Essen Spiel 2018: Pitching to Publishers
Transcript
hi I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming vlog and this video is actually a vlog unlike a lot of my other videos this one really is a video diary it's not a board game review video so you won't be seeing reviews of holding on the troubled life of Billy Kerr or Treasure Island or ever Dell or any of these games around me what you'll be seeing is me talking about my experiences of pitching designs to publishers similar to what I've done over the last few years the first time I did I think was about four or five years ago when I was my very first meetings with publishers and now of course I've started to make a few little inroads into the industry with a few games coming out and so now I'm meeting with publishers who already know me I'm meeting with other designers and this is a little video diary talking about those experiences good Morgan this is day day one of my sixth time at the SF spiel convention in 2018 last year doodle rush and Big Bazaar were released at the convention this year pic Coco gets its first essence peel release although it has been seen previously at UK Cannes Expo and some of the American conventions and also doodle rush gets its German release so no brand new games this year but once again I'll be pitching to various publishers and I've made these videos a few times over the years so don't think I did one last year it's getting a little bit more difficult because I have to be slightly vague because now I'm actually making some inroads into the industry I don't want to give anything away and I certainly don't want to offend anybody or share
any information I shouldn't so if you look back at my channel over the years you'll see a lot of videos where I'm very specific about in this meeting this was said and sometimes they're hugely positive things sometimes they're very negative things and so you get a real idea of the roller coaster ride that is pitching at a convention this year I've got more meetings than ever I think the first year I went to s and pitching I had 12 meetings with different publishers this year I have 30 spread over four days and actually this is the first year where I've had designers approaching me asking for meetings to talk about collaboration and just sort of meet and chat so that's been interesting I've had quite a few publishers contacting me rather than me going to them and actually recent months of managed to speak to quite a lot of mass-market publishers as opposed to just the well the hobby side of the market which essence feel largely covers so things have changed slightly in my sort of approach but basically is that it's the same thing I'm going to be doing half hour meeting half hour walk to the next meeting half hour meeting half hour walk to the next meeting and I have seven prototypes with me this year which I'm going to be showing some of them are collaborations with a colleague in fact a lot of them are collaborations with various colleagues but I have a colleague with me and we're gonna have some joint meetings as well many of the
meetings are with publishers I've met before and but there are a few new ones as well so it's going to be an exciting and exhausting few days and if I have the energy I'll try and keep you informed good morgen it's very early in the morning on day two of the spiel convention already my voice is going off yeah it's it's an exhausting thing going around that fair and talking to so many people in such a sort of dry oppressive sort of environment with all that background noise and everything there's so many people yesterday I had nine meetings with different publishers some that I'd met many times before some which were brand new I thought I'd talk briefly about how I get these meetings what I do before the fair is I send out emails increasingly I'm finding that publishers won't meet with you unless you present them with the rules of the game maybe or some of them will say they'll only meet with you if you send them a video which I always do and so they get a short video a short overview but I've got a colleague with me this year who I'm collaborating with and he's been sending cell sheets out to people and if they like the cell sheet they're usually willing to have a meeting so it's not hard to get these meetings as long as you have a good game and sort of professional approach upfront I think so nine meetings I'll talk through some of them I'm not going to go into any great detail about who I'm talking about and
I'm not going to go through them in any particular order so let's have a look at the list here so a couple of people that I met who were new to me other companies weren't new to me but I hadn't met these individuals before and you find some companies have a very strong brand you know you know going in what sort of games they're likely to be looking for based on what they've done in the past and they have a real identity others you go everything you look at their past catalogue and they've done all sorts of different types of games they've done children's games they've done card games in heavy strategy games at various points over the last few years and so it's very hard to pinpoint what they're likely to like now having seven prototypes with me albeit all of them pretty light hoping they would say to them at the start these meetings look like I don't really know what you're looking for right now in 2018 or for 2019 what sort of games do you want to see and then tried to fit my pitch to to that and that's kind of I've yeah a couple of them have been interested in what I've been finding with these smaller publishers I suppose is that they're they're asking for print and paid play files and usually I will I'll give them a prototype I'm happy to hand them a prototype I bring lots of prototypes to the convention but it has saying they don't want them because they don't want the cost of sending them back whereas with printed play files they can just print it off and make the game and play and that's cheaper for them my worry with that is will they do it if I
send them the files will they actually print it and play it so I'm very tempted to go back to those boots and say look here's the prototype you don't have to send it back just take it away and write that off because although that's time and money that I've spent on those prototypes I mean at least it they're gonna get played I think if I hand them a copy so so I may be revisiting those companies and giving them copies what else if we had meeting with people I Eve met many times over the years got to know quite well which is always nice I had one meeting with a company that I liked very much and I showed them three games and two of the games he said he really liked the games but either they've just made a game which is similar in feel to the one I've shown him or they've got one coming up in next year which is already signed which is similar to what I'm showing them so he was very keen to say you're absolutely on the right tracks you know what we're about you're showing us the right stuff you just need to show it to us earlier you know cuz it and eventually you're gonna get the game in there that we're gonna publish and so that's that's reassuring that's that's good I've got that one of my games is a trick-taking game and this year the the spiel convention is absolutely full of trick-taking games they're everywhere I looked I filtered the the list of games by trick-taking as a category and there were 27 of them so I'm not sure how sustainable making trick-taking games is right now maybe give it a few years and
then start the kinetic taking games again cuz I really enjoy making that sort of game what else oh yeah a couple of really big companies that I've met with it's really nice when you meet with real sort of market leaders and they tell you that your games are you know on track they're interesting they want to take away prototypes they tell you they're clever games they're elegant games are streamlined and that's real validation of sort of the work I've been doing over the last few years I suppose because there's always the highs and the lows but those moments are the real highs I also know how easily that can drop after the convention that interest can drop away and you might just you might not even get an email at all or you might get any mojo saying yes we've looked at the game we're not interested after all the enthusiasm in the meeting you can get a fairly blunt email later so I'm getting excited but obviously you have to sort of temper that circuit just remember you know a promise there we're not even a promise but but a an enthusiasm there doesn't necessarily translate into a signed contract later
good Morgan did stay three of the spiel convention and just about to begin just about to head off down to the convention yesterday was a good day had about eight meetings with publishers of various different sizes and I used to be a little bit more afraid of that the idea of giving you a game to somebody who's whose are relatively small or new publisher but you see when you see the care and attention that they lavished on these games and the support that they give to the games when compared to some of the bigger companies who if one one small game sort of falls away from their catalog that's no big deal to them I think there's something in that and so I always find these even the smaller publishers really worth talking to and seeing what they could do with your games so I had a lot of positive responses as I think I mentioned it yesterday in the vlog so many people this year are saying to me that they want print and play files rather than prototypes and I'm sure they'd love a prototype but they just don't want to send it back and I'm in one company I showed them six of my seven prototypes I only didn't show them the seventh because we ran out of time and he wanted copies of all of them to take away which is hugely promising I mean and this is a big big company but he said yes we've got but we have facilities to make all of these games as prototypes you just send us a printed play files we can make them as saying you sure because some of
these to me how is to construct no no no we can do it so so I mean that's that's good if they can that's that's great what else from yesterday I'm starting to realize this is the first year where I've come with they're explicitly children's game so again it is designed for children and the last couple of days has been a bit of a learning curve in terms of what different age groups are used to what different age groups can accept and of course this is outside of you know local play testing this is this is on a much broader scale so looking at all the range of harbour games for example they all say 5 Plus virtually all of them age five and up when you play them they are so simple so even when I design came ink I'm really really really simple and then I look at those and they are okay we need to go down a notch again so so that's that's been a bit of a learning curve I've enjoyed that actually looking the Explorer in children's games I've realized that that children's market spiel there are just as many children's games coming out as there are at host games and of course that's what you'd expect because children play games don't they but that's a whole sector that's largely ignored among most of the professional designers that I meet they're not designing for that market they're designing for the the adult market but it's enjoyable trying to get into that sort of very simple stuff good
Morgan it is early on the final day of this real convention now and I'm about to set off down to the convention hall shortly for a final day of meetings and I think I have slightly fewer today let's see one two three four meetings that's every day is it a really relaxed day I did I do actually have five but one of them I'm going to cancel because my coat is all in her if the games has already shown them the games yesterday and they didn't like them so there's really not much point in me going to meeting with them today as well so unfortunately we have to make a late cancellation of that one but the day yesterday and was a very full day and felt like a roller coaster really there was so much going on I had various sort of meeting some informal some more formal talking about various possible collaborations and you know I having a little bit of success over the last year as actually means that as people who want to work with me which is wonderful but of course those are all sort of future projects and so it's hard to pinpoint exactly what's happening there so you're having those conversations and then you're having conversations about the suitcase full of prototypes that you've got now which are kind of made my very first meeting of the day was at 10:00 in the morning and when I arrived I found that actually they weren't expecting me till 11 I suspect that's because sometimes when you book these meetings they send you to a a sort of online poll where you choose your meeting slot and I never know whether my
computer is converting that to UK time or whether the time on that poll is in German time and so sometimes you get it wrong and in this case I think it was probably my mistake and I got it wrong we thought it was 10 o'clock one actually was at you at 11 but fortunately my colleague went for me showed Darko designs and actually very kindly showed one of my games to them as well and from what he tells me they really liked my game very much as well as the co designs so I'm going to go and give them a prototype of my game and today I had meeting with an extremely enthusiastic gentleman most enthusiastic gentleman I met at the fair and I had a meeting with lesson - yes - people you know of still friendly but you go from one extreme to the other you go from somebody who will sit and shake their head as they look at your game know just where their heart and their sleeve is obvious and not impressed by what you're showing them and then you show the very same game to somebody else and they'll say well how that it's just fantastic you know you did such a good job with this and so you just have to take those highs with the lows and and and and you know it's a strange it's a strange experience it is this this convention I also had a meeting where I was talking to her publisher about I mentioned in a previous video that I made in my in my Essen preview video actually that a couple of years ago I designed the game
very similar to what CG have put out as trap words and CG you were totally unaware of what I was doing but I'd mentioned this in my video and the publisher said to me hi honey you had a game that was very similar to trap words why didn't you show it to us to experience was what I did I showed it to you to your colleague about 18 months or so ago and they didn't like it so so you know being angry with your colleague not with me but yeah trap words is great I've picked up a copy of trap words and two to play because it certainly looks prettier by my prototype the prototype was a fun game but this has got that great dungeon crawling thing going on it's it's it's a really attractive game
so the essence peel Convention has now finished its the morning I'm about to fly back home to to Wales and yesterday was another roller coaster Soliday actually yesterday was Australian day I'd have one good meeting one bad meeting one good meeting one bad meeting and had very few bad meetings throughout the fair but yesterday a couple of meetings where and I mean when I say bad what I mean is they didn't they weren't interested in the games I mean they weren't rude but but it is strange how the same game you can show it to someone anything it's super excited about it and then you walk just up and around the corner and you speak to somebody else and they really see nothing in it at all and you know both the sort of well-respected companies both know what they're talking about but I guess then it just becomes a matter of personal taste but some exciting new avenues possibly coming up yesterday from those meetings I suppose one thing that sort of I remember from the very first time I started pitching games in Essen which was about five years ago something like that and one of my very first meetings I remember meeting this gentleman I was very nervous I'm gonna show him my games and I showed him an early prototype of Pico ko at the time and and he was sort of interested in it they didn't end up taking that game on us as you know as
evidently has gone on to become one of brain games his games but we met with that same gentleman again this year as I have done every year since so I meet with this this guy every year and I said how would he remember that time when I showed you that game bin and now it's out to speak cocoa and he said yes sir he said oh yeah that was that was my very first meeting I just started working here yeah and you've realized that you know you're you're all nervous about these meetings and and you think that you're the you're the sort of the amateur and but but the publishers are there that you know they're going to all these same sort of things and my co designer he said he that waiting for a meeting in the overheard the publisher was talking to a big distributor and this was a big publisher and they were talking in you know millions of boxes in warehouses and all this sort of thing and the publisher was just saying that the distributor was just saying bluntly to the publisher right well I'm interested in this game I'm not interested in this game in this game you've just got too much air in this box you know you've just put that there just to just to make it look more expensive and my customers aren't gonna fall for that and you realized that the publishers are going through exactly the same experience that the designers are when the designers are shown to publishers the publishers happen to save experience when they're shown to the distributors and trying to get their games to market so as always it's been an educational week it's been an
exciting week it's been an exhausting week it's been fun but I'm quite glad to be flying home so yeah thanks very much if you've been watching and let you know how I get on