Brass Review
Transcript
everybody welcome to drive to review 632 today I'm going to talk about brass there's two versions that you can see my hands here first you have brass Lancashire which is kind of a remake of the old edition of brass which is more than ten years old I believe and you've got here brass Birmingham which is a completely new game it's not an expansion for this one or vice versa so I'm gonna feature mostly brass Birmingham because that's kind of the new kid on the block kind of idea but I will definitely refer to them in contrast and tell you a little bit about what's different what's new you know what makes them kind of different from each other and all that kind of stuff so the original brass is a relatively heavy weight gyro where you're building up various different shipping industries and sort of ancillary industries to kind of support that and then it's all driven by card play so you have this hand of cards that sort of restricts and maybe molds your actions a little bit and so that's carried through in both of these new versions now there's some different industries in Birmingham as opposed to what's featured in Lancashire but it's very much a car driven heavy euro so that's an interesting sort of mash up that you don't really see a lot of even today so let's go ahead and jump in I'm gonna give you a sort of brief kind of idea of how the game works I don't want to mire in all the details because frankly even though I'm saying it's
heavy and all that kind of stuff it's pretty straightforward there are some sort of idiosyncrasies we'll still try to highlight and but I would just want to recommend rowdy Smitha to watch a plate of the new version and that's a pretty exhaustive rules overview and the rules themselves aren't bad at all to learn this kind of give you that kind of comment upfront definitely if you have played the original brass this one obviously will be very easy to pick up it's basically the same game there's some minor changes to some certain things and some adjustments based on player count that the original didn't have and then this one if you've played the original or Lancashire then you'll be able to pick this up now this is definitely the more complex of the two there's I think two more basically industries that you can manipulate as opposed to this one so let's jump in and look at how it works a little bit and then I will come back here and give you my thoughts okay so here you can see the board I've got some of the different iron and coal tokens that is set up over there you can see here if i zoom in there are various cities they're connected by either rivers and railroads or sometimes they're just connected by one or the other so this one you can see is just connected by a river and then they have various different industries that you can develop and build there so players like I said are going to get a hand of cards so for example I have this one here at Dudley and when I play this card or some one of my actions I can go ahead and do a building in this Dudley area so
I could build either the iron or the coal industry so that's one type of car that you can play one of the location the other type you can play are these industry cards here and you can see here the icon and the upper corners there so if I wanted to play this then I could theoretically build a coal plant there now the interesting thing about this kind of the main takeaway is if you have a location card then you can build there no matter what if you play one of these cards to build a specific type of industry then you have to be connected to it and you can be connected to it in a few different ways most of the time you're going to be connected to it through these canal tokens here you can see these are actually double-sided so in the first sort of half of the game you'll be building canals and the other half then you'll be building rail lines there so let's say we built that canal there and maybe prior to that we had built this manufacturing industry here so we can only build a canal adjacent to a spot where we either have an industry or we had already connected into there from some other spot so let's say we have come in here we'd build some industries up there and then build some canals coming down here and then now this will allow us then to access this was this card where again if we play this specific location we can kind of break that rule it doesn't matter if we're connected to it so that's kind of the general gist of that rule in terms of how these different cards work now you are going to be also discarding these cars to take other actions so for example if you want to take a loan you can discard any card you want if you want to build a canal or a rail and the
second phase of the game then you also will be discarding a card there's a develop action which I'll talk about in just a minute to do that you've got a discard a card if you want to pass then you must also discard a card so everything you're going to be doing you're going to be discarding cards so in the first round of the game everybody gets one action so you just discard one card and do whatever it's for in future rounds you're going to be doing two actions per turn now it's worth noting that the first time you do a build action somebody the first action on of your whole game you could go ahead and do this anywhere you want because you won't have any pieces on the board in that case if you have nothing on the board then you can go ahead and kind of break that rule and build a coal industry wherever it's convenient and then at the end of your turn you're gonna draw two more cards back up into your hand limit of eight and then keep going now you're gonna be playing through this deck of cards now once this deck runs out players are gonna continue to play cards from their hand until everybody has played all the cards and then that's when we go into Phase two so in phase one the first trip through this deck in that case you're only going to be building canals here once you go through the deck you're gonna be in Phase two all the canals and the level one technologies so you can see this one here this level one manufacturing building you can see the level right there level one then all of those are gonna get wiped off the board at that point you're only going to be building railways and then only level 2 and higher technologies so one other aspect
of the buildings I want to show you here is when you build them they're going to be with this kind of face up side and then each of the different building types is going to have some kind of event or reason that they're going to trigger in this case it's a manufacturing building and when you ship this which you can also discard a card to take a ship action and when you do a ship action you can ship multiple of your industries on the board not just one per card then you're going to flip it over now you can see here this requires you to actually have a barrel that you can access a barrel of B in this case and so I'll explain a little bit about that and in a minute I want to get too much detail but if you've got a barrel access to a barrel then you can flip that if you do the ship action and then at this point you're gonna see a couple of things now these two little kind of rail icons there that means these are going to score points for anybody that's connected to the city is going to be two points basically for each rail that you have connected to the city it's going to immediately increase your income by five and then at the end of the round once we go through the deck it's going to give you three points and all of the buildings have this kind of thing so over here you can see each player's got a victory point tracker and then they also have an income tracker now as you score the different buildings in this case you can see that your income there is going to go up by five so this would actually move up five spots and then every turn so every time you do your two actions you're gonna get more and more income as you go so these are gonna help you you know collect income to spend money to actually pay for the buildings
and so on and then a certain point you're gonna kind of pivot away from the money collection because your income should be pretty high depending on how you're playing the game and then you're gonna try to go after some of the points that maybe don't give you as much income but they give you more points and that kind of thing now another cool idiosyncrasy and everything that I'm talking about so far is in both games except for the whole barrel concept these barrels that are required for shipping and some other things that does not exist in Lancashire this is just Birmingham now but everything else is pretty much the same so one other similarity between the two games is you have these little kits here in your player color so as you spend money you're gonna put that actually on these little faces here and then you're gonna reorganize these based on who overspent the least we'll be going first and so on now the money in this edition is really cool this is the deluxe edition that I'm showing you here and if you see here each of the editions comes with this little rack of poker tips which are really nice you can see you've got ones fives tens 20s and so on the kind of the basic retail version comes with cardboard kits so that's kind of one of the main feature differences there and I believe I'm 90% sure that if you want this edition here with these cool poker chips you can only buy those direct from the publisher on their website so here we can see a player board and these are all the different levels of different industries that exist in the game and you can see like here we have the breweries here this is the level one there's a couple of these and then it's
a there's a little bit of a bear of a setup it's not too bad once you've done it say at level one two three four of all these and this goes one to eight all the way up here and you can see there are multiples of some of these and single ones of the others so you spend a little bit of time kind of organizing these on your player board now the language share board that's going to be a quick look at you can see this one's a little bit simpler one two three four five kind of different technologies and industries there that says one two three four five six but there's a couple of different ones that you can ship and things like that so it's a little bit more complex here especially once you add the barrels and stuff like that but one of the actions I talked about was develop you can you can discard a card from your hands and develop and that simply is discarding one or two of one of your low-level industries and you can do that from separate industry so I could do one brewery and then one cotton mill and so on and then as you do that you're gonna then sort of like level up your technologies and get quicker access you don't actually have to build some of these low level ones if you don't want sometimes it's good to do building them and sometimes it's better to develop and get access to the higher ones quicker now some of these however you can't do so in this one you can see this little lightbulb with the cross this means you can actually develop you have to actually build this particular industry there now to do the develop you're going to need iron and in some cases if we look at some of these buildings here if we zoom in when you actually build them
not only is there a monetary cost there's also a cost of coal or in this case iron and it's kind of funny because iron needs coal and coal needs iron and so you need to have access to those materials and unlike most games you don't go buy and sell coal and iron and then kind of convert and turn that into buildings which turns into victory points the way that you get that is one of the unique things about both editions of this game of brass so let's say for example we wanted to build all things being equal this coal factory here now we want to build that now this costs us $8 in an iron so we need to get access to iron now you can see when you build these different industries here so this one actually will come with four coal on it so we're gonna put three four on there and then let's say another player on a previous turn had built this ironworks here this is a level three ironworks and they had some iron on there like that so having built this forget about the adjacency of the railroads and everything let's just kind of abstractly look at this scenario then this costs an iron so I need to get iron from somewhere so I can take iron anywhere on the board now if it was on my building I'd prefer to take that but let's say there's an idea having built in your iron then I would take an iron from somebody else and just take it off and spend it and throw it into the discard pile now if this building did not exist then I would have to buy it here from the market and you can see a stuff gets
kind of bought up then it's gonna get more and more and more expensive okay that's great but the other player in this case the purple player they want to have their iron taken they don't care if they're helping you build this because once you clear a building of iron that's when this particular thing flips over so the different goods and manufacturing in the beer bells and shop you want to do a shipping action to ship those to different ports and then those will flip over it but these you want to sort of build supporting industries to kind of support all these other kind of industries that are round so in this case once that last iron good has taken off they're gonna get to income it'll become a scoring building and then again they'll get seven points themselves and it works a similar here way with a coal once the coal flips over our coal gets dispersed on the coal flip over now the interesting thing about iron is you can just take it from anywhere you don't have to be connected to it however coal if you require coal which this building does this ironworks requires coal then you have to be connected to a coal source to get it so this case let's say it was reversed this had been built previously maybe some of these have been already removed and I want to build this and requires iron well I can't build it in this context because it's not connected to any coal source so if I had a railroad or a canal here then what would happen is I would take this and drag it along and then grab it now this could be far away it doesn't have to go over my rails and go over other pleasure rails you just have to connect to it somehow or you have to connect to a distant port so we're just
going to zoom over here you can see these there's a couple of spots like this you can see these are a little scoring icon so you are going to score points if you connect to it with your rail or canal and it has this little symbol here which means you can get coal out of it so the coal here though comes from the market here and again you've got to pay the cost now the other interesting aspect here is if I build an ironworks and let's say some iron had been bought off there then immediately as I build it these will start to go and populate the market and you're going to get this money back so if I built this I would get three six eight ten bucks right away for building it and then of course there's no iron on this and that would flip over so again the iron doesn't have to be connected but when I built a coal if these were clear off it's the same idea but I have to be able to draw a line back to a faraway port and then load this up and it only happens at the time I build it so if you connect to it later they don't start coming off automatically it's got to be empty at the time of the build so just this interlocking kind of mechanism here is very very interesting so for example if I wanted to build this ceramic factory here now this cost you $17.90 is a lot good and ten points which is a lot of points very early in the game so these supporting industries here the coal and the iron and to a certain degree the breweries here are very very
key to getting an access to some of the more larger point-scoring things and then players are always using each other's buildings and things now let's talk quickly about the barrels and then I'll kind of leave it so here you can see shipping locations here Oxford and then over here go out Chester okay so to ship here you need to have some kind of or railroads going into there doesn't have to be yours you just have to be able to draw a line contiguously to their from whatever manufacturing or cotton type of thing that you're shipping and you can see this port here it'll take manufacturing or it'll take anything so well not almost anything so it'll take the manufacturing the cotton and the ceramics whereas this one is just ceramics and this one actually is inactive because you can see actually shuffle these up and then mix them around and it depends on the player count which ones you'll be using so in a two-player game you won't add this one to the shuffle and you can also see here these locations will vary these are used in any player count whereas these here are also using any player count but there's some on here that you know aren't used so the sort of place that you can ship certain goods is going to change from game to game now most stuff not everything is going to require you have access to a beer barrel to ship to it now at the start of each round so each face so in the canal face and then in the rail phase the places that have a valid shipping icon we're going to get seated with a barrel
so you don't really need to have access to a barrel on the board you can just go ahead and use this one and then it also will give you a free bonus action as well so when you do that you can get a free develop or free to income now later on they're going to be barrels out here on the board at different locations so if we go up here if somebody had built a brewery there and you could draw a line back to them then you can take that barrel off and again you're gonna then flip the brewery and for that player and flip that over now if it's your own brewery you don't actually have to be connected to it you can just take it from anywhere on the board so that's kind of interesting so again it's another kind of supporting industry to support that kind of the workers and having like pubs for them to visit as they do things and get the goods down the canals are down the rails so really there's a couple of other kind of details and things frankly but that is really the gist of the game as heavy it is it's not that heavy on the complexity side certainly it's heavy in terms of what do I do what's the right move all that kind of good stuff okay so that was Brad mostly Birmingham a little bit talk of like a share in there so I have my three pillars I've played three and four players I've not tried to players I have played two player Lancashire and that actually worked very very well they both have similar rules it's kind of an update for Lancashire and of course new for Birmingham where you take out certain cards out of the deck you sort of isolate certain locations that you can
still get to but there's no location cards for those you can still if you play you know the different industry cards to the branch out you can still get to some of those locations it's just much harder so the map is somewhat shrunk down for two and three players and there's a couple of little kind of reminder things and like assured that are different which I didn't talk about but the game scales really well like I said Evan played Birmingham with two but i played length short too and it worked very very well there's actually a BoardGameGeek variant that floated around for years that they also include in the rulebook there which I've never tried so it's very nice and refreshing to know that brass now works very well I think at least with Lancashire for two players because typically it was a three and four player game and that's all it was which was no problem that's just how it is but it's nice to be able to kind of get a little bit of that exam experience at the two-player count I will say in terms of the player count I think the best player count is certainly four although I don't really begrudge the two or the three player count you're still going to be interacting with the other players that the different player counts you know you're still going to be kind of subsisting each other with down even oh that's right way with the different industries and you know playing off of each other that way with the iron and the coal and the beer and all that stuff so there's just like a lot more of that going on with four players and it just feels a little bit more lively which is everybody's kind of got their fingers and all the different stuff so definitely I prefer four player
but I could totally see it if you're mainly like a two player gamer take a look at it I think I think you'll like it and you'll enjoy it and you'll get a lot out of it in terms of the play time gosh I wouldn't say more than three hours and obviously it's gonna depend how much the people you've playing are playing with how much they played at how much they kind of understand of it and the player counts gonna come and deploy two players is certainly gonna go quicker than four players the four players I mean it's kind of like the same number of actions because you just burning through the deck although you're taking out certain number of cards so I think mathematically they're gonna be kind of close but the decision space and how much the board is gonna change is gonna be less with two players so that's gonna sort of cut down on your sort of okay let me reanalyze the board on my turn kind of stuff but I think once people have learned the game it's gonna get much closer to that two-hour mark even at the four player count so that's about the ballpark in terms of the play time now the other sort of third pillar of my reviews is what is it like and it's like a lot of euros sort of but it's also not like a lot of euros so you have the card driven thing which you see some of I mean you got like London it's not really the same as London which another Martin Wallace game gosh there's some other euros that did use carts so
like Lewis and Clark which is an older game that's kind of fallen by the wayside different more games that you're doing sort of very kind of efficient action you know parsing things where you're trying to you know find these like path to victory and points and efficiency of scoring income and all that kind of stuff right the whole euro thing but nothing really compares to brass now this age of Industry which is basically please don't like get into the pedantic argument with me on the YouTube or whatever but it's basically the same game as brass I know there's like people that like like aging industry more versus brass and then they want to argue about the math but that doesn't concern me age I used to be an agent industry guy actually I liked agent industry more than brass because only simply because it's a little bit more streamlined sort of and you had different maps that you could play it on and that was cool so that's one of the things this has that the old brass didn't have it was kind of you know the other one you can kind of like get into it and play it and just figure it out and it's kind of have like you sort of get into it's almost like a rut and with their strategy whereas age industry you got different sort of technologies and stuff like that you could go and play the same system and the cards weren't like named for locations the cards are sort of color-coded for different areas of locations on the board so that was cool so you could reuse the same cards and everything and play on different Maps now this is cool because especially the Birmingham one the lecture one has two
maps on both sides the Birmingham one has those kind of juggled shipping locations so that's gonna really kind of change things up and there's so many like industries that are in there that you can kind of get behind and sort of focus on one industry versus another I think the replayability and stuff is gonna be much higher with Birmingham and that's not to say like original brass wasn't replayable it definitely was it's just that you know the experience was kind of the same like it would take you several plays to get to the point where it was less replayable and that's why it's a really good game so that kind of didn't really run out with Asian industry you could you could just throw in a map and play the South Africa map and then play that like 10 times and then switch it back and forth but yeah so we're getting back to my point of you know what's a game like this there's not really a game like this and you look like you know somebody says the other day when we were playing they're like oh brass is like a pickup and delivery game and it's like yeah but not really it's not like Steam or some train game or something like that where you're picking up Goods and delivery and shipping it it's it has that I mean you can play card and ship your industry and you go through the stuff but the whole like supporting industry idea of I build iron and because the iron markets depleted all the iron sucks out to sea and I sell it right away or there's a bunch of iron on the board so now players start to build stuff that can eat the iron up and it sort of you know it's subsist it helps their industry
further along so that's sort of sort of like a cooperative kind of thing or player you feel like you're playing there in world with the other players in their actions really do kind of matter and sort of the state of the economy the supply and demand of iron and coal and just the general sort of activity and each of those kind of industries is you know informing all the other different industries I'm like oh well this is kind of happening here so maybe what I can do is I can open up a brewery here and you know there's there's an industry here there's a little sort of cottage niche so I can get into so that feels very much more realistic and more business you feel kind of feel like you're business savvy when you're doing that versus like parsing out kind of spatial math of this is three spaces away and this is four spaces away so I'm gonna do this and run run my cubes through this you you don't really have too much of that kind of abstract spatial stuff that's going on it's more of an abstract of supply and demand and that kind of thing now there's still like proximity and stuff and you want to be in the network but it gets less sort of County here and it frankly that's one adds to the theme of it and so kind of getting into that aspect of it why this game is so enjoyable in this kind of series of games the original brass agents trading down these or sort of I think like the pinnacle and I hope they do come out with more maps and things or or something like that at least new
versions of the game it's very thematic and it has a lot of like implications sort of towards like the industrial era and sort of that sort of new stage capitalism kind of vibe right because you have capitalism sort of is a theory and a concept on paper and then you have capitalism like in practice right and so capitalism and like industrialized capitalism like the Machine of capitalism is really what this game is sort of about now it's not really trying to make a sort of a judgment on it but you can sort of see the so the manipulative side of it which i think is interesting because it's really apparent I think because you add more industries in Birmingham as you have again you have like the iron and the coal that whole thing just like in Lancashire and then you have the other sort of supporting is shipping industries that are like hey they're shipping now there's trains that I can get stuff further away I don't have to just sell locally I can get it out there and so those become active because of those new industrial technologies and you kind of see those spring up and all the kind of you know leveling up of the technologies but really kind of brings it home with Birmingham is the whole brewery concept and the beer and we're like okay because you don't ever actually like ship the beer but you need it to kind of piggyback on your
shipments and stuff and there's some other things that you know will use up the beer if you want to do a double rail bill Britain didn't mention because they get in every every detail but later in the game you can discard a card and build not just one rail but two rails but you also need beer for that and then maybe this is me reading it reading into a little bit but when I floated this concept with my game group nobody said I was a dummy but I'll leave that to you to say to please no but so what the breweries you know sort of symbolize for me is oK you've got sort of the big conglomerate corporation running coal and iron in your you're like this big rich dude and you're into all these industries and then when your workers are done and they go home they buy beer at guess what your pub so they will work for you you will pay them in and they will give you the money right back as they go and shop at your grocery store or buy beer at your pub I was like hold this is a tricky little thing they put in here and I really like that because that's sort of the insidious snowball of you know runaway industrialized mechanized capitalism which doesn't have to be insidious but it can be so certainly I like that aspect of the game that a sort of sort of kind of glances a brush across that and yeah so that's a really neat kind of thematic thing it just kind of just it's like that extra little layer of that coat of stuff
because the whole like the thing of like building the the coal and iron stuff you don't really see that and a lot of you know the Euro games I'm sure like in the train games you can you sort of get that you kind of you sort of hint at that but that whole like I build this industry to this industry so many times now euro games are very much like I take this I build this and convert that into that cover at that and that covert that of that and then I get the victory points and I build my little engine of deck building or whatever and that's fine I enjoy some of those games this is different this is you reliant on other players you're very much bouncing off the other industries and trying to find your little niche and I think that's really cool cuz that's a lot of what business is really about it's sort of finding that little hole and then exploiting it yeah for a profit then that's what that's really all business ever really is because you can do things for fun and for spiritual pleasure and all that stuff as soon as you like you turn that crank up a little bit then you can find those little things and bounce stuff off and then theoretically make yourself rich so this the brass Birmingham really excels at that and it really excels at making itself replayable and the different things like I said about the different player counts and all that stuff so I think it's a fantastic game I definitely prefer brass Birmingham over Lancashire at this point for kind of the stuff I just talked about however I would say for a new player and this would go for me if I were with me and
all of my little brain faults and functions that I have if I was coming at these fresh Birmingham for me for sure would be super overwhelming if I had not played brass and agent industry a bunch then jumping right into Birmingham that would be crazy I mean I think I think I could do it I don't know if I could do it don't tell me if I've already talked for like 10 minutes have I made myself sound dumb enough that I couldn't do it I don't know but it would be rough so I would say if you're getting into like you know new gamers or whatever they don't play like a lot of heavy games Lancashire definitely is a great first step like sure still a great game I'm gonna keep both of them mostly because I can fit all of the stuff back in the one box if I couldn't do that then it would be a tougher choice but I keeping both but definitely if you put the two in front of me I'm gonna jump at Birmingham and at least for the time being now so kind of new and fresh I only played it a couple times but to me it just got lots of different layers I'm gonna have all those different avenues that I can explore for victory and all that kind of stuff and there's this gonna be a lie no like a lot of cool little moments of interaction and things that are gonna be fun so definitely recommend both games if you're like never play brass get like Asher and and go for that one and then maybe you know use that as a stepping stone to Birmingham because it's definitely more complex now once you've played Lancashire if you once you jump to Birmingham you might have the thought
of like Seoul said it was a lot more complex but it's not because but that's because I think you know theoretically this straw person you've already played Lancashire so Birmingham just that extra little bit of stuff to kind of gobble up and then fill out those blanks kind of thing so anyway so that's both brasses definitely high recommend if this is any more close to your alley like economic stuff euros heavy games that kind of stuff definitely look at it and if you kind of shy away from heavy games a little bit I think make sure probably is a good thing you know the rules are pretty straightforward I think yeah I already kind of knew it going in but I would maybe take a chance because you can you can play two three or four player now so that's it thanks
you