Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Game BATTLE!!! : Harmonies ... VS Cascadia VS Calico VS Aqua VS Akropolis

Transcript 21:40

I never felt constrained because the other scoring exists sure I can't finish my cards I've given up I'll make the river longer I'll build a mountain I'll throw a few trees in the board this is where it differs from calco cuz Calo at the end you're like well unless I draw the exact piece I am losing points that's true here I can be like well I'll make one of my mountains bigger yeah what would you give us I'm coming down actually I'm fin on Calico and aul you know look that I'm goinging a seven I like the game I don't won't gravitate to it but I think it's a fun I think almost relaxing Style game I'm actually coming in at a five uh and I think I'm going to be the outlier amongst the general public it has a lot of things going for it it is beautiful I just feel like the many games that we've already discussed Calico I'd rather play Cascadia I'd rather play for me a five is not a bad game I I want to be clear for like it's well for you it is but for me it's a mediocre game and that's the word I think that I associate with this is that I feel like it's okay it's fine it's mediocre so many other games of this ilk I would rather

play all right action now I don't normally do these type of videos but after watching the dice Towers review of harmonies I was shook honestly totally shooki now don't get me wrong I absolutely love the dice tower totally no hate on them I just knew I had to come on here and kind of plead my case for harmonies a little bit so if you are unfamiliar with what harmonies is harmonies is a brand new tile placement game um it's kind of more like a disc placement game you actually kind of have little like discs that you will be placing um onto your personal little player board this game is super super super popular right now people are comparing it obviously to other popular tile placement games I think that's very reasonable whenever a game comes out that is very heavy in a certain mechanism it's natural to compare it to other games that are like that so I kind of wanted to make my own video today talking about a handful of games um specifically in the tile placement games or tile placement game mechanism thing um and I wanted to rank them and kind of briefly talk about each one now I do want to make it clear that these five games that I'm going to be talking about today I love each and every one of these each of these games I would absolutely recommend but I am going to go through and rank these on how I personally enjoy them as of right now one of the games that I'm going to be ranking on this list today I actually do not have with me and that one is aqua so we're going to be doing Aqua which I don't have with me Acropolis Cascadia harmonies and

Calico so let's go ahead and dive into this list chat a little bit about each game and where I personally would rank them if you have played some or all of these games that we're going to be talking about today please go ahead and drop a comment below how you personally would rank them and if you think Harmony is living up to the hype so going ahead and starting off this list with number five again I really like this game but when I think about all of the games that I that that are in this particular list one of them has to come in fifth right and for me the one that's going to come in fifth place is aqua so in aqua again I would have the box here but it's actually with Kim currently CU Kim has just been loving that game you have Reef little Reef um tokens that you will be placing out into a grid in front of you now when you have three reefs of the same color that are touching and I think it's like a hexagon you will actually attract that same color of animal and it will actually rest on top of that Reef habitat now if the more animals that you collect once you collect a big grouping of those colored animals then you actually can attract your the large mammals onto those smaller animals so in most tile placement games I feel like you are just simply building out a big Rd in front of you Aqua is interesting

because you are actually incentivized to build up so you'll actually be building up your little tiles a little bit and trying to trying to score the most points what makes it interesting though is that as you are stacking you actually never lose the points that are underneath so again it kind of I keep coming I keep using the word incentivizing you really are incentivized to build in this game because the more you build you basically are just stacking points on top of points on top of points and I really think that's my favorite part about this game and I really wish that more tile there were more tile games that kind of had that mechanism where you really want to stack and build and you just keep getting points there is a game that we're going to be talking about um here in a second that you still has that building mechanism like you are building but you're not incentivized because or you're not as incentivized as you are in this game which I I again that's my favorite part in aqua is how really you just want to be building up your tiles the reason why it is in number five for me is because I have played this game a handful of times now and still I still kind of struggle with the scoring for whatever reason it's not quite as straightforward and simple and streamlined as I personally would have liked it to be there are lots of different ways to score in this game and there's lots of different ways to switch up and change the scoring from game to game so it again has really high replayability because of that but for whatever reason it's still every single time I sit down and play this game I'm

still like okay wait how does this score again and like as I'm playing the game I have to get the rule book to kind of remember how things are scoring so that's the only thing that's kind of pulling it down for me but I mean the Vincent tray artwork is beautiful it is a fun game again it has that building aspect which for me feels kind of separate from a lot of other tile placement games um so yeah so that is why Aqua is number five still a great game but I just wish the scoring would personally be a little bit more clear um for just for for me personally so number four is a game that I actually had the opportunity to play for the very first time fairly recently and as we were playing it I thought to myself okay I really really like this puzzle um and that one is Acropolis unfortunately the box came a little bit damaged so just just ignore that corner of the box here but damag Corner aside this is a great game in Acropolis you will have little they're almost like pla Plaza tile pieces and you are I believe you're building out Rome or Greece yeah you're in the Mediterranean Sea you're at the heart of the Mediterranean so you're the um architect of this Mediterranean Village and you have these Plaza tiles and you are laying them out in front of you and what's interesting is there are different colored plazas there are like there's blue um green red yellow and purple I think those are all the colors of the plazas and then there's the whites and the whites I the whites are like basic they don't really do anything um but what's interesting is each color

Plaza actually scores in a different way so I know like the couple of games that I've played when the red only scores if it's on the outskirts of the village and the Blues score if they're connected with other blues and um the yellows I forget what the yellows do the yellows score I think if they're like not touching any other yellow but what's interesting is that some of the plazas they are that color for example a blue Plaza but they have a star on it so at the end of the game th those will actually help in increase the value of all of your blue plazas so you're going through kind of doing all these puzzles it is similar to Aqua in the sense that you can stack and you can build um onto your other remaining Stacks but when you do that you actually lose everything that you cover up I wish it was more similar to Aqua in the sense that you were incentivized to build up and stack up but because you're as not incentivized to stack you actually have to be a lot more strategic when you do I have to be really strategic about the way that I'm placing my tiles in this game versus Aqua so that's why this one kind of draws me in a little bit more I think it's I don't know I just I really like this game I think it is really great um and I am super excited to continue to dive into this one it's almost hard to say that this next one is in my third spot because the very first time I played this game I thought to myself this is it like this is my favorite tile placement game nothing will ever beat this this is my favorite I love it so much it was in my top 10 games of all time for the long longest

time but unfortunately because I think of something else which we're going to be talking about I think that this game has been pushed out which is so crazy for me to say but whether it's pushed out of my top 10 or not I still love this game and this is Cascadia I'm sure everybody knows about Cascadia um by this point but in case you don't Cascadia is again another tile placement game and you'll be placing tiles out into a grid in front of you and you are trying to create the most um I think it's the most biodiverse ecosystem so You' be placing out these tiles trying to connect regions so you're trying to have you know big mountain ranges and long rivers and big open Plains and while you are going about doing that you also have animal tiles that you are trying to place onto those or animal little animal tokens that you're trying to place onto your tiles what makes the game interesting is every single animal in this game scores in different ways and the base game actually comes with a handful of different scoring um scoring um objectives for each animal so every time you play you can kind of swap it in and out a little bit um but so for example if you're playing you maybe your bears like to be in little small groups and your Salmons like to be in long runs and your birds like to be solitary so they don't like to be touching other birds this is actually one of the very first tile placement games that I played when I got into the Hobby and I remember sitting learning the game and playing it saying wait what you're doing like all these puzzles at the same time time like

I remember that was like mindblowing for me I know cozy game is like a new kind of phrase that everybody is using for games lately but this truly is a cozy game for me I think the reason why it's cozy is because as the game goes on your board just keeps getting bigger and bigger and bigger which means your options just keep getting bigger bigger and bigger so you never feel constricted in this game you never feel like oh there's nothing that I can do there's always that something that you can do it has a really good Bild you just feel like you're constantly building constantly getting more things and constantly getting more points Cascadia is a super approachable game especially for for like people who have never played games before that's primarily what Cascadia is in my Personal Collection it's one of those welcoming games right that even if you've never played a game before I know I can sit down and teach you this and basically anybody can catch on to this game and be able to play it and enjoy it I think the only thing that's pulling Cascadia down for me is that I think I personally enjoy the crunchiness level of these last two games that we're going to be talking about a little bit more so having said that let's just go ahead and Dive Right In to our number two and I'll be able to explain a little bit more why I might prefer that one over its sister game if you haven't guessed it already number two for me is calico um Calico is so fantastic this is the exact opposite for me for um from Cascadia because Cascadia is a game that I know I can pull out with basically anybody Calico I

will only pull Calico out for very specific groups of people and the reason why is because Calico is very mean it looks like a nice cozy Happy game but it is a very mean game um in this game you have basically a quilt and you are building and putting together a quilt attracting animals sewing buttons onto it trying to get the most points how cascadia's board keeps getting bigger and bigger and bigger and growing and you get more and more options Calico is the exact opposite as the game goes on you only have a limited number of places to place your tiles so as the game goes on it becomes more and more and more restrictive Calico is one of those games where you're thinking to yourself okay I need the purple polka dot piece right now and if it doesn't come out then I'm just screwed and I lose 17 points because of that so it's one of those games that I would not just introduce this to everybody I don't think it's super approachable I think it is very mean but for me I love the the tension that this game brings and how I just get so frustrated sometimes cuz there are times where I'm like okay I need this piece I need this piece please come out please come out please come out and then it happens to come out right on my turn I snag and I grab it I'm able to put together my quilt exactly as I want to it's just such a fun and interesting puzzle for me so I really like the tension that this brings over Cascadia again Cascadia was on my you know top 10 games of all time one of the reasons why

was cuz it was just so easy and Breezy and approachable Calico is definitely on my favorite list um of all time too but it's definitely not one that I would introduce to anybody we've talked about almost all the games now there's just one left which if you have been kind of paying attention to my channel it shouldn't be surprising but yes my number one is harmonies so this was one that I honestly I kind of disregarded the first handful of times I heard people talk about this I remember it was a handful of months ago I heard a couple people talk about it I saw it was on like the hotness list okay fine I have enough tile placement games I don't need another one um then I saw Amy and Maggie from thinker themer which shout out to them if you don't follow them please go do they're amazing um I saw them talking about this game and after seeing their review I was like okay you know what maybe there's something here that I'm missing so then I kind of looked into it a little bit more and then I was like you know what I have a feeling I kind of get these feelings about games sometimes I had the same feeling with Sky Team when it kind of started to get Buzz I was like I think this is going to be the next big thing for a little bit the next hot thing so I just quickly went and ordered it I had the same feeling about harmonies I had heard more and more and more people it was a lot of Buzz and I was like you know what I think this is going to be the next B thing I'm going to quickly order it so I quickly ordered it and it came we broke it open we played it that night and I immediately fell in love with this game and L and it broke my heart I fell in love with it so much that it broke my heart because after playing it I was like this is

going to be this is going to knock some of these other games off of my you know top 10 or top 20 games of all time because this is so amazing so let's chat for a little bit about what harmonies is um so in harmonies you have these little discs and you will on your turn you will select three discs and then add them to your little board that is in front of you um that's all you're doing you're selecting disc and adding them to your board but you also have a couple optional actions that you can do and one of those optional actions is to select an animal card now every single animal card is different and what you do is you are trying to attract those specific animals onto into your little ecosystem but you have to fulfill the certain um the certain patterns that they want in order to fully attract them onto your board once you have that pattern made out on your board for example the little bumblebees here um it wants three flowers or three Little Flower tokens and then one little tree and then once you have that pattern then you can go ahead and place your little B Cube on top of that tree um and in order to fully score this little b card here you need to do that particular pattern two times in your area but what makes this game interesting is that all the patterns that you're making out on the board they all can actually overlap with each other so there are times times where as you're going out you can get two or three cards that their patterns

kind of overlay a little bit so you're just going and kind of putting all your patterns on top of each other trying to be the most efficient that you can within a small area and I've been thinking about this for a little bit of why this game fits so well with me and I think this is the reason why all of the games that we've talked about today there are touches of every single one of those games within harmonies it has the restrictive nature that Calico has right when you're working with a limited board it's slowly filling up you really trying to get the tiles that you need um in order to successfully complete your animals and it's nice because Calico you have a very limited pool that you're working with and in this game it's restrictive but you have a slightly larger pool so you have more chances to get the tokens that you really need one of my favorite Parts about Cascadia is all the different animals and all the different patterns that you can kind of swap out and change from game to game in this game it's just like that except it works throughout the game throughout the game you are able to select the animals that you are wanting to score for at that time and you can constantly be getting new animals fulfilling old animals so your patterns you're working through your patterns you're changing their patterns as the game goes on and trying to get the best patterns for the particular layout that you have going at that time just like in aqua you are incentive ifies sometimes in this game to build you're building your patterns on top of each other which I just I just

it works so well with my brain I love looking at all the animals and trying to piece together in my brain okay how can I get this pattern to link with this pattern really well can I have it flip-flopped can I bounce this animal off this other animal and then just like a copis you have to be really strategic about the way that you are placing stuff you can't just place and stack willly you really have to be strategic about the way that you're going about your patterns and so I think that's why harmonies hit so well for me is because it takes all these games that I love and it takes in my opinion the best pieces from from all those games and compiles it into harmonies now I do agree with some of the stuff that the dice tower said I will make sure to link to that video in the description below so you can go check it out don't just take my for my word for it get kind of get your own do your own um information SE Arch on this game but I do agree with what they said about a couple things about harmonies it is a little bit lucky because you do have animals that will be coming out and sometimes they work in your favor and sometimes they don't but having said that there's enough animals on the board that for me I never felt like screwed over by the card play it's not lucky in the sense that like I roll the dice and oops I I got a three and I needed a four and there's nothing that I can do about that there are a lot of animals that are always out on the board and so I felt I never personally felt restricted I never personally felt like how in in Calico a little bit when I'm

like I need this tile now and it doesn't come out that I'm screwed I never got that feeling I said I I it felt more like tension because again separate from Calico you have a bigger pool that you're working with for for the tiles that are coming out and you also have a big pool of animals that you're dealing with if it was a more restricted pool and a more restricted deck of cards cards that you were working with at any time pretend you only had three cards on the table and three PS of dice that you're pulling from maybe it would bother me more but because there's so many I never really felt that also like if you don't like tile placement games I don't know if this is going to necessarily change your opinion of it but for me it does feel different from the other games like I think that there is a place in my collection for harmonies along with all of these other games so I guess I just kind of wanted to complete my case for harmonies a little bit I think harmonies is in my opinion this is one of the best games that I've played all year I totally think it deserves the hype I totally think it's worth it I know some people are probably going to love to hate on this game because it is new and because oh hi my hands are oh we should go wash your hands then anyways coming back to this I definitely think Harmony is worth looking into absolutely um and yeah definitely think it is worth the hype hi not only is one of the best games that I played this year but it honestly is one of my new favorite games in general it's like my family's just been playing this non-stop we have loved this game I'm going to be doing a video at the end of

the year talking about my favorite games that I've played um throughout 2024 and this one is definitely going to be on the list all right so there's my Roundup for you for five tile placement games um that are similar to harmonies thank you so much for watching this video today if you enjoyed this video and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel it would mean so much if you could do that really help support me in everything that we're doing over here but until next time I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you later

Progress saved