Skip to main content
Loading video...

What's the difference between a trick-taking, climbing & shedding card game??

Transcript 18:14

hi I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming vlog in last year I made a video about top ten mechanisms used in trick-taking games and it was one of my most popular videos that I've made I really enjoyed making it a love playing trick-taking games I've designed to trick taking games pick cocoa and throne which both came out over the last year or 18 months or so and there was one thing that bothered me about that video and it was the fact that I kind of flopped the explanation of what a trick-taking game is compared to a climbing game how is a climbing game different the way I defined climbing games was that you have to get rid of all your cards before the other players and of course that is not the defining feature of a climbing game that is a shedding game and it just happens that most climbing games are also shedding games so in this video I really want to pin down what are the differences between a trick-taking game a climbing game and a shedding game and where do those three things kind of merge together so uno is our main poster child for the sheding games right now everybody knows uno you play a rare card that matches the rank or matches the color of the previous cards played and you can play sets of cards and I don't need to go into you know I don't even have a copy of uno to show you but there have been numerous games a bit like who know that have come out most of them have very little control very little strategy in them but I wanted to show you a particularly interesting example of a shedding game which has no trick-taking or climbing aspects to it and that is the game Fuji flush by freedom and freeze fruity flush is a game for three to eight players where

players race to get rid of all their cards on a player's turn they place any card face-up on the table in front of them if the revealed card is lower than a previous card it has no effect if it's higher than a card which has already been played then the lower card is flushed this means it is discarded and the owner of the card draws a new one from the deck into their hand if a player ever plays a card which matches one or more previously played cards their totals are added together if this now beats another card which is currently revealed the revealed card is discarded and the owner draws a new card if your card is still on the table when it comes around to your turn again that card is now discarded but you don't draw a new one you play a card as normal and hence your hand of cards is reduced in size you win the game if you're the first player to run out of cards in your hand and you have nothing revealed on the table so in a sheding game we are trying to get rid of all our cards before the other players and that is the defining feature of what we would call that genre of games let's look at trick-taking games so what exactly is a trick-taking game in a trick-taking game each player has a hand of cards and the starting player leads a trick by playing any card from their hand onto the table then each player in turn plays a card from their hand if possible each subsequent player must play a card matching the suit of the starting players card this is called following suit if a player is unable to follow suit because they have no such cards in their hand then they can play

any card many trick-taking games feature a suit which is more powerful than all the others this is called the Trump suit when all players have played a card then the trick is complete and the player who played the highest-ranked card in the lead suit ie the suit matching that of the starting players card usually wins the trick however if a trump card has been played into the trick then the player who played the highest-ranked trump would win instead the cards from the trick are collected by the winning player and this is called taking a trick all games differ in how the players win points from their tricks ok I suspect Rick taking is probably fairly familiar to most people who've been watching a video like this particularly people who watch my channel because I go what about Eric taking games all the time right so let's give an example of a trick-taking game that I haven't covered before we're going to look at the game wizard which is very similar to a game I've previously covered called skull King in wizard players attempt to score points by making accurate bets as to how many tricks they will win in each round of play in the first round of play only one trick is played then two tricks will be played in round 2 3 in round 3 and so on a trump suit is determined for the round and then players take it in turn to declare how many tricks they're going to win the starting player may play any card and then each player must play a card matching the suit of the first card however as an exception to the rule a wizard or jester can be played at any time when all players have played one card the trick is 1 either by the first wizard played or if there is no wizard then the highest Trump that's been played or if there is

no Trump and the wizard then the trick is won by the highest card matching the suit of the starting player but playing a jester will always lose you the trick if a player correctly predicts how many tricks they will win then they score 20 points plus 10 points for each trick that they've taken players who are incorrect count up how far out their bid was and they multiply that number by 10 they take this as negative points after 10 or 12 or 15 or 20 rounds depending on the player count then the game ends and the highest scorer wins ok so now we have an example of a shedding game we have an example of a trick-taking game so is it possible to have a climbing game as no trick taking elements and has no shedding elements I must admit this one taxed my brain a little bit trying to work out do I have anything in my collection like that where it's pure climbing so the defining feature in a climbing game is the fact that when you play a card it must be higher than the cards that have been played before sometimes higher all matching but the the climbing bit is the fact that each time you're going higher higher higher until eventually somebody can't play and the game I'm going to show you is a game called 23 by amigo this is pure climbing no trick taking no shedding in 23 the deck is made up of numbers 1 to 23 each multiple times in the deck and each player starts with a hand of 12 cards the player holding the 1 card starts by playing it onto the table then the next player must play pass or fold if they play they must add a set of one or more

cards to the pile the cards must be matching each other and they must be equal to or higher than the last card which was played on the pile if the cards are more than 1 higher than the previous played card then the player takes one penalty chip for each number that has been skipped and 3 times in the game a player may use a bonus chip this allows the player to play cards as if the top card of the pile was up to 5 higher or 5 lower than its actual face value if a player passes they do not play a card and they instead take a penalty chip a player can choose to pass and take to penalty chips they want in that case the next player is forced to play they may not pass if a player chooses to fold then they exit around in this case the player takes as many penalty chips as they have cards remaining in their hand and if a player plays their last card then they get to discard three of their penalty chips the first round ends when all players have either played all their cards or when they've all folded after two complete rounds the player with the fewest penalty chips wins what happens if you combine shedding and trick taking well once again freedom and freeze has the answer and he developed a game a long time ago now called hoppin but it's been re-released over the last year and now it's called fool so this is a trick-taking shedding game inform players are attempted to get rid of their cards cards left in their hand at the end of a round are worth negative points the lead player may play any card

and the other players must follow suit if able if not able then they can play any card there's no Trump suit the highest card in the lead suit wins the trick and the winner of the trick place the first card in the next trick but the loser of the trick takes the fool token and does not get to play in the next trick at all ones are wild they always count of being of the lead color around ends when one player has run out of cards they score 10 positive points or zero points if they took the fool token in that final trick all other players score the face values of the cards in their hands as negative points the wild one card score negative 5 points the game ends when a player has scored 80 negative points after a series of tricks so Fool follows most of the standard trick-taking rules you take in turn to play one card once everybody's played a card then that trick is over albeit one player won't be playing if they were the fool um but it also has that shedding thing what we're trying to do is be the first player to run out of cards so it fits into both categories but what happens if we take a climbing game and combine it with a shedding game well the first example is a game that I played a lot as a teenager and that was a public domain game which we called but the the box version is a game from yellow produced by Richard Garfield and this is the game ghost in ghost players aim to get rid of all their cards before

all other players each player starts the game with four cards in hand and a pile of cards facedown in front of them this is called the mansion on your turn you may play one or more identical cards playing them onto a central pile the played cards must be equal or higher than the top card on the pile or you may try your luck by drawing a card from the deck and attempting to play it onto the pile or if you cannot equal or beat the card on top of the pile then you pick up all the cards in the pile and place them into your hand if at the end of your turn you have less than four cards you draw back up until you've got four in hand playing double or treble sets of cards allows you to immediately take another turn playing four of a kind causes all of the cards in the pile to be discarded from the game a yellow card can always be played regardless of the value of the top card of the pile and a yellow one resets the pile to a value of 1 red cards numbered 3 and 12 are played normally but only other red cards or yellow cards or four of a kind can be played on top of them the blue X card is wild it can be used in sets with all other cards and a blue eight switches the direction of play a blue eleven causes all cards in the pile to be discarded and once that draw deck is empty and a player has no cards in hand then they play blind by drawing cards from their mansion unseen and either placing them on top of the pile if they're able to or otherwise picking up all the cards from the pile into their hand when a player's hand and mansion are both empty they're eliminated from the game this is a good thing because

the last remaining player loses the game so ghost is a climbing game you have to play higher cards each time you play I mean sometimes you can reset it but basically you either play higher cards or you draw the deck but it's also a shedding game because you're trying to get rid of your cards before all the other players and in common with games like uno it doesn't have an awful I'm at lot of control or strategy to it it's kind of a game where you go along with the ride and it's chaos and fun and all of that I loved it as a teenager in the sort of public domain version I played I'm not sure how often I would dip back into it now but it's a hugely popular game sharing all around the world by backpackers in its original form and coast is a lovely sort of you know lovely beautifully drawn version of the game let's look at a more sophisticated example of a climbing game that's combined with a shedding game so something with a little bit more strategy in fact with quite a lot of strategy and skill to it and this is the two or three player game haggis by indie boards and cards the aim in a game of haggis is to empty your hand of cards while capturing scoring cards during play each player has a jack a queen and a king face-up in front of them and 14 cards in their hand players then have the option of betting that they will be the first to shed all of the cards from their hand one player starts by playing a set of one or more cards these could be matching cards for example three of a kind or four of a kind the king the Queen and the jack can always be used as wildcards or as a 13 or 12 or an 11 respectively a player might

alternatively choose to play a sequence of individual cards or a sequence of pairs or triplets etc each subsequent player must play a higher-ranking combination of exactly the same nature and number of cards or they must pass and players continue successively adding cards to the table until all but one player has passed the player of the highest combination wins all the cards from the pile and leads with a new set of one or more cards and the round ends when all but one player has shed the cards from their hand the player who went out first games all the cards from the remaining players hand and a few cards which were not dealt at the start of the round these are used for scoring whenever a player goes out they score 5 points for each card in the hand of the player with the most cards and at the end of the round players score points from the cards they have captured throughout the round and also they score points for successful bets hagas also features a few special combinations called bombs so a bomb would be for example a jack and the king or a 3 5 7 9 all of different suits these can be played at any time and they will beat any other combination okay so that has a real trick-taking feel to it although it is not a trick-taking game what I mean by that is the fact that we are making bets so and we're trying to hold on to the lead by by playing cards and then and then and then if we if we are the one that manages to play the highest set

then we get to lead again starting a new sort of run of cards so it feels like a trick-taking game it's going to appeal to trick-taking gamers and so I think that's where often the climbing and trick-taking games get conflated because they have a very similar feel and a very similar appeal but it's not a trick-taking game it's a climbing game and it's a shedding game so can we come up with an example of a trick-taking game which is also a climbing game if we ask Friedemann Friese once again we have the answer and this is a full gherkin in front gherkin there are no suits just the numbers 1 to 15 each represented four times the starting player can play any card from their hand and then each subsequent player must either play a matching or higher numbered card or they can play the lowest card from their hand the player who wins the trick by playing the highest card then leads the next trick and the only trick which matters for scoring is the seventh and final trick of the round the player who wins this trick must take the number of cucumbers indicated on their winning card and when a player has collected 5 cucumbers after 2 3 4 rounds then they're eliminated from the game the game is won by the final player remaining so in front of gherkin we're not trying to shed cards it's not a shedding game we are playing tricks each player takes one card they play one card at a time and we go round and then we see who's played the highest card but

the rule is you have to play the higher card than what's what's gone previously or you kind of passed by throwing away your lowest card from your hand so it's got a climbing mechanism in it but it is very clearly a trick-taking game as well now is it possible to combine all three is there an example of a game which is a shedding game and a trick-taking game and a climbing game and I discovered one last year and it's brill so I wanted to bring it to your attention this is the game vampire queen from Smits peel it's in the same range as skulking and voodoo Prince but this one is by Wolfgang Kramer who is just a master of game design and it's nice to see him dipping into that sort of trick taking climbing sort of area vampire queen is a climbing game for three to twelve players players are dealt a set number of cards and the remainder are not used in the game the star player plays a set of one or more matching cards and each subsequent player must play exactly the same number of cards of a higher value than the previous played set if unable to do so than the player must pass after all players have played once or passed then the car turned around and discarded and the player of the highest set starts the next round there are four vampire Queens which are wild when played in a set or valued at 14 when played alone there are also two vampire Slayer's and only the start player of a round can play a vampire slayer if they do so each other player must play exactly one vampire card this

can be higher or lower than the previously played cards and the vampire Slayer's counters values zero in these rounds the vampire Queens counters value one here and whoever plays the highest card picks up all the cards played in that little vampire slayer' round and when one player runs out of cards the round is over player score negative points equal to the face values of all the cards in their hands and if you're holding a vampire at the end of the round it's worth negative 15 or negative 20 points at the end of the game the player with the fewest negative points wins so thoroughly enjoyed vampire queen it is a trick-taking game it is a climbing game it is a shedding game I think the arc online I see this debated a lot people feel quite passionate about this they don't like it when people say that a climbing game is a trick-taking game you often see it people make a list of their favorite tricking games and then a little climbing game will creep in there well my point to you is sometimes those people are right sometimes those games are not just climbing games they're both and actually trick-taking games and climbing games share a very similar ancestry anyway I covered a little bit in my old video about the top 10 trick taking mechanisms so they have the same sort of lineage it's just that in the east we went off in one direction in the West we went off in a different direction and we ended up with these modern games that we play today if you enjoyed my video please watch some more I've got lots more on my channel Adams board game Wales if you want to follow me on Twitter I'm at board game Wales BoardGameGeek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved