The No Pun Included Podcast Live at Virtually Expo
Transcript
hello dear youtube viewers what you're about to watch is a live taping of our podcast as part of virtually expo but unlike other versions of our podcast this actually has video i would like to warn you that as all live recordings it has some technical difficulties and at the start my microphone isn't working quite properly but this will be resolved very soon into the episode i hope you enjoyed this podcast episode and if you would like to hear more you can always visit notepad included.com podcast to listen to more of them hello and welcome to the live no pun included podcast i am elaine nopan and this is efka included it's gonna be a little bit different today because normally our podcast lasts about two and a half hours when we record it which is why we went and acquired a time dilation device which means that you people watching at home and us here in this studio will experience time differently to the rest of the world normally when we record our podcast it takes about four seven hours which is what we will have together talking about games meanwhile in the rest of the world only an hour will pass by elaine should i activate the device activate the device
three two one activate something did something i think something went wrong maybe i think something something happened let's uh let's let's just can we can we can you fix that can you fix that no the time dilation device has gone wrong well okay this is it's clearly unexpected hooray i i i don't think the time dilation device works no i think we went upside down and what we need to do is um is just talk about free games into think and and not take seven hours okay okay all right plus editing plus editing that's what we're going to do of course for people listening on their podcast devices at home after this has been streamed live the time dilation device joke might have not run quite as well but just imagine in your world that everything went wrong and and you'll sort of get yes yeah elaine what games are we going to be talking about we are going to be talking about today project elite oath and uh the lastly the puzzle deduction one and done segment which is escape room in a box flashback which you can see on our shelves behind us why don't we start with project elites why don't we start with one thing i want to say is that we will try and keep half an eye on the chat but we only have an hour uh so we'll try and answer some questions as we go along uh at the end of each game
segment that we talk about and also because this is a live recording of a podcast and normally these would be done at a convention hall where there is an audience and a live audience to engage us and participate with us we decided that we will anticipate when you would clap and then and and then we would clap you would you and then you should hear the clap your microphone is not working or not loud enough apparently apparently all right let me try and fix that uh should i do a little dance or something while you yeah why don't you do a drum roll i'll do a drum roll okay all right there you go how about now is the microphone working better now or not let us know yes yes yes do yes uh we hope that you're all very well um good afternoon morning afternoon more afternoon morning if you're in canada where it's like five o'clock in the morning yes if you're up in vancouver and watching this uh please do a shout out in chat so that we know that you're a real trooper or if you're in australia then it's probably nearly your bedtime uh so hopefully we our dulcet tones can take you into a soothing night's sleep how is my microphone is it better now it seems to be yes okay good all right uh i can hear you in texas at 7am good morning texas uh let's talk about which game should we talk about first project elite which you can see behind us on the top shelf or if you're listening at home you can't see
behind you can't see behind us imagining in your mind's eye imagine if you will a big box full of miniatures from simon games uh with lots of alien miniatures lots of cream colored very unpleasant like salmon pink yeah salmon pink unpleasant fleshy alien miniatures and your job is to exterminate oh okay okay wow well yeah whatever you want to do it's up to you really you can paint them if you like you can play the game if you like you can you can do both if you like what we did is we just played the game yeah we didn't paint them and uh what project elite is this has a complicated history so it was originally published uh by ortipia games it was a kickstarter uh when kickstarter got some money it was a very troubled production uh i believe our tpa game said they'll never do a game with minis after that um and uh it was delivered to backers and then was no longer available right for sale uh so you couldn't buy it and then scuttlebutt started that this game is actually pretty good uh and people are like i really want to buy this game but i can't because it's not available so you can buy it secondhand uh and i was sort of mildly getting interested in this game and then uh simon announced that they acquired the license for it they were gonna make a kickstarter and then tom vassell made his number one game of all time yeah and i was like all right i have to play this now so when we originally played project elite we didn't actually play the simon version we played we borrowed a copy
from a friend frank uh who had the original ortipia version right and we had a miserable time with it yeah a little bit um it but it was missing a piece and we just didn't we just didn't gel with it at all no it just felt like work like busy pointless busy work moving things and doing things and why are we doing this yeah however let's describe what the game is right yeah so in project elite uh you have a map you have characters that you play various heroes there's different maps yeah very sort of uh butch marine type characters they're supposed to be the elites like like yeah you know they'll they'll deal with the aliens they'll deal with the aliens if you have an alien right now outside your window this is the people that you would call it um like ghostbusters for ghosts these people aliens if you don't want them there if you want them there then these are not the best people to call no yeah not a very good company anyway so you play as these people and for eight rounds throughout the course of the game eight two minute timed rounds you will roll a lot of dice and i mean a lot of dice if any of you ever played a game called escape from curse of escape curse the temple something temple you you know what i mean escape from the curse of the temple no that's not right something like that it's a similar experience you have dice and you need to roll results to do things so if you need to move you need to roll the movement result if you and there's only one on each side of the die so like one side of the dice has moved
one side has attack one side has search find yourself a better weapon if you're in the right place right right it's really hard to run the right thing so the thing is you can roll the dice as fast as you like and as many times as you like you can just keep rolling and rolling and rolling and rolling and rolling but there's the trick one of the die faces is the aliens move uh result and sorry then the map uh tells you in which directions they may move yeah so anytime you roll an alien's move result you just pick any alien on the map and then move them along the arrows the problems the ways towards you yeah all those arrows are not only always towards you but also towards your base and if any alien doesn't matter which alien and there's loads of them right gets into your base you immediately lose the game and i don't know why you would leave your base and leave the door up on the on the base why would you not just close this close the stable door before the horse has got out or before the horse gets in i don't know like why would you just shut the door and then you wouldn't have to worry about getting into your battery it's not the kind of horse you want to get inside really alien horse anywho with 15 legs one of the things that i really like about this mechanism is that moving one alien isn't really a problem right there's the map is big there's lots of spaces there's a lot of aliens so even if you move one right you don't have to keep moving that same alien closer towards you you can move another alien one space and another alien one space and it's
sort of you're playing this sort of weird real-time chess the thing is when you only have this two minutes and you only have this two minutes to do everything that you want to do like kill aliens or move or whatever and you're rolling an alien movement you'll frantically looking at the board trying to think which alien do i move which is going to have the least worst result for me because it becomes because it's co-op problematic very very quickly if an alien ever moves into your figure you lose one health losing health that's really scary right right some aliens shoot from a very far away distance so if you move them close enough to you and you move like three of them close enough to you there's all the potential that will kill you you know so you made quite an interesting point about there's boss aliens as well as these um what they call sports sport aliens um and you said that the the boss didn't quite feel me enough to be here it didn't yeah and like it's not like because you think of a boss as the you know like in sonic or mario when you have a boss you know it's going to be like the mini game right right but whereas in here it's more just like an elite kind of alien right rather than well the thing is they use the big thing on it so you use this as time deterrent in the game so exactly whenever uh any any round could spawn a boss so at the beginning of every round you'll draw a card it'll say eau claire and you're like right or it'll spawn a boss and you're like ah no right but then you realize
that the boss isn't actually that scary all you need to do is is make sure that it doesn't stick around for multiple rounds uh which means you need to spend you just have to get it out of the way trying to kill things right and killing things again you need to roll the right result to activate your weapon and then you need to roll some dice to see to actually yeah do the weaponing and and sometimes you roll a hit and you're like yeah sometimes you want which means and sometimes you will you sorry yeah which means you have to activate roll roll the dice activate the weapon again and on and on and on and on so the tenor of the game it's just a lot of frantic guys very frantic and sometimes what you would do which is what i was going to say is roll your dice too hard and it will go over to the other side of the table and there's no way to distinguish which are your dice and which are their dice yeah so you're picking up someone else's stuff you're like why do i have six dice now i should only have four and they're like where's my dice on this is and the aliens like you're trying to get off the aliens and they're going everywhere because you're chucking them you know across the other side of the board it's yeah it's uh a little bit frantic a little bit frantic very frantic but we had a good time the last two times we played it we've had a very good time so elaine's finally arrived at the zinger which is where uh shall i do the yeah do the zinger there we go it's the zinger uh yeah yeah um so we when we played this the first time we played the tipia version of the game and when we
played it like lately recently we played the seymour version of the game and you might ask well what's the difference is there some sort of like streamlining or or you know like and actually the answer is i'm not sure i feel like largely i've played the same game um and i had a miserable i can't hear sound effects that's sad they can't hear the sound the sound effect was there you go we fixed it we fixed it well i didn't do something never mind it doesn't matter okay so yeah the first time the first time we played it we were like why this uh this this feels tedious this feels like busy work this feels like a lot of frantic dice rolling and it didn't feel thematic might as well be pushing like cubes around you know like this there was something missing and and the second time we played it we were like no this is cool we're having a lot of fun and and i think the thing that changed and you pointed this out is probably not something specific in terms of rules or in terms of production but i i said that maybe it's just us maybe we changed in the last few years between playing it the first time and playing it now and it was because it's so refreshing to play something where you're not really thinking that you have a small amount of time where you go okay what's our plan but then you go go go you're not you know your brain's not wandering off about like oh what am i having fatigue tonight or what what am i
going to do in five rounds time like how do i build my engine and you know do that it's just go go so it's quite the thing about real clearing yeah is that a lot of people find them stressful yeah right and i can also sometimes find them stressful and actually one one of my favorite real-time games yeah and this was our game of the year is now borders which is a game by uh tim fowers very small cooperative game and one of the reasons i think it's one of the best real-time games is because the real-time round is only like 30 seconds or something like that it's super short and the reason it's 30 seconds is because you're you're not really doing much in the time round you're making most of the planning decisions um before the time and that's what makes you not feel stressed right the time ground just tries to get you to do the thing that you need to do very very similarly and there are some decisions in in now boarding during the real-time moment right but it's mostly just about achieving the thing and getting that slam done can we do this yes we can the theme is very different yeah the theme is very different but there's no aliens but hanging on the edge of your plane here i feel like um project elite achieves something very similar it takes the idea of okay so it's two minutes so you're you are doing a lot but everything is sort of almost inconsequent the decisions never feel impactful
but you're just doing a lot and you're trying to achieve some sort of an arbitrary goal that you set for yourself before the start of the round yes and and whether you achieve that or not that sets the tone of that timed round so for me playing project elite felt strangely therapeutic because maybe it's because we're locked in in in a i don't know if you heard lane but like there's a pandemic um well yeah who knew and i felt like almost like i'm when i'm cooking right mm-hmm like i i have i have a set number of tasks yeah and i need to focus and it is sort of timed because if you fail you will burn it right or eat it raw yeah or eat it raw yeah and and then i don't know what's worse would you rather eat a burnt chicken or a raw chicken burnt chicken definitely burnt about burnt toast or raw see raw toast is just bread so that's fine that'd probably be fine anyway should we move on to the next game because we will i would you have a conclusion i i guess i guess my conclusion is uh that uh project elite is is is a strange piece it's not gonna be for everyone you know for sure yeah but and it's not there isn't like i don't feel like a great amount of strategy or or thinking that goes into playing project elite but there's there's a sort of moment of almost frantic serenity if that makes sense there's planning yeah and then there's frantic serenity that's a nice
way to put it all right let's move on to the next game let's move on to the escape room game that we played so normally on a podcast we have an escape room segment and besides we decided that for this it's not cool it's called puzzle deduction one and done segment okay the puzzle production one and done segment uh elaine would you give yourself a round of applause we decided to honor that and still talk about an escape room game yeah and elaine is today's escape room game great it's not no i'm sorry is it is it and i this is going to be a pointed question yeah is it the worst escape room game that you've played so far i don't know i don't know it might be it might be up but it was it was just a bit disappointing so um it's called flashback and it's escape room in a box uh and this seems to be the second one because it referred to the first one but not not like in a way that you can't play this otherwise it just referred to it oh i just wanted to know uh our copy of project elite was sent to us as a review copy from asthma to uk and this was sent to us as a review copy from mattel yes um yeah the the cover like so we we've had this for a little while and i was excited to play this because the cover makes it look like it's going to be neon noir neon yeah right yeah um and it's not at all it is one of the biggest tonal messes i
have seen there's in any game yeah yeah yeah there's werewolves in it which is not a spoiler because it says that on the back of the box uh it's to do with a werewolf and but there's there's like this weird kind of language used in it where they try and be cool uh in in part of it yeah and it's like that bit with steve buscemi where he's like hello fellow teenagers it's it and you know it says like totes music whatever yeah just no this shirt just says music band right yeah um yeah it was just very strange and it didn't so there are different parts to this game and none of them for me really gelled together properly um and it does say that you can play the parts individually but overall you have to play all of them yeah so this is completely the game three puzzle arcs right and the way the game presents itself is saying there's three games inside of this and you can play like one or you can play another one and what it actually is is just the same puzzle in three parts and one of the things so when when you when we opened the box and again this is not a spoiler we're gonna try and uh keep this brief and sort of spoiler free you know but there's ins essentially free lock puzzles you know you need to find combinations and resolving puzzles you'll find combinations and unlock the actual physical lock right so the first i mean that's a normal escape room yeah that's a normal escape so the first thing that we encountered
was just the component problem yes of the locks being really really bad where you can by just by turning the locks field that oh i unlocked it and it does say specifically in the brief uh if you accidentally unlock a unlock a block or complete a puzzle without meaning to yeah you must go back and do it again it doesn't count uh the magic hasn't worked yeah like you might show your homework that was i thought oh that's a strange rule and then as we were playing the game i was like oh that's why they have that because i only solved puzzles without solving puzzles i think like four times throughout the course of the game and partly because the components are quite poor and it's immediately obvious that yeah oh this is a puzzle that's hiding something and sometimes because the puzzles are just a bit rubbish if i'm honest um so the the box says it's for age 13 plus um i made the point that i think a 10 year old would quite happily be able to solve the majority of these puzzles and i made a point that an eight-year-old could solve a majority a smart eight-year-old yeah smart all only and this is i think basically why we ended up covering because whilst we really didn't enjoy them i think we were not the target audience so first of all what's really weird is that the box uh the artwork themes itself is like neon noir
the theme itself is about werewolves which doesn't gel with the artwork at all right and the language that is used is very much for kids right what is it though well it's it's not family unfriendly well then no that's true yeah right let's change i think it's like so don't get me wrong the writing is poor but that's fine in escape room games generally there's sort of like um thematic dissonance that happens it's almost a feature of escape it's a vehicle to give you the puzzles rather than yeah a feature yeah and then what i thought okay so so you know the writing doesn't quite gel but maybe this is fine for kids you know because because a lot of the puzzles are quite childlike a lot of the components uh have this you know once again uh neon pastel color which is quite bright and quite warm and and a lot of like uh the artistic direction on the puzzles themselves is quite family-friendly if that makes sense yes um i'm again trying to be vague so i thought you know and you thought as well this this might be a fine puzzle if you have kids who've never played an escape room and you want to solve it together with them and feel like they're arriving somewhere they're learning their first escape room yeah you only really need to know your alphabet how to count very basically
yeah basically if you're if your kid meets these these these criteria yeah they would probably be fine trying to solve that puzzle and even if they're younger than eight with some assistance from you maybe you know there was never a point where like part of the fun of escape from games is when you get stuck and then you work together or one of you like goes right i'm gonna focus on this puzzle and just puts their head down and you solve it and you're like yes i've done it like we've we've unlocked the lock or we've done the thing that we needed to do and none of it felt like that but maybe it's just because we're super smart efka maybe it is because well okay so by the virtue of having an escape room game section yes on a podcast means we play a lot of escape rooms and i guess we were somewhat used to them and the puzzles felt very easy for us but there's also been some exit uh the game uh escape rooms that were of easier difficulty and i feel like those would be fine for kids as well and maybe slightly but they didn't feel like this yeah they felt a lot meatier than than this did and and i think that was why we were so disappointed by that that it presents itself as you know 13 plus which sounds like the puzzles are going to be harder but or that you need to have done um escape rooms before or if this is your first one this might be a challenge and it just didn't kind of feel like that um
and i think that's why we're a little different yeah a little disappointed well one of the things is escape rooms are very experiential and therefore you want to make sure that people have a good time i remember on the not last uk games expo but the uk games expo before that when isaac childress was visiting the design of gloomhaven um he said to us i've never played one of these escape room board games right i said isaac you must play so we went to the cosmos stand and picked up an escape an exit puzzle right yeah and we just happened to have they they had released a couple of like a beginner one that year yeah and i thought well okay it'll be slightly easier but it'll still be easy but it was way too easy and isaac's brain i don't know if you played gloomhaven right but alison's brain travels he has a time dilation device inside of it already it does i made a call back you did well done yeah yeah it does and yeah he's just super smart and and is clearly in tune with you know thinking outside the i don't say outside the box but do you know what i mean like yeah on a different plane of existence like and i think like for us sorry did you yeah no i just wanted to say it's so much about setting the experience right right right setting the tone right and setting the expectations right so yeah i think i think what i wanted to say was that when you choose an escape room game you need to like figure out is this going to be the right game for the right group for the right people for them yes right time and
i think yeah all i was going to say was that i think we wouldn't necessarily say this would be a good game even if it's your first escape room game because you still if you're an adult particularly you still have done probably if you're going to do an escape room game like logic puzzles or you know it's like if if it's the first time you're ever presented with the the two doors puzzle where you know he always tells the truth and he always lies how do you know which door to go like you you just know the answer for that because you're you've had experience of life right you've come across that in your life and so quite a lot of um the puzzles in this you will already know how to solve because of experiences in your life right you know how to do them and so i think yeah for kids that maybe don't have that life experience it would be better yeah there we go well that's a positive no i like yeah we took a thing we didn't like it but we found someone that would be good for right that's what we do yeah saying that if you're watching this and you're like who are these two people talking why are they here why are they in my living room and what do they want from me you can turn this off if you don't like us being in your living room no no no no no no no don't turning us off right uh if you've never heard of us we have an award nominated podcast nominated and runner up who knows why uh board games golden geek award for best podcast who knows why really but we are not known for podcasts we are known for
our reviews on youtube and uh if you want to find our reviews all you need to do is type in open included into your browser yes and it'll just take you to our youtube channel yeah yeah it'll show you a video that that youtube will think is the right one for you and if it's not relevant to you then maybe you can reconsider your life choices wow with that wonderful message and that's wonderful we get different adverts on youtube which it just kind of blew my mind i know it's like here's a man style advert yeah elaine does not so so as i'm not i get this product advertised today about male grooming that i despise so much because the adwords are so awful yeah and i just realized the other day that elaine's never seen it no because she doesn't get that advert no because youtube doesn't think she needs grooming not not there like not on my chest um that's what it's advertising we both get ones for um grammar correction and yeah yeah who knows why that is who knows why uh shall we move we should do our feature discussion uh today which is a game called oath so before we continue i'd like to mention that uh unlike normally so we recently changed the format of a podcast where we always have one review it's a feature review which is an actual review we normally used to do first impressions we moved to
reviewing one game and doing you know a considered impression of that game this is not going to be that this is going to be very much a first impressions of oath because oath is not a game that has been published yet however it is a game from uh leader games who are known for having done uh root yeah vast and um fort which was recently recently reviewed on the channel oaf is a new game that's coming out from them it has been on kickstarter already i don't know if you can late pledge i haven't looked up this information maybe you can if you're interested in this but i've been interested in oaf for a long time and because okay so i'm going to do a long-winded explanation okay why right okay i'll strap myself in so i'll have some tea leader games has positioned themselves as a company uh that does asymmetric experiences very wild very out there asymmetric experiences and that seems to be their shtick right and also titles with four letters in in their name oh um i never thought of that but i think that more and more uh leader games are moving from oh well this is a really kooky asymmetric game to um how do we experiment with the experience of playing a board game uh because ford was very much a brute is definitely in that way yes and ford is definitely in that lane and
oaf is an experiment unlike anything i've seen so this is from the designer root as well who and art by carl ferrance by carl ferran who graciously taught and demoed oh yeah to us on tabletop simulator so we haven't got a physical copy we just played it on tabletop simulator because i wanted i wanted to find out i just had to find out what this thing was to describe oath is nearly impossible and i think that's one of the problems and that's why i really wanted to talk about it because theoretically i would say if you pressed me against the wall and said what genre is this board game i would have to say 4x that's what i said yeah which is a disservice to the game right i made a joke that it was forex and then we were like oh wait maybe it is right for a number of reasons uh first of all because uh the forex genre has been done not only to death but people trying to extrapolate that genre into something for i don't know how many attempts now and it never works yeah you you have your titans in that genre like you know twilight imperium or eclipse right and they just sort of stay and the other reason is because the theme is actually quite unpleasant because it frequently deals with calling this colonialization and exploitation and well you know what one of the x's yeah that's one of the x's right exploit exterminate right so expand well expand yeah but that's all part of it right so i mean that that says it's mean yeah
yeah those four words exploit expand exterminate the other one i've immediately forgotten but it always evokes this sort of sense of history where there is a i don't know something bad happening in history and frequently the ones that succeed seem to be the ones that move away from historical settings and go into realms of fantasy or sci-fi um and i think there's a good reason for that uh thematically oaf is not that i mean it is that because it is talking about conquest and rulership but it is trying to frame the the whole perspective from a very different angle and i'm gonna go really high falutin here and go literary and evoke uh an author i don't like very much but i suspect that it has been the genesis of all this which is isaac asimov so if you're not familiar most people who are into sci-fi will be familiar with the foundation which is a series of books uh that tried to tell at least in sci-fi i think it was revolutionary in terms of how it told a story rather than having a protagonist and like you go and do the thing uh you know the hero's journey et cetera yeah they go and conquer the story instead is generational so instead of looking at a perspective of like this person achieves something it's more like this is the history of of almost this universe and you know let's see how the events of uh one person and what they do affect the events of the next generation and then the next generation and then the next generation and other books have been based on that kind of theme like
cloud atlas and yes deal with generational issues and and this game does that yeah strangely uh so first of all uh oath is um not a legacy game but it can be a sort of sort of a campaign game because things that you do in one game will affect the the subsequent games but i i know that you don't have to play with the same game group no so you you could play you can even play solo i think and then bring in other people and it won't matter yeah i don't see why that wouldn't work actually yeah that's a good point um it would so the game is as any kickstarter game lately you can have a solo play you can have two players i think you want to play this with at least three and we played with four yeah we played it before that that felt like a really one person has to be kind of uh have better knowledge of the game at least because they're playing there has to be one person playing quite a harder faction to play yeah so let's talk about these factions right uh so there is there is a faction so the the dichotomy of oath is that some of you uh one of you will be like the ruler of this kingdom yeah right i forgot what the actual game type right me too and and the others will be exiles so you're like politicians that have been you know cast out removed from power and you're no longer in charge right uh and so when you start the game it's sort of asymmetrical because one person is something and the other three people are another thing but that those three
people are not in a team and no one's in a team it's just one person who's playing a completely different role and has slightly different abilities right and theoretically is more powerful but the problem is is that uh the victory conditions in this game change and shift all the time yeah um i mean imagine imagine like twilight imperium right right i'm imagining uh or imagine any game with a map where you go and conquer territories and whatever it is sort of similar in that regard where you have locations uh and those locations are hard and cards and all those cards have different abilities you're kind of drafting cards also yeah yeah those locations are different cards and different abilities that they give you if you rule those locations and as as the oath keeper or something like that like the main person right your goal is to just control the most of these by the end of the game um and the end of the game will come at a certain point it's undetermined there's a role of a die if if you achieve that great hooray you won right and you're very good at taking control of these locations because you have more resources than everyone else you have more soldiers so you can keep keep them in check right so that's fine uh the problem is that the other players can acquire different winning conditions yes right yeah and suddenly they're they're very quickly become more efficient at fulfilling those different conditions which what i liked about that was that it it doesn't necessarily get revealed at the end it gets revealed at a time of their choosing when they think
well maybe i can still i can pull this off yeah but then everyone is like as soon as they reveal that everyone else is like right we have to stop them doing this because then they will win the game and when we played so i i was in exile and i had one of these conditions with it was to do with uh coins which is the currency have more than anyone else and uh no i no there was like a secret that i had to no there was a darkest secret yeah which cost coins yeah so it was tied to the resources of the game and it got more and more expensive for someone so you can steal things from from people yeah and uh but the longer you leave realizing that it sounds more and more it really is isn't it yeah that's how your brain feels in this game a little bit it's a mishmash of ideas but yeah there's there's the darkest secret which costs coins which you have to keep paying at the start of every round and someone can come and steal it and someone can come steal your other things it's a vast playscape of ideas right but somehow they all congeal so in the example of our game one of the coolest things that happened was so cold was playing the person yes that that was the main person right and we the ruler yeah you were an excel i was in exile and a friend uh paul was also yes in exile and i i i got one of these secret victory conditions i had a sense that paul had one of these secret victory conditions and i think you did it like you know if someone has taken a victory you just know what it is you just don't
know what it is uh and you had one as well right did you know that no i didn't all right so that's what happened uh so the cool thing that happened was that basically coal as as the man in charge of this kingdom had the right to invite one of the exiles and say you know what if we win we win together but you have to go join team cole right be part of the establishment yes don't you know cavort with these rebels right the chat says it's the chancellor it's the chancellor there we go thank you very much so when i realized how momentous a decision that was yeah that's when i think i fell in love with that game because cole as the chancellor he's very powerful right and he has this right to invite someone in right but as soon as you issue that someone in right yeah if they refuse yeah right that's it you've stuffed yourself because whoever you invite next they're going to be like no you didn't choose me first right well i don't know because i i i don't think i was the first to be chosen was that yeah you were was you were and i immediately went yeah sure i'm going to join whatever side i think is going to win i don't think i can pull this off on my own no so unlike unlike games like root where so much of it is i mean it's a lot of it is to do with player psychology and and analyzing you know how a person plays the game but this was so much more
evident and so much more experiential where like um so another great example of of of this was um we can so so i realized at one point in the game that me and so it's when you joined team paul me and paul had each a like one of these visions which are the secret objectives right and i realized that we were gunning for a different one right um and because this game is a campaign game unl unlike unlike other games so what we could agree for example is that even though only one of us wins next game when we play the game together we play it as like part of the same kingdom right so whoever wins is still the chancellor but like i'll be in the kingdom so i realized that because we were gunning for two different objectives uh one of us had a fair potential potential of winning because whilst you do try to stop one yes the other one sneaks away right we both kind of had uh a mark right that we was trying to stop so you were my mark and paul was cole's uh mark so my my suggestion to paul was like listen paul why don't we like team up and only one of us wins i don't care which one right but we don't want them to we we don't want them to win because then we'll like next game we'll be part of the team and paul very smartly looked at me and said
no no because because paul realized that he i mean i'm still going to be doing my thing i'm still going to be distracting elaine and cole from their objective whilst he's still doing his objectives so i think what i really like about these strategic forex games is that they move away from um like there's a lot of mechanisms and a lot of interlocking things that have happened a lot of strategy but sometimes you can just play people right and well yeah fantasy people well no i mean no play play on people like oh like real people yeah psychology people right i think yeah we played it virtually right and i i'm interested to see how different it plays physically yeah because when you're playing virtually you can't kind of stare someone down quite as much or work out they've got more of a poker face i think um so maybe that will change it up a bit uh so one of the things that i found quite interesting cole recently did an interview where he argued in defense of bad game mechanisms and saying it's just people not using them right so um he he argued for king making for example right which is if you're not familiar with kingmaking it's the idea that let's say you have a free player game uh and then uh there are two people winning and you know you're not going to win you're not one of those two people you sort of push one of them towards the
win more than the other yeah so it's not the person who achieved victory that should have achieved victory because they didn't achieve it via what they were doing yeah they were they buy a sabotage or something else right and and that can feel very unsatisfying in the game right but if you frame the game around that then it suddenly starts to make sense right because because you have a campaign game and because this kingdom involves and for example if a one of these uh secret vision cards is the victory condition yeah then the next game you play that is the main objective the chancellor right so that changes or all the locations that you rolled into oh yeah they'll change also uh but the ones you rule you you see they they become as part of the kingdom right so this this these whole considerations that you need to think about like not only what am i doing in this game that's going to affect me and how do i win but how does this shape the landscape going forward and certainly winning becomes not the most important thing because when you realize i can't win yeah you start playing a different game you start playing a game of like okay what damage can i cause how can i shape this to my advantage next time how can i be the most annoying or someone else but not necessarily annoying but that see that's king making but more like you know how how can i carve out well that's that's kind of what i was doing though yeah but but
within that like and i agree with you king making is it can be very very annoying like in a euro game or something but in this because it has that psychology behind it i just i just wanted to stop you from doing the thing i again like you were saying i know you knew you couldn't win i knew i couldn't win at that point but i knew i needed to stop you from from winning and i didn't win paul won paul won in the end yeah he wasn't that smart you know he wasn't that smart because he didn't buy into that psychology as much he just played his game and yeah yeah he didn't and he did the thing right he did the thing but that was but it was so much fun that like i i normally dislike that in the game but that was it worked so well because it has impact on on the rest of everything yeah so instead of instead of going to a person why are you doing that you're just doing that out of spite no there's there's a reason like i want to shape things the way i want to shape this kingdom yeah so i i found that to be very interesting and if if you sound very if you've never heard of often you now sell you now you're now intrigued by what we're telling you be aware that explaining oath uh oh boy which was done by cole the man not only who designed the game himself but has demoed it at a bunch of virtual conventions or maybe even in past conventions when conventions were a thing um he's done this you know hundreds of times and it still took a while and a lot of
the concepts feel very alien very strange and just totally you're thrown in the deep end and you're trying to piece this thing together and if you had to learn this from the rule book and played with people who've never played it before might be an experience uh i think we'll we'll definitely be coming back to yeah oh at some point in the future when it's released i'm very excited about it very intrigued by me too it is the kind of game that feels like you know you've thrown a cereal box in the air and all the cornflakes are falling down uh and you're trying to slowly piece them together but but eventually you get some sort of breakfast out of it yeah and you're like oh okay this is the this is my breakfast like it works it it for me like i didn't understand up to like i don't know 50 minutes into the explanation and then i was like oh i get this yeah okay i get this this has all come together now i that came later for me actually then then it did for you and it took me a while because i was sort of like wrestling with a strategy and thinking does this work can i push it it didn't uh but but i found the experience nonetheless very enjoyable and i also have been very consciously trying to avoid comparisons to root which is called the previous game uh but i will invoke one comparison right now which is the victory point comparison uh which is that in oh if there are no victory points there are just victory conditions
and i feel that that is such a momentous change one of my big problems with root was the scope of the victory point right like let's see playing a game like twilight imperium yeah you know you only have 10 points but every point was a hard-won battle yes where something happened right some interaction with another player and you know i took that planet there was there's always conflict in victory points right and so the scope of the victory point tells the story in root the scope of the victory point told the story of like um well i built this building you know or i i killed this token so you can't blame root for that that's that's like hundreds of guys no i know but in a conflict-driven game right even so i i feel like that is slightly antithetical to the experience that he's trying to evoke oath doesn't have that no oath is pure on how do i figure out how i win and how how do i achieve this can i achieve this if i can't achieve this what else can i do right and if you like that you might want to look into this game yes plus the artwork oh is this lush yeah fantastic so we we gosh about kyle ferran's art a lot but oath was just another step because it went from oh hey this is kooky and you know cute and also sometimes slightly sinister to just flat out weird and there's a giant with a knapsack with a pig in it you know
that's true yeah it's that kind of stuff and it's it's something else and it feels very evocative of the game mm-hmm i think that's probably a good place to finish our chat on games yeah i would like to do a very quick elena and grumps okay just to say thank you ever so much millie and everyone at virtual expo for allowing us this time and inviting us on and thank you to everybody who has watched us and don't forget that you can if you are watching live uh you can claim your expo special expo badge for watching a stream okay i i would the link is in the chat i don't know if we're allowed to do plugs but uh basically go check out our youtube channel uh notebook included uh also we stream board games we're not gonna be streaming a board game next week but we also stream dungeons and dragons as long as we're not plugging for the uh chest hair removal no yeah i think it's only uh us yeah that's fine uh we stream uh dungeons and dragons every saturday 8pm including this saturday yes if you're watching live we'll be doing that tonight at 8pm yeah uh not on the uk games expo channel though so we should we should clarify that uh it's probably something really fun and exciting on the uk do we have any channel we have any questions no we don't seem to have had any throughout the the podcast sorry um thank you everybody for watching i've had a lovely time i hope you've had a lovely time i mean we have a couple of we have like a couple of minutes literally right if anyone has a question yes uh
you can ask it now and we will answer in the next three minutes before we have um nobody oh uh good to see i didn't lose my voice like i did at aircon thank you very much that was weird like two days um a question about the campaign aspect of oath right uh it's not really a question it's just stating the campaign aspect of both uh yes there is one uh will we ever get another music show maybe maybe i i will say that i oh very quickly so uh our next video is not a video is a video series and if you enjoy elaine's songs there will be one of those in that video series so look forward to that oh did the campaign aspect come through in the one play through yes yes for me it did i mean okay only so much that we knew we weren't going to play a second game but we were like thinking about because we would explain how the campaign system works and what we're supposed to expect we um we sort of reacted to that and played as if we were thinking about the next game yes and in that regard that did work yes um what's our favorite type of cheese okay um i think uh have we thought about uh looking into crayon rail games uh only in as much as that i'm aware that
they exist and as a board game reviewer it's my job so it piqued my interest uh how is bessie she is good she's sleeping just behind me you can't see her but she is napping over there okay i think that's it i think that's it thank you so much everybody for watching bye enjoy the rest of expo