Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 95: Jason Perez on Cultural Consulting

Transcript 1:07:32

hey Gamers at break time first I want to remind you all that I now have a patreon if you want to support the show visit patreon.com Beyond Solitaire I'd really appreciate it second Beyond Solitaire is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations right now their second game Rising Waters is live on Kickstarter if you'd like to play a peer-reviewed historical game and support a press trying to make more of them definitely check it out the campaign link is in the show notes thanks let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and you didn't think I was gonna go a whole season's podcast without talking to Jason Perez did you no sir we are back Liz and Jason are back yo my people's what's up happy to be on Beyond Solitaire podcast for my fifth season running

I just like I just pencil you all in the beginning now it's like planning for next season right Dave and Jason somewhere and we were gonna do uh Taco Puerto Rico because Puerto Rico is hitting shelves I don't know when this episode is landing sometime in October Puerto Rico will be available Puerto Rico 897 uh the new Puerto Rico uh in October however uh right now uh you know Robin's Burgers coordinating all of the press for that particular project so uh go check out bdg uh for uh Eric's article Eric um Eric Martin I I don't remember these names uh it did we have a front page article on BGG also there'll be an article on polygon uh coming up so that's kind of you know the official line uh so uh we wanted to do something a little bit different with this episode so I'll go ahead I'm not gonna step on your into your hosting uh stuff go ahead go for it I mean honestly we're at the point where it's just like a conversation anyway like a chicken yeah we were going to talk about Puerto Rico but um I we had to Pivot but I'm actually curious about this anyway you've been working as a cultural consultant a lot and I wanted to talk to you about how that experience has been you know how long have you been doing this now and you know how many like how much of your work life is this taking up at this point because I feel like it's a lot I mean I okay so I've been working as culture console but I'm not working as much as I want to so uh so I have been uh so what a cultural consultant is someone who uh contact or is contacted by a company we make a interface somehow and I look at their game and I you know I check for cultural

issues uh things that could potentially be trouble uh things that enter the blind spots of Publishers so I I open this up right away this is like no one is accusing anybody of being intentionally racist sex is homophobic all that kind of stuff uh but stuff sneaks in we not everybody has the right requisite life experience uh so you know you always could use a different perspective I've been doing this stuff for years and years and in the board game Space I've been doing it for now since early 2021 so you know that's when I kind of you know brought my bad year blimp into the uh board game Space uh so okay I mean I I first did my Puerto Rico video the very very first one the critique on January 2021 I started to contacted Alea in I don't know April like that's when we got together uh and then maybe around I don't know June July same thing 2021 chip Theory got in touch with me uh to look at their stuff so then that's when I it clicked it was like wow these are big companies let me try to make this a real thing so yeah I got I have a website it's not great but I have a website you can go check it at chips jailstore.gbl.org uh oh.com sorry oh shelf storage gbl.com uh you can go ahead and check that out I and you know drop an email and if you are a publisher or if you think a project need to look uh so I will either give a check you know I'd charge a flat fee give a check give my thoughts and boom done or I can work with you on overall thematic development so like if you're re-theming

a game and I've worked in a couple of those like with Puerto Rico there's a couple that are coming that are like this game already exists and it's like oh No One's Gonna buy this now maurys have changed so I can help you with that my motto I do not want to shame and blame more games more history more diversity in games not less so uh so I run the gamut so I run the gamma either out you know just a brief check and a brief consult or I will work with you and help you make your game more culturally resonant and at the same time cool I don't believe in uncool games I believe in cool games so no you don't agree on that so out of curiosity do you have to actually play a game in order to be able to culturally consultant like do you need a whole prototype or do you sometimes just check Rule books like How much of a game do you need to see in order to assess especially if something might not be super obvious you gotta play it you gotta play it you gotta play it because I I like to say that games have two different narratives games have the narrative that is said and the game that has a narrative that emerges right uh so I mean I'll take the example of Puerto Rico I'm not going to speak about it too much uh but you know you have your basic thing of this is what's happening this is the uh you know the the little brown chips the plantations and that's that's kind of bad enough but then when you play it you realize that wait a minute I'm putting the chips on the ship and I'm bringing the ship in and I'm physically putting the chips I'm physically assigning the things and that

just gives it an extra level of grossness that that's where people have that visceral response so like I got that question a lot why Puerto Rico why is this such a big deal why isn't it see a big deal you're you know you killing that game too uh why isn't fees for old is a big deal Vikings are bad you're killing that game too why isn't Pirates a big deal you're killing that game too uh so there are certain games that because of the mechanism in themselves they kind of like put you an extra level into the grossness that like and that won't emerge unless you actually you know get your hands on the thing and play it that's fair uh the other question I kind of had is that okay so um you know you also make just regular gaming media you know you do play throughs and you know I don't know if you do do you review at this point you're just playing that is it's very my reviews are very very down it's it's if I'm gonna do something that's just like you know for funsies then I'm gonna do playthroughs I mean I piss people off enough with my cultural Consulting I don't want to piss people off my reviews either people don't like when I have opinions or whatever it is like you know what I'm taking that out of my life playthroughs that's it just enjoy and then people it's on the gas station and then people just kick the rules and so I can't avoid criticism anyway but oh my God whatever but I guess my question is so if you've covered something as a culture consultant like does that affect the kind of coverage that you do for a game in other spheres of your gaming media life I won't I will not review a game that I consult for I'll feature it I'll play it you know I'll do a playthrough of it and I'll let people you know decide for themselves and yeah I wear my emotions up my sleeve if I'm not like super jazzed about a game I'm

just gonna play it and you'll know and or if I'm like super you know I get into it it's like okay I'm clearly enjoying myself so like I don't fake that like that an hour of Faking I'm enjoying stuff it's really hard and I have no interest in that so that I mean like so my quote-unquote opinion will emerge in the playthrough but I'm not gonna sit there like kind of giving a analysis of the game because I don't like I it's different brains like like I've already kind of and plus if I'm contributed to it you know so most of the games that I've consulted for has there been a change it's very rare that you know someone who cares enough to have the the game looked at where it's just like completely you know utterly fine and unscathed usually they have a question and people's instincts are okay like they they're thinking like oh this isn't quite okay but let me double check and actually I double checked like yeah that's not okay so then they change it so like I'm already involved in the process so how can I give my I'm already I'm attached so and I and I'm very clear about I'm very transparent it's like okay this is what I you know I I take a little picture I put it on my video uh this is my name in the rule books my name I'm looking at burn cycle right now my name is the burn Cycle World Book uh and a couple and whatever else is coming down so so that's so I will feature it but review it give my opinions uh there's plenty of other people that you can go to for that that's fair enough I mean yeah that makes sense I just always wonder how this works you know and especially as I started to do tutorials for chip Duty so you know I've

been doing all these tutorials for uh too many bones I reviewed hapla victorum but I also put a giant disclaimer on the front because like I still have opinions I think I thought burn cycle was decent and the hopper Victoria was great so you know I'll tell you that but yeah I'm exact opposite I thought bird cycle was gray and haplo was decent yeah I mean you know like the opinion still come out but yeah how do you how do you flag it is always the question um and then I guess okay so you mentioned like talking about things like not okay having a sensible it's not okay changing it what happens when you are brought onto a project and you give feedback um and the person that you are giving that feedback to like maybe it doesn't seem to understand or hear you or doesn't take all of it like is the expectation that somebody's gonna take all your feedback like how how do you negotiate something that's that that hard already about topics that are so sensitive so you asked the very uh interesting question Liz it's the big question the big question that is involved in cultural Consulting this is not easy work uh part of it is knowledge you know I think you know as a teacher right I mean like you can have the knowledge right and that is fine on one level but then there's your ability to impart that knowledge onto students which is a very taking for granted skill because that's why in America we don't respect teachers because we don't respect that as a skill because you have to overcome certain uh your Tendencies You know I know like as a teacher you're looking at kids you can kind of read what you can get away with

and what you can't drink it too and what will fly and what will not so you're adjusting right so it's like okay uh I was gonna do a lesson this way and now let me do it that way because they won't you know Vibe with this one thing but I think this will other things will have a chance so in a way because this is an educational process you know teaching people you know how to you know think more culturally uh resonantly then it's it's kind of a similar deal where it's like I have to kind of read the situation and Pitch myself to be able to impart whatever information I have without in a way that'll be received I'll say it that way uh so and the biggest thing here is to you know like I think you were alluding to this people feel attacked you know and that's the biggest thing right and that's that's you know that's why the internet sucks because it's a giant field where people make each other feel attacked because that's how you get attention so and it's when when people feel it's hacked and in that defensive Crouch they're not gonna listen and they're gonna like you know judge and they're gonna be defensive and everything so I in my videos and also in the Consulting I bend over backwards to say like you know what this isn't about personal attack this is just blind spots you know this is um there are certain things certain ways in which POC women lgbq have you know presented themselves in the culture there's a lot of stereotypes there you know not every girl has an hourglass figure and a little and a butts and all kind of thing uh that is not the only

kind of woman that needs to appear in uh in a game so you know it's just but that's the cultural thing that's what we're used to as a culture so I can't consistently right that's the very beginning the very beginning is to let people know that this isn't about this isn't personal this is not personal attack this is to make every this is helping you see what we see which is not an easy thing to do yeah and and you know and making your product better I like to say I and I also I also put it in terms of money and and you know uh uh press like you know consult with me now my costs a little bit but think of the money and time you'll save on the back end because you avoided a problem and people understand that people aren't like like that's what people are that's what a lot of people are afraid of they're afraid of like they release something and then they're like they they're not talking about the thing they're talking about the controversy that the thing generated and that takes so much time and it's like I'm a person in a constructive way that can help you avoid that Pitfall so I want to get back to this large discussion but this does lead to another question for me which is do you ever feel like you're just being asked to rubber stamp something oh yeah so that's why people can release it and like feel good about it and how do you handle that like you're working in a professional context right you have clients they paid you you have to do the service on some level I guess like at what point do you walk away what happens if it's just not working okay so I actually have a list of four things

that I've encountered in particular and you just hit on one of them so I'll skip right to I'll skip right to that one so in my cultural Consulting and this is for any because I know of Publishers listen to this uh and whoever's watching this on shelf stories so again not personal but these are trends that I've noticed uh that we've been educated and socialized in and something to be aware of so again not attacking anybody but I do encounter certain issues and you just put your finger on one of the biggest issues that I encounter which is I call it the trust me paradigm so you're brought into consult or I'm brought into consult but the Creator is still kind of claiming that Authority it's my game I have the expertise thank you very much for your input but at the end of the day I'm not going to compromise my vision where I don't think I need to compromise it so I've encountered that in many different flavors many different uh you know areas and this is where I'm going to get a little bit spicy but you know I'm just gonna I'm just gonna go for it because I wanna I gotta get my spice this way because I can't eat it I get ulcers do not tell a white person that they can't do something do not tell a white person that they can't be the best at something that is something that white folks have been acculturated again this isn't genetic this is cultural this is the way that folks are socialized where you know you could do anything and you could excel at anything and here I am saying well you cannot excel at telling a woman-centric story

if you're a white man a woman will tell that story better you cannot excel at telling an Egyptian centered a Caribbean centered uh you you literally cannot excel at that because not because of any kind of limitation not because you're you know terrible and racist or whatever it is just because there are people with life experience every single day they're living this stuff that are going to tell that story in a more authentic way not necessarily better but definitely more authentic and that's what a lot of people want they want that authenticity when something's truly authentic that'll sell right when something feels good that will sell and I think there are white creators out there that you know they want to give that so like you know they're making Egyptian games like okay it's Egyptian I'm gonna throw some pyramids on there and I'm and it's like okay that becomes like a one-to-one or I actually had this uh situation someone was making a game and you know the Southwest Mexico area and everyone had you know everyone in the yard had sombreros and I was like okay um can we take a look at this and the person's like isn't that what Mexico is all about there's you know doesn't everybody wear a sombrero no no that's Speedy Gonzalez stuff I mean that's where that's where you got it so and there was a process of like you know I that again when I made that observation the person felt attack like well what are you saying and are you listening that and I had to go through the whole thing go through the whole thing and that can go either way sometimes the person listens but sometimes somebody will pull the card right I am making this thing be so I

have the authority and that's where like and I had that one for actually a big project I'm not going to say what the big project is but uh you know I was introduced to the person and the person was you know they had uh their vision for the game and I'm looking at the game and and you know I'm giving my opinions and this there were some issues with this game and I got the I'll take it under advisement thing and you know what that means so I'll do the console uh you know and I've done the initial consult and then at that point I'm I'm like okay I don't I'm at the point right now where I have a little bit of notoriety in the space I don't need to be attached to things where I don't need to be attached to uh so that I'm gonna apart from those so now that becomes an issue because you know I could be giving up something and there are a lot of other people in the space or they may be in other areas of life where if they don't attach themselves as a token to make then opportunities will close so there is a v there's very much a temptation to go along to be like all right well at least my name is attached to this thing this will open doors for me and I'm gonna go progress to the next thing and I can't blame an individual person for making that judgment I cannot uh I just you know for for me and for where I am right now and for that particular issue of the trust me you know I have the authority I have final say over how my game looks and feels you know I I'm gonna I'm gonna meet the personal uh um decision to step away yeah and like what's hard about that too is it that's such slippery thing I mean

I know that when we're coming hot about something right like on a very technical level like that is someone else's game and they are going to publish it the way they want to like what if they get two cultural Consultants who disagree um what if it's a very subjective thing and you're just wrong how do you even navigate that you know what I mean like I just feel like it would be really hard yeah I mean okay so so this is a a thing I encounter on the publisher side and on the audience side right that we're like the politburo and the culture consultant is like papers please I I you give me your thing and I determined whether it's acceptable or not and I you know and I could like I like I wield some sort of outside Authority moral Authority shaming Authority that's how I kind of uh I'm able to be be the boss over these things people can do whatever they want it's about reception you know at the end of the day I think there are creators who just want to make their game and be free of consequences and so that's another that's another very very much uh baked in part of white culture is this assumption that you know you know Free Speech right Free Speech means I can say whatever I want and doesn't it does not mean that yeah I mean you can say whatever you want but people are gonna have thoughts about it and react to you so can I that that's what Free Speech means you can say whatever you want I can say whatever I want and then there's a persuasion battle

so then what Free Speech rejects is coercion priest piece rejects you know government coming in and saying and exerting Force but if a a project is you know what is whatever it is that you have your free speech I'm not going to cancel it like I don't want to hear anything about cancellation like you know publish whatever you want what I'm pointing out is that you can't stop the free speech of other people too so that's the that's the move the move is to say that person say whatever they want every all criticism is called culture is invalid and so whatever like now you're suppressing my free speech and that expression free speech of people who are you know watching this stuff and I've I'm good at this like I have a and I think my background is that because also helps because I have a lot of empathy I've met a lot of different people I'm always meeting people all over the place so I I get a sense for how people think how people will receive stuff and so if I note something that's like okay that's an issue and that's nothing um the good point about um cultural Consultants disagreeing yes I don't think a cultural consultant um a really good one will be prescriptive oh say okay I don't like this I don't like this I don't like this I don't think this is whatever it'll be more like okay this group of people might take this this way okay well that group who might take this that way and I'm hopeful that you know Consultants on will agree so it's like maybe the consultant person will be like okay that's that seems pretty good but you might want to check there with that other perspective so it isn't like you know it's just like okay here's my

opinions it's not about my opinions I try to take that out as much as I can even though you can't truly I'm always going to have some perspectives but I think it's a there's a bigger thing here then the bigger thing is different sectors of the audience and how they'll respond to it so then getting back to the original thing of like okay the roller Creator can make whatever they want well then then people can say whatever they want and if you want to ensure that your product is received right in the best light what's the point of making a game the point of making games you want people to play it and theoretically you want people from a wide variety of backgrounds and experiences to play it so that's the flag it's like okay do you want the this audience to play it do you want that audience to play it do you want that audience to feel seen do you want that on this to feel like the representation here is is for them and not everybody wants that so it's like okay fine so okay I got you the consult I gave you the flag now you're prepared do put your your game with your five white males as the as the leads put it out there and see what happens or the one woman of the chainmail bikini I deal with a lot of female bikinis seriously that should just be obvious for now but so that actually leads to um my next question though because I just my Instagram let's just be obvious by now I think maybe it just isn't uh to some people but um so you mentioned trying to approach people with compassion and try not to judge them like it seems like a lot of this is getting your point across your clients while also like handling their feelings

yes delicately yes so I mean I'm sure that frustrates you do you ever feel like this is a line of work that can do harm to the person doing it because you are essentially putting yourself in a role where you have to humor someone that I mean you know when we talk about you know being a more diverse society and actually listening a lot of messaging that I get on Twitter is like white people need to know that they need to take themselves of a conversation decenter yourself shut up let people be angry in the way that they want to be angry and quit trying to tone police people like so from my end like what I learn right is that it's not all about me and that I need to like um just listen to other people expressing their feelings as they see fit but that's not what can happen in the way that you're doing this work because somebody paid you to help them do better so like how does that how does that work and like what's the emotional impact on you so dealing with white people feelings is part of the deal when you are a POC uh and you want to get somewhere you know and so uh there's so many that people you know I'm talking to a Asian uh DM for one of my uh dungeon master and d d for one of my podcasts and and you know on down the line and that that's what that's what we deal with in a context which is the call we call it emotional labor you know we are we are explaining but then we're taking on the emotional labor of not make people feel attacked because white people are educated again

not all white people right I'm gonna get that comment I've gotten that comments at 6 000 times not all white people if you if you check out of this yourself then thank you very much but there are it is a cultural tendency and when something happens over and over and over and over and over again and I don't see it challenged very much that I'm gonna you know I'm just gonna make the generality right so you know the hardest thing to deal with is the extra level you explain but then there's this extra level of like the person has their their feelings triggered and they feel attacked and now you have to do the 10x emotional labor of explaining it in a way that will give access and you know create the change that you're looking to create so yes and so you put it in terms like can that be harmful I mean I guess I mean I do not recommend this work for for a lot of people you know you can get there's a lot of people who've gotten pissed off you know trying to explain that perspective and it's like okay I'm not doing this anymore I think for me I have a mission you know my mission is change my mission like I know how important representation is and there are people who don't know but I know because people like things that are familiar we're having representation battles as we speak with you know the black Elves and the Puerto Rican elves and The Black Mermaid and why are these fights important I think most people don't really get why they're important you know they just like whoa you know they're they're this and they're important because you know people gravitate towards what

is failure and if the culture the center of the culture we're talking like very Central cultural products has faces that look familiar than other people from other marginalized backgrounds will feel more welcome in the center of the culture that's just the way it is and all humans are like this white people too white people want to see familiar things black people want to see familiar things this is human this isn't political it's human so you know and I I use a thought experiment every single time I was like okay well the the um the source material is you know is white you know token was white it was a white thing so you're violating the source material by making a a different kind of Elf beside the white out well it's like okay I get that white people want to be seen in their fiction well then give back Jesus Jesus Brown dude and what would happen if we if browned Jesus all of a sudden became the the icon of the land what would happen if you know your Ye Old Southern Baptist down there or uh you know the Catholics up in you know these other places what if all of a sudden we were just like you woke up one day and it was brown Jesus would the white people flip out or would they say oh I don't see race it doesn't matter I think that they want to tell everyone else that Jesus is there for everybody and it doesn't matter what he looks like but if you changed it you would get a a response let's put it that way and that's and I'm I'm not saying that's like bad I'm saying that's human so

we're all having a human response to what we see we just want to see familiar things right uh so that's our point but then we have to deal with the emotional labor of white folks in the middle who take that as an attack who take that as a replacement like we want to replace white people that's the big things like you know I think they were about a video about replacement Theory and that's a big thing among you know white cultures like we're playing they're replacing us they're replacing us whenever we want to see this we don't want to see that do you know how many shows there are you know like we have thousands of thousands of shows wanting five you know a representative POC is not going to replace anybody and can dealing with all those feelings cause harm of course it's exhausting it's no it being constantly misinterpreted that's the harm what you're constantly misinterpreted when when I'm speaking my truth and my truth becomes you know perverted and it becomes warped and it goes to that culture War Mill and it comes out as well they want to you know they want to replace white people they wanted to buy stuff that's exhausting that can do harm but I have a mission this is important so I I do what I you know and so this this podcast like this helps because it helps to talk about it and it helps to you know foreground these issues you know so that's that's kind of my thank you very much Liz you're my medicine oh I appreciate that so uh I have another

question you and I are both history Buffs yes and I I think I know you're into this but I'm gonna ask anyway because I think it's valuable to discuss which is yeah whatever you know the answer to all these things have I ever gotten to have you ever gotten to a point where there's a conflict between historical reality and the recommendations of your cultural consultation um no no I I and I'm uh I am I'm a little bit unique in this regard I guess I'm not sure because I do respect history so much I I'm a I'm a firm believer whether if there's a conflict the answer to that is deeper more intense study of history I history is so big human culture is so big if you dig deep enough you'll find something that will answer your problem so you know so um okay perfect example the Puerto Rico example uh when I first looked at the game and I wanted to kind of explore re-theme I knew that people would would want Puerto Rico to stay Agricultural and stay historical right that couldn't just make planetarico in space they did that swim Boston people didn't like it that that because they it's not about like people want a sensibility a certain side of sensibility when they go to the table and you know contradict that I did a theme doesn't matter it does in a sense of creating a vibe you know people want to sit down they want to have that historical tourism you know warm fuzzy you know go over them it feels good to play in these historical things so

Puerto Rico wanted to generate that so I could have made something up because Puerto Rican agricultural um history is difficult we've been a colony forever and we've always like always basically always our economy has always been under the charge of somebody else that whether it was the Spanish or the Americans or what have you so I could have you know taken that off ramp but I said you know what let me keep looking let me keep digging and I was able to dig far enough to find this reality 1897 between sort of the Spanish and the Americans I was able to find farmers who were independent and who did for themselves and that's the story I wanted to tell so I was able to do both I was able to do a historical truth and something that was culturally resonant so did I you know am I skipping on some stuff sure you know I don't want I don't want any colonialism in the game but does did I achieve a perspective that is historical and culturally resonant well yeah you know because if because I grew up I mean or my Grandma had a farm and I went there for Summers and we didn't talk about colonialism all day you know we didn't sit there like miserable I can't believe we're calling us today no human beings are bigger than that so like I I took from my experience and stuff from the history and I made something that is definitely culturally resonant the only people have a problem

with it are the people who like want misery in the game so I I I I don't have anything to you know I've talked to those people but I don't believe that is a legitimate perspective so yeah I mean I think that with so into original question with more work with more history with more with more ability to kind of shift perspective and uh explore the perspective of What alternative actors in history I think you could figure out a way right so there's there's two things kind of going on here as I read that answer one is actually what Emma Bell Holland said in her first time on the show um when you are doing history there's two stories there's a history story and then there's a story that you're telling about yourself right um and you know those are the two twin narratives that go in uh but also that um you know finding another perspective another kind of agency and another kind of joy in history that's not lying about history just because something sucked it doesn't mean that everything sucked or that everybody was miserable or that you can only tell the same sad story again you can free yourself from that right and there's a danger in that like you don't you don't want to whitewash history I've gotten the you know I don't think it's ultimately valid but I can see where people are coming from where what I do with Puerto Rico age 97 by putting happy farmers in the cover I kind of dodged and I so I I whitewashed I I do not uh accept the idea that I put more brown people in the game and it's called the whitewash so let's just put that out there first of all but am I you know am I dodging the real issues

um no because I recognize that the game engine is a farming engine so I did an interview with Andre Mack who's a the in charge of a Leia if you want to know more again if you want to know more about the official layer perspective my work with them go ahead and check out an article on polygon and we were talking Andre and I on that very interview and I said it's like this is not a colonization game this is a farming game and he's like yep we don't want conversation we never want a colonization and but there's a segment in the audience that wants colonization and that thinks it needs to be there and it doesn't does it so finding the perspective that says what you want if you want to make a colonization game so uh so um the makers of endeavor age of sale I have them on the show they're going to be on the show in a couple of months they want a conversation game like that game is a conversation that game is that game can't be written to anything else because they built it from the ground up as and they they're like okay they knew how bad conversation was but they think they thought they can get away with like people being kind of sardonic about it you know the way they play Nazis and it turns out that no you can't do that there's a really key point a really really key point that I think a lot of again white cultures don't understand so like in terms of the further barriers to uh you know people who are like why is this a problem colonization is ongoing conversation is is today so from a white person perspective a white culture perspective again not all white people um

but from a white culture perspective like killing is killing you know you know bad actions are bad actions you're either good or you're bad right and it's like okay if I'm if I'm gonna be a bad guy then I'm gonna be a bad guy and it's just a game whatever whatever and for us that's not true because some bad stuff is in the past dead gone whatever like room like I mean a lot of stuff that happened in Rome we don't have Legacy of like the Visigoths you know they're not claiming uh you know we've been oppressed by Western culture for however many years no they assimilated into Rome and there we go uh so then or like you know the different Barbarian tribes which I know you're you're researching yes yeah that's an upcoming project that maybe we'll get to talk about next season absolutely uh so then but the the project there was assimilation and assimilation more or less happened right you don't have people that are claiming that heritage in the you know Latino context our colonization started 500 years ago and it is still going and that's a different thing that that is a whole different thing and if you don't know you don't know so you're just gonna make a game about it but if you do know then it's gonna press a wound a wound that has not healed because they keep opening it right so like 1492 you know Columbus comes over by you know 50 years later the island is wiped out you know 90 of the native population is wiped out and you know enslaved and all this other stuff okay so then did that end is that a one-time deal no right now as we speak we're speaking on September 24th my island is without

power parts of it are underwater because of a hurricane a category one hurricane which category hurricane is not that strong so it theoretically should not have dealt such Devastation but because we are a colonized land because that colonizing has not ended for 500 years we're in the situation that we're in and we're being dismissed but you know there was more coverage of the Queen's funeral way more coverage of the Queen's funeral there was way more coverage of a spider crawling on the casket than there was of three million people losing power and losing drinkable water three million Americans I should say so but so the Instinct on white college would be like oh the poor Browns and even the stronger instinct is oh they can't take care of themselves they know that's too bad they have corruption they have whatever you look deeper and it's like no we've been a colony for 500 years so like we've been put under the thumb and not able to develop and do for ourselves because of the thumb on us that started 500 years ago that old Puerto Rico whitewashed and so there's no education there's no ability for people to understand that so like and this includes Publishers to get back to what we're talking about Publishers don't have the historical perspective of respecting the ongoing colonization the ongoing oppression of marginalized peoples they don't understand so you know Shifting the conversation over to women they don't understand what it is to be a woman and what it is to be cat called wherever you

go to be not taken seriously in higher levels of Academia and business and government all kind of thing and that's ongoing women know this but men don't because they don't experience that so you need a woman you need someone with that perspective you need someone empathetic to clue you in that like do not touch issues of ongoing oppression in your game even though you think it's a past the past is present for a lot of people yeah unless you're for me like a distant past that's present actually for one last like kind of serious segment of this podcast before getting just like in the chat I've I've talked about this we've talked about some face chat before but like you mentioned Egyptian games a lot and I think that's probably because you're talking to me like something you know that you know I have an interest in that so uh my phd's in into Christianity I'm an academic expert on church history my specific area of expertise is the Coptic Church in Egypt I wrote my dissertation about Coptic monks um I'm also a white woman and an atheist who lives in America so I would love to make a game about Coptic monks maybe about finding the things the desert fathers or about like a battle for Supremacy in between the nuns and you know the leader of a monastery which is something that really happened that I find really fascinating but I also ask myself the question like is it okay for me to make a game like this because there are also practicing cops today who engage with that literature there's a potion a little while back and that's my I my dude too you know and my

perspective on the Coptic church and the happenings they're in is going to be wildly different from somebody who's like coming at it from I grew up in this church perspective but maybe I didn't read all the letters and sermons and whatever of shanuta like how it how do I navigate that like I do feel like I have expertise to talk about that if that makes sense at the same time I'm really aware that my expertise does not reflect a lived experience of people who are actually being cops in Egypt so first of all I'm going to um call out a little bit of white people framing yeah is it okay is it okay for me to do X is it okay for me to do y that's very moralistic and it plays into the white culture preoccupation with feelings and with judgments and yeah yeah of course it's okay depending on what you want to do right it depends on what your goal is so tell me what so so the is it okay question and like okay not okay that's to me sterile I have to know what your goal is I have to know what you want to do I have to know why you want to do it right so if you want to do it because you have a perspective you have something to say you're very strongly about it and whatever it is then you're gonna do it you're gonna hear criticism and you're doing this to stand by it and that's fine all right and I've met those type of people it's like you know what that if that's what you really want to do uh I mean uh as an example I consulted on Brazil Imperial so Brazil Imperial is a game about

basically you're a monarch in Brazil and you're building up a Brazil Forex Euro style and the original person who made the game is a Brazilian person but they're like kind of a restorationist monarchist so then they their perspective is you know the monarchy is great and let's harken back to when Brazil was a monarchy and all that kind of thing uh loves junior bro sonaro for like being a strong man who wants to uh you know recall back to it so I didn't consult with that person directly but I consulted with Portal Games who picked up the larger wider distribution of it and there's no helping that game like that person has a perspective they're gonna put out what they're gonna put out they don't care who it pisses off they don't care that they've reduced the entire African tribe to like a tile you turn it over and you get three fruit like that's the entire representation of African peoples even though there's millions of them and they've always been millions of them and there's a long assertion of rebellion and resistance no now they're down to a tie and so on and on and on right and so like indigenous peoples the only indigenous person in that game was a famous sellout who you know sold out his tribe to the monarchy in order for them you know in order for uh that they're there to achieve that political perspective so that person had a perspective and they wanted to make their game and they're not changing it they were challenged on it and they came into forms and they said I'm not changing this I'm not going to Cave to the wookness all that kind of stuff so that person found a publisher made their game and they stuck with it so yeah but that's not the narrative

that I want to embody in my own but I'm saying is like okay people ask is it okay is it not okay you know that I'm what I'm trying to do I'm not saying that that's good or bad I'm saying like right that's a way to go you know it's a way to go and like and so what I ended up doing was I ended up writing kind of a paragraph in the beginning of the rule book that says this is not the only perspective like you know know this perspective it is popular in Brazil there's a lot of people feel this way you know please educate yourself further about you know you know other perspectives indigenous resistance African resistance Etc that's the best you can do right so you can come in there with that attitude and and honestly like why folks have the privilege of being able to do that there's this instinctual field that you're going to get canceled or you're gonna get you know yelled at and whatever but that's your fear if you really wanted to jam something through you could probably do it and so is it okay not okay uh for me from my perspective there's all sorts of things that I'm not okay for me and I can't jam it through I don't have that cultural cachet but there's a lot of white folks out there that can jam anything through that they want to so for me that question kind of like yeah you don't know what it means to read for something to be really okay or not okay because there are walls when it comes to POC stuff that really don't exist it's mostly social and emotional when it comes to what white people think okay okay so that's that's number one I know that's a little bit of a subtle point but I hope that people kind of process I'm good with it like we're talking about we you know languages I think it's fine to call it out it's important actually so yeah so okay so the okay not

okay framing if that's your approach then please reconsider that and the the the more fruitful approach is how will my how will this project land with people you know ask it in a more kind of open uh perspective where it's like you see your game in the context of the the gaming ecosystem right as opposed to seeing it as a binary plus minus good or bad it's like okay this game is in the ecosystem most games probably could be made I I I'm fine with that so what will my game do in the gaming ecosystem that's a much more valuable question for me so okay what will your Coptic gain from a white lady atheist in Atlanta Georgia uh what will that do in the gaming ecosystem so I mean what can it do what could be your blind spots so then you I can almost guarantee that you're going to have blind spots because you come in with maybe like a feminist read of stuff so that are like you know what white American feminists read and they have their own perspective so then you're going to make your game about nuns rebelling against their male monk you know whatever and it's not gonna it like there might be aspects that you're reading in terms of like Yay fat you know yay the feminine whatever whatever where someone who's from the culture would be like no that's not how I would go right it would it would go a little bit this or like that was that maybe it went that way but that's not great you know there was a backlash to it

afterwards so always always consult with somebody and if they're telling you something that's like will take you off you know and what will change your project consider it consider it don't put don't play the I have a PhD or don't play the I have my expertise card so quickly yeah that's that's what I'll say like okay just so the so the framing is how will my game play in the gaming ecosystem not necessarily the binary uh you know and so what happens if you do get to a point where you're like well I'll take that under consideration so the story that I'm thinking of by the way is it so umatripa he's an Abbot of I mean that's not so he's the leader of a monastic Federation in the fourth and fifth centuries in Egypt and several letters indicate that he had issues with the nunnery that was part of his community um he visited them one time to our knowledge and tried to kind of like impose his will and got frustrated and he like rent his garments in the manner of an Old Testament prophets to communicate biblically to them and then one of them basically accused him of stripping and like sexual harassment so he never came back and like threatened to cut off their food got mad they sent him clothes that didn't fit um you know wanted to prescribe punishments wanted to be told about sins that were taking place in community but like maybe it seems pretty clear that you know the the female leader did not necessarily want to tell him everything and so yes there's a real historical precedent for all these things but what

I see and what somebody else sees may not be the same that's true for reading history you do right but at the same time yeah I mean you have to think about like where would that land how would that you know would people perceive that as disrespectful to one of the most important figures of the Coptic church and how much do I care about that I mean yeah so like yes there I mean you're gonna enter criticism right and every game that has a historical message makes an argument we call it argument for a reason so you're gonna cause an argument with the argument that you make somehow somewhere the question is that's why I like to ask the ecosystem question is the argument that you're generating constructive an actual discussion and you know you people can disagree but then at least there's something that emerges from whatever disagreement is or is it frustrating and what I find is there's a lot of games that are made that generate arguments that reduce the cultural conversation to this consistent 101.

you know of um you know so like the original Puerto Rico I'm gonna go I'm gonna go back to it because that's just what I know uh the original Puerto Rico once again I'm not gonna talking um about the working with the Leia I'm just going to talk about my own reaction to it at first the original period recall did not make any kind of fruitful arguments about colonization of slavery what emerged in Puerto Rico was that the slaves were were not to be counted that you you they did labor they generated uh you know uh production and they didn't get sick they didn't get hurt they didn't Rebel nobody dies they put nothing nothing so the argument the conversation that is generated by the team doesn't it it's basically like okay should we call them colonists or slaves and that is such a dumb conversation to me it's it's sterile and it's not the kind of it's not the kinds of conversation that lead to Greater understanding it just it to me um okay this is uh Beyond Solitaire uh I'm gonna I know getting a little bit raw today so it's fine no I'm I'm I'm a free speecher channel in that regard because I'll do it like this is not puff pieces yeah to me people who kind of talk about the colonization in Puerto Rico are engaging in a kind of trauma porn they're thinking about it they think the game deals with it they think that the game kind of like looks at it and oh this is a game that's brave enough to put you know slaves and it makes the

players think and you know whatever that's like what kind of thinking are you doing are you doing something that increases understanding or are you doing something that is kind of like self-congratulation I'm going to explore my feelings and it's gonna go nowhere so that is to me mashupatory sorry so I actually really like this direction of conversation though because I think it really hits on something important about what games can and should be doing what we can interview doing their conversations um you know actually a geek Gamers is on here a few weeks ago it will have been a few weeks ago by the time all the stairs um and a lot of her points were about not asking yourself just a bunch of yes or no questions that lend you in a narrative dead end because it ruins the story and I think you know a lot of your earlier like when you were first getting into cultural Consulting and talking about it like with relation to um like frost Haven for example it's not just about you know again it's not is it okay it's how do we make this a more compelling Story how do we have this be a deeper and richer world and I think that that's also true with historical gaming like we like to think about history as a list of facts because that's what school teaches you to do but all history is narrative and if you trap yourself in a binary narrative it's just not going to be as Rich it's just not going to be as good right and so I'll go back to making fun of white culture again in the sense that you know when you're privileged you don't deal with on the ground or certain underground realities your middle class you're enjoying this Hobby and everything then

all conversations are fine you know I can talk about whatever I could have my tea and I could have my little circle and we could talk about whatever in all conversations are kind of relativized and fine and because the at the end the goal the point of the conversation is the pleasure of the conversation so like if it's a pleasurable conversation that's fine and okay that's your paradigm for us who are sitting in who have real Stakes in a lot of these conversations are like when it comes to colonization that's not a 500 year old reality that can just be talked about however right for us there's Stakes any conversation about colonization that does not give insight into the ongoing colonization of folks is a harmful conversation is a conversation that takes them away more than it gives and so bridging that divide has been difficult because there's that ingrained sense that every conversation is worth it and it's not it's just not and that sounds it's gonna sound people like well do you want to suppress speech people just go there immediately it's like okay well it sounds like you want to you know be the judge of what conversations are good or not

so much that happens so much and I'm like okay what is that I don't want to say that things are yes or no I'm gonna ask the genuine question of what's the point right what is the point of the conversation is the point of the conversation the pleasure of the conversation have mine's been changed have things been learned as a result of a conversation I'm going to regard that as less valuable than actual arguments and conversations that lead to Greater understanding and that ultimately adjust Behavior and that that's what I want at the end of the day because I want people to adjust the behavior because we're not going to overcome colonization by talking about it we need to get to that practice point you need to get that action point of actually changing things so to me conversations about cultural conversations that are just kind of you know oh let's talk about this and everything everything could generate any conversation and it's all valid it's all good um no I'm going to I'm not going to say you can't have them but I am going to criticize them criticism is not cancellation I'm not canceling anything but I am criticizing it yeah and I mean that's something you know you're perfectly within your rights to have a conversation that somebody else thinks is pointless like nobody's saying you can't right but if you're putting that conversation out into like a larger discourse if you're baking it you're inviting it you're inviting a response this podcast invites responses um the fact that I tweet things I just accept that on Twitter I'm gonna get whatever response it is like you know you can't you can't I mean you

know and I'm not saying like oh harassment it's just what you get no that's not what I'm saying but people don't have to like everything that we do or say nobody's required to like me nobody's required to like you like you know it's like that's not what anyone's saying what I will say is I mean interpret me properly yeah yeah liking not liking whatever you can like me not likely but when the and when the persistent misinterpretations happen that's where I'm Gonna Get You Know frustrated so like when and that's why I you know you see me pausing once in a while I'll go down a line but then I get the inner white person every PLC has an inner white person we all do like it's it's our police it's our internal police we police ourselves because that's that's what keeps us safe so I'll you know I'll talk and then I'll see the inner white person will like flash the stop sign and I have to process and I have to like okay is this worth saying or is this not worth saying can I say this in a way that will less likely bring blowback to me and is it worth saying so sometimes I'll get the police person and I won't say it because that's not I won't it won't be constructed but I've learned over the years of doing this that there are some things that need to be said and talking about white culture is one of those big flashing stop signs that my inner like white cop flashes at me and it challenges me to be as clear as possible but at the end of the day I need to overcome that and talk about white culture because white culture is ultimately why we're at where we're at

it's ultimately why um you know what is it top 400 board games mostly made by white European men so it's only like over 90 percent in Elizabeth Hargrave just did this but looking at the top 200 in BG and counted like Eight titles from women why why and and along the lines of POC pocs you know similar distribution we have to ask why questions and the why questions are in white culture they're in the way white folks are socialized there's nothing inherent in there's nothing wrong with white people I love white people I'm talking to white person right now yeah and like we are real life friends you are my friend yeah and I went on all the time sometimes you just like goof off and talk about like fart jokes so yeah absolutely so like we're just happy to be talking about white culture now so we need to overcome it and talk about what other things in white culture that stop women from being more present if you'll see from being more present I'll just be cute to be more present it's in white culture it's in male called white male culture I should say you know yeah white women have their own role to play these things but okay yeah yeah I mean the white women have their own role to play but like I still have it's still not you're still not at whole position so I I I'm willing to kind of have those conversations again not a binary all right I'm willing to have those I think of it not in terms of the binary I think in terms of Center and margins so who's in the center who's in the margins that's I to me that's obvious from Democrats it's demographic who's the center who's in the margins I want to be

able to ask why so I want to ask these questions of my culture and so bringing the circle bringing the whole conversation back to Publishers I'm a cultural consultant with Publishers and there's a lot in white culture there's a lot in a way that white folks are socialized that I'm encountering you know we've mentioned some we've mentioned the um the Instinct for Authority the Instinct that a white person like you know doesn't like to be told they can't do something doesn't like to be told that they're not the right fit for every single role you know uh white folks don't like to be called racist don't even think that they're called racist white folks make things about emotions and social stuff and want to take conversation away from some of the more material concerns that a POC might have and you know on the line right there's a there's a couple that we haven't even talked about uh so I mean I don't want to like weigh down the conversation but like no it's okay because and you don't need me to validate what you're saying but I am going to say that it's true because I mean you're saying things that I see in myself I fight them actively I spot myself doing those things sometimes like an appeal to Authority or like being really scared that somebody's perceiving me as races right now or you know I mean those are legitimate internal responses that I have and I'm not gonna lie about that I think it's disingenuous to do that I think that what I can do is recognize that it's there and process it to the best of my ability get better at it just like I have anxiety I go to therapy for that we talk about recognizing the cues that I'm starting

to spiral how to stop how to redirect I mean you know like I feel like it's a similar thing like oh I am being caring right now let me pull that back my inner Karen woke up let's just let's acknowledge she's there in like the Buddhist fashion and just kind of like let her go there is one thing I I dude I did want to hit this point um the other thing that white culture wants to do is forget and this goes back to like this kind of hits back at some of the history stuff that we're talking about why culture it's you know uh we the aphorism in amongst one of the Ninja tribes that I've been studying is the ax forgets but the tree remembers because the ax wants to forget because he actually want to figure itself as an ax the ax want to think of itself is nice the actual I think of itself as okay well the forest is clear because the forest has always been clear and the forest should be clear like no no you cut the forest yeah and the idea that people when POC speak we're trying like we're not trying to chain people we're not trying to like you know Cut You Down we're just trying to be seen and we're trying to reflect some of the actual history that's been going on yeah so that comes up whenever I hear a white person say well this used to be good but all of a sudden people think it's bad you know I get that from Publishers a lot where it's like well I've been making this for all the whole time and now people saying tell me it's bad uh I remember I had one publisher they were doing some kind of like um uh you know Fantasy game and you know

you know the tropes uh and they said okay this particular faction was based on the torrent from World of Warcraft I don't know if you know anything about the torrent from the World of Warcraft uh no cow people bulls and cows like Minotaur types okay yeah Minotaur types but like totally like native coded they're sitting in TPS and they're you know they're cooking stuff on open fires and they live you know days not very not big settlements and everything okay we didn't know in 2010 quote unquote we didn't know in 2010 when we were playing wow but now it's bad in 2022. so from a white culture perspective there's an all of a sudden there all of a sudden the tauren are racist when they become racist I can't I don't know what's racist what's not racist and that speak that's not because things changed it's it was always racist but the voices that have the life experience to be able to point out the racism have busted through the barriers and now we can be heard more nothing changed nothing changed Aunt Jemima was always racist the Redskins was always racist they've been progressing the race that they've been protesting the Redskins since the 70s the 80s yeah and but those voices just never penetrated so that's another thing that I want to encourage um in terms of Publishers if someone points out something and your instinct is to say well that wasn't racist before you probably if we're probably speaking from a perspective that likes to forget and now we're not letting you forget

so just you know again you still have the choice you can put it out and will live with the blowback or if you if your intention is to reach the brightest possible audience don't say the segments of the audience oh well you're woke calm down you know I I try I'm not I'm not trying to shame people I'm not I'm trying to be constructive here I want a truly Multicultural um space and I do think there are large aspects of viculture need to be deconstructed in order to truly make room for that Multicultural space that's what this is about this isn't about attacking people so all the stuff that we were talking about I know I pinned something there at the end but I needed to get the forgetting pot in there also we talked about are Tendencies within why culture they can be challenged they can be overcome and I invite people of Goodwill at all Publishers I find most Publishers of Goodwill the vast majority that I've worked over of Goodwill I invite everyone of Goodwill publisher and gamer to criticism you know understand the criticism is not cancellation I have real reasons for this please do not interpret me uncharitably I'm not trying to cause trouble yes you are in good trouble good trouble I'm trying to cause good trouble yeah so you know it's it's trouble for the idea but good for the person hopefully all ultimately that's where my culture Consulting is all about yes absolutely and you know as the person who is

you personally trying to see this is you know the tree remembers the ax forgets now it's your turn to be a tree and it's somebody else's turn to be the ax right the people who see that I'm taking the ax and I'm taking the ax to white people you know I am truly trying to deconstruct the Paradigm and I hope that my the Puerto Rico is the first shot across the battle on that where it's like people assume that I wanted to count to Puerto Rico never yeah never never I just want to make it like more accessible more people and I want more games so like if you want to understand Puerto Rican colonization you know from a different perspectives my friend Julio Nazario made uh borican is a game yeah on GNC that's not funded yet like it's not uh it does it has to hit at 500 pre-orders it needs to 500pr so we're still working on it so if you really want to know about Puerto Rican uh you know the the more difficult colonization stuff then that's a good project and just like more and more and more don't Jam something that has a bad message upper butts just let go and embrace something that's more resonant with the culture that's it so that's where I'm at absolutely I just checked by the way uh brief end is at 337 orders it's got to get the 55. I get the 500. it's hard it's hard but uh yes so let those who have yours to listen um let them do so and uh so where could you where could you could be found online shelf stories GB uh shelf stories GBL on Twitter uh my YouTube channel shelf

stories I'm not as active posting uh because I'm working on some projects uh so also shopstore gbl.com is my cultural Consulting website but you can like that that you can contact me all sorts of ways oh you contact me you know through Twitter Youtube you know Focus this user BG you know you can con if you want me to take a look at your game and I try to be I give your game a lot of time I'm very thorough uh I try to make sure that people get their money's worth uh when they when they uh do Consulting with me so the big project and I can announce this because you know but the Publishers don't care uh I am signed money's in the bank and contract has been signed I'm a uh now going to be a designer I'm designing my first game a co-design with Greg Long Albright who made Ahoy and who is a guest on both of our shows uh and we are doing the board game version of Howard zinn's people's History of the United States so if you don't so and this actually in um this in uh this audience would know that because it's a history audience so I've met a lot of people who are like what's that which is which to me is crazy okay so that book is like you know Pearl Jam talked about it during a concert Rage Against the Machine has it on their website for sale and all that all this other stuff uh so it is it is a book that has penetrated the culture if if you don't know it is a alternate telling of history from the perspective of dissidents rebels you know strikes and protests and all the people that push the government to do certain things

in the normal histories governments just do stuff and you know it's like okay it's time to release the slaves and it's time to have civil rights not quite there were popular movements that we pushed power to like the abolition has pushed the end of slavery and you know escaping slaves pushed the end of slavery and you know in the Civil Rights era it was black activists and women activists and eventually the Native American activists that pushed more civil rights and more like this stuff doesn't happen you know just on its own and so people's history wants to tell that story and our challenge is to turn a giant 500 year uh 500 page textbook into a fun board game but I think we are on the right track I showed you a little bit of the beginnings you seem to approve at least yeah so that that's gonna be uh so if I'm not like producing as much video content then I'm that's what I'm working on fantastic thank you so much for coming on as always Jason I love having you on the show thank you very much Liz those of you out there if you're listening you probably know I can be found anywhere as Beyond Solitaire so please like ask questions and most of all happy gaming later everybody

foreign

Progress saved