Curating My Collection (Ep. 5) | 8 Games Leaving (ft. The 2023 Board Game Buying Freeze)
Transcript
foreign hello and welcome to all you can board I am Carlo and today we are doing episode five of my series called curating my collection so it's been a little while since I've done one of these last one was I believe back in June of 2022 so about eight months ago uh now this is a series where I look at basically games that are leaving my collection for one reason or another I talk about why they're leaving my collections sort of how long they've been in there maybe comparable games that are sticking in the collection and that sort of thing um if what you're looking for is just the actual discussion about the games and why they're leaving you can use the time stamps below I will still do this similar to the way that I've done the previous videos in this series but I also did want to take some time at the beginning here it's probably going to be about half the video at the start I'm just talking about some other aspect of curating my collection I thought about doing it as its own Standalone video but figured it really belonged here because these are the videos where I'm talking about getting rid of my my games in my collection actually talking about my collection somewhat in depth so the big thing for me this year is that in 2023 I am putting a freeze on my Personal Collection so I'm doing a sort of no buy challenge for the entire year calendar year of 2023 so I'm gonna be you can use the timestamps below as well because I'm splitting these up into kind of some discussion points uh leading up to actually talking about the games I'm getting rid of again just because there's a few things that have factored in you know you're probably wondering uh why I've decided to do this what kind of like rules or guidelines or whatever that I'm imposing on myself and that sort of thing so let's get into it so first off why am I doing this is uh to mainly just get up on caught up on my list of unplayed
games that are sitting on my shelf I'm not a huge fan of the term shelf of shame because I wouldn't say I feel shame by seeing them sit there especially you know we also have to take into account the fact that there's you know the pandemic over the last few years is a big reason for not only myself I'm sure a lot of people uh to have you know have a growing collection of unplayed games obviously there's a big stretch there where it was pretty tough or near impossible to be playing anything other than online or whatnot anyways this video isn't to get into uh you know gaming related to the pandemic necessarily but not only with that but the fact that we started a YouTube channel you know a few years ago so you know we're buying games but we're also getting in review copies from Publishers or things that one of us might have backed on Kickstarter or we're meeting up with someone who has some new game that they want to play so part of this is that we're not you know I'm not getting too my unplayed games that I've bought some of which have been sitting there for two three years some even more um I'm also not getting to revisit my favorite games anymore so you know I started um gaming like the sort of hobby gaming aspect was probably about 15 years ago or so for me and for those first five to seven years five to eight years or so I played pretty much the same five or ten games like exclusively it was you know cars carcasson Katan Agricola pandemic Ticket to Ride Seven Wonders Alhambra Like Love Letter maybe a couple of small world maybe one or two other games like I basically played those same games for like a decade almost but played a lot of those 50 100 plus times a kingdom build is another one but then I got to a point where I
started asking myself like what else is out there I would try one new game and think oh this game's been out for four years how come I haven't tried this I started realizing yeah I have my favorites so maybe I can kind of put those on hold for a bit and start kind of exploring or going to more of a discovery phase in this Hobby and see what else is out there because I don't want to find out in 20 years that there's some game that's been out released for my whole life that I just spent all these years not playing so let's spend some time discovering and then so I've kind of switched from depth to breadth to expand you know my range of games I've played over the past few years um but I keep looking back at my shelf and realizing it's not only the unplayed games but my favorites I don't get to revisit and I kind of want to get back to that I want to get back to playing certain games over and over and over and getting deeper into specific games and you know getting into the nitty-gritty not only for my own personal enjoyment but also for Content that we might want to do for the channel you know some of these games that I've played hundreds of times whatever Agricola race for the Galaxy carcasson I might start doing some you know videos that focus more specifically on those games and whatnot so it's all just part of a play the games you love more or the games you haven't tried yet more rather than just like you know keeping up with what we feel is important for the channel or to be able to this leads into the next point I'll say right now is this kind of ties into like fomo like theory of missing out for anyone who doesn't know what it stands for um and hype and all that but I think I'm pretty good at resisting like the film or hype of of a game in terms of like you need to buy it right this second or own it forever and for me I've spoken about this in previous episodes about how a lot of the games I buy I buy knowing in advance that it's sort of a
rental like hey I know enough about this game to know it's not going to be something that lives in my collection forever but I really want to try it out and I don't know anyone else who has the game and I know it's popular enough that I could probably play it for a few months or whatever and then get rid of it and maybe I lose 10 or 15 bucks and I think of that as a rental fee and whatnot um but even then you know you're you're buying a lot of games that you think well this might not even live in my collection long term so I kind of felt this feeling of like well I have to be in on the discussion as a content creator I have to be aware of these games like these popular games that everyone's talking about like I would kind of feel this self-imposed pressure of like what kind of content creator would I be if I don't have an opinion on this game or on this game but again like that's I don't want that to also in fact my enjoyment of the hobby so again a lot of this just comes back to you know focusing on what I want from the Hobby and what I want to get out of it um and tailoring sort of my time spent in the hobby a little bit more to that rather than thinking too much about you know oh because of we have a YouTube channel or because if someone asks about this game I want to have an opinion on so I have to go buy it to be able to play it once or twice I just don't want to have that feeling for at least for a little while and the other thing is just the way that I buy games is I'm constantly like I'm subscribed to a couple of different online uh retailers I get updates of when new games come into stock or certain items that are on my wish list get restocked I'm keeping track of sales I track kind of like uh Trends with prices for certain games so if I see a game where it's the cheapest I've ever seen it before even if I know I'm not going to play it within the next year if
I think hey this game is either going to go out of print or this is the best price I've ever seen it even though it's going to sit on my shelf for two years I'll buy it now because I'd be a fool to wait two years and then pay double or then I can't get the game anymore so um but what that means so even though I've you know I think I've done a great job over the past however many years in terms of the money I've spent I look back on certain games and go yep I've never seen that game for as cheap ever again I'm really glad I got that when I did or I have all these games now that are out of print that I got a copy because I suspected it'd be hard to find and that's that's fine I'm happy that I did that now but my collection is now at a point where I'm pretty happy with where it is and I just want to dig into it and then start culling games from there so now I'm going to move on to some some stats about my collection just to keep you guys informed here so uh as of January 1st or 2023 or as of when I'm filming this video either way this is in February now my total number of games in my own personal collection was 191 that was by my own count this includes pre-orders I pre-ordered a few games uh they were paid for in January or sorry before January they just haven't arrived yet some of them are going to be arriving very early in the year but there were just certain titles that I didn't want to arbitrarily kind of hold myself off from getting just because of this restriction that I'm placing on myself again the whole point isn't that I anyways we need to get into the the nitty-gritty of that but I've got raw atiwa Iranian Burger canal findorff and Caesar's Empire are the five games that aren't actually in my Personal Collection yet but they're I own them because I've paid for them and also just for anybody was watching she's not familiar with the channel uh we're filming this in Dylan's condo since my
cousin who went over on the Channel with so none of the games you see behind me none of these are are mine um so don't don't be looking trying to guess what I'm gonna be getting rid of because these don't belong to me so as of January 1st 2023 I had 70 unplayed games out of 191. so you do the math it's a bit over a bit over a third obviously um so meaning that if I were to look at it basically I'm trying to set up goals for the year how am I going to get through I want to try and play all of my unplayed games this year uh it's pretty ambitious I know it's maybe not entirely realistic I might be left with some at the end but I'm trying to map out kind of when in the year I think I'm going to be playing certain games and trying to really really make a priority to read these Rule books uh and and make sure that these get played as much as possible so if I was going to stick to that it would average out to 5.8333 uh games per month so just under six new games per month and I will say January was a very successful month I played eight new games off the shelf so I played Planet unknown The Guild of merchant explorers first rat dice Realms La Havre dungeons dice in danger wormholes and heat pedal to the metal so I've got 62 games left and as of now it's February 4th when we're filming this so I've got 11 months left to get through 62 games um just quickly I'll mention some of the ones first off here are some of the unplayed ones that have been here the longest so these are games that I've had at least two or three years and just for whatever reason haven't gone to the table uh Car Wars the crypto flotilla Admirals rossio rap gods scapegoat Legacy of dragon hold Obsession In the Hall of the Mountain King there's just
10. I think those are the oldest ones I've had I don't want to be touching on each one in detail or anything like that but the ones that I'm most eager to play that I want to share because and the reason I bring these up is because these are some that you can maybe expect to see on the channel if we don't get around to covering them this year some of these might fall into the next year just because you know we want to get a sufficient number of plays as well it's not just play it once and talk about it on the channel but the ones that I'm most eager to try that I've not yet are fields of RL heaven and Ale barrage the Transcontinental crisis the siege of rundar Taj Mahal through the desert to crypto Caper Europe the king is dead Brian boru guards of Atlantis 2 El Grande Great Western Trail Argentina the king's dilemma paint the Roses Legacy of dragon Holt flotilla Obsession Scout Concordia fresh fish Free Ride Legacy Gears of time Village or at labora Ricochet robots Kayla 1303 In the Hall of the Mountain King there's there's plenty of others but those those are the ones that have been at the top of my list obviously that's a lot of games uh to sort of be at the top of the list but um so my my goals for the year and kind of rules now is what I want to talk about so not only do I want to play through every single unplayed game if possible but I'm hoping to play through them at least twice if possible that's not a it's not a requirement but um and it depends on the game anything else basically I'm going to be trying to get rid of a bunch of games throughout the year and size down my collection too um I'm not allowed and this I've never done this before I've never gotten rid of a game without having played it and
the reason for that is that I kind of it's honoring almost my past self like if I thought at one point that this game was worth buying I would be doing a disservice to my myself from whatever a year ago two years ago by saying no they had it you know Carlo in 2011 had it all or 2021 or whatever had it all wrong like I'm not gonna like this game why did I think I would back then um not to say that you shouldn't get rid of games you haven't played them because if you're not going to play them you shouldn't feel forced or required but I genuinely do want to try all these games so I am going to make a point to play them all some of them I might play once and know right away I'm just going to move on from but either way I will not allow myself to Cull anything that I've not played at least once so I've set goals in sort of three ranges uh one is the very bare minimum so let's say worst case scenario let's say this was the year of my life where I did the least gaming let's add family emergencies come up and all this kind of stuff and I just didn't have much time for gaming still a bare minimum I should be able to get my collection below 150 games and again I'm at 191 so easy it should be easy to get rid of you know I guess 42 games to get below 150. so that's the bare minimum no matter what and this number of 191 is before the eight that I or that I'm talking about getting rid of today so after this I guess I'll be down to 183.
um the next goal which is my main goal and the kind of realistic one this is kind of the one that I'm really going for is I kind of floated between 120 and 125 and the reason part of it is that like a while ago I kind of decided that if I was going to go over 100 games that 120s kind of 125 is really I didn't want to really go over that amount and the other thing is just that I think that ends up being about a third I guess right if I'm not mistaken yeah it's about a third of the games if I cut below 125 I've got rid of 60 some games or whatnot so um I think that's a pretty reasonable goal and I think uh yeah I think I'll be able to meet that but who knows it's on camera now and if I don't uh you can give me a hard time about it at the end of the year I'm going to do a couple more of these videos throughout the year so and then my ambitious goal which I realize it fully is very ambitious I don't know if I'll be able to do this would be to get it under a hundred so into double digits so um that would be basically cutting my collection in half which that is incredibly ambitious I don't like again I really don't think that's gonna happen but I sometimes take time off work in the summer and whatnot so I might have some extra time on my hands and a lot of this is going to come down to um I got to sort of make a uh what's it called like almost like a request a plead for action or plead for help to some of my friends and people in my game group that like this is going to be the year where I'm gonna be showing you a lot of new games and that's going to be my priority is like trying to get as many of these games played so that in the future we can all you know play again more of these uh the games that we love and not having to just like yeah again I don't want to be adding new games to my shelf play what's there see what's there before kind of venturing
back into that Discovery phase again so it feels nice already to have kind of unplugged from the whole uh looking at gamesmark oh look at which games on sale whatever it's just like no I just anytime doing some of the games it's either reading rule books playing games what not I don't have to worry about what's coming out we're still going to keep track and I should just add a quick caveat that uh this doesn't apply to Dylan and Braden they're going to still be buying games for their personal Collections and we'll still be buying games uh with our you know Collective money from our either whether it's YouTube revenue or patreon funds there are certain games we're still going to buy that we want to cover on the channel those just won't end up in my collection as games that I'm going to own or we're going to get games still sent to us like review copies so we are still going to have newer games on the channel and that sort of thing this is just a personal thing with my own collection of games that I own myself so um I think that's pretty much it um if at the end of the year I will say if at the end of the year I still have any unplayed games like even if it's one or two or seven or whatever if I have any unplayed games left or I haven't met my culling goals like let's say I still have 165 games left or whatever then January 1st of 2024 this continues this is this continues at least until I've played all the unplayed games and at least met the goal of 150 but ideally below that 120 or 125 Mark so I'm going to hold myself to that and basically throughout the year I'm gonna try and do one of these curating my collection videos every probably every two or three months would be my guess you'll probably see another three four five of these uh throughout the year um and in those I'll be obviously talking about not only which games I've gotten rid of but I can just update you on the numbers how many are left how's my progress going am I on Pace or not so
so far obviously I'm more than on Pace because I played eight new games last month which is over the average of six that I need so yeah I'm feeling good about that but otherwise I think I'll leave it at that for now in terms of uh you know what my sort of collection goals are for the year I'm curious to hear you know if any of you are doing something similar I actually I started thinking about this back in September I think it was and I started buying a bunch of new games to kind of stock up ones from especially 2022 that I knew I wanted to cover on the channel and whatnot and I feel like I've seen either in our Discord Channel or YouTube comments some people have said oh I'm gonna stop buying games for a while so I feel like maybe there's a common sentiment among some Gamers I don't know if it's the fact that people are tired of buying a lot of games and then getting rid of a lot of games or realizing oh maybe I didn't need that one it would have been good enough to try and I think just in general as a hobby if we're all buying fewer games and playing our favorites more and everything it's just going to improve the quality of the Hobby and the quality of games because if Publishers are selling fewer quantities of their you know lesser good games maybe instead of making six games a year they release two or three per year instead but they polish those more and so maybe we get fewer games but the quality of those games is all better instead of companies saying well you know if one game doesn't land we will release five more to see if one of those lands and it feels like a lot of these Publishers there's two directions you see some of those Publishers that publish tons of games in a year and they all feel or a lot of them feel like they're underdeveloped and then you see the opposite end of like a publisher just as one example something like days of wonder which has kind of gone back to publishing like one or two games per year and you see the kind of reception of game like heat pedal to the metal is getting right now because of how much care and attention
has clearly gone into one specific game and I feel like overall if we can move more towards that it's better for everyone and we have a YouTube channel and we don't want to come across as that we're just always telling people to go buy the brand new games so uh yeah anyways I'll leave it at that now let's talk about the eight games I'm getting rid of some of these I'm going to be running through pretty quickly because some of them I've covered on the channel in some type of a view format fairly recently and others I haven't so some of them will spend a little more time on than others but otherwise let's get right into it with uh let's start with the smallest box here that is a gentle rain so this is a little what does it say exactly contemplative uh or contemplative I always forget if if there's one correct way to pronounce we're both acceptable uh Solo or cooperative game to clear your mind so this is designed by Kevin Wilson uh I took a chance on this a couple years ago uh or maybe a year and a half ago or so just because you know I was doing a decent amount of solo gaming and it seemed like something that I could either Again Play On My Own It says it's Cooperative something I thought oh maybe I can play with my wife sometimes very simple little tiling game and I had seen it described by some people as almost more of an activity than a game which I I don't really like that I don't want to get too into the nitty-gritty of what uh distinguishes an activity from a game and win conditions and all that kind of stuff um I do think that's a bit unfair though because it definitely is a game there's you know there's a set of rules you can there's keeps track of your points you can do well or do poorly and that kind of stuff but it's basically just you Shuffle up these tiles and they have uh different colors of flower petals on different sides of them and you're flipping over a tile and trying to line up with other uh similar sides to match
them up and if you're matching up uh tiles of these flowers you get these little blossom tokens that go on the board that kind of represent that you've met a goal and you're basically just flipping through this deck it's very much supposed to be yeah like a meditative calming kind of again clear your mind type of game and that's I think the presentation the the art like the artwork the simple rules like these are the rules it says take a deep breath and relax and there's basically just that and then a little thing on the back here like it's it's super simple anyone you can give this to someone who's never played a game in their life and they can figure this out in a couple minutes and just play it as a little activity takes about 15-20 minutes maybe even 10 minutes so I my time with it was fine it was it was all right um and I think for what it's trying to do it it succeeds very well and I think there's some people who are going to love this sort of thing there's some people who if you have like a really stressful job um and you like games and you sometimes find yourself with these 10 or 15 minutes and you like something that you can just do either in silence or maybe with like a podcast playing or something like that or listening to music um you can I feel like this is something that a lot of people would enjoy and I still I've enjoyed it for me though it's there's not enough game or enough after playing you know three or four times I enjoyed it each of those times but if I'm sitting around at home or even if I'm traveling somewhere and I'm taking solo game like if I'm traveling I'm gonna bring sprawlopolis instead it's just a more rewarding more engaging uh more replayable game and it also fits in your wallet like it's smaller and then if I want like it just I don't know when
I personally would play this like if I'm at home and I want something that's this um mindless that has this few kind of decisions to make I'm probably just going to do something different instead like read a book or maybe I'll play a video game or like go do something outside but if I'm gonna sit down and play a solo game I usually just want something more than this so again totally does what it's set out to do fine um and if you're looking for that type of relaxing game or maybe a gift for someone who doesn't play a lot of games we want something like this uh this could definitely be a good choice but I'll be moving on from that um that is a gentle rate okay next up we've got uh let's talk about castle party so this is a two to four player uh flip and write game that I covered uh recently in an own it play it or skip it uh video actually our most recent one from just I think a couple weeks ago so you can go or by the time you see this video it might be a few weeks before that but uh either way you can go check that out if you want to find out my full thoughts I did say that video was a skip it uh the reason being that there are a lot of sort of roll and write or flip and write games out there and as it is it's not my favorite genre um I like having a few in my collection I play them once in a while especially with my wife or like there's a couple of other friends of mine who we play some rolling rights sometimes uh you know you go to the cabin or a lazy weekend kind of thing like I do like to play them once in a while but I don't need you know upwards of like 10 in my collection and as it is I think I'm pretty close to that you know I have welcome to like the original and I have Welcome To The Moon I've got you know the Isle of cats explore and draw which I've even tried yet I've got uh that's pretty clever which I really really like
um which other ones am I forgetting there's uh whatever there's I feel like there's at least one or two others there that I just already know I like more and after playing this a few times it's it's fine it's decent but the fact that it is kind of encouraging you to be mean and keep track of what's going on your opponent's sheets because you're taking turns around the table playing cards that together the shapes of the cards get put together to make a shape and then that shape is going to be the shape that everyone has to place on their sheets so you're all collectively having some small amounts of control over what everyone else is going to be taking but it ends up not really amounting to much in terms of like for what that requires of you to watch your opponents and plan and play a card it might not even work out the way you did and even if it did it's not really satisfying to be just watching other people's sheets when you're just doing like at least for me like a rolling writer flipping right game it kind of gives you I mentioned in the review it kind of does a similar thing that cartographers did but cartographers you at least give the sheet to someone else and let them just kind of write on it rather than me having to look at other players sheets across the table and then look at my cards and my sheet and then look at theirs and like it just slows the game down too much for what should be a quick playing game but it's a real shame because I feel like if they had just taken that aspect of the game out if they just there was some other way either random deck of cards that just determines the shape that everyone places or if it was done in a quicker or more just efficient way or a cleaner way that didn't slow the game down or muddy it into being like trying to give this
uh like added level of player interaction that I don't think it needed like I think I would have enjoyed the game more without that but there's an even a way to house rule that because you have to use these cards to create the shape you can't just say oh I use these other cards it's not like a tiny town where they give you the cave variant or that deck of cards you can flip and say oh we'll just see what we generate every round oh there's a brick there's a wheat this doesn't even have that option so if you really like Roland rights and flipping rights a lot it's definitely worth at least trying um but I just don't know yeah again there's there's too many others that I think are just better but it does at least a couple novel things that I do think are interesting and worth seeing if you like this type of thing so uh yeah that is Castle party from Divya games next up we are going to talk about let's do Abandon All artichokes so this one I also talked about in an own it play skip-it video actually the same one as Castle party and this is one I felt a little more torn on um I when I initially bought the game I was pretty confident same with Castle party and a gentle rain I should say going back to what I mentioned earlier in the video all these games I bought knowing hey I'd like to try these I'd like to probably cover them on the channel at some point but I don't think these will stay in my collection forever and surely enough I was right I did expect Abandon All artichokes to last longer and the reason why it's leaving and I mentioned this and you want to play it skip it video and I did call it a play it to be fair it's ahead of a skipper for Castle party because there's a lot of sorry maybe a lot but there's there are a few things in here that are very interesting and are very different from the way other games are done because it's sort of deck building but it's really deck destruction where every player starts with a deck of these 10 artichoke cards they're useless they don't have abilities only they don't do anything
um and the way you win the game is at the end of your turn when you're finished playing and discarding cards you draw back up to five cards first player to end their turn by drawing five cards and not having a single artichoke in their hand wins the game it's the only way you can win um and so you're basically you can either add a whole bunch of Cards into your deck so that the kind of artichokes get drowned out or outnumbered a lot you can try and remove a lot of them from your deck so you have a very thinned out efficient deck and maybe you're hoping to draw you know there's and you're basically drawing these vegetable cards that have abilities on them to either swap cards or remove artichokes from your hand or take something from a discard pile or put something on top of your deck there's just little ways to manipulate the game State you're gaining a new card from the market roll every turn and you're kind of just going around the table doing this I think it works it definitely works better with more players like ideally with four players still pretty good with three with two it felt a bit flat for me because of all the cards that come into play where it says pick an opponent or you and someone do this or you and an opponent do this and then it's two players you're just it's always the same person and just generally speaking these types of games usually are better with multiple players around the table rather than just like when it's like a small box uh the car you know game that has a decent amount of luck and this kind of like cutesy artwork like every reminds me a lot of sushi go actually and it is from game right it's the same company it's also a package in a tin it's a card game or whatever Sushi goes obviously Drafting and set collection whereas this is deck destruction so very different in that sense but I think the reason why I'm moving on from this is that I thought that the way this would potentially live on in my collection would be if I played it with like younger people or people who were
more casual gamers and they really liked it and so far every time I've shown it to either uh you know friends or family who are maybe not as into gaming as I am they've enjoyed it somewhat but they haven't loved it there's been other games that have hit a lot harder and no one has ever kind of requested for this to come back to the table um and then I also showed it to my nephews a couple months back and one of them was nine I believe and the other one is I think 13. and they kind of enjoyed it but again we played many other games and they seem to enjoy a lot of the other games we played over the weekend more and I think part of it was there's a lot of text on the cards too and they didn't want to sit there reading and and whatnot so I don't know it's a tough game for me to talk about because uh it first off it's a first time designer Emma Larkins I admire a lot of the ideas that went into the game I think almost everyone out there should at least give this game a try even if you can't find a physical copy give it a shot on board game arena because a lot of people I think would buy this and happily have a place for in your collection if you have kids um or you play with people who again don't maybe play as many games like I can see a lot of people really liking this I personally will never turn down a game of it I just know that the only times it's been played with the physical version in the past two plus years that I've had it has been when I've been the one to push for it and there's no point on me having a game in my collection that's not one of my favorite card games um it's still very good but there's just too many ahead of it for me if I'm going to be the one having to get it to the table and then still maybe looking up going I kind of wish we were playing like Bonanza instead or for sale or Arboretum or whatever the card game might be so great game worth checking out but I will be moving on from Abandon All artichokes
okay next up we are talking about this is actually one of the name no not super old games in my collection it's not like one of the first five or ten that I owned but probably one of the first 15 or 20 games I bought I've had this one for a good I don't know seven eight years or so at least maybe more that is hero Realms when I say seven or eight years 2016. seven years yeah I think I got it right when it came out because I've been playing there was originally Star Realms um white wizard games has now changed to wise wizard games they've rebranded since um but yeah there were Star Realms which is obviously the Sci-Fi space themed one and then they came out with hero Realms I got this right away I much prefer the kind of fantasy setting and just the idea of having uh Champions or or creatures or whatever I think they're called Champions rather than bases in space but this is a very simple straightforward quick playing deck building game it's technically two to four players but I will say right now I would I never really enjoyed playing it with three or four I tried it a couple times and to me I just put it on my shelf with the two player only games because I didn't want someone to say hey that plays three players let me try that it ends up being with three players it it's either or or four even is that because all you're doing is you're like you're getting cards putting into your deck but you're each sort of 50 life and you're trying to deplete all of your opponent's life so first like last person standing wins basically so in a three or four player game if someone gets to zero they're just eliminated and they have to be out of the game and watch while the other players play but if you're playing to win which again you should be then technically if you have an opportunity your opponent one of your opponents is at like seven life and you have an opportunity to maybe get them out of the game that's probably the
better play than trying to attack your opponent who's at 50 because the opponent at 7 might spend turns healing or getting defenses up and now they might get back into the game so when they're weak you want to kind of knock them out of there but I don't play small you know 30 minute whatever deck building games to play like with player elimination like I don't want I don't want to be eliminated from a game like that and then be sitting watching my friends battle it out and I don't want other people sitting watching other people battle out but then the only way to avoid that is we try to house rule once playing with three or four words you always have to attack the player with the height or your opponent that has the highest health left but that game took well over an hour because again everyone kept healing and getting defenses up and you're always only attacking the strong players so to me it just doesn't work with three or four players uh keep in mind there's tons of expansions and there's like a campaign mode and all this so I haven't tried any of that stuff out so it could be that the game works better with more but otherwise it's strictly a two-player game for me and I've just found that I haven't played it in a few years now I do like the game quite a bit but I'll say right now my wife doesn't like playing the game because she likes two-player games she likes getting the player interaction all that but there's something about the fact that you're just basically trying to like murder each other like it's all like knives instead was like daggers you just stab your opponent and kill each other whatever something kind of off-putting to my wife while playing that which I I don't I don't hold that against her um and either way like it's not one of my favorite games anymore like I used to love playing this all the time but there's just too many deck builders that I prefer playing too many small box card games that I prefer playing um and the big reason normally I would be keeping this but two uh at least two of my brothers-in-law maybe even someone else in my family basically I know two people at least very close to me who
both own Star Realms one of them actually has the or no one of them has hero Realms with a bunch of expansions the otherness the Star Realms like deluxe box so I don't need to own hero Realms here and just having it on my shelf people asking about it and whatnot so it's a great game and it still holds up well and if you're looking to introduce other people into deck building games and you need a starting point before getting something more complex or you have play The Deck Builder and you want to start this is pretty much the ideal starting point is like something like this Star Realms or Ascension is probably going to be your best first deck building game to play so yeah that is hero realm solid game and I would still I'll probably I still have the app I'll probably play the app a bunch and stuff it's a great game just physical version It's competing with too many other games in terms of I'm gonna sit down and play a two-player card battling game there's just too many other ones that are more likely to get to the table ahead of it next up we've got It's a Wonderful World so this is another one this was actually three for three from that same uh on it player skip it video this was another play it and I along with um vanilla artichokes this is of the three that were in that video Castle party Amanda Laura chokes in this this is definitely the best uh game of the three well yeah I would say it's definitely the best on the one I've enjoyed most it's a one to five player drafting game it's got some set collection I guess um depending how you look at it but basic idea is it plays over four rounds your your Delta head of cards pick one pass the rest of your opponent pick one pass the rest your opponent Etc you do that until you've drafted your whole hand of cards but unlike in most drafting games like in sushi go or seven wonders where the cards just automatically get played in front of you in this game at the end of the drafting
phase every player has a I believe it's called the construction phase where you're deciding which of these cards are you actually going to try to build because you need uh resources of different types or which ones am I going to recycle so to basically get a resource to use for the cards that I'm building instead so let's say you finish your draft and you've got seven cards you might put four in your construction zone basically meaning you can't use the abilities yet you're not getting any rewards from them but they're under construction to be you know built throughout the game and then you might recycle your other three cards and take those resources and maybe put them on these ones um and then there's like a production phase at the end of the round where based on which cards you have and you're starting um Empire card you'll produce resources that'll again help you get more cards and stuff throughout the game so and that's usually the most interesting decision is usually in that construction part where you're trying to decide what to do with those seven cards because you have your starting card that maybe tells you you get maybe it tells you you get two points at the end of the game for every blue card you've built or that you get a certain number of points for every one of these tokens these uh what are they called uh it's not commanders bureaucrats something I'm forgetting the word now but there's these tokens you can get that are bonus tokens throughout the game uh that correspond to you know you usually get these when you've produced the most of a resource in a round or certain cards give them as well so you're usually playing to your starting Empire ability um and I mentioned this and I won't talk about it too much more because I went pretty in-depth in the owner play skip-it video but ultimately what it came down to is I enjoyed my first like five six plays quite a bit um but I could tell from the first few
that the game didn't have quite enough it was a little too cleaned up a little too streamlined it felt like all the edges were kind of sanded off and it felt like it was very pleasant and satisfying the actual engine building part and that decision again of which cards to keep or which to recycle that's the best part of the game that's the key core of the game but the later the game goes on and you have your strategy established the less interesting the decisions got to me because if I now have you know three cards on the one card on the board says you get three points for every blue card this one's two points for your blue card this one's 1.4 blue card and I already have a few blue cards well obviously for the last round I'm just going to try and take as many blue cards as I can as long as I can complete them so I might have the last seven turns of pick a card and pass might be pretty automatic like why would I take this green card that I can't build and that does nothing for my strategy of course sometimes you might have to think if my opponent takes it they could get more points but again when you're playing a game with multiple players am I gonna hate draft one player if I have three other opponents no so the higher the player count the less important the hate drafting becomes or less of an impact it can have on the game too so it just felt like at every player count I played it at it felt like it was it was missing something it just felt a little came up just a little bit short so the fact that it's on board game Marina I'll be happy to Play It Again sort of any day and he wants to try it it's a very quick playing game easy to teach easy to pick up and it's one that I think there are a lot of people out there will get enjoyment from playing this a good five to ten times I just don't think it has a lot of legs long term but I will say there is at least
one expansion I think just one so far and a few people have told me that you know the expansion might have changed my opinion or that that does kind of really step the game up so if you liked the system and you kind of wanted more out of it it might be worth checking out the expansion and again it is a great game and especially if you're just looking to see what else is out there for drafting games um and sort of engine building it is satisfying to see that progression it plays very quickly it's just yeah there's only so much enjoyment you can get out of a game like this I think sort of five to ten plays so that is It's a Wonderful World which will be leaving my collection okay we've got three more here so we'll start off with uh undaunted North Africa so this is co-designed by David Thompson and Trevor Benjamin published by Osprey games this is another one that I covered in a previous maybe four or five months ago owner played or skip it video and this was I think I said play it for this one sort of on the higher end it was almost in to own it but for me and I think for a lot of people this is going to be an onit game and there's a there's a few I was very close to keeping this I I might end up regretting getting rid of it but I don't think so there's started with undaunted Normandy then there's North Africa and then just this past year they released undaunted Stalingrad which is like a massive boxing it's like 140 or something uh I think it expands the player count includes different rules there's more scenarios campaign like there's all kinds of stuff in that one and if I am ever going to get back into the series Stalingrad would be the version that I would go for I mean pending in the other I think they're also doing what was it undaunted it was a Battle of Britain or am I thinking of a different game
in the skies fighting up in the air maybe not even think of a different game anyways basically it's a two-player only deck building war game and and it's played asymmetrically in in North Africa it's the Italians versus the uh what is it called the the something desert forces and basically you'll pick a scenario there's I think 11 scenarios in the Box it'll tell you these tiles to take out set up a map and then you're going to have an objective sometimes the objectives could be just either like kill all your enemies or it could be you know uh uh demolish these important sites with your demolition team or you know drive your vehicle to this other site somewhere or whatever there's different objectives that can come into play and you either win by again either defeating your opponents uh like Army entirely killing off all their units or by achieving your objectives so the scenarios are different you see different units like your I guess Battalion depending on the scenario you'll have different units available sometimes you only have two or three different units you can use the cards represent the soldiers but you have let's say you have a machine gunner or a Rifleman you're going to have let's say five Rifleman cards in there that corresponds to basically saying that your Rifleman can take five gunshots kind of thing it's not that you have five rifling you're gonna have one Rifleman figure on the map but every time that they take a shot they get like your opponent successfully hits them with an attack you're gonna remove one of those cards either from your hand or your discard pile or your deck and basically once you've removed all of those let's say you get down to your last Rifleman card you're searching through your deck and someone then you take that last one out that means that unit is dead and then you'll remove it
from the map so you're and you're adding more of these cards or removing them from your deck to basically like if I want to get The Rifleman cards to come up more so that I have more turns to play Rifleman cards and use that unit more and move them around take advantage of their abilities versus maybe I let my demolitionist sit and I only have one or two cards in my deck or maybe I'm buying a new ability or a new type of Battalion unit that can go in there that can help me in some other way um this game introduced Vehicles there's all kinds of interesting stuff I really enjoyed my time with this game and as a deck builder it does a lot of cool stuff that I haven't seen in other games um there's even just the thing with the fog of War cards that you can um uh with your Scouts that puts fog of War into your opponent's deck so it's sort of the equivalent of like throwing off a smoke screen or like a smoke bomb or smoke grenade and they can't see you so it's like muddying up your opponent's deck there's just a lot of cool stuff I like that the dice rolling is very minimal it's just sort of down to combat you figure out quickly what what do I need to beat that or to hit that unit but also I think it's anytime you roll a zero it's automatically a hit uh and so you can take these risks you can be on the back foot and you can say well I'm at range I'm not gonna get I'm gonna have to hit a really high dice value but it's really my only shot and sometimes it pays off and it kind of simulates that real world feeling like war is unpredictable nothing is certain you know just because you're looking down the barrel of a gun and your Crosshair lines up doesn't mean when you pull that trigger you're for sure going to hit that person right take into account the wind and how far away are they is the bullet gonna dip like these things feel like they come into play and I've never
been a person to be a fan of War games in the past but I've really enjoyed playing this the reason it's leaving my collection is that with each new person I teach the game to there's a bit of that learning curve and we start on the first scenario we learn the game and we usually don't end up playing more than us maybe a second round we've played I've shown this to now three or four people and I think we've played the first scenario or two with a few of them and one person we played three scenarios or four scenarios but it's been like over six months now and it's just one of those things this goes back to when I talked about why I got rid of unmatched Cobble and fog in one of my earlier creating my collection videos a lot of these two-player head-to-head games are ones that you really want to play over and over with the same person and really dig into and and have this be kind of a regular game and that you know unmatched this and the games I'm going to talk about in a moment almost fall into an unfortunate spot for me where I'm just not gonna play it enough um I'm gonna go wild without playing I'm gonna forget some of the rules even setting up the snares the tiles can sometimes take a while I would love to play through the campaign of this with someone but again I just don't think it's gonna happen anytime soon so trying to be realistic about it excellent game of all the games I'm talking about in this video this is probably the best one and the one I would most highly recommend um even if you don't like War Games you just really like deck building you have to give this a shot and see what it does different from a deck building standpoint because even as someone who didn't like war games or doesn't normally uh I'm really happy I got to play this and if someone else buys it from me someone in my friend group whatever I'll hand it off to someone I would happily play this with anyone any day awesome awesome game on daunted
North Africa and the last two here this is just going to be a two-parter I'm just going to put them both on screen at the same time if you follow the channel you will know that I did a standalone video reviewing both these games very recently and that is of course Imperium Classics and Imperium Legends and this is another unfortunately uh one from Osprey games these ones in fact however are co-designed by Nigel bucket wow pardon me Nigel buckle and David turtsy um I guess the Osprey uh two player game model maybe just isn't for me and where I'm at in my life currently as as a gamer and the fact that I I co-run a YouTube channel right like we're playing a lot of games some of these games like undaunted like this I might not have the time to dive into as much as I wanted you know games like undaunted games like this games like unmatched which I just mentioned are games that if I only had a collection of like 10 games or 15 games or something like that or I went to live in another country for a year and I was only going to bring a few games like those games would be at the top of my list of games to bring and dive into with the same person for your like what you get in this box is an incredible amount of value both like in terms of the money you're spending what you're getting but also the replay value how much time and enjoyment you're going to get out of these types of games so these systems what Osprey is doing is they're giving you something that basically says I don't need to own other games as long as I have this and maybe a couple others I can get so much out of this but if you're not playing those games enough you they're basically not worth having so I won't get too into the Nitty Gritty because I did a very in-depth
review of these games but as I mentioned in the review basically I I just there's too much overhead there's too much managing things it's too much there's too many things that are even after getting familiar with the game and starting to internalize all the rules and even after I feel like I've gotten over the hump it feels like now there's a new Humper it feels like I'm still not playing it as efficiently as I'd like or as quickly and even if I were to get quicker and more efficient just the design of the game feels like it is a longer game than I would like for what is mostly a heads down deck building game that even if you were to play it above the solo player count doesn't really have a lot of player interaction and so a long set up long teardown takes a minimum probably hour and a half to two hours including the setup to play um it's just a bit of a tough sell to live in my collection if it's not something I'm going to play very often because every if I go two three months without playing it which I've done already since I bought it uh I'll forget some of the rules and then that kind of barrier is just is it's it's too much of a barrier for me to want to get back into it'd be different if this was a game that I thought maybe this would be a top 10 game of all time maybe it's worth it I love the game and if if I could just get rid of all the other uh things that kind of bog it down I could maybe see it being a top 50 game for me or probably top 40 50 somewhere in there but it's never going to be like even if you've got rid of all things I don't like the best parts about it would still not be a top 10 or 20 game for me so ultimately it's just not worth the amount of time it takes but um yeah civilization deck building games some of the most ambitious like one of
the most ambitious projects I've seen someone tackle if you are the type of person who doesn't you know have a lot of games in your collection or you want something to really dive into you have it maybe a dedicated game room where you can keep something set up and just swap out decks and play different matchup and you want to do that for like weeks or months at a time then you really can't go wrong with these games as long as you're ready to put in the kind of work necessary to sort of get over the hump um yeah fantastic games and I might end up one day getting Imperium Horizons which is the new one that's coming out later this year or as I said in my review if they made a digital version I would buy that in a second and I would play so much of that but just in terms of the physical copies I just I just can't do it that is Imperium Classics and legends and again uh if you want to know more about those go check out my uh in-depth review I did about that fairly recently so that's it those are eight games I'm getting rid of that is it for now I've got plenty of others that I'm on the cusp of I'm sure I'll have hopefully another eight or ten at least by the next video hoping to do another one of these probably by April or May kind of range but let me know what you think I'm curious to hear your thoughts first off about the first part of the video as well my sort of no buy challenge for the year um have you considered doing something else uh either for this year have you done something in the past how did it work out like I'm curious I'm curious to hear let me know what your thoughts are or experiences if you've done a similar thing um counting on you guys for the support too you know uh again we will still be featuring all kinds of new games on the channel and stuff but um I think you're also going to see some positive effects of this in terms of some of the content that's kind of going to come from us playing a lot of games more or games
that have sat on our Shelf that we've just kind of overlooked over the past couple years that are very high profile games so if there are also any of the ones I mentioned uh earlier in the video that you would like to see kind of priority in terms of us covering in the channel let me know and I'll try and make those priority in terms of what to play first but otherwise thank you so much especially if you start the whole video but regardless of what you watch thank you so much for watching as always and we'll see you next time