The Chairman Discommends Kiri-Ai: The Duel, Manila, Ankh'or, Lutece, Caesar & Cleopatra
Transcript
hey everybody today I am taking a look at five board games that didn't quite make the cut when it came to staying in my collection some of them missed it by a narrow margin and some of them missed it by quite a large margin now before I get started on these five reviews I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k.c. who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so let's get started with Manila now this is a 3 to five player game that takes 60 Minutes to play according to the box but personally I would say it's a a bit quicker than that now this is a kind of a a bidding and wagering Style game where you are going to be spending cash betting on these different spots here so essentially you have three of these boats that are going to be sailing up this track each round you're going to be rolling these Dice and going to determine how far these boats move but essentially you have um different actions you can take so what you can do is you can bet on a certain number of boats making it to the end or not making it to the end you can actually sit on the boats themselves and if you um if you make it to the Finish then you'll get your share of the spoils based on how many people are sat on those particular boats and you you can even kind of go all in on these little hijack spots where if somebody lands
directly on a certain spot then you can kind of kick them off their boat and take their place now the do the game does have some additional mechanisms that you can add in such as bidding for the captaincy so basically each turn you're going to have a a slight auction where the winning player will kind of Commander the ships and start the ships at different spaces so you know if they've got a high investment in a particular ship type then they might want to push that further along to increase its odds and chances of winning um additionally it does have this kind of commodity spe speculation stocks and shares mechanism where you can get shares in the different company types based on what the boats can be populated with which will give you some additional points based on um where they stand at the end of the game now I actually think those extra bells and whistles don't actually help the game too much if it was a little bit too extra and I don't think it makes the game any more fun and you know I do like the premise of this game I think it's a cool idea but I do think it has been made better by um by subsequent games the game that I most think of is camel up which was a very popular SPI dear's winner actually I think camel up does this style of game a lot better because I think the investment and the sense of ownership comes through a bit stronger in camel up and it gets you a little bit more excited again invested in those camels as you bet on them not only shortterm but long-term this game does have that in a in a little bit but not quite as um
I don't not quite as polished I think not quite as refined I just don't think it has those highs and lows like a game like celup has um additionally it can be quite frustrating uh when you know you might put a lot of investment into something and somebody just kicks you off just by you know sheer chance so in that respect it does become a little bit yeah a little bit jarring too but it's not a bad game by any means it just didn't quite hit the spot for me um and I always had that feeling of you know I'd rather play camel up in the back of my mind when I was playing Manila but I know this one have it has its fans it's got a lovely production um especially if you have the version I have here but still just slightly missed the mark and has been replaced by another game so I'll probably give this one about a 5 out of 10 if I was to grade it okay so let's move on to Caesar and Cleopatra a card game for two players now this one takes around half an hour to play again I think the box does say it takes slightly longer than that and as you can see this actually comes from the cosmos line of two-player games where some absolute Classics have been published such as um you know Kahuna Lost Cities the rose King lots of great games from Cosmos now this one is one that's certainly not stood the test of time like those other ones and after playing it I can probably see why um but this does have some cool things going on I have to be um be clear with that where you are competing for the these different kind of senators by playing cards from your hand um generally
speaking You'll Play either one card face down or two cards face up based on um you know where you place them essentially and you're trying to have the majority in terms of the um the highest numbers next to those senators and at the end of your turn you'll always reveal from this deck of cards um which will show which particular Senator is going to be scored and if you have the majority then you will gain that card each card is going to be worth a point at the end of the game if you have the majority you'll get some additional points and if you have all of them you'll score some additional points again there's also some hidden objectives that you can try score for you know secret scoring at the end of the game the game does have some additional twists however where you can play these P cards which I think actually is the coolest mechanism in the game where if you play a p card all of a sudden that will be changed to who has the lowest total and because of course you can play these face down um you might be luring your oppon into traps by you know if if you're really after a certain Senator then your opponent might be keep on playing the high cars you played one of these you're going to win however it does have this cool ccel out mechanism where if your opponent plays a p card and you've already played a p card then it will revert back to being those um you know positive points rather than or the highest score rather than the negative score I really like that flow I think it's a very cool mechanism and it does that part of the game very well I also do like that idea of of each round you're going to draw from the deck and it's going to show which Senator you score which means that as the game
progresses you can kind of deduce what is going to come up next but there are these orgy cards in the deck where if a certain of them if a certain one comes out you're going to reshuffle those cards back together which can completely change the pacing because it means that if you say score a certain Senator then you reshuffle you could score that Senator again but if that shuffle cards right at the bottom of the deck then you're going to go through all the different types of sener before they're scored again so I do really like mechanism in in actuality it's a little bit frustrating because you're always shuffling them up and it doesn't it kind of breaks the flow and the tempo of the game um but I'm willing to forgive that because you know I do like the way that it works in you know in practice mechanically um the biggest kind of pit for my in my opinion of this game is the bonus cards so basically you have your standard numbered cards or these P cards but you also have these action cards in the game which I think think are I think they're very heavy-handed and I think they're a bit clumsy and actually ruin the game experience so for example you know this one says you know remove all influence cars from one group both yours and your opponents yeah that's kind of cool in the right scenario but it does feel like it's a bit a bit forced and a bit too powerful if you have it in your car in your hand and your opponent doesn't you know search your opponent's hand and select one or remove it from the game so for a game that works well mechanically I think those other cards just feel again a little bit too I don't know I'm not going to say a Mera trashy but again a little bit too heavy-handed for the rest of the game in my opinion
but that for me was enough to bring it below the threshold of me willing to keep hold of this one because uh yeah I just don't think it's quite up to scratch with a lot of the other two-player games of this nature you know I'd rather lean towards something like as I said lost cities or maybe a battle line if I want this classic feeling you know majority tug-of War Style game this one's again not a bad one but it's not as good or refined as those others either so again I'd probably get this one um 5 and 1 half out of 10 maybe a six on a good day um that is Caesar and Cleopatra okay so let's move on to lest this is a two to five player game that takes around 45 minutes to play now the main mechanisms here are set collection and bidding so you do bidding through this simultaneous card play which is a mechanism I tend to enjoy but for me uh games like Lutes are the most difficult for me to review and that is because there's nothing really wrong with it you know I can't think of a particular mechanism or anything in particular that I don't like but at the same time it just leaves me wanting it leaves me feeling a little bit numb because the game is just a bit dull to be honest so for me this one feels so generic and it feels like I've played it you know 50 times before in different different iterations so essentially this one you are going to be playing these um cards from your hand in order to pick up these
cards from a common pool essentially and these cards will score you points in different ways you know score x amount of points plus one point for every one of these symbols you have or that symbol you have we've all played games like this and you know to be honest this one is perfectly adequate it works as it should do um but there just isn't that extra spark there isn't something special about this one I suppose if anything I do quite like the management of your your cash because of course you need cash to buy more cards um but at the same time in order to generate more cash you have to give up bids essentially you're have to sacrifice picking up cards for the round because some cards you play will simply just give you money which which can help you going uh forward I also do quite like this bidding mechanism where you know despite selecting a card and you know revealing it simultaneously you can bolster those bids by placing coins on top of them but of course your opponents don't know which one you are bolstering and you know are they going for the same card that I'm going for maybe they are so I'm going to up my bid you flip the cards and it reveals that you're going for something completely different and you've just wasted your money so I do like the way that works again has a nice flow to it um again the set collection mechanisms are just a little bit too standard um I do feel like it needed an extra step or something you know additional to differentiate it from the C of you know filler set collection games out there it looks nice you know it flows pretty well um some good well some relatively good choices I suppose but all in all it just left me wanting
for more and to be honest you can play a game like needid of AIA which has some similar crossover or some Crossover with a game like lest for me that's a much richer a much more polished and sophisticated game um than Lutes is it's just a much much much more fun to be honest um and you can play in around the same time frame so you know if I can play neid valer in 45 minutes or I can play Lutes in 45 minutes then I'm not going to think twice about choosing neid of Valia so that is Lutes again not bad by any means um but it just left it just you know it needed a certain spark it needed something extra to make it stand out so again I'll probably give this one maybe a four and a half or five out of 10 for those reasons okay so let's move on to Anor now this is by Sebastian palan actually who's a a design that I really enjoy uh this one is around 30 minutes to play and accommodates two to four players now this is a a kind of game that reminds me of Splendor in a way you know I'm sure we've all played that game so essentially you are collecting these tokens and these tokens will allow you to cash them in in order to pick up these tiles and what you're trying to do with these tiles is you are trying to create these patterns by connecting either like colors or like symbols together and essentially if you have at least two together then you'll score that many points but if you get to five you'll get some bonus points as well now the puzzle
itself is pretty lackluster to be honest um you know I think there's so many cool ways you can make puzzles nowadays and this one is simply you know put these tiles together and try to create chains of them if you want you can place one on top like this to touch all of those four tiles that's like the only little wrinkle to the puzzle um you know I think of games like framework you know games like Nova Luna they do these puzzle in such a more interesting way and a more Dynamic way this one just feels like a means to an end collect token collect token collect token buy the tow you want place the tow in an obvious place so that's pretty much what the game uh entailed very weak choice-- wise I think um it just felt a little bit I don't know a little bit obvious about what you should do um and even had a bit of a weird game Flow where the the tiles don't automatically they don't automattic automatically replenish themselves and you actually have to collect these ANC tiles in order to refill the row uh it does get rid of the furthest leftmost one which means you can sometimes mess with your opponent under the right circumstances but generally speaking it felt like well okay if you're not going to do it I'll spend one of my anks in order to refill the row and we'll start again from scratch start collecting tokens so you know again it's it's not like a terrible game or anything thing it's just very very dry very well just dull as dish water really not really much to sink your teeth into just a means to an end going through the motions collect collect collect cash in
cash in collect cash in and place these tiles in an obvious place so now despite the uh lovely production good artwork here even some good design pedigree um you know the game is Just again very very basic and almost feels AI generated it's that it's that predictable so this one probably the weakest of these I've spoken about so far probably give this a three maybe a four out of 10 on a good day so let's move on to the final game which is killi ey the jewel comes in this nice little wallet you know think of a a button shy Style game it's around the same size of that so certainly small only a few cards in this one this is a two player only game takes you know somewhat between 10 or 15 minutes to play on average now the cool thing about this game is that it's a um it replicates a jewel of Samurai so basically you're you've got the blue samurai and the Red Samurai which is going to represent each of the players and you're going to have an identical hand of cards which will show your movement on this kind of track as well as the attacks you can make uh the idea is that you want to hit your opponent twice before they hit you twice and um you'll instantly win the game now you do have these bonus cards as well which you're going to get a random one of those at the start of the game that will give you some more unpredictable abilities because your opponent doesn't know which exact card you have in those but I don't think really need to go into those and I can explain the premise of the game with these other cards so um you can see that these cards have a
bunch of different information on them so the first thing is The Stance you need to be in in order to do this particular attack so you have the kind of Sword up stance like this or you have the Sword Down stance uh like this and in order to do these particular attacks you need to be in that relevant stance so you can see in this one I need to be in the lower stance which I am um and this would attack one space away from me you got other ones as well that let you move backwards or let you move forwards ones that let you hit several spots away providing if you're in the the upper stance and so on so as you can imagine your opponent needs to be in the right spot in order for you to um execute this particular attack this one here lets you attack on the exact spot you're on but it can be performed in any of those stance that one gives you a little quick Dash and that one lets you switch stances so um essentially yeah you're going to keep on simultaneously revealing these cars moving around the map trying to hit each other if you both attack at the same time your swords will bounce off each other and none of you will deal that blow I suppose the cool thing about this game is that you cannot keep on doing the same thing because each turn you're choosing two cards and one of those cards will kind of be held in reserve for the following turn so um you know you have to be careful about what you use and what's going to get held up because your opponent will know that and know which card is not in your mix for the following turn so essentially this is a an elaborate version of Paper Rock Scissors you know it's nothing more than that really of course there are those additional twists but it does come down
to trying to guess what your opponent is going to do um and you know kind of getting into the head of your opponent luring him into traps and so on now I've had really good games of Kiri ones that have felt edgy and tense and I've had games that have been complete Duds where in the first couple of cards I managed to hit my opponent and just win the game which Falls incredibly flat at the same time I've had games that seem to just drag on um to no end because we cannot land that final blow um and he just keep on doing the same thing over and over and over um until hopefully something or someone will make a mistake and you'll land a blow so in terms of being hit or miss this game is right up there for me and generally speaking nowadays I want games that are going to be uh hitting all of the time I don't want to take a gamble if a game is going to be good or not because you know I've only got so much time and I've got so many games in my collection that I want games that are going to be you know bankers and going to always guarantee me um fun so I think some people are going to like this one I think some people are going to struggle to find the game in it um I'm somewhere between the two there um I do see its upside but I also see it downside and again I want all my games to always be on the upside so this one hasn't quite made the cut for that reason um if anything I suppose people are going to understand how this works they're also going to like the fact that it's comes in such a small little wallet so it's good it's a good little portable game that you can take on holiday with you or just shove in your pocket and just smash out a game anywhere really but bear in
mind that it can be a throwaway game and it can be frustrating at times the game just drags on to no end so this one I probably give it a five out of 10 um you know if I've had a really good game of it that might slightly change to slightly above or slightly I've had a bad game but I'm going to average it out at around a five out of 10 for Kiri the jewel so there we have it that concludes the video five games here that didn't quite land for me of course some closer than others you know Anor a big no no um less boring Caesar and Cleopatra some good aspects some aspects I'm not too keen on um kir ey very hit or miss and Manila simply being replaced by another game but I hopefully you've enjoyed the video and found value in it if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye