Is There Shame in a Tie Game? | TABLEscraps #57
Transcript
today's topic has no clear winner is that okay welcome to table scraps short discussions about board card and tabletop gaming submitted by the viewing audience and discussed with the viewing audience hey there everybody and welcome back to another episode of table scraps the show recorded with the live YouTube chat audience where we discuss a topic about board games tabletop games card games whatever the game gaming experience the gaming lifestyle we chat together about a topic that a viewer has submitted today's question comes from viewer Patrick Doss who talks about ties and he asks are they always cool more specifically when playing a competitive game how do we feel when we end up with a tie but the game has no tie breaker or does it change one's in-game strategy when certain game elements such as various resources or gaming tokens are used as a potential art alternative wind condition in breaking a tie what are some of the most unusual ways that games break ties and how many tiebreakers should a game provide to be an adequate method of deciding who ultimately wins or he continues are ties a welcomed endgame result are there just some games that sure a tie is acceptable and other games where it is not personally I loathe them I cannot stand allow owing a tie in a game to me
I mean the the whole purpose of a game is to have an activity with a set of rules and an objective to achieve and you you'll have a winner and by its nature to me that that excludes the ability to really have a tie uh you you got to have someone win right so uh first of all the the question was asked of how many different alternative win conditions should there be that if you tie on one you go to the next if you tie on that you go to the next if you tie on that so on and so forth until a winner can ultimately be determined my personal answer is as many as it takes to get to a definitive winner oh boy howdy there there's to me there is nothing quite as discouraging as getting through a game you know one to three hours or so playing this game getting to the end of it and you have a tie and so it's like oh okay well whoever had the most of this resource you know they win then okay then you go oh we're tied on that too well Whoever has the most money wins oh we're tied on that uh what's next oh well then just whoever you you you share the victory but we we put in all of this this this this work into it all this cunning strategy and planning and execution of our plans and and then we we went and we had all these secondary resources and you're telling me after all of those things we still have to share the victory ah kastal the other part of the question was was that uh do you think that changes the way that you
play or whatever when you know that a certain resource might be a secondary wind condition to break ties uh my answer to that in my experience is absolutely uh that does uh there have been many many games that I I have uh taught um more than I like to admit where I have neglected um just through an oversight of my my own part to totally forgot to read what the tiebreakers are so those games in nely when they end in a tie uh my fellow players look at me with a scowling expression and say well what's the typ breaker then Chaz and then I got to pull up the rule book and say oh Whoever has the the the most of these little tokens left that they've accumulated and everyone says well if we had known that we would have accumulated those little tokens wouldn't we have and so I've learned to um when introducing a game to someone always always make sure that before you start playing to mention what the tiebreakers are because yes that will definitely definitely change the way that players uh play the game and I think that's for the best um because it's just more information that they'll have at their disposal gazena joins us to say I entirely neutral on tiebreakers they can be neat but often it distorts the scoring making one thing that scores points points more valuable than other things sure I can see that if you have victory points and then you have like rhubarb tokens that everyone's
been collecting and the rhubarb tokens are there to do nothing more in the game than to you know generate uh you know rhubarb preserves uh resources and then if those rhubarb tokens are the tiebreaker well it's like it's like okay we had dollars that we were using to figure out our winner and then instead of using pennies to determine the tiebreaker it can feel like instead of dollars now we're looking at you know breakfast spoons and whoever has the most breakfast spoons now is the tiebreaker and I need to really clean off my desk but I would win the game um if the breakfast spoons were the tiebreaker and I think that's really what's important here is knowing for me being able to justify to myself that I would still in some way be a winner Kabuki kid who joins us to say the best tiebreaker ever is the one for Arboretum where the Tide players are to both plant trees and then revisit them in a few years to see which ones grew the tallest let's say that when you're learning a game that you're going to take everything in the rule book verbatim that would indeed be one of the most awesome tie Breakers uh that I could ever not only because it's so elaborate but it definitely would get the people that are squabbling over the tie like myself included it would get them up and away from the table and out of your hair off planting trees so the rest of you who aren't that maniacal about tiebreakers can just get on with another game so you're right Kabuki that may actually be a brilliant tiebreaker
because it gets anyone who he gets any of those people that get too focused on tiebreakers and winning get gets them just out of your out of your life for a little bit so you can play something else so you're right that might have some Merit to it Kabuki also mentions at the same time oh returning to the uh point of the best tiebreaker ever at the same time having different levels of tiebreakers helps avoid ending still in a tie so I don't hate them they are conditional o h it is interesting that they it could be that certain games perhaps need them more than others and perhaps some games by their nature then uh it's more forgiving to have multiple tip Breakers I makes me just makes me curious uh what are I I wonder if this is even something that was mentioned in the original question uh you know when it comes to games that have a lot of TI Breakers which game out there have we experence the most conditional tiebreakers in I'd have to break out some Rule books I can't remember off the top of my head but I have seen some that have like four maybe five layers deep and um you know it always kind of RA makes me raise my eyebrow when I'm seeing that it's like whoa what what are we in for with this game let's continue on to the next uh statement by Stephen who says I'm good with one tiebreaker if it's still a tie I'm fine with it having to have like two to three tiebreakers gets annoying another way to put this is do you think that if a game does require two of the three tiebreakers do you think that that
is inherent of a flaw in the game design do you think that Games should be designed in such a way where multiple tiebreakers aren't needed and if multiple tiebreakers are needed go back to the drawing board the game should be designed in such a way that that's not necessary uh Stephen does take the time to mention that yes unless it is a knife fight Knife Fight tiebreakers are always worth it I'm not going to comment on that one but instead I'm going to move on uh a bit cautiously Mike Jones no really uh mentions as someone who has just spent the last weekend almost going horse ties just aren't hype really close games are the best though win or lose that that is that is true does a tiebreaker allow a game to be more tense than uh could tie Breakers be used to increase the game's tension by making the overall win condition uh a lot easier to tie in and then by going to these secondary tie Breakers could that actually be a way to artificially um increase the game's tension is that something that perhaps we need to become aware of are we just sheep that are playing along to big cardboard Peter joins us to say it depends on the game I don't mind ties in some games but others it's very unsatisfactory okay follow-up question for you then Peter and anyone who wants a post is there certain genre
or you know mechanism of you know type of game uh that it is like card games versus uh co-ops or you know a co-op a tie in a co-op game I would think you know would be absolutely terrible if it comes down to your team versus the game and you can't determine between you and the game which one won I just I couldn't see that even happening uh but other games you know might be a little more acceptable so is it kind of genre by genre and if so which genres are the ones that it's more or less acceptable to have a tie in Kabuki also says the worst is when you are turn away from the end and the teacher Springs on everyone oh by the way the most cards in your hand are the tiebreaker I should have mentioned that what what my apologies to you I embellished on that a little bit you could have told us sooner H as someone who has been in the position of the teacher in that scenario multiple times yeah I I totally agree with you Kabuki that is the absolute worst again when you're teaching a game be sure to mention what the victory condition and the tiebreakers are before you start the game because there's nothing worse than being halfway through and having to break out uh the old rule book to say oh yeah by the way you should be collecting those rhubarb tokens uh they're going to be important all right let's continue down uh to gazena who mentions for competitive games it depends on the
tournament structure for a league there should be ties since that's a part of how you're measuring skill for single elimination tie breaks are required oh there we go there's there's a very good aspect of this yeah the gaming environment you know if it's casual game I can totally see you know who cares but yeah Tournament level of course yeah you're going to by the nature of the tournament you're going to have to have a tiebreaker and some sort of elimination uh you can't be saying well we're going to have these two people play a fourth game together because the first three all ended in ties sorry everybody uh let's go get sandwiches uh because they don't sell sandwiches there so no one's going to have anything to eat for lunch so yeah I totally totally agree uh with that that's an aspect of this I hadn't thought of it's the gaming environment too definitely makes makes that important and um any game then that you potentially would want to play in a tournament setting you're going to want to make sure has some sort of of tiebreaker because again we're all out of sandwiches Peter mentions anyone see the LSU t game seven overtimes I think we'll see some new rules soon to avoid that in the future uh wow seven overtimes okay well this goes back to the uh the previous question uh of uh do multiple tiebreakers just make a game uh more more tense more interesting funner to watch and participate in you know seven overtimes you know uh George Carlin always he talked about sports he was like I when I watch sports I want
action I want 12 overtimes and a million points on the board so maybe those seven overtimes and stuff you know can actually make the game more exciting to The Spectator instead of being a hindrance unless you didn't get a sandwich and you're hoping the game gets over so you can go get one and you're just waiting to for the end then I could definitely see a bunch of hangry people in the stands foran's question who says when all else fails ties go to the owner of the game oh I I would next time I invite people over to my house and we're playing games that I own I'm gonna try that and I will let you know when um people agree to come over again because I'm sure it would it would be a while uh so but that is an interesting take on it Jeremy mentions uh I like just one extra goal to meet my favorite is heart of crown by japanime games you get to 20 points and if there's a tie well then just go to 30 and then if that isn't a tie and then it ends in a tie if they are still tied I got Tongue Tied reading that answer about ties but I I see what you're saying there um I've seen some other games like that which are kind of interesting I think uh Blitz Bowl you have have to be a certain number of points ahead so even if you reach the the ending score you still have to be winning by a certain amount or the game continues which is kind of interesting I think that that is a really neat way to
um determin ties except you know if you did well the example here that Jeremy gives it could definitely still end in a tie if they tie at 30 which that's no good um and then if you did keep going well the game could go on potentially forever if the people kept tying so as cool as an approach that is I can see there being some fundamental flaws in it so I'm wondering if anyone has experienced that and has experienced and come up with a uh even better um Twist on that because I do love that twist but um it's a Twist that I think needs a little bit of a tweak so let's continue on with what Mike Jones uh has to say to follow up with this saying that 50-50 Solutions are like the clipon they always fail to feel right because they are so low in effort and they're just Mindless I'm I'm wondering how difficult it actually is to come up with a tiebreaker When developing a game you know is it something that you got to come up with right when you are making the game or is it something that more often is added on after the game has been fully developed and you're going through making just the rulebook and determining you know what the the tiebreakers are going to be I would be curious to uh find out more about that maybe one an upcoming convention or something I can ask some designers if I bump into them you know with the approach that they take because that would be interesting to see where in the process that comes into play Kabuki kid also says breaking a tie with something like rock paper scissors is something I love why did we play the game if this is what truly decides the winner it's like that election decided by a die roll that
is true a tiebreaker in which the tiebreaking criteria is nothing to do with what you were just doing the mechanisms in the game and it's just something like rock paper scissor or rolling a diey or whoever is tallest um or who owns the game yeah those can be totally totally uh disappointing uh tiebreakers totally agree gazena also mentions I do wonder if there's a geographic divide on this topic honestly most competitive Sports in the US try to avoid ties I can't think of in the UK that that any that do that outside of elimination tournaments that's a good point um I always think of hockey um when I'm thinking of Ty tiebreaker type things and well by that I mean I never think of hockey but I'm thinking of hockey right now because hockey can end in a tie and hockey is a sport that is a lot more popular you know in Canada and and such and soccer or football um again correct me if I'm wrong but is it possible for soccer to end in a tie um pardon me wants to say it is and if so wow that is so not anti-American but so non-american perspective um you know from from my point of view like I said we want a thousand overtimes and a million points on the board we want a winner um so that's a really good point centia it might have something to do with Geographic and that might be I wonder if we were to look at more games like games developed in Europe versus games
developed in in the states I wonder if we would see a difference in the way the tiebreakers are written very interesting point there let's continue on with a note from jarb who says because I can compete and tie with someone I will I find it funny that people get worked up about that but then I don't get to play sometimes so there there's an instance where the way that tiebreakers are instituted in the game perhaps can even uh you know affect someone's enjoyment or willingness to play that game which is something I had not even thought of again you know the tiebreakers to me always seem like an afterthought but they might be something that can actually uh makes change the games that someone decides to play Trevon also mentions how do we feel about the Ted Alpo tiebreaker Deck with a random tiebreaker used when all other ties fail ooh good question I think the tiebreaker deck thingy moer is an pretty cool idea however in practical application makes me feel like what Kabuki said about well we're just going to like play Rock Paper Scissors or some random elements going to be introduced here what's the point so I be interested to hear what other people think about that uh do we see that as a similar just outside Source nothing to do with the game Ty Breer uh that can actually sour The Experience uh really really good question and we're gonna wrap up here with another comment by jarb who says once I wear a tie no
one liked it green and purple dots but in all seriousness I always lost at this game when I finally shared a victory with someone else it felt amazing and it's so it might depend on context I think that might be actually the best place to stop anyway with this discussion yes I I think it might definitely depend on the context uh um we we touched briefly on whether certain types of games like uh Euro games versus co-ops um or or stuff like that if that can the environment or well if the game mechanism the game genre can affect that and also the the the environment like a tournament or or something else like that so if there's one thing that I know based on the responses I've seen so far is that this topic deserves more conversation so if you are watching this after the show post what you think in the comments below you know all the things that we've touched on about uh genres about mechanism about play environments about what what types of tiebreakers work and how many there should be let me know what you think in the comments below H I would love to hear and see the conversation continued down there and who knows maybe something will be said that will spark another episode on this same topic but in the meantime I want to thank you all for watching and for more board game news reviews commentary countdowns and all sorts of video whatnot content be sure to subscribe I'm Chaz marer from Parise Paradise yeah and I'll talk to you again
soon you know what note for future self edit out all references to to woke because just because and sometimes I just talk to continue hearing the words so that the episode doesn't stall
out like that