Viticulture Boards Comparison with Bordeaux
Transcript
Hello everyone and welcome to the mill today. Today I am so excited to finally get to talk about the new Viticulture expansion Bordeaux. So for those who know me at all, Vidiculture is my absolute favorite Stonemer Meer game. And when this came in the mail, I was shocked and surprised and so excited. So what I'm going to show off today for Bordeaux is I'm going to give you a comparison of the new boards. Jamie has described this as a sibling to Tuskanyany. So essentially, it's giving you a different board to use instead of that one with some different pieces in it like experts. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to show you that comparison probably season by season between Tuskanyany and the Bordeaux board. It definitely changes up strategy and what you're going to do. That was uh as someone who has played Vida Culture well over a hundred times, it was nice to get kind of a fresh take and it really mixes up the strategies. So, it's one where you could play test me or you could play Bordeaux and you can switch it up when you want cuz it's going to use the same visitor cards and everything else. You also can add in, as you'll see on the boards, different elements of Tuscanyany into it. You can use the orange structure cards. You can uh also use the special workers. So there are those elements in Tuscanyany that if you love them, you can also bring them into Bordeaux. So what I'm going to do is I
think this will work best is if I bring it down to the table so you can see the board side by side. I'll also show you on the back of the Bordeaux board is a new just plain Viticulture board. And I actually just went and found I have my original plain viticulture board. I think we used it one time before we switched straight to Tuscanyany. So I will be able to show you a comparison of the back of that to the original Viticulture board as well. So if you will give me a minute, I will flip the camera and I will show you Bordeaux versus Tuscanyany. Okay. So, first I'm going to show off the regular viticulture board and which what is the back of the Bordeaux board which gives you a whole kind of new laid out viticulture board. So, as you can see, I have them both here. Here is the regular Viticulture board. So, if you just have Vidiculture Essentials Edition and here is the back of the Bordeaux board.
All right. So, it is obviously significantly bigger. So, if we look at these, it has discard piles for everything, which you don't have here. All right. And it also what it does put out here, this is something that's new with Berdau, and you'll see it on the back. It actually gives you a little bit of a market for your grapes and your grape or vine cards and for your wine order cards. So really what it adds here, which if you just have your regular board, you could do the same thing. Um, this was one of the things with Bordeaux, my husband and I were super excited about cuz we always complain like you can get some horrible draws with your vines and your wine orders. So to have at least a twocard market when you're choosing vine and order cards is absolutely fantastic and you could put that into any uh any version of Vidiculture you're playing really. Um, but the new regular board on the back of the Bordeaux board if you just want to play base viticulture does have those there and you have the discard spots on the side. But besides that, if you look here, the year's identical, the tracks identical, the actions, you still have this spot over here that tells you what to do. Here you go.
Winter actions identical. is just spaced out and bigger, but all those are the same. I'm just double checking. Yeah, all the bonuses are the same. If you notice, what's nice also as well is the the print is white. So, if you had troubles, the black kind of blends in with the background. So, they did change these to white, which definitely helps make it pop. But besides that, I believe all the bonuses and [snorts] everything else and actions are all the same. So essentially it is the same base viticulture board just with some just things to make it a little pop a little bit better with the words. Everything's bigger and more spacious. So even here it gives you spaces like you put your coins here. You could put your beads here. So it has spots on the board where you could put some of those places. Still have the same um uh LRA track over here if you were residuals.
Yeah, pretty much the exact same. Just some things just quality of life changes. We'll put it that way. Quality of life changes and these spots. All right. So, that's the base fitulture board. So, now I'm going to get rid of this. I'll be a um we used this board I think one time, played it once base and then never looked back and used started using Tuskany right away. So, now let's look at our dough. So, as I was mentioning on the other side, we love that Bordeaux adds this market for the um vines and the order cards. It's huge. Okay, wake up Tracks definitely different than Tuscanyany. Let me get my Sorry about that. Let me get my Tuscany board out so we can kind of do some comparisons between seasons.
I'm going to use the side that has the structure cards cuz we pretty much always play with structures. And if you do enjoy the structures, you'll be happy and know why there's not a spot on the board for structures in Bordeaux, there's still a way to use them. So, if we're looking at size, they're the exact same size. So, this is Tuskany on top now. So, let's do some comparisons here. So, first you'll notice that the residual track is different. So, in Bordeaux, you actually start your residuals on one, which is nice. And then you'll notice it goes up to seven. And when you pass, you get a victory point. And yes, there's a way to gamify it. So, you could go back and you don't lose the victory point, but you can gain it again. So, that's something you can kind of mess around with. But, so yes, the residual track is different. We definitely are enjoying the Bordeaux residual track. Now, the wake up track, super different here. Um, so what all of these mean in Borderaux is if well first if you look here it's pretty much the same for your seven. It just gives you the option of being a card or victory point here. Now so still the same thing.
You have to be choose seven to be able to get the green grape thing to be able to go up here and be first in the next year. Now what's different here? If you notice in Tuskanyany if you're first that is your bonus. That's all you get. In Bordeaux, you'll notice you do get a little bit of something. The reason it has all these figures is everyone gets that. So, everyone gets a coin. Everyone gets to age a grape. Everyone gets to age a wine. Okay, so that's your difference there. If you look, if you are number two in the wakeup row, summer stays the same. It's still a coin, but you do get some other little bonuses. So, you can age one grape in Bordeaux. And this lets you re that lets you it has you refresh the market since in Bordeaux you have a market and so that's a good way to refresh it. All right. So I'm going to three same draw a vine card. So instead of drawing in Bordeaux instead of drawing a yellow visitor card you get to age all your grapes. Winter you get nothing in Tuscanyany. You get to age one wine in winter. Going to four. These are very similar. You get to in the summer you get a order card, then you get a summer visitor card. Since Bordeaux does not actually have structures, it just has a way of putting them in there. If you have Tuscanyany, they had to get rid of the orange card.
So instead, you get to age all your wines, whereas in Tuscany, you get an orange card. Five, things are really going to change here. So in Tusky you get to choose what visitor and in Bordeaux you have to get a summer. Both of them are winter in the fall. And here's another big difference because in Tuscany you get a star cuz you have the kind of the area control map and the map where you get some of these bonuses. Um, we play a lot of two-player, so we don't do the area control as much, but it's still always been nice to get the stars with these bonuses and get to choose them. But if you look over here, Bordeaux doesn't have a star map or use the star system at all. So, I'll go over that in a sec, but you'll see. So, you get a coin versus a star in year five.
go down to six. It's a blue winter visitor card versus a victory point. A choice of any card versus gain a winter visitor. Then the winter, this one's really nice. You get to retrieve a regular worker. And notice, you can tell by the shape of it. This is not a grande worker. This is a regular worker. Retrieve one from the fall in here versus this one's aging grapes. And we already went over seven. Um, if you're looking here, these are all the same. Retrieve workers, age, grapes, and wine, discard down to seven, collect residuals, choose wake up position. That order of operation is still the same in Tuskanyany and Bordeaux. It's still that same method of as soon as you don't have workers or if you choose to pass, you pass and you go through this, which both of them still potentially open up a spot, which we just played a five player um with Bordeaux last night actually, and it went really smooth and we I definitely took advantage of someone had lifted stuff up and I got an awesome bonus because I still had two workers left. All right, so now going to the math. As I said, it doesn't have the map here. What it does do, we'll move this over.
If you are looking at the spring actions, you'll notice make a one trade is over in the spring now. And what you do is instead of just making that trade, so I'll put over here. So in Tuscanyany, that's in the summer. And it tells you you can trade two cards, three coins or victory point or a grape. And then you just trade it for the other one. And this was a good way of kind of abusing it for what you need it to be. But in Bordeaux, you actually take the little beads and you block that spot. So no one can do that exact same trade then, which is kind of a cool dynamic.
Um, so you're kind of fighting over that versus fighting over the star map, especially in a bigger player game. Now, if you're looking at this, if you haven't heard anything about it, the very new action in Bordeaux is this hiring an expert, which I'll go over in a sec. But if you get your expert here on the trade action, it says before this action, you may remove one trade token. So there is going to be potentially one person who can really mess around with this so they can take a beat off and be able to do something again, but that's because they chose to specialize in it. Okay, so now let's look at our spring actions here. These are pretty much the same. Okay, so you draw vine cards, give a tour, it's pretty much the same except there's an extra bonus on here. What he really tried to do in Bordeaux was either add bonuses or actually move some of them over so that in a two-player game, you're getting more of those bonuses, which as someone who plays a ton of it two-player, I really appreciate the fact that we have that. All right, so give a tour still here. And this is what I was talking about hiring an expert. So hiring an expert is really good. And when you first play Bordeaux, do not sleep on this action because if somebody goes big on this and gets a couple really juicy ones combined with maybe some stretchers or other pieces, they can really kind of run away with it. So, don't sleep on this. Um, so it does cost two, though.
You can get one discount here if you're the first one to go. And then you're going to get four little cubes and you place one on one of these in any season. All right. So that just makes it so when you go and take that action, if your cube is there, you are going to get a bonus every time you play that. So if you look at just the ones here, so it says discard any amount of coins to get that size grape, which is nice. Uh I've used this giveour one quite a bit. It's really nice. You get to gain a coin per worker here. I was gaining a lot of money last night on that one. This is gain one exposed bonus on the chosen action. All right, so these are the bonuses. just so you get that every time you would go and hire a worker. [snorts] Um, and then make the trade. I already went over that one. Okay. So, what I'm going to do here is I'm going to start Can I start folding? Yeah. I'm going to start folding up my Tuscany board to compare it with the Bordeaux board. All right. You can see the coloring is a little bit different um because I believe there are different artists here as well. So, actually this one feels very bright. Okay. So, now going into the summer. All right. Still play a card. Same bonuses for this one. As you can see, you can kind of read the um kind of the expert actions as you go through. Um this one's nice. You can change or to and on a visitor card. Now, notice this is a really big difference.
So, you have plant here, which if you look, plant is still down here. So, that's good. So, this one's there. And we already talked about the trade being over in the uh spring. Now, now this is where things are different. So you look at buy or harvest one field. So what's interesting in Bordeaux? Notice it says buy or harvest. In Bordeaux, you actually only start with your six field active. Your five and seven are already sold and you can't use them. And I'll point out on the bottom here in a second what's going on after I go through these. So in so it's also nice because you have a way of harvesting early. So you're not going to be one of the big strategies with Tuskanyany is selling your field for money early. [snorts] You don't have that in Borau. All right. So you can buy a field or you can harvest one here. And there's some bonus actions. And also notice you you get to build a structure here. So instead of building a structure, so build a structure is in your spring and your autumn in Tuscanyany. It wasn't in spring here. It's moved over to summer.
Okay, so that's another interesting piece here. Build a structures move to summer. Now, part of the reason you don't sell a field, and I'll show you, is it's down here at the bottom if you can't read it. So in addition to red and blue card starting benefits, you also you only start with your six value field, three lera, a two grape of either color and a one wine. And you start on your level one of the residual and you get your four expert cubes. So it almost has if you now that we so many gamers what we say is it's like the prelude effect of terraforming Mars. You have a little jump start in Bordeaux, which is part of the reason it's kind of getting rid of that like, oh, I want to go, everyone needs to go sell a field so they can get their money so they can actually start doing stuff. That's gone.
So, you get a little extra money here and you can't do that. You only have the one field to start. So said it's an interesting dynamic and as people who have played viticulture especially almost completely with Tuscany well over a hundred times. This really has made us rethink the strategies because said you're not going automatically going to sell a field because you can't. So that was pretty neat. All right so let's keep going here. All right. Trying to figure out what's the best way of showing this to you. This one's right on the fold. All right. So, going to autumn. All right. Drawing a card. Still the same. Drawing the purple cards. All right. Harvest up. Harvesting fields.
Notice right away here it's harvest up to two fields is the basic action versus the harvest one field in Tuscanyany. So huge there that that's not like in Tuscany. That's one of the bonuses. Not here. Look at the bonuses you get to choose from on this one. So that's really nice. Um wine. It still make up to two wine wine tokens. Notice we've had some iconology kind of updates here that are very consistent in Bordeaux with this one lets you make an extra wine. This one lets you age a wine. Okay. So the arrows kind of means age and the plus means get. So we're kind of getting that iconology update here. Also, if you look, the text is much bigger in Bordeaux, which is very nice.
It's also brighter, so I just feel like it's easier to read. And then this one is amazing. So I already talked about how the build one structure is in the spring is in the sorry in Tuscanyany the build one structures in the spring and the fall and notice the fall action you can build a structure or give a tour and that's Tuscanyany whereas in Bordeaux there is only one spot to build one structure and that's in summer. So that's a big change. However, there's this amazing spot in the fall now or autumn. You can pay a coin to take literally any action and it also activates then your expert if you're taking that action. So, this is a great spot. It gives you that flexibility which is huge. So, you pay a coin can take any action. All right. So, flexibility is there which and when either if you're playing a two-player game and you only have that one spot.
This is huge. Also, if you're in one of those bigger player games at five or six, it's also huge if you couldn't do something earlier. All right, so that is autumn. And if you also notice our track still the same, still a 25point win just like it is in Tuscanyany. All right, I'm going to see if I can fold this up a little better here for you. Yeah. All right, so now we are in winter for comparison. still play blue card. Bonuses are the same. Still train a worker. Um once again, this says pay. This just has the four. So things are just getting cleaned up quite a bit over here. Um there's an extra bonus there in that third spot for train a worker. So same thing. Sell a wine. Same thing.
Sell a wine token. Just the bonuses are different because you don't have stars or orange cards. So they're here, but the selling the wine is the same. This is I won on this uh expert last night. So, this is a great one selling if you're selling a champagne from your large seller. So, you're getting six points for selling a champagne. It's pretty spectacular. And then filling a wine order. Um it's just nice that it's moved over that one spot cuz it was kind of annoying in two-player game not to have get be able to get the victory point. So, it's moved it over so you have extra bonuses there. And then the catchall one is just gain a LRA where here you could gain a LRA and orange card because you had them. So what Bordeaux does if you really want to play with structures, you get four structure cards at the beginning to put into your hand. Remember at the end of the year you still have to go down to seven cards, but you can you start with some structures that if you want to put them in and then also there's a lot more of these where you can get any card you want. So then it, you know, you could grab an orange card there. Um, the last kind of main part you should note about this board and kind of a rule adjustment. If you've ever played with Tuskanyany or maybe even base viculture, I don't have as much experience with that one. At the beginning of the game, you always feel like your money is so tight cuz you have to do the structures, you have to get your workers, and then by the end of the game, you're you have your residuals going, you have all this extra LRA. So what Bordeaux does is end
of the final year you convert wine and grapes to lera. So each wine for its value and each grape for its sale price and every 10 lera becomes a point. So it does make it that you're not getting that lera for no reason. Um I think a lot of us had got at least one extra point from that last night. Sometimes you might get two, but it is kind of another interesting little piece and makes it so you don't like waste all your LRA, but also doesn't make it overpowered as well. So, we have found so far in our few games, it's been a good balance. So far, I've played a couple times at two and I've played at five. And I would say the jump start definitely helps. Last night, we were playing five players. two people had never played any vida culture before and uh we threw them off the deep end and they played with everything and they typically played good a quite a bit of games so they were they did fine they you know it took them a little bit to get the feeling of it but they were able to easily go into Bordeaux and honestly without the TH5 player this was definitely under under two hours and that was at a game day with a lot of people was kind of around so I'd say this might be a little bit faster faster than Tusky just cuz you get the kind of the head start here and you get a little bit more flexibility with the actions.
you have the experts helping you. But very much for right now, we're playing a lot of just Beraux just cuz it's new and we're figuring out new strategies. But I said it kind of Molly brought up it almost feels like you have a new clank board. So a way that's another twist on a game you love. So we'll I think eventually it'll just be like do I play Berdau or do we want to play Tuskanyany? And we'll be able to switch between those two and it'll be really nice. So, if you enjoy Tuscanyany, if you enjoy viticulture in general, I definitely highly recommend this one. Um, by no means would I say I would not get Tuskany because I love the special workers in Tuscanyany. I love the orange cards in Tuscany and we bring both of those over here and we play those with our Bordeaux. So, 100% great to have both in the collection.
Personally, I would still if I didn't have either, I'd probably still get Tuscany first just because I love those special workers so much and then I can put them in here. But that's kind of my opinion with just what we personally love with Viticulture and Tuskany. Like I think the special workers are one of my favorite things. So I do like that we can bring that into Bordeaux and I think it enriches that experience as well. But those are the different boards. If you have any questions, please let us know. As I said, this is kind of one of those games that we know very well. So, it was nice to get just something different to make us rethink how we play Vida Culture. But I hope that was helpful and let me know what action or piece of Borderaux you're most excited about. And we'll see you next time. I will also get a solo playthrough in. Bye.