just play cars move along the map and um collect things along the way put deposit things on the map to get some engine your engine built up and hopefully reach the end as well and unlock a an endgame
scoring bonus and that sense of urgency does shine through because everything is scarce here you know if you and your opponent are both going for the same endgame objective then um you going to be making sure that you are moving a lot quicker than your opponent does I think the thing I really impresses me most about this game is how delicately those decks are balanced you just the perfect amount of movement cards of each type to reach the end if you play well enough and maybe maybe make a few stops on the way but you're not going to have that much leeway so unlike Earth this game is not Loosey Goosey this game is very precisely engineered to um you know not make you achieve too much but still give you the option to achieve enough to feel uh satis ified now my one real nitpick of this game is the fact that you do have these objective cars that you can try and Achieve throughout the game which will score you a healthy amount of points should you wish to take that route now it does have that ticket to ride mechanism where if you do not complete them you will suffer negative points which is fine uh but the thing I don't like about that is the fact that through sheer luck you could end up drawing a card that you'll instantly be able to achieve and score quite a healthy the amount of points so I call that the kind of takenoko syndrome where you've already achieved the objective card that you've yet to draw and that could be enough to win the game or not because it's not a terribly high-scoring game um anyway but this one despite those small nitpicks it really did impress me I'm quite surprised this one's flown under the radar to the extent uh that it has because I know
that some of these designs are quite well regarded and well respected but maybe it's it's more muted look and more throwback style mechanisms that aren't exactly you know um you know high energy they're not big Bo boisterous mechanisms that grab a lot of game's attention now these are a lot more subtle and a lot more kind of refined and a bit more kind of rained back mechanisms but they're ones that really do appeal to me because it shows a certain um design pedigree and a certain degree of being refined uh that really does impress me so another one that I think it's going to be accommodation for sure another around a 7 out of 10 uh for me in regards to footprint so you know all in all these three games have impressed me now these are three games I don't hesitate to give seven out of 10 ratings to which you know might not sound amazing um but to be honest I read give seven out of 10 out because I think those are the games that deserve attention and deserve praise so hopefully you've enjoyed my review of these three very different um strategy games from 20 uh 23 really enjoyed playing these and it go to show that great games are still being made um up to this date now if you have enjoyed enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye