Skip to main content
Loading video...

Good Games - Cascadia, GM&O, Meltwater, Square on Sale, & Twisty Tracks

Transcript 58:07

welcome to john gets games this is my latest good games vlog where i'll be discussing my initial impressions for some games that i was able to play recently that i enjoyed um five is more than i normally do for these but uh fortunately none of these are heavy games they're all light to medium weight overall now i do want to mention that if you prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you can do so by searching for the john gets games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts i'd also like to ask that if you enjoy videos like this one and you're interested in directly supporting the channel that you visit jungusgames.comsupport there you can find a bunch of ways that you can really help things out and many of them come with perks like watching some videos early and advertisement free as well as voting on which of those videos are made lastly i'd like to ask that if you have anything to say about any of these games that i'm talking about today that you please comment down below let me know which one in particular sticks out to you and maybe why it's always great to see uh what people are gravitated towards because it's an interesting mix of games overall and i'm certainly enjoying all of them and you'll see why very soon and i guess on that note let's actually start talking about these games so the first game i'm going to be talking about today is cascadia this one was published by flat out games or i guess maybe developed public published by flat out games but aeg sent me a copy of this game um i'm fortunate they actually sent me a copy of a lot of the games they published without even asking so like a week and a half ago the doorbell rang and i just opened a box and there was cascadia and i was really happy actually about that because i've seen a bunch of tweets about this and photos online and i thought it looked really great um this is a current release as you can see and it's like a

30 to 45 minute game according to board game geek and i'll say that i played this one once and we played a four player game which is the most the largest player count uh now i guess while i'm talking about length i will say that our four player game took about 90 minutes so 30 to 45 wasn't um necessarily accurate for our um for our first experience but um you know we actually we were really enjoying it and just kind of chatting and hanging out but either way let's talk about how this game actually works um in the middle of the table uh you put these five cards out um you draw a random fox uh hawk to um not tuna salmon uh elk and a bear and they have scoring conditions on them and there's i think five of these cards so you have a different mix of these scoring conditions in each game and then on your turn you simply take one of these hexagonal tiles from the middle of the table as well as the animal tile that is associated with it and that's it so like if this was my turn right now i could take one of these four pairs if i took this tile here it would come with the fox if i took that tile there it would come with the bear token then you take the tile and you add it to your overall tiling area each person has their own part of cascadia that they are building out and then you take the token the animal token and you hypothetically hopefully put it down onto a tile in your area that shows that icon so for example in this area over here there's a little bear icon and an elk icon on this single hex so that means i could put a bear or an elk token down on top of that now you're growing out this hex grid in front of you with all of these tokens and the reason you're doing that is to get points at the end of the game now this is one of those games where you score all of your

points once the game is over and you get points for a wide variety of things but in the middle of the game you're just building this out every single turn one of your turns you take a tile uh you take a token you put those down and then you move on and i think you take 20 turns um so at a four player game that's gonna be the longest way to play the game because you actually put less tiles in the supply essentially and you keep going until all the tiles are gone so if you play with three players instead of four then that's 20 less player turns that happen so it's just going to be a shorter experience although i've only played this one at four so far now the way these things score is different for each of the animal types like in theme like the bears seem to score for being clustered together in various sizes the elks are all about formations like an exact pattern of elks in your area the salmon want lines of salmon in various ways they score in various ways and the the hawks well i'm not sure how all of them work but i will say in this one it was all about line of sight like actually making kind of a webbed pattern of one hawk being able to see another and these foxes scored for being adjacent to a bunch of the same type of other animals so i'm going into too much minutiae here but as you can see just by putting these animal tokens down their location in your hex area is super important because that is going to dictate how these things diff score um you know maybe you're putting an elk down to match that specific formation but then you're also putting the elk down next to a fox because it's your third elk next to that fox and that's going to score you more points so hypothetically you want these kind of to bounce back and forth um you also have things like where these um hawks score on specific spots because they want to have straight lines to other hawks and

that means if you place another token on a great spot for a hawk for example over here there's a bear right there and if that was a hawk then that would have been great then you're essentially denying potential points that you could have had for getting that hawk now um there's only one other tiny rule to mention and that's these little acorn tokens and you get them uh in a way that i won't describe but there's a way to pick these up and you can spend these to get extra flexibility where you can actually take any tile and any token instead of having a matched pair or you could dump all the animal tokens back into the bag and pull some new ones out but these are worth one point at the end of the game now in addition to that when the game is over when you score all five of these animals you also score for the regions there's i think five different types of regions with uh like kind of grasslands and forests and water and mountains and um you get one point for each hex tile in your largest area of that type and then if you have the largest of that area amongst all the players you get an extra three points then second place gets a point i think if you're in a four-player game so what that means is this is a very nose-down type game where you're really paying attention to all the stuff that you're doing but you do need to pay attention to what other people are doing as well because of those areas when we were playing this game i found myself for essentially the first two-thirds of the game um not really paying attention to anything that my opponents were doing uh beyond maybe thinking like man i really want that hawk i hope matt doesn't take that hawk and i kind of look at matt's area i'm like i don't think mac matt wants to take a hawk okay i could probably get that tile and then maybe he takes it and then i get really surprised but once we got to the last third of the game i did start to look around at all the other players areas to see like how big is

claire's mountain range how big is jessica's water area just to see like am i in contention to have the biggest one because getting an extra three points for that is is pretty significant i can't remember what the final scores were in this game but um three points was definitely something to pay attention to and i was surprised at how relatively easy it was to glance at my opponent's areas and get a good idea of how big their areas were i will say that based off of how these hexes go together it is possible that from across the table it looks like you know that water section is added to that other water section but it isn't quite uh there were a couple times where i slightly misread that but for the most part um i was really impressed with this game and and honestly going into it i thought i was going to like it because i liked highlighting games and i like puzzly victory point pattern type things but i was worried about analysis paralysis um with all of these different tile options and animal options and how the different tiles score and also the majorities trying to pay attention to what other people are doing i was i was worried that i would really fall into an analysis paralysis spiral and i didn't that was a really pleasant surprise for me like there were definitely a couple turns where i crunched you know through many different options but i never felt like that um that awful uh embarrassed feeling when you're taking way too long in your turn and you're like uh just give me a second i just need to think a little bit more and you're all worried i never got that moment in this game and i totally expected to uh especially at the four player count um downtime just wasn't that bad even when my opponents were thinking through their turns i was taking that time to analyze their areas to be like okay how big is that grassland over there how big is that mountain area over there um you know since my opponent was thinking

about what tile to take i had that opportunity to kind of judge where things were i didn't have to think about that in the middle of my turn and you know if i calculate the size of a mountain range of somebody else and then they get a mountain well it's pretty easy to add one to that uh so yeah i've been really surprised um by how how um fluid this one play of the game was and i'm looking forward to playing it more um like i said i am predisposed to enjoy thailand games so i thought i was going to like this one already i like the art overall uh on the cards and i think honestly the art on the tiles is is fine like it looks nice and it's also easy enough to tell what it is from across the table which is really important and these um these tiles that you put the animals down on are wooden tiles with like a silkscreen animal on top it just looks really cool and i just enjoyed the puzzle as much as i was expecting to and um it was just a more pleasant experience from a downtime perspective than i thought i think i'm starting to repeat myself but there's really not a whole lot else to say about cascadia it teaches super fast i've essentially taught you the rules to the game right now uh minus the minutia of how the scoring of the cards works which is really not that big of a deal either and i can't say what this is like to play multiple times because again i've only played this one once and i do feel like i would probably enjoy it even more at slightly lower player accounts like maybe three instead of four four was fine i would not say no to playing it at four again but it will be probably closer to a 60 minute experience maybe even 50 minutes uh for our group if we played this one at three as opposed to four just because that's a lot of extra time but um it was a really enjoyable experience all the way through and i didn't really feel like it was too long and there was a lot

of great moments when you get that perfect animal like for me for example i went very hard on the hawk scoring i want to go into the specifics of it but you had to have this very specific kind of line of sight web of hawks in your area and i ended up scoring like 30 something points 31 points or something like that because i had all these hawks perfectly positioned out in this pattern to get just a ton of victory points and that felt so satisfying there's there's a lot of highs in this game and you know there's some little lows where somebody takes the tile you want or the animal token that you want but you know you pull another one out of the bag and maybe you have one of these nature tokens and you get rid of it to jump to bring a bunch more animals out of the bag and there's also a lot of moments where somebody else dumps those tokens back into the bag by spending a point and you're like no i was so sure i was gonna get one of the two hawks that were out there but you know now it's back up to the randomness of the bag as to whether they'll come out so yeah cascadia is really great i'm looking forward to playing this one more as a relatively uh reasonable size box it's not a huge one on the shelf and it's just a cool tiling puzzle uh alvin mentions that this is not as punishing as calico calico is a game that i have not played i know it's about making a quilt with cats and it looks like an incredible brain burner and i will say that this uh game cascadia did not burn my brain as badly as i thought there's definitely a lot to think about but i thought it was going to be more of a brain burner than it actually was which honestly was a pleasant surprise for me as i keep saying i was worried about the downtime that didn't actually end up coming up reishi mentions that it really does well at different player counts i could totally see that um

the majorities the amount of points you get for having the most of a certain spot of a certain type is is different um i could see really enjoying this one too because really this game is all about that personal puzzle that you are putting together in front of you and i suppose that lower player counts you're going to have even more control um over you could see farther in the future about what your options will be because you always have four watts that you can choose from no matter what the player count is ginray says that cascadia broke uh their stance on solo gaming uh they pulled this one out to play solo quite odd quite a lot i don't really play solo games but i've seen quite a few people mentioning online that this one plays great at solo because i guess then you just really are just doing the animal puzzle i haven't looked at the rules of the solo game but um i can imagine that it you know it's just really focused on making that overall animal puzzle work and i can see that being satisfying for people who enjoy solo games so yeah that's going to bring this part on cascadia to a close and now let's move on to the next game and this one is golf mobile and ohio and this is a very different game from the one i just mentioned uh this is a cube rail style game and in fact uh this is the only cube rails game i'm talking about today um and this is one that's been on my radar for quite some time this is a game that's all about auctions and that is something that has scared me about this game i've actually i avoided it at first like many months ago because as i started to enjoy cube rail style games i was like okay well i'm enjoying the stocks and enjoying laying the track out but auctions are still not my favorite thing and i heard that gulfmobile ohio or gmno is the easier way to say it is just auction after auction after auction and

that is true but i will say that it did not feel like other auction games and i really quite enjoyed it uh now this game originally came out in 2008 but it got a reprint uh with a nice box and a nice map from rio grande games a couple of years ago and um i played it in tabletop simulator but this uses the assets from the rio grande version of the game uh now gmno is a strange game in comparison to most other cube rails games and one of the reasons i really enjoyed diving into cube rails is because one game can be so different from the next like it almost seems disingenuous to to lump some of these games together uh because they you know might have cubes and they might have a train theme but that's kind of where the similarities end um in most cube rail games you have companies like maybe four maybe five maybe six in gmano there are i think 23 different train companies which is a lot more than five or six as you can probably imagine and in this game you do collect stocks but it does not feel like stocks in other types of games and there's only two stocks for each of these types of uh each of these companies now at its heart at a very high level this is a really fascinating network growing style game it's fully competitive but what you do in this game is on your turn you take one action from i think three options but 95 of the time you're going to be starting an auction you're gonna take one of these green charters from beside the board you're gonna put it into the current auction spot and then you're going to say a number of money that you have um you often have you know like 20 money maybe 17 15 money so it's not like you're bidding you know 56 money for one of these things and then you have just a

standard auction like nothing particularly fancy about it people can pass or they can increase the number you keep going until everybody passes then things get really interesting um that in a way that i've not tried things before sorry then things get really interesting um in a way that i haven't seen in any of these other games and that is that um in a lot of cube rails games the money that you pay for like a stock goes into a treasury for that company but this game has 23 different companies there are no treasuries that you have to take care of instead you take all of the money from the auction that you just won and you immediately build track and then that's probably essentially the only track you're going to be building for that company for the game uh any excess money is lost and when you put the track out on the board it's super simple it costs three money per cube that you place and that's it like there aren't even any exceptions so that means from an auction perspective you know if the amount that you bid was divisible by three then that's as efficient as you can be and if you bid a little bit more than that to outbid somebody else well maybe you're throwing a little bit of money away but again unlike a lot of cube rails games this one it doesn't matter how much money you have at the end of the game this game is all about having victory points uh which is something that many of the winsome type games have but it's it's more uncommon so when you actually lay these tracks out you just get points you get a point for the charter you took and you get a point for every city that you place a cube down into and then most importantly you get a point for every new other color that is now touching that overall network and when you build it into certain cities that unlocks the ability to lay out more uh track for different railroads at the beginning of the game i think there's only six of these uh charters that can be available

um in this example right now there's like 15 or something like that so as you grow out from the perimeter of the map you unlock the ability to get access to new railroads and that's why it has this wonderful network growing vibe to it i just loved the way the map evolved as the game went on because at the beginning of the game you just start on these specific spots around the outside but then you go to a certain spot which unlocks a new company which goes down and somebody can do a charter for and then they grow from that spot out so you have this wonderful expanding series of all these different colored cubes there's six different colored cubes and i'm not going to go into the specifics of how you actually choose which of these colors to put down it's pretty fascinating but i'm trying not to go into the specifics but i man i was really impressed with this game and i was scared of it going in honestly because it is just an auction after auction after auction and even though the auction structure is like a straight-up standard auction like there's nothing fancy or unusual about it when you win that's where it gets really interesting because it's not just about outfitting your opponents it's about also putting enough money in to be able to lay enough cubes to get a number of victory points that makes it feel worth it to spend that amount of money and then once you spent your money once you go down to a very low amount of money you might not have enough to win any auctions you can put these secondary stocks up and i won't talk about the details of how we do that it's very simple but then once a couple of those happen we pay dividends now dividends for stocks is a thing that many train slash cube rails games do and this game is so simple every one of your charters is going to give you five or three money and every one of these secondary uh charters is going to give you three money that's it you just count

up the little dollar signs on the cards that are in front of you you get that money and you move on there's no stock value track there's nothing like that that's all abstracted away and again that's part of the reason why i enjoy the breadth of um mechanical variety with these cube rails games because you know some games go heavy on stock market valuation tracks and buying and selling stocks this game it seems like it's all about the fact that there's 23 i think more than 20 different companies that you can build out and that that's really a big unique factor to this game uh so yeah you're just winning auctions you're throwing cubes out like crazy and you're getting victory points just squeaking them out where you can and i played this game once we played it at four players and it took like 65 minutes it was really quick i was super surprised and i almost won this game uh so the game got really close to being over in fact the image that i have up right now with the game is probably just like two or three turns away from being over i just wanted to show you how much the map can be covered with all these colorful cubes and it was my turn and i had a position i had the ability to start an auction that i could just win i had more money than everybody else and money doesn't mean anything at the end of the game so i just spend all my money who cares i could trigger the end of the game and then tie for the win if you have the same number of points to somebody else at the end of the game you both share the victory and this is my first time playing this game and a couple of people in this game had played it like seven or eight times and i was just sitting there thinking it'd be more fun to win by myself right so i decided to take a gamble um i expanded a railroad i'm not gonna talk about the details of that it's it's simple and um let the churn go on and i

ended up coming in second place it was a little hard to map out exactly what was going to happen well that's the thing you can't math out what exactly is going to happen because some people might bid in ways that you don't fully expect one of the players who was in i think third place decided to place a bid that that put a lot of chaos and instability into suddenly how the endgame state was going to happen and when it all shook out i got second place so that's probably my own hubris like i should have just taken the tied win but i was honestly curious just to i wasn't quite done with the game i wanted to play around with it just a little more to see what would happen when i if i tried to squeak a couple more points out and obviously that did not work so big part of this game is is reading the map because as i said when you lay these cubes out you get bonus you get extra points for touching your new cubes to other different color cubes and the winning move for uh the person in this game who won adam was to build um i think one two three four five six seven eight yeah they built eight cubes out which i think you know cost 24 money at least and they got a bunch of victory points for that because they connected up four cities but then they also connected up to i think three or so other colors so they got i think around eight victory points for that um and that's you know put them just like one or two spots ahead and this game is about timing like most auction games like you want to have enough money to win an auction at the right time and that's put me off a lot of auction games in the past but for some reason in this one i didn't mind it so much and uh i did pretty well like i said i was i could have chosen to share in a victory in this game so you know maybe if i'd been skunked in this game i'd

have a different opinion of it but i don't think i would i really aesthetically enjoyed the story of how this played out and i know i'm a broken record at this point if you've heard me talk about kubril's games in the past but part of the reason i enjoy these games is because they take about 60 minutes to play and they tell a fascinating story that's interesting even if you're not winning i i really enjoyed seeing these tracks form out on the board um i won this auction to put a bunch of cubes going up the the northern pass here and one of the people that's playing the game with who's played it like eight times was like oh wow um people very rarely take that northern pass and i was like cool well hopefully this isn't a mistake and i guess it wasn't considering i could have tied for the win at the end of the game um but i was like that's cool like i'm doing something that people often times don't and that's going to unlock new opportunities and it's going to make the map look different and again i've only played this game once but the people that i played it with two of them i played like seven or eight times and they really enjoyed it and i could see myself enjoying this one a lot in the future the biggest barrier for this game is the fact that it's auction after auction after auction and that's going to turn a lot of people off but the fact that it's an auction game where you're buying stocks but you don't have stock valuations to worry about really it really just makes it work for me so yeah i've been super impressed with this game i feel like i'm maybe talking in circles at this point um i'm you know continue to be a overly uh interested in quirky mechanics so like learning that this game has you know 20 plus different companies that you're working from uh and that you have these different six different cubes but like different companies are going to share the cube lines and you don't need you need to make sure not to connect them man all that stuff just seems so neat

and uh yeah it's just an impressive game that felt like it was doing something different even from all of the other cube rails games that i have played uh and i've played a lot now i'm actually keeping a track i have a spreadsheet um and this is uh as far as i can tell the 21st cube rails game that i've tried over the last seven or so months and i've got a list of 10 more that i would still want to get to part of me wants to make like a cube rails video just talking about my experiences with cube rails but um i want to play a few more and honestly that's part of the reason why this one got played i'd like to make a cube rails video and i didn't want to make that video without having tried gmno and i'm glad i did um i imagine this one will make that video if i end up putting it on there i've played a bunch that i haven't talked about in good games vlogs one i played a week or two ago was called dutch intercity and um that one is also auction after auction after auction and i did not like that game very much at all i only played that one once but my initial impression of dutch intercity was feeling confused and dumb and not really enjoying it and my initial impression of gmno was was feeling confused in a fun way and then just enjoying the process of how it all went out so yeah that is going to wrap up essentially where i'm at with gmno i don't have a copy of this one but i certainly look forward to trying this one more i'm not sure if i'd actually get this played that much with my current gaming group because auctions aren't a big thing for them like it's not a mechanic that people in general in my group enjoy so this might be one that i will continue to enjoy on the internet with some of my friends who enjoy this kind of stuff but i'm just glad this exists and i would uh actively look forward to playing this one more

so christian mentions here that they just picked this up after listening to the dads on a map podcast which is something i'm not familiar with but apparently they talked about it and apparently they liked it so i guess i'm not alone i mean again a couple of the people that i played it with the ones who taught me they really enjoy this game so that uh that definitely set things off in a good direction although a lot of them enjoyed dutch inner city so you know there's a lot of room for personal taste with these cube rails games and christian you mentioned if i was planning on doing a top cube rails video at some point yeah i imagine you asked that before i kind of organically mentioned that i'm planning on doing a video about that i'm not sure if it's going to be a top 10 video i was thinking about it more i might do like a just a journey through cube rails kind of like i did for rondelle games um where i was thinking about this actually this morning where maybe i start with like the simplest cube rails games and then go to the most complex and just kind of discuss why each of those are interesting and maybe i talk about 10 maybe i talk about more or less i don't know um but i think i would probably enjoy that more i'm not crazy about the the top 10 framework because you know they're just my personal opinions and that can really vary i'm much more interested in talking about how these games interact with each other mechanically so i think it's uh possible that i'll do one of those but again i have like 10 more games i want to get through before i actually uh invest in doing that maybe not 10. i'd really like to play at least five of the games that are on my list so um we'll see i don't have a time limit or a specific idea of when that'll happen but hopefully at some point soon all right it's now time to move on to the next game and this one is meltwater a game of tactical starvation so

happy sunshine raise going on here this is a two-player only game that is published by holiday and it came out a few years ago and i remember hearing about it when it first came out a few years ago where people were talking about it's this super dark theme of like a post-apocalyptic war in antarctica as all of humanity is being exterminated but the u.s and the ussr are still fighting and that's exactly what it is uh but uh i didn't give it too much extra thought a couple years ago when it first came out but now as i'm enjoying more hollandail titles and getting more interested in these things i decided to pull the trigger and i picked up a copy of this one along with some other games that i ordered from them and i've had it for a little while now and i finally got it played and let's talk about this weird game so you have a map of antarctica and thematically um the cold war turned hot uh we launched all our nukes and the ussr launched all their nukes and the world is pretty much done for and the last remnants of humanity have gone to antarctica which apparently has the least amount of radiation in this thematic scenario but the us and the ussr are still fighting with each other and they are still you know trying to kill each other even though the world is coming to an end so mechanically the way this game works is you are controlling your forces in this game i played the ussr which was red and then my friend matt played the u.s which was blue and on your turn uh the first thing that happens is a starvation phase where you check to see who starves uh odds are good somebody's starving out here in antarctica and i'm not gonna go into the minutia of how that's calculated but each one of these uh hexes can support two tokens and then that can be modified

either up with these supply depots or down when they become dirty because these little black disks that are scattered around the coastline are dirty disks they're the disk spots are dead zones where nothing can survive and adjacent are dirty which is going to be harder to survive and this is just the radiation encroaching so after you check to see if anybody is starving you remove the starving people and then you can take four actions and those actions let you move people around hopefully you know probably away from the radiation um you can also press gang the civilization some of them are neutral you press gang them into being your civilians so you say hey you are ussr now you can also militarize your civilians turning them into little soldiers and this game feels like a war game to a certain extent i mean i'm not experienced with war games but it has a war game feel to it but you have very few um actual military units you start the game with a couple of these and you can have i think at most four of these uh military units on the board and one action that you can do is attack you can only attack with these military units and you have to be adjacent to the opposing military unit and it's really simple you just remove both of the military units so it's it's a eye for an eye type situation and then you place a dead zone down onto the closest dirty spot to where the attack came from and the reason i'm going into this minutia is because this is where the game got really interesting for me and honestly this is how i won the game spoiler alert i did win this game uh because as we're starting to play this game uh my friend myself and my friend matt uh we were you know avoiding the dead zones and we were kind of pushing people around you can threaten people

like make them flee a hex and then maybe they starve at the start of the next round um but there was a moment you know maybe like 20 25 minutes into the game where i realized i could position myself um next to uh my opponent's area where they had a whole bunch of their units and they had a oh they had a whole bunch of civilians and they had one army person i ran over and then i did an attack and that spot was dirty so by doing the attack it eliminated my soldier and their soldier and it put a dead token in the middle of their spot right in the middle of a bunch of their civilians that was the closest dirty spot and then my turn ended my friend's turn started starvation happens first and everybody on a dead zone dies so that everything on that spot was wiped out and that was the moment where we were both like oh okay starting to see how this game clicks because if i'm being honest i was not enjoying this game for the first 30 of it and this is i've only played it once but we started playing this game and i had such a hard time parsing who's starving who isn't what is what's a dead zone what isn't what should i even be doing here and we were just kind of like doing things at the beginning of the game there's like none of these black tokens around you know most of antarctica is open and we were just kind of taking turns and being surprised at how things happened and and i was just kind of frustrated trying to parse the game situation and honestly like 30 in i was like i guess this game isn't for me i'm really not enjoying it but then around the moment you know maybe 30 40 in when i made that one particular attack we both realized oh there's like a whole nother level here where you can be so offensive even as you lose your military units to place these down that's when the game really started to

open up and honestly right before that like a turn or two before that my friend did a crazy threat in turn i moved one of my soldiers out of position and then my friend moved their soldier in and threatened a bunch of my people out and they all starved and i was like what and at that point i felt like oh man i'm losing this game and then like a turn or two later i was like wait a second i did my attack and you know dead zoned a bunch of their stuff and it just went back and forth and there was this moment probably more like 60 through the game where i felt like i could see the code of the matrix if that makes sense like like suddenly you know you see all the lines falling down you're like i get it like suddenly it was way easier to grok where things were not necessarily what you could do to play well because i think honestly you know i didn't play well this entire first game i think you have to play this game a few times to get good at it but it suddenly got fun like it started to get fun about 30 in and about 60 in it got really fun and really interesting and fascinating because i felt like suddenly i was making smart decisions because i understood the ramifications of those decisions so i've only played this game once but um it really turned around on me over the course of that one play i went from pretty much actively disliking it to really enjoying it and you know i did win the game so maybe that's part of my bias but i will say that my friend who lost um also quite enjoyed it uh and actually speaking of the endgame state i have an image of what antarctica looks like when the game is over it's just dead zones everywhere and you win the game once all of your opponent's units are gone and in this position a dead zone happened to eliminate the final us civilian from the map and you know us as the ussr we had a whole bunch of civilians and a couple of armies out

there it was a pretty solid victory overall as long as you don't consider the fact that you know there's like four hexes left that are hospitable on the entire planet for a human civilization and these people are probably not long for this world but you know what they lived longer than the the us so that means a win uh now actually one thing i didn't mention coming back to these dead zones is there are these cards they're kind of forecast cards that tell you where new dead zone tokens are going to be arriving on the main map and also a new civilian token that gets added in and again you can pull these neutral civilians in and press gang them to turn them into your people and as long as there are more of your people alive when every one of your opponents are gone that's how you win and this is also a part where the game started to click because for the first 30 i was like barely even paying attention to the first card and then the next 30 to like 70 of the game i was paying tons of attention to the first card but no attention to the second card because that just seemed like one thing too many i just it was just too much but then the moment it all kind of clicked is when i was like okay i got it this card's what happening what's happening right after my turn and the next card is what's happening right after my opponent's turn which means as long as my units are safe through both of these cards then then that's looking pretty good like having this two-card forecast means you do have a random deck but you can have quite a bit of control you can say okay do i flee or not uh for much of the game my opponent had a unit way over here in the i don't know if it's the west a peninsula of antarctica and this got more and more dead more dead zones got piled up and he kept leaving that person there because they knew they could just run through the

dead zones once they militarized which they did um but they figured there was no reason to run through the dead zones until they could see that suddenly okay the last that spot is finally threatened so this game really is all about what do i need to do right now you look at the forecast where the dead zone's coming and how is that going to affect me how is it going to affect my opponent and can i make it worse for them you know maybe you do an attack with one of your soldiers putting down a dead zone in a spot that's going to impact how the next dead zone's going to be laid by the game itself um also there's a subtle rule about if there's ties on where the tokens go down they have to go into empty spots so you can control that tempo as well because if two spots are occupied and one has neutral civilians and one has your enemy civilians you're gonna choose the enemy ones but there were many times where i took that decision away from my opponent by fleeing out of one of those spots or maybe threatening the neutral one out so they'd have to place the dead token on the empty spot there's just a lot of control that you have in this really strange game and it didn't feel as depressing as i thought it would i guess because we were thinking about the game from very abstract gaming perspective i mean if you really think about the theming of what's going on it's it's atrocious um but uh overall there was just so much control and there's such a narrative to this game um as you know it seems like we're losing oh it seems like we're winning and there was one point where uh a little bit later on from this image um due to a couple of attacks we actually had a wall of dead zones between all of the red tokens and all the blue tokens so at that point it was like the situation was getting so bad that we almost went into our own enclaves but then we like ran a soldier through dead

zones through that wall to then you know drop more dead zones and blast things from the other side it was just oh man very fascinating in a way and i'm looking forward to playing this one more i know my friend matt quite enjoyed it so i think we'll probably play this one more in the future i don't think we're gonna be like clamoring to play it but i'm really glad that it clicked to a certain extent and i'm sure if it takes three five eight months for me to play this game again then i'm probably gonna have that first 30 where i'm like wait what's going on now but knowing that it can click at a certain point and that you still have that narrative even if you're not making great decisions uh means that um i'm happy i'm happy to have played this game and i'm happy to hopefully play this game in the future and introduce this to uh some of my friends there's some people i play games with i think this will bounce hard off of but people who enjoy the overall narrative of how a game could go i think will really fall into the the story that progresses through this like as i said uh my opponent had this civilian way off on the peninsula the dead zones were piling up they militarized that civilian and then more neutral civilians showed up on a boat and they press gang those and then at a certain point they said okay let's all run and they ran through a bunch of dead zones um actually now they think back on it i wonder if only the army could have run through those dead zones i wonder if the civilians could have we might have got that rule wrong it's entirely possible we got other rules wrong but the narrative of that moment we were talking about like you know what what it must be like for those people way off there on the side and then trying to come over here and rejoin the other enclave and stuff it just it just had had a story to it in a way that i'm not used to in games like this and i was really impressed by all that

looking at the comments reishi says uh i hoped we'd move to antarctica because that's where all the penguins are at yeah there's no uh there's no penguins in this game i think you can assume that penguins are doing just about as well as the humans and you know thematically if you think about too much it does fall apart and that's fine like you're trying not to starve out here but you're just being on the open ice in antarctica which is one of the most hostile places on the planet anyway so you'd think that it would you wouldn't be able to survive off just like melt water but maybe that's what they're surviving off of maybe it's penguins and whatnot and the uh maybe these dirty areas um you can survive less because it's hard to wipe out what uh wildlife is actually there um i listened to a podcast uh interview with the designer of this game and uh i vaguely remember they said that they didn't put a whole lot of research into doing it in antarctica it just it worked so they went for it like you know don't don't worry about too much of why it would probably never actually happen it's just it's a framework for you know this very grandma setting and uh yeah it looks like some other people are are definitely agreeing with me uh the starvation phase in the game is brilliant i will say that was my biggest frustration in the first third of the game because there's a lot of hexes and we're just like constantly checking and checking and checking is this starving is it starving and then you know as we got more into the game it kind of emerged also we more had a feeling of like okay we've checked everything what has happened since the previous starvation phase well a couple of dead zones arrived and you know we can parse that and also you know one person took four actions we could parse that so we stopped feeling like we had to check the entire map after every uh at the end of every single turn and that streamlined

the situation quite a bit as well so yeah that is uh meltwater it's it's a fun game with uh an awful super grim setting uh so let's move on to uh another abstract game that um has a very abstract setting this is square on sale uh this game is old it came out in 2005 and i had not heard about it until a month or two ago i think and this is a very peculiar abstract style game i played it once and it is effectively um othello with a turn-by-turn auction mechanic and you know i say auction it might send some people screaming it's it's not your typical kind of auction i'm going to talk a little bit about the specifics of how this works because it's it's it's really strange so at a very high level this is othello you have a square board a square grid it's a five by five and what you're trying to do is put your tokens down onto these zones and whenever you do that and then there's um like a line between one of your tokens and another one of your tokens you put more of your tokens on top essentially flip the color of all of those but this is a multiplayer game that you can play i think up to four players so um you know if we take an example here we've got a yellow token and then there's three red uh in a row so if i put a yellow token on the end of that row we would have yellows on either end of a row or i guess in this case a column and then two red in the middle and you would plunk yellows on down on top of both of those so by putting one token down you actually kind of put three tokens down and that works just like othello but the way this gets crazy is because the way you actually put your

initial tokens down is by winning multi-turn auctions now on your turn what you do is you make a bid on one of these squares you have a certain number of these money tokens and you place the bid down and then you put one of these little auction counters and this is really where the game gets fascinating because if i start an auction let's say i'm the teal player and i start an auction on a location that has no other money on it i put like maybe three money down on that i take one of these two pip auction markers then i put it there and that means that it's gonna be two full turns two full rounds around the table before i win that so i put that money there my turn's over the next person goes the next person goes now it's my turn again the first thing that i do is every spot where i have i'm winning an auction i lower the counter so that two will turn into a one and that means i'm still not winning that auction until it goes all the way around the table again where i'm the person who has the highest bid on that spot um so that means you know from a bid perspective a your opponents have a lot of time to try and beat you and b you're really locking up your money for a long time as well because you have a certain amount of money i can't remember exactly what it is maybe 20 tokens or something like that and once your money's on the table you can't use it for future auctions so at the beginning of every one of your turns you count down every one of your things so if i was the yellow player and uh at the start of my turn i have an auction here with a with a counter of one then that means this has gone around enough i remove the counter and then i leave the money there and i put my token down on top of that spot um after i do that obviously you can othello that token as i mentioned earlier and then the money

stays there so the beginning of every one of your turns you pull one money back from every one of the squares in the middle of the board but every square on the perimeter which is stronger from an othello perspective that money stays there until you spend an entire turn just taking one money back from each of those so there is a really fascinating tempo to this game where at the start the board is empty and players are putting these tokens down right in the middle and again at the start of your turn you pull one toke one money token back from the from every one of the stacks that you've won from the middle so that means in the beginning of the game you're spending money and then you're getting it back and you're spending money and you're getting it back but a certain point these tokens are piling up to the point where people start going around the edge and then the tempo goes i don't know up down the amount of money that you have available to you goes down and the tempo of the game goes up because suddenly you can start winning auctions for less and less money because everybody has less money because it's becoming more and more locked in fact if you put money if you win one of these corners which are the strongest parts in the game the only way to get your money back is for somebody else to outbid you there you can't take this money back so it's lost forever effectively and that is so interesting and i don't know if i'm doing a good job of describing how this works but um the last mechanic that i do want to say well i guess there's two other things the first is that if you start an auction on a if you outbid an auction like let's say i wasn't the yellow player this auction is happening it's got two money on it and it's got a one counter so it's gone around the table once if it goes around the table one more time the yellow player will take it let's say i want to outbid that and i'm the red player there's two money there of yellows i put three money down yellow takes their money back so that

means they have more liquidity to try and compete in other auctions and then that token stays at a one it does not reset back to a two so it's this crazy game of a hot potato where there's a whole bunch of potatoes and they're getting hotter so you have situations on your turn you can only put your money down on one spot so do you put it down over here and hot potato that over to you or do you maybe say well i'm gonna start a new auction over here put a new counter and just have all these counters ticking down and there's no way my opponents can deal with all of those and that was just really fascinating i really quite enjoyed that the last mechanic to say is that when the game is over you get points equal to the um the number of tokens on a stack that you won so if there's a stack of four tokens with a teal on top then teal gets four points if you uh win a stack of one token you just get one point so you're more and more incentivized to win stacks as they get taller and taller now this game took oh about 90 minutes 80 minutes something like that i don't think it was more than an hour and a half to play uh we played it at three players and it was a wacky experience um i will say that i wasn't blown away by the game but i really enjoyed it and i found it mechanically fascinating i also found it befuddling like trying to figure out how the heck you actually play this game well that's a very difficult thing to do i said it was kind of like hot potato but it also felt like uh whack-a-mole maybe whack-a-mole's an even better analogy because you're not sure which mold whack and sometimes you're like well maybe instead of whacking a different wall i'm just going to add another mole on the board and then my bones have to worry about that and i did a really good job of utilizing the corners um i think i i transitioned to the corner uh auctions

at the right time which meant i lost a lot of my liquidity which made it difficult but i put a bunch of tokens down and there were a key moment where some one of my opponents outbid me on a corner and then i they won that so i got that money tokens back and then i immediately started another auction on that spot when none of my opponents were in a position to actually compete with me on that so they won they put tokens down and then i won again on top of that put more tokens down and got even more points and honestly i think this was a blowout i think i had like 40 points compared to like 23 or 20 points from the opponents but the game ends on two different triggers which honestly i won't go into the specifics of but if the game had gone one turn longer not even one round but one turn past mine i ended the game then i would have lost and somebody else would have won because they were just about to place a token down to put a whole bunch of their tokens because of the othello situation in fact i have the end game situation um here so you can kind of see just how much money ended up being locked out on the sides like you're not pulling any of this back and in fact when the game was over there was zero money on any of the internal spots because we were so focused on trying to win these uh these positions around the outside because of the othello mechanic just stacking things more and more throughout the middle uh so yeah this game has a fascinating tempo it's got tons of decisions it's got crazy whack-a-mole uh mechanics and i'm not really sure how much i like it i liked it i i definitely enjoyed it but i'm not sure if i was overjoyed by it like i was contemplating maybe purchasing the game and i think after playing it once i'm happy to play this game more but i don't think i'm going to run out and buy it

because i don't know i'm not really sure how much it would actually get played there are copies of it on sale on the amazon the japanese amazon store i don't know the more i talk about it right now i'm like maybe i should have picked up a copy yeah this game really was really fascinating and that's the thing it is super fascinating but how fun is it for me i think it's like a 7 out of 10 fun which is you know definitely saying a lot that's that's better than a lot of games that i play but i'm not sure if it's enough for me to run out and grab um the fact that it's got this multi-round auction vibe where it's not like you know the standard auction like i talked about in gmno it's like your turn is just starting a new auction or outputting somebody else on an auction boom that's it trying to calculate this stuff out and see where everybody else is i think there's a lot of interesting uh pathways you can go to go down with your brain and some people are gonna like that more than others and i think i i land somewhere in the middle on it i did want to talk about it today because i think it's a fascinating game and i did enjoy it overall i would not say no to playing this one more in the future but i think yeah i don't think it's the kind of game that i'm gonna rush out to suggest if that makes sense um i will enjoy playing it if i have more opportunities but it it broke my brain in some strange ways and i won this game by a lot uh i don't think i necessarily won because of randomness uh honestly part of the reason i won is because my opponents didn't realize i was going to be able to do something and then just end the game immediately and part of that is crunching through the options and paying attention to can my opponent and the game on their turn that is going to change what i do on my turn and you know there's definitely moments where you can capitalize on that and some people are going to like those kind of

things more than others so yeah that's square on sale it's like a 14 year old game it's an amazing combination of multi-round auctions with othello type abstract mechanics it played great at three i can imagine it's even crazier at four um it's definitely a tactical chaotic situation where you're still trying to think multi-mini turns in the future and maybe that's where my brain is at is the fact that it feels like a tactical game where you have to think two plus turns in the future and that that is kind of a clash which is fascinating interesting but also a little bit frustrating which lends me to feel a bit gray about it overall like happy to have played it happy to try it again but but it didn't click in a way that other games have and it didn't click in a way that makes me like extremely excited to play this one again in the future well we've now reached the fifth and final game that i'm talking about today and this game is twisty tracks now that's not currently the name of it on uh bgg the name is uh in polish and i'm not even going to attempt to uh spell it you can find the spelling in the description of this if you want um but this is a game that i first learned about a couple of months ago and i immediately got so excited about it because it looked so cute this is a train themed game but this is not a train game this is a relatively light tai lang style game where you are building out these crazy networks of tracks in front of you and there's a bunch of photos of it online on pgg and i just instantly fell in love with this game and i looked to see if i could get a copy everything i found said seemed to in tone that it was only published in polish a few years ago and so i actually found a reasonably

priced copy i think it was like 39 after shipping to get this game shipped from poland over here to california so i bought it and then about a week after it arrived i found out that it has been signed actually and it's going to have a north american distribution next year uh i didn't know the publish which publisher that was going to be until this morning actually i can tell you that rio grande has actually signed this game and they're planning on publishing it and they're going to title it twisty tracks which is why that's what i'm going to be calling it here even though it's technically not called that in board game geek just yet i'm just i guess ahead of the curve now let's talk about this game uh because every player is going to take one of these borders they put it in front of them and then you take four trains uh one of each color and you put them onto the starting train stations now within this border there is space for a four by four grid of square tiles and one of those is already kind of done the border kind of uses that so there's essentially 15 holes in front of you and every person has an identical deck of these train tiles that are square and at the start of the game you shuffle all of these up and then the structure of the game is super straightforward everybody randomly draws the top tie from the stack they then all simultaneously think about where they want to put this tile down and it has to extend out a previous track once everybody's decided what they want to do then we all simultaneously place the tile down and then all of our trains move as far as they can along that track now as i said you start with four trains in their colors and this has a very thorough vibe for it if you're familiar with suro or other games like indigo it's one of those games where you put a tile down and then that extends a path

and you have to go as far down the path as you can but um in this game you have four tokens each every player has their own four tokens so you're building out your own set and yes the tracks are very twisty you make some really twisty things and there are multiple ways to play this game this is definitely a family weight game um that there's a basic way to play and then like these two more expert modules but what i'm going to tell you is with all the expert stuff added in because even that is a pretty lightweight game now when you move your trains you actually get one point for every border that you cross so if you put a tile down and then you move your purple train like onto a tile that's a point it leaves the tile to a new one that's a point and if it curves around back onto a previous tile that you already scored you get another point so that's another point there and it moves on to another one and then the train just goes until it it stops until it hits a dead end uh or until it hits a train station so around the outside of the border everyone has the exact same setup of the what is it seven different train stations and when one of your trains reaches that station you take one of your tokens and you plunk it down onto the topmost uh indicator for that on this train station board and essentially it's a race you want to be the first person to the train station and the farther the train stations are away from the starting area the more victory points you get for going there um so yeah it's just a mixture of trying to get points for sending your trains through lots of twisty announce like the longer the train goes the more points you get and then the sooner it gets to train stations the more points you'll get compared to your opponents and you just keep playing this game until everyone has all of their trains at a station or until everyone has placed all 15 of their tiles and that's it so it's just a maximum of 15 turns and they're all simultaneous and you score

simultaneously and this game is just a joy it's just a splendid joy to play it's it i just taught you all of the rules and i played this game twice and i want to start by talking about um the rules that come in the box i mean first of all the rules were in polish uh but fortunately um somebody helped me out and sent me an english translation um i did a google translate which mostly got there but i i got an english translation as well not an official one but the game is simple enough and i i really enjoyed just the the toy factor of this game of putting the tiles down and zipping your little trains along and then that that feeling of like okay i could put this tile down now and that'll connect up to the uh you know orange station um can anybody else connect up with the orange station and everybody's thinking simultaneously you might see somebody maybe testing out maybe putting the tile there maybe they'll put it somewhere else and you're not sure where they're gonna go and then you all drop them down simultaneously and you see like do you want to push your luck and wait and you know get a little bit farther on the tracks to squeeze out those points or do you get unlucky and somebody goes to that station and now when you go there you're gonna get less points um and honestly that's that's the game and it's just it's just wonderful to play but there's an extra wrinkle to this and that is that on board game geek the designer of this game jeffrey allers a couple of years ago posted a alternate train station board and um i want to show that to you now um so this train station board not to go into the specifics of it um but it's harder it's more challenging because there's a lot less spaces on it for you to put tokens and if you go to put a token down onto one of these train stations and there isn't space you put

it down the bottom and you lose 10 victory points for it which is a ton of victory points now on this harder board there's an exact number of spots for every single train so that means if everybody plays optimally based off what other people are going to do no one is going to suffer these negative points but if you don't play optimally and you find yourself running into a station that is already full up you're not getting points for going to that station you're losing a ton of points and so the uh recommendation along with this alternate board was that this is a way to play the game with people who want a crunchier experience because the game that i talked about before it's not crunchy it's pleasant it's lovely but you know it's it's very friendly as you're uh running yourself into various stations and you're getting points and oh no i'm you know one of the last people to go there i guess i'm gonna get one point or zero points but you're not losing a devastating ten points for getting in their last and i have played this game at three players with the original rules and two players with this advanced board and i'll say that i love the game at both of these counts but i'll say that when i played this one two players with my wife jessica she didn't like this alternate board as much because she enjoyed how freewheeling and splendid and easygoing the base rules are and she likes mean games like tough uh heavyweight euro games but just for the weight of this game she felt like she would rather not feel stressed as she's putting these trains down and i totally get that but i will say that it's my understanding that some form of this board is also going to be available in the u.s printing of the game i'm not going to say it's exactly like this i'm not going to commit to any of that but it's my current understanding that the original boards and i think this are going to be both there so that you can play

a pleasant version of twisty tracks and you can play mean twisty tracks where you are sweating bullets the whole time and i think that it's great that both of those are available i do want to say i skipped right over it but i wanted to show what the final version of this looks like once you fill your whole board in i took a photo of it because there are just so many tracks they like the name of this game really works out when it's called twisty tracks it's my understanding that the original polish name is actually the name for a popular children's song about trains i think it translates to the train that travels far or something like that which is lovely but i think twisty tracks also make sense because you're just twisting and winding all over the place and honestly i love this type of mechanic there's a reason we own indigo still which is a reiner kenicia game that has putting down hexagonal tiles and you move neutral tokens around and then you try to orient them into your own little goals i think indigo is wonderful in this game you have a similar kind of thing going on except you have your own area like they're not neutral they're yours and you're doing your own thing and i honestly really dislike soro which is like you know a simpler version of this but like you only have one pawn and if you just run into a wall or run into a dead end then you're just done and uh that's just not fun for me so i enjoy making crazy pipelines there's a wonderful um endorphin head when you realize you're like oh i'm gonna put this tile down and you're like hold on a second that means i'm gonna go over here and spiral through that and spin through this and go through that and you're like oh my gosh i just went through like 15 tiles and then landed in a train station and you just feel like you know you made a three-point shot or a half court shot or something like that hole-in-one

when you do those kind of moments and you know that's why i like in games and then you know when it all wraps up this game takes like 30 minutes to play because it's all effectively simultaneous so i'm super impressed with this game um right now i think it's very difficult to get a copy i'm not sure if the polish versions are even available anymore but again the polish version doesn't even come with english rules in the box and it's my understanding that uh rio grande is going to be publishing a version of this one in early next year so not too far off so if this one sparks your interest at all then definitely add it to you know your wish list or whatever and keep an eye out for an official announcement um specifically rio grande told me that i was okay to to say this so i guess to a certain extent i'm kind of announcing it uh but uh this is a lovely game and uh i fell in love with it the moment i saw an image of it and then i got to play it and i fell in love with it even more and maybe that's just a bias maybe i was expecting to love it and therefore i really liked it but um for what it is it's just a great time it plays so quickly it the rules teach is so fast and it's just it's just got a fun toy factor-ness to it where you just like you know you get giggling as you realize how these things can work and all the different uh ways you can make it happen um i think in the future i would probably continue to want to play with the stressful board because i like that extra feeling of risk but i could totally see enjoying playing this one either way successful geek says it reminds me a little bit of whistle stop um yeah i guess to a certain extent whistle stop is a bezier game that uh came out a few years ago and that one i believe had hexes and um you move i think your own trains but along various paths but that one was more of a medium weight euro-y game where you're acquiring resources

and spending them at various action points this game is just about trying to make as long a track as possible and i did i guess kind of gloss over the fact that you know the rules i taught you were like the quote-unquote most advanced way to play this game but there are simpler ways to play this game where you don't score for going to stations at all it's just about going as far as you can on the tracks and there's an inverse i think where it's just about trying to get to the stations so you can play this with less and less complexity to make it more enjoyable for probably playing the game with younger and younger people i haven't played it with young people but i imagine it would play very well at that especially considering you can reign back on some of the scoring conditions and just play with some twisty tracks with your little trains well that is going to bring this one to a close uh thank you so much to everybody who stopped on by for the live feed for this one and uh for everybody who watched it afterwards uh and please let me know um if you are intrigued by any of these games what part of them really sticks out to you uh some of these are um somewhat well-known and some of them less so uh i do enjoy finding you know the odd diamond in the rough and i feel like the twisty tracks is certainly like that and honestly square on sale too i'm worried that maybe i was a little bit more negative there than i wanted to be because i i did enjoy playing that game and i feel like every uh every minute every time i think about it my opinion of it subtly changes but it never goes under like feeling like it was a really fun time that i would not mind playing again um just you know i have so many games in my collection i just worry how likely i'd be to be able to get a strange auctiony abstract game like that played uh but you know there's definitely a market for it uh there's a lot of people who enjoy those things and

i i can continue to play that one online if i want to as well uh so yeah i think that is going to bring this one to a close thanks again to everybody for watching this video as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer-level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to junketsgames.com support also if you enjoyed this video then please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved