Under the Hood - An examination of dice mechanics
Transcript
hello and welcome to under the hood an exploration of board game mechanics this is the first of a new series for three-minute board games we will be looking at the core mechanics and games and picking them apart as this isn't a recap video it will be much longer than three minutes and I hope the additional time spent will be worth it think of this video is a visual podcast there'll be graphics popping up but the main focus will be on the woods and you could just as easily listen to it and not miss much so let's kick it off the origin of dice dice are old like super old Romans played dice games the ancient Egyptians Indians and Chinese played with us dice are probably the first board game mechanic and it makes sense that we look at them first there's some really great research out there about dice pre 1900 but that's really outside the scope of what I want to cover here dice have mainly been used in gambling and gaming as a way of creating an element of luck and that's really still what they represent the primary way games ad luck and uncertainty to games so let's start off with the basics Plastics excited dice became cheap and easy to make in the post-world War two world due to advances and plastics technology and research by companies supplying dice for casinos dice and gambling is not what I want to cover selects how they came to look at the board games and start with some of the older ways to use dice roll and move roller move is one of the most basic and well-known mechanics and board gaming it's also one that many serious gamers hate with a power of a white out star in essence dice are used to determine how many spaces you move on the board roll the dice move their many spaces over the years of market has produced thousands
of very similar roll and move games usually based on whatever IP was hot at the time or whatever IP they thought they could make it quick buck off the reason it's so reviled is so many of those games that use rolling move have few ways to change the results and you can feel like the game is entirely arbitrary and luck based in extreme cases like snakes and ladders where there are no actual decisions to be made that's entirely true roll and move has become almost synonymous with bad game design but recently I played a role and move game that I absolutely love yeah legends of a trip system and the reason it works in gr is that they built other mechanics around it you can get bigger engines and roll bigger dice you'd have multiple actions at a turn so one bad roll is less likely to impact you terribly and you have an impulse drive that doesn't use dice overall it's a small part of a much larger game but it adds an element of uncertainty to that game I simply consider an exception to the rule that roller moves sucks but overall it's still a pretty accurate observation of the mechanic in the end most of those games what you roll determines whether you succeed and fail there's not a lot of decision making and for a lot of people that's just not fun it's not engaging and it's not rewarding target numbers another basic mechanic is the idea of single target numbers for dice rolls that is when a task has assigned a difficulty number that you have to roll equal to or higher on the dice to succeed if we're using a basic six-sided dice a to bus target number represents a very easy action as a rezoning a one in six chance of bailing while a sex difficulty is extremely
difficult as there is only a one in six chance of success Twilight Struggle is a highly regarded game that uses single dice target numbers quite a lot the advantages of target numbers is that players know the odds of their action before they roll and the game can apply modifiers to that role for example using that 1d6 system it might be a 2 plus role to shoot someone but different modifiers to the role such as cover poor lighting and range could change that to a much higher number many games revolve around the idea of target numbers for challenges but early on designers noted that a single die system with modifiers was still quite arbitrary and difficult to show degrees of success as it always produced a binary succeed or fail result this led to the development of dice pulls a dice pool consists of a group of dice rolled together against the target number the number of dice in the pool could be determined by the skill of the character involved for example a doctor character in a game would likely roll more dice on a medical skill test each individual dice would then be checked against the target number with each success counting towards the overall results this can produce far more varied and interesting results and some games using the system have different outcomes based on the degree of success a Kimura is a well-known game based around dice balls and target numbers in that game almost all rolls a target number I am so excited dice many each day has a 33% chance of success what this means in a dice pull of five dice the chances of rolling zero successes drops to 13% and with 10 dice it drops even further to about 2% so while it may seem that die systems are entirely based on luck in
reality once enough dice of being rolled luck starts to disappear under the weight of probability at this point failure becomes less likely and you are measuring degrees of success so using the example above when you're rolling 10 dice you're far more likely to achieve 4 or 5 successes than you are zero or 10 dice balls act as a way to balance out dice rolls to ensure that success has happened more optim creating a bell curve shape towards the middle number of successes as you'll note that means you're succeeding in a lot more roles of you using a dice pool system and that's especially true when they start adding dice modifiers there are two main ways to modify dice adding bonuses to the number roll so there are four counts as of 5:00 and rerolls we are allowed to pick up a number of dice and re-roll them and take the new result while most games will use these towards the players advantage some games also make Yuri roll successes to increase difficulty a lot of the time they will appear in games as part of a resource management system where a character may have a finite amount of resources that allow them to re-roll dice they can also appear as part of a skill specialization system in order to make certain characters better at niche skills of the game a good example of this is the Fallout game which allows you to use skills and cards to reroll dice checks now have enough rerolls any dice roll can be made with enough time and effort so games need to add restrictions to this in order to maintain balance our camara has its clue system other games aren't defenders at the last band as skills that can only be used once for turn the sweet spot for this mechanic is that the reroll represents the
expenditure of a limited resource so a player decision needs to be made over their rewards for completing earlier challenges and tasks game the memory role feels best when it feels like an effort move as though it's something to do with the character being skillful or the fact they brought the right gear or their they have intelligence and information about the event attain a reroll that's just a reroll for the sake of rerolls just seems a bit mechanical and doesn't quite work with me as an alternative to using dice balls a number of games have reference charts to determine your results a large number of variables could be added and the chart reference during play a basic example of this was the hit location chance that appeared in early games at Battletech and Battletech you enrolled to d6 to determine whether hit landed allowed for a degree of detail on how the target was impacted on pets but as the hit roll was mostly random all it did was add an extra layer of complexity some old-school wargames such as those designed by avalon hill and SP i would include combat resolution tables and if you haven't seen one of these before you're in for a treat you would match the combat strengths of the engage units by the appropriate ratio column and then shift the result left or right based on modifiers this design feature still gets used in some modern war games of which wing leader supremacy is the newest one I play these charts allowed for quite a bit of detail to be compacted into one master table and you could reduce just about every role in the game to a single one B six role however downside was you usually end up with a lot of variables shifting the columns back and forth and up and down and they're a bit of a pain in the ass another example of charts and tables and games is the original Arkham Horror they used encounter charts
instead of the encounter cards in the modern version and you would roll and consult the chart Lister to determine what happened this is pretty uncommon these days and most games will instead use encounter cards or a book of stories to determine the results almost shark crazy game I've ever played was a role-playing game called roll master every single weapon had its own chart including every attack spell and each weapon was matched up against 20 different types of armor that you would roll for on the chart there are multiple critical hit charts as well which could have incredibly detailed damage results the level of granularity was insane thankfully most games are moving away from charts to lists bookkeeping intensive mechanisms so far we have code basic mechanics but have not really looked at how dice rolls can test with each other and our two players can roll off against each other in a conflict for a basic example let's look at Ellis Minh if a player attacks another they roll one dice each and add their combat stat with the highest roll being the winner contested head-to-head rolls can be incredibly swinging Howard with the variance on a contested d6 roll being plus or minus five and you can have some very odd results with contested D 20s it's plus or minus 19 on the roll that is colossal one or two pointed bondage makes a negligible difference in the result of the actual role Spartacus buttons and uses a more complex variant of the system of each player rolling a dice pool and matching them up against each other with a winner of each dice pairing determining the overall result this system which is similar to the cord I system of the old classic risk is probably a fairer and more balanced approach the contestant rolls in head-to-head checks as I mentioned my biggest issue at contested rolls is that there is that variance and
while dice are great for adding uncertainty it's a little too much uncertainty for me in most cases another variable to add to dice is inclusion of different sided dice such as the d20 made famous by Dungeons and Dragons most common number of sides on these dice are four eight ten twelve and twenty the large of a die the smaller and individual modifier will have all its rolls for example the roller succeed you may set a basic target number of its average roll rounded up on a d6 that would be four on a d20 that would be 11 a plus one modifier to a d6 roll has a significant impact on its likelihood of success from 50% to sixty six point six seven however plus one modifier at a d20 roll only increases it from 50 to 55% this means that a d20 systems require large modifiers to make hits very likely or unlikely and the swingingest of such variable dice roll can appeal and annoy players in equal measure as a rule the more sides of the dice the more extreme their variables will be and the less impact dice modifiers will have the fewer sides the more certainty you will have and this is one of the many reasons why six-sided dice and remain valid and useful even in modern games they actually have quite a low probability distribution so if you're thinking about adding different sided dice to your game it's probably good to look at how those distributions of probabilities work I knew a guy who made a role-playing game based on a t30 and it was complete garbage because he had all these stats rolls all these numbers and all these skills and in new brolove d30 and it would make whatever you had on your character sheet largely irrelevant my personal preference are 4 D 6 D a and
D 10 games some games are a to start with a die of a certain size and upgrade them by actions or abilities that's called dice booster for example you may need a 5 to hit a target and with a 6 sided dice that's unlikely but if you upgrade that dice to attend Saturday's your probability of success dramatically increases portress America is a great example of this with basic military units using a d6 advanced ones da and the elite ones détente I personally really like the system in theory due to the subtle ships you can make two probabilities that changing the target numbers required for the dice rolls in practice though involves a lot of fiddling around and figuring out what dice to roll when I took the time design my own miniatures war game a while back I used dice boosting as its call system and there's a really neat things about it and how modifiers to dice and stuff work it also led to a lot of people going what dice do I need how many am i rolling what's happening here there was a lot of confusion just because of shifting dice up and down it's a lot of bookkeeping which brings us to dice do not have numeric values but instead use symbols on them that communicate different game information for example x-wing dice are 8 sided but they really only have three types of side blanks heads and focus this is what custom dice do they replace charts who used in older style games and acid' put the information directly on the die we no longer need to see that a dice requires a six Buster hit on d8 if there are three sides of the dice showing heads the advantage of the system is once we load the dice symbols gameplay speeds up dramatically however it does make the game slightly dependent on those custom dice a good example of this is first Martians the game has 12 custom dice all
unique and while that could be replicated with regular dice you would need a 12-part chart to interpret the result probably the most extreme version of this is too many bones which has a gazillion different dice types it's not a game I'll get played but I have admired it with some trepidation from afar the advantages of custom dice are that the informations right there and once you get up the speed of the game you can interpret them really quickly and it speeds up gameplay the disadvantage is that frequently the games don't come with enough dice and you have to buy other additional sets or play pass the parcel with the dice a lot well my biggest complaints for style was rebellion is there's only enough dice for one player in any given time and while only one players rolling at any given time it still means you have to pass the dice back and forth constantly it's just a hassle some games even use custom dice with multiple bits of information on them a basic example of this is hostage negotiator but each dice has a numeric value which is used in some roles and a symbol used in the core game mechanics pull out as a step and includes two different types of symbols on the dice that can be used in the various dice mechanics of the game but I think the st. first edition was the first game I played that used this mechanic a lot the advantages of this idea is you can keep one set of dice for multiple mechanics and again which cuts down on the number of components and fiddling around looking for the right dice and there's no real disadvantage compared to any other custom dice game it just means that you can have multiple different dice mechanics within the same game and that seems pretty good to me dice puzzles a dice puzzle game is one that is solved by the rolling and placement of dice in a certain order or sequence Yahtzee is probably the most
well known and one of the most basic of these outer side takes CRC system of rolling facets and using rerolls and applies a narrow death and versary and reward systems of the game turning into a cooperative experience one deck dungeon is a solo dice puzzle game as each encounter requires you to place dice in certain areas to ensure you have the right dice you need to use rerolls and dice modifiers from their various skills and roll player takes us to another level with the act of rolling up a character for a D&D game becomes the whole game roleplay has multiple ways to manipulate those dice so it really does feel like a puzzle and you're not bound by what the dice were initially rolled as those puzzles can be a lot of fun as long as there is enough choices for the player about how to modify and tweak their roles for a dice puzzle game to work for me the puzzle aspect needs to be the strong part the dice need to be able to be manipulated and changed in ways that I can control if the dice puzzle feels too arbitrary then I'll lose interest that are quite quickly worker placement is a completely different mechanic and one book we will likely look at in the later video however as part of the evolution of that mechanic dice have also been used as workers euphoria build a better dystopia uses dice on a relatively simple fashion in some locations the dice value does not even matter but in others the individual and combined values of the placed dice has an impact on your result role for the galaxy goes a step further using customized diets of different types that can placed on multiple different types of actions and with many of the different custom dice having
different strengths of likelihoods of rolling with different action types and yes many people don't consider role for the galaxy a worker placement gamers search anakata isn't but there with me to the example well this does has added an element of uncertainty to a John regimes that traditionally doesn't have any and a standard worker placement game the only real uncertainty is what actions of your opponents will take adding dice means your actions have to adapt to the options available to you this is neither a positive or a negative and design it's just a difference and that difference could be really appealing to some players or really off-putting personally I quite like it I particularly like roll for the galaxy because you have a lot of control and how you customize the workers in your dice pool where you place them and how you modify them so while you are rolling dice and there is an element of uncertainty you also have a lot of control over how they end up coming out which means a player skill is rewarded some games will go to an extreme on our dice are used in the game and quantum is a standout here the dice being the actual playing pieces in the game it's a clever and unusual game and its explanation is probably left to an actual review of it but if you are curious about how you would use dice as actual pieces in the game go check out quantum we've covered just about everything you can think of to do with dice aside from ripping the numbers off and pasting on new ones okay so here's dice Forge the game of ripping up the sides of dice and replacing them as you progress through the game this game allows you to control what the variables and player but not whether they come up it's a fascinating game and one I think has some
interesting potential to be expanded on I think a dungeon crawler like the synth third edition with customizable dice sounds like a thing that could actually happen this is this war of mines rubble dice it's an irregular sided dice that comes with a chart I have no idea how well it works but as example of some of the weirder ideas people have had the dice over the years it's a great example of how people are still trying to innovate with dice a mechanic we consider very basic and very fundamental to a lot of board games here we have it and a regular sided dice why do you need an irregular sided dice why not just sent I'll bias at a chart who knows but it's interesting that people are looking at this idea and trying to come up with new ideas and options the psychology and mysticism of dice luck makes people a bit strange and the number of rituals sacred words and superstitions around dice pretty funny Elissa diocese malformed there should be no lucky dice even though our brains truck us into thinking that there are a classic example as three dice I used in the role-playing game and nominate they rolled during their campaign and an ordinate number of 1 1 1 s and 666 rolls it was noticeable and memorable because the game treats those roles as momentous events but since establishing that legend those dice appear to roll very normally what happens is we get tricked by significant events into thinking dice are lucky or unlucky there probably are there's there's really no such thing as luck there's just probability but gamers are really suspicious bunch also how many
times have you heard the phrase I lost that game because my dice are all sucked compare that to how many times you've heard people say I won that game because I roll really really well dice can be a crutch players blame football play and I've done it myself although it's a habit I'm personally trying to break a lot of people will play a complex game like Star Wars rebellion or War of the Ring and say the game is bad because it has dice rolls which means luck decides the outcome reality is that with enough rolls and with genuine decisions in between a skilled player will still win the overwhelming majority of games and that's because the dice really don't decide the outcome of those games they add uncertainty to actions and while you may recall vividly the Fistful of ones you rolled in an important battle the overall distribution of roles in the game should balance out over time so next time you play a game instead of cursing your dice on a bad roll of throwing them across the room and disgust just acknowledge that bad rolls happen and skilled players adapt to them get better and stop blaming the dice when you lose it's not their fault conclusions Carl von Clausewitz renowned Prussian military strategist and also the mascot of this channel has a concept called friction friction is all the random things that happen in war that turn it from a mathematical challenge into the messy chaotic experience it is from soldiers misinterpreting orders to misinformation and late intelligence through the overwhelming physical factors of the T in disorientation a lot of games give players perfect intelligence about what is going on and 100% certainty on the consequences of their actions dice or one way to shake that up to provide that element of uncertainty and to create scenarios where a hundred
brave souls defend a bridge from a thousand both misinterpret me are saying this that all games need dice of randomness they don't what dice can add is those moments of drama and those swings that happen and conflict and they help tell a great story a well-designed game of dice is not really decided by the dice rolls there should be enough rolls and enough mechanisms through the course of the game the luck balances out for the most part dice represent that not all plans go perfectly and that strategies need to adapt and then uncertainty is a part of conflict don't hate dice learn to love the stories they can tell thanks for listening all no doubt I've missed out something massive from the steep dive we'll glossed over something but I think I've covered a lot of what dice are about and how they are used if you enjoyed this video like it subscribe and check out our patreon this was the pilot for the series and based on how well it does I may look at other game mechanics in a similar way until then take care of