How to design fun games | James Ernest
Transcript
more is not better yeah you know I think people make their own games complicated I think and sometimes in an attempt to differentiate them which I think is not a good design pillar um mostly just because that's what they know how to do and it's always better though often harder to take a rule away than add another one if there's something that's not working you have two possibilities you can add a rule or you can take one out and you know I think that there's a fear that if you take away too many rules you'll wind up with nothing but I I've never actually seen that happen
all right James so I reached out to you recently to help out with this book I've been working on called find the fun and it's really a book about how to go from idea all the way to marketable product and one of the main things to think about if we're new game designers especially is creating something that's fun because a lot of times designers they make something that works you know they play test it and they're like hey nothing is broken but that doesn't necessarily mean it's fun or it's going to be a good product out in the marketplace that other people want to play and so when you're thinking about the word fun in the context of board games what does that mean do you have like a certain definition or certain angle what do you think yeah there's it's a complicated word and there's a lot of definitions for it um I think that my personal take is always trying to think of the product from the perspective of the player and from specifically from the perspective of the new player because a game inventor will and I geez I had this happen to me just yesterday I'm working with a team of people for whom um a game is a list of features and they're looking at a whole bunch of other games in the space and they're comparing their feature set to their to the to the other games feature sets and saying see we have a game because we have this feature from this game and this feature from this game and I'm I play the game and it's not fun but that like that doesn't enter into their thinking I think as when you're when you're creating a game it's easy to get trapped in a mindset of a game must exist and this is how you make one and forget that someone else has to come to it fresh and like understand it and play it and so yeah so
so it's always thinking of the product from the player's perspective which sounds trite but that's like I'm amazed how few people actually do it RAF Coster has a a book called The Theory of fun for game design it's it's a hopefully you've read it uh in preparation for writing your own and he talks about oh humans are hardwired to learn stuff and and so as long as you are getting something out of your interaction with the system that is like natural response that's why people like to play games because they don't learn enough stuff in their everyday life right and my version of that is that fun is poking at a system and predicting what's going to happen and usually but not always being right so that's what we're doing we're messing with this podcast software and hoping that it does what we want and it's it's uh entertaining because uh we think we've got it figured out but it keeps surprising us now in that yeah and that's an interesting point though where does Surprise Play into that right so you said you know you're poking a system and then you a lot most of the time get what you think is going to happen but then though sometimes you don't right sometimes the dice well it's it's science isn't it you make a prediction you do an experiment you get the result right that's the scientific method and if you can't make any prediction at all it's not fun because it's confusing this is this is koster's bracketing system is it if something is so confusing that you can't predict any results it's not fun
because no matter what you try you don't know what's going to happen and at the other end of the scale it's boring if every prediction you make is correct like nobody needs to test you know I I'm not going to pull a random Theory but no you know things we all know no one needs to run more experience experiments to find out if apples fall from trees right we we know that um and so that is that the boring end of the spectrum and somewhere in the middle is this this gray area where you can poke at a thing and see what happens but make predictions about it and usually be right or sometimes be right you know that's as long as it's not never and always you're in the you're in the groove and what people find fun about games is different people to people because because I might be playing poker because I've never seen five cards before and that's interesting and I'm I'm going to hope that I hit this flesh and maybe I will and maybe I won't and I know what's going to happen but someone at the same table is poking at people and seeing how they react and seeing if they can make them play badly by getting into their heads and that's two different systems that work in the same game and those people are having two completely different flavors of fun yeah that's a really good point and thinking through okay who is the target audience for your game what what types of fun do they enjoy and then how can you lean into that as much as possible and so when you're designing a game are you thinking about that like right at the beginning Ground Zero before you even get into the design space of before you even start working on a game I mean I yeah I don't uh
I don't know what one should think of first but I know that what one should always have in mind is the user's experience um I've been working with a I mean I've worked with so many teams who are and individuals as well who they know they want to make a game and they know what features comprise a game but they don't really know what experience they're trying to deliver and so they deliver a sack full of parts and it's not a game and they don't know why um I always try to think of a game as the player the players experience the player's first time experience and the players you know 100th play as well but it's all about what they get out of it and it doesn't matter what I put into it no one cares as much about the details of your game as you do that's your job to make that invisible they care about their experience to it and as they unpack it and learn all the nuances of what the game can do that should be a an experience of Discovery and not just like executing a set of rules I think that's the the fine line right for new designers they come in like I was saying earlier they're like hey this works it's like yeah but it's not fun and so how do you do that how do you go from the bag of parts to something that's almost magical that's like oh this is really enjoyable it's really hard to bring me into a project halfway and again I'm speaking about some current experience I'm having right now but like I my first reaction is to throw all those parts away like okay I know that I have all these tools right and I we made we made some mechanics and that's great but let's start over and figure out what it is that we're actually trying to do
because from the the player's perspective it's hard to see things from the player's perspective you know um I I it's hard to also know whether your game is fun unless you're honest about their feedback that you get so when you put a game in front of someone else which people are reluctant to do right people who come to game design from other disciplines I think they believe that they need to finish the painting before they can hang it and game design is sort of unique in that no you actually have to show them the blank canvas and say I'm going to put a duck here what do you think and like literally that's really hard to do uh if you're not used to it but if you don't see what what people expect or or hear from them what they think is going to happen in your game you can go a long way into the weeds and then build a thing you're you're too attached to to throw away yeah absolutely one of my favorite quotes is you can't read the label from inside the bottle and as game designers we are just like right there on the inside and we're we're staring as hard as we can at that label but it we don't know we can't see it from the other side and I I can tell you from personal experience over and over and over again I have designed a game you know not to completion but gotten to a point where it works and I'm doing different things and mechanisms are playing off each other in Combos and stuff like that and I will sit there and think to myself I think this is fun like I'm having fun I'm enjoying this but not until I sit down and I just watch somebody else play it and then they have that reaction I mean okay good or oh okay huh and but it
really does require you to put it out there not only does it require you to put it in front of people but it requires you to strip your ego um because if you're not receptive to the actual feedback that you are getting you cannot make the product any better if I don't I can't tell you the number of times I've had a designer show me a thing I've had issues with how it works and his response well this maybe just isn't your kind of game and I'm like no man that's that's not how you deal with this like this is your one chance to get feedback from this player hear it you know don't just dismiss me as not in your target group that's not useful even if I'm not in your target group the feedback is still useful so so anyway yeah you got you got to be receptive to it and like you said you can't read the label if if someone if you put that label in front of someone who doesn't know how to read then you're not going to get a lot of good feedback but you're still going to get more than you can't from inside the bottle 100 and also like just because someone's not your target audience or whatever like they could they should still have moments of going oh that's fun like I'm not the kind of gamer that I want to sit down and play a three-hour Euro experience or an eight hour Twilight Imperium that's just not my deal but I've done those I've played those games in the past you know doing favors for friends and things like that and there are moments in the game where I'm like oh that's good that's fun like that's an interesting thing to think about or interesting decision space and so even though I'm not the demographic I I can still you know if that was a prototype I could still go I'm not your person but this right here oh that's really fun and so to just dismiss
somebody you're again you're letting ego creep in and you're gonna miss some of the best parts of feedback and you're never gonna probably never gonna get to like the best experience of the game yeah absolutely and and uh you know you learn as a designer to take the love and not the advice uh you know to to you know accept the candy but you don't have to swallow it what I'm saying is I think Neil Gaiman says this uh that if someone tells you there is something wrong with your work they are right and if they tell you how to fix it they are wrong like you have to understand that you can watch someone not have fun and that's hugely valuable you can watch someone get frustrated stuck confused bored all these things that's hugely valuable that's a good note if you then have a conversation with them and they start riffing and telling you how to make it better you can't take that advice at face value you can still read what's under it and that's valuable but like their suggestions are going to be terrible that's okay like let them make the suggestions but but understand that what's really going on is that there's something wrong with the game that they don't uh understand what it is especially don't know how to fix it yeah I was talking to Rob W about this a while back and something he said that I thought was just such a good little nugget of wisdom very much along the lines of what you're saying is like play testers have a tendency to be able to know when something's wrong but have no idea how to fix it and so as a designer The Way You Can level up in your designing and something you just grow with experience and in your skill set is reading between the lines and you know
the player is saying hey I felt like I didn't have anything to do I felt like this and the other but like read between the lines you're like oh I just need to give you more gold at the beginning of the game I give you five I need to give you 15. and then you'll feel like the decision space opens up the reading between the lines like really figuring out okay what are they actually saying and so have you found that to be the case in your designing Journey yeah absolutely I mean it certainly depends on who's playing but if if they're novice play testers like you want them to be regular Gamers and Gamers don't know how to build games in fact I uh I made a mistake fairly early in my career of getting a lot of like very detailed feedback from from essentially a Critic he wasn't an inventor but he was a Critic what he did was write about games and his advice on how to fix stuff was totally useless but I took it because I was like well you play a lot of games you must know so when I play with regular Gamers yeah I I I watched them play I get the experience they're having but I don't try to drill too deep on methodology or implementation or fixes because that's not a language that they speak but if I'm playing with designers I have a regular designer group uh who meet every two weeks in Seattle and those guys they see the Matrix they know nuts and bolts and so when when they have suggestions I'm like okay good let's let's do the line on this what problem does this solve how does this solve it like I can I can do that but it it's got to be someone who's who's in that same space who's done that design work yeah 100 so when you're watching play testers what are you
looking for how do you know that a game is fun even before they tell you what are the kind of things you notice I don't know that's so hard to generalize but if they want to play it again that's a pretty good I I you know I think there's a level of conversation about the rules that means they don't know the game very well yet and then after that there can be a level of conversation about the strategies that shows that they're actually enjoying themselves if they're thinking about how to win instead of how to play that's that means that they're actually having the fun of the game right if they start talking about Good expansion cards or good things you could do to add stuff to the game like it isn't because it's not good enough it's because it's that's sort of triggering their brain to like be creative and and think about the game again um I think of really good tentpole games as destinations and a destination is a place that you enjoy three times you enjoy it before you go you enjoy it while you're there and you enjoy it after you get home you you plan your trip to Disneyland you you figure what you're what you're going to take and when it's what what the weather's going to be like and you think about it before you're there and of course it's fun while you're there that's almost a given and then you have stories to tell at photographs at the end when you're dedicated to a game like a game like magic the Gathering which is what I sort of grew up with um all of these things are true and that game has a one player experience of deck building that is sort of prep work for for the for the two-player experience of of the game things to talk about things to remember it becomes a lifestyle if
it's that that's that's that's higher than fun that's like engrossing that's addictive right but um but on a micro level if you have play testers who are like hey do you have that thing about London again I want to play that again that's a that's huge right that's a that's a great sign that they that they want to that they've been thinking about it when they're not playing yeah absolutely okay so as far as feedback during the actual time at the end of the game dude first of all do you even do that do you sit down like do you listen to people because Eric Lang he got to a place where he didn't even listen to anything he gathers all the data he needs watching and then he doesn't even like ask questions at the end he's like all right thank you all for playing have a great day and so do you you have those conversations and if so what are the questions you're asking to really try to hone in on is this yeah I mean again it depends on it depends on many factors right who is the group what is the game and at what stage is it so at the very earliest stages I'm workshopping ideas I'm saying hey would you play a game in the old west about an Undertaker who's trying to keep a big you know big box uh Mortuary for moving in and killing all of the townsfolk like would you play that game I don't have a mechanic I have a theme so that that's all after conversation because I pitched the idea to you and I'll talk about what you expect and um you know the game goes through phases at a certain point it it you're fairly confident that you're not going to make fundamental changes to the mechanic anymore and now you're like did this card make sense to these rules say what
I what they're supposed to say and you can yeah once once the game is a known entity you can probably learn most of what you need to know uh during the play test um for just strictly from observation but uh I'd say last time I did a big game test I was at I was at Rincon in Tucson a couple weeks ago and I had a game called Tomb of the Ancients which is an archeology game and yeah I would talk about it a little bit beforehand I'd watch people play and uh talk about it a little bit afterwards you know just a a q a to make sure that they got out of it what I thought was in there gotcha so I want to Circle back to something you're talking about earlier with the idea of surprise right so people go into a game kind of what you're saying like they have the pre and then the Deering and then the post and we're to surprise play into that and how do you kind of what what levers are you pulling on what knobs are you turning to increase surprise or decrease surprise increase you know things happening like oh man I didn't expect that tell me how that all kind of plays into the design well I think um I'm going to send you a link to a video but there's a video of goats on a on a metal sheet I don't know if you've seen this but it's there's a imagine a big metal sheet it's standing up in an arch and the young kids are jumping up and knocking each other off and they're playing with this thing and it's bouncing around and they're they're playing this is fun right and the old goat is sitting in the back just watching it happen going I uh whatever I've been there like that's that's a
video of what fun is and I try to think of that as a metaphor for how people are interacting with my game if they are delighted by it because it can surprise them they are enjoying it and if they feel like it's not for them they've seen it before or whatever or their bones are just too old to climb up on the thing like whatever the reason there's going to be people who are sitting to the side and not being impressed I think the way you provide surprise is not just by randomly beating people with unexpected results but um but giving them I guess a little more agency or a little more you have to opt into the chaos does that make sense if cast just hits you randomly then it's painful but if you can say okay I know that there's five points sitting here on this platform and I know that inside this box is three to seven points I choose the box right um the story that I tell about this in in design lectures is about the the 520 bridge uh in Seattle I was driving home one day and I saw a sign that said in 15 minutes the bridge will be closed for half an hour whatever they're repairing something whatever the sign says okay you have 15 minutes to get to the bridge and if you get there late you're going to be stuck there for half an hour so my options are to take the long way around um or to take my chances with the bridge but I know that I have that option and so when I got to the bridge and got across I was delighted right uh but I
imagine the person in the car next to me who hadn't seen the sign having two very different possible outcomes I could have either been delighted because I hit the bridge on time or been okay with what I lost and checked my email for on my phone for half an hour and that would have been fine too because I saw the sign and the guy who didn't see the sign was either gonna cross the bridge like he expected to cross the bridge or he was going to be surprised and pissed off because it was closed and nobody told him right and that's that's a metaphor and that's that's explaining your rules and explaining what the rules are inside that box helps people decide whether they want to take the chance or not instead of just like hitting them with it yeah I love that what would be your best advice along those lines in the rules making it clear making the the options of like you said you you have five points on the platform or you have a three to seven chance over here like making that clear for players going in so that they don't get unexpectedly surprised in a way that is not super fun I mean that's that's the that's the challenge of any game any system like that um I I think generally speaking it is always better to express a loss as a cost instead of of a straight up lost in other words I I paid this to have this result instead of the game took this away from me um but yeah it's it's one of the things that's excuse me just impossible to generalize um I think that gambling is a good example of of an opt-in cost so you know here are games
that are stripped down to their absolute fundamentals they're accessible to everyone many actual Gamers find them incredibly boring but it's fascinating to me because obviously it's a very big money-making successful game gambling in general craps slot machines blackjack poker all of these things um they are incredibly simple and in terms of like craps which is probably the simplest well or a roulette something like that um people opt into that choice you know when you make a roulette bet you know that your options are either going to be probably to lose five dollars or possibly to lose two or three or five or 30X you know what you bet depending on what you placed on there and you know you know that over the long term you will probably lose but no one really cares you know they're there to have the entertainment of the risk and uh most gamblers have a budget that they're willing to lose but anyway I'm off the weeds here but but that that's clear right roulette is clear that people are bad at math I get that but like people know what the possible results are I'm either going to hit a number that's in the block that I bet on or I'm not and the results are clear it's not like there's a whole other wheel that the first wheel leads to that has results that are you know unpredictable that doesn't that wouldn't make it more fun those games don't succeed uh they're just too hard to understand it's too hard to predict I mean I guess if I was going to say slot
machines are kind of that that slot machines have now evolved to a point where they're incredibly complicated and no one can really explain what's going on but I think the proposition is still the same like put coins in get coins out sometimes less sometimes more repeat like that is still pretty simple yeah yeah I agree and I think like you're saying simple but even the complicated games that I've played in the past the really good ones the Twilight imperiums of the world that take forever to play even still the systems inside the game like each individual one was fairly simple to understand there might be a lot of them and now you're trying to figure out okay how do they stack and do different things but individually they're not that challenging you know you don't have to pull out your calculator and figure like you can go okay here are my two options here here's some two options two or three options over there here's two or three over there and now together a lot to think about but or I could just take it individually and go I want to do a I want to do three and I want to do blue let's see what happens and so players can come into that and just start figuring things out and so one thing one thing I love about your games is the Simplicity right the rules typically not very long very easy to comprehend I can play them with my kids I was telling you before we started recording my daughter one of her top three favorite games of all time is kill doctor lucky uh you know I told her I was gonna interview James Earnest and she was like uh who cares I don't know who that is and I was like oh he designed code Dr lucky and she literally went it like lost her mind and she's like oh wow and now she thinks I'm somebody because I'm talking to you so I appreciate you you know pushing me up higher on in her eyes but she loves that game and it literally
talked you know it took me three or four minutes to show her how to play and then we've been you know messing around and so let's talk about kill doctor lucky mainly so I can tell her about it and then she'll think I'm even cooler but tell me like your design process for that game The Experience coming up with things things you cut out give me kind of the big picture in turning that idea into something that was really really fun well I grew up playing traditional Hobby Games and I have always tried by always I mean in most cases I tried to make a game where the potential for strategy is is huge in comparison to the complexity of the rules I want to play the game I don't want to spend my experience learning the game are we talking about nose time how much time does someone spend with their nose in the rule book you know let's let's keep this as short as we can so so you know Dr lucky aside I I grew up playing Scrabble and pitch and you know Yahtzee and those incredibly simple easy family games where there's a lot going on in some cases under the surface so kill Dr lucky was originally a title um that that the design process began with a notion of what it was a a mystery Style game based on a murder mystery event where everyone in the house wanted to commit the murder and this is familiar to the literature and the clue
game is kind of like that everyone has a motive um I had done a short story in college where everyone wanted to kill this the same guy and in that story that lights just go down and they all just build a Gallows in 30 seconds and they all hang in together right but in this game okay kill doctor lucky is funny because we're all gonna try and we're all gonna fail because he's lucky full stop like that's that was from the theme to The Story of the game we're gonna try a lot and we're going to fail a lot and the way you win is do it mechanically that's a little tricky because you can't necessarily build to that conclusion it's a it's a Boolean event you're going to try and try and try and every time you try and fail you're going to be right back where you started and so it took us years actually even after the initial launch of that game to figure out a way to build strength through failure um you know in the current version of kill Dr lucky when you try to murder him and don't succeed you get a permanent bonus to your strength and so try and again make is going to be easier and easier you're leveling up you're getting experience points which is not a thing that was in the original build uh the original build was more about timing and hoping that you were the person who picked the time when his luck had run out but that was a lot of deduction and there weren't even a lot of scaffolds there to help you do that deduction it was a lot of guesswork really um so like over the time of that game's existence we've managed to make it into a better game by saying yes you can
build slowly towards this goal You Can level yourself up by doing the Korg Behavior by trying to kill him a lot knowing that you're going to fail and saving up that energy yeah and I've played both versions I played the original years and years and years ago and it really it was all about timing and really just hoping and it was a lot of surprise when you when you won the game but at the same time um I really prefer the newer version because it gets people acting much sooner you don't get that like sitting on G everybody waiting on oh who's gonna act first kind of thing no it's like I'm gonna do this as quickly as I can because that's going to build me up and I'm gonna have a much better chance later as the game progresses and here's here's the kind of crazy thing I was thinking about this earlier today um years ago when I first got into game design just as a hobby just as something to kind of take my mind off life and craziness the first game I ever prototyped was based on kill Dr lucky I had played it I had a lot of fun with it and we had this running joke with my friend group that my best friend growing up his dad worked for the power company worked for the light department in our little town in Alabama and he was always the guy that was going out after storms and fixing stuff and hanging Christmas lights taking Christmas lights down all kind of thing and so the local paper seemingly once every couple weeks would have a picture of him on the front page doing something and it was just this running joke that's like does anybody else work at this place like is he the only one he's the only one ever in the bucket truck and so I made this little game based on kill Dr lucky that he was going
around town with all these like Town spaces on the board and he was fixing stuff and hanging Christmas lights whatever and then you were a photographer for the newspaper and it was your job to take his picture so you were trying to like land in the same place and have cars and things to take his picture and then whoever you know got his picture multiple like there's a timer anyway it rounds like it wasn't just take one picture so it was different enough where I was like hey this is you know not exactly just a rethink but um our newspaper was called the Outlook and so the game was called getting in the Outlook and it was all about taking a picture of my my friend's dad dad Johnny and and anyway and so it's kind of cool to come come full circle now 15 years later or whatever long it's been to chat with you about this and so tell me tell me more about the design process you talked about the thing you changed right there did the board you know was it smaller did it get bigger tell me anything else that you kind of have evolved yeah I mean I I know more about I guess the the changes from version one to the current version then I can remember about that initial design initial design phase was probably like three weeks this is before cheap ass games existed this is the year that we came up with cheapest games and so kill doctor lucky existed first as a pitch someone took the the idea to the gamma trade show and pitched it to Darwin Bromley as an aside and he was like I would buy that game and so I heard that from my friend who went and I was like well then I should probably make that game and then by the end of that year I knew that I wanted to do cheap ass games and I knew that Dr lucky was the best of the several games that were in development so it became sort of our lead title and and whatnot
I think that the original game had a lot of wacky surprise crazy stuff in it because at the time I was willing to believe that games like that are just like that and sometimes you just get hurt and like I I didn't have any testers who were going to dissuade me of that and it was just kind of like they were frustrated from time to time about how this game played out and we would all just kind of shake our heads and say well games would be like that and that was the end of it right and you know I I'd know more than that now and I know that games do not actually be like that and that it's well it's fun to have chaos and Randomness and you know these things help level the playing field and all of this like there's still different ways to implement that chaos that are more and less conducive to a good experience I don't want to spend a whole game building a perfect uh you know racer and then have it crash as soon as it comes out of the gate because games be like that like I want to know either I wanted to crash before I build it if that makes any sense or once I build it I wanted to I want that investment to to pay off um and and so yeah my games don't quite be like that anymore we just redid biting off heads I don't know if you know that game um Biden off heads is a dinosaur chase game it's a it's a it's a silly romp rolling Dyson and attacking each other and sending each other back to start like in perpetuity um it was fine and it was popular popular
and so we never bothered to change it but it's been 25 years now and I'm a much better game designer so I took that thing back to the lab and made a much better version of it where along with other things so you can imagine in a game where I can land on you and send you back to start it's possible that the game will never end and because of specific rules in that game it was possible for players to kill themselves to get access to spaces where they could shoot at the people in the front knock them back to the start and the game would literally like never end like as long as people were willing not to try to win themselves but only to keep others from winning oh well games be like that no not today um what I did in the in the rebuild of fighting off heads was I figured out that my my real sort of underlying design goal was to make sure that the heat was always rising and what I mean by that metaphor is the average player distance to finish is always getting smaller so when I throw a rock at you from the starting space in the original game I would knock you back to start and here we are where we started again right in the new game I switched places with you and so you're back at start but I'm right next to the to the finish and so the average player position has not gone back that means the game actually Trends to a conclusion and it sounds silly to talk about it in in this context of this game but in general it's it's a it's a good game design principle to engineer a trend to conclusion if the game tends to end it's
better than if the game can go on forever yeah that's a really good point and also going back to what you're talking about earlier and that people hate to lose something right they would much rather uh what's the old quote people hate to lose more than they like to win right that negative feeling is greater than any positive feeling and so anything as a game designer well that's that's the difference but that's how you differentiate the recontextualized loss as a cost yeah because I may hate to lose unexpectedly more than I uh uh like to win but I'm also willing to pay the cost of a risk that I understand and so that a lot of that is just framing yeah definitely and when the game takes something away from you especially out of nowhere you know you turned over an event card and now you lost 10 resources like why because I happen to be the one to turn over the card and then my buddy he turns over a card and gains 10 resources that's a pretty big swing that's not super fun and he's maybe having a little bit of fun that kind of engineering has been in the DNA of board games for hundreds of years like literally you know roll a die and see if you go forward or backward is like what games were uh prior to Monopoly you know Monopoly is a track game with random plus and minus events because it was based on a whole family of track games with random plus and minus events that sort of also gave rise to Candyland and Shoots and Ladders and you know that variety of game that's like that's that's what a game is from the perspective of those designers that's what a game is and so that biased Randomness that picks someone to hate is is engineered into the games is kind of a leveling Factor when in fact you don't
you don't need that at all you you can have Randomness that actually serves everyone equally which is strange to say but um but still balances the uh the the outcomes like uh you just you just have to build it right yeah definitely there's a game I bought for my son he's four years old and he loves trucks and monster trucks and I found this game from the 80s called crash Canyon and it's this massive you know molded thing and it's these little monster trucks and they go around the board and it's literally just roll and move but it also has a die in there that has a star and the star meant you could move somebody else and you could push them back and the way the game works is like you could literally push them back one space and then that causes them to fall into the canyon and now they're like 20 spaces back like this just and it's not it's not fun especially if if I'm playing the game if I'm playing the game to win like I'm pushing my four year old's truck into the canyon you know I mean like he's got to earn this and I was like it's just it's just not good game design for nowadays and so I changed that rule to anytime you roll the star which is the one instead of moving one not super fun it's exploding so now you can roll it again so you got a one oh your order one again that's two roll it again oh now you roll a six now you just moved eight so one that's enjoyable a little bit of surprise there but two it gets the game over faster because I'm not trying to play a 45 minute game with my four-year-old like what are we doing like this needs to be a 10 minute experience and it pushes the game forward and just that one little change made the game so much more fun and so I think that's something else game designers can take away from this conversation is we're not talking about these massive changes complicated things like a lot of times you can just switch the framing you can switch the the
phrasing or you can change one little make one little tweak and it gets the game to its completion sooner which I don't very few times if I played a game and everybody was like man that ended too fast shorter is always better if it's short enough you can play it again I totally agree with that you know I I have games with repeat times under one minute like that's that's where I like to be um and yeah the monster in the water is not fun I totally agree like that that die that that that again like I said it's in the DNA of game design because it's been around for so long um that there's always a chance that you'll die um I think I I think it that most of the ways to implement that are just pretty bad um I have a game called holdout where that that that little chance is always there um holdout is without explaining it it's basically poker um it is a game that serves the role of Poker in a fantasy universe and it doesn't have the same betting system as poker but one thing that it does have uh sort of in common is essentially the the draw on the river when when uh when a player is very likely to win but one card will save the other player this particular game goes through that window almost all the time and everyone's just kind of okay with that like I have to get to the end of the game in a good in a good state to win and the other guy is always going to get that one draw but we like we kind of know that and he he goes for the draw he pulls the wrong card I win most of the time he pulls the right
card and he wins once in a while and we all sort of like we're okay with it it's not like the monster in the water because we all kind of like know that's how it's going to work but I think that's an exceptional case I think normally that that that last minute reversal surprise thing unless the odds of it happening are really well understood and the game is short enough that you can play again uh it's really frustrating when it happens I'm reminded of Sid was it Sid Jackson who made the civilization video games and he was talking about how you know he would give percentages to the player he would say hey this has an 80 chance of of succeeding and then even so that's still a 20 chance of failure but players would get so frustrated because they'd be like no this is The Game's cheating he's like it's really not and so he had to tell players 80 but on the back end it was really like 92 or something like that just to kind of match up the psychology because players are getting so frustrated with with the numbers we can't exactly do that with board games but it is interesting kind of psychological thing to think about that's interesting he was burying the odds under a lie that's that's that because I'm not going to say whether that's good or bad but that's terrible um like uh no I've worked with a lot of game designers who get into the the gotcha systems in in uh online gaming and they they try to fiddle with the odds because they want them to play out the way players expect it's it's weird because you start up by introducing a system that's going to be really punitive and then you tweaked it
so that it wasn't why did you introduce it to begin with like why don't you just do something else right that's a good question and I don't know if he was too far into the design process where he was just like ah it would ship it it'll be fine it will just tweak the numbers on the back end and you know again that was some years ago but it is an interesting thing to think about something else I want to go back to you're talking about your game with the Dinosaurs where it's this constant Loop right where people can get in there I'll tell you what man my friend Brad would love that game every time he's played Super Smash Brothers you familiar with Smash Brothers okay he was always Donkey Kong because Donkey Kong has this ability to grab people and then he can walk around and so what Brad would do he would grab you and then he would jump off the edge and kill both of you because he he didn't want to win he just wanted you to lose and that's just how he played the game and so you know if you have a game that has the potential for a loop to occur there are those people out there they're like we're playing this for the next six hours and so anything yeah well I I think I think that knowing that there are various griefing player types means you have to engineer games to survive that either to appeal to that and appeal to that player type only or to uh exclude them in some way or just to survive their behavior they're you know that like if if you've got that kind of spoiler in your game if the game is robust enough he can do his thing and lose and not really hurt either the group or Worse an individual
with that right but that's that's a matter of engineering around it I I was lucky enough to sort of cut my teeth on Magic the Gathering and once you've written rules and cards for a ccg everything else is easy right yeah when you understand that players can basically build their own game out of the parts you're handing them um every every everything else is a better structure no doubt all right so another thing I want to ask you about is the level of of abstraction so give an example for the last several years I've been working on this football college football based game and I remember one time I played with some testers and somebody said well hey there's a there's no penalties in the game why are there no penalties I was like well that's like the least fun part of football like no one has ever unless it's at the end of the game and your team lost but there's a flag on the plate like that's the only moment that anyone is really excited about a flag and so no I abstracted that out there are no penalties we're just gonna assume it's a clean game the entire time and because that's fun it's more fun to me so tell me your thoughts on abstracting things out that if this was a simulation it would need to be there because it is part of the reality but I'm trying to make something fun make it a game so when you're thinking of okay here's the the theme here's the thing I'm trying to do what are your thoughts as far as abstracting certain parts leaving certain parts in trying to get to the most fun I think specifically in the football example I would only include penalties if it was the kind of thing that players could decide to do in other words I I am going to to do a foul here because it's going to cheat on purpose I'm gonna right I'm gonna I'm gonna break the rules and I'm just gonna
see what whether the whether the ref notices it or something like that's interesting right but if Flags just randomly happen like what good is that I think generally speaking life is not always fun and so you're under no obligation to simulate the reality in your car in your game now on the other hand if your game more or less represents the real life systems that it's supposed to it's easier for people to learn how to play it for people to know what to expect like um an economic game you know if if you're only allowed to have a certain amount of money how is that a game about economics if money isn't exchangeable for other money how is that money like I'm all I'm often confused by metaphors in particular games that don't seem to care about theme where they were they told me what a thing was and then it behaved differently from that and it made it worse than if they didn't tell me at all but like I said reality is often no fun we we had a game Deadwood expansion deadwood's a game about making movies on a back lot and the expansion included several little locations that you had to ride the bus to get from one place to the other and the bus the bus mechanic was extremely uh realistic they're they're you sat at a bus stop and rolled three Dice and if you rolled one of the locations you wanted to go to you could go there and if you didn't you had to keep waiting that's just like waiting for the bus is it fun absolutely not like as a designer I thought this is a great mechanic it's just like waiting for the bus but as a player I was like why are you doing this to me this is the
worst thing that ever happened yeah I've got a similar system in a game I'm working on right now it's this open world where you can go you know all over and it's got a bus system where as long as you've been to a location one time you can go there again easily and for free and originally there was a mechanic a little mini game that you had to play to do that to go from A to B but I was like this is not fun and it's getting it's it's blocking players from doing the thing that they really want to do where the fun is they want to turn the page they want to go to the the next area they've already been there and now you're like putting a barrier it between them and fun we'll get rid of that and I've had testers go well it doesn't make as much sense that players can just just go there like there's no cost I was like yeah but that's like you're saying plus bad feedback right riding the bus is not fun right I think like there is no way to do an effective simulation of reality there is going to be an abstraction at some level so all you have to do is decide where that is people don't have representations of reality in their heads that's not the point of any of this right so so yeah games give us that luxury of copying only the parts that are good yeah exactly oh and I think that's a that's a good sound bite right there as a game designer it's our jobs to copy Parts about life that are good like that's that's it that's it all right James what else what are some other things to think about are the things that you've learned personally or things that you share with other game designers that you know when it comes to fun well that's an open-ended question it's not bringing
anything to mind uh what's something you wish you had known years ago that maybe you've learned you know as you've designed more and more games that you're like oh okay here's a here's a quicker way to get to find here's an easier way to do it here's a here's a way to cut things out I the answer to that question is 400 pages long and I'm supposed to be laying it out this week I'm not kidding like it's a it's a it's a it's a tough uh question my my joke about that we did the uh the cheap ass games retrospective book a few years ago that contained like the rules and some example components from every game in the cheap ass catalog it was kind of like the Line in the Sand that says I'm through with this I'm doing something else right now um and that book starts with this is the book I wish I'd had when I started my games yeah I'm in the same place right this book I'm working on it's like I wish someone had handed me something like this 15 years ago that I wouldn't have to have fallen into so many holes and bumped my head into so many walls it's just those it's just those things and again it's little things it's little tweaks in your design process and so I guess to kind of close things out what would be I don't know just best advice you know the number one top three thing whatever it is right anything that comes to mind to kind of leave listeners with that'll kind of help them level up a little bit in their game design I don't know I I design at the simpler end of the spectrum for sure and I believe that that's the game designer's job to do the math so the players don't have to like there's nothing fun about learning how to play your game and and I know that there's
disagreement among the community about that like I see plenty of games that are essentially procedural and once someone has figured out how to get to the end they basically feel like they've played it and I feel like that I'm just getting started when I when I figure that out I now I I want I know how to get to the end it's obvious now how do I get to the end with more points is is how I want to think about games so so yeah it's it's more fun to to think about winning than try to remember the rules yeah that's a really good point I think something helped me as a game designer was to kind of what you're saying to realize players already know how to play a certain number of games they could just open the box and start playing that and get right to the fun versus having to open the box in my game and learn it and so how can I overcome that barrier how do I make the E the rules easier to learn easier to explain quicker how do I cut out edge cases so players aren't having to put the cognitive load of all this extra stuff in there abstract some things out get to the fun as quickly as possible and even one thing I love about games nowadays A lot of them are like teaching you how to play as you play so you don't have to learn 10 pages of rules 20 Pages rules first you can learn two pages of rules now you're playing almost like a little kind of demo round or turn and now we're getting into the the fun faster and I think that's something else for for people just think about how can you get to the phone as quickly I think it it didn't take me long to learn this but I've been telling people for 30 years and it's more more is not better yeah you know I think people make their own games complicated I think and sometimes in an
attempt to differentiate them which I think is not a good design pillar um mostly just because that's what they know how to do and it's always better though often harder to take a rule away than add another one if there's something that's not working you have two possibilities you can add a rule or you can take one out and you know I think that there's a fear that if you take away too many rules you'll wind up with nothing but I I've never actually seen that happen that's a good good point but I think that's something else for new desires to realize it is harder to cut than to add and you really learn that the more the more you do this because you'll get to a design Challenge and it's like okay I can add four more rules to fix this right I can just keep throwing in edge cases and cards and stuff like that but that's gonna probably decrease the fun overall because it's more to think about more to learn less less enjoyable surprise like now it's surprised because yet you just read the rule book for five or ten extra minutes and to figure out oh you can actually do the thing you really wanted to do that's not super enjoyable again things to to think about but James this has been excellent do you have anything you're talking you're saying you're working on a book right now if you want to tell people anything about that or I've been working on this book for years it was the it was the course notes for a game called design class that I taught 10 years ago I still haven't managed to bind it up into into a book so I can't promise that but I can say that my design lectures and lots of new products are at crab fragment Labs that's my uh my new design studio we also host a lot of the old cheap ass games PDFs over there but uh but there's good new stuff every day including games
that I'm working on right now to procrastinate working on my book I I understand that struggle a hundred 110 but I'll put the I'll put links to everything in the show notes and the description on YouTube and whatnot so people can find that and James man really appreciate your time thanks for everything you've contributed to the Hobby over the years my daughter wants me to thank you as well for creating all right well thank you for enjoying the game and of course I'll be like the comedian in the parking lot who's like did you see the six o'clock show or the 7 30 what what uh what's what edition of kill doctor do you play at your house oh it's the newest one I got it Target or Walmart Oh far out good yeah like well that is that's the best viewers of course the latest one is a half two years ago um I bought it because we were doing this Mission thing at the church and we knew we were gonna have a bunch of people and I was like oh let's get killed after lucky because you can play with a lot of folks and it's actually more fun with more people and my daughter was along with with that group and um we sat down and and we played it and she was like let's play it again immediately and then yes say that yeah good feedback and we played it like five or six times over the course of two days and then when we got home you know she was like hey let's play it again like honey it's it's not a great game with two players like I I don't think you know and so you know she's been kind of frustrated and trying to get her siblings to learn and but oh that's great that's great she loves it the James man really appreciate your time thank you so much for coming on the show yeah thanks for having me