Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 227: Shadi Torbey on inPatience

Transcript 1:01:31

It's ad break time. I'm proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. I'm personally very excited because CLGs has a springtime crowdfunding project on the way. They'll be publishing a revised edition of Jason Morning Stars the Blue Way, which you can hear about in episode 224 of this podcast. But for now, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz David from Beyond Solitire and this week we got a part of a very special guest, solo game legend Shotti Torb. He is the designer of the Oniverse series and also the owner of Impatience Games, uh, which is his own publisher. How you doing today, Shotti?

Fine. How are you?

I'm doing great. I'm super excited to finally talk to you. I feel like I've played a lot of your games for like 10 years. Uh, so it's it's fun to meet face to face.

Yeah, it's fun. I I've been writing to you and reading, you know, what you are writing, listening to your, you know, podcast, seeing your videos. So, it's Yeah. Uh, yeah. I couldn't say it's nice to put a face on the name because I I I knew your face from the videos, but it's nice to meet you and talk to you finally.

Absolutely. Um, so, uh, I mentioned that you are the creator of the Oniverse series. Uh, for people who don't know what that is, how would you describe it? I would say it's a it's a series of games that can be played solo or two-player cooperative. Um, and the games are somehow linked by um the fact that they have the same artist, the same designer, the same player count. Um, but I I still try to do a different game in each chapter. So it's not a variation on the same mechanism going from one title to to the other. Um there is no um order in which you should play the game. Um I try to um use a different game mechanism in each each one and they still will all come together in the final game of the series um which will be released in one year more than one one year and a half in in Essen next year 27.

And uh this game will also be a standalone game. So you won't need to play the other ones to to have it to you know to be able to to play it. But it will have some features that will allow you to connect um the games together and itself with the other games of the the collection.

Oh, that's new and very cool. Um so we can get back to that in a minute, but you know, when you first designed Oniim, did you have a sense that it was going to turn into a series this big or is that something that came later? maybe not this big, but from the very first day I I wanted to have a collection because it actually all started I I was in Berlin uh and I you know well we all know that game culture in Germany is very strong and so you can go uh in a lot of department stores and have quite an impressive um game board game I mean department not not only toys but also board games and I um as often when I I I I'm on tour, I was looking for solitary games and there were very very little at the time. I mean, I'm talking 2008 or 2007, maybe 2008 um almost 20 years ago. And I somebody had recommended me um Alabon from U Rosenber Rosenberg Bonanza series. It was even before he released um Agricola.

So, and and somebody told me there is one game in the series that is a one two player uh game. You can play it solo and um and so I bought it, played it, and I I really really liked it. It's it's it it is exactly what I was looking for in in this kind of situation. A portable small card game with very clever decision, a very neat, elegant design. And I I loved it and I was like, "Okay, tomorrow I'm going to go back to the same store and buy another game of the series." And then I the second after I was oh stupid this is the only game of the series of the Bonanza series that you can actually play solo. And then I thought wouldn't it be cool to have because as I said it it's quite a department store. They had all the Bonanza series and I was if only the whole series was playable solo and then I thought I should make a series of game playable solo. And so I started tinkering with ideas and I had two ideas this evening. One was you are in a labyrinth and you have to find doors and you are not alone. There is a menace of a certain kind with you, a threat. And the other idea was um there is a conclave of good and bad beings and they must not fight, they must find some sort of balance. So actually I had the ideas for the first two games of the series uh from the very first evening not the rest this would come uh later on but the idea

of a series was there from day one.

That's really cool. Um I'm very glad you decided to make a solo series. It's solo is like the hot thing now. You liked it before it was cool. Um, and so now with Ultimon on the way, uh, are you sure that it's the last one in the series? And what kind of led you to decide on that if it is?

I'm not sure it is the last one. I mean, there are two stuff I I want to avoid. I I want obviously to avoid killing and smothering ideas that I would have for the series by just saying, "Oh, no. I I I I gave my word it this is going to be the last one. So, I'm I'm kidding now. But what I want to avoid even more is this kind of feeling we all have with TV series and movie series that go on for too long where you think they should have stopped way before um this. And so I have ideas. Obviously, there are some titles in the Honverse that I removed from the series because I was totally unsatisfied with the two-player version. So, there would be the possibility to go on. If it goes on, it would probably be something else. Maybe a subseries, probably a different kind of box.

It has I think this series as it is has to stop. We had one big arc spanning almost 20 years. I think we we we have to say that's enough. So, Ultimon will, as I said, pull all the games together and that will be it for this type of ONverse games, I would say. But I love working with El and and obviously the ONverse is a very open setting. So, I'm not saying we will never make another Omniverse game after Ultimon, but we will certainly not make another one in this kind of box with the little figure and this I think we should move to something else. Otherwise, it's it really feels like, oh, and they did another season of this TV show. No, why?

You know, and yeah.

Yeah. I mean, that's fair, but that also leads to the exact followup questions I wanted. So, you mentioned there could be other Oniverse games. Um, do you ever feel a desire to make something that's not an Oniverse game, just a game by you that's in a different setting entirely? I could I could I mean now that I'm I I'm doing impatience games that are from other designers and that I'm working with other artists, I I have the satisfaction of of going other in other direction artistically. So um so I don't feel stuck in the universe. Would I feel stuck as a game designer if I had I don't know. I think it may be weird to to to say this. I I've said this a couple of time in my life. I always feel weird and a bit crazy by saying it is that game designs they have a will and a life on their own. So yes, you are the big I am the designer. I am the master of the universe. That's not entirely true. When you obviously you the first idea comes and then you develop it and then at at some point it is almost as if you were dealing with a living creature somehow that you cannot force into something else. So if I feel that a design would be better at home, a personal design obviously better at home outside of the honor, I would have no

trouble in saying I don't feel it as an omniverse game. If on the other side I feel it really belong it would it could belong to a sort of a subseries into the universe then maybe I will not block it just by thinking I want to do something else in my life. Um this this would be probably artificial. So

yeah. No, I think there's a lot to that. Um, I feel like sometimes I know that I'm doing something wrong in a game design because I'm trying to force it. If it feels wrong, like it's probably wrong. Um, and you know, one of my colleagues, Nick, loves to say the game wants X, Y, or Z. And he's absolutely right. Like it's it's a funny way to put it because like it doesn't want anything. It's not sentient. But like at the same time, that's absolutely correct. Like there are things that you can see that it feels right to put something there or take something away. So, you know, I feel like um this also, I guess, leads to larger questions about um I guess inspiration and kind of like going with the design. So, the first time you wanted to make an Oniverse game, you there was like a need that you were trying to fill. There was a a gap in the shelf.

Um but um you know, now where do your I guess inspirations come from? because that's no longer the issue, but you're also now like a fullyfledged game designer who's like out there making art. So, how do you know when you've got an idea that you need to do something about versus just kind of I should have an idea soon?

Maybe I was fortunate in in this matter. Um, I never relied on games to make money. And it it seem it seems maybe weird to say this. The series was always fortunate enough to be able to continue, but never fortunate enough that I thought I need to do a game this year just because I will get so much money out of it. And I never had the at the time I was working with Zman games they the games were always successful but never enough that I had my publisher calling me and saying we need a game for Christmas this year. What are you doing?

You know it was never this situation. So somehow you could say it's unfortunate obviously not to have the success of I don't know the ticket to ride series because I you know obviously my bank account would be much fuller now you know but in a way artistically it's very good because I was never forced to to do a game if if the idea came and I thought it was good and as we just said they have somehow a life on on their own. So if it didn't move forward enough, I could drop an idea easily without thinking, oh no, I should pursue this. And and one of the stuff I learned in game design because before designing Onarium, I tried for years to make an opera game, a game about opera. And I was fully unsuccessful in even making a good game, not even marketing it or signing it by a publisher. was way before. I mean, it was not even at that stage. And I learned a lot about not hammering and trying at all costs to have an idea developed into a game. And so this is why I I I could take this whole designing process of the whole series in a much cooler way. If it came, it came. And fortunately, it came. But even if it hadn't, it wouldn't have been such a tragedy. Uh, so yeah,

fair enough. Okay, I want to get back to opera, but first I want to talk about impatience. So, as you mentioned, you know, the first Onverse games came out from Zman.

Um, so what's just the sort of short version of the story behind you getting the rights to your games back and then starting your own, starting to publish them yourself?

Okay. Um I have to go back then to the basically the period of time where I was designing on.

Yeah.

My first idea was to already at this time found a game publishing a game publishing house. Uh, and I thought I I was going to do it only for the French um territories and I went to Essen looking for partners and this is why I met Zev Shazinger who was at the time owner and boss and founder of Zman games. was before he sold the company and um he offered me a a worldwide uh contract on the game and I I felt it it was the right thing to do to to say yes and not to say no no you are only going to have the rights for English and I'm going to keep the rights for French maybe it would have worked but I didn't I thought okay Zmen which is what was one of the companies I admired the most and I really felt the honors would be I actually when I went to Essen I couldn't I if I dared to dream, you know, for five minutes. I thought Zmen would be the perfect company for it. And I got a a proposition to to publish the game.

And so I thought, okay, I'm going to put this um publishing house idea aside. I had also too much to do as a singer. And I was totally new in this um gaming world. And and so I I started working with Zev. Then I worked with Sophi Gra when Zev sold the company to to Sophie Gra. And um and then when Sophi sold to Asodi, there was a moment where I thought, okay, maybe this is the right time to do um my own publishing company, but Asodi seemed to want to keep the series. And I thought, I'm not going to go against those guys. Uh let's go with the flow. And then when after another title published with them, it was clear that we weren't a good fit.

Then I thought, okay, this this is the right moment to to do it. So it it is a long story of of it was long in the making, but I thought it was the right time also. I don't regret not doing it 20 years ago. I think this would this would have been another adventure, and I don't think I I was ready. I didn't have the time nor the knowledge at the at the moment.

So with impatience you're publishing of course the oniverse but you're also selecting games from other designers and they are uh typically from my experience charming small uh something you could play for one or two players. Uh is that the full like ethos going in for impatience? What is what is the thought for like the kinds of things you're make you will make and what you're looking for

as a gamer? This is a bit um paradoxical. I actually enjoy those oneshot uh basically escape room in your living room type of games. Uh or those puzzle, you know, behind the one where you have to do a visual puzzle and then flip the tiles to see if you got it. I I enjoyed them as a player. I'm not super interested at the time as a publisher. I really like in patients games like before the Honorverse games to have if you like them to have big a big replay value and even the small the small series that we now have the the min in mini impatient series even if there are much smaller in scope and in components I still try to have variance and difficulty levels so that you can have enough replayability even in a in a small box and this obviously you don't have in all those one-shot games. So those are the ones I'm staying away from for the moment. I'm not saying never but and since also I have so many proposition comingings uh from you know prototypes and other designers I don't feel the need it's not like I'm stuck you know at the beginning of a year thinking my gosh we don't have anything signed what are we going to publish this year I have almost too many prototypes so so waiting that I want to to to publish from other designers so yeah so I I will stick now to I I think we will

stick forever to solo cop. This is sure I mean this is really the DNA of of the of the publishing house. Uh I mean the idea if if you want to play solo you can look for an impatience game and if you see impatience on the box you know it is a soloable game and not some version that we tacked on just to make it solo. Um, so yeah, this is going to be the DNA of the of the publishing house. And for the near future, I don't see also myself doing narrative games or games that are solved once and then you can gift away the the box or set it or throw it away.

Fair enough. Um, have you found that you enjoy like the part of the process that is making a product and not just designing a game? Yes. And I think I already was somehow groomed into it because on the onverse series I was already doing the whole art direction with Elisi. So there was never a publisher doing we always worked uh together making the game and then presenting it finished so to speak to the to the publisher. So a big part of of this I was already doing on on the Honverse series. And so it's obviously great fun to do this on games that I did not design with, you know, various artists and and so on.

Excellent. Uh so when you're working with artists that aren't lease, how has that felt? Because I feel like you worked with one artist for a really long time, or at least that's my perception, and then had to branch out. So, um, what about that process surprised you or was interesting for you?

I I wasn't I mean I learned a lot already by working with Eliz. It has something to do with um and maybe this this is something I took with me from the opera world also is I mean now I speaking the opera world you have to be super prepared obviously you cannot show up at the first rehearsal not knowing your part not knowing what's what it is about and stuff like this but if you are overprepared if you have already established the psychology of your character and the relationships with everybody around it is actually totally counterproductive because your colleagues may have completely other ideas. So sometimes journalists ask singers how do you see your character?

how is you know and then the poor singers you know feel obligated to respond oh my character is that and that and it is particularly um embarrassing at the beginning of a rehearsal process because we don't know and we will build it usually together and so working with an artist has some similarities with it obviously I mean I could come and say I want to hire you you're a great artist. This is the game mechanics. I have absolutely no idea for theme. Just give me something. With some artists, I suppose it could work. And actually with El, I did it a couple of times. I told her, "This is my prototype. Those are just abstract symbols. What do you see?"

Still I I never did it so far with games that um you know impatience games with other artists and maybe I will do it in the future, maybe not. Anyway, there is this back and forth between do giving some input but being able just to be open to what comes and it it is exactly the same in a rehearsal process in an opera production. and and so I was prepared to a lot of this and I use the same method so to speak it's a bit unconscious but with all the other artists my big luck is that I really couldn't draw to save my life and my my daughter's life you know I I am so bad at it you know that I I cannot even tell any artist oh Come on, it's not that complicated. You should do this and this and you know I am fully uncapable of this. So the only thing I can do is comment the images that I get and this I do sometimes extensively and I suppose I can be a bit of a pain you know on some details and saying oh no this is also my experience as an art director I would say and as a singer with stage directors I can get along with a stage director

that says is you are going to enter this, do three steps, then lift your right hand, then touch this like this and do I actually did a production, an opera production that was fully rehearsed by the director, the stage director and the whole crew of standins. So basically the staging was done. We just had to fit into what was already decided. And I found the experience really interesting. Uh I know a lot of my colleagues absolutely hate this kind of stage directing because they feel completely blocked and they say I have absolutely no creativity. On the other hand, I have worked also with stage director that just come, they sit and they say, "Okay, guys do whatever, you know, and and I also have colleagues that hate this kind of work." Because they say, "My god, what he he doesn't say anything. We have to do everything ourselves. He has no, you know, and so I I have no trouble with it." But I know listening to my colleagues that those are both extremes that should be avoided most of the times. So you have to give some input and not be too you know otherwise at a certain point you will probably have an artist that says re listen I really don't know what you want you know you are telling me too much stuff you are rejecting everything you have too too strong do it yourself you know just throw the bloody thing yourself I think

this would could happen if an art director had ideas that are really too too strong I could imagine Imagine since it's not my case and since I cannot draw it it never happened and so this is more or less the method I I follow. Uh

yeah no that makes a lot of sense. Um sort of in that same vein like it's very interesting to hear you talk about your own work as an artist and then how that makes you treat artists in different media. Um but what about as a designer? So you take prototypes uh how much development do they get once they come to you and who's doing it? So far, with one exception, I've doing the development on each game from another designer that I I I got. The exception being amazing that's coming out this summer. Uh because it is an abstract game and it is not the kind of game that I I play. I played a lot. I played obviously a lot of abstract games, but I I think I'm not very good at it and I'm not a good chess player.

I'm not a good go player. So, and so I asked Jeremy Partiniku with much more specialized than I am. He teaches chess. He designed some great uh abstract games. And so I I showed him amazing. And I I told him, listen, I'm developing this, but I don't want to do it alone. Do you want to be with me on on the adventure? And he accepted and we did great uh teamwork on on on this game. Um otherwise, I usually do it alone. uh obviously with the designer with the main designer. Um huh it's it's hard to tell. There are in instances where the designer even asked me do you want to be co-designer on the box of the game because he felt that my input was really um uh big. Um I refused and and so far I never I never do it. I never put my name on the box.

And so yeah, it's hard to tell. It is a very interesting question because and we have seen it in the last years, the previous years, there had been some games reissued by other publishers who did not hesitate to put their name as co-authors. Um, and it's interesting because there is no I think it's it's a bit um it's a gray zone. Where are you just a developer and where do you become

also an author? So me having my own series obviously helps a lot that I never have this wann to be game designer that I say I really want once in my life my name on the gaming box which I perfectly understand. I'm not making fun of a developer who would feel this way. I would probably feel the same because indeed when you work on development on a game and you really it's already a great game but you just give the little idea that will put it here.

Yeah. somehow you contribute it to make it the game it finally is when it is released. And so it is legitimate. I'm not saying it's not legitimate for the publishers who put their names. Even when you compare their product with the first release of the game, the changes are not that much. And so you could think hm if they are co-authors then I could also be co-author of so many games I worked on you know on the development. So for me it's cleaner also being the owner of a company and starting putting my name you know next to the name of the designer on each box. This would be fully it would be ugly just I wouldn't I would hate it. So um uh so yeah so I I never published so far a game the way I had it. You know this is the prototype.

Okay, I'm just going to put some art on it and to the printer. This never happened. Now, the extent of the development, this varies from one game to to to another.

Yeah. I mean, it's the same at my job, right? Like, you get a game, you have some thoughts for how to make it grow from like a game into something you could publish, and the team works on it, and you know, it's uh it's it's always different every time. But because you're such you're very interested in like I guess artistic consideration and like going with the flow and thinking about the the will of the game. Um what happens when what you see is different from what the designer sees or is that a rare occurrence for you?

It is a rare occurrence. I love I wouldn't say conflict. I don't like conflict but I love discussion. So I don't necessarily want a game designer who says yes yes of course. Uh um so far I have never been in the situation where I had to say I'm sorry we have the final cut. This is the way it's going to be. I think I would hate to be in this position. I don't know what I would do. I I think I would ask a lot around me, you know, to other people to, you know, make the decision for me if it really went into a conflict that is that you cannot solve.

Um, what I did a couple of times before signing a game was to ask the author, would would you agree to go into this direction? And uh um this is the most honest honest stuff to do. Now there are cases where you sign the game, you think it is great, we will work a bit on it and then you you see that the work is a bit more consistent than I a bit more how do you say meaty than what you expected and the contract is signed and usually as the publisher you would have the possibility to twist the author's arm and I would a to do it. Then you really have to discuss and it's really I like I like it. Uh uh because I always think we both have advantages. The author know knows his game much better than I do. Big advantage. I have a fresh pair of eyes on the game. This is also a huge advantage and we just have to see um what works best for for the game.

there also I don't know you you saying there are some opinionated people in this in this industry um it is true I I might be very opinionated I don't know if being a game designer in in this published game designer helps or not I would like to think it does because then I don't have this ego stuff of I need to it is my once in a lifetime chance to you know make a game as I want it to be so I will force my ideas. The danger is maybe I could become arrogant and think I have done enough games on my own. I really know how you do a solo game. We have to do it my way which would could be a big mistake in in and you know so I don't know. You have to ask the authors I I worked with so far.

This is

I love by the way that um you know here we talk about game designer. I actually really love your use of the term author because I do think in a lot of ways there is something very close about being an author versus being a game designer. I think

we see externally game design as more collaborative and so I think we don't always use the word author here but I mean you know books that go through a publisher are also collaborative we just don't see it.

Yeah. So, um, yeah, that's really interesting. Like, nobody ever talks about author in the world around me. I wonder if we should. Um, that's cool.

If I may, there might be a danger also. I mean, um, I use it and I stand by this use. There is a part in of my brain who I mean, the repertoire I sing as a singer is is mostly in early repertoire. So I do barack music, modz out and and a bit of rousia. I rarely do romantic music. Um and and so I'm I'm deep into this uh repertoire where it was it was a time where the notion of author was not as strong as later on in the romantic particularly in the romantic um era and uh for instance one of my favorite composers is handle and handle scholars have written a whole book it's quite fascinating I don't have it because it's really for for complete geeks where they take all of his operas and he has written I think about 40 of of them and in each opera you have about I think 40 pieces solo pieces and for basically each piece they say okay he's basically he borrowed he stole you know this melody from this composer and this melody from this and so when you go through the book you basically think this guy had very little own original ideas

he was such a master in putting them together that he was one of the greatest of his time and somehow it is a bit similar to game design. I mean it's it's really rare that somebody comes up with a totally new idea and when you have a new idea it is sometimes also borrowed from another game or another type of games or you know and but obviously the the the greatness is to make a good game out of it. So I totally think we should use author but maybe a bit more not in the 19 late 19th century sense like I am an author I am a great artist on my hill you know on my mountain above everybody as you said it's collaborative and and for people in the 18th century or 17 it was much clearer that yeah everybody borrowed ideas from everybody. Yeah,

bit what we have in in in the game gaming industry. Now, fortunately, you cannot protect an idea. Otherwise, we would have uh trials, you know, and and and and cases uh all over the place like, oh, you stole my idea. I had drafting before you. And fortunately, all those are building blocks that that we can use a bit like music two centuries ago. Now if you use I think three or four notes one after the other you basically stole an idea and you will you will end up having you know a lawsuit and having to pay a lot of money. I think in the music world now it it be it it's like this. Uh so I'm not saying it's bad but it's really a point of view. How do you see what is the concept of an artist of an author uh in in a given situation?

Yeah. No super interesting. I'm a classicist by training and so you know the Greeks and Romans also had very loose ideas of authorship and what belongs to who and all that.

Totally.

So I I do want to talk about this. I think it is so cool that you're an opera singer. Um you know how how does a person decide that that's what they're going to be? I fell in love with with opera when I was 15 years old and and I I thought oh I would like to sing take singing lessons and probably for a professional career it's way too late because I had in mind all those little pianist and uh violinists who had to start when they are two and a half uh basically and um years old and uh and actually I I I discovered that for an opera singer it was quite young uh to start training so I trained and Um eventually I did some audition, managed to get some contracts and that was it. So uh yeah.

Uh the other thing I thought was interesting is you mentioned that you prefer like you have a repertoire of like earlier composers. How do you land in I guess an area of specialty in opera? Is it just something where you get opportunities and you just kind of pick it up or is that like a sort of music that you fell in love with and you pursued more than other kinds

with the voice? You have the physical limits of your voice and and also maybe the strong points. Uh I'm a bass baritone lower bass baritone and um it's not that I don't like the romantic repertoire but people would probably expect a bigger voice than mine in this repertoire. And luckily for me, I can move my voice quite quickly, which is a good advantage in this early music where you have very virtuistic moments even for the low voices. We have this idea that it is the higher voices that have to go fast and the low voices are just heavy elephants, you know, but it it it was not true in in the earlier music.

And so this is how you end more being you know employed in in this you can I mean voice is something it's it's flexible enough you could say now I want to do another repertoire and maybe your instrument will allow you to go or maybe you will ruin partly your instrument trying to do I mean there are a lot of cases throughout the history of singing of people who try just try to do a repertoire that was a bit too heavy for them and um damaged a bit their or a lot their their voice and you have cases where they manage to because as I said it is flexible it is it's like muscle muscles you know you can start exercising and and and get you know but also there are limits you cannot you know I I couldn't you know think okay now I'm going to box in the heavyweight division I would have to eat I don't know how much and take I don't know what kind products to to make the weight. So I could say I want to jump you see boxers doing it all the time jump one or two categories but you cannot jump five categories and I I think singing works a bit like this. You can say okay I'm going to go a bit lighter now or a bit heavier but you cannot say okay I have sing sung bar all my life and I'm going to sing vagner because yeah I I like it.

So,

um, one thing that's kind of I think is so cool about opera in particular is that yeah, it's about singing skill, but you also have to be an actor in a way that like if you just go watch a symphony, it's not the same. Um, you know, there people are expressive when they play, but like you have to do stage blocking and interactions with other characters and like embodiment of another person that you're singing. Um, so how much do you see yourself as a singer and how much as an actor and how do those things like intertwine for you? Ah it is it is complicated. Uh I I really don't know. I think it's I always remember there's this horrible sentence. Uh I think it's still Gutier the writer who said uh he said this about a particular breed of opera singers in in France the ones that were singing the opera comik which was a mix of spoken dialogues and and singing. And he said, "Terrible actors that justify their bad acting because they have to sing and terrible singers who justify their bad singing because they pretend they have to act." So I mean um and and uh yeah so it's always a bit difficult to say yes I'm more of a you know because uh what I know when I see uh stage actors or movie actors you know or movie actors coming from the stage I'm I'm I'm just thinking we are absolutely not at that level of you know uh it's it's you see incredible stuff on screen

and on stage by by I would say real actors that I would find a bit pretentious to say I'm an actor too, you know. So, uh just put me on stage, you know, in a Shakespeare play near a real trained actor and I I'm afraid you will really see a difference. So, I couldn't say yes. Obviously, it is super important. Um, and I hope that I manage to make uh plausible characters on on on stage uh even when I'm not singing because you have operas where you have to speak dialogues and I hope it doesn't come uh over as oh yeah this is a singer trying to act you know so I don't know I know it's super important I studied literature I did not study music when I I went because as a low voice I knew I couldn't start a career very early. So with 17 uh when I graduated high school uh I was like I'm I'm not going to try to have a career now. It's too early. And so I went to study and in in um in university and I was like do I want to do musiccology?

And I was like no I'm going to be bored. I want I want to study literature. I want the stories. I want you know everything that is behind you know this is what really speaks to me. uh not not just the the music musical analyszis of you know oh it's a G G major and then you have this uh you know the chord of seventh that I never really found this super entertaining and so so I would say my first love would be more toward the text and the play than the music but then again I I I don't want to make the experience to have to do a spoken play with real actors Um

no I actually I know I would love to do it for the experience but you know maybe just the rehearsal process and then you know the opening night I would you know as a my cover do do it for me.

Um so literature uh what um did you have a particular focus or uh you know what what is your what do you like to study when you're studying literature? French. It was French Italian literature with a bit of um ro Roman, you know, literature from from the past. I wasn't very good at at reading Latin and uh but yeah, this was my

if I had taught you, you would have been fine. No, I'm kidding.

Yeah. No, I tease. I tease. Um so, um just I just like reading recommendations. I can't help myself. So, uh, if I was going to read something very interesting, uh, from those years of study for you, uh, what what really stuck out to you from that time?

I don't know from I I was a bit of a geek and I went into reading sprees, you know, if you had a a lesson on Zola, I would read basically all Zola. It was before the internet. You had the time to do this. Now, I don't see any student who would, you know, find the energy and the time to to do this. too it's too much stuff happening on the internet but or balzac you know then I read almost all Bzak you know it's really huge body of works but I just could read you know for for hours but maybe what impressed me the most maybe came after my I don't know did I for me one of the greatest is Luis Bor that I actually did not study because also I took Italian and not uh and not Spanish so I had to read it translated I I never could read Spanish well enough um so I would say this This was one of my, you know, greatest uh still is one of my my greatest love uh in in literature. So, uh yeah,

I was

What did you what did you what what what was your big uh love in while you studied?

Oh, so I um I wrote my dissertation. This is weird. Um I so I love just classical literature in general. Um you know, Latin, Greek. I probably I was deeply moved when I read Homer in Greek for the first time. It's really an incredible experience. But uh I wrote my dissertation about this Coptic monk named Shinuda who ran like a monastic federation in the fourth and fifth centuries in like upper Egypt. And he's just so sassy. Like he's the most you know a lot of Coptic literatures like the last is the Egyptian language. Um we only have translations from Greek into Coptic. So like it's Egyptian writers making Greek texts accessible, but Shenuda is like a huge sample of like native Coptic writing. Like he's writing in his language for people who speak it.

And he is mean and he is funny and it's just I um I you know I miss like the era of my life when I could just sit pick over a text like that.

And you read it in the original.

Yeah. That's what I that's I decided I was a weird kid like sort of like you like you know it's like you're a geek, right? So I got I was really bad in confirmation class. I had a lot of questions. I got really frustrated and I was like I will answer my own questions. I will take Latin. I took Latin in high school like late compared to some people. But like I immediately was like this is something I really like to do. Kind of like when you probably when you fell in love with opera, right? You're like okay this feels natural. Like when we talk about things like flow and about like not forcing it,

it was like the least forced thing I had ever felt because it just felt natural to do it. So I just did it and kept going. But then I was like, wait, there are other dead languages out there? I could learn these. And so yeah, I just like went all the way down the rabbit hole.

And how many did you learn in the end? How many languages?

I was good at Latin, Greek, and Coptic. Uh, I did a little bit of demotic, which is an earlier phase of Egyptian that I can't really remember anymore. And to my great sadness, I took a couple semesters of Arabic and then didn't get to keep going. And if I could go back and learn more, I would because it was beautiful.

So I uh and I can read French and German because you have to pass French and German reading exams.

Okay. So you know like basically I can read a lot and speak a little of so just out of curiosity so you've chosen these like really highintensity hobbies and interests like music is it takes up a lot of time um you know I played classical piano as a teenager and I was not a great player but like good enough to know like that you had to practice a lot to get

better. So, um, how how does gaming fit into your life if you're reading all of Zola and you're, you know, developing a voice, which takes so much time and effort, and you're studying a liab, um, was gaming something that you also always did, or did you discover it later as like a way to let off steam? Like, how did it happen for you? So, first of all, singing is maybe the laziest form of classical music you can find because because there's the physical limit of your voice. You cannot practice more than I would say three hours a day. Especially if you're young, you know, with age and technique, you can basically go all day long, more or less, you know, and maybe not each day. You have to rest the instrument. as a young singer when you don't have a technique and you are building you know and the body is not there yet and um you you really cannot practice more I would say than two hours a day you can ruin your voice I mean maybe if you have the greatest teacher that totally follows you you know and puts everything at the right pace you know very early on maybe then you you you are off a good start it was not my case so you know I was and I felt it I felt that I was getting tired so this this saved me more or less is that even when I didn't know what I was doing, I knew I was doing stuff the bad way and so I never forced I never pushed

and which means that once I had done my one hour and a half, two hours a day h I still had a lot of time left and I would say studying literature is also weird discipline because if you just want to get the grades I suppose it's not like engineering or chemistry, you can lay off. And I had some of my comrades who really partied a lot more than they studied. Um, since I was a bit of a geek, I just love to, you know, sit and read for hours. So, so once you have read, you know, sang for two hours a day and read for five hours, the day is still very long. and so I could even squeeze some games, you know, at the time. So it was I could I especially we have also to go back uh 30 years ago now um we did not have that many games available and for four or five years I basically only played Magic the Gathering. So even if I played it quite at not at such a bad level, it still was only one game and I went when internet started I I went there only to see what kind of decks were, you know, performing in competitions. I didn't go to board game geek to say, "Oh, this this is something new and this one and I have to

try this one and I want to watch this podcast and I want to to watch this this video explaining the rules." And no, it was just magic for years. So even if I played uh a lot, it still was only only one game. So this is how the days were filled back then. Easier life than than today.

That's funny. So okay, so you eventually got into solo gaming because you were on tour and you wanted to entertain yourself. I just want to know, so you also mentioned that you make solo games that don't necessarily reflect this the full spectrum of what you play. You like a variety. So what solo games do you really enjoy playing yourself these days? things have a bit changed in the last years because um I mean now my pile of shame is almost only solo games because I think yes of course I'm going to find time to play them and I want also to see what other publishers do. This is the theory in in real life. What happens is that I have I much prefer playing a prototype. Either I have to give answers to offers and I'm already late in this and I feel very bad about this because it's not nice. You know, somebody sends you a prototype and you keep it for a year and a half and then you eventually say it's not really for us. Horrible stuff and I've done it and I feel like a horrible person. But you know or there are prototypes that I have signed and I want to work on it for the development and so this is why now but I know it sounds really bad and mean like oh I don't play game solo games by other publisher we are the best in town so why should I bother you know it's not this it's simply the time you know and the and the energy and so when I now play published games I tend to play multiplayer games because it's my those are the social events I play with my

wife I play with my friends and So now solitary gaming I probably play much more solitary games now than 10 years ago. Uh but those are all prototypes that Yeah. So

that are some conveyor belt either the I have to test to give an answer or I have to test because I want to develop them.

Yeah, you know it's actually really relatable. I've been really struggling to game as much as I want to for my own personal enjoyment since going all the way into designing games myself. Um, it really changes my relationship with games and what I can get played, how long I can spend on something.

Um, and you know, I'm I'm sure that like over time I'll find the right balance for me, but it is uh it can be really tough to like see so many things that I want to play and I know that it's going to be tough to to make it happen.

So,

yeah. Um, so are you still a reader? And if so, have you read anything recently that was particularly good?

The problem is I am I'm still a reader, but I realize that I it's very hard to me to get into a fictional work now. And it's been like this for yeah, five to to 10 years. I really like to read essays. It's much harder for me to get into into fiction now. Uh yeah, on on one hand I find it sad and on the other I think you know yeah it's like people telling me I they don't love opera. I I'm never I never thought oh how can you it's such a great form of I was like okay too bad for you but I there are music I don't get into. So also this helps when you you know I cannot say yes I have universal knowledge of music and too bad for you little person that you cannot love opera. I feel exactly the same for other forms of of music and so I think yeah okay you miss you are missing something and I am missing something in this and this particular it's okay I mean at a certain point you you start knowing that everything you don't play you don't read you don't listen to this is actually the choices that you make and this is what gives you your your unique personality and so I don't feel bad anymore about oh I should read this and I should play this and no I Uh yes, some supernatural being could read and know and and and you know listen to everything. We we we can't internet in

this matter has rendered stuff so obvious since I have taken a subscription to um streaming service for music you know I mean I knew obviously when I went to a record shop it was clear that you couldn't listen to everything but within the confines of a genre you could still apprehend more or less everything at a certain point with opera. I was going to the library, the the music library and I was looking at this big wall and I was thinking I listen I listen to almost everything here. uh you know and then came the internet and so

so I guess this leads me to one more question which is you know I think about this too as somebody who makes games you know we are when we make games asking people to pay attention to us and spend time with us in a world that is full of so many options um I guess how what how do you um I guess how do you feel like you're making your seems worthwhile as a bid on somebody else's attention.

For this, I do as I always uh as I've always done. If I enjoy playing it, then maybe someone else will. And since as I said before I never earned enough money to make it only for the money it is quite easy to to keep this kind of philosophy. Uh and also this is something I I brought with me from from the opera and that I learned the hard way is that you cannot please everybody that they will always have people who absolutely hate and despise what you do and will express it sometimes in in a very aggressive way.

uh and in this matter internet has actually helped because before when I started my career as a singer you had printed critics and if one was bad out of four or five you got one out of four or five was bad and and it could be really demoralizing and then came you know internet and board game geek and you could see that even a game that was celebrated and loved by thousands of people could be absolutely hated. Really hated. Not just, oh yeah, I don't really like it. It's not my type of game. No, really, you know, aggressively um bashed on by hundreds of people, not just by one guy who said, "Yeah, probably the game designer stole his girlfriend when they were young." No, you know, you have hundreds of people who hate this game.

Uh and so it's okay. I I cannot say much else. This is my my my the only compass I have. Do I like it? So far I have never published a game thinking, oh, I don't like it, but I will make so much money with it. I maybe then I would feel bad, you know, thinking I'm stealing people's attention because, you know, I'm selling them crap uh that I don't like, that I don't use. like a drug dealer. I I sell drugs, but I don't I don't use them myself. You know, it's the opposite. I I I want to publish games that I first love as a player. I receive a prototype, and if I can stop playing it, then I think this is a very very good sign. So,

yeah.

Yeah.

So, what's coming up in uh on your release schedule that you're excited about? You mentioned earlier, but it's this is a good moment to recap games to look out for from impatience.

Okay. Okay. I don't know when you will uh release the the the video and within about a month.

Okay. So, Khan would probably be just uh uh passed. So, in can we release the two next um games in the minima and mayor of Chicago by Xavier. Uh then planned for the summer we have Mazing, the solo two-player uh cooperative abstract game, something totally uh weird. And then for Essen this year, we have planned to release Carnivorous by Inca and Marcus Brand. This is a solo up to four player cooperative game. So this is our schedule for this year. It's pretty full because we have some backlog from last year where we couldn't uh release two games because of the whole um US China uh trade war. So we we got stuck with with two releases and we didn't want to push all the releases one year. So we decided okay 26 is going to be a very big year and we will see if you know what happens.

Yeah sorry about that. Um, and then if um if uh people want to uh follow you or your work online, where do you like to be found?

We have an Instagram account. Uh I am not super active, but when there's a new stuff, we will post it. So we will not post something every day just to keep uh the flow going and people interested, but when we have a release or then we have our website. Um, obviously it's a much slower media, but also when we have a release and then if you want to know a bit more about our games, we try to make pages with little pictures that explain quickly each game. So if you want to have an idea about the game, you know, we try to explain it as easily, you know, as it's a very quick read. Um, yeah, I would say this is mostly the way.

Perfect. Shotty, thank you so much for coming on the show. This has been a real delight for me to get to talk to you. Thank you. Thank you for having me. It was very nice.

All right, everybody out there. You can find me anywhere online as Beyond Solitire. Uh please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.

Progress saved