A Quick Word About Puerto Rico...
Transcript
hey guys uh so um just wanted to say a kind of quick word uh about the fact that puerto rico features as number one on our most recent uh euro games uh list like i've seen in in the comments a lot of talk about its problematic theme uh and that is something that we didn't mention in the video and just looking back on it that doesn't really sit right with me um so obviously board games when it comes to kind of especially board games with problematic themes are it's a subject where it feels like i don't necessarily want to i don't want to lecture from a point of privilege because i understand that a lot of people are able to enjoy a board game with a problematic theme something that hasn't aged since it came out 19 years ago and are able to put that theme to one side and enjoy a game and very often um their enjoyment of the game feels intensely personal and i didn't want to kind of say you shouldn't enjoy this game because of this theme um but it also does feel kinda cowardly to not engage in that conversation um so obviously i've played puerto rico i had a wonderful time with it not a huge uh heavy euro games fan i've taught myself a lot about euro games in the making of these lists um but puerto rico is the most fun i've
had with a complicated euro game played it with my friends we looked at the table thought this is a bit grim but we pushed through it and eventually we just sort of swept up the mechanics and the theme ended up kind of fading away i understand that is not an option for for some people um and yeah i i guess i just want to use this as an opportunity to say um uh we completely get anyone who is uncomfortable with puerto rico being recommended by the channel i suppose um i would like to kind of use this opportunity to recommend a really beautiful sort of anti-colonial board game in the form of spirit island it's not strictly a euro i guess but it kind of it's very heavy very complex dealing with a map managing your hand managing resources but you are playing as basically indigenous spirits trying to purge your island of uh white plastic invaders it is uh it's an exceptional game um so i want to signal boost that game and also no pun included's video on colonialism we've put a link to that at the top of the description because that is a incredibly articulate and emotional and beautifully researched and very personal piece um from the excellent guys over it no pun included so yeah we i
didn't want to just ignore it uh i also realized that kind of like it's not necessarily my place to kind of lay a moral ground but like speaking of someone who comes from a country that used to be a colonial power um it's easy to kind of put problematic themes to one side when you uh you know have that kind of privilege and i just thought that yeah not engaging in the conversation at all just felt like bearing head and sand i still really like puerto rico i am so on board uh if it gets a retheme which i hope it will because yeah it's grim stuff i just wanted to put like a viewpoint at least some stance across that yeah um there is a increasing movement in board games kind of against these colonial type themes it's a very common theme in eurogaming because yeah you arrive in a place and you make an engine out of the place and a lot of euro games don't yeah they don't kind of wrestle with the fact that the engine is often made of people and yeah there is a lot more um kind of self-examination that is being done and needs to be done in board gaming um i yeah i i still like puerto rico i
would still play it that is sort of the personal choice that i have made um but yeah i don't think there should not be a discussion of it on no rosbard just because yeah is this something that means a lot to a lot of people anyway um yeah thank you for watching this if you did and also please please please be good people in the comments because yeah i think it's a conversation worth having worth having civilly and i think it's perfectly possible to say i enjoy puerto rico i wish it didn't have this theme but i enjoy the game that's personally my standpoint on it i'm not going to tell you to throw out your copy just maybe let's all be aware of certain things that uh that are prevalent in this industry and that could do with just changing to make other people feel less weirded out less grossed out more welcome and less like maybe their own uh culture or history aren't being kind of yeah sanitized cleaned up and turned into a kind of pinball machine for people who have never really had to wrestle with that anyway thank you for watching this if you have bye bye