Do our Game Picks from 1, 2, and 5 years ago still hold up? - On Our Radar
Transcript
Welcome to On the Radar, where members of the Watch You Play team usually share the games that are making blips on our personal radars this month. However, Rodney is away this month. So, the rest of us are going to revisit several of our previous picks from 1, 2 and 1/2, and 5 years ago. You know, to see if these games are still making waves with us. Join us for this special Radar Revisited episode, which begins right now with a puzzly game I was pondering this time last year, Open Season, where monsters seek revenge on the groups of adventurers who invade their home and disturb their peace. Then the monsters repurpose the defeated adventurers by decorating their living rooms with the embalmed remains of their former foes, like you do. True, the theme is a little macob, but I originally picked this a year ago because Open Season takes that theme of you actually play the part of the big bad monster going after the heroic adventurers and it puts a pretty unique twist on it. I liked the puzzle of deciding whether to use the cards you collect to trigger other abilities or use them to increase your final score.
Okay, it's time for some brutal honesty. I have not thought about this game probably since we filmed on the radar a year ago and I talked about it. There's just been a lot of new games that have come out since then. And I've only played this one digitally. So, I think sometimes when I've only played a game on Board Game Arena and not like physically interacted with it, maybe it doesn't stick in my brain for as long as something that like I have on my shelf and I can pull off the shelf and like touch. Uh, and I don't own this game, so I haven't actually really thought about it in a year. That being said, now that I'm remembering that this game exists, thank you to this video, I think I'm going to play it again.
Like, I think I'm going to go over to Board Game Arena right after I'm done filming this and set up a game of it because it was fun. And I am remembering how much I did enjoy that puzzle of you bring the cards in, do you use it for its ability, do you hold on to it to be able to score? And like that's such a tricky thing. And I think the art is really charming. They're just like the idea of it is really fun. And so it is now firmly back on my radar and I'm going to be playing it probably. Chaz also had a few choices he championed this time last year. And before we get to that, let's thank the game that made this episode possible. Fountains by the OP Games. In Fountains, you become a master fountainer tasked with transforming an elegant city's gardens and plazas by creating the most magnificent fountain the world has ever seen. You can do it. I totally believe in you. Fountains is a take and make game where each player starts with a round fountain that features a spout and room for four features. Then by moving tokens strategically around the central board, you'll find just the right additions to incorporate into your fountain, adding its token to your board. Then you can expand out or up or both. But you'll want to make sure that you have a spout at the highest point of your fountain with water flowing all through the lower levels because fountains without water aren't going to get you any points. Throughout the game, various items will be scored, requiring our fidious fountainers to remain in a
flow state themselves. And you can flow on over to the link in this video's description to find fountains online and at your friendly local game stores. Then prepare to get your feet wet with this drafting tile placement masterpiece. Now, Chaz, this time last year, your radar was lit up by the party game Rabble, where all you've got to do is get your teammates to guess the words on your rabble cards as quickly as possible. In fact, each round uses the same exact words and phrases. Sounds easy enough, right? The catch is each round is governed by different rules. Maybe you can only say one word or perform charades. increasing the challenge are cards with additional strange rules that your opponents can give to you to gum up the works. So, is this gummy game one that you're still chewing on?
Oh, yeah. I was drawn to Rabble because it reminds me of the game Times Up Title Recall, which I always enjoy playing. And the comparison between those two games makes sense cuz they're actually both based on another game, the public domain game known as Celebrities. There's actually quite a few games that follow this formula, but Rabbel is still my go-to for this category. It's a regular companion on my game days even still. And I played it just a few months ago. So, yeah, Rabbel, it's definitely a keeper. I'm glad to hear it's a keeper because I'm going to use that to awkwardly segue to the idea of inkeepers by checking in on a game Matthew mentioned last year, Tales from the Red Dragon in, a new cooperative game for one to four adventurers who portray famous characters from the Red Dragon in series of games. The multi-senario campaign pits the players against gamecontrolled enemies tailor made for each illustrated foldout game map. All of the players win the scenario together by completing its final objective, which can vary from kill all the enemies to get to a specific location to survive a number of turns against increasingly impossible odds.
Yeah, Tales from the Red Dragon in was an unusual pick for me because dungeon crawlers and miniatures games, they aren't usually what I'm drawn towards at all and I have tried. But I found Tales from Red Dragon in to be utterly charming. And unlike my own personality, there's more here than just charm. There's substance. a huge campaign full of deep tactical decisions, tech trees, unlockables, mysteries, and danger, but always maintaining its sense of nonsense and whimsy. What I've loved about this one is that it really doesn't take itself too seriously. It's a deep game with constant interesting decisions, a great story that doesn't take 3 hours to read between games, and a huge variety of things to do and experience. But it's it's not pretentious. That doesn't make it better than other dungeon crawlers perhaps and it won't be to everyone's taste, but that self-awareness is what makes it stand apart from some other games. I think in my opinion, it makes it accessible to new players and to me it makes it fun and it's challenging without being frustrating. It allows you to play rather than coming up with scenario after scenario of ways to put the players in handcuffs and restrictions.
Now we start digging a little bit deeper with games that we shared two and a half years ago. I don't know why Chaz chose 2 and 1/2 years ago, not two years ago. It seems strange to me, but here's where we are, people. I don't control this. Blame Chaz. So, we're going to dig in a little bit deeper. And this includes a game that was flying across my personal radar, Freshwater Fly, which integrates modern game mechanisms with the theme of angling, which I saw at the time as a refreshing choice. In Freshwater Fly, players encounter a rushing mountain stream teeming with fish armed solely with a rod, a reel, and a selection of flies. I don't know why these are the gestures that go with that, but apparently they are. Catching fish and earning valuable achievement points will require carefully performing a series of tactical maneuvers while executing a deliberate and evolving strategy. Is this game still on my radar? It sure is.
It actually is. I haven't played it in a while, but I have um recently called like a whole bunch of games, like a hundred games out of my collection, and I'm in the process of getting ready to try and do that kind of again. I really need to downsize. If you could see what's like just right here out of frame, you would understand why. And you know what? I am not considering adding to that culling pile. It has survived the first call and it's going to survive the second one. And it's Freshwater Fly. I think it's such an interesting and unique game. It is firmly still on my radar. I do not really have like any other games about fishing. I don't think there are that many that exist. Whatever other games about fishing exist, let me know in the comments because I can't think of any. And so, this one is such a unique game in my collection. And I don't want to get rid of it. I still really like it. I think it's really neat and I think more people should be playing it. Put it on your radar, y'all. And in the rivers and lakes that populate our favorite fishing holes, you'll find a variety of islands.
I don't know if you're going to have islands and rivers and like I guess you could have small islands and rivers. It's fine. I'm I'm going to stop questioning what Traz has written here. Perhaps you'll even find the island featured in Matthew's former favorite, My Island by designer Reiner Kenitzia. Modeled after 2020's My City, the game My Island is a competitive legacy game of developing your own unique island out of connected hexagons. I have it. It's here somewhere. Oh, it's in the pile down here that I don't want to show you, but I do have it. I wish I could grab it to show you, but I don't. Um, over the course of 24 games, players will experience the history of their island and discover its secrets with each individual session introducing new rules and game materials which will permanently change their landscapes.
I love my island. Great Britain. No, sorry. This is the game. I love my island. The game. Look, I'm a huge fan of Canitia. That's no secret. Be very open about that fact. But they aren't all good, right? But my island is just Oh, it's fantastic. I prefer it to My City even though I think you should play My City first. This really does feel like a step up and away from My City. And what I love is that the game progression is simply more interesting. Without spoiling the game, the scenarios change more in My Island, and it's just just more exciting. is some more genuine surprises and it was just a joy to play.
And our flashback to 2022 continues with a look at one of the games that Chaz was excited to discuss that month. The Siege of Runar, a cooperative game for one to four brave dwarves who must defend the walls of Runar and the treasure they keep within. Together, they must engage in deadly handto-claw combat against orcs, goblins, and trolls, each of whom would surely track mud into the stronghold before burning it to the ground. So, they deserve it. A deck building system allows players to upgrade their weapons and tools while they hold off the radars. While they hold off the radars. Players to upgrade their weapons and tools while they hold off the radars. Oh my gosh, the radars. How many times am I going to say this? A deck building system allows players to upgrade their weapons and tools while they hold off the raiders just long enough to build a tunnel that will allow them to escape the terrible siege and transport their treasure to safety.
I always enjoy discovering a game with a tower defense flavor to it, and Siege of Runar intrigued me for that very reason. It's It's a great game with fantastic production quality that is no longer in my collection for two main reasons. First, the game's theme and overall vibe. It just, you know, it was just enough of an overlap with another cooperative survival type game, The Last Bastion, that when given the choice, I found myself pulling that game off the shelf instead of Siege of Runar. And actually, speaking of shelves, as cool as Siege of Runar's production was, or perhaps because of this, its box was too wide to fit on my shelf. And it ended up just being a game without a home that kept being moved from one spot in my room to another. And as a result, as much as I appreciate the game, I did eventually give it to someone else who has wider shelves who I know would enjoy it.
And now, let's dial the time machine all the way back to the year 2020 when the On the Radar series began to check in. I cannot believe we've been doing this for 5 years to check in on several games that were featured in the episode that honestly at this point it feels like an age ago, which is actually convenient because the first game to check in on is Cloud Age, a strategy game set in a dystopian world for one to four players who compete to survive using a mix of engine building, deck building, and resource management. The game also incorporates a campaign system with new elements being introduced into the game as players progress through its chapters. And much like a campaign of our very own, as this on the radar series has progressed through the months and years, the show's format has evolved. For example, episodes 5 years ago were based on a general consensus of selections instead of our personal picks. But let's check in with Matthew to find out if Cloud Age is a game that he still has in his mind and on his table. if for no other reason than we had to select someone to follow up on it in order to keep the episode moving.
Ah, yes. Cloud Age, a name I've not heard in many a year. I never actually managed to play it. Don't get me wrong, I wanted to play it, but I want to do a lot of things in life that are never going to h Look, Cloud Age remains one of those games that if someone says, "Hey, do you want to play Cloud Age?" I'd say boy how do you bet your Nelly I do but for whatever reason it's just one that's fallen into the ether or so look go play blackout Hong Kong by the same designer that's also massively overlooked so good it will be a little easier to discuss the next game we featured 5 years ago because I know it's one that Chaz adors and still has on his shelf today Santorini New York a three-dimensional abstract yet highly thematic game where players move workers and construct towers in the grand land of New York at the start of the 20th century. The game also features 14 sets of roll cards to increase its variety and replayability. Well, apparently this is the part of the show where I now contradict myself because whereas I mentioned that one of the reasons I gave away Siege of Runar was because I thought The Last Bastion made it somewhat redundant to own both. Right here, front and center on my shelves, we find not only Santorini New York, but also its predecessor, the original Santorini. And there is absolutely more
redundancy between these two games than there is between Runar and Bastion. And yet here they both sit, each being cherished and enjoyed in equally shared amounts. So yeah, I'm I'm a hypocrite and a bit of a liar. But that's not news to you. What may be news is that if if neither of these games has nudged the other out of my collection at this point, it is probably a pretty safe bet that neither one's going to anytime soon. And interestingly, I think that we find another potential overlap in the final game from 5 years ago, which Paula is going to be our resident expert on. Oh, throwing it back to you, Paula. That's right, because this time 5 years ago, we were discussing the then newest game from Stefenfeld, The Castles of Tuskanyany, which is a sequel of sorts to the game The Castles of Burgundy.
Tuskanyany follows in its predecessor's footsteps as players make creative decisions to build their region into a flourishing domain by supporting towns, villages, and monasteries, or by extracting marble and delivering goods. As players expand their lands, they gain new opportunities and earn points to bank toward their ultimate victory. You may or may not know this about me, but Castles of Burgundy is like my all-time favorite game. It's certainly the game I have played the most by a landslide of any other game. So, is Castles of Tuskanyany still on my radar? Well, earlier I was talking about how a freshwater fly has survived cullings and is going to survive the next culling. Well, I currently have Castles of Tuskanyany on my shelf and I don't think it's going to survive the next culling.
I think it's going to go because here's the thing. I think there's definitely things to like about Castles of Tuskanyany, but I'm just never going to pick that game over Castles of Burgundy. And I've realized that over the the last five years where I've had a copy of the game and I'm always choosing Castles of Burgundy instead to play. I'm just not going to pick Castles of Tuskany when Castles of Burgundy is right there. So, I have a feeling I'm going to be um passing Castles of Tuskanyany on to greener pastures and it's going to kind of come off my radar, I think. And there you have it. a check-in on several of the games that we were anticipating from one, two and a half, and 5 years ago. Let us know which games from past years are still spending time on your game tables. And for even more games that viewers are playing, continue on to our people's choice video, which reviews the games that our viewers have recently reported playing.
Some are new, some are old, and always some are unexpected, cuz y'all got weird taste. You can click here to join us over there. And thanks for watching.