Codenames & Decrypto Mashup Review - By Board Of It
Transcript
hello farrell and tally here from board of it and today we're going to be doing a mashup review of code names and decrypto first they're both excellent little party slash family games and secondly they kind of share the same idea of the game they're both word games yet with a few little variations and tweaks they become totally different games in the way they play and it's kind of how they feel while you're playing them so we're going to timestamp this video so if you want to jump from one to the other or you just want to skip one you can do that and we're going to begin with code names codenames is probably one of the most influential board games of the last decade and we'd be surprised if you've never heard of it and the very small chance that you haven't it's a party game based around words and whilst that description sounds hella boring code names is hella not in short you're split into two teams so ideally you have between four and eight players although there are variants for less than four each team will have a designated code master each team will need to guess a bunch of words on this 5x5 word grid and the codemaster knows what those words are the codemaster will give a one-word clue followed by a number which tells their team how many of the words relate to that clue like so when the team thinks they have found the right word or words they will touch the cards
christmas one exam two and find out if they are correct or incorrect the thing with this game is on paper it sounds dry af but in practice something about it really tickles something in your lizard brain to produce joy we think in part due to the fact that the play time is quite short around 15 minutes per game so you're always ready to just go again the great thing also about the word cards is that they are double sided so in your next game you can just flip them over for a speedy setup but code names doesn't just produce joy it will produce a whole spectrum of emotions stress anger rage smugness happiness there's nothing more fulfilling than giving a clue that relates to four words and watching your teammates guess each one in turn and there's nothing more frustrating than watching your ignorances of a team pick words that have no logical relation to your clue or even worse debate picking the assassin oh yes there is an assassin a word which if picked will lose the game immediately for the team that picked it and it's so funny to watch your fellow codemaster sweat through their shirt as their team debates picking the assassin and this is because we as codemasters have to suffer silently you can't show emotion you can't talk to your team you can't even make eye contact and this is particularly hard
when the other team is being a bit of a dick and throwing out really stupid guesses to your clue and everyone's laughing code names is an addictive party game for everyone from children to oldies to family and friends just as a personal example when we got code names it was when my family were here visiting and we ended up just playing it with them the entire trip over and over because we had so much fun and this is also a game that we've stayed up till three in the morning playing with friends now the reason it's so addictive is because everyone wants to have a go as the code master and so this leads to you playing a few games to give everyone on the teams a chance to be the code master and then it gets competitive and then people say let's do best of three best of five best of nine and it just keeps going but the good thing is as much as everyone wants a turn at being the codemaster it's not a game where it's any less fun to be the guesses they are equally as good it's just that something in that lizard brain of yours you know you want to have the power of being the code master and to challenge yourself to give good clues there's also a lot of variability in the words as even though you'll see them all over time the fact that 25 are randomly placed in front of you combined with the fact that the code cards are omnidirectional provides unlimited possibilities as the game is about linking words and these are going to change every game if you enjoy the game then it's never going to feel samey or boring and now on to codenames brother
sister cousin decrypto the reason we've linked these two games is because when explaining to crypto to people i always describe it as the inverse of code names you know whereas in codenames you're trying to guess your team's words in decrypto you know your team's words and you're trying to prevent the other team from guessing those words it is for between three and eight players which are split into two teams essentially your team will be given four words at random they will be numbered then you'll draw a code card with a three number code on it you must get your team to guess the words in this particular order by giving the clues in that order seems easy right considering they can see the clues wrong because both teams hear the clues you give write them down and then try and guess the numbers on the code card thus the issue is if you make your clues too easy or if you run a link through your team's clues throughout all of your turns then the other team will begin to get a general idea of what your word might be so on future clues they will then know that that clue relates to a specific numbered word because it's too similar to all the previous clues then they might guess the code correctly they guess the code correctly they get one of these tokens if they do this twice they win the game decrypto is great at tension much better than code names playing
decrypto is like playing battleships as a kid but you're terrified the other team are gonna score a hit whereas here you're terrified they're gonna crack your code each turn provides joy tension drama and relief there's instant relief as you reveal your code and your team have guests correctly which quickly flips to tension as you wait for the other team to either celebrate or just kind of tuck and immediately start discussing which clue goes with which number for next time and the thing about it is is that giving clues into crypto is a different experience and potentially more rewarding when giving clues and code names this is because in codenames you're trying to link a lot of words together when you give a clue so sometimes your clue is really tenuous for some of the words and other times you'll give a clue that relates to words that aren't yours but you just hope that your teammates get enough of the right words before getting a wrong one whereas trying to come up with a clue into crypto is kind of like trying to play with a rubik's cube because you have to consider a lot of angles you know firstly you've got to think about how difficult is the clue and will your team may get it because obviously you've got to be obscure because they can see the words then you've got to consider the angle of what were the previous clues your team have given you know is is your clue gonna really twist the make a twist on the previous clues and surprise the other team and make them rethink what they thought or is it just gonna be something that
gives them a clearer idea of what your words are honestly there's no better feeling than coming up with a clue which is really apparent to your team but is in such a wildly different direction to all that have come before it that the opposing team's theories come crashing down in front of you as they question everything they thought they discussed up until now it's also nice that the clues aren't limited to one word you can give whole sentences if you wish which is an interesting choice however we do find that people tend to lapse back to giving one word clues most of the time perhaps because of their code names effect one negative is that the crypto is a longer more intense game whereas a game of code names can be over in 15 minutes game to crypto can go on for up to an hour or more if both teams are doing really well at hiding their codes and the other thing is as we're just saying these codes are complex to come up with and you have to come up with three of them and this means that the terms take longer and there's a lot of downtime for anyone that isn't the clue giver but at least in later turns the other team can use his downtime to discuss their thoughts and theories we think the issue is that games like these demand to be played over and over again so you can do a best of three or five or mix the teams up whereas decrypto it's a toss-up how long the game is going to take but what does save it a bit is that the clue giver changes each round so everyone gets a chance to
be one thus unlike code names you don't need to have multiple plays in order to play in the different roles so in summary both are wonderful party games that you should have in your collection they're easy to explain quick to set up and can be played with all ages they're both perfect for family game night or to play with your non-gamer friends even better both are cheap surprisingly cheap considering how much joy you're gonna get out of them and out of the two the crypto could be considered the underdog just because it's less well known uh you know code name is very popular game even non-gamers know it and have played it but the crypto is actually the number one rated party game on board game geek with code names coming in at number two and i think that's deserved because i think when it's all said and done there's just a bit more to crypto but i personally prefer code names and i think this is because it's quicker well it's quick and snappy i think it's a funnier game and it's easier teach i think that the concept of just having these one word clues that are really vague and then you have to get multiple words from that clue lead to these really hilarious discussions with you know between the teammates and we're actually going to show you a reenactment of something that happened in one of our games of code names ready okay mammal two
well that's a bird and a dog's not a mammal so it can't be those i think for me decrypto just edges it over code names even though i love both i think because you have to really come up with those creative clues and i just find it really satisfying to come up with them and put the other team completely off the scent thus get both you're not going to regret either and if you enjoyed this video please give it a thumbs up we'd really appreciate it and please subscribe to our channel for regular board game reviews always with a little hint of logo