Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 225: Dan Bullock on Penitent

Transcript 1:02:01

It's ad break time. I'm proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. I'm personally very excited because CLGS has a springtime crowdfunding project on the way. They'll be publishing a revised edition of Jason Morning Stars the blue way which you can hear about in episode 224 of this very podcast. But for now, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is David from Beyond Solitire and this is going to part of a very special guest. This is Dan Bulock. He is a game designer, a generally awesome person and a podcaster in his own right because he does game design game design deep dive. How you doing today, Dan?

Wonderful. Thanks for having me, Liz.

Yeah, thanks for having me. So, for those of you who are out there, you should know that I literally just recorded a an episode for Dan's podcast and we're just swapping. His is his interview will probably be better than mine. Um, but Dan, the last time I had you on my podcast was literally years ago. So, Blood and Treasure had not been signed. In the Shadows was not out. Like, it's it was forever ago. So, uh, what are some games that you've come out with recently or have been working on recently?

Yeah. Um, I think the ones that have been released, um, since then, uh, The Gods Will Have Blood came out in 2023. Um, I it released, uh, actually GMT released in the Shadows that I co-designed with Joe, uh, Joe Schmidt. And then, um, I'm prepping a release right now for Penitent Lockhorn's game. So, that's going to be the second game I'm publishing through my own little imprint. And um so that's been um what's been absorbing most of my time lately. And then I've got a couple other projects in the hopper. But yeah, so the ma major change has just been um going down the road of self-publishing uh since those early releases um with Compass and Deeds Foundation.

Nice. Okay. So um we you you've actually done a mixture of releases. So there's the things you're publishing yourself and then things that are coming out uh through publishers that offer you developers. So we're going to talk about both of those. Uh but starting with um your self-releases, what uh what drove you to start Lockhorns and also to uh I guess do the small print runs you're doing? Like I felt so anxious I was not going to get a copy of Gods Will Have Blood and I'm feeling the same anxiety now.

I think the mailing list is pretty manageable. It's pretty tiny actually at this time. Um, but I for uh God's Will of Blood, it was interesting. I only sent it to one publisher initially. Uh like I had sent it to um Holland Spiel to see if would be interested in it because years and years ago I had uh submitted um no motherland without to Holland spiel uh for consideration and I ended up going with uh compass instead because I you know for your first design you really become a little bit obsessive like will it be in stores? Will it be on online stores? will people see it and then see my name on the box and hopefully make my job easier to get that second game. It's all about not even getting the first game out. It was like, oh, will I be able to get a second game?

Will anyone let me do a followup to this game?

So, I was a little concerned.

Yeah, exactly. So, I was a little overconerned probably with that from from the perspective of wanting to be have a game that was distributed versus like a print on demand kind of release. And so I always felt like um that was something I was really interested in though eventually was like publishing with at some point down the line when I had a project that was a little bit more um a fit a good fit for size. And so when I submitted uh guys will have blood passed on it and I think it's because Republic of Virtue was also the the holiday giveaway that same year that I submitted. So there was like uh so because there wasn't really any interest in putting that out, I kind of decided to just put it out myself uh and see if there would be any takers for that project. Um because even though it was a very small game, it was uh something that I felt like I had gotten the play experience exactly where I wanted it.

Like the narrative arc, everything was exactly as punchy as I wanted it. So it's like I'm just going to roll the dice and see if I can put it out myself. And I was also going to treat it as a kind of a guinea pig for potentially putting out other projects in the future, either by myself or by other designers who are working on like a little underserved topic that was a little too niche. Um, so I did that and was able to sell out pretty quickly on that game and then it was a it was about uh two years before I was able to get Penitent lined up and ready for a second pass. uh because I still need a little more of a war chest before I can put somebody else's game out. But I think the desire there was really just I had these topics that I could see what kind of games I would want to design for them. And even, you know, with almost 10 years having passed since I started design, there's still nobody in this hobby that publishes those kinds of games like anywhere. Nowhere to submit it. No one will take it. No one's interested. So, it's like, all right, well, I guess, you know, because it's not a kinetic topic, it's not a kinetic warfare. It's not really on these things. Um, I think I'm going to have to kind of put out my own game. And I I always loved to um you know, kind of the smaller projects of like folks like Nate Hayden, Martin Wallace when he was doing the Tree Frog designs, like had like a little subscription model for those games. And uh I was not a Tree Frog

subscriber, but I've paid in excess for each of those games after the fact. So I have quite the little Martin Wallace collection in hindsight. Um but yeah, I thought that there would be something to that where you kind of have like a a tiny little core audience. you get to make games for them that want it. And then it's not a big um it's not like a production where I have to um make too many sacrifices with things that are important to me like where the game is manufactured. Uh what kind of labor is is used for it and also like whether or not the game is like kind of eco-friendly before it comes out. Trying to minimize waste is is is a big part of it too.

Makes sense. All right. So, for those of y'all who did not catch The Gods Will Have Blood when it came out, uh, that one is about being a judge during the French Revolution. Well, the reign of terror, I suppose. And it's, uh, based on a novel of the same name. Um, but since you can't get it, let's focus on Penitent.

So, what is Penitent going to be about?

Sure. So, uh, Penitent started out as a tease that I put out on on Twitter. uh the morass, formerly known as Twitter. Um so I basically teased this idea of a game like do you want to play a game inspired by Quaker penal reform in the 19th century and Vlad's Galaxy Trucker? Of course you do.

Of course.

And here's here's how you'll find it type of thing. So uh the idea was to cast players as the role of kind of prison architect. Um, and they would be creating an early, you know, kind of like a 19th century penitentiary design. And it would incorporate certain schools of reform. Uh, either a reform base set around the silent system, which was like silent congregation, the Auburn system of prisons, or it would be B based off the Pennsylvania system, which was like very uh very much derived by Quickers. Um but this sense of solitary confinement and folks would basically um be able to draw a floor plan for a prison adhering to the constraints of one of these two systems or a hybridized system that kind of incorporates both.

And then they would use these event cards to kind of see how their basically how their floor plan would be judged over time and the impact that the floor plan would have on uh prisoners that are residing within their prison. So it had it got allowed me to incorporate something that uh I hadn't used since No Motherland was out, which was like kind of the equivalent of the generation board. So, it had this great inmate board that had little portraits of uh individual inmates, and you'd be able to track statuses to know when they were released, when they were transferred, when they were sick, when they learned a trade, um when they were going mad, like all these things would be tracked on this little board. And then also, the most important part would be you'd be tracking recidivism throughout your penitentiary over the course of three eras. So, I I thought that this was like a delightful little idea and I got to do all kinds of wacky things with the system and it had a little bit of a bag draw. It has lettered tiles. It has like all kinds of goofy stuff, but mostly I I love the idea of people having to consider when during play. Um, drawing is almost like a weird substitute for the journal game. It's like a bit of this considering the space that they are drawing for people. And one of the points of reference inevitably is going to be the room you're sitting in when you're playing the game becomes almost a reference point for space as you're

drawing it. Like, well, how does this how would this cell compare to the dimensions of the room that I'm sitting playing this game in right now? Or how big would this kitchen be in comparison to my own kitchen? You know, things like that. And uh the floor plan and the prison, it's not a penitentiary that's going to house 250,300 prisoners in 1817, but it is a microcosm of a larger facility. So it gives players an opportunity to kind of see what would it look like to house say 24 folks because it allows you to kind of reduce the scope and then you get to examine the impact on individual prisoners which you know you know me Liz I like I like a feel bad experience and I think this won't disappoint.

Uh you know I love a good feel bad experience. I'm excited. Um, so, uh, logistically speaking, how difficult is it to like print your own games for these little boutique print runs?

Uh, it's it takes a lot of research after the project's essentially ready to kind of find the vendors that are going to that I'm going to use to source things. Uh, when I did Gods Will Have Blood, I think I went through five different vendors for all the components of that game, box included. And then once they arrived here, I just assembled them all myself and sent them out. And for Penitent, it's down to four vendors. So,

I'm already getting better at this. Um, but everything

yourself from the prison of too many vendors.

Ah, indeed. Please liberate me. Uh, so yeah, it it's it's interesting because like I I am it allows me to be um very picky about, you know, what is what is a good quality game box, what are good uh quality components, and then also uh you know, a good example would be something kind of inane that no one would really think about, but like I have lettered tiles, like the equivalent of scrabble tiles. They're drawn out of a bag because I use the letters to reference prisoners that are on the inmate board and how they correspond with cells in the actual form plan. But I use the numbered result to correspond with results that I need instead of dice or any other kind of mechanism.

When prisoners die because they become violent or they go mad, their tiles stay out of the pool and are no longer a result that you can get, which means the letter is no longer available to keep absorbing bad outcomes from events. But that also means the numbered result is something you no longer can get. So it becomes a wacky pair of dice that can no longer roll 10 or something along those lines. Now, uh, letter tiles, I was able to find a printer that would laser cut them out of chipboard and then I can put them in every single box. Um, but I went that route, not because it was the cheapest route. The cheapest route is actually buying wholesale scrabble tiles and then just grabbing the chunky satisfying feel of scrabble tiles and putting them in a bag. But then I'm throw out 74 of them every single set that I would make.

But if I print them, then I'm not creating any waste and it's costing me like pennies more every single copy it gets. So almost every single component that you're choosing to go in the box costs a little bit more if you're going a more environmentally friendly route or you're going through state state side vendors. But I ultimately this is the game I can live with. This is what I want it to kind of turn out. And that's the thing that most publishers are going to be much more concerned with the bottom line. I just don't have to be like that. It's the nice thing about being this size, doing it smaller, and only having to ship out 200 of these suckers. So, I'm kind of excited for that.

Fair enough. Um, so how do you decide when you're just publishing your own game, um, when it's done? That's a fabulous question. Um, I think for that it's not that dissimilar to how I know most of my other designs are done. There's a point where you're not seeing wild shifts during iteration. The you can feel the concrete drying a little bit. And so each each move, each evolution feels like it's smaller and smaller and we're kind of losing some of that inertia. And so I I suppose that it's when the changes between versions are not getting as dramatic. Um I am convinced however that with a lot of games that I did not have developmental help with um they probably could have undergone like a more significant evolution at some point during that journey. This is just more about the trajectory that I was capable of taking it to without that outside kind of voice.

Yeah. So, you and I have chatted about this. In fact, we're chatting when I hit record uh about the need for a developer. So, um have you had a developer for these smaller Lockhorns games as well? And how did you manage that? And also, I know that you've got games that are coming out with um with publishers who are at long last providing dev assistance for you. and like how has that been?

Um, I think I'll start there. I I think the working with the developers has been great. It's been pretty fantastic. Um, I think every one of those relationships is pretty unique and different in terms of what they're going to contribute to the project. Um, but I worked with Joe Schmidt and I worked with Jason Carr for In the Shadows. And um I think that with working on that project with Jason, it was very interesting to hear him come up with just a couple little tidbits. He'd like lob one at you every now and then. U for example, we had an early, you know, came out of a game jam. So early on there was a um one of the early contributions Jason had was I would like to see this without a die like a dicebased resolution mechanic and maybe go to shift the cards and Joe and I were not very resistant to that because we aren't really in love with dice anyway and then also we um could see the potential in making uh with a with a card resolution mechanic of course you have the opportunity to make wilder swings. It can be a little bit more narratively appropriate in certain circumstances. So, we kind of liked that input. Um, and then it an early point, one of our earlier iterations of the game, it was the historic model that didn't really work. Like it was kind of it just like was a little off from what we wanted. And it was because we had kind of changed what we were doing midway through the game jam and then we

never successfully uh we never successfully cleared out all the you know the antivenenom had not run its course yet of like some of the previous idea and so I think that when we had kind of moved our um model up two years

like being two years later it had a dramatic point like effect on whether or not our model was historically accurate or correct anymore. And so um I think Fred Sval and Jod Hurst actually played through it and they gave us a little bit of feedback on it. So we were able to incorporate some of that feedback into things that we wanted the model to show us. Um and so I that was like really beneficial to that project. And um aside from that, it's just more eyes on everything like just having all those eyes to check over your rule book draft and move through everything. So it's not even just a single developer, but having a developing team of proof readers and things like that. Um because I think that for

uh some some of the other projects that I done early like with No Motherland without I think only one person from my publisher actually looked over any of the materials and I can't speak to how thoroughly they looked through them. I don't I don't know because if your project manager has 12 other projects they're doing. Um yeah, I I know there there's there's some folks have their opinions about Compass in general, but I will say um for the volume of games that they put out in a year.

There's there's definitely a need for more people there to manage that. I think we would all agree that that is definitely something where they they're kind of underserved by that. And in general, the more games that any publisher is putting out, the more need there is for uh like hands-on development teams and project managers to kind of massage those things through that system. And so for my first two publisher games, um they didn't I mean I had a I had a developer that was like a friend for No Motherland Without. he had no industry experience, but it was someone to sound like a soundboard for ideas. So, I think that helped a little bit and it was also pretty strongly influenced by um Twilight Struggle. So, there's at least something to iterate on, you know, that that first design you always do has like so much other games DNA in it. Um but when I got to 1979, u moving over to Deetsz, there wasn't any developer at all. It was just me.

And I think that that might have been a little too much game for me to bite off by myself in general. Like that's something that I definitely wanted wanted a little more assistance with. So for these other projects, you'd think I'd go toward develop like a solid development team right away, but it's just the reality of it is for self-published projects, that's not an option. you know, I don't want to have a developer who I don't pay for their time

and the projects are too small and the print runs are too small to pay that person. So, as a result, I'm doing my own art on a my artist pro 16 tablet and I'm doing like my own play test and organizing all those things. But, so the so a game like God's Will Have Blood, I can honestly say aside from my play testers, no one else touched it. I did

Yeah.

did all of it. And for Penitent, it's very much the same, which just means it's a little janky and a little bit funky, but it's also um it's been a obsessive little piece of work. So, as a result, I do think it kind of comes to a thing of like you're in this weird brain space of a game that's not going to be like other games because it's just not none of the edges have really been sanded off that way. the rule books been poured over a lot. So, I know that that's at least something that's going to be uh intelligible by other people, but as far as like um the uh the system and everything like that through rigorous testing, it's it's still pretty pretty wild. I'll be honest.

I mean, it makes sense. I think that um you know, in an ideal world, right, every game gets developed and you know, it's also just a reality that's not the case. So all you can do is test and iterate as much as you can and have testers you trust.

Um I will say that uh for foxes and lions having access to developer has been amazing so far. Um I've been really really happy um just with that and having another person kind of like invited into the relationship who can see it really clearly.

Yeah. I'm I I like I I recommend for especially with like people who are designing their first game, like their first first game, like it's often a thing like, oh, this is just you should insist on this. See if you can get this. But we know as to your point, like I think with a lot of publishers, it's just not something that's necessarily in the sphere of what they provide. And that's why in the war game hobby especially, there's some publishers where I think that there are folks who like sometimes someone with the publisher or who runs the company has a hand in developing a lot of those titles and things like that.

Yeah.

Um I know like Revolution is like a good example of that, but there's like some of these titles there's a bit more hands-on. There's someone that's going to be working with the development team and it's not always about size. So, I definitely think that there's opportunities to get people involved in these projects to do development. It's just not always something that is prioritized by a lot of these publishers.

Yeah, I mean it makes sense. Um, I will uh flag for a future interview that'll come out. I talked to Shotty Torb recently and he does dev for the impatience titles that come in. So he started like publishing other people and does a lot of that dev himself and that I thought was a very interesting chat. So stay tuned everyone.

Uh so uh of your fourthcoming game. So Blood and Treasure is coming. I think that we were just talking about it almost as like a it was just a fun prototype that we didn't know anybody would sign the last time we talked about this in like 2022. So how have things gone for Blood and Treasure?

Yeah. Uh signed with Fort Circle. um in 2024 and uh I have been working on it since then. Um play tests have been going really well with it. Uh I have a developer for it. Um been working with Joe Doohurst. We have an artist Neils Johansson's doing the artwork for it. Um

that's a great lineup.

It's really good. I I'm I'm very excited about it and um it's I mean the hope is to see it at least come to crowdfunding by the end of this year. It's tough. I think you know so much we talk about like the will is the desire to self-publish like some of it has to do with you want to have multiple projects on different timets. So something is always being cleared from your docket just as you're building up a new project.

And um it's tough to reconcile sometimes like the projects where you wait four or five years for a game to come out from you know the the clock doesn't start with the publisher. the clock starts when the when you have the playable prototype and maybe that's not

ideal but I I think that that's where sometimes we have like a little you know fire under our ass where we really feel like we need to get that thing out and um I think for In the Shadows it was like a really long wait like about five years for a game to come out and it felt like that was something that I did not want to happen with a title again if I had any power over it. And so having these little tiny uh tiny uh print run games that I could do through my own publisher was like ideal because I would be able to move a little bit faster, but is also that that time is all condensed in the game. So, most folks, I think, if they see a game that they really are waiting for uh coming out for pre-order or something with a publisher they like, it's they see that four-year process and they assume that their game is getting a little work every every passing month, right? Every passing year, little little touches are happening with it. And I think the the reality of it is that a lot of that weight is waiting for your day in the print queue. And more than likely, uh, your game is probably finished in some state well before that, but maybe there's a whole arm of it like we're waiting on artwork to get done.

We're waiting on our time with the manufacturer for it to get printed or a number of pre-orders need to be hit for a certain thing. So the reason why you can do a small print run and not have to you know you you accelerate a lot of that process is because if say it's all one person doing all those things it condenses the project considerably. It's always about oh I shouldn't be playing you know this video game I should be doing that that artwork or laying out these cards or working on the graphic layout for this box. So you can kind of see how those things are move a little bit faster. Um, but there's also an element of um, you can kind of intensify the project as you're getting closer to the done date. You can kind of accelerate it and it doesn't feel rushed because you've been working on it in a organic way a little bit every single week. You know what I mean? For the entire longevity of that project.

And I think that that's like a thing like where you kind of lose your patience sometimes with some of the manufactured or like with the other published projects. But I'm finding now is I don't know if your experience has been this, but I actually like having a variety of projects that have different lengths and sizes. So that way it's just I just need the variety of something's going to be coming out, you know?

Yeah.

Every year to free up the space.

I'm big on the variety as well. So, like right now I have games that are like going to print, being printed, or ready to pitch. Um, and so I don't have anything that's like in its like first like, you know, growth.

I don't have any like new life currently on the docket. Does that make sense? And so it makes me want to start a new game because I like to have things that are kind of first blush of an idea getting newly worked on, things that are getting close to pitch, getting tested. You know, the the game has sort of congealed into something. I see what it is and you know what could it what what it might change into. And then stuff that's getting printed. That's a new one for me. Like this is going to be finally 2026, the year you can actually get something that I made in the world. maybe like three things if everything goes really well. Um because um Queen of Spies is printed or being printed right now. Uh Night Wishes the like the rule book is finally getting laid out right now. Like there's actual preparation for crowdfund at this time. And so I I mean you know I signed that in 2023. It's been a long road

um for to see my first game in this world. And then um you know the oath stuff we're in pre-press so I'm like Ricky and I are frantically pouring over the solar rule books and cards like since the leader split I don't have access to the files anymore

and so it's like weird because I'm trying to

I'm trying to finish this project because my name's going to go on the box but I can't finish it myself the way that I originally intended to. But all the same like it's close to done. it's going to go to the printer and um so up to three things by me could be out there.

But I started my first game design in 2022 and now finally like I've been joking that I'm all cattle and no hat. Like I'll have a little hat. Um I don't think that people fully appreciate like how long it takes to become I guess successful by whatever standard. But if successful is having games out from beginning of design to when they are out. It's a process. It's like years

Yeah.

of working and waiting and dealing with the entire system of getting things published. It's crazy.

Yeah. I It was five years for me between starting that between um starting that design

and then I had two come out the same year. So having then I looked like the CDGs were oh that's easy. You just bang one of those out no problem. And like I I mean the uh the idea that I mean like starting starting a project on the heels of the other one when I handed it off to the publisher and then that whole project got done while it was just waiting for its day

to be printed. I mean that was enough time to like do a whole game you know like afterwards. But I mean the research for those projects it like the research for the Ron project it was like two solid years of reading about it like that's all I did and I only had one design at a time when I was working on those projects. So that was the other thing too.

Um so I I don't know what the time would be like now that I allow myself to work on more than one thing at once but

yeah it's interesting to think about. So what are some of the other designs that you currently have like in process? So, uh, I know about fruit because I finally got to play it last time I saw you at a convention. Uh, but what other that tell us about that one and just whatever else you're currently cooking.

Sure. So, fruit is uh about uh United Fruits activity, we'll say, put it politely, uh, in Latin America in the early 20th century. So, each player is going to play like an empressario. you're like a business person and they've got a little player board with interests that are aligned with either the national interests of uh one of the five countries on the map uh or more more to the point a business that's sort of aligned with those like an say a Nicaraguan fruit country for example or a like Guatemalan fruit country or they have an interest ownership stake in United Fruit which case they want the company to do really Well, but all these interests start out on their board secret from all the other players and you can basically it has like a little action menu. You can manipulate activity whether it's in labor uh building up these plantations um or you know exporting fruit out of a given country or even things like instigating a coup and rousing rebels or also secur like kind of uh putting together a militia to put down put down a coup. Um but you have a lot of power to kind of start fires and put them out all over the map. But where your hands are caught in meddling is really going to be telling the other players at the table what your interests are and your level of priority over the course of the game. So it was like my first uh kind of

attempt to do something that was a little bit more um of a multiplayer game where it was going to be very heads up. I wanted players to ideally be watching other players when it's not their turn and scrutinizing the actions those players are taking. Instead of having something where it's very ponderous and heads down where they're looking at their player board and I'm always really sensitive to that when I'm playing a game. I'll play something like a what's a good example? Whose game should I drag? Um I know you love that. Uh because that's good podcasting. Um, uh, David's, uh, David Turzy's, um, Captain's Chair. Have you played that?

Not yet, but I heard it's great solo, so it's on my to-do list.

It is only solo. It should only be played solo. It is a very heads down

heads down affair. And I think that the thing is sometimes when I'm playing a game that has a player board that has all the information on it and there's almost nothing happening in the center of the table, I become really sensitive to the fact that we're all looking at our player boards and none of us are looking at each other. We've basically created a new screen for us to me. I don't want to have to look at people. So, you know,

well, some of us don't want to play like a parakeet with a blanket over their head. you kind of want to be in the shared space, you know, plus you'll get the blanket and your drink. It's like very disruptive, but sometimes um sometimes for a solitary experience, I'm fine with that. I can be very heads down. Um but I I've noticed that element of um kind of looking at the the game state and what things people are focusing on. Like when I'm watching um play tests of games, I like to see whether players are orienting their focus on the shared state. a personal state and how much of the game's friction comes from is this thing from the personal state rearing its ugly head now? Like uh so I'll mention a game I kind of I kind of do like I like the game Argent a lot. I like worker placement if it's mean enough. And nothing nothing says mean like having players compete for tenure. I mean when the stakes are that low, right? They all at a school for wizards all I mean it's it's a wizard school but still it's you know uh competing for ten tenure and argent the consortium the vibe is very much like uh about where you place your workers. You can lock rooms out of other workers and be very mean about it. What I have a trouble with in that game is that there's these little spell cards that have these explosive effects and they're all facing the players who are building up toward this huge showstopper of a game event. And it's very tough to track what each player is able to do in that game. And it just gets steadily

harder and harder as the game progresses. And so that's something that I'm always really sensitive to when I'm looking at other people's games or even play testing my own games. It's like how much of a shock will it be when this thing comes out of nowhere and screws up the game? Like, and is it a shock we want? Is it like a party game kind of element or is it something that's just going to piss everybody off? Like that kind of weighing those things.

Yeah. Actually, where do you come down on that? I'm very curious because I mean I uh I adore you for this, but you do like a mean game and you do like to stir So like at what point like how is it at what point in a game like a heavier one especially is that justified and like earned versus

I mean it's it's tough like I for me the feels I would say on the extreme end of I can't believe this super dramatic thing just swung the whole game like a saloon door. I think dominant species marine is probably the the high watermark of how much of that drama I'm willing to accept in a game. I think that can be very swingy and very mean and punitive. Um, and I can't include original recipe dominant species. That game just takes too damn long for me. I don't know. I think with two extra players that's that's that's a whole meal could have been eaten there. That's a little too long. Um it's yeah I I can't quite count that. But in general like I'm probably more upset um by uh an evening where I'm just rolling pitifully like in the same hex encounter war game for like five hours.

I can't you'll notice my games don't typically have a lot of dice.

Yeah. I I'm very anti- dice in general. I don't like it and I will go out of my way. It's like one of my two most hated things I think in a game. So, I usually go out of my way to not put them in

in there.

Um, unless the game is supposed to be kind of like a have a laughing at everyone's misfortune party game type of atmosphere and you're like, "Sure, dice." What when did you realize you were anti- dice, Liz?

Um, honestly, I just never seem to roll well when I'm playing with my friends to the point where at work they refer to it as a Liz roll. Like one time I was playing arcs and I rolled like 10 dice or something like that. I got like two hits. I don't know if it was that. It was bad. It was bad. And so like I just don't roll well. And I also don't I enjoy feeling like I understand probability and have personally manipulated it if that makes sense.

So

yeah,

you know, like the first time I played a Grile Master of Britain, I was very interested by the chit cups and like the way that they represented political feeling moving back and forth. Um, you know, for Night Witches, David and I decided very early on we didn't want dice. Partially because we neither of us I guess David might be more of a dice person than I am, but I'm really really not. Um, but we wanted you to feel like you had some sense of control or understanding over what was in the bag. And we wanted a little bit of control of the randomness. So, like in Night Witches, you know, if you pull all of your positive results early because you overdrew, then that means there's only crap left in the bag and you could get yourself into a situation where you're stuck. Where with dice, they could just all go well or all go poorly. And I enjoy I guess like almost the arc that you can create from randomness, but there's like a controlled set of outputs that are possible.

Yeah.

I feel like it gives flavor and like some decision making. like David's and my games together both so far have had like you're pulling from a bag and you don't want to overpull, but you also want to pull enough to make sure you're going to get the result you want. And so kind of making people decide how much they want to push it um is really satisfying. And so I feel like that is that is part of it for me.

Yeah.

What about you? I I mean I just I play too many old school word games and then I leave mad because I just roll so poorly and it's just it's always about the the harsh mistress of the CRT blah blah blah.

And I and in general too when I think about the war games I love the most. It's it's the Hannibal Rome versus Carthage. It's it's Sea Gajara. It's Maria. It's none of them have dice. It's just they're they're more fun. is because it's also um I feel I feel very strongly about this. I want combat in these games to be something that the defender feels too has a decision space also. And so if that tension isn't shared, then it almost is like the combat feels a little trit to me.

And it's like uh this idea that there's going to be one side in a two-player war game that's going to just be the attacker

for 75% of the time and then they're going to roll the dice like

180 times. That's just like boring as hell to me. And then the fact that the defender just needs to sit there and see if they take a punch.

I think it's a lot more interesting to have it where the defender has to play something where they can get something out of it based on like either matching a card or maybe they have to assign like and I don't care what the element is, but they need to have a decision to make in that other than which warm meaty body is going to absorb the brunt of some ballistic onslaught. Like I just think that that's not very pleasant, you know, as far as like from a game perspective. And when we're doing that too, it's about tension. Like about oh my god, are they going to draw this out longer? I mean, aren't they they should know they're going to lose? They should Why are they Why are they making it keep going? It's just like that's a lovely point of tension. I think that that's fantastic.

Yeah. Yeah, it is true that, you know, um even something like Here I Stand, which I love obviously because I'm making a Here I Stand series game with with Paul, right? um you know watching somebody sit there and roll to see if they convert in different spots in Germany like it's not I do not enjoy even if I'm one of the people who's participating and like you know I was the Ottomans last time I played and piracy was such because you have to roll to commit piracy successfully and like I never got any cool pirate points at all like what is even the point of this action that I know I will never succeed at because I'm not hot on the dice like

yeah Um, I I don't know. I like to feel like I have a say because maybe this is me being delusional, right? But like I feel like in real life, if I'm somehow a general and conducting a war, um, I mean, I would want to feel like I had some control over my situation, win or lose, right? And I feel like gamers also want that sense of agency. Too many die rolls doesn't feel good to me.

Yeah. Um, I I want to feel like I can assess the situation in a way that's like a little bit beyond what DICE will allow and I want to feel like I can control the situation beyond what DICE will allow.

Absolutely. It's always It always feels really silly to me silly to me too to like see some of these CRTs where it's just like a oh well this skirmish has like a one to three or like 3 to one ratio so it's automatically going to yield this in terms of casualties. Yeah,

you and I know it's just like it makes a big difference whether there's 4,000 people there or 40,000 people there.

Like

the casualty rate's going to go up exponentially. We're talking it's not about a ratio, it's about, you know, who's there, right? Type of thing, exposure. And so for some of these things, it's like

it's funny how much

uh to pick on World War II games where how many folks in the hobby, they're kind of like rivet counters about certain capabilities and certain elements and then there's this one thing that they are totally fine with a level of abstraction which to me is bananas and makes no sense at all. Like it's like, okay, this part is just it's just goofy, right? We're just getting goofy. And so at that point, just try something else, like try other things. I I've loved some innovations that I've played like on those kinds of systems. Um, you know, one standout since we're since I've been, you know, talking making fun of all these things that I don't like, but like uh John Butterfield's enemy action series. This idea that you have to to reach into a chit cup and based on how many like what forces you have present determines how many chits you could pull, but the more you dig deep for those hits, you're also taking on more casualties. That speaks to the kind of pressure your luck

component that you and David are talking about, right? like where you just kind of want that risk of like oh do I really just want to inflict a lot of damage and I don't care what the cost is because that to me feels reflective of the presence of the number of units in the space and not just a goofy ratio

and feels a little more I don't know like sensible and rational but

yeah it also tells more story and so like you know as a solo gamer right I need my game to give me a lot of story um and so having it be Oh, I rolled the dice and I get the result. Whatever. If it's like, oh man, I kept drawing from the chit cup hoping that I'd get hits, but I died instead. That is way more interesting to think about to experience

and to like, you know, it's just to me that is superior as as an experience in general.

As designers, we're setting the table. So, we're the history isn't telling the story passively.

Even as the designers, we're not telling the story. But what we're trying to do is put everything that needs to be on the table for the players to come up with their own story. Like they're going to tell a story. So the model will definitely fortell some relationships. We hope that there's some takeaways that they'll get from things um based on, you know, certain principles of maybe how supply is checked or how the battle is conducted and waged. But as a result, I think like you know that the story that has staying power for players and impact is always going to be the thing that they got from their own play,

right?

And so it's about putting all those things and arranging them on the table in a way that it's going to be memorable to them.

Yeah. I I think that that's the thing I think about with every design when I'm starting is what kinds of different stories could this design allow players to tell on their own? And if they were oriented and focusing on two totally different aspects of the same topic,

is this game situated in a place where it can tell more than one kind of stories? I think for something like um uh for something like Penitent or Fruit, it's like really situated in that. Whereas for a game like The Guys Will Have Blood, it's so tiny. Like there's just a little more rigid. It's telling one kind of story and how much flex it has is is very limited. But again, you know, when you're dealing with games that are 15 minutes versus say three and a half hours, like you got a really different, you have a a lot more room to work with, I think, with the longer game for people to eventually contort the entire model toward the story that they want to tell.

Yeah. Yeah. If it's going on that long, I hope there's a lot of meat in there.

Yeah.

So, uh, we were kind of joking in pre-hat about how you've been solo designing against your will. What is your current relationship to solo gaming?

Um, I don't really play anything solitire. Generally speaking, I think um most of my solitire has been SFM design. It's interesting you did point out one though. Serious. I love the Amabel Holland like a Gricola games and Charlmine like that. Oh yeah. Three bags of three cups of terrible, however you want to call it. That is that is marvelous. I love that system so much.

Yeah, I love

Yeah, it it's really good. Um, but I think in general part of what I'm looking at too is, you know, it just it was kind of random because I was first I was designing a game for a classroom for classroom use and to me classroom games probably can't be very competitive like with a set player count and be easily cranked out within a 40-minute class period. That's not likely to happen.

But a one a game that's made for one player and the one player happens to be a room full of shouting classes like classmates like

true that's good

that might be doable. So that's why I kind of designed that first one for solitary play because I thought that that was going to adhere to the constraints of the classroom game. But for penitent, you know, uh, games about prisons and prison architecture and penitentiies, they've been tried before. And I think that there's something an element about having that be this rollicking good time at a table that feels

icky to plenty of people and justifiably so. And I thought that making that a solitary experience would kind of give it the sense of space that it needs and also the level of consideration that that topic deserves, you know, because the continuing the through line for a lot of these games isn't just like pitiable characters, but it is or nuance, but it's like generally like when I'm designing, I'm thinking a little bit more about from the standpoint like radical empathy. like how do I get players to view this topic in a way that maybe they don't normally look at it? Um, and it's not necessarily going to change their mind, but it's also just the exposure to like a different element or facet of that topic that they might not have thought of before.

Yeah. So, I think that when you've got a series of games where maybe you're making them think about uh the average citizen in North Korea or, you know, Iranians in the you know, between 1950s and 1970s um defense contractors uh in the US Afghan war or um folks in a penitentiary, be it now

or in the 19th century. Um, those are all I mean then it kind of makes sense too. These topics all garner my interest and they don't typically garner the interest of publishers and it makes sense because it's not a American or kind of Western European lens of empowerment, you know. So it's it's the reason why you have more games that are about colonialism

and fewer games about people who are disempowered and like their position and their plight and their stories and and that's why the publishers of companies in America and like West Ram don't want to publish those games either because it's not a safe bet. It's a pretty risky bet and so that makes a little more sense as like a a limited run like something to try on more of an experimental basis.

Yeah. Well, I am gonna tell a fun anecdote now because actually don't even make me think of this. So, when I had David Turtzy on this podcast years ago now, I had originally brought him on because Prison Architects like the board game based on the video game was on Kickstarter. It was going to be crowdfunded and he was associate with the project and it got, you know, frankly rightly criticized and then pulled. Um, and I was going to interview him about it and he was like, absolutely not. And so, we talked about other stuff instead. So, um it's fun to actually talk to somebody about their prison game in a real sense on my podcast.

Yeah.

Um instead of just like have to sleep under the rug.

Yeah. I I think you ultimately have to be okay with talking about any project you were associated with at the end of the day. I if there was something that made you want to distance yourself from it in hindsight, you'd hope that that presence of mind was available somewhere earlier maybe in that project's gestation. Uh but

yeah, in his defense, it was a fresh cancellation. So,

it was pretty fresh. Yeah, I

I think I linked to that actually in one of my design diaries for penitent as a matter of fact, like that whole

um was a thing.

Was a thing. Um yeah, you know, and too like even when you think you're handling a topic responsibly and you're going through these parts of it's like it's it's fine if other people are going to basically be like push back and be like, you know what, no, I don't think that was handled very sensitively or I don't care that you're doing this with your pro proceeds from the game or doing whatever. It's just like I just don't like that you're doing this topic or I don't like them the way you're handling it. And I think as designers, we need to be like a lot less defensive of that because it's, you know, it's to taste, right? Like some projects in it. All you can do is kind of stand by what your thinking was when you're working on the project. What motivated you to do it and hope that that doesn't come off as scuzzy. And chances are if it was scuzzy, then it's going to not defend very well. It's going to be a little rough ride. Um,

yeah. I mean, that's okay. I mean, I read a lot of novels that contain plenty of objectionable stuff that just came from somebody's mind, and I feel like that's just part of art. I I think that it's more about like, well, are you doing art or are you doing a weird cash grab? And to me, that's the difference.

Yeah. Yeah. Though, I will say it is interesting when I hear criticism leveled to certain historical designers that they are doing a cash grab when I know for a fact that their project is going to make basically no money. like it doesn't make it okay that the project doesn't actually profit the designer. Um, but it doesn't it's a it's a weird it's a weird flex of like a oh well they're clearly doing this for like all all the the fame and fortune that's associated with making a heavy historical game that no one's going to play or you know even if it doesn't treat its subject matter like with the uh let's say intensity and scrutiny than it probably should or the sensitivity that maybe would be more appropriate to it. Um, and I think it's often the subject matter that we kind of take for granted because we've seen it covered so many times when someone does an exceptionally bad job. I'm looking at you, American Civil War. I think when it gets handled really poorly, like then then it really stands out because people are really blindsided like, "Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Where was the scrutiny with all these other titles?" And then you can kind of go through the receipts and stuff. I don't know.

That's

Yeah.

Fascinating. poof. Okay, I have one more real question for you before softies, which is um so you know you've been doing your podcast game design game design deep dive for some time now. Um how do you feel that your podcast informs your other work if it does?

Um you know like I I was thinking around the time of the first Zenobia how awesome of an opportunity it is for folks to be able to get mentorships from established designers and getting that kind of insight into their design process. and those kind of things. How that can inform like an aspiring designer, I think is really incredible. But that's not realistically available to a lot of people. Not just because they don't maybe align with the mission of Zenobia, but specifically just because it's an opportunity for a limited number of participants, right? And I was thinking about how much I really liked how much value I got from various resources that were um free and widespread like on the internet. And so sometimes it was a matter of like um a particular designer's like design journal like their design diaries and how I would read those very meticulously like kind of going through them and how they kind of made me consider questions because sometimes it's not about you arriving at the same answer that you know a designer that you look up to does but about the questions that they raise when they're starting their project and it's like oh I should be asking these questions too because I would hate for someone to be asking me some question that's fundamental to my design and me to have no answer. Just long quiet pause. Crickets, what did you intend to accomplish with this design?

What made you interested in this topic? You know, in what manner do you think this topic's underserved? Things like that. Like to have no answer to that would be not so great. And so, you kind of want to be bridging these things as early in your process as possible. And I think of my podcast as being the opportunity for my myself to have basically been able to been the ear of like, you know, three dozen people who do the same kind of work and get insight in those pro processes. And I'll be honest, like uh I've encountered zero people who approach design the exact same way I do or even like 90% the same way as I do. And so there's a value in all those conversations because they're all doing something um very different in the same space. So I just I think that that if that has value for me, that's definitely going to have value for aspiring designers. And I have far more people who come up to me and say, "Hey, I I love the podcast or ask me a question about a given interview or a given person that I interviewed than I have ever had talk to me about my designs." I can see that the that that is like such a positive impact like to see that that's possibly getting people to think about their first design or enter into the hobby. And it's all about just trying to throw the throw the gate wide and let more people in. I say that while I trash talk all these older, more venerated designs and subjects, but you know, I mean them both. I I do like that idea like kind of looking at the old

through a different lens and kind of welcoming the new because they are the new lens through which we're going to look at a lot of this stuff. Um Oh, yeah. But

it's it's the podcast has been great for for all of that.

Fantastic. All right, so Softy questions for you. First one, uh what games have you been playing lately that you really enjoyed or found exciting?

Oh, wow. Um let's see. I'm thinking of ones that I've gotten to the table. So, I really like Congress of Vienna. It is super long, which is the greatest impediment to getting it to the table, but uh it's it's got a lot of So, for folks who've played like Church Hill by Mark Kerman, it's similar uh to Church Hill. Um but I would say that it's uh because it's a fourplayer version of it. I mean, we're adding a little time to it. And it's been interesting because it has a definite threeon-one feel of the coalition against France, you know, during the Napoleonic era and then one player playing as Napoleon in France. Um, but the coolest thing is just the way that the war theater feed feeds back into the negotiations, excuse me, at the conference table. And I really like it.

It's something that um feels like it's not just drawing from Church Hill, but maybe even like the influence uh of something like Westfallia like by Holland where just like you want success out in the field because it's giving you something to bring back to the table and just like a lot of a lot of levers to pull in that game and it's a it's a co-mingled deck. So each power doesn't have their own deck. So I really love that. Found found that design fascinating, super fun. um constantly trying to recruit more people to play it because it's hard to get people on board for that. And um and then uh the campaign version of Arcs like the Blade Reach, I've been playing a lot. Um, and I think it's because I don't I like the idea of being able to play that as a um kind of as a non-competitive game, but more as almost like a story generating game. And watching the same factions change over the curse course of the game because of the given fates has been really interesting. And it's been a nice way to if I'm playing a war game with the same opponents for a few weeks, we'll do like a little detox one week and we'll just do a an arcs campaign and it kind of removes that fog that of, you know, too much competitive play where we can kind of beer and pretzels it and just sit back and enjoy the ride. We're trying but, you know, we're also drinking so that's nice. Uh, but yeah, those are the kind of the elements of like those two games that I really love.

Um, yeah. I don't know. Not a ton of historic titles lately because I'm just been working more on designs, but I try to play all the time.

Yeah.

Nice. And then, uh, if people want to find you online to follow your work, where do you like to be found?

Um, I'm on Blue Sky. I have no idea what my Blue Sky handle is. You can see I'm really prepared for that. That was excellent. And um I just started a website lockhornsgames.com uh for my little publishing venture. Um so Penitent is the next upcoming release and then there will likely be a another release later this year as well as a reprint of a previous title. So that'll be something to kind of keep in mind. For this first printing of Penitent, this is just going to be shipping stateside only. And then the plan is to do a second printing and that one would be Canada and overseas. I wanted to kind of get our legs underneath us and make sure we can fulfill lightning fast and have all the bugs worked out of the process before um doing that. And it's kind of nice because uh unlike doing um a a project through uh you know kind of like a like a campaign or some sort of Kickstarter or gamefound um it feels really awesome they have a project where basically the files are all ready to go. Everything is just sitting there. So the minute I hit my number I just send everything to the vendors and then they print the stuff and it's all stateates side. So it's just the minute the last shipment arrives. assembling boxes and sending them out. I mean, that's great. Uh, I'm giving us till uh May to fulfill for the project um

just to give us a nice cushion. But I know like last time I think when I did gods will have blood, it funded and then we ended up fulfilling six weeks early, four weeks early. So, I guess stateside vendors really allow you a lot of savings and time to just be able to send that stuff out. So, pretty exciting.

Fantastic. I'm excited. Um, so yeah, thank you so much, Dan, for coming on the pod. It's good to have you back on here. Um, it's always fun to chat.

Thanks for having me.

All right, everybody out there. I can be found anywhere online is Beyond Solitire. So, please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.

Progress saved