Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brass Lancashire vs. Brass Birmingham: A Buyer's Guide

Transcript 16:07

hi everyone tally and farrell here from board of it and welcome to our buyer's guide for the brass something series one of the all-time greats in board gaming if you've ever wondered what the differences are between bruss birmingham brass lancashire which one you should get or even if you should own both then hopefully we've got you covered yep and you should know that our buyers guides we like to keep factual until the very end which is where we'll give our personal opinions and thoughts on the games themselves and it's also helpful to know that we split these videos into sections so please feel free just to jump to what's relevant for you so if you already own one game and you're only interested in learning more about the other one last thing to know is that while we bought our copy of brass birmingham our copy of brass lancashire was very kindly given to us by publisher broxley games the story of the brass series begins in 2007 when the first game in the series brass was released now brass was a game focused on the lancashire region of england during the industrial revolution and it was designed by martin wallace and published by warfrog games it was very well received and actually had a bit of a cult following this was then re-implemented in a 2010 game called the age of industry which was just a more streamlined and accessible version of brass but where the story really ramped up and took a turn was in 2017 when publishers roxley games decided to

have a modern reprinting of brass which they titled brass lancashire now this was basically just brass with a few slight rule changes and obviously a modern production in this kickstarter campaign for brass lancashire they also included brass birmingham which is a sequel of sorts that takes the core rule set of brass but introduced new mechanisms and new strategies and obviously focused on the birmingham region of england now because of the excellent production values and also gameplay you'll find in these two boxes it is really no surprise that brass birmingham and brass lancashire are currently in third and twentieth place on the bgg best board games of all time west both games share the same core rule set and many of the same actions in both the goal is to score the most victory points over two eras of gameplay which is done by building industries on the main board and then flipping them to reveal their victory points you'll also be building links of either canals or railways between the cities which will also score you points based on the industries that they are connected to the first era is the canal era where the only links available to build are canals at the end of this era your score for all of the canal links that you have built and all of the industries you have flipped and then your links will be removed as well as your level one industries industries have multiple levels that you

have to work through in order with the higher levels being worth the most victory points but they are more expensive to build the second era is the railway era where you can only build railway links at the end of this era the game will end and then you'll just score up as before in both the gameplay is driven through card play each action you take will require you to discard a card often what card it is won't matter like if you take a loan but when you build it suddenly becomes very important what card you play this is because to build you require a matching location card eg matching the city or the town where you want to build or you'll need a industry card matching an industry you want to build at a location which is part of your network the key to winning is flipping industries but different industries will flip in different ways coal iron and brewery industries all produce resource tokens that go on top of the tile when those industries are built and they'll get flipped once those resources have all been spent shipyard industries just get flipped automatically once they're built in lancashire all other industries will get flipped when you take the cell action and this requires that industry to be connected to the market and have certain prerequisites in place such as being able to discard a beer in brass birmingham or being able to flip a port tile in lancashire but the tastiest aspect of these games is that a lot of what you build can be used by other

players iron beer coal and port tiles can all be used by other players iron can be taken by anyone from anywhere but the other three will require you to have a connection between where you're using it and where you're taking it from now it means that both these games are more interactive than you'd expect from euro games particularly as you also have a fight for space on the board that can be very tense however it also means that there's a wonderful kind of tension in the game in regards to people taking your stuff because at different times you'll both want them to take it to flip the tile you'll be banking on it in fact and other times you want them to stay the hell away because if they take it it means that all of your plans go up in flames as previously covered brass lancashire is a modern reprinting of the original game brass with a few raw tweaks and is now for two to four players the game focuses on the lancashire region of england during the industrial revolution and thus is about building cotton mills shipyards and ports when selling your cutter mills you can either sell to the foreign market which might get you some additional income but there's a risk the market gets oversaturated and you won't be able to sell at all or you can flip your own or any other player's port tiles if connected to sell and flip your cotter mills shipyards are flipped instantly when

they're built it's also worth noting that lancashire has a fan created two player variant map on the reverse side of the board and it has some variants in the rulebook instructing you how to play the classic brass brass birmingham could be considered a sequel to brass and thus brass birmingham and it is also two to four players it is set in the black country of england during the industrial revolution so called because of all the pollution industrialization caused now it has the same core rule set but brass birmingham does replace the port and shipyard tiles from lancashire with breweries potteries and manufactured goods now breweries act like iron and coal they produce little beers that you have to spend to flip those industries the manufactured goods is virtually identical to cotton mills and lastly the potteries could be said to be a bit of a re-implementation of the shipyards except they don't flip immediately when built now you have some minor rule changes and also some new actions like the scout action which allows you to give up cards in your hand to draw wild industry and location cards letting you build what and where you want more easily the last thing to know is that brass birmingham has randomized setup because you can only sell certain goods to certain marketplaces and where these will be is randomized each game

now if you're used to brass birmingham and you come to lancashire you'll find it tighter meaner and more singular in options available to you link points are more of a consideration and the development action is a must to win there are no wild cards and thus no scout action but you can spend any two cards and just take one action on your turn to use that as a wild location there are less spaces on the board so it's a much tougher fight to build what you want and wear particularly if you're going after shipyards it's just a much more cutthroat game because in order to sell cotton mills other players are likely going to be using your ports or they just take the option of the foreign market out of the game altogether so players can find themselves in a bad position where they have things to sell and literally no way to sell it if you go to brass birmingham after having played lancashire you'll probably find that there is a great bull number of available strategies and it's less harsh more freedom less pressure you now have the scout action which gives you a wild location and a wild industry card meaning that you're not the mercy of a bad draw and you also have the new breweries and beer which essentially replaces ports but because you can take your own beer from anywhere on the board it means that you're able to build breweries in the middle of nowhere basically not near anyone and you know it's safe which you couldn't do with port tiles

because players need to be connected to your breweries to take your beer and the last thing is you're probably going to get a little more variety game to game because you have these marketplace tiles and these essentially say that this marketplace will only take this good or this marketplace will only take that good and they're shuffled at the beginning of the game so it makes a little puzzle about how to connect the specific good your you've kind of invested in to the marketplace needs to go but also just the game kind of evolves differently each time so what do you need to know well firstly that the brass games are an excellent series of games and the production quality by ruxley is top notch however they're not going to be for everyone you could say that the theme is a little bit dry and it is a euro but there is a lot more player interaction than you might expect both in the fight for space and also the fact that you can use other players resources players do tend to struggle to get the rules set down in the first couple of games because there are some tricky things to wrap your head around such as where you can build connections where resources can come from and when you can sell things but we have found that once the rule set is understood it really tends to stick in your brain and it's quite easy to pick it up again for future games both games are widely considered to be better at higher play accounts but they're certainly not subpar at two players

now this is a really tough section because there's a real debate about which one is better if one can even be considered better it depends on how you like to play lancashire is tighter meaner and more one note it has a smaller map which forces the players together and it has mechanisms which create more risk and more uncertainty there's also less options here than in birmingham so the games will play out more similarly and you'll be exploring the same options and strategies more often we've also found that due to the lack of the scout action you can be more impacted by the luck of the draw birmingham's for people who like a bit more breathing space in their games who want a greater variety of strategies to explore and who also want each game to be a little more different as you have this variable market setup as a sequel it's fair to say that brass birmingham has more although that doesn't necessarily mean it's the better one of the games because as you said different each one will appeal to different people so it's not necessarily that one is better than the other because there's a lot of debate about it but should you get both no we were sent lancashire by ruxley games and i mean we're delighted to have it we love playing it we're going to keep it we're going to keep playing it we're going to play both of them but we're glad that we didn't buy it ourselves i mean you can consider brass birmingham to be a kind of stand-alone expansion to lancashire much in the way that nemesis

lockdown is to nemesis uh by the way check out our buyer's guide for those games plug plug uh but yeah you don't need both and you should really only have both if you're kind of a super fan of the experience

and now time for what do we think well thanks man i think that brass birmingham is the best design game i've ever played and i don't mean that's my favorite i just think that is mechanically perfect but it would probably also be in my top 10. uh you know it's an evergreen for us it's one that i could see us playing for literally decades ahead and we always have a great time playing it but what i will say in terms of lancashire is that i do feel that brass birmingham uh is uh an improvement upon it i think that we played brass birmingham a lot before we came to lancashire and that's made lancashire feel to us or to me i should say because you're going to say what you feel uh it feels kind of older a bit rough around the edges more restrictive and strategy and i feel much more at the mercy of the deck compared to brass birmingham but this is only in comparison to brass birmingham on its own is an excellent game and if you prefer games meaner tighter and harsher then it could be the one for you yeah i mean i agree with all of your comments on brass birmingham it does just pip it for me as my favorite of the two and i think it's because you've got those like more variety in the strategies uh because of the different industries that you can explore and like you said i think is particularly important because it's a game that will likely keep forever so it just feels a little bit more interesting and

makes you want to keep going back for more a little bit and whilst i really really do love lancashire in part because i've won more 80 percent of the games that we've played which is a real rarity for me i did feel like i won in the first game with a certain strategy and then i was just able to execute that strategy the same pretty much every game which was just going after cotton mills and basically ignoring the shipyards and i guess it just got to feeling a bit samey that i could just win with that same strategy every time until i beat you until you beat me that one time but maybe that's just because we played a lot of games in quite quick succession so maybe the feeling of it being a bit samey was amplified and it wouldn't be there was a bigger gap between and maybe i just got lucky with the draw of my cards so i was able to execute that strategy so it might not be reflective of everyone's experience with the game so this is our boss guide for brass birmingham and brass lancashire the brass series please feel free to ask us any questions about the series you might have and we'll do our best to answer them uh we really hope this was helpful uh so if it was please consider subscribing because that's really important to us and you know also like all the other good stuff yeah there's usually another dog here in our review videos it's just mr sven today megan's off somewhere so i mean come for the game stay for the dogs yeah

but most importantly thank you for watching and thanks to roxley for sending us lancashire yeah uh which sally appreciates of course because she keeps winning but uh i hope you enjoyed it see you next time

Progress saved