Skip to main content
Loading video...

Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 130 - What Makes A Game Truly Replayable?

Transcript 46:20

Morning everyone. Broken Mele here for another podcast. 8th of March 2026. 26 is already starting to fly, but we're still in the quiet season for board games. There's not a huge amount to sort reflect on that's new. Uh so, you know, hence reviews have been a little bit more sparse since January when I caught up with all my stuff, but there's been at least some other content that you can have. There's, you know, one review already out and the second one coming. And of course top 10 list can now try to resume because well I've got the time to do them because there's not many other games to review. So there's definitely not on the way. Uh otherwise things uh so far here pretty good. New job is going well. I'm enjoying it. Uh people are nice. I'm uh you know settling in nicely. It's a lot of work. It's piling on but not overwhelming. And I feel like everything I do is more meaningful there. So you know so far so good. You know in good spirits there.

If anything negative's in my life at the moment, just that not a lot else is happening really. I mean, a lot of my stuff doesn't really kick off until about late March in the case of April and that February and March just tend to be pretty devoid of any weekend activity. And, you know, half my weekday plans lately have been cancelled by people because they're doing other things. And it's just like, yeah, when everybody else has plans and then they cancel and then you're basically left to wallow away in your own house by yourself, it's like it can get a little demeaning at times. But, uh, you know, I've I've tried to keep myself entertained, but, I mean, there's only so much, uh, channel stuff to do, and obviously I do need to take a break every now and again. Uh, but I'm trying to play some solo games now and again. I waiting for the next Steam sale before I do any more PC gaming cuz I've just finished a second run of Bouldersgate 3 with the Dark Urge uh, playthrough where I go full-on evil. It's fun. You get to do some messed up stuff and the ending is just like everything's god to pot and love it. Yeah, playing evil is more fun in games. I I always tend to play the folk hero as the first playthrough. Play the goody two shoes because that's always the main way you're supposed to play these roleplay games to play it as a good character or somebody who gets a redemption arc. And so after I played it as a good character, I decided right now I want to play it as an absolute dick.

and and I played a, you know, played a female teling bard character and went full-on evil, manipulative, persuading and decepting everybody to do pretty much what I wanted to do. And oh god, yeah, you do some messed up stuff on the Dark, but there's other games I want to play. I want to play Dispatch. I want to play Clare 33, but I'm waiting for the next Steam sale before they uh before I get them because they'll be cheaper. Yeah, I could buy them now, but I'd be behind inflated prices and then I know in two weeks time the Steam sale will happen and then they'll be discounted and I'll be like, why didn't I just wait two weeks? How often am I going to get to play the game in two weeks? So, you know, at the moment I'm currently, you know, down here sorting out all my Arkham Horror LCG stuff because I'm preparing for the next like wave of uh, you know, cards that are coming out for like the second edition thing. And I've only just acquired the Drown City Investigator cards or at least I've ordered them. haven't found a copy of the Hemlock Veil ones or whatever they're called uh lately because they've been out of stock. But I wanted to get the investigator cards, not the campaign stuff, you know, cuz the campaigns have been a bit sucky, I think, since Edge of the Earth. Edge of the Earth was a good one, but then I hated Scarlet Keys.

Scarlet Keys sucked. Absolutely sucked. And I haven't heard the best things about uh the Veil one and I don't know about the Drown City one, but I feel like they're getting too convoluted these campaigns. There's already some good campaigns I can play through. I've got enough content for the game. But yeah, they are starting to get a little bit too overroought, too long, too complicated, and that puts me off, especially when you got to commit to eight games or something. So, I'm keen to see what these changes for the new addition of Arkham LCG are going to do. might actually revamp my interest in the game and propel it higher up my top 50. But um first of all, I need to sort out my cards because they were organized in a way that wasn't the most easiest to build decks from. You know, they were done by class and then done by type, but that was it. Friends of mine have suggested to do that, but also to separate them by resource cost, uh ascending resource cost, and you know, type as well. And I've got to admit, it's a bit of a time-consuming exercise, but let's face it, it's not like I got much else to do at the moment. But um it will actually make deck building a bit easier cuz then when I net deck off the internet, I can sort of look at the resource cost and go to the exact section I need. So it'll be a bit better. I don't bother with alphabetical nonsense. That's just not worth it. Um you know, but yeah, I'm sorting through that at the moment. And maybe this will kick drive a desire to sort out the Marvel. I mean, most of that's pretty much sorted. That's fine. But it might even kickstart something to look at my Lord of the Rings LCG stuff again, you know. So, you know, I'm kind of looking more at what solo games I can play that I enjoy. So, because I don't tend to play Euro games much solo anymore. Um, I

tend to play more of the sort of thematic uh or quick games solo, but big heavy raw. I mean, I like the KBAN EV, you know, solo behind my head, you know. I like the Galleries Euro. Um, yeah, I like a few of these other Euros on my shelf that I can see solo, but it's just the time. You got to relearn the rules. You got to learn the extra rules on top and then you got to play it. It just takes a lot of time and I'm just not as keen, you know, especially when that's time I could be spent at the gym. you know, I'm trying to go to the gym as much as possible because it's a never-ending fight to try and not appear as a chubby bastard basically. So, yeah, all well and good, but that's uh basically the case with uh trying to sort things out there. That's the basically the case with life. Oh, I haven't actually presented the screen, so that's not going to help.

But come on, present screen window. Um ah, let me put myself back on the screen a minute. So yeah, I mean in terms of the channel, it's been doing good. You know, we're doing fine, but as soon as I actually figure out how to present my screen, I'll be able to actually show you it. Yeah. See how prepared I am today on this particular show. Um, in terms of conventions coming up while I sort this out, um, uh, not going to Aircom, uh, various reasons I don't go to that now. And, uh, I will be going to Shake Batam roll, uh, at the end of the month. So, that is a given. Uh, that's a Southampton based local one. So, that will be good fun. Um, I don't think I'm going to BCON in April. I mean, the problem is is I mean, there's two problems. Firstly, I've only got so much time in a year uh to go to conventions, but also because I joined this job late uh compared to when they do their payroll stuff, I wasn't allowed to buy a week of holiday like I normally would.

So, I'm gonna have more money this year. Not that I need it, but um you know, desperately. But the I'm also like unable to buy the extra week. So I'm 5 days holiday short of what I had last year, which means I need to be a little bit more sparing with the days holiday I do take. And so that does mean restricting myself to certain conventions or not taking the Fridays off with some of these conventions, you know, and and doing things like that. So it's just something I've got to deal with. But it does mean restricting which conventions I go to and it will just depend on that really. But shake battle and roll is still desperately happening. So channel-wise 273 to1 being quite a few extra subs in the last uh month actually thanks to the top 50. So that's a good shout. The top 50 is now wrapped up. That is all done and dusted. So all 50 games have been talked about. And as usual the views tend to be skewed towards the top bit. I mean I mean if we go to the bottom here 5,000 there, 5,0006 there. So about equal 6 and a bit thousand there. Then 20 to 11 7,000 and then 10 to 1 11 a half thousand. So yeah, please keep the viewership on those going up because they are probably the best videos I do in terms of viewership. But yeah, it's always the case. The top bit always gets more of the views and you know, I'm glad people are for the most part enjoying it. I mean 96.4 like so 24 people dislike my top 10 games purely for the reason that they don't like the 10 games in my top 10. What a pathetic reason to dislike a video. Shame on you. But um yeah, so

they're still going strong. Uh reviews uh since the last one. I mean, I finished off the Beyond the Base game double I was doing. So Beyond the Base game uh Bordeaux for Vita Culture, you know. Wow. I mean, I give a seal a distinction to something from Stonemire. Go figure. Spoiler. And I've got two small reviews to do. One for Movie Tricks, which is ready to go. I'm just going to air it probably Tuesday, maybe Wednesday. Tuesday, Wednesday this week. Um but uh obviously because of this podcast and Spokes got uh sent um got issued on the 5th. So Spokes is a very local game. It's a UK based game, a little cycling racer. By all means, uh check that one out. I mean, it's low views because no one's ever heard of it. But yeah, you know, if you've been to the UK Games Expo, you should have seen this game popping up every now and again. So yeah, by all means, check out that one. It's a very quick review. It's only 16 minutes. There's not a huge amount to talk about. It's a very small, light game. Um, but yeah, that's kind of it for the channel. In terms of future content, I mean, I will start uh doing the top 10 trick taking games uh very soon. Um, because I think it's about time we got those underway. I mentioned the movie tricks review that's coming out shortly. But other than that, there isn't really any other games to review.

I mean, I am told that there's, you know, I was meant to get like a I was meant to get Stone Saga as a copy, but that doesn't seem to have happened. I was promised that back in January, so I don't know what's going on with that one. Um, I was meant uh I was meant to get a copy of Lands of Sylmer or whatever it's called. It's um or something like that. It's basically the next uh um uh what you call it Ryan Lockit Red Raven Games thing. Uh but on for various reasons, I wasn't able to get a prototype copy of it. So instead, they're going to send me a production copy when it's done and I'll review it then. So, I will do a review for it, you know, but just no um upcoming uh review of that. And uh Lands of Evershade, um the one that I did a preview for for Awakened Realms, I should be getting a mass production version of that in the next uh month or so. Uh there'll be an embargo on it to not talk about it for a while, but it will give me some time to play through it as a final copy of the game and give a full review on that [snorts] basis. I've already given a preview of the game, but now I get to see it in its full production and give it a full review at that time. So, that'll be interesting. But that's stuff in the uh the next couple of months. I mean, March does not have a lot of new game releases planned. I'm not aware of any new games that are coming out to be played and stuff. So, uh I think March will just be a case of what content I can do really. I mean, is there something that I mean, what do you guys want? Um, I mean, obviously I'm going to do some top 10 lists, but is there a game that I haven't reviewed that's uh recent that you need me to talk about? I

mean, obviously if I've got the game on my shelf, I can look at it and obviously it's got to be worth the views. You know, I'm not going to review a game that no one's heard of for 10 views. That's not going to happen. But the, you know, is there something I've missed out or perhaps something you need thoughts on? If necessary, I could always talk about it in the next podcast episode if necessary. But, uh, yeah, you know, I'm up for ideas. But, you know, top 10 lists are definitely a thing. So movie uh so trick taking games is definitely the first and then I'll think about what topics to do for the next lot. Um I think it's about time the patronons were given a heads up as to coming up with some list ideas. Nice bit of coffee there. Do right. Uh so yeah, stuff to come in the future. Uh in terms of the industry, well I mean the industry's had a bit of a shakeup lately recently, hasn't it? I mean, it's controversy and polit politics all over the place. And I mean, people ask me, you know, what's my viewpoint on these things? And at the end of the day, I try 99.9% to keep that kind of stuff out of the channel cuz it's especially politics. I'm not interested in politics. And, you know, believe what you want to believe, do what you want to do. I'm here to talk about board games.

That's why people are here, not to listen to that kind of stuff. So, I try to keep that stuff out of the channel anyway. And you know in terms of like other industry creators and sort of controversies there I mean I mention them every now and again. I mean we had the the dealings with a cracko pages ago and how crazy that went and you know recently we've had the watch it played controversy as well and you know people s oh what's your opinion on that and it's like honestly you don't want to know my opinions really on that kind of stuff but at the end of the day somebody made a very good quote on a feedback thread for it. Um, I don't know if it was a quote from something else or whether it was just his thing, but basic I think it might be like a quote from some film or speech or something, but basically whenever you have a scenario where it's two people arguing about something and it's a con uh controversial thing, right? Every time you get one of those scenarios, doesn't matter who it is, what industry it is, or anything, there's basically the same outcome. You have Persian person A's viewpoint of what happened, you have person B's viewpoint of what happened and the truth. That's pretty much how it works. Nobody ever comes out of the scenario squeaky clean with a nice like flat sl, you know, with a clean slate.

It doesn't happen. There's always something else going on behind the scenes because people are only willing to talk about the stuff that's going to help their case. So, I like I say, I've I've had no dealings with them, you know, for ages. You know, we clashed ages ago and it's like, you know, I've never bothered to do anything since. And you know, at the end of the day, there's clearly some wrongdoings going on. Um, you know, I don't use any of that stuff to, you know, inflate views and stuff like that because it's all rubbish. It doesn't work. It's easily noticeable and what's the point? It's just money down the drain and reputation damage. But, you know, at the end of the day, I don't believe that everything's all squeaky clean from everybody else's viewpoint. So, I'm just going to leave it be and just say, "Look, something went wrong here." You know, people are going to take sides. People are going to you're going to get sick of ants on one side, sick of ants on the other. It's just going to be one of those things that will blow over eventually and people will just stick to whatever they like.

You know, nobody's going to get converted to what they already believed previously that it's just going to cement their reasoning. So, at the end of the day, whatever. Hey, whatever. Um, it's just another one of those things that's kind of just saying that the industry has definitely taken a bit of a dive in the last, I'd say, five years, maybe even the last decade, but maybe five to six years since lockdown. It's never been quite the same, has it? Anyway, uh, let's talk about a couple of games first. So, uh, nothing too strenuous here, nothing too long. I'm going to mention a new trick taker. Um, this got suggested to me by a a friend from the Drander Games team who also showed me the Kosu Dice. We went to the booth. Um, uh, I can't remember who was saying it. Well, it wasn't one of these publishers. Sunny Bird, Newill Industries, and Blue Tiel. It wasn't them. I think it was Good Games Publishing. The same people who did our 12 Rivers were selling it at the time.

It was like barely even 10 quid after, you know, Euroka version. So, it was really cheap. And I thought, yeah, you know what? I want to buy this. Now, the pictures, this is the picture of the box that I got, but the pictures that you see in a minute are probably going to be of the old version of this. It's called Seven Prophecies. It's a trick taker. And, you know, I love trick- taking games, so naturally, I was keen to see what this one is like. Now, these photos are of different editions of the game, so I don't think this is going to be quite as easy to do, but frankly, it's a bunch of cards with numbers. I mean, what more would you need? But I'll try to find a more clearer picture of the game and how it works. Uh, so ah, this is good. So the idea is is it's a typical like play so many rounds, try to get points for winning tricks and first person to get to a certain point and then wins. But there's a bit of a twist with this one. And I do love these trick takers twists. The idea is is that you are trying to predict, well, this is not the twist. the idea that you're predicting how many tricks you're going to win in the round. But the idea is is that you are predicting how many times you're going to come first, second, third, fourth, whatever, depending on player count in the round. So, I'm going to win three tricks. I'm going to come second twice, third, three times, you know, that sort of thing. It's like, how the hell do I gauge that? The clever twist here, though, is that these cards at the top here, these color cards, determine what trump is in effect for each hand of the round. You previously before the round starts predict how many times based on those color cards and your hand how many times you're going to come first, second, third or fourth. You track them on this little marker card here with cubes. You put the cubes on

the first, second, third, fourth like cards on the left. And the idea is that you play through each hand of the trick and you're trying to essentially like, you know, get unload all those markers. So the decision as to whether you're trying to win a trick, lose a trick, or just try and come second or third in the trick is like constantly a decision space for every hand of the round. It's a very clever little game and it doesn't take too long to play about half an hour. It's basically a filler. Um, you've only got to get so many points, but there's a good amount of like, you know, yes, you got to follow the league color and stuff like that, but there's tactical play as to whether you think you should win a trick now or lose it now because you might be in a position to win it, but you don't want to win it. You've already unloaded all your winning tricks, so now I need to lose this one. Well, I could play that instead and come third. That's not so bad, you know, but now I need to lose the next trick. I need to play some really low number. And it's very clever, very cool little system. Easy to play, but well, easy to play after you've played a demo game of it because trying to explain it to people was a little bit on the tricky side. You like, oh my god, how's this supposed to work? This is very different. But I was impressed with this one. And, you know, I've played it enough times now. So, will it appear on my top 10 trick takers? You'll have to see. But this was Yeah, this was a neat little game. Very clever. Definitely worth grabbing if you see it on a convention. And you're not likely to see it too often in retail, although maybe you'll get lucky. But yeah, if this turns up for cheap on like a, you know, one of the like Asian board game stores at Essen or Games Expo or something like that, then I recommend grabbing this one. This is a neat little game. And

then the next one I'm not going to talk about too much uh because I feel like I might have talked about it briefly before is The Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship of the Ring tricktaking game. I've not played the Two Towers version. It's more the same. But, you know, what are my views on this particular trick taker? Overall, I do like it. Um, but there is a caveat. You know, this is basically a co-op trick taker. So, each round of the game, you have character cards that you draft. They have a special ability for the start of the game, start of the round, but also a condition that must be met in order to pass the round. And basically, you play a trick taker with your friends. Standard trick taking rules, except you know, Frodo has to win a bunch of ring cards. Gandalf here has to win one or more tricks. Sam has to win a specific hills card. That kind of thing. They're pretty they're pretty repetitive, these objectives. That's one of the problems I do have. But you can already get the idea this is kind of a bit like The Crew. And that's pretty much what this game is. It's practically a clone of The Crew. And I love The Crew. The Crew is a fantastic trick taking game. This is a solid trick taking game, but I think I prefer The Crew. And you know, the artwork I'm not a fan of. This is not my style of artwork. Uh, it's very renaissancey. It's it's it's just an art style I'm not a fan of. So, I don't like the look of this game, you know? It's not for me. But other people will disagree. It's just what kind of art do you like? But you play through it in chapters. The story is whatever. We know how Lord of the Rings plays out now. And this is a trick taker, so the story doesn't mean jack. Um, but you play through each chapter, and each one

introduces maybe like a quirk to the rules. Like one round you've got Tom Bombadil's tree and it h sucks up all the forest cards and does something with them. And another round you have a character ability that means they draw more cards than everybody else so they've got loads of options. Another character is fewer. So it's it's stuff like that. And you basically just play through each chapter. They get progressively harder and you try to win it as a team. Now it's a solid trick taker. But the crew is better. The crew has more variation for what the abilities um uh well, it's got like 50 scenarios, which I think is more than this one has anyway. So, there's more variation in terms of the uh difficulties and stuff like that, and like the special quirks you can get, but also the mission criteria is more flexible because you flip over the cards from the deck in Deep Sea, for example, and it, you know, that's how you determine what the conditions of the round are. This one, they're fixed. It's fixed by whatever characters and scenario you're doing. The only thing that will slightly differ is which characters do you take? You know, do I take, you know, we have to take Frodo and we have to take Bombadil, but we can decide whether we want to take Mary and Pippen or Barry and Sam, you know, that kind of thing. And that's the main bit of variation. It's decent. As I say, I enjoy playing it, but they just don't seem like very varied like abilities and stuff. I mean, for the first I've played through about I think 9 to 10 chapters of the game. I want to say somewhere between seven and 10 I've played through of this game, right? So, I've seen a decent amount of the chapters in the game and you don't get much variation

with the characters. I mean, you always have to have Frodo and his is is start is like victory condition exactly the same every single game and then you mostly have Mary and Pippen a lot and then it occasionally frozen Gandalf or frozen Bilbo, frozen Bombadil, that kind of thing or you know a couple of the elves and I just don't feel that there's enough variation between the chapters. You know, they don't feel that different and there just appears to be more rinse repeat with this one than I get in The Crew. But that's not to say that this is a bad game. I still really enjoy it. It's just if I'm going to say if you're going to tell me which one am I going to pick out of them to own, I'm going to own Crew Deep Sea any day of the week. You know, it's not It beats out the original Crew and it beats out this. But this is nice if you prefer Lord of the Rings as a theme and you want something a little bit more simple. I mean, this one is definitely simpler to win and simpler to play than The Crew, but The Crew is not exactly that difficult. I have played it solo. I tried to play the Fellowship solo. It plays out more like a puzzle game than a trick taker. For Northwood did a far better job of doing a solo trick taker. This one just felt like a a fairly boring puzzle to play.

So, I wasn't as big into the solo game of this. But, you know, it's a fine trick taker game and I will happily play it. I will happily say, you know what, let's play a bit of that. You know, we haven't got the crew. Let's play that one. So, I'm not exactly going to dismiss it, but it's it's a bit like playing Seven Wonders Duel and Seven Wonders Duel Lord of the Rings version. Okay, Lord of the Rings, Seven Wonders Duel version is perfectly fine. You know, I am totally fine with that game. It's entertaining. It's good fun, but I prefer the original for various reasons, and that's why I would never own the other one. I'd just be happy enough to play it. Same with this one. I already have The Crew. There's no reason I would own this one, but I'd be happy to play it if somebody shoved it in front of me. So, it's uh like I say, I like it, but it's it just feels like we're, you know, we're running out of ideas here. I mean, this is practically cloning the crew and not really adding much more to the formula. So, you know, we are starting to run out of ideas in a lot of genres and I think this is an example. This and the seven wonders duel one is kind of an example of that.

Throat is drying up already. I need to drink that coffee and like it. But yeah, you know, two games there to chat about. So hopefully a shorter episode at this uh rate, but I say that every single time and I never do it. So we'll see if I eat my words. But we're going back to uh that smores board list of um suggested questions that I had from the previous podcast cuz I thought they were pretty solid. And we're going for a question which is what makes a game truly replayable? Because replay value is something that gets talked about a lot in, you know, board game reviews in general, me included. I will say a lot about the replay value of games, and it will factor into my rating. But I think you need to understand that there's more than one way to say a game is replayable. And it's going to depend on some other factors as well. It's not just simply how much content you shove in the game, you know, because you can bloat things. You know, people think that the best way to make a game replayable is just to have practically infinite number of combinations of stuff going on. Well, that helps, but that doesn't necessarily make me want to replay the game again because I mean, for starters, the re the game has to be fun before you want to replay it. You know, I don't care how much content you shove into something like Mage Knight or whatever. It's like, I'm not going to play it, you know? But that's that's a given. Let's just assume you like the game. But, you know, do you want to replay it again? Shoving content after content after content doesn't always work. I mean, LCGs are certainly bloated to that extent, and they've affected my enjoyment of the game. The fact that

they do get a bit bloated, but there are games that have got a lot of replay value that I've sold. Uh, I sold um Manacrony, uh, the David Tury Mine Clash game, and I like anacrony perfectly like anacrony as a game, but that Infinity Box, I mean, it had way too much stuff in it. You could never remember all the rules to it. It took ages to get it to the table and played, and those mini expansions just weren't worth the cardboard they were printed on. especially the later ones. And you know, yes, you could argue, oh, but there's so much replay value in that game because now you can combine it with all these modules and, you know, have the advanced version and do all that, but if it's too much effort and too much of a time sync and that, then it doesn't matter how much content you shove into the game, it just feels like I've wasted my money buying stuff I don't need. So, you know, just spamming content doesn't necessarily make the game replayable from my standpoint. Now, you know, some some will argue, well, okay, you can't have uh a game be replayable if there isn't, you know, multiple sets or multiple things that you can draft from and things like that, but I'm not so sure. Let's take, for example, let's go to Board Game Geek and throw up this one. Let's throw up like some social games like The Gang for example, one that I talked about pretty highly on my top 50 spoilers. Um, but I love The Gang, you know? I love The Gang. I like Texas Hold and Poker. So, something like The Gang really sings to me. But there's not really variety in this game from a

like gameplay perspective, is it? There's 10 different powers that can help you and 10 different powers that hinder you. That's it. Apart from that, there's no other special rules in the game. I hear the new version is going to bring in some extra expansions. We'll see. But, you know, the main game doesn't have, you know, particularly any variety in it, or at least not what I would call variety. But this game gets played constantly at conventions. It gets played on multiple tables at game stores. I play it three or four times in a row without any question, and I'm happy to bring it to another setting. That's got nothing to do with how much content's in the game to say that this one is a replayable game. This one has the advantage of being the people. So, you know, hate I hate looking at the pictures of just random people I've never met, but uh you know, this game is about the people. You know, the game mechanics work, but when you play something like this, anything that has a social element, these games are more replayable because you play them with different people. And even if you play them with the same people, you are still going to get different ways of thinking.

You're still going to have people change their minds about aspects. Even personality changes can have an effect. But, you know, you're going to even just having one different player in the group can spin it on its head and like introduce a new element. And when you take it to conventions, you're typically playing it with people you don't often play games with, you've never met before. So, you get a different experience then. And that's nothing to do with the variety of the mechanics and it's nothing to do with the variety of the content. It's the variety of the people and that makes these games. You know, Cosmic Encounter, Deception, Murder in Hong Kong, One Night Werewolf, One Night, you know, were you know that all of these social deduction games are basically made by the people experienced, which is why they tend to not get stale. Now, if the mechanics themselves rinse and repeat too often, then that can have an effect. Like, for example, I will not play the resistance again because, you know, I mean, when you play the gang, you can get some very different outcomes based on what players are kind of like. In the resistance, I feel that we're at a point now where the game plays out the same way no matter what happens. I mean, the first round is basically a writeoff. In games like the Resistance and Secret Hitler and Feed the Kraken, the first round is a writeoff. you have no information and nobody's going to be dumb enough to play bad on the first bit because it would just kill them stone dead. So, you know, people do it, but it doesn't end well most of the time unless the rest of the group are morons. Um, so it's it's just

one of those things where, you know, not all of them will stay replayable. But a lot of these games will because of uh people aspects. Oh, yeah. My throat is sore this morning. I wonder what's getting into that one. Maybe it's just uh quite dry in this room. I don't know. It isn't pretty warm in this house. Uh but uh yeah. So, I mean, that's one aspect of replayable content. So, what about games that aren't social then? Can a game not have a social element and not have a ton of variety in the setup and still be replayable? I mean, I don't see why not. You know, there are games um well, sticking to this uh well, well, we'll come off the social bit, but another example I suppose I could have said is um Hijgemany. Um Hegemany, you play that one as a big massive Euro game, but every time I play this game, it feels different because you play it with a different set of people combination and that's already different. But then you play with a different class with those people and it's different. and then the way the policies get voted on and the way the cards come out and stuff will change exactly how this game plays out.

So, Hegemany has near infinite replayability for that reason. And that's a big, you know, grandio Euro game. Uh, but, you know, that's not to say that some games aren't replayable because they have, you know, a decent amount of content. So, I mean, we take something like, uh, Spirit Island, Sentinels in the Multiverse, uh, you know, Spirit of the Island's a good one. This one is a puzzle. The puzzle's kind of a similar deal each time. You know, you you're trying to kill the invaders and get them off your land, but you have a ton of spirits to play with now. You know, loads of different options on that front. You've got all the different adversary cards. You've got all the different um yeah, adversary cards, spirit cards. You got all the power cards, you know, the the way the powers come into play is going to have an effect. uh the combination of spirits you use is going to have an effect. You know, combining this spirit with this spirit will be fundamentally different if you com than if you combine this spirit with that spirit. So, this is an example of a game really being replayable because of the like the content having an effect on the puzzle.

you know, the content in some of the things like an Acrianat doesn't necessarily impact the puzzle to a great extent, whereas this sort of game where it is basically one giant puzzle is definitely influenced by the fact that there's a lot of cards, a lot of spirits, a lot of options. So, you know, you can set this up in a different way and it will be a different feeling game enough to make it replayable. You know, I can play a game of this solo, finish it, and then decide, you know what, I fancy another game of this. let's just change the spirit and now I'll have a completely different outcome, you know. So, it's, you know, this is definitely an example of where replay value comes into its own, you know, based on just how much content there is. Now, I mean, one thing to sort of stress is that replay value doesn't necessarily mean, oh, the game has no replay value, therefore it sucks, you know, because, you know, people got on my case a lot with Emberart, you know, where I gave that one a like benchmark rating because I just think for a Lords of Water Deep level weight game, it does everything it needs to. But Ember doesn't have like pretty much any variety in it. I mean, you use up all the cards in all the stacks except for the heroes. That's it.

The heroes are the only thing that add any variety to the game. The rest of it, you will see everything that plays out. But, you know, one thing that makes games like this have a good amount of replay value is their simplicity. This one is simple and buttery smooth in how it operates. You know, you got one or two minor clunky bits like with the mountain and stuff, but it's very easy to get past that point. The rest of it just flows nicely. And you know games that do this where you know they flow nicely and are just smooth as butter. Cascadia and you know other lightweight games are going to be replayable because they are simple to get out to the table. And so I suppose the next point to consider is just the sheer size and weight of the game. You know he is infinitely replayable from its content and its experience. How often do you get to play a gemony? You know it's not like something you get to bring out every week you know. a symbol game like Cascadia Ember. I mean, the amount of plays Ember's had even since I reviewed it because people have asked me to bring it to a club and I can just get it played in an hour and a half and I'm done, you know. So, all well is good there. Uh, but then, you know, other little simple games that are just quick to play, you know, card games, trick takers, you know, fillers, that sort of thing. You know, Splendor, how much replay value does Splender have? It's the same sort of cards every single time, but you can get a game done in 30 minutes. you can teach it in 60 seconds.

I mean, it's a very quick, simple game. It's therefore going to have a decent amount of replay value. Even something like Katan, uh, well, Katan, well, yes, it's, uh, mostly the same thing, although you've got all the different modules you could throw in, but let's just take normal Katan, the different people you play with bring that social aspect back. You know, people have different attitudes to trading and stuff like that. So, that's going to make it feel different when you play it the next time. I would say yeah, Ember doesn't have a lot of extra variety in the content, but because you can bring it out often and because it's so smooth, it it's comfort food and comfort food can be nice to just play through over and over again. You know, you want to play it multiple times. You don't tend to get bored with it. You know, light themes, themes you're into, color, you know, those sort of things add, you know, the atmosphere, the immersion factor, you know, those sort of things will certainly help for uh the replay value of a game. what makes it replayable.

But, you know, if you take a really dry I mean, that's this is the thing with like really dry puzzle games or something like that. I mean, I hate Concordia, okay? I don't care that Awakened Realms is doing a new version of Concordia. I hate Concordia, right? So, let's get past that bit. But even then, what's really you play this for a good hour and a half to two hours or so, and you're basically just getting victory points, putting huts on the map, getting cards hopefully, because otherwise if you don't, your whole strategy falls apart, and that's about it. Collect some resources, build some little huts. There's not enough immersion in this game to make this replayable. Every time I played Concordia, it felt as dull and boring as the last time I played it. And I never felt like, oh, this was a fundamentally different game when I played it the second time. It's like, no, it just felt the same as all previous times. And so, even if you like the game, you know, you got to be honest that there's a reason why some people might get bored of it over and over again because if you do play it, eventually you are just going to see everything the game has to offer.

And so, the reason you've kept the game is because you love what it is it's offering. But you got to admit it's not offering anything different each time you play it. So, you know, I mean, I'm using Concordia and maybe that's a bad example because I hate the game, but you know, even just uh trying to think of a trying to think of a light euro or a midish lightish euro that I've sold because uh well, I mean, Lords of Water Deep was one that I mentioned. I have now sold that. So, I like Lords of Water Deep. It's a perfectly solid game, but I am a bit bored with it now. I mean, it's given me all it can. The variety in this is pretty much reduced to I mean, the quests all kind of feel the same. Really, the main variety is the buildings and what buildings get built by players, but even then, you know, the game does tend to play out fairly similarly each time. Uh the there's mandatory quests are a bane on the game.

I hate them. Hang on a sec. Yeah, I'm really struggling with the throw at the moment. I might have to take some breaks during this recording. Um, but the idea is is that I don't know, this one grew stale over time. Like I didn't feel like I was getting anything different from the plays despite, you know, with some of the flaws it had. And when it is basically a cube pushing game of put a worker here, get some victory points. You know, it's difficult to make a game feel that replayable when your objective is get victory points. It's the most boring victory condition you can have. Just get points. Especially when the theme isn't really there. I mean, who plays Lords of Water Dig and feels like they're really playing a D and D game? It just doesn't really happen. So, you're just playing a generic Euro for victory points. And even if you love the Euro game in question, it's still basically play it, get victory points. And so, the puzzle doesn't necessarily feel any different.

So moving away from yeah euros, let's talk about another aspect of replay value which is story narratives. So I like Frost Punk for example. Now Frost Punk is not a campaign game. You don't play it like a campaign. You play through scenarios but it's the the story narrative that is played is what is the, you know, the deciding factor for this one. So yeah, when you play Frost Punk, the game arc develops in a different way each time because you're going to get the different laws, you're going to get the different uh events that play out. And again, it is linked a little bit to earlier when we talk about having a lot of variety in the cards. You know, there's a lot of variety here in terms of events that can happen, etc. But every time I played Frost Punk, even the first scenario, they've played out very differently. You might have an idea of right I should aim to get these first or I should aim to do these later or something but you know changing a law here and there deciding you like you know going for option A option B on this thing you know defining the board game story arc fundamentally does have an impact on this game more so than in other games played and you know that is a element of good replay value. I mentioned Boulders's Gate earlier. So, you know, when I played Boulders's Gate, I played for it twice, and I'm playing for it technically a third time because me and some mates are playing it multiplayer. Now, the multiplayer is introducing me to some elements I didn't see before, but for the most part, it's rinse repeat. But I'm enjoying it because I'm playing it with friends. I'm trying a different character, and the character choices you make in terms of,

oh, I want to play a cleric this time, I want to play a mage, you know, I want to play a fighter. You know, those are going to have an influence over the game because it's a very different style of progression. But then comparing the folk hero playthrough I played with the I'm evil as the dark urge will allow me to be playthrough. Then you know they played out fundamentally different in the campaign because of all the branching paths all the branching narratives and if you know you're going to get a different story each time it's going to have an element of extra replay value. And there are some campaign games where you play through the campaign and that's it. Like if you play the pandemic legacy games, if you play most legacy games, it's a oneshot wonder. So you play through it, you know the story. There's no real sense of branching narratives. I mean, you might change a mechanic here or there, but otherwise it's playing out the same. And the major plot points are still going to happen.

So if you played through it a second time, you know it's coming. And yeah, they don't have replay value. Like I've played through Pandemic Legacies, all three of them. I don't like zero. Two was fine. Like one, but at the end of the day, I would never play any of those three a second time. never, you know, even Pandemic Legacy season 1. There's no point. I know the story. I know how it plays out. It's going to influence how I play. And so those legacy games don't have replay value, you know, and and that's one beef I have with legacy games. They have no replay value. You know, they try to shoehorn it in by saying, "Oh, well, you know, you can play this game after it's done." And it's like, yeah, but if your Ticket to Ride Legacy game was trash when I was playing through it as an evolving game, do you think it's going to be any more fun when I play the finished map knowing that this sour taste in my mouth came from your crap game? It's, you know, it's not going to it's not going to happen. Um, but Frostbunks an idea of like a scenario with, you know, branching narratives. But how about something like Tainted Grail? Um, you know, one of my favorite um, you know, campaign games I've ever played, Tate of Grail and particularly the Kings of Ruin, which wasn't an advance. You need the second edition of Fall of Avalon.

You need those extra rules put in. But yeah, both campaigns I love and I've played like the spin-off stories from it. You know, I have played a lot of Tainted Grail, but this one, I mean, yeah, you have the major plot points, but you can still go off on pretty different tangents with this one. I mean, depending what it is you do in terms of, you know, who you meet, what decision you make, what type of character you are, who you're playing, cuz that will have like backstory elements and things. You know, some bits will repeat, but there's a lot of different approaches you could take. So, you could still play through games like this a good at least a good two or three times before you feel like, yeah, I've seen pretty much everything there is to see, and you know, that's it. Nothing else more me here. But, you know, even they aren't too far off from legacy games because there's only so often you can uh, you know, play these all the way through. You know, you are going to have times where you play it through at once and you feel that's enough. I don't tend to play a lot of campaign board games more more than once because I feel like I've done the majority of the game at that point, but I feel like I could replay it, but then it's a time sync.

And that's the other aspect going back to the uh simple games I mentioned earlier. Uh simple games are easier to replay. They're easier to get to the table. A big game that you got to commit to is harder. And that's why Arkham Horror LCG has suffered because yes, you can play the standalone scenarios and they are better. But most of the time you're playing it in a campaign and that requires committing to an eight campaign game, four if you play the dream eaters. And I know that this new edition of it is going to have just three. And I think three is good and bad. bad because it might mean that they can't cram enough story into free acts, but good because it means you'll be able to play through a campaign a lot easier. Also, I'm a little bit curious as to how easily you're going to be able to level up your deck. I mean, how much experience can you possibly get in free axe compared to eight? So, there is [clears throat] that aspect and I'm not sure how it's going to resolve, but you know, it's another thing to bear in mind.

All right. So, I think my throat is definitely playing up. So, I might have to wrap things up there. It's a shorter episode. But, uh, you know, what I'm getting at here is that, you know, it's essentially a case that, you know, what makes a game replayable? It's driven by variety. You know, certainly, but it's about allowing players to experience something new, different, or more challenging in subsequent playthroughs. So, you might argue that the Euro games, for example, the ones that I say, well, you're just doing something to get victory points. wes to replay value. If you are one of those skill monkeys that loves to speedrun a game, video game, or wants to become the best possible player at a particular euro, then well, yeah, you might actually get the replay value from the challenge of trying to improve your high scores, but I don't really care about that sort of thing. But, you know, you want it's about the experiences. So, you know, you you've got narratives with multiple endings, as I mentioned. You've got, you know, rogue likes, for example, can have decent replay value, although I tend to get bored. I tend to get a bit bored with the rinse repeat nature of a rogike. Um, you know, you've got character builds.

So, you know, I'm playing this game and I'm going to play a fighter versus playing a wizard. You know, very different styles of play. Uh, you've got the social aspects. So, you know, playing with different people is going to influence the replay value and that. So you know you have different ways of playing from different people in social games and that's going to have an impact. Uh so there's a you know sandbox games sandbox games I love. I love fields of hal uh you know pursuit of happiness and that and because you get a different feel each time you play because there's just so many options in the game and that works for Euros you know euros where it's just one way of playing and that's it. I don't find that replayable. You know, people will think, well, now I can really hone my skills, so I can play this one way. So, well, that tends to bore me. Whereas in the sandbox game, I can go, right, this time I'm going to rear sheep. This time, pigs. This time I'm going to do mining.

This time I'm doing adventuring. This time I'm doing farming. This time I'm just going to build buildings. This time I'm going to get six dwarfs. This time I'm going to get no extra dwarfs. Yeah, it's that sort of thing, you know, makes it more replayable for me. So, overall, what is it that makes the game replayable for you? Are there any factors that I've not considered that you want to bring up? By all means, get them in the comments. Uh, do you agree or disagree with some of the claims made? Uh, interesting little topic to talk about and uh, you know, you be interested to know what you have to think. But I'm going to go rest my throat cuz it does seem to be very dry and very itchy this morning. Uh, maybe maybe I've got a slight cold. I don't know. But something's a little iffy with it. Maybe I'm maybe it's just a bit too warm and it's a bit too dry. Perhaps I just need to hydrate more today. Uh, but either way, you know, I should be fine. So, thanks a lot for listening. Hope you enjoyed. I'll see you on the next Broken Mele show. Take care and thanks for listening. Take care, everyone. Bye for now.

Progress saved