Skip to main content
Loading video...

Trash or Treasure!? The Great Board Game Purge of 2024

Transcript 38:48

what's up everybody welcome back to the channel today we're going through a bunch of games and deciding whether or not we want to keep them or or call them I don't like that name keep what call keep I guess call does sound very violent I think like Mass Slaughter I think Mass Slaughter or I think like Kevin sorbos call the curer these are the two things I think when I hear the word call I don't what else do you want something better uh treasure treasure and trash we're going to decide whether treasure or trash game tabletop Turtles treasure and trash first up we have creature Caravan this is treasure no there you have to have suspense you have to build up you don't just say treasure right away oh the hell treasur so okay well at least let me introduce the game this is creature Caravan in creature Caravan players build a card Tableau of creatures while traveling through a dangerous land players take turns simultaneously placing dice on AES on their cards moving their Caravan on the map and playing new creature cards the player with the most points is the winner this is definitely the surprise hit of the year I was not expecting much when I first played this game and then we played it once and then I was like I got to play it again then I got to play it again cuz he lost the first few times I didn't lose the first time yes I did want Redemption few times I lie but I did want but Redemption aside I did want to keep playing there was just something about it that I just found very Charming very engaging you know the mechanics they're they're really well done it's

it's all relatively simple but here it's I'm okay with that when we first started playing this game we first got this game I thought it would be something more for kids maybe it's the artwork and how cute and cartoony it is yeah it's best art I thought it' be light very light and easy but it also has layers to it and there are some parts about it that are slightly L dependent and there are other parts that make you feel like wow I'm really smart cuz I did this stuff together yeah the whole game just goes together really smoothly and the fact that it plays simultaneously means that well okay we'll spoil it here I guess you already spoiled it I I want to keep it too I want to I want to treasure it we decided we treasure it we're both going to treasure it because it just it just makes sense because it plays it plays at all player accounts I can whip this out when it's just two people I whip this out when it's what does it play up to five whip this out five people like it's just it's it's really well done high with about ability score no what with B ability yeah that's right it's high on wh whip about ability score it's just a solid game and I I really love it it's I just did my tier ranking list pretty recently and I didn't rate this game I think I give it an S I was wa an A and an S but I think it's an S rank game I really like it yeah it's one of those games I think we knew it was going to be um San play before we got the game and so we expected it would be like a little dry cuz like we love playing Bo games for the social component of it but something but this game there's no interaction here I don't know there's L interaction

in the turns but the wor the game you are looking at other people's playboards and you're looking at the trade board looking at you're looking at different things and something with this game we put on some good music and we all just got focused on our thing and we just and everybody loved it everyone that played it loved it yeah I'm always fine with games that don't have interaction provided they're able to provide me a puzzle that's like interesting enough to solve and they don't overstay it's welcome and this game plays in like 30 minutes so like I I don't care I don't care that there's no interaction I have my fun we're going to keep this one let's move on to the next one up next is explorers of nooria explorers of nooria seize players on adventure to explore new continents that have emerged you'll build settlements on these continents craft supplies and items for your adventure and collaborate with various races of nooria to Aid in your exploration draft cards move up tracks rinse and repeat until the end of the third round where you all turn around to the table and ask each other if what you just played was a board game so what do we think do we think we should treasure it or trash sh trash trash for trash it's not a bad game no it's not bad it's not it's not bad it's just not good it's not good and it's boring it's really boring if you want more in depth opinions on this game you can watch our review of it but it's pretty damn boring the the deeper you go into the worlder board games the more games you play and the more Solari you find between games and it's it is really hard to stand up when there's so many games you really hard to S down and I think if you didn't

have big collection of board games it could be great it's got some unique features it's really easy to play uh it's a great back of the box blur but if you've never played any other their board games this is a good game the difficulty is that like there's just not a lot of player agency in this game like you take your turns and everything feels pretty scripted like my turns feel obvious when you go and you do the second portion of the game where you have to work a placement portion the there's there's like these three tiers of places first you don't SEL really select you're just selecting from like this this these little discs and you're just matching the colors but then it's like a tier system of like okay do I select um this worker action this worker action this work action it's just descending in value so the choice is really obvious choice is always obvious and even when I'm drafting cards I'm not selecting from the entire group I'm just pulling it from a bag taking two discs and being like I yeah and I'm saying like Okay I guess I'll take this one and not the other one yeah there you're right all tracks are the same like they the game doesn't even disguise itself that it's just moving up tracks the track to the same there is a very this this is one of those games it's simple but there's no deeper strategy no you know there is a very clear this is the strategy to win the end and so every time you play it's it's the same game it's the same game again and again versus other games where you can approach it differently each time you play and there's still and there's no very it's well balanced there's only one very clear way for win you could win through during different things and just extion of how you know those different things this is a very straightforward game with without many layers of complexity and so it's not in great no

no there's not much discussion that needs to be had about this game like I said if you want to watch the review watch the review uh we kind of trash on the game but oh we want to thank the publisher for sending it to us thank you sorry but I don't like we don't like it was a good experience but it's just it's it probably would benefit if you know if we had kids or younger audience uh people that were deep into board games yeah this is a great game to pull out for them yeah people suffering from brain damage whatever okay trash and up next is spectral deduction in spectral players control treasure Hunters moving around the haunted manner to deduce and incover treasure using secretly revealed Clues while also doing their best to avoid demonic curses but uncovering that treasure is not enough treasure Hunters need to make sure they have enough men in that area to take that treasure from other players once the game ends all right so what do we think of spectral do we want to keep in our shell treasure yeah dou a thumbs up for me yeah I'm not the biggest deduction fan but I do like this one I do like the fact that it plays so incredibly quickly and there's a bit more of a game attached to the deduction component a lot of times you have uh like search planet unn is is good Planet X sorry is good but sometimes it doesn't feel like a board game like sometimes it is just feels like a deduction puzzle this one because it has not necessarily area control but the little men that you move around and you're trying to outbeat other people it's interesting and plus you can like you can really read other players and that's I think that's the part I like

the most read other players it's like a read me there's more like social deduction is what I'm saying than just like deducing the mechanics of the game you're deducing the actions of other players as well so it's like this layer of deduction that I really appreciate I freaking love this game this I I love deduction games in general I love um social Planet X I I just I don't know I like to think it makes me feel very smart it's something about these games that really feel like it's some interesting puzzle something about the structure in which they place in different rows and you're trying to figure out which row is which and so you're trying to eliminate the possibility of which uh what what they call it curse is in which location it's simple but creative enough that it leads to a fantastic game every time yeah yeah it's a really solid game I I enjoy it um and it's just easy to teach like super easy to teach so it's definitely something that we think we should keep in our collection just because it has a wide audience of people that I think will enjoy it so this will be treasured up next we have quartermaster General in quartermaster General players team up as the Axis or Allies to fight across the world with fun card play where each nation has its own unique set of cards to Marshall their forces and attack others on a shared map and gain victory points so what do we think about quartermaster General we actually played this really really recently so that's why I kind of brought it to the block because it previous to that time it hadn't been played for like three years I think all right so 3 2 1 treasure what the hell does that mean neutral

neutral that's not that you know you have to pick one it's a binary you can't go in between it doesn't matter you're overruled like more games but I do feel like this game was really good and it was particularly good at a player count of six players yeah but it also has a team Dynamic which you don't see in games so it's I'm a solo player well I think it's pretty fun to have like three people on one side three people on the other side there's enough depth here that like you know you can really sink your teeth into it but there's not so much that you can overwhelm new players who have never played before because if because if you're trying to gun for a six-person audience the chances are you're going to get a fairly mixed audience you're going to have people who are really good at games and people who are like pretty new to games and you can you can pitch this to either either camp and even though it's it's War it it's pretty light like it's pretty light and it's pretty easy breezy and you don't feel ganged up on because are sharing your loss and your your your win with a with a team I think there's some games that you can have in your collection that with with you have the full knowledge that it's not something that's you're going to be able to whip out every year maybe you know that it's going to be a very specific game for a very specific audience at a very specific time it's like Twilight Imperium you know you can't whip that all the time same thing with quartermaster General you need six players and you need people who love being on a team so for that it fits that purpose really well so it will be kept I will call it Board Game Cafe game it can be yeah it be of game types some games I don't think I really need to own but I'm happy when I go to BF I know I want to

go see this game it would be a lot of fun to play a cafe group setting yeah this would be a lot of fun to play the cafe so if you ever see in a cafe and you got six people or five other people with you give it a try it's awesome next up is sand we also recently reviewed this did we yes we did it's that forgettable sand is a quick pickup and delivery game that sees players traveling around the desert visiting different towns and collecting goods and doing the usual pickup and deliver stuff that you've seen probably a million times before so what do we think about sand do we treasure it do we trash it do we throw it into the sand pile trash I was oh I didn't do a countdown hope that didn't influence your opinion no I like this game I just don't love this game and like he said it's not the most memorable game yeah yeah this is I think we gave it a six or something and I stand by that even now like we played it somewhat recently it's still kind of a six it's not it's not a bad game by search of the imagination I'm s I'm sure there's going to be a lot of people who like pick up and deliver games who are going to appreciate this for what it is um we are pretty mild on pickup and deliver games so it has to be something fairly special and this one's pretty not AR tribes was a great pickup delivery like yeah it is you do pick up pieces that's okay this is the issues you're run into when you have like a Channel with one person person who's like very deep entr trenched into board game terminology and all that and one who's like really

new no pick up and you can't Co the terminology I'm not coing anything no pickup and deliver is when like you have you you've picked up goods from one area of a map let's say and you want to fulfill a contract and so you're delivering them you're moving your guy across the board to get rid of those goods to fill a contract at a different area of the board that's that's sand you're just that whereas five tribes yes you are physically picking up pieces and you're you're delivering ier through the board you drop a pieces okay Bruno cathal pick up a delivery game five tribes does it stand up to five tribes it does not it do that that's yeah it's just kind of I it was just kind of boring like I didn't really like it I certainly didn't hate it um but it was just it's nothing special again I'm go back to the it's a good game yeah it's not distinct enough from all the other games that no doesn't leave a lot yeah and just because things get trashed exactly just because things get trashed doesn't mean they're bad games it's just like you only have a limited amount of space in our house for certain games and yeah yeah and it just it doesn't meet that criteria so goodbye and next up endless winter in Endless winter players develop their tribe across several Generations from pneumatic hunter gatherers to prosperous tribal societies over the course of the game Tribes migrate and settle new lands establish cultural traditions hunt Paleolithic animals and build Everlasting megalithic structures I recently played this at a friend's house or tried to play this at a friend's house it had been like a year

and a half and I didn't remember a lot of the rules and I realized when I was starting to teach it that I just didn't care and we packed it up and played something else and so I thought I'd bring it to the chopping block because I'm not sure if I want to continue owning it so let's decide let's decide right now 3 2 1 trash oh okay I didn't I like this game you like this game you don't you don't know me I really like this game I don't like the number of minatures and how Bucky the game is I think kind exessive I guess yeah it's not the game that if a friends play something I don't think would bring this game it's just my issue though is like it's it's a tough thing to teach new players because there's so much on the table there's like okay look guys look at this little board see this little board here well this does this okay we got all do that stuff okay next board see this next board here and you're just going through be like okay I teach this now it's just it's a lot yeah I think part of why I like it is it's got a really strong theme it's a really strong theme that makes yeah I guess and I love the animal collection cards but that is OD it's a set collection you collect you collect these animals and basically looking like I'm I'm I won five reindeer saber saber-tooth tigers because I get x amount of points and you can eat them too if you want you just reduce the amount of points you get but you get meat yeah the there I guess a really strong theme and so there's all these different small mechanisms that added to this theme and it's just well done yeah there a lot of boards and I think there's a lot of games now where

there's too many boards to think about and there's mechanisms yeah there's too much to to balance and I the problem with some games like that is when the theme is not strong and they feel disjointed this game this game in particular I feel that the theme is strong enough that the different components for mechanisms were still in sync so it didn't feel like it was that pain like oh I want to do this I I have to do this and plus it also allows for the Strategic play that which we enjoy where you can go really hard at one thing or another thing in different game you can try different things different games exactly you can your your strategy can change between games and you can still win in different ways so it's not like only one approach so I do like this game well if it's not unanimous then it means keep okay so we will keep it and when we play it again you better like it we're just going to get rid of it I liked it every time all right and next up is harmony another game we recently reviewed so check that out if you haven't already harmonies is an abstract strategy game that sees players drafting a set of three discs at the start of their turn which they'll use to place on their board to complete various patterns required by animal cards they've drafted so do we want to keep or do know what do we say trash treasure do want a trash treasure okay right well yeah wait yes treasure I love this game yeah it's really good it's just a really good it's a solid solid abstract game um I don't not a big abstract fan but I think this fits into any collection right beside aul and Cascadia I think they're different enough puzzles to Warrant holding all three of them um

and this one I think is probably the heaviest of them I say heaviest but I'm just meaning like I think it's the biggest brain burner like I feel more mentally taxed when I'm playing harmonies than I do those other two games whereas in this game the animals are I I feel like in Cascadia the animals are like this like constant thing right cuz they're all just set out and you just do whatever you have to do whereas the harmony is it's just constant changing thing where you know like you draft a new one you got to compl complete that one then okay you draft a new one like there's a lot more there's a lot more tactical awareness necessary in harmonies than there is in Cascadia there something about that feels so so simple so easy to teach so easy to talk about but then when you're playing it it's like okay don't talk to me there's a lot of things I need to right now yeah it's like leave me alone I am solving my puzzle I don't want to interact with you okay it's so hard to fully optimize the amount of space that you have and the part I love hate about this game is that mik wins it for me every single game where ending it because he's run out of space on his board every single time it's you that run out space on your board and I still have space left so I can do more and so I feel like I'm not getting the optimal version of it but then in a way it's Al like a race you know the person yeah it's player controlled ending so if you think you're near the end and you you know you think you're in the lead then you have no reason to let the game keep going so do your best to to Speed it along yeah so we really enjoy this game it's a great game like I said if you want more opinion of it on it more detail check out the review we keep it up next we

have Rock card 1977 another game we recently reviewed in raw card you'll play as an aspiring musician trying to carve their way into the industry by making mixtapes writing songs honing their skills performing at venues and consuming way too much candy so what do we think of rock hard 1977 do we like treasure it or do we want to tabletop treasure it three two one trash yeah trash um it's it was go ahead okay Canadians so it it it's a good game we'll probably just say the same thing it's a good game when you first play even maybe your second playthrough yes you're like wow this is so much fun you're like reading these cards that pop up you know it's an adventure I compared this to Elder tour and it kind of is like you go around this map you know exp not exploring well yeah exploring the CD Night scene and and you know playing a dive bars you quit your job and stuff become a rock star and you get to read like oh I I got genital warts Boo or oh I'm getting drunk tonight you you read them from the cards it's fun it's fun but the problem is that that fun you know that uniqueness of reading those cards it wears off and at some point you're just looking at the card and be like okay this gives me plus one to my chops and this gives me a plus two to my whatever and then you just toss it yeah I completely agree I think the novelty of this game game was really cool um listening to her music while playing the game was a fun thing but I I want to create a new category it really it's it's just sport Game Cafe games GES that like are definitely worth the

experience but might not be worth keeping your collection yeah worth it to try not worth it to buy oh we should have a new called that rhes worth trying Worth to trying but not to buy but again thank you for sending it us along to us uh di uh we appreciate it we just didn't I don't think this game is for us but I could see families you know liking it and if you're a fan of uh both uh 70s rock stars in general sure or or just becoming a Rockstar yeah if you ever had a dream of that this is a cool game to try for that that's true it'll bring you closer to your dream not really not really not at all okay goodbye and up next is loot in loot players control a horde of Vikings raiding the mainland capturing buildings stealing the englishman's cute little sheeps and just racking up as much riches as possible while getting in your opponent's way at every turn till you have crowned the yl of the Vikings do we want to treasure or trash loot 321 trash I mean treasure treasure I said the opposite of what my thumb was saying yeah lud is just it's a el out of fun and it's so wonderfully mean when you if you want it to be it's if you want it to be mean I love I love playing to be mean in this game I don't love mean I because if you you have two components where you're placing tiles on your own board but to get those tiles you first have to like maneuver and place out your Vikings on the main board and I love spending you know that you have these one Powers these three three powers you can use but you can only use them one time and using them at just right moment to like block off your opponent from him getting like a or her

getting a castle or something or a house it always feels good it always feels good and it becomes this like cat Mouse game like oh should I use my double placement but if I use my double plac and she might use this and yeah I never tried to be mean I'm so glad I live that's what makes the game so fun for uh so I guess in a way that's pretty cool that we like very different things and we both enjoy this game very much I don't like mean stuff at all but I still really enjoy this game so well done another example of a such a simple game and super intuitive but still so much Dr my turns never feel obvious and and it never feel like they take a long time either something so is very quick and it's very easy to do but it still feels like it's got really really good depth I'm always okay with like I think a lot of I've got a lot of com say like you just hate light games cuz I I shat on like Harvest and stuff I I'm okay with light games but you just have to give me some semblance of choice you have to give me some semblance of depth why suppos good good be a good game just be a good game and this game is a good game listen I don't think this game is really to very short but it's short enough that you feel like you you get to the good stuff and you have for a little while and then it ends when you still want more absolutely then going to play it again so if you want more information check out our review of it we're going to keep it absolutely treasure it up next is the Talk of the Town everybody's favorite game in the entire world except some people arcs arcs is a Sci-Fi strategy game where players play cards to perform actions using a trick-taking mechanic all to exert their dominance to the Galaxy gather resources engage in a

little diplomatic Intrigue so do we want to keep this game that literally every content creator is telling you it's the greatest game all existence 3 2 1 ready treasure oh why unpopular yeah you don't like this game I do not like this we we're in the process we've played it four times now so we're in this process of reviewing we have to play like you know six seven eight more times and I can tell that Kim is not a fan really for me on trash but I really like it I think it's great so the I I'm very excited for the review cuz it's going to be basically like a love and hate review yeah I think that's also why we wanted to create this channel together is that there are a lot of games where we like very different things where we both love and there a lot of games like this where there part I like and there are Parts he loves and we clearly have a very different opinion about this game this game is very confrontational so it's not going to be for everybody like but but part of the thing that I love about it is the fact that it's so confrontational and it's Unique within its confrontation like you know on the one hand you are throwing you're throwing other players like individual ponds into like prison or you're stealing their resources from them or you're stealing their cards from them or you're attacking their planets or you're like she likes to be mean or you're just burning down their their their buildings there's so many opport you're blowing up their spaceships there just OPP opportunities to be to be not cool tactical strategic but I ALS but there's lots of other things I like about this game I I also like that a lot of it's player controlled I feel a ton

of power and and agency whenever I play this game like the fact that you can set up flate in don't flate has ego and power no but like when you set up the victory conditions or the point scoring I really like that I like when games provide that it's really cool yeah well you can decide like as a as a players themselves decide what will determine the victory say you like that yeah and like the trick taking element I hate trick taking games but in this it just works it works really well even though I completely understand an individual's criticism of the game where they say like it's really it can be really random because you yeah you you can't get that hand of cards where like you really want to score the The Prisoner thing but you can't because you don't have that card in your hand yeah yeah the I think sometimes for us too I'm sure we've experienced it where the luck element for certain games for some people like for me in this game and the cards it just feels so unfair and there's so little you can do about it that it just the whole game sucks like some games it's all competation and only that if you don't do that if like if for this game for example if I don't want to invade some those places there's nothing else I can do there there's very little to what you can do to just focus on you know way like an engine building kind of thing we kind of do that here but at at some point if you don't go looking for confrontation it's going to find you somebody's coming knocking at your door for your stuff and it's going to be me so it's I'm going to keep this check out our review it's probably coming somewhat soon um it'll be controversial I guess at least well your hatred of it everybody seems like it I just don't

love it I just would be happy never playing it again okay wow we're keeping it I this is a this is a play with the boys game I guess keep this up next is oh my God this is deceptively heavy SE the search for extraterrestrial intelligence in set you lead a scientific institution tasks with searching for traces of Life Beyond planet Earth you'll explore nearby planets and their moons by launching probes from Earth while taking advantage of ever shifting planetary positions decide whether to land or to surface to collect valuable samples or stay in orbit for a broader survey this is one of those games we played at packs really recently we've played about three times we're probably going to have a review coming soon it was demo To Us by the very lovely elanie what do we think about this do we want to keep it do we want to treasure it do we want to treasure it do we want to trash it three two one treasure treasure for me as well yeah that's funny cuz like I didn't think you liked it that much I like played with it loved it they loved it I like it quite a bit they loved it so we played this uh so we tried it a packs and we literally brought it home and that night we played yeah we did even though we were all just like worn out and tired yeah I was ready to go to bed like I was tired my feet were hurting I was not up for it but at the same time I was like I do want to try it yeah we watched uh we watched Alan's um tutorial video on this she works she works for check games if if you ever want to learn a check game just check out her videos she makes some of the best tutorials online I think uh we actually just sat down we watched our video and then straight away we started playing and it

was I had a lot of fun even though I sucked that the your first couple plays this game were going to be a little sluggish trying to get a hold of all the stuff and oh oh table to Turtle strategy tip of the day strategy strategy strategy that's it's like a interlude I see strategy tip of the day when you first play this game okay your first two rounds should be primarily about making sure you have an income okay so you should be playing cards and doing actions that provide you an income for later turns because if you don't do that it will be really hard the game will be hard on you and you will have a bad time because everybody else will be generating like I have this much energy I have this much coins and just I have to comment on that I get that strategy tip but this is I guess a part I don't like about the game it's so hard to get stuff to it is a difficult the income happens by you have this one card off the side and you stack cards underneath it and the bottom of the card has some some item whether res resources exactly and that is your income and you'll be getting that an end every round it's so hard to find that icon to slot another car under to increase that income so you like he said those spots are rare yeah the ones that allow you to Slot Cards those those are rare those it's on some of the cards but the spots on the board it's on planets when you go and orbit a planet and it's so hard to go orbit a planet in the first few so it's really hard to put up that income yeah part of the front of the game is the tightness to which you are playing slow build fast

yeah exactly like every resource you have counts yeah it's not like the game we have in front of us right now which is andromeda's Edge where like you know most of the things you're doing is like rewards rewards T have this have this in this game no you're you're scratching and and cry crawling really efficient how you spend your resources and that could be fun sometimes it is I think it's really fun yeah and that's why we're keeping this up next is oh my God this is also very heavy deashi tooshi deashi daoshi deashi is a worker placement game where players work to make the city inhabitable by electrifying its districts discovering new inventions and tring with Far Away cities but you have to be careful because if you encroach too far to the Wilds you'll anger the spirits of the land so are we going to be keeping this in three or two in one trash trash yeah uh again it's one of those games that is not a bad game I really wish it's actually pretty decent I actually I think I'm not sure when I gave it when gave a six um or a seven but I have warmed on a little and I would give it almost I would give it a seven it is a good game but it's it's not a great game in in our collection there's only room for great games I can't have games that are just like yeah that was good and then but I don't crave this game like there's lots of components that I enjoy you know I love the fact that you sort of has this like semi Cooperative nature to its design where you're sort of building out the board together I like that produce other people can produce too yeah exactly yeah I I like stuff

like that there's a lot of mechanisms that I really appreciate but for whatever reason with them all together it feels very clunky and cumbersome and not particularly enjoyable I have this was I would say my most disappointing game as it I loved like really love some components of this game and some mechanisms but I also really didn't like some other things and that's why I don't think this game end up being for me I love the whole middle wheel component and then you build the parts a lot of the actions the putting your color specific color workers a lot that stuff I loved the way the game scor that I really didn't like I didn't feel like it made a lot of sense the the different way to Pi points like the four different tracks I don't think that made sense to the game and this is where I felt like sometimes a strong theme helps the game go so far cuz this felt to me felt disjointed felt clunky so yeah if you want more information on it we went into way more detail in our review of the game uh which oh shoot we didn't publish that yet never mind coming soon guess but yeah we'll getting rid of this one up next we have the surprisingly light game cuz I've emptied the box cuz it's in front of us andromeda's Edge which I guess we shouldn't have in front of us cuz can't you're you're hide you're hidden the drama is Edge and a drama is Edge you'll be building a new civilization by gathering resources claiming moons acquiring modules to add to your station and populating planets all to gain Supremacy in the Galaxy so

drama's Edge is a game we play actually really recently we just had a fun come over yesterday we you play it for your first time that would have been my this would have been my second time playing it and let's well let's just do it do we trash it do we treasure it 3 2 1 treasure so good so good I I was watching CU I before we even played before I wasn't thinking about this game I was watching like content creators just gush over it um and I was like oh can't be that good CU I'm kudin heart I think I was like well that's heart in in all senses the word reality and then I played it I was like okay this is pretty damn awesome it's fun it's pretty fun we already liked dwellings of Elder I love dwellings she loves it I really like it um I think I why we haven't talked about this yet I think this is better I think this is a better game or definitely improved on Parts yeah like the targeting system I know the combat in technicality I know it's better because of all the improved components but I don't it I think I like I would say this I I think dwellings is a is a more Charming game yeah it's more Charming has a different feel and vibe to it these all very sound very vague sorry something that's it's easier to te to really simple that game it's complex I mean they both big box games really big it has some depth yeah but it's like really easy to teach I'm still learning different strategies for it I'm still learning different approaches so yeah and we're in that phase right now because we only played like I she played once I played three times but we're both in that like early excitement phase so

we have to play it more just to make sure whether that excitement maintains or whether it sort of fad away cuz you don't want to you never want to review a game after like three plays cuz you might be like yeah this the greatest game of the whole time and then a year later you're just never talking about it yeah that's a really big thing I see a lot of people I see a lot of our friends and people we know online is St too like they do that right like we're at some point like this is the world's greatest game and then you never he about it after yeah absolutely it's definitely something we're going to have to play a lot more just to see whether or not that greatness Fades away so we'll probably look out for a revieww of it sometime soon and we're also going to do soon we have to play like at least 10 more times oh yeah that's true okay maybe in a couple months but I have a funny feeling it might sneak its way into our top 10 games of the year maybe oh I don't know I did give this an assy my tear raing so it' be weird if it didn't end up there which is a video we should be watching out soon like I said we played this a pack and it was just it was really enjoyable it was really enjoyable we ended up meeting the designer Luke and he was really rad and he was really nice and warm and everybody at cardboard Alchemy and Lucky Duck were all cool and they helped us teach the game and this is like this is the end of the night they didn't have to do any of this they had a lot of my God stuff they had to be doing I some people were like so exhausted from this whole long we so if you guys are watching this uh thank you very much thank you very much we love your game and this is Def the like highlight of our trit it was yeah so this is a different keep for us I look forward it's a treasure treasure it's just treasure treasure treasure treasure yeah we're going to keep this for a long time and now we will decide because it's perfectly related do we do we treasure

or trash dwellings of elderil dwellings of elderil is an epic worker place game set in the once lost magical world giant Elemental Monsters roam while dragons Wizards and warriors battle for dominance to grow in power and control elderil I feel believe this is even a conversation right now well we just played it's it's it's it's pseudo replacement so we have to make the tough call now no do we treasure or trash this three two one treasure I think they look the same game I mean they're pretty damn similar pretty damn similar okay okay I get why people can say that they're similar but they're not the same game no it's not the same game but it has a a lot of the same mechanisms and so do many many games but they still justify a different game if the theme is different and the play is different and the experience of the whole game is different I also agree I also think that if you can have different types of strategies for the games then the different games they're different games yeah I guess yeah I mean I do really like dwellings I still love dwellings there is no but the question becomes like can you honestly see us playing this over androus Edge yes when the friend comes up why well why why would we do that cuz you can make people at the houses I do feel the D is like the more I don't know simple version if it simp almost it's friendlier it's it is friendlier it's I don't know it's I feel like this is the more fun version and this is the more and drous Ed is the

more intense version like drous Ed is the more strategic intense version and dwellings is more the light-hearted fun version of it yeah I don't see so okay so I don't see a purpose to eliminating this game because you own andromeda's Edge I think they can both sort of live together on your shell however if you own neither I I don't think it'd be a good idea to buy both they're both pretty expensive like if so you know cash if you owe neither if you owe neither uh it would depend on your audience are your are your audience consists of individuals who don't mind longer games who don't mind like okay guys we're going to sit here and learn rules for about 30 minutes you okay with that they're both longish yeah yeah but but andromus Edge is a harder game so if that's your audience then yeah go andromus edge if your audience is like you know sometimes you'll have people over who don't play a lot of games you could still teach dwellings pretty easily and they they'll understand and they'll have a lot of fun I would almost generally I would almost say that dwellings is probably more for everybody little bit yeah and dwellings is probably the everybody game and jabra's Ed is probably your hardcore board game friend yeah as pretentious as that sounds it's kind of true it is kind of true and thematically as well something about drawing the fantasy type it's Charming like I said yeah it's it's very appealing it's very easy it's it's the same like I would say D and D is to everybody's RPG you know like anybody can kind of jump into it and play dwellings is that version as well like it's anybody board game yeah

so I think it's it's definitely worth owning both um we're going to keep it I guess so there is no question about it I don't know why I was in this video at all it was always going to be I think it's a w that was worth asking no thatb wraps it up for Treasure or trash tabletop Turtles treasure or trash alliteration Adventure hope you enjoyed it guys um it is hard to curate a a very tight board game collection um but you you have to okay don't become one of those people episode of Hoarders where you get buried and then all of a sudden you they find dead cats in your thing even though you don't even own cats some people's happen is having a whole apartment from Florida ceiling stack and board games that's true that's but one day you'll get buried in them and then they'll find dead cats it doesn't matter whether you own dead cats at board games is somebody's Heaven somebody's fetish I guess all right bye thanks for watching everyone see you later

Progress saved