Skip to main content
Loading video...

Aqua Garden and Sky Garden Reviews - The Birds & The....Fish?

Transcript 11:29

Hey, I'm Alex Rack from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Aqua Garden and Sky Garden, not Dino Garden, which is here in front of me. And the reason for that is because I've already reviewed Dino Garden and I highly encourage you checking out that video because that's kind of what that this video is going to be heavily based on that video. What I mean by that is these games over here, I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. These are all prototypes, rules, components, subject exchange, all of that. But they're basically part of a series of three games. Dino Garden, which I've already reviewed, Aqua Garden, which is actually the first one in the series, but not the first one I played. I actually played Dino Garden, then Acro Garden, then Sky Garden, and the order may well have biased my opinion on these games. We'll talk about that soon. But it's a series of three games that all have a strong similarity in the structure of how they operate and then some minor differences as to what they each bring to the table.

Because of that, I was like, I could do a full other review for Acro Garden and Sky Garden separately, but I'd mostly be repeating nearly the exact same things I said for Stino Garden with minor differences about how I feel about those small changes. So, to that end, check out that review. You don't you don't have to, but I do recommend checking it out. I'll be diving into how these games generally operate, as well as the differences between Acro Garden and Sky Garden, what they bring to the table, and then my thoughts on those differences. If you just care about my thoughts as to how I feel about all three of these games, just skip to final thoughts because I'll be covering that in the final thoughts. But with that said, the general idea of these games where I have I have I have aids over here. I have aids from the games. This over here is the board for uh for Sky Garden. The basic idea of all of these games is you're going to have these people who are moving around this track over here in order to collect various things to put them onto their personal player boards. These are going to be your personal player boards in the game.

Again, slightly different in each game, but to give you an idea of the differences in case you haven't seen the Dino Garden review, this would be the Aqua Garden playerboard, and this would be the Sky Garden playerboard. You can see that they are strongly similar in the general structure of what they're doing while having some differences. But you are going around this rondelle, around this track, and you're trying to gather various pieces, uh, which are going to be the various birds, fish, or dinos depending on the game you're playing, and putting them into your personal exhibits in order to score points. That's the very very high level of how these games operate. Outside of that, there are nuances to each one. Aqua Garden falls on the probably the most not probably for sure the most accessible of them. It was the original. And while Dino Garden and Sky Garden bring new mechanics to the table, Aqua Garden kind of is the most straightforward. You're gathering various fish. You're putting them into your exhibit. You do have these cards, these milestones effectively that you're trying to get certain fish into the tanks in order to achieve various points and extra tokens over here. That's the main thing you're trying to work on.

There's also a bit of a movement puzzle where you have your your worker moving around these exhibits and you can only place next to where he lands and you're trying to balance the various needs. Uh, in most of the games it's oxygen. In Aqua, sorry, in most of the games it's space. In Aqua Garden, it's oxygen, but you're balancing the needs of those fish versus how much each tank can provide while having other things that you can add to those to give it more. So, you're basically gathering tokens, putting them to your exhibit. This one is the most straightforward. Acquard. Acquart is the most straightforward. If you watched my review of Dino Garden, there was a whole mechanic there where you had carnivores and herbivores and you had to gather the herbivores in order to feed the carnivores. And so you had this predator track where effectively every time you ate meat from the herbivores, you were moving up those tracks. You had to balance where you placed your dinosaurs based on their needs. You have to balance moving around the food so you can get the right food to the right dinosaurs. So it's a little bit of a pick up and deliver while having extra components and elements to manage as you play through Dino Garden. Acro Garden just doesn't have any of that. There's nothing really it really has that's extra. It just has minor variations on the rules. And then these milestones instead of the goals that you had in Dino Garden, which doesn't really change things significantly. It's just a different thing to go with. All the games have the kind of like little event card, which I think is mislabeled in terms of the way it's structured, but they have an event card where as you pass them, you're rewarded for having certain things in these two exhibits over here. That's a consistent trend across across all them. But effectively, if you imagine my entire review of Dino Garden and strip away the entire concept of predators and only focus on trying to get things into your garden, that's the

basic idea over there. In fact, the original Aqua Garden, it doesn't even have the special cars as the core rules. The special dinosaurs effectively or special fish in this one, they're not part of the core rules. They're just they're in Dino Garden. They're part of the core rules. In Aquagard, they're like an extra advanced mode that you can play as. I will say the one thing, where is my board over here? The one thing it does have differently, something fell off to grab that a second, is in over here, uh, when you are doing advertisements, instead of just taking three money, which is something you can do in Dino Garden, you can take money based off of having certain criteria. So, you're going to choose one of these over here and effectively be advertising pulling people into your park. So, that that gives a little bit more of a something to consider. It's the one element of Aqua Garden that is more nuanced, more in-depth than Dino Garden.

That's kind of a garden. I think you've seen everything you need to see. We have the advanced fish over here. We have the various again those milestones you're working towards. But outside of that, it's it's Dino Garden just with less predators. Then we have Sky Garden. Sky Garden adds something else to the genre to the puzzle. Similar to the way Dino Garden added something. Again, for me, I played Dino Garden first, but the way Dino Garden kind of took a garden and added an entire Predator concept to it. Sky Garden is doing something similar. I should note before I dive into this, this prototype had a lot of issues with uh re misprinted boards effectively where I got multiples of the same board, which meant I kind of had to proxy some elements to make it work. It was workable, but they definitely had some issues to this, some prototype issues that got a little bit in the way of the experience. So, my experience with Sky Garden isn't as perfect as it should be. Again, prototype issues and all those things. Just worth noting that cuz as much as I was able to make it work, those things can get in the way of the experience. But that said, uh, Sky Garden is basically adding one more thing to the board. Uh, instead of having predators, you have the basics of the game. So that basic rondelle, you're moving around the rondelle. It maintains that aspect where these advertisements are rewarding you for specific things as opposed to just giving you $3. So when you have a choice to uh buy a car, you can either buy an advanced bird or alternatively, you can take one of these and get points to a maximum based on certain criteria you have. So again, adds that element back in, but although I guess depends on back in, depends on the order of these games. But the main thing it has is it adds this concept of these eggs and hatching. So effectively what you have over here is you have well it changes up the way you do the milestones as well. So you have this milestone track where you're basically

going to have these various milestones. I'm not going to lay them all out but you'll have different uh various things in various cages that you're earning points. You're what you're doing is you're trying to fulfill the criteria on these. And as you do so you're going to get points for the rows and columns of getting these rewards over here. So you are going for milestones. Again, if you remember my review of Diner Garden, you kind of had to match up two milestones and you got rewarded for those random pairing of a top and a bottom milestone versus for Aquagard, it's a straightforward single milestone. And in the case of Sky Garden, it gives you a randomized grid. So, you're working on the rows and columns in order to get the rewards on those. So, again, it gives you a lot more to consider as you try to work your way towards these. So, this one was the most interesting as far as the milestone puzzle. Not to mention the fact that I just generally like um I generally like uh uh uh doing rows and columns and trying to figure out my way towards it cuz getting the whole grid feels like you got everything versus otherwise you have to figure out what you're actually able to achieve. So, I liked this board the most. We're diving into opinions here. I'll skip opinions.

Uh let's save opinions for shortly. But then outside of that, you basically have this whole bleeding mechanic. So, in Dino Garden, you kind of magically just had children every single round uh which were then promptly eaten, which was an interesting mechanic. But effectively in this one over here, what you're working with is you're working with getting birds into the same exhibit of the same species uh along with a nest token in order so that you can make eggs. You have this little nest over here. You'll be storing the eggs and then depending on how high your income track over here, your fun track, you'll be multiplying the point value for these eggs times the number of eggs you have. So, you have to balance an entirely different game. You are still trying to be mindful of what goes where in the game. Uh, but it changes up the way you're trying to do things because you're trying to pair up nests with two of the same species in order to breed and then trying to make sure your funds are high enough to maximize that scoring. That's the main difference in Sky Garden, which means I've kind of given you the main differences between these games. If you watch my review of Dino Garden, if you watch this video, and if those fell over there, then you at this point know basically how to play all three of these games. Uh, as far as my opinion on these games, we're going to jump to the final thoughts part now. I'm just going to jump straight into final thoughts because it's kind of mostly what I said about Dino Garden with some small nuance differences. So, Aqua Garden is my least favorite here and I think I am colored by the fact that I played Dino Garden first. So, I had the more complex version of the ecosystem was my first introduction to the ecosystem relative to Aqua Garden was dialed back. So, for me, I I played Dino Garden and then I played a game that had less interesting decision space. So, Acardarden's fine, but rating wise in Aqua Garden, I'm

going to give it a three out of five. Dino Garden was a 3.5. I like Dino Garden. It has a decent amount of juggling as far as trying to make it all work. My biggest concern is the replayability of it. Uh, Aqua Garden, though, is the same, but less so. Now, that doesn't mean it's not right for you. It may well be better for you depending on your level of complexity you're looking for. And I will say pick up and deliver isn't even my favorite mechanic. But that said, it just to me it felt like I played a game, had a core concept of it stripped out, and then played that version. So, I'm almost certainly colored by the order in which I played these games, but it made me enjoy Aqua Garden less because it felt like Diner Garden, but less. Sky Garden, on the other hand, is my favorite of the three. Not by a large, not by a large margin over here. It's still a 3.5 out of five. Uh, but for me, Sky Garden was the one I liked the most because I mentioned I don't love pickup and deliver, and Sky Garden kind of gave you something else to manage, but I like the milestone board significantly more. Or again, even with the protype issues where even with the protype issues, I like the uh milestone board significantly more as far as the structure of how that operates. Uh and then overall, I I like the I like the uh breeding mechanic and then trying to maintain your fund track. That's a big thing as well, like the the forcefulness ma the forced maintenance of your funds in order to maximize your egg scoring.

That gives you something else you really have to manage in terms of you can't just get money and then spend it. So, it gave you more to juggle in the game while removing pick up and deliver as a mechanic. So it kind of felt like Dino Garden but tweaked with elements that I enjoy and appreciate more. I still have the same concerns as far as the core concept of the track is basically the same or I guess technically one of the difference in Aquagro Garden is Aquagard you have the ability to get multiple fish from a track if it wasn't selected. That's one of the minor difference small things. But either way yeah I like I like Scar Garden the most because it felt like the most it felt like it gave me the most uh it gave mechanics that I liked more while being layered like Dino Garden is. But I still have the same concerns that the core concept, the core loop of what you're doing is very similar game to game. And the milestone track does shift it up a bit more those crisscross. Again, even D Garden has the mismatch milestones, but this gives you like a a whole grid to work on with slightly more interesting. But overall, I think it still suffers from the same concern that the core thing that you're doing is very much the same across the three or four rounds of play depending on the player count that you are playing through. That's my review of these games. Aqua Garden is a three out of five. Down is a 3.5. Sky Garden is a 3.5. Sky Garden is my favorite of the three just for having mechanics that are slightly more to my personal taste.

That's basically my review. Feel free to check out the crowdfunding page down below. And until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Board Game Co. Hope you found this video helpful and as always I hope you have a good

Progress saved