Interview with Wyrmspan designer: Connie Vogelmann
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome to the mill today we have a very special episode Molly and I are joined with once again Connie vulgan who's not only the designer of apiary but also now worms span hi yeah thank you so much for having me back I really appreciate it I'm really looking forward to chatting and looking forward to talking about worms span thanks for coming on again and letting us interview you a second time in such a short period yeah of course I that brings me right into the first question um we heard from Jamie that he asked you to design this game um while you were still working on apiary um what was it like to work on a second game so soon but also not just a second game but like a game tied to wingspan which has been so such a huge hit around the world yeah absolutely I mean you know so as you said jimie asked if I be willing to work on a sequel with Dragons you know we came up with a pitch pitched it to Elizabeth Elizabeth you know was on board with it um and it's definitely an experience I mean I I will say that I tend to be kind of a one project at a time person um but this was very much helped by the fact that AP was almost done by the time that I uh started working on worms span they were in very very different stages so AP was in sort of the final play testing and development TOS worms span was in very kind of early concept stages and I mentioned this before but one of the reasons that the the releases ended being fairly close together was that the
art for worms span was done basically simultaneously with the design so Clementine um was working on the dragons at the same time that I was designing the game whereas for apiary most of the art was done after so that's part of the reason why the the releases are as close as they are that the work on them was a little bit more separate um but I will say it was definitely big shoes to fill I mean you know with with worms span it's definitely standing on the shoulders of giants um with Elizabeth and and wingspan and everything um and there was definitely a lot of imposters syndrome that sort of like oh my God you know am I the person to do this like are you sure um and so there was definitely some of that but I also knew in taking on the project that you know Elizabeth was going to be there um on board from the beginning as the developer Jamie was going to be on board and helping as well and so at that point it's like well if they think I can do it then I better think that I can do it as well um but yeah it's been an absolutely wonderful experience that's great it sounds like I was say it seems like it's working out because PE a Perry is all over like top of 2023 list like it's done wonderful and now it's just like and you're back right away like people don't have to wait for you I just hope they don't get sick of me but um yeah I mean it's I've been just absolutely thrilled with how A's been received I mean it seems like folks are getting a lot of of enjoyment out of it and so that's been absolutely wonderful you know once you when you put a a game out into the world you don't really know how it's going to be received I mean you sort of have hopes for it obviously and you don't put it out into the world unless you think it's pretty good and you think people are going to enjoy it but you never really know so it's been
really really wonderful and very very gratifying to see that well we loved aary and we're happy to talk to you again it'll be weird talking to someone when else when the next Stone me one comes out did you know you would be backtack releases when you took on them both were you hoping something would be in between you know I wasn't sure to be honest with you and then oh the other thing I should mention too is I think the freight shipping for a got delayed by a month or two so they weren't supposed to be I think quite quite as close together as they were I think I realized sometime maybe like 8 months ago that there were going to be back to back releases and it was like oh my gosh you know buckle up or Buckle in or whatever the phrase is like this is going to be you know different um so yeah I I didn't didn't know what I started so I was gonna say because you still have a full-time job right now as well too right I do I do in fact like do you breathe do you sleep uh I will say that I don't sleep as much as yeah yeah I mean and and I mean I definitely don't sleep as much as I I should and this is something that I'm trying to work work on is sort of you know pacing myself and this sounds very um of um you know whatever new age or something like that but I feel like I've been like really focusing on sleep hygiene lately trying to like go to bed on time and things like that but I will say I'm also just very very lucky too I mean it's you know we don't have kids I I honestly don't know how how folks do it with kids and then I also have a very very supportive partner who's always always sort of helping out and and taking up some of the extra loads too but yeah I mean it's it's it is sort of
like a full working a full-time job on top of your full-time job um I think that's that's sort of what the stuff is but I absolutely love doing it so I really can't complain awesome yeah and your partner is amazing online with all the questions by the way just want to give just want to give uh him a shout out because that's been awesome yeah big big shout out to David I feel like he's been on all of the forums and answering all of the questions and he also keeps some of the rulings in the adjudication straight much much more easily than I do and and so I feel like at this point he's become kind of the living breathing repository of apiary knowledge and and which is absolutely wonderful so that's great I always see him answering questions in the Discord yeah he's very very very good at that um when you accepted this design like what were the steps in trying to like Implement a well-known game being an omage to it kind of but make a heavier game like that sounds so challenging it was definitely a very much very much a living breathing process so the initial kind of concept from Jamie was wingspan but with Dragons heavier than worm span and the other piece of the initial concept and this got dropped um a few months into the design was actually make it a bag Builder um which I think would have been really interesting and really fun um and I think it would have made for a very very good game but something that was just a bit too far away from wingspan and so that was actually a big part of what Elizabeth did too was sort of um so we're we're local so Elizabeth and I are both in the the Washington DC area and so a lot of times I would just kind of
take the game over to her house we' play it and then she'd kind of give me feedback and a lot of that feedback was this feels like wingspan this doesn't feel like wingspan let's try to capture that field and I think that you know one of the things that I think is really important to emphasize is we didn't just sort of throw a dart and hope for the best I mean the sort of difference between wingspan and worm span was something that Jamie and Elizabeth and I all put a lot of kind of time and effort and Care into because we really wanted to be true to that Foundation I mean you know wingspan has tons and tons of fans and we don't want to advertise this as a spin-off to wingspan and then not have it kind of have some of the same feeling you know we don't want it to be too different but at the same time we want to also kind of respect people on from the other side and basically not you know it's certainly not a reskin and so trying to kind of find that right difference of how is it similar enough but different enough you know I think there going to be a lot of folks who are going to think it's either too close to wingspan or too far from wingspan but we really kind of tried to strike that that kind of balance and that happy medium um and that that was really something that was a very big topic of conversation with just about every version and every iteration throughout the entire design and development process for rpan yeah as gosh you you talk about impostor syndrome I feel weird I'm the one in this conversation who actually has a copy in front of me right now it feels very odd like you should have this no no no no but I mean you you're also you're taking all of you're taking all of the photos for the game which is which is absolutely wonderful and and for folks who haven't seen it I mean please go check out Stone Meer site I mean the the photos are absolutely beautiful so yeah no it's been a blast I mean this game between mechanics the
artist just been a like a photographer's dream to like take pictures of it's gorgeous um but yeah so as the one playing it I would say we found and I've played with a couple groups we've definitely seen like you you're right you see the bones there but then as Jamie's already done a video for there's like there's definitely some very distinct differences so I guess what is your favorite kind of unique aspect or maybe a couple of them and why like what was when you finally got this all together and what was your favorite part that was more unique or just very different from wingspan yeah absolutely so there's a couple of things that I want to call out so one is the building out the caves so in worm span you have to build out a cave before you can put a dragon in it and that gave me a lot of opportunity to do like when played abilities um yeah um Carol's holding up a couple of the cards now but it gives you a lot of opportunities to do kind of like instant abilities which are things that I tend to love in games and so you can put together some fun combos with those so that's one of them uh another one is the dragon Guild track so one of the resources that you get in the game is um basically advancements on a track and first of all I love tracks and I love track advancements um but second of all the thing that's really fun about it is you basically have the sort of Center Spot in the track and those are all really big bonuses and so every time you hit the bottom or the top of the track you get to put a a cube onto one of those spaces and then you basically take that space you take it away from other people and then you also get it yourself
and a lot of those spaces are essentially free actions or deeply discounted actions and so they're very fun to sort of string those things together the last thing uh that I want to flag to that I really like and this is a very sort of it's very subtle from a rule standpoint but I think from a feeli standpoint it actually makes a really big difference and that is that the cave entrance costs in worms span increase so if you want to uh you enter a cave you basically activate your row by sort of sending your Adventurer into the row so it's left to right movement instead of the right to left from um wingspan but the first time that you enter into the into a row you can sort of see on that top red row or the the middle yellow row there the first cost is one coin the second cost uh is a coin and an egg and the third is a coin and two eggs so those costs increase if you go into that same tunnel multiple times in round um and so it really makes this very interesting kind of sequencing decision of when are you going to do it how many times are you going to activate that round and I think it creates a very different feel from Wings band even though it's a very very sort of small sort of subtle rules change so those are a few things that I particularly like uh from the differences standpoint I'm looking down at so there are four guilds right now in the game I'm looking at the Guild of sea fars right now which is actually I haven't played it I'm hoping to play it soon I'm like one of these bonuses you could get is gain a coin and two Dragon cards so I think that's one of the things I like is that ability to get more coins which are essentially the action cubes so it feels so satisfying to get another turn absolutely yeah so one every game too sorry yeah yeah well
and I think you can really start structuring your game around them too depending on which one is up because they're all kind of themed around a particular type of resource so one is around cave cards one's around Dragon cards one is around resources and then the last one's around eggs and so you'll kind of realize that in that situation if you're doing the one with eggs for instance all of a sudden eggs are going to be a little bit more plentiful so that's when you might want to try to build out one of those tunnels and uh enter it multiple times in a round because you're going to have sort of the costs required to do it um so so yeah that's sort of what of and and I think getting free actions I mean everyone loves free actions it's one of the most fun things you can do in a game and so I think kind of building it a lot of different ways in worm spand so that you can get those extra actions does make it feel a little bit different and it allows you to sort of extend your rounds um in a way that I think feels very different from wingspan yeah it's exciting I love games where you can like analyze the setup like Terra mystica and I feel like you nailed it with those Guild cards like there's going to be different metas based on which one is out so yeah I mean that's definitely what we're what we're hoping hoping for um so my next question I wanted to ask um I when I had heard about wingspan hadn't or worm span I hadn't seen any of the art and I always joked that the dragon on the cover would be the scissor tailed fly scorcher which which I made up but I feel like that is the one on the box um what's your favorite Dragon uh in the game yeah yeah so probably my favorite dragon is this Dragon called the Primal worm and I mean you know worms uh are not maybe the most photogenic dragons in
all cases they tend to be a little bit on the um nasty side I mean in the lore but so it's this this giant dragon that's sort of rising up from from the the Mist um but it has an ability that I just really love and that's it basically eats eggs off of neighboring cards and gives you Dragon Guild advancements and the dragon Guild as I said is one of my favorite parts of the game there's something that's just so evocative about this Dragon um and you know a lot of the the dragons and we'll talk about this I think a little bit more later s of their abilities and their names are kind of all themed and it's a little bit subtle but a lot of the dragons that give you Dragon Guild advancements are named after old things so ancient or primeval or primordial or things like that sounds I called the patient red worm he's a worm I don't know there he is yeah and obviously we're kind of playing a little bit loose with some of the you know Limbs and wings and Tails and stuff like that but we did try to stick to some of the kind of more you know to the dragon lore so that a lot of the dragons are recognizable or are sort of the things that you see from from the lower very cool yeah these are super fun like I don't even think I could pick a favor right now but that there are some of those hatchlings that are just so adorable the hatchlings are adorable and I think Clementine just did an absolutely so hatchings are basically baby dragons they sort of grow up um in your Tableau or you kind of trying to feed them in your Tableau and they're all basically baby dragons and I think Clementine just did this wonderful job of they're adorable but kind of not in your traditional way I mean they're not sort of like cute chibi dragons I mean
they still look like something that could be very much in the real world um so yeah I mean I think they're just AB yeah well this one's like half in the egg yeah the art on this is just yeah I love the art the watercolor it's beautiful M yeah I mean Clementine is is absolutely fantastic I don't know how she came up with cuz I mean she basically pulled these dragons out of thin air um and I I'm I'm in awe of what she was able to do with it since we're kind of already talking about it one of our next questions was going to be because as you mentioned you and Clementine did quite a bit of research into like various cultures Dragon lore correct yes yep so then how did that research really play into either some of the game mechanics Andor we kind of already started talking about the art but any more of the art cuz you can kind of tell like worms versus serpents like they have different looks absolutely yeah so so basically what what happened is Kine and I both did some sort of independent research trying to figure out like okay which which types of dragons that are common in Dragon lore throughout the world do we want to try to include in the game and it's worth mentioning that there's no IPS in the game so you're not going to see you know your smogs or or um your toothless or anything like that in the game um which would be wonderful but I think that would be kind of an IP uh and probably stylistic nightmare too um but so we kind of talked about it ahead of time and said okay you know we have your dragons your wyverns your worms your serpents your ampers your quadd your you
know uh your Drakes you know a few others and then we kind of figured out already how many of each of those types of dragons do we want in the game you know something like worms are a little bit harder they tend to look all a little bit more similar whereas some of your dragons and your wyverns and your Dres and stuff give you a little bit more kind of room for creativity um and then what we did was sort of a multipart process so as Clementine drew the art it basically was like kind of working in real time to associate them with the different cards and we did that based on a few different things so basically the second word in each of the dragons names for the most part is dependent on their sort of wing and limb situation um so your dragons you know for instance have your wings and your four your four legs um and then what we basically tried to do okay yeah um and then obviously there's some there's sort of some you know like land dragon is sort of something in the game and we have you know the red worms and things like that so we kind of played around with that a little bit um but then there's a couple other pieces of it too and one is the colors on the cards so we basically tried to associate the colors with the color of the tunnel that I went into just because I think that's kind of an easy mental shortcut so basically your red tunnels gets a lot of your Reds and your oranges and your pinks and your Browns your kind of warm colors your yellow tunnel has your yellows and your greens your Silvers your whites things like that good perfect red example and then your per your purple tunnel has some of your Blues you know your Blues your purples your kind of cool colors um and then the other thing you'll note too is that the food actually matches the tunnel as well so all of the cards that go into the yellow tunnel have at least one gold all of the dragons that go into the purple tunnel have at least one Crystal and so on uh and then the last
piece of it is based on their kind of ability and the abilities are actually themed around what they do in the game um so as I said before for instance a lot of your ancient dragons your old your ancient your primeval primordial uh Etc uh have to do with basically Dragon Guild advancements um and there's kind of different connections through that um a lot of your uh cards that give you Dragon cards are named after intelligent so that's wise uh and you'll have kind of knowledgeable perceptive um in words like that so we tried to kind of uh really sort of theme the dragons around kind of the entire unit but I will say that um I also played a little bit fast and loose with it kind of intentionally because I was sort of imagining this world being very similar to our own current world and if you think about bird taxonomy or animal taxonomy it's insane I mean people were putting it together from all different parts of the world all throughout history and so I thought that if it was too consistent if everything was entirely consistent and entirely consistent with this framework that we laid out it would just feel very artificial and very phony so we kind of I kind of played a little bit fast and loose with it which was very intentional because I wanted it to feel like this fully fleshed out world that actually existed so that's the long answer it's a fun answer too though there's just you could tell there's just so much thought put into these so yeah these are I'm just looking at them and I'm seeing all these wise I'll see a lot of Fay Dragons Were Fay ones like supposed to be kind of like mystical a little bit different y yep absolutely I mean and in
a lot of the lore they tend to be very small um and I think we kind of mucked around with that a little bit but yeah a lot of them tend to be um dragon as you said mystical or sort of fairy like I mean sort of this idea that they could be kind of confused with fairies throughout uh different cultures ni think going deep in the lore is perfect because people will always be comparing it to wingspan which bird lore is pretty extensive out there a lot of a lot of people were brought into the board game hobby with wingspan who like really cared about stats and facts and stuff and so the fact that you are keeping like a whole booklet of them for people to enjoy is really great yeah yeah so there's a a big color glossery up of all of the dragons and all of the and facts so we kept the information off the cards um in part because it just it felt a little bit weird to have kind of made up facts on the cards it also made them pretty cluttered too because there's already a lot of information on the cards and I mean Clementine's artwork is so beautiful that it seemed weird to shrink the artwork to make up a fake fact to put it on the dragons but what we did do as and this is part of kind of fleshing out the lore of this world is basically put it all into a separate booklet and so people can kind of page through it when it's not their turn or as they're playing Dragons um also gave us a lot more space too so you'll see that some of the descriptions are actually a little bit on the long side but that was one of the kind of flexibilities of taking them off the card and so I think this is kind of a good kind of happy medium I mean so you still have all of that information and you have all of that lore but it's also not cluttering up the cards very cool I think it's great um so
now you've had back to back or you will have I should say it's not out yet Stone meire releases are you um feeling burnt out at all are we going to see a third game from you anytime soon any more games at all oh gosh I mean I hope I hope there'll be more games um probably not anytime soon I am um working on a couple things now but I think uh anything that I'm working on now is fairly far out unfortunately but I absolutely love game design I'm hoping to kind of you know keep keep on keeping on so I think you guys are unfortunately stuck with me for a little while what are you talking about we we're getting this down now keep bringing you in all right hey I'll take it all right sweet so I kind of had a fun question that's rather silly CU I feel like it's kind of been almost like a tradition Stow games like when you look at wingspan no one cut it's worms and wheat and like everyone just makes up names for the food and I know my group tapestry it's always the bamax I don't even know I don't know what the little gr human looking dude is supposed to be so I don't actually think I don't actually think I know because we just thought was called The Bay Maxes too so I mean it's like I feel like this happens with so many stonm games it's like stars and BX and uh bags and so I I'll try to hold some of these up and
I'm I can share what my group has kind of said but I'm curious what do you think people are going to start calling especially these gold bars so I don't know cuz I it's I mean they do look like pretty clear gold bars to me although I think and and maybe this is me being a little bit vain but I would absolutely love to see like a little bit of like an aary crossover you know I mean calling the gold honey or something like that like that would be sort of living living the dream but what has your group started calling them um we called them butter okay that's fair we we decided to go with a full food theme and so the gems we we're calling grapes mhm mhm which they don't really look like it but we're like oh those could be grapes and here's butter I mean this is like you know Gamers being silly so we were calling that butter I remember if we called the meat some sort of fruit too and then milk was milk because we didn't feel like we needed to change that but yeah we went we like let's go make them all like a food theme so yeah it was butter and grapes and milk and meat I'm just I'm interested to see what other people I just feel like it happens and for some reason it happens all the time with stone me games absolutely and just a quick note on the milk too cuz I know a few folks have said like what the heck dragons don't drink milk and I'm like well in this world they do but I think some of it too was coming from this idea of like you know a big part of the reason um I mean I'm not I'm not really an expert on this but you know I get the sense that like you know when mammals became warm-blooded or you know the the milk
that mammals basically need to get going is often you know um tied to this warm-bloodedness you need a little bit more energy to get going when you're young so I sort of thinking that in the lore you know dragons are often considered to be warm-blooded or very hot blooded so maybe the dragons the young dragons need a little bit more to get going and so the milk is kind of related to those hatchlings um it's a it's a resource it's specific to the hatchlings to the baby dragons and I thought too that it was just like okay what resource can we have that very clearly says this is tied to the babies and so that's kind of where the milk came from we actually had Dragon nip for a while too that was like a green resource um and we actually ended up cutting it because I think we we ended up going from five to four resources for a number of different reasons and people like this is really dumb and I'm like yeah but it's fun it's like catnet but for dragons that would be adorable I think fun us all it's a fantasy world so something can hatch from an egg and then drink milk I mean dragons being able to fly at all being that heavy is already fantasy right of course I mean of course oh yeah no and you're right I think it does give that really good symbolism of these are the babies I mean that's what people people associated with and so yeah no I think it works out really well as I look at a little hatchling here who needs his milk yep yeah so as you can see from the card that Carol's holding up it needs an egg and then two um three milk I think to to feed it and then um a lot of the the dragons also require you to cash milk on them that's basically how you trigger their ability so it's it's I said it's a
very hatchling specific resource yep all right um so I think we just have one more question question and just is there any other kind of fun stories I know that well as of the day we're filming us filming this recently Jam's like Tales of production has come out um is there any other kind of fun stories or anything else you want people know about worms span before it as of this recording goes on sale next week yeah I mean I think I what I just sort of ask as post to do is is take a look I mean Stone Meer has put um out a lot of information about it Jamie has videos where he's taking a few turns um and you know a lot of the reviews will be out uh as of January 22nd so I will say that it's just been an absolutely fun process from the beginning I mean it was an absolute Delight to basically riff off of the system that Elizabeth created um that's worked so well you know I think that one of the beauties of of wingspan that worms span also shares is this the Cav mats um or the the player mats and wingspan Cav mats and worms span you know because it's this idea that every single card that you play into your Tableau makes it better it almost doesn't even matter what the card does I mean it does sometimes and you want to play good cards and you want to be uh thoughtful about that but just this idea that every single card you play makes your Tableau better and I think it just makes it such a wonderful game Space to be in it just makes every turn feel really satisfying um and so there were actually a lot of versions that of warm span that had very very different systems you know one of the systems that we tried out that in another world I would have liked to have made work was basically a modular uh Cave board so you
basically added the spaces in which also provided the benefits that were associated with the row so you'd be kind of building out your own your own cave but what we found is it was just it was very variable and so sometimes it worked really really well and sometimes you just couldn't quite get the things that you needed and so I think kind of going back a little bit more toward wingspan and toward that wingspan mat it just makes every action feel so good and so satisfying so yeah I guess that's sort of all I have all that's kind of the main the main thought on that but as I said I think the game was an absolute joy to design um and to you know working again with Elizabeth and Jamie and so I hope that that comes through to the game nice you have anything else M I was just going to say I'm really excited to play the game because um I see about it it seems like you struck that perfect balance and I think a lot of people are going to be pleasantly surprised with I mean I hope so um but yeah I you know again I really really hope so and and I'll say too it was just I it was very intentional so I mean we really tried to do our best just to strike that balance so all right well thanks so much for coming on again Connie for second time in what three months yeah well thank you so much for having me I really appreciate it yeah we loved it um thanks again and we'll see you for your next game sounds good thank you all right bye Connie bye good
bye