Skip to main content
Loading video...

It's Time to Say Goodbye to Air Hockey

Transcript 36:55

this video is sponsored by skillshare hello puck fans i know what you're thinking where is the game of the year video it's it's coming okay it's the next one and i know for a fact you're also thinking afgha's finally lost it i mean surely air hockey is sacred right well if air hockey is indeed so good answer me this why haven't you got a table this is obviously a leading question one that totally failed on the six people who are watching this and do actually own an air hockey table and if you are one of them congratulations you win i will be sending you your prize as soon as the pandemic is over if you're a person who's really into air hockey if you know about things like regulation sizes or the usaa or ahpa then this video is probably not for you this video is for people who like me always wanted to enjoy air hockey casually but never had the means to first of all if you want an actual air hockey table like the one you find at arcades that's going to cost you somewhere in the region of a thousand bucks if you want one that's good you're looking at three and a half grand that's just straight up unaffordable to most people but even if you save up money for it you then have to put it somewhere and those things are the size of big dining

tables the average person in polite society has enough room in their lodgings for 1.2 dining tables which means that if you do furnish yourself with one and you want to have guests over for dinner you'll be crowding your plates on a cardboard box in reality you're more likely to find an air hockey table in the lobby of a hip tech startup than in someone's actual home aha but what if i buy one of those smaller ones you might say well i bought one and let me share my comprehensive opinion on it i don't need to tell you that this miniature version is awful you probably already intuited that but if we look at why this isn't something that anyone should be spending any money on we get to see why air hockey is great and how we can acquire an alternative that's manageable affordable and perhaps just as good just in slightly different ways first of all unless you get one that you can plug into the mains it eats batteries like a starving jack russell and i should know i only jack russell and i keep having to buy new batteries it eats the batteries to fulfill the requisite part of air in the name air hockey strapped underneath is what is effectively a cpu fan blowing air through tiny little holes on the surface of the play area to

gently propel the puck as you launch it with your striker this is what creates that glide feeling removing the tension and friction between the two surfaces and whilst the miniature version completes that part of the brief it lacks in all the others air hockey is fun because you can make big wide swings if you shrink the size of the table you take all of that away holding these strikers feels weird and clunky they're far too small to get a good grip on and at the same time they're too big for the play area if i hold my striker here by the goal zone there's almost no chance the opposing player can score a goal that is stupid you also don't get the sense that you're holding an exquisite piece of engineering and craftsmanship i know air hockey tables can and do look like they've been constructed by a caffeinated child but i invite you to watch this youtube video on how they actually get made they're marvelous i think the reason that air hockey caught on in arcades is that it's incredibly approachable you don't need to teach me the rules i mean i know there are rules but i don't need to know them to enjoy it put me in front of a table and i instinctively know what to do but this is the final thing that cements air hockey into the throne of greatness despite its approachability it is a game of skill you can and will get better at it if you keep playing it with all of

that we have a sort of a list of what we want from an approachable air hockey alternative it should feel like air hockey this one seems obvious so let me expound on that you should face another person with symmetrical opposition on a table where you can score a goal with a park and ideally it has a wild pace it should have an exquisite build if you're gonna have these tables in your house they might as well look nice it shouldn't take up too much space but the space that it does take up should be in line with how the game was designed to be played it should be self-evident how to play without knowing how to play it should be a game of skill and there's an unspoken number six it should be fun that's sort of a given any game should be fun and this is trying to tell you some sort of a philosophical moral tale where not having fun is the point but i don't think we're gonna get that with air hockey alternatives the good news is that we have not one not two not three but four potential candidates and my money is that you'll leave this video with at least one of them in your shopping basket what better way to start this video than with a game that literally has the word

hockey in its title here's the thing depending on where you are based geographically you either know this game all too well and were born in places like canada or you've literally never heard of it but today i don't want to just talk about rod hockey i want to talk about a very specific type of rod hockey first let's do a general brief to the uninitiated rod hockey might seem like a close relative of foosball each side has a team of hockey players with horrifically melted plastic faces appropriate giving the existential dread of realizing that you are forced to eternally live on a hockey rink and you can only move via the whims of a steel metal rod attached to your feet that's manipulated by a giant person looming over you to those who are initiated and are asking me efka what are you even talking about does rod hockey even belong as an alternative to air hockey isn't it its own thing with variable sizes of tables yes you are right sorry but the whole point of alternatives is that they're not like the original they just evoke elements of the original hopefully in a good way you face another person on a symmetrical hockey rink and try to score a goal with a puck in a fast frenetic game it is self-evident how to play i steer my existentially cursed men with a rod to launch the puck into my opponent's goal zone no one had to explain that to me

and it is an incredibly skillful game we'll elaborate on that later admittedly this table does look bunk it's plasticky bendy and has all the panache of a nascar race car without the benefits of it being a car believe me i tried sitting and driving in this thing it just doesn't work it's also bigger than all the other alternatives in this video but if you recall the original criteria specifies that the play surface should be designed to be the size it is well with many different variations of rod hockey you might think that just like an air hockey the bigger the table size the better and that is simply not true in fact many recognize that the best rod hockey table is this one manufactured by stiga and whilst they do have some variants they all conform to this exact size and shape which means that you can affordably enjoy the best that raw hockey has to offer in the comfort of your own home which leaves us with one question left to answer what makes rod hockey so great let's examine the physicality of play each side controls exactly six figurines one goalie and five i don't know what a hockey player is called i'm guessing it's hawkster or

parker i'm gonna go with hogster it sounds less rude each side controls exactly six figurines one goalie and five hogsters crucially not all hocksters are located on your side of the table and the placement isn't static but moves on predefined lines carved into the surface of the table by pulling a rod corresponding to the hoxster you make that hoxster travel along the predefined carved line however if you spin the rod by turning it counter and or clockwise you then in turn spin the hulkster thus manipulating their stick this is how you hit the puck what makes rod hockey different and objectively better than foosball is that the game isn't limited to these two modes on a basic level in foosball you can either move the players or kick the ball there's more nuance like holding or passing but there is no overt third layer which is that in rod hockey you can travel with the park this is precisely what makes the stigger rod hockey tables so great each path has been carved with thought and precision it's not an arbitrary slit it's game design as the hawkster travels along its lines they reach different invisible zones some areas are where they can intersect with different opposing hosters whereas others leave them safe with no interception possible each hawkster you pass to has different

potential some are safer but lean towards the edge of the table to use a sports term they are open i know sports i know a little bit of sport others have much better potential to steal a puck from the opponent but only by the virtue of being in a very busy center so to play rod hockey well you have to be smart but you can only be smart with experience you have to know this field and all of these players intimately and on top of that manipulating these hogsters requires precision and finesse you can make ludicrously fast spins to hit the puck hard and scoring a goal like that is a satisfaction few dexterity games can offer but you can also be gentle gliding through the ring with elegant moves it will come as no surprise that i'm nowhere near good at rod hockey to show off these moves but here's a video of a master at work just look at how casual his body language is as he's making these intricate smooth maneuvers that to me seem nearly impossible and as much as i admire that this leads us to why rod hockey might not necessarily be the best replacement for air hockey i'm not going to say that this game isn't fun if you're not good at it because that's simply not true but every time i play it i feel like this game relentlessly wants me to get better it

is by far the least accessible game in our video just because it requires so much manual dexterity and finesse and if your opponent isn't quite on the same level as you you really feel it even if you're just like a little bit better you're not playing a game you're trancing them and that's fine if you want to get really good at it but you need a partner that is equally invested because practicing on your own isn't even possible and even if it were you just get too good and other people wouldn't want to play against you because it wouldn't be fun

to sue the bomb of harsh competition here comes a game that has a total 180 of rod hockey a game whose name i won't say out loud because the algorithm will think i'm saying something else and it will mess up adsense you don't need to squint hard to see the similarities between air hockey and there's a rink there's parks there's even a gold zone albeit this one is shared and it's right at the center of the field also there's 16 packs and each player has a peculiar string can you guess what happens next that's right you press a puck against the string to then use the tension to propel it through the gold zone into your opponent's area the packs are divided evenly at the start of the game eight to each player and all you have to do to win is to end up with no pucks on your side of the board are there any other rules well aside from high-tenning your opponent before the game starts and pausing the game as soon as a puck leaves the board entirely no which means most of the time you're just wildly swinging a wooden puck with a string which let me tell you is great at first glance might seem mindless all that matters is speed counterbalanced by the need of a little bit of accuracy getting the puck through the generously wide gap isn't particularly hard and the ceaseless moving and launching of puck is to use a

scientific term fun so that's what you do move a park launch it move another park launch it move the same park launch three things can happen as a result one you miss in which case you curse yourself in your head and nab the puck and launch it again two you don't miss in which case you telepathically hear your opponent curse in their head and then you nab a new puck and launch it free the perk gets lodged in the gold zone in which case both you and your opponent start hearing an alarm bell inside of your heads what's important to acknowledge at this point is that of course as you're frenetically grabbing and launching your opponent is doing the same thing at the same time suddenly you realize that maybe you should slow down maybe you should time your shot to hit your opponent's puck as it's moving through the gap so that your puck hits it right back into their zone or maybe you're too late and now their puck is already in your zone and also it's blocking your path so what you should do is not launch your puck but pick theirs up by hand and launch it back at them but then hubris overtakes you you think you can do it you think you can score that one in a million shot and of course you miss and then your opponent launches yet another park into your zone so to summarize it definitely

feels like air hockey it's a lovely handmade wooden thing that feels sturdy the string feels good plus the makers claim to replace it for free if it ever becomes too loose and in addition you get two of these if you ever need to defending yourself in life against tiny vampires or alternatively to just tighten the tension of the string there we go tiger now the size is designed with the experience in mind and it is the smallest game in our compendium it's incredibly obvious how to play take a puck launch it with a string only a full would need this explained which absolutely makes me a fool because i thought first you have to like ping the string and then use the tension to launch the pack on its own i was overthinking it so it is incredibly obvious how to play unless you're me which brings us to number five is it a skillful game and remember i said this is a complete 180 of rod hockey well is skillful but the tricks and moves you learn aren't particularly fun or make the whole experience better for example the manual and by manual i of course mean a miniature christmas card that i can't show you because i threw it away the manual says that you can use one of your hands to permanently tug on the string whilst your other hand launches the puck with

greater force i have tried this trick and i have successfully achieved a greater degree of finger pain the other tip you get at the desperate attempt to clutch at the straw of skillfulness is launching pucks with both hands sequentially one after the other therefore increasing speed and here i do have to admit that i once again successfully achieved a greater degree of finger pain which brings us to a simple verdict is pretty neat just don't expect the experience to be long lived however if all you're looking for from an air hockey replacement is to just muck around with some pucks from time to time with a friend you couldn't get a better bargain

every good compendium needs an oddball entry something left field something that doesn't quite fit the mold well what's more oddball than a mashup delivered on a lazy susan first of all let me say i wish more games were delivered in rotatable form gone would be the days of precautiously leaning over the table i could just spin the pieces towards myself by now you're probably wondering what is karuka and the answer to that is surprisingly simple it's snooker with packs that you flick on a circular board however there is a touch more going on here the name karuka is a portmanteau of snooker and quran the latter being a game that's popular pretty much across the entire world with variants emerging from america japan south africa and mexico but originating from india and snooker well it's nuker isn't it yet karuka takes on more elements than just those two for example both snuko and karam are played on square or rectangular boards whereas this adapts the circular board of crocodile a game inspired by karom first originating in canada i imagine some of you are more familiar with crocodile and are wondering why we're not just discussing crocodile and there are two answers none of which have anything to do that i can't actually afford a crocodile board

yes it's a tried and tested design beloved by many but first of all crocodile was already covered exceptionally well by the um rivals i'm kidding they're not rivals there's no competition here we're much better second whilst crocodile is very good there's something so intimately familiar about the snooker part of karuka that i think transcends generations if you have a relative who used to play snooker back in the day this will be easily something you can bond over that was the worst break it obviously doesn't feel like air hockey again this is the oddball entry air hockey is fast and frantic karuka is slow and measured the game is turn based so you have all the time in the world to take aim it creates real tension you watch your opponent you watch their eyes the beads of sweat that form on their brow before they finally commit to the flick it's such a great moment and so familiar to anyone who's played any kind of a pool game but presented here in a much more accessible fashion but also one that's a lot more intimate there's something really special about this board it's handmade it's wooden it's luxurious the board itself comes in two finishes we went with a classic snooker

table green but you can also opt for cocky if for some reason you want more of that colonial explorer vibe i don't know i don't really get it but you do you when it comes to size here's where karuka gets weird it comes in two different sizes three if you count the tournament version we got the larger one which poses a storage challenge and there's certainly more cumbersome but we suspected it would be a touch more skillful ultimately the two size options are pretty nice to have because you can tailor what you buy to who you'll be playing with believe me landing these packs ain't easy and it's intuitive but only if you're familiar with the rules of snooker and even then there's some caveats snooker isn't the easiest rule set to remember child's play if you're a regular at the pool hall i'm sure many of you are but more mystifying if you're only familiar from a distance there's a lot of wait a minute how does that work again and an occasional bout of translation confusion trying to piece out how the rules of snooker would work in this different iteration something that the included rule book doesn't elaborate on much and this is where we arrive at the real beauty of karuka and the real reason we decided to include it in this list is just so much fun getting good at

kuruka and every shot you make involves one puck bouncing into another puck and as we mentioned before it's much harder than it seems not quite as hard as actual snooker balls though which gives this the edge in approachability but still retaining what makes snooker so good you're still making the same decisions evaluating the board relative position of pucks measuring up what shots you think are possible and what aren't and you still get the satisfaction of snookering your opponent you get to wear that glib expression on your face handing them an impossible move even though you engineered it entirely by accident it's really good plus you can practice on your own which i have been doing a lot and i'm still rubbish here's some not so fun things about kuruka whilst significantly cheaper than crocodile it's still an expensive thing and the most expensive game in this video with boards ranging from 125 pounds to 147.5 pounds without shipping it is only available in the uk and if you're upset that we just sold you on a game that you can't buy well get croquenol instead tables are available all across the world and crocodile is just as good at creating spectacularly tense moments yet remaining a very skillful game even if you can't lazy susan them you really

can't once you sit down you cannot lift your bottom according to the official rules and just in case you're wondering why crocodile is so expensive well each board is treated with seven to eight layers of wax significantly reducing friction and allowing the pucks to glide effortlessly karom and karuka boards are not treated like that and instead use carom powder to reduce friction the problem here is that caron powder is just another way of saying boric acid which is toxic and we at mpi do not recommend using it in fact we found it a bit disappointing that the makers of karuka gleefully sell and will even include a free sample of disco carom powder which according to the website are little tiny spheres that essentially put roller skates under your counters to make them really fly now that sounds nice until you read on further where it says that disco caron powder is just finely ground teflon what's wrong with teflon aren't kitchen pans made out of teflon well it's not quite that simple but there's significant evidence out there to suggest that teflon is pretty bad for you and whilst i can't guarantee that that's the case if i were you i would be very cautious with using something like that that's it enough concessions class is everything you ever wanted out of an

affordable and manageable air hockey alternative let's make this check mark part quick class smashes every single category to perfection okay there's one compromise there's no park it's a ball but otherwise this game is perfect i think it's genuinely better than air hockey in class you'll try and land the ball in your opponent's goal zone which is a little round cut out hole in the surface of the table the only way you manipulate the ball is with a little striker that sits at the surface of the table however you move it with a magnetized counterpart underneath the table seems like a gimmick i assure you that it isn't it's absolutely what makes this game consider that this version of toddler air hockey is about the same size in table surface yet manipulating it feels clunky and weird whereas playing with class feels abundantly wild skillful and fun in part this is because there's no hand looming over the surface area nothing crowds it and the striker is free to glide around the entirety of the playfield this is then further assisted by swapping out the puck for a ball which doesn't require a smooth surface or airflow to achieve speed making it frenetic but also cheaper to manufacture and free of reliance on toxic chemicals

i can't i can't believe that that is an actual point that i had to make there's one final element that rounds all of this out and i think it's my favorite thing about class you think about it you have this fast freewheeling game where people go bam bam bam bam bam and that's neat but what if the juxtapose that the entire playfield was littered with traps at the beginning of each round of class you will place three in the parlance of classic enthusiasts biscuits each biscuit is a little plastic cylinder with a magnetic core if your striker ever approaches a biscuit it will permanently latch onto it like a parasitic face hugger i've been watching alien a lot lately one biscuit on your striker is fine however if you get two you immediately lose the round and the point goes to your opponent which is where you go that's fine it's not gonna go near the center stay in this area except it is perfectly fine and strategically encouraged to launch the ball into the biscuits sending them into your opponent's play area

defending your goal zone is pretty easy in an unincumbered playfield it's much harder to whip back a speedy ball when any time you move to the right you could die class has diametrically opposed points of design tension yet it never tugs on either of them too hard to stretch it out and make it feel flabby first of all it's obviously skillful because there's just so many things you can become good at you can get more precise increasing accuracy with your striker you can get good at launching the biscuits into your opponent i didn't manage to do that this time get good at defending you can even learn how to launch a biscuit with the striker without it attaching itself just like that but second whilst all of that is happening from the very first moment you sit down to play class you cannot help but laugh riotously it's just such a rip roaring funny time there's almost a slapstick quality to everything that happens in this game the ball zipping about biscuits flying everywhere the striker falling apart and you desperately clamoring for the magnets to reattach before the opponent scores a goal if you remove your striker into your own goal zone that's you immediately forfeiting the point to your opponent so tactically that's yet another trap on the field but when it happens there is this clock as the striker detaches itself and the

magnetic force pulls it to the bottom again it's funny because it's sudden loud unmistakable and it means you lost you have to be dead inside not to laugh at that which means that class is great whether you're good at it bad at it whether your opponent is of equal skill or not you are never having a bang time all the meanwhile you feel like you're mastering something more and more it is literally like someone took air hockey and said what if we make it faster gamier funnier and kept the price at 45 pounds for the purposes of disclosure unlike the other games in this list class was sent to us by the publisher whereas we purchased the others ourselves and you should definitely take that into consideration since i am being very effusive about it it was however sent to us two years ago with no expectation of courage and i'm pretty sure the people who make class have forgotten about us yet for all this time myself and elaine have been enjoying class and looking for an opportunity to give it the spotlight that it deserves and i suppose if you wanted you could view this video as us glorifying it in the face of its competitors but whilst i do think class has universal appeal i think the other three games have their own strengths get stigger rod hockey if you enjoy mastering finesse get pocket if you want something super casual get crocodile or karuka if you want

something methodical and chill and get class if you enjoy having fun not a single one of these tables is ever leaving my home and hey if you enjoyed this video you can always support us on patreon we're just two people doing a home-grown thing by donating a little bit every month you'll get access to bonus videos a very lovely discord server and knowing that you're making our journey through tabletop gaming a reality we promise to never ever use your money to become a hip tech startup with a full-size air hockey table in their lobby we'll use our sponsor money for that instead what i really like about our sponsor skillshare is that it's a community for endless exploration within you will find thousands of inspiring classes on things you might want to learn or things you haven't yet realized that you might want to learn from finally figuring out how to snap a pretty picture to relearning something you've long forgotten like crochet i remember really enjoying learning how to crochet in school but being a boy in lithuanian the 90s meant that i was encouraged to pursue other interests well i'm no longer bound by that nonsense and can explore and learn whatever interest i like on skillshare i found a professional beginner level class modern crochet essential skills for getting started that taught me how to begin where to begin and what to begin with and explained what i do next and look at me now i've crocheted this

okay i didn't really crochet that that was just a present from a friend but someday that's the beauty of skillshare i don't have to worry about rushing or pushing myself i can take structured courses at a leisurely pace dipping in and trying as many different subjects as i like all of them ad-free not sure skill shows for you the first 1000 people to click the link in the description will get a one month free trial of skillshare so you can explore and learn however much you like

bye wow uh so

so you

Progress saved