Evolution & Expansions board game review
Transcript
I'm admin Wales and this is my board gaming Vlog and today I want to talk about my favorite board game Evolution and the games that have come from that system now when I first uh discovered this hobby um several years ago uh some of the first games that I really got excited about were Dixit and the game Agricola and very quickly these became my two favorite games and it stayed that way for a long long time and in fact I would still rate these as as well essential games like absolutely love the pair of them um and I didn't really think that uh well I had no idea what would ever topple them from the top spot now the reason I loved these games so much Dixit was purely the Artistry of the whole thing the creativity but especially the artwork the beautiful artwork this was a game I could show to people and they would go wow that looks amazing and uh I could play it with anybody um I mean there's all manner of reasons why I love Dixit but the art is is one of the central things there now agria is a different thing agria I love The Logical sort of immersive experience it it this is not a storytelling game and it's not a game that's filled with flavor text but it is a game where I feel like I'm part of a story I'm totally immersed in that whole thing if I want to build fences I need to get wood why do I need fences because I want to have some animals on on my farm why do I need animals because I'm going to need to make some food to feed my family why do
I need a family because I need more workers to work on my farm to increase my yield okay so there's a whole logical sequence of steps that agrica takes you through and you can start off with that family game in agrica um I'll come back to that a little bit later but there's always been this family game in agrica and then a more advanced game where you use a whole load of cards and the game comes alive because these cards can combo in all sorts of different ways so no two games ever quite feel the same although Everything feels very familiar um so that's what I've always loved about agria um and that's stayed with me uh over the years that I've been playing these sort of modern board games now when Evolution turned up I saw it I I I go to Essence Spiel each year I I was aware of this game Evolution and actually I I kind of ignored it I overlooked it um now Evolution I don't know why I did because evolution is a uh a topic that I I'm really interested in I've read a lot of books about Evolution and how it works and and the mechanisms of and the science of it um so as a topic I find it fascinating um I think uh I I had previously looked into an old uh older I think it's a Russian game which was uh called Evolution the Origin of Species which was kind of got again these mixed reactions and the wasn't that great and so I was looking at it thinking well this is an interesting theme but the game doesn't look it doesn't quite catch
my uh my attention so when I saw the new game Evolution and I saw that it was based on that previous game I guess I kind of ignored it on that basis I also knew of Northstar games who makes this new Evolution game um as a party game company they make the game Wits and wages and say anything so I was aware of those games i' I've got the game Gambit 7 which is like the European version of wits and wages um licensed from Northstar games to days of Wonder and I like this game very much I don't think there's anything wrong with Northstar games party games but I did wonder whether they were going to be able to make a strategy game that would appeal to me so I ignored Evolution for some time and then the opportunity came up to pick it up in a trade um and so I thought well you know there I often take a chance if I'm trading these are the times where I can try out a game that I would otherwise not have tried and I'm so glad I did because in that trade I picked up Evolution the base game and evolution flight and uh my eyes were open to the game really it's uh it was an astonishing uh game in evolution each player develops a series of species throughout the game on a player's turn they're given cards which can be used in several different ways they can spend the cards to create new species or to increase the body size or population of an existing species or they can enhance the traits of one of their species and this is the Crux of the game because at the at the end of each round species need to feed in order to survive and food is often scarce added traits might
just allow a species to jump the queue for food at the watering hole or to find food from another source or even to turn carnivore and feed on the species of another player additionally traits can be used to develop defenses against carnivores shells camouflage climbing burrowing and at the end of the game the player whose species at the most food wins it's all the same reasons that I love Agricola okay this game has that total logic to it it makes sense what you're doing it makes thematic sense why these things interact in the way that they do um and there's so many card combinations that every single game and every round of every game feels totally different and you're adapting to the play of the other players it has the appeal of Dix it in that the card artwork is beautiful it doesn't look like any other game this lovely watercolor artwork um that looks like um illustrations from an oldfashioned textbook but the the colors are so vibrant so much love and care and attention has been put into it um and what's happened here is that Northstar games and and and Dominic cerett have honed that system from that original Russian game working you know collaborating with those original designers and creating something um that just works so Beau beautifully now I have over time seen some people turned off by this artwork actually some people just don't like it they find it garish and odd and it doesn't fit with you know
the what other games look like and so um you know it doesn't work for everybody uh and that's true of the game play as well um this is a game where EV practically every game that I play particularly when I'm playing with new players players say well that's it solved you know we found the killer combination we found the combination of cards that you cannot beat you know the that dreaded phrase this game is broken I hear that quite a lot about Evolution and it's not true you know you try and play that exact same strategy on the second game it's not going to work uh evolution is like a tennis match you know you can do that brilliant shot one game but if you try and recreate that shot in your next tennis match it's not going to work because you've got to react to what's sent to you you can't just repeat what you've done previously you're going to miss the ball and that's true Evolution as well um so you know these these killer combinations intelligent carnivores first time we discovered intelligent carnivores in evolution we're like well that's it this game is done you know there's no beating an intelligent Carnival and then you find that you can uh you can beat them in all manner of different ways you can starve them out you can attack them you can team up on them you know um there's loads of stuff that you can do to stop these sort of runaway leads that said it can leave a sour taste in the mouths of of some new players players who go carnivore on their first turn they think well this is how we play the game I'll be the carnivore and then they find there's nothing to eat because everyone else has got defenses they lose their
first turn essentially because they become extinct and they're starting from behind you know they've got a lot of catching up to do the game is brutal uh in that way um and and I've seen that happen fairly frequently players getting shut out of the game um and it's it's a little frustrating that that can happen uh um because it turns people off from the game when if they continued to play it they would find there's so much to explore and actually those times where I've done badly in the game I've tended to find that I can still enjoy the logic you know if my species has been killed off it's been killed off for very good logical thematic reasons and I can enjoy that and the game always gives me something it gives me a pile of cards that I can then use to rebuild okay I'm not going to catch up but I'm still playing the game right up to the end and I can enjoy that process um so there are a couple of things that make me say I wouldn't recommend this game to every player although recent developments within the system have changed my mind to that a little bit um so so that's Evolution the base game now Evolution flight um let's have a look at Evolution flight in evolution flight players have one additional way to use their cards on their turn by discarding two cards they can create a flying species for this they get a unique species board with reduced body size and a flight trait card the flight trait protects them from carnivores but
it also gives them access to an alternate food source which other species can't reach the clifftop this food source is stable it increases each round predictably and if one player is the sole flying creature they will have a banquet to Feast on every single turn however flying creatures expend more energy hence they must eat additional food which is wasted and it doesn't count for victory points to this end each flying species must eat food equal to their body size before they can feed their population the flight expansion also adds several new traits and event cards to the base game so Evolution flight introduces this whole other level to the game so in evolution flight you just waiting for one player to take to the skies and every round there's going to be food added to that Cliff top whether anyone is a flying creature or Not So eventually that Cliff top is going to be full of food if no one's taken to the skies so at some point someone's going to become a bird they're going to start to feed on that Cliff top and if we don't stop them as the other players then they're going to run away with the game so at this point someone's either going to have to become an intelligent carnivore catch that bird and eat it and kill it or someone else is going to be have to become a bird and start to compete with them on the cliff toop so it adds this whole other arms race to the game which is extremely satisfying the new traits in this one work really well um and essentially it's a a fairly simple addition to the base
game uh if you're playing with experienced sort of games players not necessarily people experience with Evolution I would say in their first game you could introduce the G the the flight expansion straight away I in fact I frequently have done without any major problems if you're playing with people who aren't very experienced with modern board games then maybe Evolution isn't a good starting Point anyway although the introduction of a beginners game which I'm coming on to uh has changed that a little bit um but you could start with the base game and then introduce the flight expansion after one or two games I suppose something like that um so you've got that option um now having played Evolution and evolution flight for quite a long time I was quite excited this Autumn to see that there were two new evolution games coming along at the same time so the first one here is evolution the the beginning in evolution the beginning there are no species boards there's no body size being used and the variety of traits in the game is reduced the game also becomes turn-based so when a player turn they add food to the watering hole they gain one new species they draw three cards they play their cards in order to adapt their species they then feed their species and then they score all of this is done before the next player takes their turn a species is represented by a face down card on the table a second card placed in the face down column represents added population and so with the third card and the fourth card and so on players must feed their species as normal or this population is going to be
lost traits are simplified in their effects compared to the base game but they still revolve around carnivores defending against carnivores finding alternate ways of feeding your species and increasing your population so Evolution the beginning in America is a Target exclusive at least for short period but in Europe that's not the case and evolution the beginning is a perfect introduction to this system and in fact it doesn't even have to serve as an introduction this might be all players ever play and that would be absolutely fine it's a fun simple 30-minute card game back and forth quite a bit of take that but still with that sophisticated theme uh and story and beautiful art of the original game it's got fewer traits yeah but that's the thing that makes it accessible the rules of the base game Evolution aren't complicated at all what's complicated is those card combinations and and seeing how they interact and predicting the damage that other players can do to you and that can leave players feeling a little stupid when they haven't spotted um what's coming now you don't get that so much in evolution because you can very quickly learn those traits and know what's likely to happen so it serves as an excellent introduction to the system and it may be as far as anyone ever goes this is a a a simple game for um for people who aren't very familiar with board games or for families this sort of thing albe it it's a fairly aggressive game still there's a lot of attacking and it actually um it's part of a trend you know
recently we've had this Agricola Family Edition released which does exactly the same thing for Agricola um agrica always had a family game in the basic box but this simplifies it further uh and and and now we have this you know this this introductory version or perhaps this is as far as anyone's going to go with agria I love this trend I hope this happens more with with board games because a lot of these complicated games I absolutely love them but I don't play them that often because they take a while and they take a long time to explain and they intimidate people these are the games that I'm going to get to play more frequently uh most likely now the other game that came along alongside Evolution the beginning was Evolution climate now Evolution climate you can either get it as a standalone game which includes all the things so you don't need to have the base game of evolution at all or you can buy it as an expansion to the basic game Evolution as you can see I've got the Standalone game so let's have a little look at what evolution climber adds Evolution climate introduces a climate board which represents the changing temperature our species must survive in when players select cards to manipulate the food supply in the watering hole at the start of each round they also manipulate the temperature based on the hot and cold symbols on the cards as it gets warmer larger species start to lose population and as it gets colder the smaller species will die off the temperature changes also alter the food supply and changes in temperature
can trigger events like wildfires volcanoes or even meteorite showers uh which can change the environment catastrophically new traits are introduced to protect species against the Heat or the cold and existing traits from the EV base game have added effects related to the climate in this version of the game each species can have four traits instead of the base gamees three trait limit which allows greater diversity now what all of this does is makes the game a little bit more complex um and and by no means now is this an introductory game the rules aren't super simple the combinations are extensive and the different ways that you can die are increased so it's perhaps even more brutal than it was before but it is in depth we've got this whole other layer of thematic integration and story in there um no longer can you rely on there being food in that Watering Hole each turn because if the other players Don't Starve you out then the changing temperature might um so now you've got to make sure you've got these alternative food sources from uh migrating or from um you know long neck or or all these different things that you can do to get food food that other people don't have access to the climate uh game is not compatible with the flight expansion that's that's an important Point actually there are probably ways that you can mix the two together but it's not recommended because the balance is lost now Dominic
crapper shets and Northstar games have intended this game as as sort of Tournament level um balance um and I think that's very true of the base game certainly I haven't explored climate enough to know yet um but throwing in you know mixing in expansions always is going to affect the balance um and so hopefully eventually there will be people coming up with nice balanced ways to integrate flight into the climate expansion but as it is you've got two very different ways to expand That Base game and have different experiences I've seen quite a lot of people uh online who are obviously um proponents of intelligent design um you know religious folk um and and and they've they've dismissed the game coming from the opposite Stu somebody who who is as I say firmly entrenched in this idea of evolution and and loves that as a as a something to read about and and study the game actually feels a little odd because what we're doing is essentially intelligent design what we're doing here is playing cards to adapt our species we're playing God here we're changing the temperature we're changing the food we're changing the body size we're adapting the traits on our own species none of this is random um none of this is done through any sort of uh selection that's out of our control and uh I mean this is no problem this is the abstraction that you get in board games if we go back to agrica you know uh there there's lots of things in there that don't make very much thematic sense why if I go and do one job can nobody else do it at the same time um but it works for gameplay purposes so
there's a little bit of suspension of disbelief here um and this is true in evolution climate and and in evolution um there are promo cards uh particularly there's one about darwinian selection which I quite like which means that you play your traits face down so you don't know what the adaptation of your species is going to be you can still adapt the body size and and the population um freely and change the temperature and all the rest of it but the actual traits that go onto your species you can add traits but you don't know what they're going to be um so I guess the game is I've not tried this this this card yet but it's interesting these little promos that come out each new edition of the game and each new version of it always has a bunch of little promos that are released I don't know how easy there to get hold of so some people might not like this because it is essentially exclusive content however it's also generally um user generated content so this is fan-made stuff people are coming up with this stuff emailing the company and they'll produce these beautiful cards that aren't particularly balanced and some of them are quite funny and silly um but but again it just increases the sort of expandability of this game there's even a little expansion promo expansion where you can build a little plant sort of um area along alongside your species and then use that as a food source and other and then try and defend it with your carnivores against other people eating your plants again I haven't tried this yet there's so much to explore here the game is not for everybody I can't say that this is the greatest game ever made um I guess that
game would be something that you know everybody could be involved in but this added sort of uh levels to the game these different versions of the game do give multiple entry points and mean that um you know that there is a a wide audience for this game in some form or other it's brutal it's aggressive this is not normally my sort of game this ATT attacking thing but here it's not tacked on this is this is firmly entrenched in the game play and you can always come back and even the attackers are always vulnerable because everything you do to make yourself stronger usually makes you weaker in some other way it's a game that you can work to Master uh it's a game that you can play at a highly competitive level or you can just enjoy the simple stories that it tells the artwork is phenomenal the production standards are great there's a couple of small uh errors in the evolution climate game which are just starting to arise on the board game geek website so I'm sure we'll have answers to exactly how those things are supposed to work um specifically the one that's been noted over the last couple of days is that there's some wording discrepancies between the card for migration and the rule book but these are minor minor quibbles with something that is of a very high production standard these are some of the most beautiful games that I own in my collection anyway I'll stop raving now so thank you very much for watching I hope you enjoyed this video if you did please watch some of my others on my YouTube channel And subscribe it's Adams boardgame Wales and
on Twitter follow me at boardgame Wales and on boardgame gim adam78 so thank you very much for watching all the best