Skip to main content
Loading video...

Flexibility & Achievements - TCbH Quarantine Solo Diary # 5

Transcript 20:28

hey everyone welcome back to another cardboard herald solo quarantine playlist where we focus on solo gaming topics as well as talking about some of the games that i've been playing solo during quarantine to give you some of my impressions and today we have five games to talk about which is going to be beat down streets of justice we got flourish pax premier 2nd edition pendulum and tapestry including the new tapestry expansion but before we get to all of that as always we have our topic to talk about now we've talked on this channel a lot about what makes solo board gaming cool why you might choose to do it and what are some of the benefits of it now we've also talked about like what kind of sets it apart from multiplayer gaming something that i truly love and still generally prefer but the more that i play game solo the more that i realize that it it delivers so much more than just a an opportunity to play a game that i wouldn't otherwise have the chance to play multiplayer and i've thought a lot about this and one of my absolute favorite things about playing solo is the lack of pressure the only person that is there that is going to be affected by the outcome of the game is me now i'm not someone who takes a game too seriously i don't need to win i don't need to lose but there is a certain exchange that

needs to happen when you're playing a multiplayer game right there's an expectation that people are going to be trying to win in fact i think there's a real famous reinhard kenitzia quote that goes along the lines when playing a game you should be trying to win it's the trying that's important not the winning the the thing is is that i don't have as much room for experimentation when i am playing a a multiplayer game because it breaks the social contract of playing that game together with your friends i mean sure you can invest in different strategies when you're playing a game but you don't have that true flexibility where there's not someone relying on you either cooperatively or competitively to be trying your best but during solo games that's not the case yes you want to try to win and you want to be able to have a positive outcome and feel like you had a successful experience but what defines a successful experience may be completely different in a solo game because you're the only one affected by that outcome so what am i really talking about here i am talking about achievements now for the most part i imagine most of you know what achievements are in a video game context they're some sort of uh earnable little blip on a screen that is going to tell you hey good job you did something rather unconventional or was particularly challenging here's a little notification that you

have this reward and you can talk to your friends about how cool you are for having it now there are board games that have implemented achievements like actually into the game itself you have things like mice and mystics which had a whole achievement list that was pretty novel and it feels good when your team gets these and then there are games like say terraforming mars that have the the achievements and milestones as a system within the game but those aren't really what i'm talking about because they're part of the avenues that you must employ or more likely will need to employ in order to have a an effective strategy in the game and i'm really talking about having a list of parameters for yourself where you are going to try things that are out of the box that allow you to really enjoy your games in different ways but it goes beyond that it's not just the enjoyment thing it's that i think with this flexibility this lack of pressure that you have in solo games it allows you to understand the framework of games much more it's just like practicing shooting hoops by yourself sure you don't have the actual opponent right across from you in order to give you that particular challenge but allows you to strive for different things and work on your particular weaknesses or understand more about the game itself

and that's what achievements can do for us now rather than going through all of my different games that you may not own or you know you may not be interested in and talking about the various achievements that i've set up for myself i wanted to encourage you to come up with some of your own and share some of them that you think are are particularly cool for yourself there are whole lists of achievements out there and a ton of resources this isn't a new concept but it's something that i think that particularly while we're in quarantine while we're spending a lot of time at home by ourselves we can use this as a way of really investing ourselves in some of our favorite games that may have gotten stale from just playing them over and over again or to to give yourself some new challenges uh in order to really feel like you're fulfilling something at the table that's different than the standard parameters that you have now i'm going to create a google doc that is going to be a list of some achievements i've come up with for my favorite games whether i've achieved them or not and if people comment and reply with their own then they can go ahead and get that added to the google doc or rather i'll add it there and if there is some enterprising and far more bgg savvy user who wants to make a geek list out of it more power to you but we now have to turn to our quarantine solo playlist

we got these five games to talk about first i'm going to talk about flourish this game is interesting for a lot of reasons but in a specific solo context you're still going to run into some of the best and worst aspects of flourish and that is that the game feels very lightweight as you're playing it it feels like something that you could play without really having to crunch a lot of information at the end of each round it's going to check certain things and depending on the cards that you played you're going to get certain points some cards have end round scoring some cards just have certain features which will be considered in those seems really approachable but once you get to the end game and you have your final round and and game scoring for all the different things that are going on in your garden and many of your cards could have end game scoring conditions then it becomes this real crunchy thing that you didn't realize how complex that the the nature of your garden was as you played it it seems to feel like it's at odds with itself you may want a lightweight game but suddenly at the end it feels much crunchier than you expected or maybe you want a really challenging crunchy game and the act of playing it may feel a little too lightweight as you're doing it either way it takes only about 20 minutes but it seems to not really fit into any specific niche which

in a way is cool that it sets itself apart but it is hard to find what is the the mental state that you want to be in to sit down and play some flourish now you also have here tapestry tapestry is a story to game for lots of reasons but i think one of the best things about it is the solo mode i made a specific video about the solo and while there's a lot of discussion about balance in tapestry this whole thing that we were talking about in the the lack of pressure of an opponent sitting across from you that you have this expectation to do well well the only thing you have to balance against is yourself in the solo mode and the automated opponent but who cares about the automated opponent either win or you don't but you still get to wring out the most points that you can possibly get from your particular civilization now the plans employees expansion one of the big features of it is solo focus there's a set of scenarios that can be played as a campaign that have these buckwild parameters i mean they can be achievements in and of themselves they're going to set specific restrictions or limitations on you uh that are are going to feel very counter to playing the game in the normal way and pressure you into coming up with creative solutions kind of exactly what we were trying to do with achievements here except a little bit more overhead one of

the things i don't like about tapestry solo which overall i think is one of the better auto factory solo modes is that it does restrict you on a lot of the different components that can be included so if you are selecting your civilization you need to take out x y and z civilizations for a normal mode and then you also have plants employees has some new civilizations which you might need to take out and then you may have specific scenario civilizations that need to be taken out as well and so there there is some upkeep in the beginning of restriction and then there's also going to be the same sort of restrictions applied to tapestry cards themselves because they they will affect the actual balance or or the intentions of the solo scenarios but the core system for the automa and the shadow empire is really well done it involves two cards overlapping with one another to define what it's going to do for the turn it has a great escalation for the opponent and one of my favorite things is that there are different civilizations for the opponents and they're not the same civilizations that normal players would play with but they do give that sort of flavor of playing against a real opponent now speaking of ottoman factory another one of the anime factory joints that we have to talk about is pendulum now this is the storied new release of stone meyers that's a real time worker placement game instead of

defining your limitations based off of the turns that you can take in a worker placement game this is defined by time you have little sand timers that are going to flip basically once you've put someone into a location you can't activate them until the timer is on its side but you also can't move them to other locations until the timer is off one of the really cool things about this is that i think that the auto factory has come up with some of their most creative work in order to extremely elegantly extremely simplistically make it so the pressure is on you even in this real time game because any time you move a worker in the solo game which you are inherently playing it the same way that you normally would but when you move a worker in the solo game you draw a card and that card is either going to move what locations are blocked by certain workers and then it will also tell you to flip certain timers if those timers have run out one of the timers in the game as in the multiplayer game drives how long a round lasts the purple timer and you could just not ever move that giving you more freedom on the green and black timers but if the automa opponent flips the purple timer they get a little acceleration in their points for every one of the time tokens the the counter for the end of the round that they claim by bumping it off and that means that the pressure is on you

in order to flip the timer which is going to accelerate the end of the round putting the limitations on yourself you're incentivized to really force your own end game in this and it it feels like such a brilliant way of approaching how to make a real-time strategy game like this make sense and by not having that opponent it gives you a little more flexibility to look at the few avenues that you have for approaching the game in different ways for the most part when you're playing with a multiplayer opponent it feels somewhat linear and limiting because you want to make the absolute best use of things and you're feeling this pressure of time so you you don't really branch out you go with what you know because you don't really have time to think about different things as you're playing the game but in this solo context you have a little bit more flexibility and that that lack of pressure uh from having someone sitting across from you that you might investigate different strategies which could have very real ramifications for multiplayer mode so if you've never played a real-time game that really worked for you or made sense in a solo context if you get a chance try try and pendulum i i thought it was really creative hard to recommend game in general because i think some of the mechanics involved are kind of competing for what type of people may enjoy them but i like weird stuff and i ended up liking

that game okay so that's going to bring us to our last two games on the list now first off we have beat down streets of justice and when you pick up this game the first thing that you're going to notice is the art style i mean it's undeniable that this has pretty amateurish art but in truth i actually think the artist did a lot of creative things in order to make it come across as charming rather than something that is just kind of bleh now the the presentation of the game aside the game itself it's attempting to kind of ape some of the overall aesthetic of like classic beat-em-up video games you know streets of rage or river city ransom that kind of thing but you're not actually like side scrolling or moving along you have rounds where uh there's going to be opponents who you're going to fight and depending on who your hero is you have certain cards shuffled into a hero deck and you're going to create these combos and the combo system is really the killer feature here and something that felt completely unique and is really intriguing like it's something that you want to invest in more basically it's a push your luck system where you play a card and that card may impact how likely it is that you'll be successful on the next card that you play and there's some other resource elements within the game that will affect being able to pull off successive attacks before your round is over

there there's penalties for failure in your combos there's rewards for particular levels of success and there's tempo elements where certain cards if they're played in certain orders are going to be more powerful versions of them whether they're finishers or something that sets up another combo or is played in the middle the game is okay like i came away from it feeling like you know i i've gotten what i need to out of the game i really love the combo system what i'd really like to see is this designer to to really develop the system uh and find like a way to really tighten things up where you have a game that all elements of it are are just as good and just as profound as that central combo system within it now the last game is the ultimate contrast to that pax premiere second edition now i hadn't played this during the solo quarantine whole shebang here but i had played it solo mode in the past and i just had all these other games that i wanted to try because i played pax premiere and you know like i wanted to make sure that i was hitting on all these other games i hadn't tried coming back to this now that i've played a lot more solo games chef's kiss that game is incredible i mean the multiplayer game is incredible like it's just such a well-designed game that feels like such a cohesive ecosystem of choices where everything is so

tightly interwoven and impacts one another uh and the the solo mode developed by ricky royal is so so good it's such an elegant system for defining what is going to be populated on the board during the wakans turn what is going to uh take effect during the wakan's turn the escalation of power that they have i mean the game is a really complex system you're going to be checking the rule book a lot you're going to be looking over that wakan section you're going to be checking the bgg faqs to make sure that you're carrying things out but once you get cooking in this game it is among the most satisfying solo gaming experiences i have ever had it's just this really really tight puzzle where every move that you make is going to impact what the solo opponent is going to be capable of doing on their turn and so it's not purely reactive but you're going to have to keep track of so many features as as you play what's available in the market how much money is in the market how much money has been flooded into the game period what sort of capabilities your opponents have based off of which favored suit is on the table and so it's much more of a puzzle than a lot of solo games that i played where it feels like you can really optimize your turns not that there's only one strategy but you can feel like all right i've

analyzed it enough i think this is the best possible thing that i can do here and then there's going to be some randomized elements based off of another two-card system that is going to define what uh cards the opponent radicalizes taking into their court uh and what actions that the opponent does um but you have a degree of anticipatory control of some of their possibilities before that happens but not so much that you can fully plan everything out it just is one of those games that it looks so great on the table it feels so smart as you're playing adapting to different factions based off of whether they're dominant or not or trying to make sure that no one is dominant and you have enough tribes on the board or in play anywhere your little cylinders uh is just such a rewarding puzzle and is among the best gaming experiences that i've had period i've played it a ton since i recorded this last video uh and i i can't recommend it enough if you like really cerebral puzzles but it has that thematic resonance then i think pax premier is among the best and that's how we're going to leave it today thank you guys so much i hope you come up with a lot of great solo gaming achievements and i look forward to hearing what you have to say let me know if there's some recommendations for games that i should check out that i haven't listed in any

of these solo gaming playlists uh and if there's any games that i've played that you've since checked out based off of this series and how that worked out for you thanks again keep on playing i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved