Skip to main content
Loading video...

Viticulture: A Buyer's Guide

Transcript 21:33

hello everyone tally and farrell here from board of it and welcome to our buyer's guide for viticulture one of the all-time greats for both theme and gameplay in board gaming have you ever wondered what the difference is between viticulture and viticulture essential edition are you thinking to maybe get the tuscany expansion but you're not sure have you ever wondered what the vista card expansions are all about well we've got you covered so before we get started you should know that we like to keep our bias guys factual so we kind of keep our opinions out of it uh but we do go over what we think at the very end and you should also know that we divide this into sections so please feel free to jump to the section that you are interested in say if you already own the base game and you want to learn more about the expansions and lastly we will let you know that our copy of viticulture world was kindly provided to us by the publisher stonemeyer games sorry to interrupt your video but at the moment we are doing a i guess you call it subscriber pledge drive and if you've seen this before you know this is something we've never done but we realized that in the last month 84 of people who watched our channel were not subscribers so if we can even get you know one to five percent of those people to subscribe that is a huge difference for us in our subscriber numbers and you'll also know that we've never really you know done anything like this before and we've never asked for

anything from anyone before as a channel we don't have a patreon we don't ask for donations there's only ads on our channel because youtube started running them anyway and we thought well we're not gonna let them make money of us for free and we just do this to help you find the best game possible so if you've watched us before and found it helpful or entertaining please consider subscribing same goes for if it's your first time watching us and you find this helpful and importantly there is a reason you should subscribe and it's because it helps us become a better channel the first thing is the more subscribers we have the more attractive we are to developers and publishers which means they're more likely to send us interesting games that we can share with you and second part of that is if they send us these games it means we don't have to pay for them ourselves which then means the money that we would spend on those games we can reinvest in the channel maybe get more equipment better equipment make the photography better and you know these are really ways that we can hopefully improve the channel which we haven't been able to done at the moment because our output is on the games so please please consider subscribing it would really mean a lot to us every subscriber we do look at and really appreciate and if you're already a subscriber thank you so much and please consider clicking the bell icon because we're also at half as many people as is the bottom of average who do that and again the more people who are notified

when a video comes out the more people who watch it and more views we get and same thing for the publishers and designers it makes us more interesting to them but back to the video viticulture is unsurprisingly a game about viticulture or the cultivation and harvesting of grapes viticulture is also closely entwined with wine making and can be used synonymously with wine growing viticulture the game thus uses the term in this way where your goal is to create a profitable and well-respected vineyard from a property that family has left you in tuscany for one to six players the game was designed by jamie stogmeier and alan stone and was published by stonemaier games the core mechanism is worker placement but you'll also be doing a little bit of engine building to make sure you're consistently producing wines viticulture essential edition is now the commercially available version of viticulture and can be seen as a second edition of sorts as it took some of the modules from the first expansion from the original viticulture and incorporated them into the base gang there are many expansions available from small ones that let you have alternative cards to larger ones which turns the game into a cooperative puzzle story of this culture begins in 2012 when a kickstarter for the game was put up

and this was done by designers alan stone and jamie stegmeier the game was released to the backers in 2013 and it was well received this in turn led to an expansion called tuscany in 2014 now the designers weren't done with viticulture at this point because 2015 saw the release of viticulture essential edition and this essentially took the first version of viticulture and incorporated several modules from the various expansions into the base game of course now that you had viticulture essential edition you needed tuscany essential edition which followed in 2016. this involved some of the modules from the original tuscany expansion just revamped but they also weren't done with viticulture at this point because between then and now viticulture has seen another three expansion releases two of which were visitor cards that you can put into the game or swap out the existing vista cards with a brand new set and the viticulture cooperative expansion released just this year viticulture world that makes viticulture a cooperative game now nearly a decade on viticulture is still a much beloved game as evidenced by its position at spot 29 on the board game geek top 100 games of all time bitter culture at its core is classic worker placement but with a smidge of

engine building a game round will last a year of winemaking in spring players will decide the turn order for the upcoming year in summer players will take summer specific actions in turn order by placing one worker on an available space until they decide to pass in full players will take either a summer visitor card or a winter visitor card and these are cards that will give you resources or boost your actions in winter players will again take actions that are specific to winter by placing a worker on an available space but here their worker pool is limited to those that they didn't use in the summer the aim of the game is to produce wine and fulfill orders for vp but there are other ways to score vp notably from the visitor cards to produce wine you need to obtain and plant vine cards you'll need to harvest your vines put the grapes into your crush pad and then finally bottle up your wine once the wine is bottled up and at the right age then you can fulfill your orders important to note that both your grapes and your wine in the cellar ages at the end of each year the game will end when a player reaches or surpasses 20 victory points and then the winner will be the person at the end of that year summer and winter actions are distinct with the summer actions and summer vista cards being more about setting up your vineyard i.e building structures planting vines and the winter actions and winter visitor cards being more

about your end processes harvesting your grapes bottling up your wine and fulfilling your orders the number of available spaces on each action is dependent on the number of players so things can get a bit tricky because once somebody takes those actions then it's not available or is it interestingly with viticulture each player has one grande worker that can go into a space otherwise blocked off by other players vit culture is an excellent game and one of the greatest examples of work placement you could possibly play but it does have one very common criticism leveled at it that you should be aware of that is randomness a lot of the gameplay in this game is driven by decks of cards be it vine visitor or order and the luck of the draw can have an effect on how well you do in the end because what is important about this game is that atlas core is in some many ways a race game a race to the finish line of race to 20 bp and if you don't get the vine cards that match your orders or vice versa and you have to go back to those decks and draw more it means you've probably already lost particularly if another player gets exactly what they need first time the biggest issue though are the visitor cards because these will provide vp and that means that they're going to have much more of an effect on the game and thus are the biggest source of

complaint now i personally have never been too bothered by the randomness of cards and viticulture i've never really felt like it's affected the game too much that i didn't enjoy it but on the other hand tally certainly feels differently and certainly feels that some games have been completely decided by the luck of what first cards other people have got because they've given them a lot of vp however if you do feel that this randomness might be an issue for you then you can grab the visit from the ryan valley expansion because these cards swap out the cards from the base game for cards solely focused on winemaking thus you shouldn't have this issue of people locking into vp another thing that you should know is that people consider viticulture essential edition to be a great game but viticulture with the tuscany essential edition is a perfect game in fact this is the kind of thing where people tell you to buy tuscany with viticulture and just play from the start with the expansion included you might ask do i need to like want to enjoy viticulture do i need to like drinking or anything like that and the answer is no you don't we do think the theme is excellent but the mechanics are also strong and you can definitely enjoy it even if you don't like wine or drinking or whatever a perfect example is tom vassell from dice tower i believe he's t total and

he's had viticulture in his top 10 games of all time on the flip side if you're interested in viticulture maybe because you work in the wine street alcohol industry you should know that this game does put mechanisms over accuracy and it's not quite an accurate simulationist game if that was something you're looking for the version of viticulture that's currently for sale is viticulture essential edition and this has two big expansions the first of which is tuscany essential edition this is a modular expansion which adds some really cool stuff the main part being is that it comes with a new game board to replace the one from the base game which alters the worker placement so that there's four worker placement seasons instead of two it also comes with some brand new actions which open up the tactical and strategic space and also a little area control minigame which provides some bonuses and vp next up is the buildings module which adds a brand new deck of cards each card is a unique building you have the option to build which adds some interesting gameplay decisions and then lastly there's the workers module which adds some workers that have some special abilities that can be trained up for a bit of extra money which really creates some interesting situations the second big box expansion for viticulture is viticulture world and this turns viticulture into a cooperative game it comes with a brand new board upgrade

tiles scenario decks and little hats for your working meeples now each scenario deck is set on a different continent and it will task you with creating a reputable and profitable vineyard in that region but you're also going to have to deal with the inherent issues of which culture in that continental region but each of these scenarios will also play around with mechanisms of viticulture meaning that you do have interesting challenges to face and that each scenario feels quite different coming on to the smaller expansions first up there's the more visitors expansion pack which adds a new deck of cards which are shuffled into the original deck which are a bit more wild and spicy alternatively there's the visitors from the rhine valley pack which is used instead of the original deck these focus a lot more on the wine making as opposed to providing vp so it could be good for those who maybe weren't fans of the randomness of the original deck when it comes to providing bp there are also the arboriculture and for maggio modules which were part of the original kickstarter for tuscany but were deemed non-essential so didn't make it into tuscany ee these are currently available only as print and play content from the stonemeyer website finally you have the cosmetic stuff you could buy the viticulture wine crate which is essentially a big box storage solution for viticulture and all of its

expansions shaped like a wine crate but you should know that at the moment you can only buy this in combination with viticulture worlds but i believe next year you'll be able to buy it just on its own then there are the customary metal coins and if you live in the us you could even get viticulture wine glasses so this is the only part of the video where we share our opinions and thoughts on viticulture you can almost think of it like a mini review first things first we absolutely love viticulture for us it's one of our all-time favorite classic games and it's one we can't imagine ever getting bored of we particularly love hosting viticulture fridays where we get our friends around have some tapas food get some wine of course play a good game of viticulture it's one of the best examples of classic worker placement scales really well according to player count and in our opinion has one of the best themes in board gaming and despite being really fun and approachable also has a nice amount of tension because it's also a race game as often the player that reaches the 20 vp first will be the winner now as i said earlier people consider that viticulture essential edition is a great game but this culture ee with tuscany ee to be basically a perfect game and they say this because mainly because of the new board that tuscany ads i think

it seemed to add more strategic depth allow more maneuverability and it essentially kind of takes away the criticisms people have of the base game in that the randomness doesn't matter so much because there are workarounds now we actually agree with all of that and i think what it adds is really terrific and also the other modules but we are in the minority that we're not so hot on the new board uh and we agree with kind of everything we said but what we don't like about it is it takes two work placement seasons and turns them into four work placement seasons and for us it essentially breaks kind of all flow in the game it makes a very stop start very bitty and the base game had a very nice smooth flow and just don't feel that anymore um so yeah so we do still recommend uh tuscany essential edition for the ads i mean it's a great expansion but we also are just as likely to play the base game of viticulture without the tuscany board as we are to play with it so moving on to the smaller expansions with the more visitors we think this is pretty good fun and add some cards which shake things up and make things kind of interesting as they're a bit spicy we wouldn't say it's a must buy but it's definitely worth considering if you're a big fan of viticulture and you do want to shake up those visitor cards

probably not worth getting if you weren't a big fan of the swinginess of the original deck though because this deck only exacerbates that and if that person is you then you could consider visit from the rhine valley a must buy expansion because these cards will you'll swap out the base game cards with and they have a focus just on wine making so they won't give you any vp and the game will more be about getting vp from making wine and fulfilling orders so if you don't want that randomness check out that expansion and lastly there's the newest expansion viticulture world this is an interesting one because it turns viticulture into a cooperative game and we do feel like a lot of people were a bit nonplussed when this came out we certainly think that a lot of culture fans were maybe mildly disappointed by the announcement that it was cooperative but we're really happy to say that it seems like once most people play it they change their tune and we will admit that this does include us it comes with a new board and the big change is that the spaces don't have bonuses but players can upgrade them in two ways they can either upgrade them so that the spaces can hold any number of workers and get a small bonus or they can upgrade the specific action tied to the spot to massively boost it so each game you play a viticulture world will have the same goal

every player needs to get to 25 victory points and you collectively need to gain 10 influence by the end of the sixth year but they each game is actually quite different because what you're going to be doing is playing scenarios and these scenarios represent having a vineyard in different continents and kind of you get some bonuses you get some new um kind of disruptions to the game to give you some difficulties and these scenarios also will each one kind of mess around with the core mechanisms of the game so it turns out that you do have quite unique experiences each scenario now one thing that you should know is as we said we were definitely converts when we played it because we liked it much more than we thought we would but damn is it hard this game makes mansions of madness at times look like a friendly fuzzy experience but on the flip side tally has said that this has made her like it more because you thought it was going to be like a fuzzy little walkover and it wouldn't be much to it but it's pretty it's pretty tough so you do get a lot of repayability out of this because between all the different scenarios i think there's seven or eight uh depending if you get a promo pack or not uh and the fact that you have this difficulty you're gonna get a lot of kind of content out of it yeah but what you should know and this is kind of the only negative to it is

the difficulty and the randomness because the randomness is definitely more apparent here because the game is so tight on the timelines it gives you and one makes you do plus you might get things thrown at you and money's really important now uh that you can know you've lost in year two because you just didn't draw good line cards or order cards or something right yeah so that's a bit of a kind of disappointment i guess you could say that it's so tough and also which uh upgrade tiles come out when can have a really huge impact on how smooth your game is so final thoughts if you don't have viticulture and you're in any way interested then we say get it or at a very minimum give it a go in a board game cafe it's an absolute classic to us the tuscany ee expansion is also seen and no pun intended here as essential we would fully recommend it although we do have our own personal issues with how it changes things don't necessarily recommend the visitor card expansions unless you're looking for a very specific way to change up your base game of viticulture viticulture world however is definitely a recommendation from us if you want to shake up your game of viticulture or if you're a big fan of cooperative games be warned though it's not for the faint of

heart brutal and that was our buyer's guide for viticulture we hope it was helpful please if you have any questions just ask us below in the comments and if it was helpful we'd appreciate it if you could subscribe and most importantly thanks for watching and we hope it was helpful see you next time bye

Progress saved