AZUL vs AZUL vs AZUL - Ultimate Board Game Review
Transcript
hey dude so what three games did you pick for tonight well actually i thought we could play azul as all and as all what do you think i meant three different games bring on the is all marathon the azul line of board games is probably one of my most favorite abstract pattern building thailand board games that i own in my entire board game collection and these three are some of my fave in this video we're going to be comparing each of these three games to see which one is better and which one can out compete the rest and without further ado it's hammer time nailed it many people often describe abstract board games as dry methodical mathematical and completely devoid of theme azul has challenged that common misperception and introduced pops of color vibrancy and has turned something that could have seemed dry into something so shiny it looks like a square disco ball across each round players will be drafting tiles from these factory discs players will have a simple decision take all of one type of pattern tile from either a single factory disk or from the central area it's like deciding between the salad or the dessert from a buffet bar once gathered players must place their tiles in these line rows placing one tile in each space available they all however must be the same pattern type have any excess tiles and they go straight into this floor line to be scored as negative points at the end of the round the tiles get
transferred onto the wall from top to bottom scoring plays valuable points along the way connect them to other tiles both horizontally and vertically and you're singing misplace those tiles and you shall linger in your misfortunes azul summer pavilion is all about evoking that summer feeling the cool drink chilling by the beach and the hot weather what is really hot here is the strategy as you'll be kept on your toes as you gather tiles and place them on your floral board here the rules are similar to the original azul draft tiles from the factory displays and place them strategically on your board the differences here is that you are now dabbling with parallelograms and connecting the petals together to create combos of points you're completing clusters of flowers with the same pattern or different patterns if you're creating the one in the center here there is a new system to cashing in your tiles where the number on the pedal indicates how many of that tile you'll have to pay in order to place a tile there interestingly one colored tile will act as a wild tile each and every round and this changes throughout the game furthermore players will be able to store up to four tiles for later use so forward planning is really important however greediness in this game is never rewarded as if you have excess tiles left over at the end of each round you lose them as victory points it doesn't sound so summery after all does it ever wondered what a beautiful garden fit for a queen would be like well in this version of azul players will be drafting garden expansion tiles and colored hexagon tiles fit for a queen a queen
bee that is unlike in the other games drafting tiles here occurs differently at the beginning of each round only four tiles are revealed to plays as players take their turn the tiles not taken are moved along in front of the other players like some sort of sushi train players will be picking tiles of all of the same color or tiles of all of the same symbol whilst avoiding picking two identical tiles at the same time tiles are also embedded into garden expansions which also can be used to pay for the cost of placing other tiles the lovely delightful thing about this game is that the tiles gathered can be placed anywhere in your garden provided that you've got enough space ultimately players are trying to create clusters of connecting symbols or colors together the symbol on each tile indicates the cost of placing it a bird for example costs two tiles to place it out the puzzly thing about this version of the game is that players can have to venture and collect the patterns that they need as the icons that are printed on the hexagon tiles score as face-up victory points at the end of the game which is huge additionally each round players will be scoring points from activated colors and patterns from this beautiful garden wheel as well as any face-up pavilions that are shown this game is truly an afternoon delight i find the drafting aspect of the original game is all quite intriguing at the beginning of each round players are all going to know exactly what tiles are available to them and also what sort of patterns are going to be numerous and what sort of patterns are going to be limited in numbers this
provides for some really cool careful strategic planning and timing as the round kind of unfolds i mean players have to decide do they take limited quantities of a particular tile they need from the factory tiles or do they wait until they all get pulled in the center before nabbing all of those same tiles there is a beautiful timing element to the game where players have to kind of peck in at the right moment and at the right time it's like a seagull swooping in on a bowl of hot chips while someone's eating them at the beach you can force other place to take a copious amount of a pattern that they definitely don't need because as players fill up this pyramidal staircase of azulus players who overdraw the number of patent tiles are going to have to place their patent tiles in this broken tile row and that's going to cause them to lose points and what i really love about azul is that you can see all your tile options from the beginning of every round
uh what are you doing i was just creating a multitude of different permutations and combinations in my brain just to see how many different ways this round could play out the drafting in azul summer pavilion provides players some really interesting flexibility i like to describe the drafting in this game a little bit more economically driven the tiles that you take have to be used in a way so that you can place uh the tiles onto your stars as most efficiently as possible depending on what numbers are on the stars themselves also the fact that you can save four tiles each and every round means that you can use them and set them up for later turns you can also access these uh tiles around this central wheel if you surround certain statues and pillars on your board meaning that there's a sense of economy that comes through this game when it comes to picking the tiles off the factory tile set and seeing which ones you want to save up for later and which ones you actually want to use now it's like deciding what to do with your pocket money and how you're going to budget it out so that you make the most out of what you've got additionally the idea that each colored tile will become a wild tile somewhere throughout the six rounds is an interesting aspect of itself in the first round the purple tiles will always be wild whereas the red tiles will always be wild in the last round and knowing when those tiles change their function throughout your course of the game and planning for that change is something that's really well worth thinking what really impresses me a lot with the azul series is the fact that the designer knows how to take a really well oiled formula and elevates
it to another level to make it feel fresh different and interesting at the same time i really like the drafting that occurs in this version of the game you can hear the rain outside pouring down that's for some dramatic effect don't you think whoa pretty wild in here being the first player is an incredible disadvantage because the first player only has access to four tiles they're taken from the bag in fact if you are the last player in turn order you have an incredible advantage you get to see the tiles come out you get to see what other players pick and then you can kind of peruse and plan what's a strategy that you're going to take when it comes to your turn unlike the other versions of azul here players are not going to know what sort of tiles are going to appear throughout the round so there's a element of risk or luck that's involved so in terms of the drafting experience azul comes in third place zul's summer pavilion comes in at number two bozo queens garden i rank it number one oh this game is far better than the other silly game that we played last week which game oh the one where you place the square tiles on the grid and create patterns minazul the one we're playing right now would you look at that i scored a 7 victory point combo yes generally humans like filling things in and when it comes to puzzles solving puzzles and filling things in is something that humans do really well and there's a great immense satisfaction
that players get from doing something like that and azul really ticks those boxes it's like filling in a crossword or a fill-in puzzle or a sudoku what i really like about the puzzle aspect is the fact that players can line up their rows and set up their boards for some really cool scoring situations where when you place your tile and you convert that perfect color right over you can combo out by scoring that connected tile both vertically and horizontally and being able to do that multiple times and setting that up for some really cool chaining effects as you go down your triangular staircase pyramid of azul tiles just creates for some really big point scoring opportunities where you might even realize that you'll score so many points that your little marker just flies right off the board if you flip the game all the way onto its back you've got this grey grid where the game is open slather wherever you place your patterns is going to really set you up for where you can and cannot place tile patterns later on in the game wow this game is kind of like sudoku but with prettier tiles what really delights me in this version of bazool are these parallel star patterns that plays have to technically fill in i really like the pattern that plays have to try and work towards because each of the stars has a numerical value which is the cost of placing that particular colored tile in that area so if it's a space with a number four and i'll need to pay four purple tiles to place a purple
parallelogram in that space there is a sense of geometry when it comes to picking your tiles and then thinking how those tiles are going to then translate into these floral patterns out of all the games i've played of the zul's summer pavilion no one i have seen has ever filled in every single star on this board it is incredibly hard and incredibly challenging to do so in terms of the pattern building aspect that features in this game i think there's a huge sense of openness but i also want to say that this game is all about network and route building i know it's an abstract game but what you're really trying to do is you're trying to connect all the same symbol but different colors together in a cluster and you're also trying to create linear paths of all tiles of the same pattern together whilst at the same time trying to surround all of these park bench statue and pavilion symbols to gain extra jokers which you can use to fulfill some of those cool tiles that might be missing from your collection the pattern building element in itself is beautiful it's elegant it's almost like you're creating this cool winding colorful path and you're paving this path around this really gorgeous hexagonal shape garden the fact that using these hexagonal shaped tiles means there's lots of options for branching out and connecting it to other clusters and patterns that you've already established there's a beautiful sense of progression and expansion that you have in this version of the game where you're kind of like in a hive and you're trying to build the hive out and and allow it to grow
organically i also like the element of being able to collect patterns and the fact that the tiles have a dual function the particular symbol tells you the cost and the point value of the tile as well as the color being part of the scoring that you're going to need to do if you're creating certain clusters at the end of the game in terms of the overall pattern building mechanism azure summer pavilion comes in for me at number three i rank azure queens garden number two azul comes in first place there are two primary ways to score in a game of azul summer pavilion first of all it's all about connecting those parallelogram shaped tiles together in the same star being able to connect a chain together means that you're gonna compound points so if you fill in that one space and then fill in the two space in the three space you'll be able to progressively increase the number of victory points you score each time you place a tile so being able to connect them sequentially in order is actually really important the other way to score is at the end of the game by completing certain stars certain stars are more valuable than others the purple star is worth the most mainly because that tile is the wild tile at the beginning of the game and the red star is probably worth one of the least the central star's worth even less than that because it kind of has that flexibility of being able to be filled in when you kind of opportunistically have the chance to and also players can score points if they fill in all the ones on all their stars or the twos or the threes and the falls in terms of the scoring mechanism
the zoo queen's garden is probably the one that is most different from the other versions of the game in this game players are going to be aiming to try and score different tile patterns and colors each and every round based on this rotary wheel you also score a point if you've got a pavilion that's showing as well as there's a different way to score if you want to play a different version of the game which throughout the game you kind of get sprinkles or little breadcrumbs of what sort of point scores everyone is on but no one really truly knows who's winning until the very end of the game because at the very end of the game you do this massive scoring that occurs where you score every color you score every pattern for its face up icon value as well as clusters of six to be able to then determine who the winner is and i can see why the scoring happens primarily at the end and that's because players are constantly adding to their clusters in their garden it's still growing mid-game so you don't really want to score something that isn't truly finished so i actually really like the uncertainty of not knowing what points i'm going to get like i know in the other versions the point scoring system compounds so you can really clearly see if someone is in the lead this creates a sense of excitement as well as reducing a lot of the account keeping that's required in this game till the end of the game and in terms of its victory point scoring mechanism as all summer prevailing for me comes in at number three i rank azure queens garden number two azul comes in a really lovely first place so i place my blue tile here and scored 10 victory points
in terms of the strategy and theme of the game i think the two elements really marry well together the idea that these spanish-inspired tiles are being laid out in this opulent portuguese kings palace is just something that really comes through not only in these starburst shapes type lolly resin square-shaped tiles as well as the beautiful art that's evoked on the factory discs themselves in terms of the gameplay itself i would definitely describe it as elegant a lot of other board games come with real exceptions you can't do this or you can't do that the restrictions that are imposed in this game in terms of where you can place tiles are very simple and clear and they are part of the puzzle itself take too many tiles from the center and you're going to be wasting them and throwing them out and costing the king money if you ever have to take a group of patent tiles and place them on your board and there's physically no space on your patent line rows you have to place the excess down on this floor line down below which kind of represents all of the broken tiles that you'll have to throw out wow that seems kind of wasteful what are you doing uh just throwing the tiles out or if you don't take enough you won't be able to place that beautiful shaped yellow tile on that wall space where you really really want it there's a cool marriage of both strategic thinking and how the game systematically plays itself out uh dude i think you got your games mixed up here oh really you did say that i could play whatever i wanted in terms of the strategy and theme azor summer
pavilion is probably the one game in the series that has the least amount of restrictions it's probably got the greatest amount of openness and flexibility to kind of dabble in different colors different styles different patterns different regions of your board without too much restraint in terms of the theme whilst the game itself looks remarkably colorful and the tiles are absolutely vibrant and pop off the table i really find that there is a strong disconnect between the summer pavilion theme and the game itself in terms of looking at the strategy and theme of this version of azul i just love gardening and i just love green things and when this game came out i got so excited even more excited than any of the other versions of azul that i probably think that i'm a little bit biased i do like how in this game the idea of your tiles and your gardens growing organically from all these central hex points just really plays into the idea of expanding and tending to the queen's garden do you think that the color of the tiling is a little bit too similar especially the greens and the purples strategy that you have to employ is one where you have to kind of invest in what's already been drawn for the bag what symbols have we already seen who's already placed those particular symbols on the board and deciding whether you need to change your strategy halfway through the game and i think that level of unpredictability and also being able to deduce oh look there's 10 yellows out already how many yellows are still left in the bag that does come and play into effect there's
all summer pavilion for me come to that number three original zul comes in second place for its theme i rank azul queens garden number one the time has come friends to do the final rankings which of those azul games do i think is the best design board game in third place is azul summer pavilion and in second place for me it is azul queens garden surprise surprise there the best designed azul game is for me the original and now to throw a final spanner in the works i'm now also going to re-rank those three games in terms of my personal affection and love for the games themselves sorry to say it's all summer pavilion this used to be my favorite version of azul just because it was a gamer's gamer version of the original azure and i just loved it so much and i still do but that comes in third but the one i really love and it comes in second place is the original azul meaning that the one that comes in first place as my personal favorite one that i absolutely love and i connect with so much is azul queens garden so what did you think of these three versions of azul write your thoughts in the comments below i also want to say that i haven't actually played the second version of azul i think uh azul stained glass of sinatra and i purposely didn't include it in this list because i hadn't uh played the game and i don't really own it it is one that has intrigued me but for some reason it just hasn't really connected
with uh what i've seen of the game but if you've played that version of the game definitely let me know where it sits in the the rank of all four zul games what your preferences are whether you agree or disagree with what i've said in this video i'd love to hear your thoughts in comments and if you ever follow a board game sanctuary and thank you for making it so far in this video if you'd like to please kindly give me a like and subscribe to the channel for more amazing board game content stay with me guys and i'll bring you some more amazing board game content in the near future this is danny signing out see you guys next time