Skip to main content
Loading video...

Retro Reviews (Ep. 1) | Pandemic, For Sale, & The Voyages of Marco Polo

Transcript 25:00

foreign hey how's it going everyone Carlo here from all you can board and as always I'm here with my cousin Dylan and today we are starting a new series which we are as of now tentatively calling uh retro reviews so this is kind of retrospective reviews basically taking uh old you know beloved games whether they're games that we love or the general public loved at some point and looking at it through the lens of how does it hold up today so this is kind of a follow-up of a series we used to do kind of when we had some written content on our website um and basically we're going to be looking at each of these games we're going to be talking about three games today we're each gonna review one kind of independently and then together we're gonna co-review a kind of a bigger more complex game at the end so we'll always have three of these and for each of the games we're going to give you our verdict on has the game uh is the game showing its age has it aged well or is it a classic so again you're never really gonna see like generally like bad bad games on here because we don't want to just pick a game that's bad and say yeah it still sucks the whole point is to see how does this good game still hold up or does this game that used to be amazing still hold up today we're going to talk about some of the comparables in the industry and stuff like that so yeah I think this is a fun one um and we're curious if you like this let us know in the comments below afterwards if there's other games you want to see us cover in future episodes um I guess the last thing is just generally we're going to try and keep the games you know we want to lean towards the older ones we're going to aim as much as possible to go like 10 plus years but sometimes we're gonna go in that five seven eight year kind of range so yeah the only thing the only thing I'll add is that we we're calling this retro reviews right now but we we

honestly both react our brains being like is there something better we can call it like it doesn't we don't know that completely fits so if you we were kind of just gonna throw it to you guys as well if you think that there's you know you have an awesome name or a better better way to kind of get across what we're saying in like a single word or two words something relates to sync like that then compared to like retro reviews or retrospectives or whatever let us know in the comments and if we like what you what you've thrown out there we end up using it we'll credit you and we'll use that going forward yeah good point good point all right so I think I'm actually going to throw it over you Dylan to uh tell us about this first game here yeah this is the first board game I ever myself I think unless unless we're talking like back in the day when I bought like actually I guess my parents bought me those games so I I think this is yeah I think it is I think the first time that you invited me over to play a board game was this yeah and it's one that I think most people will know and it has been unfortunately in the last couple years uh it has now has an unfortunate name um but this is uh pandemic and this is the original box of the original box you can't find this anywhere anymore I have had this for a long time and yeah like I said it's one of the first games I played this is a Cooperative uh board game I think it's what is it three to five two to four two to four um and I thought you can technically play it solo too because you can control whatever rules in this game of 2008 I believe this was 15 years now or almost almost 15 15 years old now yeah they're gonna you know they're gonna have a 15th anniversary oh absolutely um so pandemic is a Cooperative game where you're essentially trying to control the spread of a pandemic disease which yeah like I said is an unfortunate theme nowadays for for a game I don't think this game would get made today after what we've been through but um but

yeah you're basically have different roles every Rule's gonna have a different ability and you're moving around a world map and you're managing four different colors of diseases and you're trying to eradicate them and eradicate in all fours how you win the game but you're constantly pulling from this infection deck and that's going to cause more of these disease cubes of the of the four colors to spread and you have to kind of use each other's abilities and work together to establish research stations to make effective travel to get rid of these diseases and and to gather I think is it's five cards of a single color in your hand yeah that's to find the Cure eradicating helps you more but it's just fine yes finding the Cure um so yeah it's it's honestly I don't know if it's the first Cooperative game like this of its kind but if it's not the first it's definitely the one that became most mainstream and was most effective at communicating that idea yeah I think the other big popular ones around the time were forbidden island and Forbidden Desert but I I think those were a little a bit newer yeah and it feels way more popular more popular I think it was even a little bit more involved too than what's going on and how much you're having to like really use each other's abilities and work together so it had actually been a while since I played pandem the base pandemic because I should mention there's many versions of pandemic now like in terms even like Legacy versions and completely different re themes and with new mechanics everything expansions yeah it's a it's a you know wide reaching game now it's its own brand essentially um so I hadn't played bass pandemic and I don't even know how long a very long time even though when I first got I played a ton of this game um and we are in a game right now on board game reading it's the first time I played in a while and it's it's reminded

me about like the positives about it the the negatives and everything and it's been really really good to go through it it's a game I still really really enjoy um I I think that every what playing at this time on BGA reminded me just like how much it did for Cooperative games because I see elements in it that like even in newer games we played like the loop and stuff I'm like oh like this owes a lot to pandemic this wouldn't have been this you know successful of a game or wouldn't have maybe Incorporated these mechanics in this way if not for a game like pandemic existing and everything so appreciate it a lot and yet I might surprise some people by saying that I'm giving it um the grade of showing its age and the reason I'm giving it that is not because I still don't enjoy it because I'm really enjoying our session uh on BJ but over the course of 15 years and many people trying to emulate success and all the different versions of pandemic it's just not it's showing its age in the sense that there's just so many better options out there and I shouldn't even use the word better I should just say in my opinion more fun you know more engaging more interesting whatever like I would play the Legacy version even season one again over playing bass pandemic I I still haven't played a pandemic Iberia and I really really want to play it afterwards I love and I think is by far the superior version yeah like there's there's expansions you can put on on this but there's like also like there's the what's the there's a Cthulhu version the other one I've heard a lot of good things about is I think fall of Rome oh right of course I forgot about that one heard really good things and then there's the there's the two or there's at least one Warcraft themed one there's that Wrath of the Lich King that got really good reviews too people said it's

a much more interesting immersive version than base pandemic so and then and then A system that keeps being adapted right yeah and then even like having played the loop recently you know it's it's that's not a wreath Theme by any means but like we said it owes a lot to pandemic it's that's the very same style of game of managing stuff coming out of control with everyone having unique abilities like very much same Essence but the loop has the cards that are interesting yeah you get different cards every time and stuff exactly so like and it's simple to play even new games that are coming out now are saying like we can take this system that we oh obviously to pandemic and doing it so well and just make it better so I it's hard for me to give it any other grade when I was thinking about just because truly it is an example of it just showing its age you if if everyone if no one someone had not played pandemic but it played pandemic Iberia the fall of Rome the Cthulhu version The Legacy version The Loop and then they're like I want to go back and play the original I feel like there's a good chance they're gonna be like this is kind of a letdown yeah why are you showing me this like we're going backwards here yeah so I think it that's that's kind of where I'm coming from there like again it doesn't diminish the impact it had doesn't diminish it it's a good game it's just a case of it is showing its age and because it's been 15 years and a lot of people ever find this formula by now so yeah no that's a good point this is one that I'm glad you took on because I was at home thinking about like man if I was doing that one would I be saying it's showing its age or aged well because it's it's that thing where like obviously it is aged well enough that the the bones the system the idea of pandemic is enough to spawn all these you know other versions and stuff and people still will play it and it's still the bass version still does sell but

like you said it's undeniable like from all the versions we've tried if this is near the bottom of all the pandemic versions has it really aged well so I I have to agree with you ultimately that's showing its age even though it does still it is still fun enough to play yeah still a Monumental game just now it happens to have an unfortunate theme yeah but it did so much for the Hobby and yeah if especially theme wise like Spirit island is just so much more interesting yeah exactly oh that's a great of course I can't even believe I didn't even mention Spirit Allen that's a great example of like play Spirit Island then go back and Play Pandemic and it's gonna be hard to say that this is more interesting than spirit I don't know yeah thematically and just the whole card the way everything yeah yeah so that's pandemic I think that it uh each one its age that's totally fair and I agree with you okay the next one we're going to talk about today is a game we've spoken about a fair bit on the channel over the last couple years I would say uh and that is for sale impressive Rock uh Rock filled box over here apparently so this is a game we've obviously spoken about on the channel before if you watch us you've heard us talk about it before uh it's a game for three to six players um it's a little auction bidding game I forgot to look up what year this came out and it's either early 2000s or it was like what 2003 it's older than the pandemic yeah yeah it's older than pandemic for sure somewhere around 20 years old might even be older it might even be in the 90s anyways uh designed by Steph and Dora very very simple game um basically there's two decks of cards one is a set of uh properties ranging from value one to Thirty and the other one is a deck of these like check cards ranging from zero to fifteen thousand

um and the game basically plays over two phases everyone starts a certain amount of money um and you're flipping cards from a deck that are properties and you're basically going around bidding uh trying to open the other players to stay in the round or you're passing and getting out of the round and taking the lowest least valuable property left and then in the second phase of the game you're using the properties that you've gained everyone's secretly picking one at a time when the checks are available and then you're basically flipping them over to see whose properties get the most valuable checks play with the most money wins super simple game that's pretty much all the rules right there it plays in like 15 20 minutes it's graded pretty much every player count you can play it at we've had so much success teaching this and this is I should say this is a game that I only discovered and played for the first time on board game arena during the pandemic and I think I probably played this 50 or 60 times just against random strangers before I even got to show this to anyone and I remember I think I showed to you and a couple of other friends and then it kind of became this regular game we played throughout the pandemic we both went and bought our own copy of this little small travel version um you know what as I'm praising the game I'm just gonna say right now this is a classic uh without a doubt for me um and it's a classic for a few reasons one is like the fact that how old it is and the fact that it holds up this well and that you can just show it to anyone and play you can play it online again in silence or not like with voice chat you can play it in person around a table everyone's always going to have a good time people are always requesting to play this again the thing that really gives it that classic status to me is it feels like today and I think a lot of this is

driven by like Kickstarter and crowdfunding in general is games a lot of the time have added options and variants and modules and stretch goals and things that are like oh then you have variable player powers and there's in-game objective cards and you can get these item cards right and there's always these and a lot of times like there's certain games where yes it all belongs there but sometimes it feels like too much and there's something beautiful about the Simplicity of this game there there isn't anything else to it I remember when they recently announced the uh for sale Autorama version or whatever which is like the updated version that's like car themed but it's like a 50 or 60 dollar game there's all these other 50 or 60 yeah and it's like a different module or like it's at least I think maybe at least 48 or something I think I think I saw it yeah I think it was 55 I saw that's wild beautiful art by Quantum Orion stuff but when I read about all the rules and stuff I just thought like is that what I want from for sale like I want a simple filler game I don't want new modules to add in or things that are going to complicate it like I'm hoping to try and still I'm not judging that game without playing it but there's just something we've played other auction games we've played other fillers and yet like this one truly does stand the test of time I've played it probably over 100 times now and I don't think this is ever going to be my collection because of how simple it is and again travel version like you bring this camping bring it on traveling with you whatever wherever you go um awesome game it just holds up so well yep I think I think if I like I'd have to think about it more but I'd be pretty close to giving into classic status too depending on how like critical I want it to be because it is just for how long it's been out there's not many games that have you know often cracked that

formula of being like short plane fill or ask and yet like nerve-wracking decision making with like a large player count potential as well like yeah it has so many elements that are not always easy to balance and not always easy even just to hone in on one of those and do it well and it seems to do them all well in this small package that is really simple yeah and an easy rules teach like yeah you have two choices but the player interaction like sometimes you're just bidding and someone's like how dare you I can't believe you just outbid me like it gets people talking it's a social involved game and uh yeah there aren't many games that give you this much fun um and this much decision space in this amount of time and with this simple of a rule set so yeah um yeah for that reason this is one of those very few games that's like that much sort of bang for your buck that's that old so yeah for me it's a classic without a doubt love it all right now we're gonna do a joint game so this joint game we or it's the same game we're both gonna give our verdict on it we're probably gonna start by saying our verdict because otherwise it's gonna like probably be too obvious whatever it is and we both have to give it um but uh you know I'll let you introduce again because I think you're gonna do a better job introducing them well thank you he's too kind it's only because I played the game more than he has but uh so today we're gonna be talking about the Voyages of Marco Polo so this is co-designed by uh is it Simone Luciani and Danielle tashini I believe wow look at that we also did zulkin and did they also do there's at least one of them did I can't remember if they did as a team but I think so yeah they've done lots of games together um uh and actually I guess they did the Voyages of Marco Polo 2 which came out a

few years later so the first voyage is Marco Polo I forgot was it 2014 2016.50 some around there but yeah this is one it's not super old it's less than 10 years old um but it's one that I only discovered for the first time on board game arena a couple of years ago uh the basic overview is that the game plays over five rounds and it's a dice placement game so kind of like work replacement but with dice so everyone has a pool of five dice or depending on your character you might have more or whatnot and you start the round by rolling your dice and then throughout the round there's different spots kind of like work replacement action spaces on the board that you go to that can give you different resources allow you to travel around the different parts of the board like there's a map of a part of a portion of Asia you all start in one location you're trying to move around the map and get to Beijing where you can get extra points you can drop trading posts along the way when you're traveling to places but you need to acquire like money and camels in order to travel there's all kinds of cool stuff there's certain spaces that only one person go to or once there's a die there no one else can go but there's other spaces that you can go on top of other dice but there's an extra cost that you have to pay based on the value of the die there so every round is kind of an interesting play of you roll your dice and you try and figure out what am I going to try to accomplish this round and also what do I think my opponents are going to try to accomplish because if I know there's places that I really want to go or things I have to do I want want to get them for cheap before the players take those actions and I have to pay the extra costs to go there it might mess with the amount of resources I have to do other things so there's contracts that you get that you can cash in to get points and other resources and things like that and you're scoring for all

different kinds of things at the end of the game you're scoring for your contracts and your you know trading posts you left behind and leftover resources and all kinds of stuff right so yeah there's a lot and it's a variable setup so you always have a different map and here I'll leave it to you now to tell people about the most interesting part of the game sure which I'm assuming you're talking about is the all the initial starting character powers that you can get variable player Powers which is just what make this game yes I think there's a ton of different variable player powers and they all are not just like you know minor things that's like oh cool you're gonna be able to get do this this game like they very much break or bend or completely twist the rules of the game in the sense that now I'm going to be able to do something completely different than than someone else is going to do and I'm going to look at that and think how is this even fair like what I can do is going to be completely broken for everyone else until I realize that they also have a power that completely you know breaks something or makes them feel overpowered so everyone's going to have this interesting you know unique approach that now next to my play yeah I'm playing the same game but with a completely different way to break the game it's going to feel very different and I think that's what makes it so much fun to go back to is I still haven't used I might have encountered every Power but I haven't used myself ever Powers which I think makes it so that I still want to go back and that more right right absolutely and and again going back to the the characters with the variable setup gives more life to those characters because it's not just you try them once or twice and you think oh I've seen everything there is you see different action spaces on the board that you travel to that will give you different potential combos so every game is a different puzzle of assessing the board and trying to figure out where to

take advantage of the strengths of your character and what not to do kind of thing and not everyone has to move you know you can play games where you don't move around as much and you figure out other ways to get resources and cash in contracts and things so so what's uh let's say what what our verdicts are and let's talk about a little bit um do you want me to go first doesn't matter of course uh I think it has aged well okay uh I am also gonna say age well but I was so so close to saying classic me too and definitely closer to Classic than the other way I think I think I talked myself out of it because I was like maybe I should be a little more critical of a classic or something but like yeah but honestly like it was it was pretty close and uh since you said your verted first I'm gonna give my reasoning first yeah so for me it's that I still don't know if I can think of another game that incorporates many of these elements or a lot the majority of these elements that it has in one package that I like more and and it's only been from playing it more that I that I realize that obviously but like I I'm a huge fan of dice placement like and manipulating die faces and using those as as workers or values whatever like we've played a handful of games like that now and I've always enjoyed them on some level whether that become or whether that be coinbra um yeah but toku like I really like that mechanic and yet I go back and play voyages Marco Polo and I realize that here's this game that came out you know you know whatever whatever is like seven years ago eight years ago and it still does it better

than any games that have come after it yet they've had the information to pull from they've had the inspirational from and it seems difficult for them to find a way to top it and maybe that's because sometimes you just you strike gold and you realize you figure out the best way to do something from the start and everyone's trying to circumvent that but like there's something just so satisfying about you roll your dice here they are you have a minor ways to manipulate the value they give you this option to get a to you know cash in and get the extra black dye so you have this way to like get more dice if you need it but you have to pay for it and then the the simple the simple but super effective thing of yes you can you're the only one who can go to this spot but you can go if you're willing to pay more but you're trying to craft the strategy of like well if I pay more then I'm not gonna have money to do this though and I've I've planted just perfectly so now instead of that can I do this and then the order people go to some places you're like I know someone here is going to go and travel but like if I travel now and it's not going to be as effective of a travel but if I travel later I might not travel at all like yeah there's just like so much balancing between all that and it's all done good like it's done well like that's that's the surprising is with variable player Powers with dice place and with with traveling across like a map on the board with collecting contracts like all managing all your resources there's so much going on and all of them I would say I wouldn't say it does any of them poorly no I think people agree with you all very very well so in that sense like I almost said classic because if we're considering classic as something that like still holds up as the epitome of what it does I would say it's pretty darn close it it it's just

honestly I don't even know exactly why I didn't push it to Classic I think I was being a little critical it's close it's really close I'm glad I'm glad you mentioned that because I very very I was so close to picking classic as well and I kept thinking the same thing like is this a game that if I didn't own a copy of ever I didn't know anyone who owned a physical copy that I would be okay with just playing on board game arena once in a while and I think that's what made me say like yeah technically like I don't need to own this and again like I would be fine to just keep playing it on board game arena so maybe that's part of what pushed me into there and the other thing is we've started obviously a game of Voyages of Marco Polo 2 but we haven't completed one yet I haven't seen enough of it I don't know yet I don't know if you have any First Impressions off comparing the two games like obviously voyages Marco Polo 2 has uh has taken away a lot of the it's loosened the game up right it's giving you way more options way more flexibility you're not starved for resources it's not all like trying to get scraps wherever you can it's like no just get there's wild resources Jade that can help you there's all kinds of benefits places it's easier to travel yeah and I don't know how are you feeling about it so far I I I think that like the things you're mentioning right now as even as you say it like that it's taken away are some of the things that I think are what makes the original so good so I I think that even then like even if I end up liking the second one more I don't know that it's going to be a situation of like it replaces it because it's very much a sequel like it owes everything to the first one it's a little bit different and I'm almost wondering if for me the only thing that's gonna it needs to push to Classic is just a couple more years with no game topping it and that's what I was yeah if it had been out for 20

years you'd be like man this game has really stood the test of time right if another three three years goes by and no one in our eyes obviously this is subjective other people might be like I like I love this dice placement game way more than it but for us if in three years we've played you know a slew of other dice placement games the slew other games that also have play variable player Powers with and all this stuff and none of them can seem to do it better at some point I think it's gonna be like you know what I give a classic stats because I I nothing else is coming close or maybe not coming close but you know what I mean right yeah you know and I think I think it is those and just from what I've seen of the player powers in the second game in Marco Polo 2 I think the powers seem a little more broken and a little more uh like in a good way right like they're more wild and more interesting like game breaking where you're just like what like this character can literally just choose the die values you can just be like yeah oh my dice are six and you're like but sixes are usually the best that's cheap cheating and then another character it's like now you have two characters on the map and you can move to different locations like what and it doesn't feel quite that shocking in Marco Polo too so I think that's where it's also feeling like it's really maintaining its its status as just a really solid game and and the fact that on your turn not only are you picking actually through dice but you can span three camels to buy these extra black dice to add more dice to your pool or you can take certain free actions so there's even little things on your turn that aren't just pick a spot and go to it there's more to it than that too so yeah and even just like you said like which contracts you have like you're gonna prioritize um travel more or less depending on how achievable they are but also on like you know compare like which player power you get if you get one that really affects

your travel suddenly you're like I'm gonna make sure I get to what's the last spot you want to get to Beijing Beijing you might like on the last thing in the game we played I had the ability to travel more efficiently so I'm like well I'm just gonna make sure I get to Beijing first and I get my contracts because I know I can do that efficiently and that would be like not my priority but something I know I'm going to accomplish this game which I think in our game I don't even was it the one we played where you didn't even like complete your contracts you only completed or sorry um you're you're traveling yeah I didn't complete either one if you won right yeah I think it's like it's cool that you can approach it that way they give you two starting goals you can't you don't complete either one and you can still win the game yeah that is yeah yeah no honestly it's a game that is aged very well it's almost there no I was gonna say as well it's ages various yeah definitely on the very high like just about reaching classic status and uh who knows maybe we'll revisit this in a couple years or five years or whatever and maybe we will say you know what we were maybe a little harsh maybe it is a classic in three years comment on this video and say where does it stand now yeah yeah but a very good game and the BGA implementation is very good so if you haven't tried it yet highly recommend you check it out on there um is there anything else you want to add about the Voyages of Marco Polo no that's it I think that's it and that's that's the three games so just to recap pandemic I said uh has uh I was gonna say has not aged low but uh which I agree with for sale is a classic and Voyage of Marco Polo is uh has aged very well yeah very well close to Classic yeah maybe not quite there so those are the three

we looked at today uh once again if you like this series if you liked us revisiting uh older games uh let us know in the comments so we know that you enjoy you want to keep seeing it and if you have any inspiration any ideas for a name outside of uh retro reviews which stands for retrospect reviews that you think encompasses what we're doing a little bit better let us know in the comments and if we like it we will credit you and we will use it as long as you're okay with it and as long as you're okay with not getting paid for it because we're not yeah exactly but no conversation but we would love your we would love your help there otherwise uh that's all we got as always if you're enjoying this content uh subscribe to the channel if you want to talk with us more join our Discord if you want to support us go to patreon or just keep watching our videos and we love that you guys watch our videos so thanks so much for watching and we'll see you next time

Progress saved