Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 72: Kathryn Hymes on Games about Language

Transcript 43:39

hey gamer's quick add break as you probably know by now the beyond solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations and that is a project that i'm super excited about because i believe that learning through play is the best way to do it and the clgs is making it happen in college classrooms and hopefully high school ones part of that initiative is a games press if you want to back their first successful kickstarter project pre-orders for monumental consequence by dr mary beth looney are open now and keep an eye out for rising waters designed by dr scout bloom this is an upcoming game about the mississippi flood of 1927 one of the worst natural disasters in american history and i will be interviewing dr bloom about it on this podcast in the coming weeks thanks so much and let's get started with the show hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitary and i'm here in the pot with a very special guest katherine hines she is one half of thorny games how you doing katherine i'm doing great thank you so much for having me liz oh it's super great to have you on so why don't you give us just a basic rundown of thorny games and what and what y'all do yeah so thorny games is a game studio uh that i helped run with my partner hakan celola and we make uh storytelling games um and uh the special twist i think on a lot of the games that we have is that they're games about language they use language

to offer a different lens on how to say interesting things about people their relationship to their own identities to each other to the broader culture there's so much good stuff you can dig around in with language so um we we love story games indie rpg is usually the scene that we find ourselves in um but separate from that we're big board gamers uh digital gamers all of that larpers i have to say larpers that's that's very important because we are prize libraries as well i 100 i'm 100 in favor of that um so uh did you have an interesting language and then in gaming or did these things sort of co-develop for you yeah definitely i'd say i'm uh personally just a playful person i've always been playful and like you know what a game is formally or not it's just i'm someone that hopefully doesn't take myself too seriously and i would always kind of look for the play in in stuff that i do but but my uh interest in language goes goes away back as well and i loved tinkering with languages as a kid uh and uh my i'm guessing that that that might be similar to your background based on some of the things we talked about before this recording started but i i had um i could just lose myself in grammars uh i remember i'd asked for like a danish grammar and like an amharic grammar when i was young and eventually that led to studying linguistics and needing to find

a way to make a career in the world and so i became a computational linguist so someone who does language but also uh enough computer science that you can kind of overlap the two uh and build stuff so that computers can do interesting things with human language so that started first uh and then my world as a gamer developed just uh as gaming became uh you know an all-consuming hobby and so naturally the two had to collide at some point i feel that actually you know i'm also super into the fact that you are into computer computers and language i know that khan is a cryptographer is that correct did i read that right yeah by training yes oh my gosh it's so cool so i approach languages as sort of a tool to get history out if that makes sense but when you see i think language as code or as something to crack um how does that impact your language learning do you spend time a lot of time with specific languages do you like to check out different languages and just kind of poke at how they work you know how does how does study of a language go when you're looking at it from that perspective it's interesting yeah the i'd say you know i have two different answers for this because there's the perspective of what what is uh like the computational study of language and in in that in that world you are often asking questions that are less about like the human process of of

understanding a producing language but more how you can replicate that in a way that is computationally feasible how can we make it so that computers can do what we do effortlessly uh and uh it turns out that what we do is really sophisticated and uh and it's really hard to do the computers are getting much much better at it generating speech um understanding it and navigating it um yeah and it's all happening now but but i think that there's also another uh interesting sort of history bit when it comes to let's say machine translation uh in general where like that we're all used to using google translate or something like it uh and you know you click a button you get from english to russian but some of the uh earliest let's say conceptions or motivations and uh in thinking about that problem we're actually to think about it like it was some kind of code like what how would you approach the problem differently knowing full well that english and russian uh are separate languages that have their own histories but if you pretended that english say we're just a mangled version of russian uh what sources or tooling could you use from say cryptography or signal processing or statistics or something like it to try and get out meaning and i you know the field left that that model pretty quickly but it was a sort of a motivating question kind of back in the day when uh when that was a very salient concern for people um but when it comes to my own language learning uh there's just it there is

sort of this joy of understanding um and i think that like you can find that same joy in cracking a code but for me it's just this it's this mental puzzle of being able to put together a grammar and enough tools that i can feel functional and like creep into uh different kinds of conversation and it may start off with me just like oh i'm gonna like try and put a little playful toy picture in my own head of what italian looks like and then maybe challenge myself to try and read something in hungarian uh but uh you know that only gets you so far and i've done that especially as a linguist you end up playing a lot with little models of language but it's such a different thing when you try to like deeply gain fluency in something um and uh it uh i i've had to do a lot of reflection on like just the the manpower and hours it takes to truly like immerse yourself as an adult to fight for that second language fluency and ultimately i believe you you really just need to be surrounded by it um yeah but when you get there it's so great that is super interesting it's super easy to hear this from youtube because so i don't work for them anymore but i spent a lot of time freelancing for the coptic scriptorium project uh where i spent a lot of my time teaching a computer basically how to read coptic good so you know you parse parts of words you give them grammatical labels i spent a bunch of time like drawing arrows between parts of sentences that were supposed to like work together and

it was so interesting to watch the parser get smarter the more input it had like it still couldn't replace a human reader but it was like the more input it got the better it got at recognizing patterns like catching things that it had not caught before it was a super fascinating thing that said i always warn my students like do not use google translate for latin one i will catch you because it will come off wrong and two it's an ethical problem but uh yeah it's really interesting how much we i mean computers are amazing and they're still not us yeah um yeah and i think that actually that that's a deeper there's a deeper philosophical question there too just about language as a as a tool um and where um you know as computers become more fluent in being able to use it and you know maybe there will be a day uh who knows how soon or how far it'll be when uh you know it won't be possible to know whether or not google translate was involved in the latin translation or whatever it may be just because it's that good and there really are some amazing models out there that are generating language that um that feel you know impressively human and it makes me think about just whether or not there's going to be this kind of crisis of self or identity around what it means to be language speaking beings and when we have so much of our own culture uh and

again identity markers that are reflected in our language when maybe a lot of our actual speaking is done with non-humans how how that all net out or maybe everyone will be fine and we'll have other things to worry about but that's my that's my shower thoughts uh kind of rumination it's like the true feature of those comedy writings that are like i ran all the olive garden commercials through a bot and this is what came out yes so um i'm really fascinated too by how you can express linguistic concepts through games so thorny games has come up with three very different approaches to language through gaming from what i understand um do you want to go over the three games that y'all have made and like what they were trying to communicate in short yeah definitely i should say that there are more games that we have but these are let's say the three big releases um that um that we have yeah so we have a a game called dialect uh and dialect is a game about telling the story of an isolated community uh through uh its beginning rise and fall in some sense or or you know the the end of its isolation and you do so by building up uh dialects that's particular to the people that you're creating and uh what is interesting is that the language that you end up creating at the table with others becomes this reflection of

who the people that you're playing are what happens to them and how they change as the community changes and then the language also becomes a little kind of trinket and takeaway that uh you know are something that you share just with the people that you've co-created it with and so that's a game that's kind of really exploring a couple of ideas in language uh you wanted the whole thing is somewhat of a love letter to sociolinguistics in the sense of like exploring the idea of language as a reflection of identity and community and um you know your use of it reflecting on you and you know the words that are particular to a particular group of people that share some common circumstances in space and language history and then i it also is uh talking about the way that language can change so one of the things that it does is it uses uh these this card-based mechanism to um have people think about the ways that words truly do often change in terms of the the big trends the idea of meetings becoming more specific or you know more uh more generalized or other examples that you can find these are card based prompts that the people can experience and that gain deeper meaning when you play it especially if you created the original word you see how it becomes something new uh and then it also is a a way to talk about let's say uh language uh endangerments

and and uh just language death which is a thing that is happening on a whole new scale now in the world and uh you know is um a consequence of many things globalization uh uh power structures uh you know what have you so much um and uh but what it means is just that the the world is becoming less diverse linguistically uh and that is a a huge loss in terms of uh you know what are uh you know something that's deeply important for for human culture and uh and that i think uh is something that the game in and of itself is um almost uh an accompaniment to different kinds of commissioned work that that it comes with that we have a set of backdrops that the game is shipped with which are settings written by other people to help explore maybe their own point of view on uh language in a particular kind of community but also a chapter about language revitalization written by a linguist and activist who has been deep in his career thinking about how to how to help languages be more sustaining so that's one of them that's dialects we can do an episode about each of these we keep going uh then there's a game called sign and uh sign is uh about uh or it's inspired by a story that is a true one uh which is

the the history behind nicaraguan sign language nicaraguan sign language is a language that was created by a deaf children in nicaragua in the 70s and 80s and is a living language today uh and uh that is uh a great example of what a language born in modern times which is a fascinating thing but also just a language that i was born from children who uh eventually it sort of made its way to becoming then the nationally recognized sign language within the country uh and there is a a lot of amazing things to think about about uh just that history that story and and and what it means and how that seed of language creation and the need to communicate is in each of us and uh and also just particular to to the people that created that language so um sign is a live-action game uh that uh helps to uh let's say or or is in part inspired by that story and that um we uh has really led us to do a lot of interesting let's say research and collaboration on our own when it comes to thinking about nicaraguan sign language specifically we've worked with a charity that's focused on promoting sign language in nicaragua and my partner hakan has had the uh experience of being able to go with them into the field a few times um and so part of the that game is that it's uh physical uh proceeds that we get

uh from uh selling the physical game are donated uh to this charity uh and to support sign language education in nicaragua so that is sign um and then the third game is called xeno language uh which is inspired by what we call the soulful sci-fi genre uh but primarily uh amazing media like story of your life which is a short story that the movie arrival uh was based on uh and uh also let's say older book and movie combo contact uh but this idea of uh you know thinking deeply about our relationship to uh life beyond us uh and especially how that may be reflected in language so this is a game where you play a as one of a group of scientists who are called to make contact and unders and communicate with them with alien visitors and um as you begin to try and make sense of uh a message uh you begin to see your own life and and relationships differently uh and so it uh it's a great uh um game for us where we've gotten to explore lots of fun and different language mechanics for thinking about how to represent uh language especially uh this alien language and uh the the way that

that is manifested in the game is we uh have a custom built channeling board uh you know maybe people are more familiar with ouija as a term but you know it is a channeling board where people collectively touch and uh uh let a planchette like lens travel over um alien symbols that then they are left to uh think about and i think that there's some interesting there's a couple interesting linguistic concepts there um one around just uh uh meaning and how we derive meaning from different kinds of symbols and different kinds of meaning that we can ascribe to different things and then uh also just translation and what what translation means and and what is found in loss i guess in translation uh so those are those are the three oh my gosh she's also amazing so i think my primary question as i was looking over all of these how do you balance languages are very complex there's a lot to talk about if you're talking about a language you know i've been studying latin for more than half my life now i still suck at land sometimes so how do you combine i guess the complexities of language with the simplicity that you need to make a game that anybody is able to pick up and play like how do you decide what goes in how do you kind of simplify aspects of language so that players who

maybe have no idea what's going on especially if you're you know you're working with something that is essentially simulating an alien language experience you know how do you do that without overdoing it it's a great question and and in one like i'd say so all these games are meant to be i mean they're entirely meant for people who want to have fun and uh it's they're they're fun games they stand on their own um they're meant to be experiences that you seek out because you're looking for you know an experience that you would get from a game which is a different a different type of experience but it's not an exercise in education and that is a great thing to do you know like there are many fine educational games but um these uh these games have been used in the classroom but but their main purpose is to be a deeply generative of story and the thing is is that language is that way too uh language is deeply generative story and so one of the ways that we kind of hold ourselves to the right degree of complexity and simplicity is that we design all of our games to be language independent to some sense in the sense that um with a couple of exceptions uh that are you know easily chopped off say from the rules uh or or separated uh you you can and people regularly do play all of these games in whatever language is most natural to them uh and uh all you need is to translate the rules or to have someone who can you know translate the the the materials to be able to have the same full experience

um and that's because these games are exploring or they're designed to help explore some of these broader concepts that are true of many languages about the way that identity is reflected in language and how languages change over time and some of the shared components that people can build on without becoming overly technical and i think that sometimes it's actually it's amazing to look underneath uh and marvel at how technical uh language is and and how technically accomplished we are to be able to do it i think it's like you take a phonetics class or a phonology class to me that always does it even more than grammar and because like you can kind of write grammar down and get roles for it and i think people are used to that but when you actually realize all of this computation that you are that a brain is doing constantly as a speaker in a dialect or you know in uh whatever is uh you know the the speech that you're presenting at any point in time you are doing so many minor things that you are unaware of uh and uh it uh and it's amazing to get to to let's say marvel at that detail but also not to get lost in it and to realize that there are these broader concepts that are true about language that you can still marvel and think at and so we try and hold ourselves to that higher level and and oftentimes i think that that higher level has uh um has a lot of overlap with just uh

storytelling and you know the idea of language as being this reflection of people changing uh you know as as people change culture changes so toot is the language it's a give and take uh and and you see that in the way that the stories play out especially in a game like like dialect that's really interesting i have so many questions i could ask about this but i think i'm gonna take it to you so we're talking about you know storytelling and language change and culture um although these are independent although these are language independent games that really anyone could play um a lot of them especially i would say sign and dialect seem to have their roots in real cultural situations and issues and i know that language i think it's a very personal thing for a lot of people especially a language is dying and that people are trying to save so how are you i guess sensitive to the cultural realities of what language can do and mean for people uh while also communicating as naturally as possible you know um what a culture shift and language would feel like to people who don't necessarily think about it yeah this is a an important question and one that we've tried to spend a lot of time on um i mean one of the things that we do uh in dialect is talk about it like the game is meant to be a way to bring attention in part to the fact that this is something that happens in the world and that a lot of people aren't aware of um

and uh there's some uh so there's bringing attention to it there's also making sure that that the right people's voices are also represented in the game itself um so we we write backdrops that come from us as a game studio that are meant to illustrate the process of language change which is something that happens all the time in many different contexts and isn't just about uh let's say language death um but we write at least the core backdrops to be more about this kind of language change so we offer um one where people will play out the history of a martian outpost and what that means you know developing a dialect of mars or developing uh thieves can't you know your thieves that are working together and like have a secret language or you're a set of let's say like wally-like machines that are uh uh you know fulfilling their last mission on earth uh but you know as they've been left uh but there are like real perspectives in the world that we wanted to make sure were at least represented in just the way that that uh these backdrops could look to people and so we commissioned uh different people uh to actually write their own uh and uh and and there's a lot that's available um and they aren't just around uh they're varied they come from people with with different language backgrounds we have some great work by uh gosh um yeah so many activists linguists

and and game designers that are a part of it um i think what comes with maybe 12 extra backdrops um and and uh you know i think even just the act of reading these can give people different perspective um they're designed to at least be written from the point of view of uh you know a particular person who is representing a particular language community in some sense or you know is offering their perspective there but but it's just a different perspective that isn't ours which we felt like was both an important point uh to to make for the subject but but also more broadly um something that um that would make for a a better experience holistically just with the with the game itself um and then also the game comes with uh like we said sort of an actual chapter and material by an active linguist who is thinking about language revitalization doing more than just thinking about it but like living it doing projects actually has sort of calls to action about what that means um and i i i would hope that you know in there there are so many uh hard questions and trying to represent you know a game that that is that is thinking about topics that on one hand are sort of like you know language change happens all the time and i don't speak the same way with my high school friends that i did then but on the other hand as is actual you know terms of you know language diversity uh that is waning in the world and so um i think that i you

know the as a product that at least is trying to to navigate those two things uh in in a way that uh is elevating voices of different people who can represent themselves certainly better than than we would ever be able to nice and i also think about this i guess as a language teacher you know i i try not to force um output of language for my students before they're ready because i'm trying not to stress them out i want them to interact with latin because they feel like it's a language that they know that they have some ownership of um how do you i guess encourage participation and communication from players who might be a little bit shy or reticent in these games i that's something i always wonder about especially with with tabletop role-playing games i mean i know they're somewhat self-selecting right but anybody you know would hopefully be able to enjoy them um but you can't just sit there and like let the action flow by you have to interact so how do you kind of coax that from players as best you can yeah um a couple things one is um one i think like we spent a lot of time just in the presentation of the book to try and make it uh a real experience that you could do as your first rpg and uh and for a lot of people that that actually have played it it was it's an amazing thing to see that and i think that part of it is that it's about um you know as we've heard from from fans and players like uh if you're drawn in by the subject material of language and

this is sort of the push to finally get you to try a storytelling type game and this becomes your first experience and you know all of the joys and awkwardness of uh improv and and doing that kind of creation on the spot as an adult uh so the book comes with uh just really some mottos to think about um that are that are meant to facilitate people um gaining some self-confidence in their ideas making space for each other and realizing that fundamentally like this is collaborative storytelling so you need and want everyone at the table to participate in order for it to be the like the experience that it's intended so the experience you signed up for um the game also very explicitly has a facilitator which is interesting because it's a gm-less game uh and uh it uh but we we did this intentionally and i think that uh we do it with all of our games have a facilitator even though they're all gm-less um in the sense that well sign is a little different anyway but the uh um uh we like gm list games i should say but all of them will have facilitators because when you have someone that you've named to a special role to help host the game then you can encourage them to think about what are things they can do to make space for people who are new at this are are trying to find their footing and and inevitably they'll

be amazing at it it's just that you really need to to kind of call and kind of give someone the title uh so that they feel the responsibility and just uh the power to realize that they are going to be the host for this uh gathering and so it's up to them to make sure that that other people are welcome the other thing i will say too is just that some of our games very explicitly mechanize the use of certain particular kinds of words um as a way to practice and really just like breathe life into words within contexts so in dialect when you create a new word say or a new piece of language part of the term structure is then to see that played out in a scene and it's an utterly necessary part because it actually makes the language feel real and lived in and then it will come up again and again on its own even if we're even unprompted right even though that isn't mechanized um but it happens consistently are these games meant to be played once or multiple times yeah um multiple times uh they're replayable certainly like uh i um sign has uh i mean they're different in that sign is one where you are playing through a similar synop scenario each time but in dialect um there you have wildly wildly different uh scenarios that are you know uh provided in the book the book also comes with a scenario writing uh chapter so it can help people write

their own we've heard of so many awesome ones i think my favorites are like the book actually has been translated now or the game has been translated in in a handful of languages and it's so it's so cool to see sort of like the fan uh backdrops that are being written by uh let's say a gaming community out of korea or italy uh that have their own take on what they feel like is an interesting isolation to draw from so um yeah they're all one shots though i should say and that uh it's designed to be played in a in a single session uh you know different people have different styles and how they like to play one shot sometimes i have like two good hours of storytelling in me and then i i'm done and so i break out a lot of one shots into multiple sessions these days that makes sense so i'm assuming you've played your own games a lot what was the most what are give me you know one or more if you've got more really memorable moment when playing or testing your game that really brought it to life this is a hard question i don't know if i actually have a good answer for you i i have played them and seen them played so many different times but i have so much the brain on at that at that time of being a designer that it uh it can be really difficult to actually uh to separate it and more than anything actually some of the best things are are play reports that come past me um because then at least like i wasn't there it happened and uh and then i can just kind of get the fruits of it but but i don't actually have a pity single answer for that

no so you get to make all the magic and you don't get to fully i think that's the curse of making things it's just that you don't actually get to enjoy any of what like it's like dialect or like some of these games are sort of like okay i mean i would have loved yeah i can never have the the same relationship to these games as a player um i i think that that's true of anyone that like that that makes something it's like you just can't you can't enjoy it the same way or i shouldn't speak for everyone i certainly can't enjoy it yeah i mean it makes sense i've never met an author who like reads their own books for fun or anything like that yeah um so you you've chosen a couple of different things to express about language through games so far um do you have any upcoming concepts that you would really like to encapsulate in a game and are there any that you think might be so challenging that you're not sure that you could do it oh awesome question yeah uh um yeah i've been i've been thinking about this um the uh you know so we we've worked on a i'm really interested a couple of things that come to mind um uh separate from any of the games we've talked about um i'm really interested in in games as a format uh to rethink how you do lots of kind of coordination for people because really like a game is a rule system that allows people to like take concerted actions together collaboration and scale that and we had a really um

amazing collaboration uh that lasted for more than a year with a set of um uh universities and support groups and game designers that were all designing uh games specifically for and with people with aphasia aphasia is a language loss usually due to some kind of brain injury often stroke and uh and and you know they're um it's very difficult to get adequate care after you know when aphasia becomes a chronic condition and uh many people with aphasia report this and so um there was initiative that was started later funded by an academic grant to see about making games together um uh with them you know again people with aphasia and support groups uh speech language pathologists and real game designers to see if um if you can kind of mechanize some of the basic principles of speech therapy so that people can do let's say their own uh kinds of gainful or playful uh therapy without the need of a clinician to be present so at home like within the situation that they live in and we made some games collectively together and later also published an academic article about the co-design process some of these games are now being actively played in aphasia support groups and it was uh an amazing uh experience all around um just a for this kind of collaboration to work uh and i would love the idea of thinking about

how to you know like how how something like that can be continued like what are the next steps in terms of um let's say playful medicine when it comes to speech language therapy um you know to really become uh you know to to walk the path of uh of a let's say medical tool like you you're talking about clinical trials at that point to see whether or not uh you know this uh gameful intervention is something that uh you know is actually causing measurable impact for people or what what what you can measure from uh from people who are playing these things but i think that just that concept of you know uh playful bass here with the like a language community that has a need and also has a seat at the table designing it and then um uh you know active therapists and scientists who are thinking about uh you know how to best treat this condition all coming together to make something is really powerful love to see that kind of repeated in different ways and to think about um what that could look like for other kinds of maybe you know speech disorders or or you know um again language communities or needs uh so there's that um that might also be the same answer to those like what's impossible though i don't know so um but but in general i'd also really i'd be really curious to to make more games about uh like just exploring the idea of um of machine language and like machines actively becoming competent language

speakers and so much so that like within our lifetimes i'm certain that we'll probably be talking to things and not be able to judge their humanity based on their ability to uh to speak uh or to produce language you know and so having fluent conversations with machines what that looks like and how that changes us um it's gonna be fascinating am i looking forward to or dreading the day when the phone bought when i call customer service can actually yeah and i'm sure there's gonna be good and bad like like everything um has some of your work ever made you nervous i mean you are kind of on that edge of you know you're looking at it's not just computational linguistics at this point but also maybe kind of pushing into a.i and you know sentience in a machine in some way right because we understand language i think is like the ultimate sign of of really like being conscious and being aware um have you ever kind of freaked yourself out with the work that you're doing or do you do you trust in our technological future i'm i'm regularly let's say uh i i have like a whole suite of emotions not so much in like the the games work that i do but yes just in seeing like the way that like uh that technology is progressing uh like uh you know robotics things like it yeah like so every day there is like uh i am in awe and in crisis constantly

around some of those uh some of those feelings and then other other times i'm just living my life you know so but you know you get a glimpse of certain things and sometimes you're like pulled into the abyss and other times you're like oh what what amazing things humans are so that actually seems to one of their questions so my students i think would love it if google translate were better um but it also kind of leads to the question of if computers were able to solve all of our translation problems what value would there be to learning language and i have my own answers for this but i want yours yeah that's interesting actually like one of the things i would even like pull on even now is that there is such popularity in people learning languages even just in this moment and over the pandemic and i mean you can argue really that it's already at a point where people can use google translate to like make their way into the world to do so many things and yet like language learning is something that people actively want to do and young people i know a ton of people like you know duolingo is a is a huge you know powerful like uh you know force in in language learning and you know people can have their own feelings about like what is the best way to learn a language but like there's interest and active interest right now um by so many people so i feel like it um you know i think in the same way that uh you know you can get a player piano to play chopin or something uh you know but like no one's uh you know but but like people are musicians and we want to see

we want to talk to humans see them do it uh we want to experience language and culture i think we intuitively see that there's like a deep part of understanding uh about you know uh what it means to come from a different place in the world in a perspective and a cultural tradition that is reflected by by learning a language deeply um it's like a basic desire that i think a lot of us have for all of us you know to some degree maybe all of us have so nice all right what's yours i want to hear i don't hear your answer so for me i think partially i feel like a different person when i'm working in different languages if that makes sense like the way that you can express thoughts by actually understanding a language as opposed to just translating it to the only one you know um i think it changes how literature feels um you know i'd read the alien in english many times before i learned how to read attic greek but probably the closest thing to an actual religious experience was reading it in greek because i was able to understand why it was so beautiful as opposed to just picking up the content does that make sense yeah um one thing's actually like it's more of my hobby person i have been called a content creator because i don't think that language exists to fill space it exists to me meaning and so i think that having access to as much language as possible um and i think it helps you write your own stories to yourself about your life i mean that's how we encode our own memories right but it also helps you receive story from others whether it's written or spoken and i think that being able to appreciate why something is beautiful or

when something is complex or like one word choice over another you know there's lots of words in english that can mean good but like what's there's a difference between amazing excellent that's optimal oh wonderful you know i mean these things all have a different tone and i think that that's something that i i maybe maybe ai will surprise me one day right but knowing the difference between even though something like how bless your heart oh bless your heart you know like those tonal differences that come from really knowing a language and really using it to communicate as opposed to as a blunt force object to um i think it changes the vibe enough that it's worth spending time in other languages as much as you can yeah as a fellow language lover i mean i i i fully agree um yeah everyone should learn languages yes and everybody should play games about them so where can we find you online um oh beautiful segue um uh we're at thornygames.com um and usually uh i think our we pick and choose social media places to be but but right now we're on instagram excellent uh i'll put all that in the show notes by the way everyone uh as you all know i can be found anywhere as uh beyond solitaire online so come and come hit me up but catherine thank you so much for coming on the show it's been so wonderful to have you this has been awesome thank you so much for having me all right everybody out there like

subscribe comment leave questions and most of all happy gaming

you

Progress saved