Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 131: Cole Wehrle on Oath

Transcript 57:57

it's ad break time I pleased to announce the Beyond soliter podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual there up to amazing things if you want to improve your own skills as a game designer you should absolutely sign up for a loyless Santa's upcoming class the art of game crafting for your classroom boardroom or game night the class starts October 9th and aloy is a great teacher you'll also get credit towards a certificate in applied game design which is offered as a collaboration between CMU and Gen Con cgs's latest game 500-year-old vampire just finished a very successful campaign but if you forgot to back it you can now pre-order through backer kit the link is in the show notes I also want to plug my own patreon your support means a lot to me both emotionally and financially patreon money is what makes it possible to keep improving my channel by upgrading the equipment and I'm also hoping to increase the amount of videos I can publish over the course of the next year if you want to help out head over to patreon.com beond soliter for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond solitire and I'm here with a special guest Cole whle designer genius from leader games and also worldly gig how you your day Cole I'm doing well is how are you I'm doing all right it's super good to talk to you it's been a while since we you were on the podcast I mean we talk fairly often but yeah but one of my favorite episodes was with you so I think that uh we will just reprise that easy easy no problem s setting the bar so High um so uh let's just talk basic news

first which is that uh you have an upcoming release from warly gig I'm gonna give you a chance to talk about it right now awesome uh yeah we have on the 17th of October we are going to be uh launching our next campaign it's for a game called Molly house by brilliant young designer named Joe Kelly with some additional design by myself and it is uh in some ways a very different kind of game from the games we normally release um it's shorter it's an hour uh it's it's um spirited light-hearted a little bit easy to easy to pick up easy to play with with a group of folks who don't normally play historical games uh but in other ways is so deeply like a whle gate game it is exploring um a interesting slice of History it's about um queer culture in the early 18th century which is such an interesting slice because a lot of uh Creer history has been completely uh kind of bulldozed it's It's the sort of history that gets destroyed um but this little slice the slice about Molly houses in the early 18th century we do actually know a lot about and so it is a kind of sensitive reconstruction of that period and it's about um it's also about like the history of police Leasing and of parties and different ways of thinking about identity uh long before categories even like queer or trans even existed how were people sorting out and negotiating those identities um and I I just adore it to death and so we'll be launching on the 17th we've got lots of interesting things to show people and I'm so excited to see uh how this game does fantastic I also want to flag that this is a Zenobia

finalist game that is now making out in a publication and uh By the time this episode runs applications for Zenobia 2 will be open uh they're open through the end of October so uh Cole do you want to to say something really quick about finding this game as part of that process so that people can hopefully feel inspired yeah the Zenovia contest for for anyone who is thinking about working on um on a subject like this or uh who isn't you know if they don't see themselves reflected in the the bios of a lot of people who work in historical boore gaming the Zenovia contest is for you um it is a it's a two-pronged it's a it's a kind of a two effort contests one part is of course the contest the other part is this really fabulous mentorship program it was through that program that I met Joe and helped them on their design over many many months and uh it is it's just a wonderful nurturing space to take these projects through something like the kind of pre publication process um I think there were eight or nine finalists for the initial contest most of them have been signed by companies and you know Molly house is uh is not the first one that's going to be on funding are the first one that's going to get published probably fantastic yes and I'm so happy for Joe uh they were great to talk to you during the contest actually this has me thinking like I need to just have them on for another interview now but it just it just feeds itself yep exactly my my job's done uh but I uh I do want to talk today a lot about Oath so oath I think is one of your riskier

games in a lot of ways uh because instead of grounding itself in a very specific element of History it's an attempt to be both a game and kind of like a I don't know if it's a study like a representation of History proceeding along from game to game um and I guess I you know I know that we've got some expansion stuff coming for it in the future uh do you want to talk about that like as much as you're able well I I mean here's here's how I'll frame the expansion things um we're working on an expansion by which I mean now that oath has been around for a bit and we've seen people play it and one thing I love about running to people at shows so I I love going to shows because you get to you get to see all these things made physical all these like these people bumping into you and they talk about projects you've worked on you think oh that project was just a PDF really for me but it's it's something very real for this person and you meet fans of your work uh it's it's wonderful I meet lots of people who play roote and and they have root nights and things like that but the oath fans are different because they'll tell me oh I'm 30 games in and this is happening and they actually just launched directly into the narrative no one ever says like oh I really like this part of Oaths design what they instead say it's like oh this thing happened in the game and there's a line between the design and the storytelling that is like it's gotten very thin um and that's that's wonderful and now that I've seen oath kind of grow

uh in it in its in its players and in it storytelling it started giving us ideas about how we want to expand it improve it um and and that I mean it's it's an interesting project because we had never we of course have never planned to to to expand it you know I I I approach every project uh generally with with some exceptions as uh assume this is my only chance to do this thing so I'm GNA try to do it as best as I can um and with oath it does seem like the audience wants us to spend more time there and whether or not a game gets attention it's always a negotiation between what we're working on what the audience wants what we think the game might might need and having seen and played a lot more oath and thought about it I do think that there are places where the game can kind of grow and expand um but yeah this is not an easy thing for me to convince people of uh because oath is as you said like probably the riskiest project we we had ever worked on yes and so I I want to talk more about why that is but I do want to disclose now I can only disclose so much even to you Cole H but I spent this morning playing oath but is not oath as anybody knows it except for Ricky Royal and me and we'll have that meeting later and that's that's all I'm gonna say about that so I'm particularly interested in this project for personal reason Liz just booked a third appearance with me in six months where we're going to be talking about what she's working on yes so we have to invite Ricky yeah who should always be invited to everything anyway he's a

delight yes true but okay okay so in what sense were you hoping for oath to sort of evoke the passage of time and like an ongoing story and then how does that compare to how it has turned out would you say that like what was your you know your your thesis your hope for this game and then has it lived up to well you know oath had uh it's funny a lot of the times when I work on big projects I I boil them down into actually like a very simple pitch there's like one it's really just one thing I'm trying to do and then the way I frame it to to Patrick um who's the one I ask for money uh when I tell him like Hey we're GNA direct some studio Budget on this experiment um and I always tell him that you know I'm gonna need some amount of time to figure out if this is even feasible so I I never say you know give me uh give me a eight-month budget or a 12-month budget for this project which I can for sure deliver to you at this time I say give me a few months and then I will start to know how long it will take to execute with oath the very simple thing the very like kernel of the idea was I think I want a board game where the instate is a viable start state that was it um and Patrick immediately recognized that even though this sounded like a simple premise it was sort of like

fishlyn filled with entropy and they run out of energy and some engines are uh they move towards perpetual motion within the game Space right so uh Katan as you play Katan by the time you get to the end of Katan the game is producing so many resources that there is no way for the game to eat the resour like the the players outgrow the design of the game because the game is so funed right uh and and other games like chess by the end of a game of chess most of your pieces are dead or captured and they they can't spend energy anymore the board has kind of exhausted its action potential neither one of those games produces a continuing State uh the game's over and so as we got into oath the ve the opening premise was like okay well how do we get around that problem and so as we were thinking about the design I was thinking about like okay well what parts of the game are going to be healing restoring itself reorganizing self to kind of make that possible now that's a very mechanical answer but it's with oath it's very difficult to tease out the mechanical from the Thematic because they are so closely linked and I'll give you another example of that when I was thinking about um the the the theme of the game I was spending a lot of time thinking about stories that take place over one to three generations because I was thinking a lot about brodell and thinking about like long dur and just the appropriate scale for

history when it comes to board games so this is the other big question because if I'm going to make a game about history uh it might seem like the obvious thing to do is to make a civilization game after all you know most of those have like a Cleopatra and Napoleon on the cover or something and a rocket ship and someone like you know riding on a Papyrus um but that is a very weird like I think Sid Meers has done like more harm and good to like people's sense of History history because history really occurs on this like very generational level I mean really your and I our contact with history is less us encountering like a Thousand-Year old manuscript in a library and more like a conversation with a grandparent like that's the place where history and our human scales are kind of like actually having contact um and so I started thinking about a game that was generational and what kinds of narrative possibilities are there with in the kind of near focus of like a generational story this actually led me to like reading a lot of fantasy novels that have generational Scopes uh or even like the scope of a single life and what I realized was there were all these tropes that kind of kept coming up one of them was an object that is like lost but like not truly lost and so that then created these categories which is like we have the world uh and then we so we have the world that's a big circle and then within that Circle there is the world as we see and perceive and then there are other categories like outside of the world but

critically because we're only perceiving a small portion of the world we don't know what's truly in the world and what is no longer relevant I mean this is a classic question of politics right which is like to what degree are we haunted by the past or not haunted and what you know of course it's a complex mix uh of of all those things so now let me those are kind high-m minded historiography but let's talk about the mechanical demands that that then immediately places on the design so imagine your playing a game with a deck of cards and because I'm a game designer we'll start with a 52 deck of cards in our imagination which is about what Oaths deck is surprise now in this deck this is the world this is everything that could exist in the world but I don't want players to experience everything that's in the world because that would be a historical and odd and strange so let's say they experience half of the half of this deck okay great now it's it's important that they experience half the de too because it means that they could see something and then they could not see it for a generation or two and then they could it could come back so that like Exile and return Dynamic of an object has to re re require that a deck is not fully utilized and then if the the world should change so we have a deck of 52 cards and some portion of it's changing but if it changes too dramatically um I mean this gets a little bit into the ship aesus like we don't want the World to Change too quickly or it won't be the same world we need to be slowly Chang changing it and so you know I I went through you know just just numbers and thought eventually

settled on like well six cards are going to go out and six cards are going to come in and the deck will stay roughly the same size and of those cards that come in well there's a chance that they'll be in the deck that you see there'll be a chance that they kind of come back so that allows you to like have an impact and then not actually see the impact that was had for two or three games now all of that was actually figured out like within a couple months so when I told Patrick I wanted to experiment on this design um that was really what I was doing I was trying to figure out like what is the speed of the world what's the player's experience with the world and at the end of that exper at the end of that kind of you know summing um I realized that I had created a really awful problem for myself because I had to design this big game with lots of different things I wanted to put in the game but it had to work in basically 25 cards which is half let's say half a deck 26 cards and that is not that many cards if you think about like a button shy 18 card game uh that's a lot of work to do in really very very few cards um and that then creates the like all the different puzzles uh of oath now you asked a big question which is how then like what are the places where the game starts to fail and stumble and I think the the biggest place where it starts to stumble has to do with the width of the game's political imaginary um the game relies a lot on fantasy tropes but also I wanted

it to be a really interactive game so it's going to use it's gonna Prime violence it's kind of you know force is going to be very important now the game works but that kind of means the game can only speak and force everything has to be at some level reduced to to a battle um in the way that you know that's how fantasy novels end you know they end with these these big battles right um and that's because it's the thing that connects all the different spheres and the notable fantasy books are ones that don't quite manage it right that find other ways of framing the narrative so that it doesn't need to end in a battle um and and so I think that as I was kind of like thinking about how to design in the in this small space I started from a very pack style framework that really emphasized um State and and violence and there might have been other Frameworks that could have been added to that soup which is something that we're kind of trying to explore anyway that's big answer to to your question I like big answers um actually there's one role that I kind of want to talk about just because I've been thinking about it in my own work with oath right now and that is the role of citizen I feel like in a number of games that I play the chancellor never really wants to make a citizen very few people want to be a citizen I find that citizenship is a very troubling Concept in o on the ground and so has that turned out differently from the way that you intended um am I just playing it wrong or or um this is an interesting yeah goe

yeah I guess just like where where do we go with that social role like what did you intend for it how have you seen it play out in other people's real games and you know what next this the question of citizenship often hinges upon how much players come to care about the world that they're building and the game I think uh to its advantage and disadvantage doesn't give players a lot of reasons to necessarily care about the world but players might invest in that world and by the world I mean just the collection of cards which is going from one game to another sometimes players who play a lot of role playing games will get really attached to players and places uh to the sites and places that happen to to make up like the kingdom of the game and they will actually want to preserve that world as much as they want to win and the citizen role exists to make that possible and so other groups and I'll even put my own group in this in this mix don't care so much about that um and we did an interesting meta thing where I uh I was I was talking to to a group and um they were asking me about Oath as a tournament game and I was like this is nonsense there's it's not one um but I said you know the one way that you could think about it is you should re record Persistence of Dynasty and Persistence of Kingdom so and what what I mean is if if if the Empire is staying uh if if no Exiles are winning

then the the state is continuing and if uh if a player wins if they're a citizen um that's a new Dynasty and every Chancellor win uh increases the length of a dynasty and Exile wins always restart dynasties and then I I asked I told them I was like imagine that you are getting kind of your meta victory points from founding a kingdom that lasts a long time and in that context it really changes the game because now I found the this Empire I'm the chancellor for a game or two so that's my initial Dynasty and then it's looking bad I and then I I plead and beg and I bring in those citizens because I would rather have the Empire continue than my own Dynasty continue and uh so that that's how it's supposed to work but it often doesn't work work because I think the victory impulse is a lot stronger and the game doesn't signpost that as an option this is exactly the kind of space that I'm exploring right now with ARs and it's the space that I'm uh that I'm exploring with some of the new expansion materials that I'm drumming up you know there were versions of oath a long ago where uh all players began as Citizens and so you always started inside the Metropole um and they were interesting but like didn't quite work the the biggest problem is like the game just kind of needs Exiles um it needs that like outer Force pushing in to really like hum and so we found that it was

just better to have the player positions like go from game to game um but ARS is actually the opposite and ARS is as a very um narrow starting subjectivity where ARS arcs is a similar frame to oath uh with a couple major differences but one of the things that that's similar about it is you have this kind of like you know space Empire State thing uh and the players at the beginning of game of arcs are all of the same class they have all kind of like returned from their grand Tours they've got ideas and then the game opens but they're all on the same side and it manages this because there are these like blighted worlds that are slowly messing everything up there's a there's a a good like player versus environment tension right at the very start um and and there are other reasons why arcs arcs works the way it does but arc's got the other version of that framing I think the thing that I'm trying to explore and one of the oath expansions is I do think oath needs more Persistence of players and so this actually gets into like part of the uh you know every design is like a Gambit you're always making bets about what you think is going to work and not work and in oath I decided that like it's a legacy game but it doesn't care about players because players can drop in and out and what I found was that like nobody wants that really because people who experience these games play with the same group of people and so you don't actually have a lot of people dropping in and out and there was actually a

middle ground where you could say well what you could have people drop in and out but you could also have people stick around and so one thing that I'm looking at is finding ways of building that like like Dynasty family fra framework more directly into the game so that you know every color isn't just a color it's like a family uh and potentially we would include like some other colors so that if you you know Jerry always plays blue but they're not here this week so we're gonna you know we're gonna keep blue like off to the side um and then that lets people think a little bit about the status of the of the those families right this is a family that has been citizens for a long time I don't just want to become Exile because maybe I'm going to lose all of these like lineages that are associated with our position and I think part of the part of the problem in in in oath and this is in a lot of Fantasy games is that um when when when we're designing we we don't like friction we want to lessen our points of friction with our players um but of course the world is full of friction friction is good it premere works only because players can't freely determine their loyalty they have has to be an opportunity and so in that same way like I wish that the player positions of oath had more friction not less that's a really interesting take on this I like this conversation about I guess helping people invest in to become

more attached to the world because it is true like there's certain cards that you see often and they come up and you're like yeah it's you again hey buddy or you know there's certain locations that everybody ends up kind of spatting over because it's just I don't know everybody's favorite um but that doesn't consistently happen the and the wind instinct is strong I think it's very interesting to think about things in terms of dyes and in terms of maybe established citizenship like maybe a role in the society that you've come to Value but it also leads back to an earlier thing you mentioned which is that you know violence is so inherent to the system of the game and you mentioned that Exiles are kind of needed to create the tension in the game that kind of runs it so how do you get yourself out of that if you ever do I mean th this is the the the big and unanswered question about this set of of materials um I have an operating principle for the oath expansion which is basically uh most most expansions look at the core game as a foundation on which to build which is a a good way of thinking about it um in most cases and with the oath expansion I'm instead thinking about Oath as a branch of a a larger tree so like the oath that oath Chronicles of Empire and Exile you know 2020 whenever the game came out that's one branch but you can you could further Branch from away from from from that spot or you could go back closer to the trunk of the tree and so one way that

this then manifests itself in the The Game's mechanisms is that you would say okay this Victory condition is all about controlling the most sights maybe there are other variants of that Victory condition that kind of meditate on that theme or you know th this Victory condition is all about the darkest secret and in this particular world the darkest secret is something that can be seized through Force but maybe there are other versions of the darkest secret that cannot be seized by force not so easily now where where this is going to get a slightly messy is it will require some rewriting some adjusting of the game's core logic to make room for other ways of of interacting and and I and I don't know what that's going to be necessarily because I'm I'm deep in arcs and you know really a lot of a lot of my dissatisfaction with this element of oath was funneled directly into arcs because arcs basically is a it's a it's a kind of a meditation on asymmetric like the limits of asymmetric design because asymmetric design is so powerful it's expensive but it's powerful um because you can uh you can start to understand true difference in player position which is of course a a fundamental element of of History in storytelling is players have different subjectivities they have different motivations and the stories come at at the points of contact with with those differences and so asymmetry gets you closer to that which is great it costs a lot of rules which isn't so great but one problem is that if you want players to really speak they have

to be able to speak the same language um and oftentimes in root for instance that's the language of warriors on the map and the language of throwing dice so you know Roots big innovation in the asymmetric game Space was saying okay what if everybody can move in battle and and they're these core Rule and craft and there're these like core systems which all players participating in the problem is um those systems are all Marshal in nature and one of the things that I try to do with ARs and and we'll see if it works I mean I think every you know it wouldn't be fun if I were doing safe projects and ARS is about as weird as anything um ARS is big in inovation basically is to say we're going to use an abstracted action structure that turns every interaction into like a little bit of an action auction basically but if I'm trying to evacuate a planet and you're trying to cure a disease and someone else is trying to like found a state we are all competing and interacting in the same shared space through the the game's cardplay Dynamics and that then allows our a symmetry to really like blossom and grow much farther than root much farther than even something like vast um and oath probably won't get anything that dramatic but part of me thinks that if I step back and look at Oaths action structure like if I were to add one action or if I were to revise how a couple actions work that might be enough

to like widen the space as big as it needs to be I can actually see that being the case because oath one of the things that surprises and interests me about the game so much um espe especially through just repeated play and repeated consideration of it is it's so simple really like I don't I don't mean that in a bad way I mean that it does a whole lot with just like a whisper of a set of of mechanisms and I find that fascinating um but that also means that even the tiniest changes can have like a pretty wild butterfly effect on this game I think like even the presence of a certain Relic or not in your world can really change a lot um yeah there is a funny I want to I want to say something about about the game Simplicity because uh Oaths uh combat rules are tricky but it's really the only part of the game that's tricky like everything else is like extremely straightforward and even the combat is straightforward it's just the exceptions are really expensive like again it's the fact like it's honestly it's the citizenship rules is what Josh would say it's like that's the fundamental thing that that that's tracking it and so I actually think if we can if we can trim or adjust the way combat Works a little bit we're going to free up the space to do whatever else we might want to do that's a really interesting thought and I guess I kind of want to ask like as we think about expanding oath um is this going to be something that's more like isn't it going to be expansion or are we looking at something that's more

like you have a tendency a tendency that I personally like but is rare in board games to go back to things that you have made and just rework them utterly so tax premere and John company have both benefited from that in really incredible ways um yeah that's I think you know my my intent with oath is to not do a second edition which I think is a it's a way that that it could be done but but I also think uh I and also this is going to be a little bit of a question for next year but like I um so let me actually I'll talk a little bit about how decisions around second editions and expansions are made a little bit on the back end so second editions are very useful for moments when uh a design has kind of like gathered to some dust and you need to make a decision about a print run and then you kind of say like all right we could reprint this game or it's been long enough that we can actually go in and kind of fully reimagine it so in in the case of Premier uh and John company the second edition was something that was decided like very early like we had an opportunity to reprint Premiere that we didn't take because we were like no I think let's let's wait a little bit and do a second edition a similar kind of exercise is happening right now with vast where everyone at the studio likes vast we all want to do more vast and there's demand for us to reprint it if we were to reprint vast we would certainly sell it um but I think there's

a sense that like we're gonna it would be a lot better for the design if we were to do a second edition of vast and it would be a really good project for kind of everyone um with something like root it's impossible because root sells so consistently and has such a lively audience that there's really like no opportunity to do a second edition and there's no reason to um with oath oath is more like root there is like we actually see very stable and healthy sales we have a good stock of it and so then as I'm thinking about the changes that I want to make for the game I have to a little bit more strategic because I can't just go in there and like rearrange everything instead I have to say like okay let's imagine we do additional oath content and then there's this really fun consideration which is something I'd never thought about really five years ago which is thinking about what does the oath line look like like for someone who's going to buy a copy of oath um what what are their options like well you can buy a journal you can buy like you know some card sleeves or whatever um but if you're going to like buy an expans expion is this expansion one product is it two I mean do we for instance have an expansion that's that's like this is oath as uh like we're going to introduce like the player legacies as an expansion and this is another thing that like has a more dramatic Chronicle phase um or do do we package it as kind of an Omnibus like like prophecy of Kings um there's like a lot of different ways that an expansion can look my sense

is that in order to make a lot of this stuff work we're going to be in a kind of one point D you know D and D 3.5 situation where I'm guessing it'll be like one or two slightly bigger expansions that are meant to work together and that are for both people who've played a lot of oath but also people who who have been like you know if you bought a copy what I would love my like dream is someone bought a copy of oath and it sat in shrink and they like loved the idea of but they never played it because they got a little worried and then we have something to offer them that says like hey this is actually going to help you better understand and get excited about this thing uh and be able to to explore it I mean the other thing I'll mention here is that you know when when we're thinking about our work at leader especially we're really interested in like sustaining audiences and then tooling ourselves to helping those audiences continue to explore something that we think is is valuable and uh oath is definitely demonstrated there's a sustaining audience so we are like we want to like return that you that enthusiasm yeah absolutely okay so I want to talk about two kind of larger concept things as we discuss oath the first I want to talk about is kind of Oaths relationship to Fantasy literature and then I want to talk about how all of that can be serious commentary about history um so as part of my research for this I'm actually really glad that I ended up reading uh it's Lloyd Alexanders chronic is it pane is that

who you say I always say pedane but Chronicles of pedane sure uh but you know starting with the book of three uh I read that whole series I devoured that series at Le it's just so for those of you who have not read The Chronicles of prane by Lloyd Alexander I highly recommend it it's like a set of five little middle-grade fantasy novels that are the most Charming thing I'm actually gonna put in my classroom and see if I can get kids to pick them up but yeah they are Charming they're great they were just great um but you know I thought it might be kind of fun to talk about the ways in which that War influence appears throughout the world of oath starting with uh henwen the pig so that little pig is an oracular Pig everyone but yeah but there's just so many fun little Easter eggs to to what extent do you still see The Chronicles of prane when you look at oath or is it one of those things where it was kind of a distant influence and you just kind of see little Echoes and it's fun so the Chronicles PR I had I had read many many years ago in fact in fact um one of my first like book reports for class was on the high King which I definitely did not read but picked off the shelf as a well I mean I think there's something funny about like I'll do a 90s kid sound off here uh there weren't a lot of like fantasy books in libraries when I was growing up no so it did a weird thing like like my kids right now are obsessed with like fantasy graphic novels and like don't really want to read chapter books and I I could be like you know come on guys read chapter books you're

old enough but actually what has happened is I had to skip to The Hobbit in red wall because there wasn't anything else in my age category yes oh my God red wall that was big for me too right and where whereas the kids it's like no actually there's a lot of stuff that's actually more age appropriate because there's just ya fiction is in such a great spot so the high King was like I mean these books are from the 60s uh it was one of those one of those books like on on the shelf and I was like o a person with a sword and I remember reading it not really even knowing it was part of a series attempting to write a book review of it um and then I reread them a little bit later and and I'd like them and Kyle and I often often talked about them because there there's something I mean there's a lot of remarkable things about them so one um Lloyd Alexander is a very good writer and these books are so well structured like there's a there's a lovely I think it's like a slate piece or something that like talks about the chronicles of pran and describes them as like Oaken like they're just like they are wonderful to read a they have this like fabular like uh very simple clean storytelling quality that makes them so wonderful to read I've read them all of my my children they feel older than they are something Primal about them yeah right right for sure and they're also like the narratives are are not really glitzy I've been reading um the these uh British uh children's books from the 1930s and 40s called the swallows and Amazon's books which I'm obsessed with uh and could like have a long I could

talk for like five hours about the swalls and Amazon's books um but but they have a similar kind of quality which is like very straightforward storytelling like almost sleepy and boring but like extremely compelling at the same time and like all you're listening to is like the story of like some kids finding a cave or something um and unlike The Hardy Boys they don't really get sensationalist um and so I think that there or or you know I get to nany Drew books too anyway the the predan books Kyle and I had both read and I think when we were working on oath um we did a really interesting exercise where I I said like okay well here's a game I want us to to be on the generational level and so that means when players play a lot of games I don't want the world to go from ancient Rome to the space age in 10 games I want it to go from like a theme in like Eastern Byzantium uh like from like in 700 to like 1100 or like 1050 or something something um so the the world should be changing but not quite changing like so dramatically so we were trying to find like the right setting to have a deep history one of the problems like if we would have done a science fiction setting one of the problems is that like things change that's part of part of the fun right you get to see like the Star Wars movies and then you go watch the prequels and you're like the production design of these movies is neat because they're trying to do like the art Nuvo like what is the industrial stuff look

like you know 50 years 30 years beforehand but but a critical element is that like things are changing in really big ways and I was like well no because part of the problem is all these cards are shuffling in to a deck which means if we're building like a tableau just like ra like a Tarot spread we're a little Celtic cross and we're gonna like flop out our little cards um they need to look like they belong in in one world and not like you know some goofy Tech you know like I always think about Through the Ages is when you like draw a card and you're like how's why is this card in this this part of the game or I've been playing um this silly uh real time strategy board game called time of Empires which is a scream but every once in all you'll be like in like a war like a modern war and you'll flip a card and be like oh these are like my Flint Nappers that are still somehow they're like still in my deck that doesn't really make sense um so as we were as we were stewing on this um Kyle suggested well like what about fantasy as as a possible setting and he made he Kyle was the one who suggested that the suits should be um like cultural aspects rather than peoples which I thought was really smart and so Kyle made this chart and it it's just a sketched out chart and it has all of the suits his proposed suits and then levels of like development and engagement from like zero to five or zero to six and he just kind of did it as a thumbnail so you're like okay here's like a little discordia demon it gets really really big and here's like the little arcade and here's like a space obser obser Observatory

like their highest level of realization and like those all sit like a world and then as part of this conversation we start talking about pay because one of the things that is so remarkable about pay I mean the books are remarkable for like a million reasons but one of the things I adore about them is um the world is old and Arcane but in ways that like at some level don't matter like like in in Lord of the Rings the world is old in ways that do matter right but in in in our in in the in the prane books the world is old in kind of an unfathomable way um and you know the the main character um he he wants to kind of like be in this heroic role and then part of the the trick of the books is realizing that like the everyday objects that he encounters actually are in important like that pig isn't just a pig and his teacher isn't just like a teacher and those like heroic Veen of the everyday to me it's like the thing that is remarkable about the pran books fundamentally is that they are democratic they are like thinking about how do you tell these stories in a way that emphasizes an Ordinary World instead of an extraordinary world and and which is why Taran wonderer is the best is wand it was definitely the best one so for those of

you who have not read this series tan Wanderer is very Coming of Age the only thing that bothers me is that his female counterpart I don't know how to pronounce his name her name is it alen we I don't know Al yeah but um I feel like she doesn't get as good of a character Arc as he does but yeah she's like a remarkable creation for the time and is very good in like the early books yeah but her her book is like a little weak and you it's sad that she doesn't get the especially the high King the high King I think is it's both the it's the one my kids like the most it's exciting but it's also like kind of the weakest one but Taran wander is the best one because it I love your point about right the extraordinary from the ordinary because you know Taran he's an assistant Pig keeper from book one he always he wants to be a hero and he has to kind of go through this process where he's growing up he's learning about what other people do that is important he's developing skills and he's confronting his parents AG in ways that are really meaningful like it's just so wonderful to watch him like I guess become a man who is worthy of all the things he thought he wanted but not get there in the way that he thought he would and like some of that comes from like the way the the book engages with like leadership as like an actual concept like in this I didn't realize it was really I mean it was funny reading that book um to my kids like in 2019 or 2018 18 when I was working on oath I was shocked at how few

books like really talk about leadership like okay I I'll pick on Lord of the Rings which is a which is actually another big I read I read all the history of the Middle Earth while working on oath all like 4,000 pages of it and it was fascinating um and and I learned I learned a lot about how those books work um but in in in in token stuff it's like ah Aragorn he's a leader a leader of men look at HIM lead and it like doesn't really talk about leadership like the quality of leadership is often taken as like it's it's as innate as hair color or something often with the same racist overtones yeah um and in in the pane books leadership is something that is complex and like it you know so much attention is spent on like you need to understand what failure is like and how failure works and how like leadership means not being an expert and these and all and then there's this like lovely moment in in Taran Wanderer where he's confronting the fact that like there's something he wants to do but he's not good at it yeah and I was deeply moved yes yes and like and recognizing that like no that that leadership aspect like it is actually its own kind of skill and it has something to it so it's funny because you know so we have all oh this filled with with Easter eggs relating to the prane books but it it was never like a prane fan project because we were

trying like I think uh Kyle and I were just vibing on it we were like this is the kind of world where we you don't know how old it is we're not going to seek to answer that because we want the players to be inhabiting it like someone asked me if there was a a lore Source book for oath and I said no it's like your first five games of the L Source book like you have to you know you you have to assemble that stuff yourself because in in keeping with that kind of democratic spirit I want players to be like riding their own lore because like oath is not oath is a is a very storytelling forward game but I wanted the players to be the ones doing that authorship now I I'll contrast that to two other things arcs is completely opposite arcs I have a 30,000 word like Source book that I wrote that is like this is how the world of arcs works there are like a lot of rules and the storytelling is a lot more structured but it's because ARS is more of a of a cultivated story that's like it like needs it in order for it it to work it like starts kind of inmat arrest um and the other game I'll contrast to which I think this is a really interesting it's like one of my favorite titles from the last few years but it's a Ross Cowan's um the city of winter which is a fascinating it's an RPG kind of um it's an RPG in in the genre of um like the quiet year and his early ear fall of magic which is to say it's an RPG that um it's an RPG for people who don't normally play RPGs

because it's very like careful about table talk and careful about prompts so that um like I I play City and winter with people who do not play RPGs and I think it's it's like it's my most my most moving game experience this year was playing City of Winter City of Winter is amazing because I don't know that I don't think Ross played oath but he was working on city of winter at same time as I was working on oath and they're the same project as approached from two completely different perspectives and because City of Winter is all about you play a family that that's running from something awful uh the Umbra it's called but it could be anything and every every um phase of the game what happens is you share traditions and memories and then you pick up new ones that relate to the place where you're where you are and then then eventually you decide to move on and because the bad thing's coming and you just slowly watch the culture of your little group change and as you like it has it has these brilliant rules like um characters age they have these like little age dots and they can hold on to as many memories as they have age dots and then when they get to old age they start losing those dots and you have to like you like share a memory and if nobody picks it up off the table it gets lost and it's like and then when you your last age do your character dies and but because you're not you just make another character um and it is so powerful and so moving and then you

eventually arrive at so like and and all of that is like the prologue you do that over two or three sessions and then you arrive at the city of winter which is like this big big city big Metropolis with public transit and everything and then you kind of encounter a very different way of cultural recombination um and it's incredible it's an incredible design um done with with basically no rules I mean not no rules it has it has it has certainly has rules to it but um I really like its storytelling approach and it's something that you know oath is more of a game it's more of more stately and more uh more more competitive certainly and and there are advantages to that so oath oath to me like o oath can speak in in in dynasties and it it can it can tell like it can tell those sorts of stories but for the you know other kinds of stories um the city of winter is is great so it's my high recommendation oh man that really sounds good um so I want to connect all this so the other I think one of the reasons that I enjoy talking to you so much is that I think we have a lot in common in the sense that we're both people for whom a game can't just be a game it has to like mean something uh and I think that that's very connected to our backgrounds in history so we talked about all this fantasy and even reading Fantastical history but how does your I guess leader game self creating something like oath um also reflect your historian self who's

doing things like what worldly gig is making and how does it come out in oath so some of it is a is an approach to the work where uh when I start working on a project the first thing I do is like pile up books and pile up games and just try to think about what is this game actually about who else has done anything about it can I learn from that like I I I sort of think in lit reviews um just from the perspective of Labor really just like how how do I how do I tackle a big project I don't know I'm sure other people have tried to do it before maybe I can learn from them uh but in terms of approach what I like about working on projects with leader is it gives me access to allegory and metaphor in ways that the history games don't quite and so so you know I um when I'm thinking about root one thing I adore about adore about working on root is that I can think about a political problem and then I can try to abstract it like it lets me like play like kitchen philosopher a little bit because I can say like okay well like I want to see lock and Hobs like fight I want to like see like what happens if you put John RWS and John Lock in a cage like who's going to win or what are the tensions that are going to be exposed by that by that conflict and that's hard to do in a history because in a history you are bound by a case study you know you're

like Bound by the fundamental realities on on the ground you can bend them um but but there's there's a lot of uh there are a lot of like re requirements and a lot of structures that you have to place on yourself if you're being truly rigorous with some with something like a leader prog project uh it allows me to practice a different kind of rigor uh and it's a rigor that is a little bit more fantastic and imaginative um and uh I don't know and also just tremendously fun in the same way that I think like writing a novel is different than writing like a biography right that that that's really sort of what it is like you're you know if you're writing a piece of historic fiction or or or a fantasy like you can be deeply researched I mean I think about like RF Kong's Babel um oh man I love that book did you finally read it uh I might be like halfway through I'm getting through um and yeah we can talk about yeah I finally I finally got it like seriously underway because I I started this book for context for the viewers many months ago and then it like literally fell behind my bed and for and I was like gone for a week I came I was like where's Babel I'm like I don't know I'll start reading something else it's been recovered I'm now underway but but the thing is you can read a book like that or you can read like uh jeon's uh like uh broken Earth books which I adore um books that are deeply about our own world and deeply like am mesed in questions of like history and society

and politics and philosophy and all the rest um but are also uh imaginative and kind of freely combined I mean actually so I I don't know if we've ever talked about this but I am um I like attend the Church of Kim Stanley Robinson I'm like obsessed with Robinson's work um he's he's like probably one of my favorite living authors um my brother and I are always reading like a Robinson sci-fi novel like we have like a Perpetual I'm always reading a Pinchin novel and a Robinson novel those are like that's why my Baseline reading practice are always those two book I have read none of this guy's books it's got to happen now okay so read Aurora Aurora is the one I always recommend people start with it's the one on on the Generation ship um so what I love about Rob Robinson so Robinson I think he was like one of uh Frederick Jameson's students and then he went off and had like a career in sci-fi and what is amazing about Robinson is I mean uh so well here I I will tell you how I got introduced to his writing I was reading a New Yorker piece on something unrelated and then they made this comment about like you know a toll stoy for our own moment and then in parenthesis they were like and if anyone has that title it's Kim Stanley Robinson close parentheses and I was like what who is this author I've never heard of I love Tolstoy we have a Tolstoy I don't know about it um and what I love about Robinson is Robinson is like a practicing utopian he is trying to figure out how to make the world a better place and so as he

arranges his novels he's like okay here's a character who like passionately believes in this thing and here's a character who passionately believes in something different they both are trying to make the world a better place and in my novel we're gonna have them argue and we're gonna have them sort out and fight and it's going to be you know it'll be interesting there'll be interpersonal elements to it and then we're going to see kind of what shakes out and so he really looks at fiction as a space to sort out ideas that matter like at I'm like a real like you know in that toll story and like let's actually sort through this and so it's never like I hate calling him a political novelist because it's never preachy he doesn't know the answers he's trying to like figure out the the right Fring of the discourse so his famous books are like the the Mars books which are about the terraforming and building of a world um and if you find yourself exhausted by Mars board games but would like to think about something that actually like feels like the thing that it's supposed to be about the Mars books are great but the one I but the one I always recommend is Aurora which is it's a Generation ship book but it starts like four generations in on the Generation ship where here's a ship full of people going to a world that none of them agreed to go to because their parents all agreed and just like thinking through like we're on this like Tin Can going to this place that we don't know if we should be even going there and it's it's a beautiful novel it's fantastic um and yeah I don't know

uh his his stuff's great but I I really do think like I I have felt such a kinship with his narrative practice in working at leader because I think about the Fantasy games as ways of putting the historical work like into a kind of practice and that that is really exciting oh man that's fantastic uh I kind of want to talk more about this but also it's been just about an hour so I feel like we should cut it here yeah it's up to you I can go a little longer let's go let's let's go offline but we were reprise this conversation I think when maybe there's more oath to talk about I think that might be actually the best the best thing to do um but I normally ask people what they're enjoying but you've given us a fantastic game recommendation was it RPG again it's called Uh the city of winter fantastic and you g us a great book recommendation which is should read Kim Stanley Robinson's Aurora which is like the one I always feel bad because I love all of his books but Aurora is my favorite one to start with also a personal note about Aurora it rescued me from like the worst dold Drums of graduate school like when I was like really low and then I just happened to to pick up a copy of it and was reading it on the bus to from campus and it was like oh I do love books I forgot it's always going to be reminded oh man um but uh yes this was awesome I can't wait to sort of continue this conversation I see this is something that's like an evolution in process that

we'll just read we'll touch back on it later um but for now if people want to follow your work where can they find you they can still find me on the site formerly known as Twitter uh at coly I have a blue sky at the same name I will use it as soon as they open up up their applications like I'm you know it's right now it's just work for me to double post so I don't do it um but as soon as blue sky is fully open I will probably start crossposting there but yeah you can find me at Twitter my DMs are open um you know fantastic I have course I'm forever online and can be found anywhere as Beyond solitire so please reach out and everybody uh please like subscribe comment ask questions most of all happy gaming

you

Progress saved