Skip to main content
Loading video...

Quadropolis vs. SimCity - Part 1 of 3 (Going Analog: Episode 6)

Transcript 15:18

we're willing to bet that the SimCity series has turned people onto and off of a career in civil engineering sure it's fun molding and empty swath of real estate into the well-oiled metropolis of your dreams it's not so fun when disasters hit and try to revert your beautiful city into a Land Before Time well drop alice is a light board game that reflects the more positive aspects of SimCity as long as you're careful in real life nothing should catch fire here up to four players compete by placing apartments offices factories parks and other features into their individual cities hoping to score the most points by games end here's a basic look at how it works this is the construction site full of buildings that you'll take turns drafting on your turn you're gonna take a particularly numbered architect and point it at a certain roller column in this case I have architect three so this allows me to claim building one two three as I grab this building I will take the Associated resources to energy in this case and the architect I use also dictates where I can place this building so architect three means I'll have to place it on column or row three over here in this case sticker right here and the resources that I've claimed will also help me activate these buildings later so to win this game of course you're going to have to build your city very carefully in this case I'll give you a couple instances of how to score some of these buildings shops for instance will score points based on how many people you can stick into them so

you can make money parks are going to score points when they're next to buildings since buildings are full of people that will go and go to these parks and the harbour that I just placed here score is best when I can build a long row or column of harbors so most points wins and add the base game comes with these this basic mode here but that has six buildings it also comes with an expert mode on the back and the expert mode comes with a much bigger grid to build on and to additional building types for this review we also added on the separately sold public services expansion this comes with several score enhancing buildings such as police stations city halls and schools now let's see what the going analog reviewers think alright guys thanks for coming over we're gonna do a special three-part series and you guys are gonna be helping me out with this because we're reviewing two different games that remind us of Sim City so we'll have two people have to stay tuned for the next couple episodes but first let's start with quadropple around Days of Wonder but first Anna you've been on the show before you know if you work on Double Fine's so thanks for stopping by you're gonna be here one of our regular reviewers Jess this is your first time on the show we're co-workers at a unnamed video game company I'm not supposed to be talking about where I work but you're in a video game industry in your one of my my number one board game friends like we played board games all the time

yep sometimes at work so yeah so we played a bunch of games of this the next game we're going to review between two cities but let's start with quadropple us from days of wonder you know what did you like about this game so the thing I really love I mean of course I'm a big fan of city building games and so number one I like the theme of course and then I also really like the art in it like I think they did a really really nice job in making all the pieces you know kind of like it's it's I mean this is a very basic sort of compliment but the art really makes you want to play the game I think the pieces are nice like I love these things like I kind of want to eat them when I look at them and don't even go that's but that's a comic I mean that is a compliment you know when I play games I want to eat all the pieces but only when they're well made and this game has nice pieces I do really like the amount of thought and the amount of like you know crossing of strategies that you have in this game like how so the fact that like so you have these these grids on the board I really love the idea that you can vertically stack forest towers to get around some of like you know the restrictions like you might have constrained yourself too much by using up all of the spaces here but you still have this one trick up your sleeve actually my favorite thing about this game is I love the fact that things have to operate the buildings and so like you know as you when you buy pieces you get these little resources but they're actually they're really unique just think about that as well and that was

probably my favorite thing about the game is the fact that I had like a certain amount of people's like oh no I have too many I have to buy some shops like okay cool and I really like that oh how about you just yeah I'm just to kind of piggyback on what Anna said about the production value I just I just think I just love everything about the game in terms of the production value the art isn't over-the-top it's clean all the iconography and the color coding really helps with teaching the game and playing the game this is going from a designer and so they yeah and the acrylic pieces you're not used to acrylic meeples or resources and so these this was a nice touch to add to this sort of paper pieces here and also the the insert by the way yeah super nice like all these tiles fit in there perfectly yeah in days of wonder you know tends to have really good inserts and production value overall and so it's not a surprise with quadropple is that it's it's this well done so on top of the production value just the design of the game is very elegant just everything about it seems buttoned up in terms of how the turns work the management of resources and how are you using those resources and on all your pieces everything about the game is balanced like you can't there's so many things to do like Anna said but you can't do it all and that's something I learned in the first game I played was you know you can't do everything otherwise you're just spreading all your resources out in too many places and depending on how the pieces come out on the board that really affects your initial strategy and where you're gonna go in the game at least in the first couple rounds and so yeah just not you

know I just love the fact that you the game makes you make tough decisions whether it be grabbing a certain type of piece or how you're spending your resources because you can't gain too many of them but you can't not gain enough of them so yeah because you can lose points for all the extra resources or people that you don't use at the end of the game yeah and I think um totally agree with you and I like I love the articles that pops is really colorful but it's not childish um this is really inviting and I like the the tying this back to Sim City I like that similar just Sim City you want them build out in zones right you have your commercial zones your residential zones so in this game you're like oh I want to put the residential area next to the park because that raises the value of the part where the buildings people want to go shopping so you want to make commercial districts so if you like some cities I think this is a really good fit and the one thing I like about this board is like its this is like what to your point just like the making decisions about which buildings to draft this part gets agonizing sometimes because when you move this this thing blocks what row or column that you can pick so you're accidentally gonna block somebody all the time it's gonna drive them crazy but it's really funny like oh man which which of these architects so I say for what row for what calm because I really need that building so I think that's probably my favorite part about the game is like trying to decide which tile you're gonna draft from the construction site and we play three different ways for this game to there's a classic mode which you see here on the back side we play the expert mode which has more buildings and then

we also played with the expansion public services which adds more scoring options did you guys like what you guys liked about like the different modes like which was your favorite which is your preferred way to playing you know so I really like the expert mode though the reason for that is because I love like think I mentioned earlier I love the stacking thing and then in the expert mode there's a like kind of a power like the office towers like that was just another - in addition to apartment towers you also have office towers I also like the fact that you had a common pool of these workers so like on the for the expert mode they flip and I like that it would kind of paint myself into a corner a little bit too often with these like you know because you only have four of them in a normal version and if you use them if you use a particular number and that's the one you need you're you kind of blocked yourself off you can't really do that as often when you have like the pooled resources so for some reason I like the expert mode more because it felt like that restriction was a little bit looser yeah hello Hugh just yeah I liked all three modes with the standard and the expert and adding these this expansion here I don't think it took either version takes away from you know the game itself I did like the expert mode better just because there was more to do and with the expansion as well so I guess I liked everything all at once because there's just more to do and and creates more tough decisions the other

things I liked about having those more to having more decisions to make is that it almost brings like a push your luck element to the game because you'll see what other people are drafting into their cities which is you know part of the interaction you're trying to see what other people are building because then you start getting competitive over certain buildings or things that you're trying to build but then you'll see like maybe your last that round and the piece that you need is is is all gone you're kind of banking on that it's going to show up the next round that you're gonna be able to get at that next round and then the other part of it is yeah just just having the different options like these were these the public's republic services yes public services having the option to choose one of these in the expansion as opposed to taking the one from the board that's a really cool thing I love this expansion what I bought it I'm like this is it just a few more tiles but I love that decision-making because then we might be not just competing from these tiles but like oh man who's the first one that grabbed one of those that's gonna score a lot of points so I definitely dug that alright now what did you guys not like about the game let's start with you just um to be honest there wasn't really much I didn't like about it yeah okay you don't have to yeah not like anything yeah yeah how about you Ayla uh okay so so for me when I when I play something like SimCity part of like what I get kind of like my fix on is I build like a little park around like you know a bunch

of residential zones and then I just watch those residential zones fill up and like it's like all people are liking the city of people they would I guess what I'm getting at as that is an Shinsuke reward like of actually building something and I felt that this game got you got your payoff at the very end that you're essentially laying down tiles but you're not really thinking about like you're not really getting those tiny little payoffs that you would in a city building game like to feel like someone's enjoying the space that you've built up right so the thing that I loved was being able to like you know when you build something you get the payoff of like having these particular resources and then you can actually put them around like this is that this is the reason why I really love that feature because it felt like it's a shop oh great I'm gonna put like a bunch of people in there I wanted there simply get okay pays off at the very very yes at the very end and so and it's like expressed in points whereas I wanted to be expressed a little bit more in the kinds of things that it unlocked for you while you were playing it felt like work a little bit too much rather than an exciting like you know something like a cool mechanic that I was excited about it mm-hmm yeah um yeah I get what you're saying and I think I like that kind of build up to like did everything work out how I want it right like like oh I finally have my row of four harbors or I got the parts and residential buildings built up just perfectly so I kind of

enjoy that but I also kind of feel like despite the art and I really like art for me it's like I don't know it's hard to kind of define the personality of this game right like I don't I'm not sure like you've you asked me like oh just tell me in one minute why this game is great I'm like I don't know you build cities and you're working towards points like I don't know they're just there's something a little bit soulless about the way you take these tiles in the way you place them because it's very I might be saying the same thing you are in a different way of where it's very mechanical it's abstract yes it's abstract but not they're abstract board games that are awesome but this way like I don't know if I think a lot it's just sort of like you know once I find the right place there's like only a few logical places to put it so I don't have a lot of creativity I think that's what I'm trying to say is like in building yeah so alright so let's get to the conclusions so what we're gonna do is we're gonna each roll a d20 die you guys know the drill and this is how many words you're gonna get to make your final thoughts our that's a good roll actually makes it harder yeah no I'd rather have like a few words I work back Anna I don't think you're quite done you're like I'll let everyone else water first get back to me and Jess off-camera you were so you're beaming with heavy it was like this is like the biggest challenge you've to ever so just

you rolled the highest at 18 what did you write alright so I said although it doesn't quite capture the city building spirit quadropple is an elegant and fun tile placement game cool right I rolled a 14 I wrote fun colorful art interesting drafting but placing tiles is very mechanical overall not bad and it is your turn all right here we go ready slick design - whew management mechanics my turns took forever all right now we're gonna vote if the game gets unanimous love switchers two thumbs we will get a platinum award it's not happening yet on the show so if you love it give it two thumbs up like it you're okay with it or am it you don't like it alright so on three one two three all right one like in two minutes somewhat I think that's what we did last episode for adrenaline all right thanks guys I appreciate your time on this now people should know we're not going to do Shawn baby this episode because we're gonna save up for the comparison discussion two videos from now but next stick around you guys are going to help me review between two cities which is another SimCity's game so everyone should stay tuned we're gonna do between 260

Progress saved