Tides of Time Vs Tides of Madness Board Game Review & Runthrough
Transcript
Here I am welcome all this amazing with inside time my trying to match to games seats change the time and thus the claustrum tribe itself had to make a collection and garnery victory
plays 15 minutes - card drafting games one survivor today I'll be comparing tide of time with tides and madness both games are set collecting card drafting games for two players tides of time plays raise fortifications build kingdoms and hopefully they withstand the tides of time long before civilization has ceased to exist in times of madness plays push to the brink of insanity to try and garner the most victory points and thereby win tides of madness it's a sequel to tides of time tides of time and tides of madness are both designed by Christian curler it's published by portal games the games are
for two players each game takes about 20 minutes when you compare the box cover art you've got this beautiful painter drawing of Cthulhu and you've got this beautiful monument here I think hands down both of them are equally as impressive so they both get my thumbs up comparing the theme of both games tides of time is more focused and centered around building those monuments building those fortifications that will last the test of time and hopefully place choose the right monuments over the three rounds they'll garlis and reap some very important victory points types of manners is set in the world of HP Lovecraft and some of these very well-known pieces of writing this game with the addition of madness tokens really raises the level of tension and the choices that players can make across the three rounds tides of madness gets my thumbs up the tides of time cards really evoke a sense of grandeur if you look at each of the individual cards they have their distinct flavor to them the art is incredibly detailed and immerses the players in the actual world that you're playing in each of the 18 cards are uniquely Illustrated in rich detail you'll also know that the art on the cards are enclosed by this white border which is really good because as the cards get worn out over time the art
still remains in pristine condition the tokens themselves are well printed and are highly durable the iconography or the suits of each cards are written very very clearly with the cards in tides of madness you'll notice that the art goes all the way to the edge of the card really encapsulating and exploiting all of the space on the card and making them as beautifully rich as possible madness tokens are very large durable and very functional the icons once again are very clear and very easy to understand when you compare the artwork in both games we can all agree that the artwork is nothing short of amazing I really really love it so this decision is really hard because I think ultimately it comes down to preference I will have to choose tides of madness
when you're comparing the rules and the instructions and the ease of learning and teaching someone else how to play I think both rules do it very very well I also like how the rules actually immerse you in the thing you've got this kind of traditional looking paper manuscript in these tides of madness with tides of madness if you have played tides of time before it'll be much easier to pick up tides of manners because you just only have to look at the slight and small rule additions
in my rules overview because the games are so similar I'm going to give a general overview of how the game works and then talk about some of the minor differences between the two so essentially tighter time and types of manners are pure card drafting games what you do is you take the 18 cards shuffle them up and then give each player five cards what's interesting about this game is that all 18 cards will be used at some point in the game so on the first round players would look at their cards they would pick a card that they would like to keep place it facedown in front of them and then pass the rest of the cards on to the other player for example this card here the great library has the scroll but you need to have the majority of the hands in order to gain the 7 victory points so it's really important to have a look at the synergy that is involved between the cards so this card might be a useful one to pick now because this card works in some ways with the library card here because you need a set of these to get 5 victory points and this will help you to get the 7 victory points later on so picking this card might be a quite a good choice although I've just noticed the Kings Nest is in here this is a really good card because if you're tying with another player you actually win the tying get the point so I'm thinking maybe I should choose the Kings Nest so I'm gonna place it down in front of me
place the other cards down the other player chooses their card and we swap our decks and then we reveal the cards we then or into our hand the four cards that were passed from the other player and I've got a look for cards that will help me gain lots of victory points for this round but also in the long term so seeing I've got a king's crown I might use this card as the one I choose and what you should see over time is the fact that you're building a to blow and as your tableau is built up you will hopefully maximize the amount of points that you're getting what's really important here is to make sure that you're observing what the other player is doing so that you can either try and interrupt this strategy but also try and deny the cards that they need in order to win because at the moment they've got the two Scrolls giving them a card which gives them victory points for the maximum amount of Scrolls is probably not such a good idea right now once there are no more cards this triggers the end of the round phase will then need to score the victory points based on the abilities of their cards plays then draw the five cards back into their hand and choosing one that they'd like to discard and that means removing it out of the game this strategy really can prevent the other player from garnering those very important victory points and then choosing one that they would like to keep which kind of embodies the
strategy and the long-term goals that they're trying to achieve within the game play then reveal the card that they've chosen to keep by using a token and reveal the card that they're discarding to the other player so they know what card has been removed and play should have three cards left in their hand they then draw another two cards to bring it back to five and then round two would begin where you were draft then you would record the score then you would choose another card to keep so therefore you should have two extra cards with tokens on them before the third round where you would have it to blow of seven cards in front of you and that would trigger the endgame and now in times of madness the gameplay is almost identical to tides of time with a few additional rules at the end of the round plays need to count up their tentacles that they have on their cards and they receive one madness token for each tentacle that they have this player has three cards with tentacles on them and this player only has one card with a tentacle on earth now whichever player has the most number of madness tokens they can choose at the end of the round to remove one madness token or gain four victory points straight away if a player ever receives up to nine madness tokens lose the game immediately welcome once again everybody to tribal council this game is about relationships
and alliances what trustee you have in your lives and your ability to win the sole title of board game survivor did you see strategy for using these madness tokens is when you can see that the other player has accrued a lot of these manners tokens you might be able to choose cards that don't have the tentacles on it in the third round and push the other player to gain more men as tokens than they actually need and thereby forcing them to lose the game beam out on this tropical arm for 29 days now you could go a little bit mad at you how do you control that madness addition to the madness token mechanic two of the cards actually have abilities that relate to the number of madness tokens you have the Necronomicon gives each player a victory point for every man is taken they have and the Dreamlands is a wild card but allows you to take a man as chokan from an opponent what's really important to notice that each descriptor on each card the suit that's on it doesn't always match with the suit that's actually on the card itself so a really good deep understanding of the synergy and the way the cards work together is really important here because you need to balance our effect of the card as well as gaining the suits that you need to maximize the points in comparing the
gameplay both games are essentially very very similar at their core drafting mechanism I feel like types of time allows you to maximize those really great combos between the cards if you really get some cards that synergy as well I think tides of time really excels in that department remembering what cards your players are playing cards that are in play and denying what your partner needs I think is a really important strategy for trying to win try to madness really takes it to another with those madness tokens in addition to those strategies I just mentioned with tides of time I think the madness tokens really levels out the playing field and really tries to make you work on your timing strategies timing when the best time to garner madness tokens is and timing when to use certain cards as well I feel like in this game the Kings Ness is slightly overpowered and gaining that card and using its ability really overthrows the game and really skewers it in one direction I mean it's not impossible to beat some with the Kings Ness but using it in a very strategic way can make the game feel a bit in balance whereas tides of manners getting those maximum combos isn't your only thing that you're trying to do reducing the amount of madness and leveling the madness up so you don't hit that 9 level is a really important thing to consider when you're playing the game I think tides of madness comes up on top in
terms of gameplay when you lay out 12 of the 18 cards from both tides of time and tides and manners you can see that the car abilities and effects themselves are quite similar except for tides of madness which I'd like to draw your attention to these two pairs of cards have some minor changes the original game had a leaf as a symbol on this card the maze of the Damned whereas the I'm gonna be gonna try and pronounce that has now the outer God's symbol but the effect is essentially the same sky pillars card and the deep ones the only thing those change is that now you get more victory points when you use the deep ones but there's the added effect of gaining madness these are the four pairs of cards that differ across the two games you can see there are two cards here that are devoted to effects that relate to the use of madness tokens then you've got cards here that help you score more victory points it's all about the different types of suits and whether you have a lot in one particular suit or whether they have the most numerous suits so so is more about collecting the actual sets of different suits and maximizing the scores that way is now time to vote so we have a tough decision to me tie the tie more tides of manners are the games so similar that you only really need one and not the other and what if I've never played tides of time all types of madness well it doesn't matter which one you get and probably have a really really good time
if you're asking for my preference I would say that probably tides of madness especially because those madness tokens really level out the gameplay a little bit more and add a little bit of complexity but if you're looking to get both of them I definitely get tides of time first just so you get an idea of how to play and even combine the suits is quite fun but then progressing to tides of madness is really essential now really good interesting variant if you do own both games there's a bit of a rarity it's supposed to be a face book but this is melding the two together is if you have four players that's really interesting to try and combine the two sets of cards together I don't know if that'll dilute the game down but it's an interesting thought or what you could do is have two copies of the same game and play the four players and see what happens by the time tides of madness the tribe has spoken