Arkham Horror: Under Dark Waves - Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we are doing a no run through review for under dark waves and a refreshing review on arkham horror third edition because boy did our opinions change of third edition um quite a bit so uh let's go ahead and talk about the underdark waves expansion first um and then we can kind of touch on a little bit of third edition and kind of uh where we're at with it so the other dark waves expansion brings in more of the same it just gives you more content to third edition now if you love third edition then uh great it's an expansion you can easily go out and get because it gives you more scenario cards it gives you uh more scenarios or not not scenario cards more encounter cards and more scenarios gives you four snares gives you a bunch more uh characters to play the ones that you see all over the place you know uh ash campy you know the [ __ ] the waitress the the politician father mateo or whatever is it material hell yeah very good um it it just gives you more characters uh to play and uh and a little bit new newer mechanics that came into uh into the game uh two of which are the major ones which are the travel routes and then the um the terror the terror tokens and the terror deck so let's talk about the travel routes
so with some of the newer scenarios they're going to come with a separate sideboard which then now similar to the street locations or the streets you now have a uh you know travel locations which correspond to country roads or the harbor or or mysterious locations like the devil reef which is just an area that's [ __ ] over there um uh to use the travel routes you basically now have to spend money uh to use them and uh that's that's that what do you guys think of the travel routes i was gonna say uh it can get a little inconvenient if you don't have funds for whatever reason um it you know it does since it does cost money to travel which is fair it can be kind of cumbersome and burden and you're like oh well i would like to help over there but ooh but it'll take me four turns to get money so i guess uh you're on your own yeah so i mean overall i wasn't super like not not that i wasn't endues about the edition it's just kind of like okay yeah yeah thematically i think it's nice and it makes sense and it's a fun idea to throw in a twist on movement um mechanically it just gets in the way of getting around and getting places yeah yes because it takes a turn to collect the money yep and then an extra turn or two to actually get across right yeah i mean i'm right there with
you brett i think the uh thematically it's like oh great yes that's how you now have a way to travel you know through a dirt road to get to the village or if you want to get to uh you know ins mouth shore you have to take a harbor to get there um i like that however because of arkham horror arkham horror third edition's ludicrously stupid rule of one uh you only do one type of action uh per turn uh it drastically slows the game down because not only do you have to like you said get money uh which hardly anyone ever starts out with like oh man look at my 17 or something two yeah it's two i had one because i'm a drifter even though you think since i'm a drifter i'd be able to freely ignore that uh because i find ways to get around but nope uh you have to spend a turn and then to move and it's like oh well i don't have like because i don't have the dollar to take the country roads i guess so it'll just take me forever to get to arkham to help out i know it's a cooperative game but man we sure do a lot of the time i do spend a lot of time being by ourselves yeah we we split up yeah and never actually got back together yeah i mean because it's like yeah i mean when you ran out of money and i'm over there fighting dagon it's just like oh i can come help oh no it'll actually take me quite a bit too because i can only move two spaces oh but i unless i spend the money once you spend the money move forward and then i can't make it
across exactly so it just it it expands the board in a absurd way where it's just annoying because in in regular scenarios it's one arkham so you can always kind of run around but the addition of having money to cross to get to the other side is is just annoying so that's travel routes uh then we go into the terror so what terror is is supposed to represent the the the populace of arkham or of the locations you know becoming freaked out there's monsters running around uh crazy things happening um and if uh terror it kind of replaced the anomalies there's no anomaly deck where the anomalies were if one location ever got three doom an anomaly token would come out and you had to go through that was kind of like their their replacement for gates because there are no gates in third edition that you go through that's kind of the anomaly uh here you don't do that if a neighbor if area ever gets six doom you clear out one spot and place a terror and then you take a card from the tarot deck and you place it on top of the encounter deck which is not what i thought it was was oh this is going to be your replacement for the encounter and it's going to function like an anomaly it helps you get rid of terror tokens nope it's just another card that go that you have to deal with before your actual encounter which can be a double-edged sword if
you're trying to get a clue at least it doesn't stop you from trying to get that clue but if you don't get the clue card then you just have two encounters and the terror usually is a hindrance depending on how many are there what do you guys think of the terror sarah was just another way to kind of slow us down in my opinion like nothing really like oh nothing really stuck in my head i couldn't even give you an example of one that we encountered that's fair actually yeah yeah again i'd say you know if it's the theme nicely sure mechanically it just slows things down and gives you unnecessary complications right and they're already difficult to gather resources and utilize them yeah why are you making it more complicated yeah that's that's pretty much it in a nutshell i really don't like them either i mean because now you have to spend influence to get rid of them so while you're already getting bombarded with doom you're getting now bombarded with terror and it's just like and they don't do anything really yeah it's kind of there you just now stack it's like you just stack the the cards on top of a a thing and it's like okay now we just have to deal with those and it's also kind of fiddly because like if the the tarot card doesn't ever tell you to remove them so it's like you you have an un uneven number of tokens that are on the board versus cards that are on the deck so it's like did we resolve it but there's still tokens here so i don't get why these are still on the board it's because with the anomalies which weren't
they were fine whenever you resolved it you most likely removed doom that was you making progress towards dealing with the anomaly right here she was like oh no the monster was chasing you but you outran it nice all right go to your encounter and then it's like the encounter it also is kind of a thematic disconnect because it's like oh man i outran this horrific beast that just ate a child whole then you read your encounter it's like you take a nice relaxing break on the bench in front of the at the park and then you see a strange man you talk to him and he gives you some money and it's like what happened to the monster that i was just being chased by nope nope big they don't come into the parks they're not allowed listen they're not rude they see you relaxing i guess it's just it's [ __ ] stupid i hate it i really do this expansion like we mentioned if you think the third edition is the best version of arkham horse it's the best cthulhu game you've ever played then underdog under dark waves is going to be the best expansion that's come out because it gives you bang for your buck you get a lot more scenarios a lot more a lot more content but if you are kind of hoping that a bigger box expansion would fix the issues that third edition brought uh it does not do that it enhances them it it it actually yes you're right it makes it worse because of that dumb [ __ ] rule that
they put in it's like okay how can we make that that obnoxious rule even more obnoxious oh now you're really gonna feel how slow you are now you're gonna really feel how human you are i like to come home after a long day of work and just feel [ __ ] useless it's just it's so obscene that i it's it's like now like i was i'm mentally exhausted from just how drug out one scenario was and it wasn't even exciting it was literally like the the scenario we did spoilers i guess for a subpar scenario it was like oh you got get some relics yes get rid of one and summon the god of the sea and beat the [ __ ] out of him with a baseball bat beat the [ __ ] out of his mommy no it was father day gone first and then you're like man yes 13 health i took him down it was me and duke you know the odds were against us nope actually just bring the other one in yeah and it's like what like why and i mean that that is the the fun humor of arkham horror where it's just like the undescribable horrors of space and then you just you just kill them with a shotgun you're like man couldn't survive this harry this [ __ ] casual that's the humor of it however when you when you go through the the the monotony of like oh okay we have to
get a clue and we have to we have to research and we oh i we failed every [ __ ] die roll but we finally got it all right now we take this this uh you know whatever research deck and gets or so this relic deck and we get those we have to place the encounter the leads and we have to get them we have to discard them to summon and it's like okay yeah just came down to a bullet sponge boss 13 health which i actually i could have weathered it wasn't even hard um it was more just going to be annoying it was the fact that like hey you had like a healing elixir you could have came to help me but oh right no but sorry you actually don't have any money so i guess you can't use the ferry right so we're split up and it'll take me another turn right you get the money to get across exactly it's just it's so it's it's faux difficulty that yeah the expansion like you said just enhances it and i i hate it so even even what we did accomplished didn't feel like there was any sense of accomplishment to it yeah you mean well at that point it was kind of an endurance test so it's like okay we overcame that instead of a celebration it was like okay what's next all right yeah what's the next let me search through this i mean this is this this uh deck is is pulled from their game of fallout which was to represent the quest you get in fallout uh i have no problem with this actual deck i have no problem with the scenarios but it's just yeah you're right you mentioned it while we were playing that it's not so cause because some games like robinson caruso or uh pandemic are like have like a
roller coaster you do something good you feel accomplished it feels good yeah we we built the shelter you know we hunted that we got some food we're good for a while pandemic yeah we cured out this whole area we're good for a while the roller coaster kind of thing here it's a it's just a slow sink like you're just like oh well just being ground down yeah we're probably going to lose right but it's going to take a damn long time to lose exactly and it's like you never really want to feel that if you're in the if you're if you're going to lose you should be able to be like oh i i know like like i can see it coming yep um and then it's over and you're done because i remember you were like have we what are we doing there was a part whenever the second card came out you're like what's the goal yeah and i'm like still get clues yeah that's it that's that's always been the the goal in elder torah and arkham horror that's how you progress um but here getting clues is such a [ __ ] slog and coming from second edition where you just oh there's five you know there's five at the end visit aisle you know i'm going to run over there pick all those up because we need 10 to complete that to complete that uh that goal or that mythos card um but here it's not even a guarantee you're going to get a clue so you waste your entire turn just oh but it's one of these three cards okay it wasn't that one all right i guess i'll kind of you know focus a little bit wasn't that one right yeah so it uh it's it's it's just it's it's just a bad time unless you really like arkham or third
edition then you'll like under dark waves uh so cat even because you've never played archimore until until we were doing this expansion right now um yeah in our at the time we liked arkamore whenever we did our run-through and discussion over it originally yeah uh yeah it's it's just it's gotten worse every time we play it yeah we're just kind of like yeah like the luster wore off and we're just like okay yeah it's like oh god yeah i'm like i'm mentally exhausted from trying to force myself to be immersed you know uh and yeah that's just okay yeah um i mean and everything about it is just slow like and not to i don't want to send you off onto a bunning trail but for for how long it takes to set it up it's one of those games where you're like this better be good right right yeah i hope this scenario is good because i mean with so the the game is like an amalgamation of all their other arkham games mansions of madness is the scenarios arkamore lcg have some terminology the way the monsters work and stuff like that um then it has eldritor with the uh of course with encounter decks and regular um like and and the clue events like i don't mind the clue events i think that's awesome because that's a thematic way of you getting clues to progress the scenario but the fact that you're not guaranteed to get it is just annoying like i don't know why they couldn't just do it to where it goes to moz boarding house and you have a moz boarding house
clue card like it could have easily just been that because you're not even guaranteed to get the clue yeah most of the ones we got was gain one but there's times where you have to make a test and then so oh i guess i didn't get it so and then the fact that they added this mythos these mythos tokens is just so [ __ ] slow because normally in eldritch and second edition was a card that had elder chas uh icons on it similar to kind of like these icons oh you know an event happens you know or something uh but that's just one card for the whole for everyone playing here it's draw two tokens so now not only do you have to draw two and be like oh okay so that's that's a reckoning all right everyone check your reckonings uh are we okay let's check monster reckoning scenario okay so we did that okay and uh oh that was a uh uh a doom okay so let's [ __ ] [ __ ] with the card so doom comes out okay cat here's your turn to draw to oh that was another you know it's just i know there were times where i was grabbing it and i was like we were still finishing up on brett's and i'm like oh no you're still going yeah yeah i mean not only because you also have cards and stuff that pertain to the other things so one token draw can take five minutes to figure out how everything's going yep and and i mean i was hoping you hope for the blanks not because uh not because you don't want the game to do something bad to you just so you don't have to [ __ ] waste 10 minutes
move on like it's like great blanks okay now i can draw yeah yeah and for a game that's as slow you want to be invested the entire time oh yeah so it's not that the game is it has nothing to do with how long the game takes oh yeah i mean we've played we've played games for you know 10 hours yeah and it's been great the whole time right one game yeah legacy type game yeah uh this is not it yeah yeah you're right this is a legacy game that should be about an hour an hour hour and a half yeah like i'll play elder shore four hours and have a blast the entire time because there's so much going on um and there's it's weird how disjointed this one feels from the other ones this is the step brother or the the cousin of those other great games um hey second edition oh and you brought third edition mom made me yeah right this is my little brother third edition why'd you bring him i had to it was only way i can come over and hang out it's like fine just give him the unplugged controller calculator and we'll tell him he's playing with the set we'll set up our more third edition over there for the people we don't like so uh so yeah that i mean that's pretty much it i know um give anything you want to talk about for third edition nah cool well on
a scale of one to ten cat and i are going to do three different rankings we're gonna rank the expansion if you like third edition we're gonna rank it if you for us if you don't like it and we're gonna rank third edition as a whole and brett is gonna do one ranking so can i come today you come over and like i have to set up again and you're like mom said you had to let me play all right mom's not [ __ ] here mom od in the tub i told you she was sleeping hey okay this game makes me want to od oh no yeah yeah take all the melatonin we have and i'll sleep forever and that will feel sleeping for eternity will feel shorter than playing one scenario of third edition under dark waves if you really really get a hard on for a third edition is probably an eight it gives you more of the game uh gives you more scenarios more characters more more more a couple minor new mechanics yeah new mechanics or like if you're getting tired of the the same thing it does add a little bit new uh mechanics uh for me um actually yeah the more the more i've talked about i'm gonna give it a four like it enhances already what i believe to be bad mechanics in the game and the scenarios uh that are in it i couldn't give two shits about so it's an ins mouth is one of my favorite uh uh areas in lovecraft lore um and i did not once feel like we were in
his mouth in smith that is true are you okay yeah i'm dying i'm i'm hoping it's it's all that hopefully yeah oh just cough of blood it's the ulcer that this [ __ ] game gave me uh so yeah i i really really just didn't like it and arkham horror as an overall game is a five yeah it's it's pure average but it's a game that i have no reason to play because there's the lcg that i have everything for it's mansions of madness i have everything for it and they'll detour that i have everything for yeah and i love all those games so why keep it there fair all right so i'll go for under dark waves if you like third edition um i'm gonna give it a seven because i still don't think that it brings enough to the table and especially um just with what we've been talking about for it being a big big box you would expect more i don't know sure i don't know something i mean it's really a fantasy flight what they make is lcgs it's arkamore lcg and marvel champions and everything else they're just like they pad the box with that that trench insert because i can actually show you how they how they package this um oh yeah yeah this is where all the content goes you think there'd be something nope yeah so they they inflate this could have been a small box half the size yeah yeah but i mean this is a big box it gets recognized on shelves and it makes you feel like you're getting more yep oh man boy is it just like opening up chips and you're like that's a lot yeah right oh man
yeah but it does definitely give you more content than the uh the dead of night that one was a small box i guess and then just it as like a standalone um since i don't really care for the third edition uh i'll give it a a five and then um and then i'm still gonna take like arkham or third edition just in general down to a five uh arkham horror used to be my favorite game i think that was the first game we ever played together i think so ever and i really did we played arkham or talisman i think it was talisman then we played arkham horror so but still though it was the right up there with like getting into board games and it was i just loved the theme and then now it's kind of just like ah so i'd rather play mansions of madness yeah or mountains of madness oh yeah that's i wasn't including that or eldritch hoarder and the alberta i'm hoarding all the eldritch what is that it's no one knows it's insanity it's indescribable um quick let me describe it yeah so that's yeah yeah so seven five five okay all right so mine is a composite of both because i don't know how to separate the two having not played it before so overall this is definitely not my type of game again i love the theme but mechanically overly complicated overly difficult unnecessary um
lots of cards lots of different things that could happen to keep track of every single turn and then every turn adds more so those are all turn offs for me um so overall i should state that there have been games that we have played that do that same thing but you can do it enjoy yeah uh the fact that it's cooperative uh helps me a lot but it doesn't get overcome any of the problems that we've discussed yeah so i'm gonna give it overall for myself and my style of play three right on just wild yeah fair though all right so that's our thoughts on arkham horror and the expansion under dark waves let us know what you think of the game and the expansion in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time update it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you