Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:14

well it's part four of the cooperative game series and today we're gonna talk about one that's very difficult to find a good one on we're gonna be talking about semi cooperative games first guys us to find what semi cooperative is cuz I don't think that's really a category I think we kind of made it up anyways you don't look at board yeah doesn't mean I've heard the term used many times yes I've heard a lot of people confused when somebody says semi-competent so that is absolutely correct though there's many definitions of this that I don't agree with I've had people explain games to me and I've said oh so it's a semi co-op and they just look at me like I'm crazy hmm and what is that so you're saying like people don't know what it is well I think we're all over the place I know explain what your definition of it is and I'll tell you why you're wrong and will continue on so I think a semi cooperative game is a game where everybody the table has some sort of common goal but at the same time they're not necessarily liking each other or working with each other and this could be something like you know you have to keep your spaceship from blowing up meanwhile you're trying to loot the most loot from it because you're I don't know gonna ban and ship soon so there's a goal you lose if your ship blows up

everybody loses you're all a bunch of losers but you want to be you know just helpful enough so you don't blow up but still win the best non loser that's exactly right that's how I feel about it it's essentially a semi cooperative game to me is a competitive game where you must cooperate every now and then or everybody loses that's period what it is yeah now when I said earlier that there's a lot of people that are wrong I did a google for semi cooperative games and what returned was a bunch of stuff that isn't semi cooperative in my opinion a lot of people are saying that hidden traitors is a semi cooperative game that doesn't that's not semi cooperative no it's immune that's a hit for training right because I feel as though that semi cooperative must be competitive everybody's working against each other except when they have to work together yeah is very important to this definition for me that is my definition of a semi co-op hmm it's it's you are competing against each other but there's some mechanic that you all occasionally have to work together towards and it usually ends up being someone going not my problem right if you guys deal with it and and well mark this on the calendar we are the same idea yeah well now my thing with semi cooperative games is it's almost impossible to find one that's good and even the ones that we would consider good are just ok mmm you know I'm saying like there's very very very few of them that that work because it's it's a delicate balance right like

you have to make it a good solid competitive game but then you have to put in the the co-operative aspects of it so that people are are forced to cooperate with each other because sometimes like that like you said those you think never mind about it you know and then it gets by and never it's never a problem in any way there's just a delicate balance there in the game design that very rarely happens yeah and it's a primary problem is that typically the piece that people have to cooperate on just comes across as being like put in there tacked on yeah it's just tacked on to make to give the game something else yeah but really like it's a cooperative game that has this piece of junk tacked on to it that no one really wants anyways may as well have been a competitive game exactly yeah well I think I think when when games do it well though mm-hmm semi coops can be great because I like the interaction sometimes between people trying to convince somebody else to pay for something because I don't want to pay for it yeah right you know it's wheeling and dealing right yeah one of our favorite things to do in games is negotiation wheelin and dealin trying well maybe I'm speaking for myself but I like to get other people to do things for me it's I know now whatever lives in Syria I love it I love it that's so much fun it's I love to try to convince people of certain things and semi cooperative games we have that aspect to them as a matter of fact the one that I picked for my recommendation you can't really do that you just got to do what you got to do

I'll get to that but I just love the negotiation factors and most these semi coops well hopefully we've managed to find three that are good hopefully I think we did yeah I think we did all right well Chris go ahead what is your semi cooperative game recommendation all right so my first semi co-op is not only semi co-op but it has a lot of other mechanics that I really dig in a game and and I love playing this game and this game is Archipelago it's a game where you're coming in and colonizing an island there are no evil spirits there so you don't have to worry about getting chased away but there are natives who get grumpy and they'll have an uprising which is the semicolon so in order to do that certain challenges will come up at where you have to pay goods to meet them and if collectively you don't pay enough goods the natives get restless and if they get to the top then everybody loses right but it also has exploration tile placement building territory control trading all kinds of cool stuff and variable winning conditions too right so every player has a different scoring condition so not only is it semi co-op but it has a ton of other cool stuff in it and I believe it is even to the point where there there is a winning condition in there where the you win if the natives have an upright yeah there's a there is a traitor man and we scrapped that card yeah we didn't like it well I the reason I never threw it in was because there was always a new player

and the game just doesn't work if the new player gets that card yeah so I always kind of scrap it out but I think the game is very good I think like Battlestar Galactica we talked about last time it needs a second edition with a bit of tweaking because the game itself is awesome the the exploration is great the building buildings is great settlements the way workers like you put workers around in the different places and again it generate your resources and then that semi co-op aspects are terrific all of that stuff's great and actually my very favorite part of it is the winning conditions because everybody gets dealt a winning condition and that's also an endgame condition so everybody is beholden to this same point score condition but you don't know what it is until the end of the game but you're gonna try to work as right yeah because you see what they're working towards and you got to try to work towards it too because it might be the winning condition terrific other than that though it is one of those games we like to call fragile or sometimes you're gonna have a bummer of a game it just drags on those are the ones I hate or it could be you could lose in like two rounds and then you have to reset it up cuz the natives upright rows up yeah so archipelago is a fun game a game I enjoy playing but a couple of things can be annoying with it first off sometimes you get tiles that don't really fit anywhere because you've already designed your archipelago out and there's not a whole lot of room it can go and it might just be a weird tile you explore a tile and then you lost a turn because you couldn't place it I'm looking at you volcano tile now the

other thing that's kind of annoying too for me anyway cuz I'm more of a you know confrontational gamer is that you find this sweet juicy island you're all set up it's a tropical paradise and Chris's trashy purple people come over and you can't get them off of that island they're like freaking stuck there well then that is an awesome game right we dig in yeah I just think it needs a second it yeah I think but it is a good game otherwise I like it my pick is a game that I think it came out last year and I believe that it's gonna be on shelves this year because it was a Kickstarter and it's called crisis let me tell you this by far is the best semi cooperative game I've ever played because the balance is just right on target but this game is a business building style game it's worker placement and it's in a cyberpunk world like just near future with newer technologies up but the thing is that the economy has crashing and if the economy crashes to the bottom everybody loses so you got to keep the economy up so basically you're building you know you're buying businesses you're building factories you're Manning those factories with all the different kinds of employees that make it work then you reaping the benefits from that there's all sorts of different stuff like that but the way the semi cooperative stuff works is that every round of the game everybody needs to score a certain amount of points or higher or the economy is going to be reduced by that number of points so as a matter of fact

it kind of sometimes makes people playing poorly feel bad because they're the ones the economy right so if you don't play well to get a bunch of points you fall like say five points below that that threshold the economy goes down five if like every player can't meet that threshold it goes way down and goes to the bottom so here's what's good about it you have to work together to make that happen sometimes you need to work together like oh you need to buy that because it's gonna raise this score and it's gonna raise this up and make this thing happen but you're still competing to make the best businesses score the most points get the you're competing against the workers because there's a certain workers that are tough to get like bankers or harden again so you're racing to get those and instead of letting the other people get them so there's tons of competition in the game but the semi cooperative nature of it is just on point crisis man ah we see wouldn't you love this game no I want to play it now after hearing about it that's a great pick and you can't go wrong with cyberpunk because that's just a fun you know world to be in you don't know what's happening things are cybernetic that is true what I think is cool about what you described to me is uh not just like many other semi coops where you you're kind of competing against the game to not let the game win in this one it sounds like you're almost pushed to help other players a little bit instead

of just like okay I can't do this action because I need to not let the game win and this one you're like okay we got to get Jamie and gear because he's slacking and not getting enough points here so everybody help Jamie out but not too much not very much true story rotten Steve all right let's tell me what yours is Steve it's this is gonna be rich mmm sure it is some trouble coming up with semi co-op that I like a lot so I landed on dead of winter now this game can be played with a trader if you do that it's not a semi coop it's one versus many and it's both I think still right because like you're still doing the semi cooperative your own specific goals a foul the regular co-op but then there's a trader in it it's right now hybrid almost traders can be in a semi co-op that doesn't stop it from being a semi coop but it doesn't make it a semi coop I'm just surprised Chris didn't pick Battlestar Galactica yeah it's definitely not a co-op game every single game oh come on nickel video we do is good at Battlestar Galactica doesn't it I like it I have to put it in there so anyway in debt a winter you are survivors in an apocalypse and there's zombies coming at you and for some reason you're in the Arctic or something it's really cold out so you've got to get food you can't grow food it's too cold yeah I get food guy get supplies gotta survive the zombies are trying to get you and trying to break in where you

are and you have to stay alive and keep everybody alive and win the game but the reason I picked this as a semi co-op is because everybody has personal objectives so my objective could be get two books right so the zombies are coming through the walls and the windows and everybody else my team is fending them off and I'm looking for books because I want to win the game to y'all I thought you were gonna say they need books to fight off the zombies and you're like I don't have any books because you're sitting on a stack of it this is like I thought I always feel like when I'm playing that game this is a weird one because it's like a reverse semi co-op in the respect that usually I said that's a competitive game that you're trying to every now and then you're forced to cooperate in this one it's a cooperative game or every now and then you're forced to not do the best thing for the group so I guess technically I'm going to allow it but it is a reverse so here's the deal though if everybody wins and you didn't have your objective completed you don't win mm-hmm yeah so there is no cooperative win there's a cooperative loss but that doesn't mean you're gonna win so it's a semi co-op yeah you win but everybody else went you lose but everybody else wins correct right right yeah so there is sometimes situations where you be like hey give me that book because I need that book because I'm a I'm a book Oh file a bibliophile O'Brien I've decided that the world needs more libraries I'll allow it Steve it isn't nice at least

you didn't put it on there because of the stay hidden trader that meant I would have been upset I think it's a perfectly fine pick it is a semi co-op I want to play it again it's been a while since I play it I didn't really like it the first time maybe I was just in a grumpy mood or something I don't know so I want to try it again cuz that everybody seems to love this I mean we get so much flak for not liking dead a winner no and that's on the same way because I whenever it comes up I'm like mmm because I just didn't really dig it and the first times we played it but I do evolve over time I like change my tastes and what I like about games and certain games like that and we should try it again it's try again I might like it who knows go back well I'm glad you two youngsters approve of my opinion we always appreciate Steve not your jokes your opinion that's fine that's true I'll take what I can get all right everybody well thanks so much for joining us for our cooperative game series we hope to see you next time and until then have a good one everybody be a guy's secret cabal out thanks so much everybody if you've enjoyed this video please do us a giant favor by subscribing to the channel and click on that wacky Bell icon if you're into board games miniatures games role-playing games we have a bunch of audio podcasts you might enjoy you can find those at the secret cabal comm or on iTunes and stitcher

Progress saved