Do this BEFORE designing a game | Leo Taylor
Transcript
don't let your cleverness don't let your excitement for this whatever new thing you're going to add in there don't forget about Bob though cuz Bob's your target audience now if you needed to now be targeting at Steve because the game has changed and it went from a 30 minute you know filler game to like a twoh hour you know game night okay that's fine but be very intentional in going from Bob to Steve gotta keep Bob I'm gonna change that that section to keep Bob in mind I like keep Bob in mind don't forget about Bob don't forget about Bob cuz Bob's buying your game hopefully it moves Bob when he plays your game he he's like this was made for me so Leo you've got experience working with Hasbro you've worked with some pretty big Brands you work with clue you work D and you've worked with risk like that's that's a pretty good pedigree as far as a resume is you know is concerned but you've got this really cool Gauntlet you call it where you basically determine your pillars of game design and you kind of plug an idea into all these different thing it's it's pretty it's pretty big and I'll link it to people down below the show where they can kind of see it for themselves but we're just going to dive into into these pillars and dive into all the sub pillars because that's the thing it's like one big idea and then like a whole bunch of subtopics that really just kind of help you put the game in the box so to speak right figure out what are the constraints where do I want to go what do I want to do so before we get into it you know in more detail tell me exactly like your thoughts like what is this thing that you created to help you design games and then also like why why did you create this as opposed to just sitting down and seeing what happens and let the let the game design just kind of flow from you like why get more
technical with this kind of document yeah of course well thanks for having me Gabe um huge fan of the podcast thanks for having me on I um so the pillars of design started when I started listening to things like this podcast reading books learning like you know how it goes it's a multi class kind of focus game design and so I was like man I'm gonna forget half these things I'm notoriously you know not great memor so I just want to start documenting them and then I realized at some point oh this is kind of a like like you said a gauntlet like this is a good thing to think of before I start going into deep design work um so let's say I'm I'm working on a game I'm thinking oh this theme would work really well um maybe I have like a noodling of like where to start but actually I think I'm ready to develop let's go ahead and like do a checklist almost like um kind of like not only how many players that kind of thing but also think of it from like different angles like what's the narrative what's the theme how are you gonna Market it and it's not really to stifle your creativity it's just to kind of help you get a full picture to kind of get those nodes in your brain connected before you start going into design I also find it very comforting to set those constraints because then I don't go off in the weeds which I'm also notorious for doing I'll think as as you guys probably all do it's like oh this mechanic but what if I added this other mechanic and so this is a way to keep you in the Box um and just have kind of a Target that you're aiming for the second part is if you ever get lost in your design let's say it's you know you're in development and you're like what was I doing should we change this to to this rule A or B you can
always look back at the document and say well if we want to make it a family lightweight party game then that chooses for me I don't need to you know waste too much time thinking which mechanic to go with it's like oh there's the there's the target so it's kind of just a way to keep yourself honest um and it's also not a like you have to do everything on the checklist it's I will typically go through these um I'm skim and kind of like I can answer that question right now that one I don't know I can answer that one um so I apologize the document that's a lot going on but that's my document you know like I I encourage everyone to make their own because the process is different but yeah that's one thing I've really been thinking about lately is is not hey you should do this instead it's hey I did this and this is what worked for me your mileage may vary but here's the systems and ideas that that I kind of figured out uh here's the evidence in my own designing my own publishing my own crowdfunding journey of what works and what doesn't and then hopefully other people can learn from it right and they can take some things way but it's not Theory right you are actively using this document to create games that have sold in the you know in the marketplace right like I said you you've worked on clue and d and d like you've worked on these big Brands right you've made Escape rooms for like a clue escape room is a brilliant idea that I'm so excited that it exists but it's like when when you hear that though you're like well of course that exists like that's a that just makes sense and so we can use these games I want you to help kind of structure some of these ideas using the games that are on the market right that way people can kind of really get a a real sense of how this
document then translates into a product right and as we just kind of go through these things feel free share any stories anecdotes about the process along the way and I think the best thing to do is just kind of go through the highlights the pillars on the document and then dive into any of the subtopics we don't have time to do it all because this thing is massive and I like I like that it has lots of options right but to your point it's not for someone just to copy paste and say oh I'm GNA do that too it's like no look at this figure out what works for you someone might have totally different ideas you know based on the kind of games that they're wanting to design or publish or bring out into the marketplace and so yeah let's just kind of let's just kind of dive into oh another thing I I wrote down while you were talking is uh this document creates a decision filter and that's one thing I taught to new designers especially you've got to constrain yourself if anything is possible nothing is going to get done because you just it's it's too open-ended right and so creating a document like this even if it's much simpler right even if it's just like a handful of bullet points on the front end of like what kind of game you're wanting to make those bullet points will help you have a decision filter so that anytime like like you said if you want to change the mechanism if you want to do something thematically well you just look at that filter and then you just process everything through it you're like no that doesn't make sense because here's what I'm trying to trying to accomplish right because if you don't have that it's just like let's do everything look like you're never gonna get well I find that for me I love to I love designing Around theme and kind of making sure the Motions match the mechanics that kind of thing is important to me so I feel like you're juggling a lot of different mindsets at once so this at least helps
you kind of at least jar those like you know it's like okay I'm thinking very mechanically right now but at least let me look at this document oh right narrative and it kind of just helps jog your memory to like keep these things in mind um as well which is kind of fun yeah it's great to refocus also I can see the benefit of like maybe you hadn't worked on the game in six months or a year you can come back to this document and go oh yeah here are all the things that I'm trying to do and it's not just like sporadic not not that you wrote down during play test it's like very specific answers to questions and on the checklist like that's got to be super helpful when you're coming back to a design you got to love those scrolled notes on the back of rules that you're like I can't even read this what did I say right you're short hand you're like I don't even know what this means yeah so the first one is experience which I love because that's that's where I begin I I'm thinking through what experience do I want to create for players so let me ask you this is this a hierarchy like is experience first on purpose or is it just kind of random okay so I have to admit it is a a bit of a um Brick by Brick over the years I've added chunks to it and they I haven't put them in a perfect order I don't know if there is such a thing but I find this this system of going through from the top to bottom for me useful right now but every now and then I will purposely take a chunk of it and move it around just because I don't want to get locked into like oh I always think how many players first then I do this um so to keep it kind of fresh but I think experience is a is a good place to start as well I'm also a very experiential designer first so I like this one yeah so couple questions in there are one is how does it end which I
think you know begin with the end in mind is one of the most like old school business pieces advice in the world but I think for game design is great too because you know how does the game end how do you win like what are the things that are going to bring this experience to a close if you know that early it can help make a lot of decisions as far as like what are the what are the things pointing to that you know how do the rounds work are we drawing cards rowing dice all these things yeah but why oh because they lead to this endgame State oh okay that makes a lot more sense so I think that's that's super smart I always when I read rule books I have I have my favorite types of rule books the ones that give you a premise who are you what are you doing narratively how do you win and I like that because it it kind of uh it's a little bit clearer I don't know I like I think it's just clear for me to get context of what you're doing so you know why is why not designed that way too I also think in mind like how does zen could also be a like moment like oh does the family throw their hands up in the air and go ah we that was a close one you it's kind of like noodlings of moments of just kind of interaction uh so it could kind of be that if you wanted to be mechanics how does it in how do you win but also how does it like what's the climactic you know moment of the game what are you kind of looking to build towards I had a really great conversation with Jeff Anglin recently and we were talking about design Theory and that's one of the main things we talked about was understanding these moments in your game and and the ending is so vital because that's that's what people are mainly going to remember and so if the ending just kind of goes out with a whimper right and the best part of the game was in the middle well people aren't going to remember the middle as much as they remember the end
right so even if the middle was amazing if the end was like me they're gonna think the game was like H it's just okay you know versus the other way around another thing you have in there is what Peak experience are you trying to create so again what are these moments so talk to me about some some of those moments like for your own games right with these escape room games with the risk which is like the risk game is super cool because it's like a card game version of risk risk strike right where you're trying to take this massive board game experience that people have been playing forever and condense it down into a card game experience which is no small task right so using maybe some of the games you've worked on help me to understand how you would apply the this pillar of these questions to one of those games so with risk luckily uh that's one of my personal favorite designs because it is I loved risk growing up and I was like I don't have time to play a full game of Risk so let's espresso shot it how can you get espresso shot for like the modern kind of you know time limits you have um so that one it was actually their blueprint was already existed because you could go to risk you could be like how does it feel to play Risk what are the big moments there's the dice moment where you have your big troops you know and you're fighting against your friend and you guys are both kind of mad at each other and you're like well let's do this final battle and we roll the dice and there's kind of that moment of like ah I win or I or I got you through the dice rolling and so that is not a complicated moment but that is a very crucial moment to the risk DNA of dice rolling and kind of like just beating you through kind of like chance and so for the risk strike that that was a must you had to have dice you had to have the same kind of like I got you um I'm a little proud
that we've added a little extra layer there are some like tactics cards you can play to like kind of oh I got you but then you know reroll your dice um so that's kind of an example in that system of a peak moment of like you need that risk throw your hands up in the air uh you rolled better than me moment um now for The Clue Escape series it's the AHA of solving it so clue once again luckily enough we had a great brand to work with the thep so we could just look at those games under a magnifying glass and be like what are what of the best moments and so for that one it was very much of I I'm I've solved the mystery I'm smart Aha and so that's kind of what we needed to replicate in our escape and solve series and so you do do puzzles there's little ahas as you solve puzzles but there's a big final puzzle you have to solve which is the the murder or the mystery of the box and uh so that's something just to keep in mind and I once again like if I was writing the document it might not even be that involved I might just literally write like have AA moment like that's the we got to hit that or have like throw your hands in the air that's the peak experience you've defeated your friend um kind of thing so that's really cool I'm I've been working on a game called roboman Forever and it's a long game and it it just kind of plays out over the course of lots and lots and lots of sessions and so thinking through these moments but also thinking through you know I want I want them to happen at certain points in the story one to reward the players but to have those moments right where they're not just kind of grinding
it out and trying to get through it it's like where the game changes slightly not massively necessarily but you know you're opening up a new box or you get some new cars or new dice or new something and and the game has a moment where the player had to sit back and go huh okay the game the game has changed right and now it's new information but they can kind of grow into it because if it's one of the things if you put all these things on the player at the beginning to learn it in the rule book whatever like it's just overwhelming but to have these moments along the way where the game changes in some way Dominion is great at this right one one of the best things about Dominion is you have to figure out when to switch gears and stop buying cards that that do things and start buying cards that get you victory points because that's how you're going to win and when do you do that small world great example as well like when do you put that Civilization into Decline and get a new civilization like that's a big moment where the game changes shift yeah so it doesn't even have to necessarily be I guess what I'm saying is it could be narrative driven or it could be mechanically driven but like the moments you know like you're saying like where you stand up you're going to roll those dice that's a cool thing to to design for and think about and actually leads into the next pillar which is moment design so one tell me how those things are a little bit different and then tell me what you're thinking as far as like how do you design a moment so U moment design is actually there is a power of moments book I read it's a great book I'd recommend it I pull up actually who wrote it see here looks like chip and Heath it's a kind of a more you know it's not really game design Focus per se but I found it really useful because they actually broke down the science of
what you need to have a peak Moment Like a moment you would remember years from now what are the like elements what is the moment is kind of their way of saying like where are you playing the game is it a birthday party is it a friend's house uh is it a game night that you always go to um see if it's a like I guess they say like alert to key transition ition points this would be like birthdays or anything that's like a shift because they found that in like kind of in science like when you're kind of like when you're in shift of a change you you typically remember that a little more now I don't know if you can really do this all in a board game because usually you meet up with your friends you play board games there's nothing like too groundbreaking like you're not playing in an apocalypse you know like everything's falling apart or anything um but I think where it actually starts getting useful is the break the script um you've probably already kind of heard this but in this framework it's basically just just what are games in the same genre doing and what is their current DNA so like social deduction you know there's always the kind of like we have hidden roles we have uh accusations and distrust um and then how after you've like analyzed what the current script is how can you break it um so what's the Twist and that actually works really fun from a gaml perspective but more even fun from my like hook like let's say I don't know um you have it's werewolf but you play it underwater of course that game might not work but people might at least perk their ears up and be like oh okay I've never heard of that I'd try it it's it's werewolf but you spray each other with
with water guns you know that kind of thing that that also sounds like it's a game potentially It's A Game's hook right what's going to get people to lean in and go oh tell me more or if it's you know sitting on a shelf somewhere or sitting on Kickstarter that you have this sound bite basically that says it's werewolf but underwater like oh oh what how's that work and now people want to like click and they want to you know turn turn the box over and look at the back and read the copy that kind of thing so that makes sense as well from a product design as much as it does from a just game design space and then also too there's just like things that I find like raise the stakes is usually in most games uh it's like what's your objective what's going to heighten the tension um you know are you competing uh and then boost sensory peel is actually one of my favorites from the book is this book doesn't really talk about game design but it's like translating it to game development how does it work sensory appeal seems very much aligned with board games like the reason I play them is because it's like it feels cool these pieces are nice um just overall delightful to play this like beautiful work of art and so thinking of like what are your pieces like and how does how do you interact with the game and how does it feel is kind of a fun just question to ask yourself yeah also how instagrammable is it sure how many how many Tik toks can you get people definitely right I mean just is what it is right how how can you help yourself from the marketing standpoint right with the visual sensory appeals um if you think about party games they party games are so easy to put on Tik Tok because they're silly and goofy and people are
doing you know doing funny things right and that lends itself to a 60-second clip and so just thinking thinking through that because again we're not just designing games here we're designing products right so it's something else to to think it's all this stuff kind of coming together more than just hey I've got this passion project to design a 12h hour you know space epic like yeah but is that gonna be a product on the marketplace because you know if you don't care all good not saying you have to not saying you got to worry about it but it is something to these are things to think about if you do want to come to Market yeah I also um this is probably a readed inside tangent but I think very much about being a game designer myself uh there's nothing wrong with like you said space epic if you're designing that but if you decided to design a game um that's your thing and you want to run with that like that's awesome uh but I think for this this checklist is always like I want to be a better game designer and I want to design lots of different games so I do keep that in mind as far as just like I don't know one of my own personal goals like oh I want to be a better designer I don't uh so a lot of these questions I feel like are kind of so that you can put a lot of designs through it uh of course if you have your own you know big ass game it's like you can you don't really need to have pillars per se because you can set those along the way of your journey I wouldn't recommend it though for like selling like you said it might be tough to sell but I like one of these next one's players finding aha moments I think that's a cool thing either narratively when there's a a sudden change in the story right all of a sudden you find that Bob is is a traitor you know that's a cool moment betrayal in house on the hill is
excellent for this like when now we go into this second phase of the game and somebody has to leave the room and read a different rule book and they're going to come back and we're we're all now it's we're against them or are we are they against like we don't know these kind of aha moments narratively but then also mechanically when a game clicks right when you've been playing for a few rounds and you go oh that's how this thing works and the game now changes because I have a deeper insight into it I think that's that's really cool uh you have any moments where you've kind of like designed for those moments so we have um this is a project that's really kind of in development it's not finished and published but there's a kind of a deck builder we're working on and a moment we really wanted for aha is that um like like you said it's kind of like mechanically as you build your deck you are discovering what you could do for the next game you're like oh I built my deck wrong and or I built my deck this way this time but if I was to do it you know like oh that card if I added that in I think that kind of thing is really fun as well so not only narrative like emotional moments but like like you said game playay like oh man I want to play again because I actually want to build this differently or play a different strategy um so I think that's also really fun yeah I think it's so important as designers to make it somewhat easy for players to realize why they won or why they lost right if players get to the end of the game and they got decimated right they lost by 50 points that they go well it's because I made this decision I built my deck like this I tried this risky thing over here and it didn't work out but I can at least point to myself and go I'm the
reason versus you know I just had a bunch of bad die rolls and the the dice gods were against me tonight I mean we're probably gonna blame the dice Gods anyway but for players to be able to go here's why I won here's why I lost I think that's super super helpful especially for getting people to play again because if I have no idea I'm like I don't understand this this game I might think ah this game's just not for me I don't want to play it again versus oh I see what I should have changed about my strategy mid game next time we play I'm gonna get you because now I understand it like that's a just seems to be a better better game experience that add Insight in the aha moment is is once again something to keep in mind uh just why you design I don't know if you can always like start off and be like this is how I will design that moment but it's nice to just think about like oh what will keep players wanting to play it again or what what's going to be their like tripping over the fun that they find during play yeah I think it can also just be like you're saying an idea like I give you an example um when Eric Lang and Rob davio were working on death may die Eric Lang I heard him say this in an interview he said when we started the game my idea was wouldn't it be cool if you could shoot cthulu in the face with a shotgun that'd be cool that's a cool moment how do we design for that and he had no mechanisms he had no narrative there was no nothing other than I want to create this experience for the players where they feel like they can do that versus most cthulu games which is like you're slowly going to go insane and you're just going to kind of see what happens you know you can't really do a whole lot to fight these things but like what if you could you know so I think that's a cool experience to start
from and so even if you're coming at it from like very very basic out there in The Ether kind of an idea of okay I want to be able to do this cool thing I don't how how I'm going to do it or how it's going to work or how players are going to accomplish that dice cards I don't I don't know but I'm aiming at this I think it's at least a good place to start that's cool and it's also kind of a design hook for yourself in a weird way of like I've broke the script through it's cthulu but instead of you being scared you can shoot him in the face so it's kind of a fun like not only does it work as a cell point it actually works to inspire you to hopefully you know figure out what the mechanics are um the next one is called like ad Pride by the way it's just kind of this one's a little more I don't know if it really for you know translates really well to game design but it's mostly like why would people be invested in in their milestones and in games typically have like objectives so it kind of naturally fits like oh you want to win U or if you know if it's not win maybe in a party game like you have the pride of your team has selected your correct word you know like in taboo or something um so adding those like like like little moments of Pride that you feel when you play the game is kind of fun to think about um but typically I find that this section I usually do kind of skip quicker because it's like okay the game has an objective so your pride is around usually your winning and or competing or cooperating with your friends you can also do this mechanically um or or at least you definitely can with Legacy games so Risk Legacy comes to mind where every time a player wins they get to mark that on the board right and then the winner gets to to do something you get to add a sticker you get to make a
city different you get to change some numbers somewhere and so you kind of get that moment of like oh man I get to do this thing um but you can also do it mechanically in the game like I've seen some games where you know person in last place or person in first place they get this extra little thing that they get to do so you know that's not like oh look at me I'm great but like even in the moment in a very small way you can kind of get some little extra bonus or benefit for being in a certain position and so just kind of add add pride in there right um just different things I guess main things just different things to think about as far as creating these these moments that's kind of a fun one I thought like just naming a card um like you said Legacy like signing your name on something actually goes a long way of being like cool I have a little hit of like that's that's fun that's I'm I'm proud that's my card or that's my you know like said the sticker moving into the the next one design Inspirations this is one I like to do I like to list out the games that I'm thinking about this is really helpful later if I come back to it six months later I'm like what was what was that game about the thing where you did the other stuff like I can't ever remember but if I write it all down is a lot more helpful or if I saw a game review or a playthrough video or something like that I'll put the link you know that makes it everything easy to find but just go through and go here are the games that are inspiring this how can I do things similarly how can I do things differently so it stands out you know their Hook is this so my hook is going to be that but that's super super helpful so tell me you know you you've worked on a lot of games where the inspiration was literally in the name clue the escape game right A D and D Escape game um risk like you're
starting off with some pretty well-known Brands which is nice but also maybe more constraining than you know other opportunities but tell me about this as far as your design Inspirations how do you handle this particular sure so I I find that like let's say I'm working on a game it's not IP it's kind of just a game I'm thinking of it's a you know random I will I will think about what did I what I I I think a lot of nodes like I don't know why I think of them the circular dots that I have in my life that I've experienced you know like this little experience or this song I listen to and somehow in my brain they'll connect and then I'll be like oh that's a cool game idea so it's really just taking stock of like kind of reflecting back of like what did I have to make me want to make this game so for example let's say I'm making an alien game I I watched the movie Alien that's one node what other experiences did I have that's like oh I also saw this cool color palette online that was like very bright and maybe I want to make a bright alien game um of course this is all fictional I'm just making something up but it's more just like thinking back like oh I played this other game it made me feel I really liked how that mechanic worked or how uh the game kind of actually made me kind of feel different and so it's really just like I'll write out um kind of like what I've experienced and that just I don't know why just helps me kind of almost like get more awareness of why I'm choosing the things I'm choosing and also call upon those experiences for inspiration later let's say I get lost in the weeds I'm confused on what part of the game I should work on I can look back and these like oh yeah let's let me go watch the alien movie maybe that'll
help like kind of like pull on those uh like DNA of where it started yeah that makes sense it's also like for for a sports metaphor it's like watching film right if you if you have something you want to do or you want to get better at or you want to understand and well you just break down the film right okay they you know you find people doing it well and they go okay they they take their first step this far out they're lined up here they move this way okay how can I recreate that myself that way I can be really good at this technique or whatever it is as well same thing with game design right if you can break down a game mechanically narratively produly whatever marketing all those things and go okay here is the thing that I think is really cool why is it working how did this sell a million how did this make a million on Kickstarter like how in the world did they do this okay let's break it down okay well they had this email list they they had eight months leading up to the campaign like you start breaking down the steps and all of a sudden it gets a little more interesting first of all but a little easier to actually recreate it because you're breaking it down so I think this makes a lot of sense and like I said it's it's always nice to be able to go back later and remember oh yeah that that inspired me let me go look at that video again let me go watch that movie again and I'll probably get that same inspiration happening right like sometimes if I watch let's say make a theme part game I watched a cool like roller coaster documentary I'll link the like the documentary link there just in case you never know you're like you know what I'm feeling like I'm kind of lost in the weeds let me just watch this and like oh I kind of feel the like you know initial thoughts of like oh that's a cool video let me see if I can you know get inspired to put in my game um the other
thing I really like of under this list of these other questions is what experiences could you have to help you with this project and so that's almost like what are steps you could take if you feel like you want to kind of go further into research um so let's say with the roller coaster example I could go to a theme park let's say actually haven't gone to the theme park nearby like the Six Flags or whatever but maybe I could write that on there and if I ever feel like you know up for it I want to get inspired it's kind of just a nice little checklist of like play a theme park video game um you know look at some look at some pictures or learn about the mechanics of how they build rides um but I really like that one I use that one a lot as far as like trying to think through think ahead uh what could I do to really help me research this this style kind of project yeah that makes sense it reminds me my conversation I had a while back with Martin Wallace and whenever he's working on a game he just immerses himself in everything he can find books documentaries movies everything one to make sure he has a good handle on kind of like what he's doing so in your example like the roller coaster game so he'd go out and read every roller coaster book he could find he'd look at all the diagrams and the blueprints and all the engineering and all that kind of stuff one to to say okay here is like the truth right here is an actual factual based game about roller coaster it's still a game we're going to have some abstractions and some fun things but here's as close as I can get it but also when you immerse yourself you start finding some really interesting ways to bring that theme to life and these little like minutia things you know things that a lot of people maybe don't even notice or they don't even recognize but all of a sudden you start talking to an expert and or especially someone who
like gets really excited about the thing like oh let me tell you about all these tiny little details you've never noticed like all of a sudden you can make your game more interesting more real more fun so I think that's it's a really good thing just to to think about if you have an idea for a game go as deep as you can into that topic because you're going to find these little nuggets of wisdom nuggets of gold that you can kind of bring to life in your game experience totally agree I think it's uh really fun to get I think it is interesting how someone who gets excited about thing is is interesting even if I'm like I I didn't know I love roller coaster design until we were standing in line at a theme park with a friend and she was like I read all these these did you know that they use these rivets and these the way they build it and I was like H I'm now it that sounds awesome I kind of want to go read that it's like you Catch the Fire of their excitement and so I feel like kind of doing that for yourself helps it's just like oh let me go get you know kind of catch that fire um and then use that and try to convert it into my game design to get all kind of maybe hopefully there's like a through line and then the end of the day when people play it they feel the same feeling you kind of did yeah absolutely there's a book by Donald Miller came out years ago called Blue like jazz and part of that book is this this like realization of and he talks about jazz he's like I didn't like jazz until I heard someone who loved it and was good at it playing it and that changed it for me and I was like oh man C really how do you apply that in other parts of your life and then how can we kind of be conduits for other people right um to help them in in life in general right but especially in our topic here is like bringing them into the gaming space how do you do that as a designer just just
things to think about those moments at the table where players are going to interact and like you want it to feel good you so how do we do that effectively but um yeah just things again these are all just things to been thinking about you don't have to like sit down and write a doctor level thesis on like all these things for your game but just things to be aware of things to be thinking about as you as you design and so right let's go to the next one design Vision which I I would probably put this one first in in my head right as far as like who are the players where are they what are they doing like all these kinds of things so tell me the stuff you typically write down with your design vision is it is something you start off with as well or tell me about it I do typically start with someone in mind uh like I said there's like different ways that think about it like an avatar or a person or kind of a market whatever you call it I like to think of a very specific person um so for example uh this is actually my first game is cave game it turned into Galaxy gold mine I actually thought of my mom a lot I was like could my mother play this would she enjoy this because that was kind of the target audience I wanted to have like a family game um and so it was funny because I just kind kind of thought of her as like the target to to think on but actually to take a step back the design VIs visualiz uh thing is I typically will actually kind of close my eyes and just try to think build the game out in my head and like what are the people around the table look like who are they uh what kind of moments what are the looks on their faces is it a very thinky war game and they're kind of smiling with the smirk of like okay I'm about to do this
cool move but it's gonna take four turns or is it a very fast frantic party game where everyone's yelling and it's just like around a couch um I find it just useful just to kind of see it's almost like you're you're checking in with yourself like how much Clarity do I have around this vision of a game um is it very clear is there things that are fuzzy um I just find it like a fun useful thing but I I think like to your point I I typically do start here um in one way or another this is more just like the stop on my like list of like take a second and actually just close your eyes and try to do this little process as silly as it probably feels it works PR well I think yeah again it gets back into the whole like begin with the end in mind and if you really think through who is this game for you know if I'm designing a game for eight-year-olds it's going to be a 10-minute game 15minute game like that's if that's the K the the group of people I'm envisioning in my mind for this game it's going to change a whole lot about the design space right and so if you can kind of really Envision who the game's for the moments they're going to have like that's going to determine a whole lot of other stuff whether it's the player count the play time how deep and complicated the mechanisms can be the price point right so if I'm thinking okay this this is going to be a 20-minute family game it it can't cost $100 right and so now my component you know filter is is going to be different then if I'm designing some kind of big epic Space Opera that's going to take two and a half hours to play well okay that could be hundred bucks and have a bunch of really cool Miniatures and this big board and all these different cards so anyway a lot of this stuff just helps you again back with that decision filter
and the earlier you can get some of these things figured out the quicker I think you can get to the actual game that you're trying to to create right and also you I have a lot of repeating questions during this whole document and sometime sometimes it's just useful to just kind of keep checking in with myself like you're making a game for someone uh I think of myself like kind of a you know you design experiences and you're giving it to somebody who is that somebody you're trying to give it to because like I said that'll determine your design but it also keeps you keeps me honest because sometimes you know I like to theorize like this mechanic's neat let me just make a game around it but I don't actually have a like what am I doing I'm just mostly you know playing around with mechanics um so it's nice to just kind of keep reiterating like what are you who is this for who are you going to give this to and who is it who will enjoy this the best I I find that really nice to just keep checking in be clear more than clever so I have to always tell myself you know it's like oh this is so cool yeah but it's going to take two and a half pages in the rule book to to describe is it worth it you know are you is it worth that much real estate is it worth that much cognitive load for me as a designer just to feel clever and say hey look how cool look how good of a designer I am you know is just cutting that and actually the game doesn't suffer if anything the game got better because I cut that part right which can hurt it can hurt your ego a little bit but to your point it's like if you create whenever you create this customer Avatar right you've got Bob and Bob is this kind of a gamer and he likes this amount of time and you know has this much time to play a game whatever it is right don't forget about Bob don't let your cleverness don't let your
excitement for this whatever new thing you're gonna add in there don't forget about Bob though because Bob's your target audience now if you need to to now be targeting at Steve because the game has changed and it went from a 30 minute you know filler game to like a two-hour you know game night okay that's fine but be very intentional in going from Bob to Steve and so that's that's just normal business kind of stuff and something Bob I'm gonna change that that section to keep Bob in mind I like keep Bob in mind don't forget about Bob don't forget about Bob because Bob's buying your game you know it's like don't forget about the person that you're aiming this whole thing hopefully it moves Bob when he plays your game he he's like this was made for me it's what you want it's better I I think I've said this several times recently on the podcast but it's better to be someone's favorite game and also you know people's the game they don't never want to see again versus everybody's me you know better to be a festar and a one star than a whole bunch of Threes because there's there's actually no money in the middle there's money in you know when you're someone's favorite so how do you how do you design a game that's going to be Bob's favorite now are you always going to get there no right it's it's kind of like catching lightning in a bottle but if at least if you're aiming at it right and you're leaning into it and thinking the difference between going okay this is good it you know it's it's going to be fine people in general are going to think this is good versus people are going to love this and then some people are gonna hate it I think that's a better place to design right especially from the the marketing side yeah I think it's it's the most fulfilling when you hear someone who's like man I had the moment you know you
watch play test and you're like they're having the moment I'm intending them to have that's kind of a magical moment but of course that moment you're designing is not for everyone so it's nice to like you said like I don't think you can you know you can't force everyone to be moved by an alien movie I personally was I was like oh this is a cool movie but you know it's like try to design the moment the best you can and know who it's for But ultimately you're not gonna hit everyone's not gonna be moved by your your specific design and you don't want them to be you know I I think about like my favorite books over there on the Shelf my favorite games of all time all of those have one star reviews on Amazon on they all have ones on Board Game Geek you know where people are like oh this is not for me I hated it it's like oh but I loved it it was like one of the best experience I ever had and so I think I think that's just a better place to to design for all right so design motivations all right tell me about this is this more personal right is this kind of more deeper existential as far as your own like designer motivations yes so it in a nutshell it's kind of an ego check um like you said you being clever versus creating something it's mostly just like what started why do you want to design this is it because you want to experiment with a mechanic and try to be a better designer by getting your chops you know with this like thing is it because you need to make money is it like it's mostly just trying to be honest with yourself and be like what am I trying to do by designing this game there's no wrong or right answer it's just checking in with yourself um and so it's nice to know if you're just experimenting like oh this game I just want to play around with this like could
I add this really complicated mechanic and will it work um because maybe it's not meant to be a product you're trying to sell maybe it's just supposed to be an exercise um so it's just a nice check- in see what's going on um once again I have who who is this for again I have it probably in every section I don't know why I keep copying and pasting that one but um because you don't want to forget Bob right right don't forget Bob um I think my favorite is why does it need to be a physical game um coming from a little bit of the video game industry there's lots of media you could do to create an experience like we did escape room design and video games and there's apps and there's all these things um something I keep in mind is like the medium of board game design is kind of magical and why does it need to be people in a room physical pieces um and maybe you can't always answer that but it's a nice way to start thinking okay so I have a game has I'm thinking it might have an app but could I delete the app and make it more social interaction would that make it more reason to be a physical game uh another question I like to ask is like why can't this just be an app like do the game I make just a better version of an app because you know how there's many complicated games out there that might be better off for just being like instead of having a bajillion pieces I rather just be digital so I could just you know play Smooth um it usually always goes around why are people face to face though I think that's more important to me like what what can the game how can the people playing the game Interac with one another in a meaningful way um so that's kind of a nice section
of this it might not even belong in design motivations but I like that question a lot one I might add to it if you know making my own chart is why does this game need to exist at all right how is it different enough from every other game on the market right how is it going to create a new experience how is it like why why should this be a thing that I'm going to spend a ridiculous amount of time on that I'm going to put out into the world for people to tear it apart right so like you gota think through so why should this exist if I'm just creating another generic Euro game that I'm just finding another random City you know in some random country and like oh here's Brussels the game it's like yeah but why do I have something new to say you know what I mean or am I just rehashing a bunch of other stuff not that there's anything wrong with like taking mechanisms and ideas from other games but like what's the hook what's the spin like how is this different you know and so I think that's that's one thing I'm always thinking about because I don't want to just put out something where people are like oh this is like this other game except not as good yeah because there's lots of lots of games out there and I always think about like lots of products that exist in the world does it need to take up space or cut down some trees you know it's kind of like at what point does it need to exist so I like that I have that I think a marketing section that's at the very bottom because I don't want to do marketing up front because it kind of feels like it I personally think it's like the you know that's more of like the actual nuts and bolts of how do you sell it um so after you notice I start very nebulous and then hopefully by the
end of this document it becomes more more like you know player count time limit that kind of thing I like this other question you have in there what excites you about the project I think that's always something to remember it's like what made you want to design this in the first place right what seed of an idea was planted that you're like o that could be a game and you could do this and you could do that and that'd be kind of fun you could intersect this and and this other thing and like what was that because sometimes either you haven't designed you haven't worked on it for a while so it's nice to come back and go oh yeah that was so cool but also I think it's nice when you're in the grind of the 157th play test and you're just like I am done with this game to have that written down as a reminder of why you're here right um just to because it's what's the old thing talking about like marriage it's like marriage isn't a onetime event marriage is something you choose every day you have to choose to love your spouse daily it's not one one time um it's it's it's ongoing thing I think same thing with game design and designing it's like it's an ongoing thing where you have to look back and go why am I doing this because sometimes it's hard and you get 47 rejections for this game you know is good you know it's fun but other companies aren't quite seeing it yet and so just as a as a reminder to yourself to have something written down you can go back and look at and go that's right that's why I'm doing this either for the game specifically or just as a designer in general I think some almost like a mission statement you put above your your computer or something like that right yeah but but something more specific though like that
really dives into the heart of like the core of why you're doing this you know to always come back to on those days when you you know you've gotten your 50th rejection letter in a row or a play test just went off the rails and you're like wow that was a dumpster fire but just have something written down you can look at and go that's right that's who I am that's why I'm doing this let's get up let's keep going I think it's just super helpful I think that yours is very true and it's very motivating to see what excites you I also will note on a darker side um if you're this is earlier in the project when you're filling this out if you just sit there and you can't think of a reason it might be a good indicator of like well maybe I should just work on something else or you know you know not give it as much time as I would maybe other projects I'm more excited about um because as you many designers do you might have a lot of different ideas and you're trying to Noodle on a lot of them um and so this is also a nice stop of like am I excited am I like truly excited about this project do I want to invest time and energy because you could be doing so many other design projects it's kind of like which one you know pulls you the most and so it's hard to fill out that's also a great indicator yeah that's a really good point and also what you fill out is it sustainable for the amount of time it's going to take to actually get this to to bring this whole project to life right if you write down money right you see an opportunity in the market we like hey this is an idea that can make a lot of money hey cool is that enough for you though like a lot of people money alone is not enough to sustain you through 200 play tests like he's like oh unless it's a lot of money which let me know your secret if that's the case if you're designing games for a lot of
money like we're well everyone gets into game design for money we all know that is's a huge a huge amount of money you can make uh right no so many of us are also teachers because of all the lucrative teaching opportunities out there I have noticed that Trend teacher and designer random fun fact my mother was a teacher my sister's a teacher my dad's a teacher I'm not a teacher but I'm a game designer but it's basically the same thing if I wasn't designing games I'd probably be a teacher it's funny man like I was a teacher for several years you know while designing games and I don't know I think the schedule lends itself to that um you have instant access to play testers like I was teaching high school kids and so like they they helped me play a lot of my games um you know other teachers on campus were great for trying out games and bouncing around ideas I don't know I think it's just a a profession that kind of lends itself to being able to design games and also you're used to having to write things down you're used to having to explain things to people right and so like a rules teach or writing a rule book definitely overlap I think uh like you're presenting experience that hopefully gets them to learn something but but game design it could be to you know different experience or I think also too uh fun teachers sometimes do game design without knowing it to introduce a lesson plan kind of thing so yeah I mean if finding ways to gamify what you're teaching right to get kids to to learn whether they want to or not right trick them you trick them into learning because they're having fun they're like oh what are we doing we're having fun guys as you learn algebra or whatever it is it's just all kind of winds in there together let's uh let's move on to the next one emotional
details now what in the world do you mean by emotional details so a lot of people say when you design a game like what's the core mechan you go on board your board game geek and it's like what's the core you know big mechanics in this game dice you know dice rolling worker placement um but I noticed when designing what's your core emotion um you don't have to pick just one but it's like how do the players feel and I guess for me this is really useful to list out early once again just to keep Bob in mind as you said um what do you want to make him feel because games it's fascinating to me that you can use cardboard and make people have emotions for this cardboard you've put together um so is it supposed to be tension is it supposed to be like a race of like oh I gotta hurry up is it a push your luck emotion of like oh I hope I don't uh break and typically I will admit in this section I typically write out blurbs like ah I'll type out ah or or wow that was clever I'll just type out kind of like noodlings of kind of undertones of emotion through like little quotes things like that or I might just type out scared like I want them to be scared or tension or or I want them to be cozy I know that's a big thing with like games like wingspan things like that's like I feel comfortable and kind of cozy why we just relax play this game um so yeah it's just nice to have a core emotion in mind I don't kind of like with mechanics I don't know if every game needs so many layers of all these different conflicting emotions it might just be nice just to have a game that makes you feel connected um or have a game that makes you feel tense or you know kind of just nice to have a just
one to go for as game designers and writers and anyone dealing with these kinds of mediums we're we're handling magic in a lot of ways right Stephen King talks about this a good bit he he has an excellent book about writing but he talks about the magic of being able to write down a sentence and then that sentence goes out into the world somewhere else and someone else who he's never met before reads that sentence that he wrote and then they have a picture in their mind of what it is now is that picture in their mind exactly the picture in Stephen King's mind probably not picture in his mind probably a lot scarier but uh this idea that we're able to transport an idea transport a moment transport a story from where I am here in middle of nowhere Alabama that I could do that you know to someone in middle of nowhere Europe or Australia or Africa or wherever that's magic like that's a miracle that our brains have the ability to do these things right and so to kind of lean into that and like how am I going to provide these really cool experiences these really cool moments in this magical kind of way to create memories that people have that that I've never met right I'm never going to see these people they're never going to be able to tell me about it but I'm helping to make memories in their own lives and their with their family and friends and because that's another thing to think about it's like people talk they don't they don't talk mechanically typically right if if I'm playing a game and I'm remembering what happened I don't say oh Leo hey man remember remember that time I rolled two dice and you rolled four dice and I moved some green and you move some blue cubes wasn't that cool like no
it's hey remember that time where my Army was outnumbered two to one and then we found a way to overcome and and you were trying to take over my country but I didn't do it I pushed you out and I ended up taking over your country like that's how we talk we talk as as like real terms right and to think through how can you create those moments for people to have those memories and to share those like those stories in interesting ways I don't it's just fun to like think about that and then turn it into reality that's exactly one of the I think it's the third question now it's like what Memories will players share about your game because I do the same thing it's like oh man we we almost we we almost got them this time if it's a co-op game or oh we get so close every time and I want to play again but we're gonna lose again or it's kind of like I said like saying it out loud that's why I kind of type typically write it stream of Consciousness in the section because people don't talk like I felt scared playing that game like they would they might say like oh I remember that time it was kind of creepy and like we almost you know like I I couldn't know if you were the killer or not I didn't know and then there's this kind of big moment so once again a little nebulous but I find it really useful just to try to tag a key moment and I actually even have a print out of like a feelings list you know there's like that like emotion wheel you can go online and type in Emotion wheel sometimes if you want to get inspired to just design a game emotion first that can be fun just pick a let's see is there a good game that can make someone feel grateful I don't know it's an interesting prompt um so it's kind of fun to start there sometimes yeah for sure um reminded of the original pic pic Legacy pmic Legacy season one by Matt Le and Rob davio and
to hear them talk about it because there's this I don't remember which month of the year because the idea is that you play through 12 months January through December 12 sessions of the game is kind of the idea and one of the months there's a big twist and I can't remember which month I'm just going to say September right but there are people that will walk up to Matt or Rob and just like look at them and go September freaking September it's just like it's this realization and and they know what happened in this experience in this memory that was created around a table and they only have to use one word to do it like that's that's such a cool thing and you can design for that right even if you're designing mechanical abstract games you have those moments where people look at look at you and go huh that that thing that you did cause some dissent in my house between me and my spouse you know like whatever it is that's what I love about the the risk um strike game is like man we still this game makes us fight just as much as the other risk does I'm like cool that's that's what we're going for for yeah exactly that same experience but in a in streamlined I like the way you said an espresso shot of risk I think that's a good way to say it all right moving to the next one we got player types and now this seems to be the U the player types from Magic of the Gathering is that right yep and so this is a perfect example of how I will as I learn things I'll just like hey that's useful let me keep that in mind and I'll copy and paste it so this is from Mark rosewater it's just the like Timmy Jimmy Spike uh framework which is like think of these archetype players and how they'll deal with your game um and so we don't have to go deep on that but it's a really cool resource and I found it useful so I just put it in my
pillars of design uh just to see just be like oh yeah in my brain keep in mind people want to be you know they want to have an experience or maybe they want to express themselves or maybe they want to compete um how does your game work in that framework and so it's just kind of a quick pulse check of keep these three player types in mind and think how that changes your design decisions right also how can you make make sure you're play testing with these people in mind because if if you don't have one of these types in your group then you got to do it superficially because they're these people exist right and so there's going to be a certain percentage of people that play your game that don't care about winning that only want to do stuff that's cool okay well how do you design with that in mind there's some people that that don't care about anything cool they're just trying to minmax everything to get the most victory points to win the game okay well let's think about the game from their perspective Rob davio recently in a podcast I did with him he talked about how he assigns color like if you know you get the red player and the blue player player the purple whatever he will assign a player type to that color as he's play testing especially if he's by himself you know so he's going to be the red player for this round okay well the red player you know wants to do cool Combos and wants to like really push the game limits right see what happens not so much worried about winning okay blue over here men Max and everything gonna try to win purple over here doesn't want to win uh she just wants you to lose so she's going to do everything to kind of troll you and mess with you and like put you know push you in different directions um but assigning color that makes it easier to kind of keep in in your head as a designer like what you're doing and just remember right but even even if you go to a play test night you can say hey uh
okay can you help me out by playing the game this way right especially if you don't have those certain types that you're really trying to stress test the game for um I think that's a cool way cool way to do it and just again keeping these kinds of people in mind I will give a quick shout out to a thanks of the Austin board game Design Group they have lots of different variety of people and so I'm lucky enough to have an outlet that we have a couple men maxers we have a couple people who want to like I'm personally the kind of person who just I just want to play and experience it of course if you can't tell by this talk I I just want to feel the game and try to experiment and then of course we have our you know men maxers and so it's really nice to have those in mind um but once again maybe your game you intentionally don't mind if it's not that you know you can't express yourself maybe it doesn't need that many layers um but yeah there a fun little pit stop on the way on this list of like just keep those guys in mind see how it looks through those lenses also from a bigger perspective as far as this document is concerned and anyone wanting to make a document like this to realize it's a living document you're going to change it it's going to e and flow you're going to add to it you're going to take away depending on where you're at and your design level and skills and things that you're learning and things like that you know books that you read podcasts you listen to you're like oh that's cool let me add this question in there that's the point is right to continue this document to help you become a better designer making better games definitely has gotten uh a little bloated over the years but I mean it's useful information I don't want delete But ultimately it started off I think with like three sections and now it's like 12 so yeah but also not feeling like you have to
answer every single question like it's just it's something to help you it's a tool in your toolbox right not something that you have to have as a crutch but something that you can you know help you along in your your process all right the next one story details right so some of the things we've talked about a little bit before so tell me tell me why these things are here and how they're maybe a little bit different from some of the other sections sure so before it was all about like what's the moments you want to create the you know who you're going for this is now actually getting to the nitty-gritty of like what is the narrative Arc of your game play um like what are the characters in your game who are the players playing as or who what why kind of things so it's like um using the let's say the roller coaster game for example you just defining like your you as a player will be taking control of a company uh person building roller coasters who are you you know and then how is your narrative art going to change throughout the game and so it's kind of just thinking very much like a movie script the whole like either hero's journey or just like how does it end narratively does it end with the the park is built and you're satisfied because the park is finished and you as the designer have the most points um so it's just kind of now getting into like going from high concept to like okay the game actually has beat I I like to think in act three acts like act one set up figuring out your game making a strategy act two you know we're in the middle of the game how is it tense and what is it why do you kind of have that momentum and then act three is like ah it's close but how did I win uh how does the story resolve itself um and not every game has
to be this narrative epic uh even like simple games I feel like have a a pretty like nice narrative like the whole risk strike example um you you start building your continents you decide the sets you want to collect you have a couple battles it escalates by one player becoming kind of more in control everyone kind of tries to team up to take them down there's this like last minut of like do they rush to take it and win or is it like power is quickly swapped and distributed um no I wouldn't say a great movie but has the Beats I think of progression yeah it can also help from a design standpoint of thinking okay in act two I want these kinds of things to happen right so does that mean new things become available maybe new you know piles of tokens or piles of cars whatever now those are open and and players can start leaning into that if you think about games that kind of you set up a a deck where you have level one level two level three enemies or something like that you again you're thinking through the the ACT structure and how the game's going to play out over a certain amount of time one could be mechanical because you don't want a level one player fighting a level 10 monster that's just going to destroy them right that's not fun so you want the players to level up as the Monsters level up so anyway there's lots of reasons you can think about that both mechanically and just narratively but um yeah it makes a lot of sense to be thinking about those things because the players are going to experience it in those those ways the two quick takeaways I find the most two useful questions in this section is who are you that's a nice one and then also how are you how do you change because every good story has character development or change you like oh I start off as the grumpy old man by the end of the movie I you know
I'm in love with this dog I found uh so I think of that like it doesn't have to be exactly always that but like how will the players have their their their story how will they change um so it's something I keep in mind all right the next one a little more self-explanatory mechanical details okay we're talking player count we're talking difficulty uh the game game length the specific mechanisms in there so I mean that that's kind of stuff people would expect from a document like this but anything you want to add or really highlight as far as the mechanics um no kind of like many of these other podcasts there's lots of great advice on like you know how many how many players you want it's really useful to have up front kind of your nuts and bolts the one I do like on here is H difficulty to learn the rules I think of BGG a lot of like the weight like oh how what is the like weight of this game and and mostly not from the whole game I find that a little hard to visualize how the whole game is going to be complex or not but just like learning the rules how's that on- ramping going to be is it do you want it fast do you want it like do you don't mind it being a little longer because the game is worth that um I find that probably one of the most slightly different questions in here but everything else is pretty standard um core mechanics that you want you know difficulty to learn the rules gameplay length that kind of thing yeah definitely the next one though is something I think more designers need to be aware of as far as gameplay details and one a couple really stand out are how much luck versus skill is in the game because that is a lever you really have to pay attention to as a designer how long is this game if it's a two-hour game you you got to limit how much luck is in the game right because if I have a
bunch of bad die rolls that destroy me early and there's no way for me to catch up because the dice right not because of any decisions I made and now I've just got to sit there for the last 45 minutes and kind of play out this thing and I already know how it's going to end that's not super fun right so thinking through that um also what were what are players going to do on excuse me why will other players care when it's not their turn I think that's another thing to think about what's the downtime like because a lot of times we we're so excited and you give players these cool combos they can do all these things on their turn yeah then their turn takes 15 minutes and so everybody else at the table is like gotten up they're making a sandwich they're checking the the weather like okay that doesn't create a good experience so some things to think about what else really stands out to you in the in this section U of course there's the classic what choices will the players make um but I I I agree I think the luck and skill one are fun just because you know uh we we typically work with mass market and mass Market likes a little more luck we found um of course gamer hobbyists like a little more you know they control the game so I'm just thinking of that lever and how that works um what interactions will the players have is probably one of my favorites because once again one of my missions is like if I'm designing a board game I want people to be there face to face I think interaction is a must for me I think it's like that's the reason I like playing board games is I get to look at my friend and be like either hey we did it good job high five or I'm totally winning uh you're not going catch up either way there's that moment of connection um so interactions through the game play is important to to think of um just like will the players have light interaction will they maybe even this is not a mechanic but will
they even just like cozy talk to each other why their turns are not going like you know it's okay for games not always to have this take that or as long as you just keep that in mind it's a nice you know once again just something nice to jog your memory of like interaction is important uh can you design for it or is it just a thing that's going to happen happen that you can't control definitely and also just to help you be intentional right if this is the game you're trying to design well let's write that down and then be intentional about how we're going to make that happen makes a lot of sense all right next couple ones really get more into the business side of things we got visual details and then we'll get into marketing details so tell me your your thought process as a designer you're not a publisher right you're reaching out to other companies you know you have you and your Design Studio two your friends that you're kind of making games and then pitching to some pretty good companies right uh but you're not doing it yourself so tell me about why why do you have these more business side of things in this document versus just letting you know letting those companies figure it out themselves so um I mean yeah we like to pitch to Publishers because we like to you know we started off we're like oh we just want to be game designers and so we're going to pitch let the publisher do most of the business but I mean we've we found that you know if you can speak the language of a publisher and you already thought through a couple things goes a long way um as far as I think them just being responsive to you of like oh they know what they're talking about they've they've thought of us for example with like you know the clue series we did we did a lot of research on clue we thought as well as they did as far as like how would it Market will escape rooms be
palatable to your average you know Bob will Bob want to play our escape room what does he think an escape room is um that kind of stuff is just useful for us to not only help connect with the publisher and do a little bit of that leg work but also design with intention once again um help filter your decisions um so good example is we we thought early the escape room game um is it is it going to be a card based system like kind of like exit or something like that where you just have to you know there's these games that like come and there's like everything is available to you you open the packet there's these documents and you have to solve it but that has a pretty high like you have to take everything read it all so can you Market it to like you know average Bob we need to make it like uh you know like a board game because he knows what a board game is like a move to this spot that would connect more and so anyway just thinking with the publisher kind of alongside them has been really useful for us right as far as visual details what kind of artwork is necessary how many assets are you going to need you know how many Miniatures if you need Miniatures can you use wooden you know pawns instead do you really need a plastic mini like is that really vital to the game experience does it make it more of a toy like all those different things to think about because that's EX what the publisher is going to be thinking about maybe like right after thinking about the idea they're like wait how much is it going to cost to manufacture right so like if you're going to sell it that you have to think ahead with them because otherwise you've you've done all this work and then you realize oh yeah I sent that
thing off it cost me a lot of money to send to the publisher in time and I only got really one shot to show them and I forgot that all these Pieces cost so much money like and they kind of are turned off to that so the the more the basically the less load you can take off the publisher the more likely hopefully they'll hear you out and maybe move on with your product or your concept yeah that makes sense and then going into the marketing side you know again to design with intention to design thinking about how we're going to Market it what what's the hook going to be what's going to draw players in what's going to look good on Instagram all those things that just makes everything makes everything easier to design because then you can get focused right but also trying to think through why right especially if you're going to pitch this either way right either you're pitching to Publishers and then they're going to pitch it to consumers or you're a publisher going to pitch it to Consumers either way you're pitching to Consumers it's just a matter of how how far removed are you right and see thinking through why should they care right this is an investment it's investment of time and money and what's the return on that investment going to be right that's really what marketing is it's it's letting people know that however much money and time they put into this product that they're going to get a return out of it that's going to be worth it it's going to be more valuable than whatever you put in right it's it's simple Roi in a lot of ways that's what marketing that's what you're trying to do that's what a Kickstarter campaign page is right the people that go there they're going to back your game 99.999% of those people have never played it unless they were in your little group of
play testers which you should be giving those people free games anyway so they shouldn't be back in your campaign unless it's for a dollar right but you know mo for the most part people are seeing a thing that you're trying to convince them is going to be worth whatever the cost is same thing pitching to a publisher right you're saying here's idea here's the game here's how it plays it is a worthy investment that you were going to get a return on and then we want x% of that return so thinking that and it's Bare Bones right so when you have those things written down right the price point the hook the the the demographic of people that would be interested in this game how much money that demographic of people have right so if you're this is why designing kids games can be smart because you're designing games not for kids but for parents to buy right and uncles and grandparents right thinking through that right it's not the kid that's going to see it on the Shelf necessarily it's grandom who's walking through the store looking for a birthday gift and she's like oh that looks interesting yeah I think little suie would love this so thinking through that so anyway that's that's kind of mind my my mind goes with the marketing things what are some of the other things you're thinking about you got a lot of this is one of the bigger sections you got a lot of stuff going on on this one so tell me some of the highlights so I think just a real quick overview I think marketing also if you can fill this out it also helps you with your pitch to The Publisher you basically have a blueprint for how you want to pitch it it's a it's a this game but there's a hook but also it's it's going to be this much you know to cost and I imagine it's for this target audience and I think they really like that I mean just makes it easier um to pitch helps you out kind of keep focused
Al Executives aren't necessarily creatives right right like they're not they're not a game designer they're just like I mean a lot of Publishers are but as you said it's like you're you need to speak the language of marketing so that the marketing team team can get on board otherwise I mean I've been guilty of this where I've started a game pitch I'm like oh but the the mechanics are so cool and it's just like you know kind of goes over their heads and you're like well it just helps kind of speak the lingo and put on different glasses to look at the game from different perspectives um I would say there's a lot here but I think the two I really like is pre hook which we've you've probably talked a lot but it's always good to reiterate like what's the wow factor when you pitch your game what is the like oh I'm interested and usually it's I found the formula is mostly something familiar and something unfamiliar it's like oh you like uh you like clue have you ever thought of a clue escape room um and so it's like you know I know what this is and what's that so that's the pre hook my favorite that I've re recently learned I actually have to admit is the post hook um what is after playing the game people are gonna be like wow I want to play that again or oh hey um Gabe you got to play this game because there's either a mechanic or like man it had like you if felt like so crazy to play and they had this fun progression and so just those two are nice um to try to think of yeah that makes a lot of sense I like that posto idea though right what are the story and we talked about story already but like what are the stories people are going to tell and then are how how are you going to get people to tell their friends about it right because one it's one
thing to see a Facebook ad from a company that says hey buy this game that's one thing it's a whole another thing to see your friend who you trust post about a game and say this was a great experience check out the pictures check out the ti whatever like which one of those do you trust more you know what I mean and so how can you get people talking about your game in a way that's positive and gets other people to go oh that sounds interesting let me get a copy of that too or hey make sure you bring that game to game night and let's let's check it out I want I want to see it myself how can you design with that in mind and how can you pitch with that in mind either pitching to Publishers or pitching to you know consumers on Kickstarter wherever just thinking through right all this plays into it and a lot of times honestly when you see those games online that have a million dollar right they've made a million bucks on crowdfunding and you're like how in the world it's because they've gotten this right they' figured it out it's not because the game is amazing nobody's played it it's on crowdfunding it doesn't technically really exist yet right so what it means is they've done an excellent job at the marketing side of things as far as like getting people to look at the value look at the cost look at the investment all these things and for them to look at that entire equation and go this is something I need to have okay how do they do that what does that look like and then start breaking that down super helpful so there's a lot going on but I think the other one that's useful is what's the two sentence pitch um you don't always have to fill that out but if you filled out a lot of these other ones you could probably you know come up with one or oppositely if you're just starting on a game and you're like you know what I'm gonna start with the two cence pitch first like you said Eric Lang did the
it's cthulu but you can shoot him in the face that might be his pitch and that also might be the inverted start with marketing then design backwards um but yeah it's just fun to think about all these and once again I usually don't fill them all out but it's nice to think of no I think that's one especially maybe not right off the bat but definitely like Midway through the design process you need to be able to fill that one out I think it's I think it's Einstein who said if you can't explain something simply then you don't understand it right so if you can't boil your boiler your game down into two sentences and it really explain what the game is then you maybe don't quite understand the game you're making yet not that you won't eventually but but you need to be able to it's that elevator pitch thing right where you can kind of concisely put the game into a handful of words and get people to go oh that sounds interesting tell me more or I want to play that right and so I think that's that's super important right also too something I've learned from the Prototype group here is um actually testing your pitch out like you test your game you test your game all the time so why not go around and tell your friends your two sentence pitch just see their face do they go oh that's kind of cool or did they go sweet like you know it's kind of a it's a subtle thing but it's easy to say two sentences to somebody just see if they resonate with it it's like you can play test your pitch um it also kind of you know play testes your your game hook and you can always kind of change that as you go yeah absolutely all right coming into the last one here design Outlets so
what do you mean so this is we were talking about this earlier before but it was just like the outlets I found really dictate what I design uh so for example we have our foot in the door with Hasbro and that's great and I love that relationship and so I want to keep pitching to them but they're definitely an outlet that I have in mind when I design like it's Mass Market they're looking for certain types of games for a certain type of audience and so it's nice to just think of what is your design Outlets like I have a play test group that we can play usually for about an hour so does that is that dictating my kind of like this game needs to be about an hour um where can you get feedback I think it's for myself it's really crucial to have the energy kind of like here's a game I share it I get feedback um as you always say like keep play testing is very crucial so it's more just taking stock of what are your where are you play testing who are you playing with how is that going to kind of how can you set that up for this project um so I'm making an I'm making an alien game it's a space epic do I have friends that like aliens and want to play for two hours if not could I set this up um what kind of feedback can I get from them what do I need it's kind of just a checklist of what you need to do next steps to have an outlet for your game or your project and also hopefully helps you start thinking outside the box of you know I've got my normal play test group that come you know we come together on Tuesday nights at 7 pm okay but this game man this game is kind of like magic it's got some interesting magic elements to it what what nights does my friendly local game store run
their magic tournaments okay maybe I could go there like an hour early hang out with some of the people that are like the ogs that love magic and like maybe get their thoughts on this oh that's interesting or what are some of the Facebook communities that you know play these kinds of games maybe I could get in with some of those and and see if some of those folks would want to hop on T toop simulator and play test game like you start thinking outside your normal you know I'm trying to think the the stuff you normally do right and and opening up to new ideas and then all of a sudden the game gets better because you're pushing the limits of your play testing in your design space yeah you also get to meet new people and get New Perspectives is always refreshing and inspiring when you get new new play testers um but Al yeah I guess what I was trying to say is both either go find new play testers or recognize that you like you said you you had only kind of like yourself so you made a solo game and just recognizing that that's your kind of Outlet um is really useful because it helps you once again just make a choice should I make a five hour epic I don't really have the group for it maybe not or I need to go find the group for it um so that's just kind of what this is about and there's there's a lot of random questions in here but it's like mostly that's what it's about in in the whole thing yeah leaning into your situation to set yourself up for success as you just alluded to I got to a place in my designing where I didn't really have access to people then the pandemic was going on like all these different things it just kind of pushed me more and more into solo design game you know design solo games and I just went with it you know I didn't like be like no I'm
going to design three- hour Euros D git like my situation that would have been setting myself up for failure now could I have found a way to do some different yeah maybe probably if it had been that important but I just found that I really enjoyed solo games and so it's like yeah let's just do this and let's see what happens so I think that's another thing is just not trying not trying to go against the grain too much right as a creative person like see what gets you into flow see what gets you into that design space and the exciting place and then just lean lean into it and go with it if you don't have a group that can play three-hour games don't design three hour games it's just kind of that simple basically I like think I I very much believe we're product of our environment so what environment are you in can you you know get to the table that kind of thing yeah definitely man this has been excellent any kind of like closing thoughts you want to leave people with like I said I'll put the link to this document in the show notes of the episode and so if people want to check it out for themselves and and you know pull ideas from it do it you know again we're not saying hey here's your thing it's G to fix everything it's like no this is just an idea something that has worked that might work for you you know make it your own figure it out but what would be your your closing thoughts sure um I think the only closing thought I had is just that uh game design is a multiclass skill so I know we talked about like uh kind of emotions and trying to figure out Target audiences and things like that but just um something I keep in mind for myself is just to try to experience new things and try to go out and gather new uh kind of information even if it is not always from the the game design sphere or the
playing game sphere maybe go just try something random kind of introduce some random notes and you never know what might happen yeah absolutely so I know Rush excuse me risk strike just came out um and so tell me where people can find it where they can find some of these other games I guess most your stuff sold in like Target and whatnot so that's kind of nice but anything else you want to tell people about of course so um we have a couple clue escape room games at Target uh risk strikes on Amazon Target um one I would like to shout out to is there's a game called D and D dungeons dragons bedam and never winter that is a escape room Dungeons and Dragons game uh where you get to play as characters who are solving puzzles but also combat and also it's light enough to where you can play with your friends who are not say D and D experts it's very much an on- ramping kind of like my first D and experience but you get to Sol puzzles um really proud of that one but yeah thanks Gabe I mean you guys can check out the games anywhere but I appreciate you having me on and just letting me share my kind of huge document of of nebulous ideas but hopefully they're they're helpful to someone yeah absolutely thank you so much for being here really appreciate all this uh excellent information cool see you