Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Games We Don't Like...But YOU Might!

Transcript 51:38

foreign hey how's it going everyone Carlo and Dylan here from all you can board and today we are telling you guys about the games we don't like but you might so don't think of this as just our least favorite games or the worst games we've played or anything like that we would have called the video that if that was the case these are games specifically that we see um you know the value in them we see why other people would like them and in some cases we might even recommend these games to other people but for whatever reason they don't click with us in our personal preferences when it comes to games so they're games that I think in the most like in a lot of cases we either haven't feature or wouldn't normally feature on the channel but it gives us an opportunity to talk about why they wouldn't click for us but might for someone else right yeah for sure and so we're going to be talking about five games the first one that we're gonna talk about is actually one that we share uh a share a game that we kind of share the same opinion on even if it differs a little bit we both are putting it on for similar reasons and then we're each gonna have two of our own games that we're gonna bring to the software five total so I'm just gonna say this right now I'm pretty sure you're gonna be really disappointed with both of the games that I brought and I say that just as anticipating a little bit of this I'll also say right now it's not like I put a gricola's not on here

in general the games that I brought are new to me games that um that I just didn't land and I guess getting into the criteria a little bit the way I've approached mine is that these are games that I've played very few times in some cases just the one I think actually maybe maybe both of them I've only played the one time aside from the art joint game I've played more than once but um the reason I'm putting them on here is because as we you know cover more games as we play more games in our collections they're so big we don't have a ton of time as we as we're getting to a more further into adulthood to play games and I'm not often going to suggest to play a game that I actively don't like or currently don't like like it would be more likely that I go to someone's house and they're playing them like yeah you know what I'd like to give that game another shot but even then it's going to be you know not my first choice yeah you're going along with what other people want to play exactly so the reason I'm putting them on here is that they they I understand both of them fit the criteria of games that I I am sure certain because that other people like because I'm pretty sure you like both of them um and and I know a lot of other people will as well but at the same time it's possible that I could at some point end up liking it maybe if there's something about these first plays that just didn't land and so I'm open to not just other saying that other people will like them but also that over time if I do play it again and all of a sudden I'm like oh you know what I feel differently I'd be willing to explore but okay it's not a top priority when I have so many other games I want to explore including ones I'm certain I enjoy right fair enough yeah I didn't come over to uh today trying to hurt your feelings so I don't think I understand I don't think I have any games that are going to offend you in any way actually one of them I don't

even know if you've played but but you grabbed one off my shelf so how do you it's uh it's not something that you yourself own it's something we co-owned together yeah and the last thing I want to say because this is a really small subset of games that I think you and I both like it was hard to even pick three I think my whole shortlist had five or six games there's not many games that fall into this category of these are the games that I think would have of if you look at shelf side the YouTube channel which we really like they do something where they talk about their personal score and their like recommender score which is sort of like a subjective versus objective and these are games where I think of my personal enjoyment score would probably be like anywhere from you know four or five out of ten to where my objective score if I was like a teacher evaluating someone on game design a lot of these games I might give a 7 out of 10 from like an objective standpoint so there's a really wide range in terms of how I feel about the game for myself versus in general kind of yeah and the last very last thing I'll say is I don't hate any of the games that I picked I dislike the experience I had but it's not like these would be like you know me right in these games like a one out of ten to a ten through ten they might even be higher than a five I'd attended for one by just like my personal rating score or whatever yeah it's just that again as with this many board games we're just a little bit more critical and also we are more you know appreciative and aware of our time that we're spending playing board games so sometimes don't have enough time and there's so many games that's exactly it's just a matter of being more selective so uh why don't we start off with our joint game that we already knew as soon as we came as soon as I got it we knew what the game was right let's do it you introduced it okay so the first game we're talking about is a two-player only game called Target

uh we don't have a physical copy between us this is one that we've each only played on VGA I think you've said you played it more than once I think yeah twice and but it's been a while now and I think both those players are really close together uh because after the first play I remember being I came with high expectations because I heard so many people talking about it and after the first play not land down was like maybe I just missed that I played it again yeah and felt the same ways yeah and I think I played a similar thing I think I've played it about twice um so the the long and short of is the game where you're and again a lot of these games because we've been playing them a lot the rules explanations or the overview is not going to be super thorough or yeah or clear necessarily but um you are basically playing on this little Grid it's kind of a two-player uh work replacement game where you're determining you have these multiple workers that you're setting on the sort of X and Y axis of this grid and whichever lines kind of intersect or the lines that the the workers are in line with determine the actions that are going to be available to you that round but your opponent can't put their workers in the same rows or columns so the start of each round starts with you placing these with just going to kind of determine your lines of you know there's going to be a total of maybe like six or seven actions depending how you line them up they're going to be available to you that round and some of these are going to be getting certain Goods that only you know that you need to trade in for points you can get tiles that there's different like set collection little bonuses that you can get so the whole game is about acquiring resources and converting them into points while trying to get in your opponent's way and deny them their opportunities right it's a very interactive very mean game you have to be watching what your opponent's doing and kind of getting in their way almost more than watching your own your

own benefits right yeah um so yeah what were your first impressions and what did you like like or what's the value you've seen it versus what you don't like about it yeah so for all these these picks for all these games I'm going to kind of like folk I'm going to say the specific characteristics that make it something I think is online and some of them I might not even fully know exactly what it is what combination of things makes it not land free but I'm also going to say the things that I still do like the mechanics or the things that I mechanisms whatever that I still do enjoy so like with Target I was was most interested in it because of the idea that it's the cross section of where you place your workers on the border that you're taking actions just without having played in hearing about that I thought that's an interesting way to approach placing your your workers on this on like this grid of cards um and in theory I was like hey that's pretty cool and then having to like not just think what am I going to try to like take as an action but also what is my opponent going to do am I trying to deny them so in practice that or sorry in theory that was the thing that kind of like attracted the most to Target besides the fact of all the buzz and everyone talking about it um for some reason that in practice wasn't as interesting to me as I would have hoped like I still thought I was a neat mechanic but the execution of it for whatever reason as I played I just never felt like like there's some games where I could ignore other things going on or I could forgive other things going on because one mechanic one mechanism is so interesting to come back to Target's main you know gameplay mechanical there like just didn't hook me the way I thought it was and I will say that the

biggest detractor the biggest reason I I struggle with Target and this might seem like something that you know should be easier to overlook but it's the same reason I struggle with a game like battleline is is I just don't find the game that nice to look at and and I think I'm more critical of it because two-player only games is such a wide spanning genre of organs and also an important one it's one that I always want to have like multiple contenders my playlist or my playlist on my shelf my board game playlist um as well as some of my favorite games are two player only and like new ones are coming all the time like now Splendor duels up there and it's like one of my favorite two-player only games so for for Target to then for me to set up a table with seven wonders duel or Patchwork or Splendor duel or like even like so many we could name and then Target just like even I know we've only played on BJ but like it's also something that as a table presence it just doesn't have something that's really hooking me and I don't think our opinion would change much playing it in person no I can't imagine and it's it's hard too because I often play two-player games not like we we play we play lots of board games together we're not it's not like we always play two player only games are playing variety it seems to be that the people I play two player only games with the most are people that don't play war games that often or I'm playing a game with it for the first time with them and Target's Gonna Be A Hard Sell based on the fact that it just kind of looks Bland yeah so I can't even feel like what are you doing it's like oh you collect stuff and trade it for points yeah and then you try to get in your opponent's way like there's a lot of games that have that that basic premise

right yeah and also I just found it to be a bit um not complex or complicated maybe that is what I mean but I just found it like from lining that up and having to deny your opponent and picking the actions you want while also managing the robber whatever it's called going around the side of the board and also talking about the robbery yeah yeah and then also taking the cards and making your own Grid in front of you with them or whatever like it there's just like I found that there was more going on than it I felt like it needed and I didn't feel like enough reward for the investment that I was putting into it so I think it's bad for me it's a combination of all those things but the main one for better or worse is just not so much I don't know if it's the theme it's more just the look of the game like the artwork and and the colors are just not something that is is inviting to me and I felt for some whatever reason I held it back I've asked this before but yes would either a Marvel or Final Fantasy theme make this more appealing to you it doesn't have to be I don't know if it doesn't have to Marvel it could just be fantasy things okay Animal Crossing but yeah I mean honestly like with it with a it's like you know like um so back two player yeah like that it doesn't have to be that theme but that has a lot of color it has a lot of character it has a lot of personality I feel like that is something that would give it a better shot of Landing with me I don't know if it would completely change my overall opinion with a boo definitely have a better shot for sure no honestly that's a great example that's a great comparison yeah honestly I have a lot of the similar reasons is you what I'm gonna highlight though and and I guess it's funny because this actually only popped into my head as we were sitting here filming the comparison

but I'm going to compare it a little bit to furnace in that it almost has two halves of the game and I like one half a lot more than the other the idea of the selection where you're gonna place your two I like that aspect yeah because it feels like there's a lot more to consider and you're thinking um I can't remember now if you place one and they Place one and you take turns I think it is all for you right so you still don't know if I put one here what are they gonna do and is that gonna then change my second choice and even just you don't know how the round is gonna play out yet but once those have been established like the the tiles that you take into your business question that are going to determine your scoring conditions are all open information it's all public so if I have like two tiles that are going to get me points at the end for getting a bunch of dates or a set of you know date pepper and whatever the other thing is you can just see what I have and you know exactly what you need to deny me so yeah I find that once we've done the the actual thing where we set our workers the rest of the round is less interesting and feels sometimes a little bit procedural because it's like well obviously they want that and then they need that so they're going to go there and then after they go there then maybe I'll go there and sometimes it plays out the way you'd expect from the beginning of the round so it just there's not that unpredictability and that tension in the same way that I like from a lot of two-player games yeah I don't want to Discount completely there are some of the tiles on the border spaces that you go to that give you interesting options to like go somewhere where your opponent is or manipulate the board in some way so again it could be a game that maybe if we played it more or maybe if like you and I played it or played with the same person over and over you might enjoy it more but I'm not at the point where I'm like interested enough in playing it again so I'm open to playing it again I see why a lot of people would

like it and I think for people who like games that are very thinky very and where it's all about basically getting in your opponent's way and there's a bit of that math in terms of like well I can score this many points for myself or I can deny my performance six points by blocking them from getting this and if you're gonna play it with the same person a lot then I could see that being you know a really good experience but so far I kind of just bounced off of it yeah if you're someone who you know especially if you're gonna play with the same person very often whether it's because you like it's a roommate or something you game with very often and also you don't you know the theme or you know the look of it isn't something super important it's more just about like a really solid you know lab mean not even I don't want to use the word mean but like yeah like denying your opponent having to think like yeah not just like I'm playing a board game but I'm also stopping my opponent from effectively playing yeah you're playing the player more than the game in Target yeah so I I feel like if those are the type of games gravitate towards and you are looking for two player only games like I know there are tons of people who like Target and there are also tons of people who haven't played yet that will love it so I think that's why it's a great one for this list because even though we don't like it I'm certain that you might like it or are you already doing you're the cursing this on the other side of the screen I was gonna say it's an odd one because we both thought we were gonna like this game a lot because people have been recommending it for years tons of comments last time we did a two-player video what about Target what about Target but anyway I think I said enough about Target all right so I'm I'm doing my my first one yeah go ahead disappointment everyone in my heart okay I was got the knife right here right in there yeah get it ready I was gonna try to do them in the order of like disappointing like I'll disappoint you here and then I'll disappoint you

more there so I don't even know which one's gonna disappoint you the most I'm just going to take a guess so my first one that is on here that I've only played once and I'm open to playing it again but after my first play of it I would I will say I don't enjoy it is the Estates what yeah so wow yeah so yeah so wow yes the Estates Mr I love auctions I know I know so okay yeah this is the dagger is right in there okay so the the Estates uh there's a few reasons I think it's not landing and I'll I'll go over them and because I'm not 100 certain it's one of the reasons that I'd be really interested to play it again just to be sure that that like the reasons I'm listening here are accurate but yeah I I I've discovered I love auction games I think we both did as we played Modern Art or whatever I think the problem for me with these states is that I Modern Art set such a high bar for me and has so many different types of options and it's it's that level of all these different types of auctions and and how to manipulate the market that I I love in modern art and I came in with such high expectations for the Estates just knowing there was an auction game that also had like you know a lot of people or at least I've heard that a lot of people enjoy it for some reason there's just multiple things about it that I don't like so one of them and this is like small but I'll just start here is I don't really enjoy the aspect of the way the money is used in the Estates like the closed Market is okay but one the fact that I on your turn you can just choose to just slide

one under the board I don't find that thematically it's cool the embezzling everything I think that it's a cool tie into like the theme of the game but in practice of actually just like I have the option to just tuck one away and essentially I'm just like getting a point of return I just don't find that super an interesting way to to get points I get that you're being rewarded I forget I have a comment on that yeah and I want to set you off yeah yeah I get it it's like you know you're being rewarded for having like you know played in a way that you have a bunch of money now you're stuck in some way I understand it just for whatever reason for me I didn't quite like that mechanic as much um I also just think that for me personally as a gamer it's too mean and and that it and I think we both agree it's a mean auction game but and I like meanness in certain games I don't know what it is specifically with this one that it didn't land but I just found that the idea that I felt like I was doing more denial than I was playing for myself I like um I like communism games but I'd rather be able to like I'd rather have it be like if I were doing a percentage split I'd rather be like 60 of what I'm doing is my you know my board my Tableau my whatever like is a focus on my play and then the other 40 max is me denying other players me being mean or whatever I think that's probably the ratio that is like the top uh that I'd want to hit for me personally with games I just found the Estates to be more than that at least in in the game we played and while there was aspects that were interesting where I felt like okay I'm not even playing myself I'm just trying to like play the other players it just it didn't I would say

that it just wasn't as fun to me as as I would have wanted to as a game I'm going to come back to okay and then the um oh actually do you want to comment anything for it because I feel like okay is there something you like about the game or anything else yeah yeah like so so I I think that the idea of the auction I don't want to say being secondary but like that's the wrong way but driving the building of the buildings or whatever yeah like I like well actually you know my favorite thing about the Estates and I'll say this right now uh is that um grid of cubes and that's how that like determine what's going to be auctioned based on what's Exposed on the ends and being able to say okay now if someone's made made this an auction that exposes another colored Cube that now is available for someone else but I actually thought that was really really cool that was the thing that excited me the most when it was set up when you were teaching to know that that's how you decide what is auction and even just the idea that you can choose what is being auctioned and and that you could do something that's for yourself or do something that's just to try to like you know put your phone in that top position I think that is my favorite thing about the Estates but when we get into again I think it's probably also because I'm spoiled by modern era but I I found them I found the auction part lackluster like and maybe it's because there's only one oh like with just that one single type of auction but I found that to be way less interesting there's tons of times where just like people put something up for auction and it was everyone it just made I understood why they put it up for auction or I know why I put up for auction but I knew that it was just gonna be like most people are just gonna pass I just found that to be less engaging a little less interesting

for whatever reason like I I I'm explaining a whole bunch of different things because I'm not sure which one is not Landing with me the most or why it's causing or if it was just all these little annoyances that added up throughout the game you said I didn't really like that didn't really like yeah just and the last thing I would say is that if I was ever going to sit down and with with four or or players for instance and play an auction game I would just much rather play Modern Art and I think that that's like to the point of like I don't I don't think I Tire of Modern Art enough to be like okay let's change that by going to the Estates because I just for me I would just feel like halfway through halfway through our game I just remember thinking like I just wish we played Modern Art because this I'm having a way more fun to fun time so I think modern are in some way spoiled me a little bit right so yeah that again I this is just me I know there's a lot of people who like it but that's just and I know I know you and even I think everyone at the table besides me probably enjoyed that play a lot right um for for some reason it just didn't didn't land okay fair enough I I am a little I am surprised to be honest yeah I'm very surprised I I got the impression that you didn't I got the impression right away you didn't love it anywhere near as much as me but I thought you at least enjoyed it um I played it twice now I've really really enjoyed it both times yeah I will 100 agree with you that Modern Art the auctions themselves are more interesting and I think I've probably done the Estates a disservice either on this channel or to maybe to you or people I've spoken to about the game saying referring to it as an auction game when like yes there was an auction every round that's what you do you start your turn by holding an auction basically but it's more of um it's not area majority area control but

like it's kind of hard to Define what that is on the board but it's that's the game it just happens to be driven by auctions yeah right it's like the auctions are what enable the pieces to get added to the board so I don't like the auctions themselves because it's the same type and because you can only bid once it's never going to come back around to you yeah they're definitely less interesting and the auctions are almost like a way to throw your weight around right based on your position on the board or um or it's it's the what makes the options interesting is the piece that you choose and at what time you choose it because yeah what you choose the onus you're kind of like looking over at someone's table like I know that guy needs this piece and I know he's going to pay through the roof he's gonna pay me like seven or eight thousand dollars for it probably yeah or something like that so that's important to focus on is that it's a very different type of auction game than modern art yeah um and one thing I want to mention real quick just about the thing with the tucking the money underneath I think like in a way I agree with you that like the decision of it's just a yes or no like outside of your turn do I stash one thousand dollars because you can't stash anymore and it's just a simple thing I think the reason why it's in the game I could be wrong I haven't played the game enough to know for sure but I think is because if you're auctioning off pieces and you're um people are paying you and buying a lot of the pieces it means you're not putting as much stuff on the board but you're gonna have more money so by stashing money under the board because it's this closed economy if I'm in the lead let's say I have like fifteen thousand dollars the next player has six every time I start tucking money the total pool of money between all the players is smaller so the value like my advantage gets bigger the more the more players do that whoever has the most money their advantage increases sort of in reference to how the other players

have right so now a bit of three late in the game is way more costly than a bit of three early on so yeah I think it offsets like whoever's winning auctions is not gonna have as much money so the person with the more money that's not affecting the board has to have the control to bully players around to win more auctions so it's yeah I I honestly I love saying that should convince you that it's a good no no but I think I think it's important just for anyone watching that that's I think why it's in the game yeah like and I think the reason I stress like the thematics too like I think in like I I understand why it's in the game and I also understand like why it might even be close to being a necessity to have something like that in the game I just want to boil it when I boil it all down the idea of just like on my turn I just say give me a point give me a point give me a point which is essentially what it is you're just like saying I take a point I take a point I think that over but you're not I know what it does I'm definitely oversimplified just like to like try to like hone in on the aspect if I don't like I guess it's just something to do with like if using our game as an example yeah it was like something happened in the first few turns of the game or whatever you got a whole bunch of money and so because that played out in that way now x amount of turns if you remember to do it you just say I take a point I take a point I take a point by sliding a money under a person I understand like it makes sense but I just didn't find that as like an interesting thing to do and in order to have to remember to be like okay like I'm gonna take a point or I forgot to take a point last turn like I don't know it just something about it I didn't really like and that it's a I start with X it's my smallest gripe with the game I would say my biggest one for sure it just comes down to personal preference on uh player meanness like I

would say I would say that's pretty much the biggest barrier for me and that's that's entirely preference which is why I put it on here because I think there's a lot of people who enjoy that in board games and and I do too I think it's just slightly over the ceiling of what I want to allow for my game and yeah it's I would say without thinking about too much it's probably the meanest game I've played and yeah I'm only going to play it with certain groups of people it's going to be a sort of a situational occasion type game but so far I love it and uh yeah I can't wait to play it more but and you're disappointed I can see it on your face next time that whole uh host the game night if I'm even considering uh States I'll let you know so you can play it again I'm interested that this is okay good good I think on both of the games I'm going to talk about I'm interested to play them again because I'm open to my mind being changed I just don't feel like it's going to maybe just a strong negative reaction for the first game okay fair enough all right I think we've uh I think we're gonna cool down from the server before I move on to my my first picture so uh the one I'm gonna talk about is a game that we actually I think you reviewed it on the channel a while ago or is some type of overview video okay this was something we got as a review copy at the time from Capstone ah yeah right of course curious cargo so I played this with you once or twice this is a two-player only game designed by Ryan Courtney same designer as pipeline this came out a year after pipeline I believe um we've never played pipeline we were interested in it and then we got offered this game and we thought at first we were like oh maybe we should try and play pipeline too we still haven't got around to it but yeah so we played this I played this with you either once or twice I know you played it a couple more times without me and it was one of those

games where as you were explaining the rules and we were setting up and starting to play I remember thinking like this sounds really interesting and I was I thought I was going to enjoy this game and the basic idea is you are you each have sort of a factory right and you're It's Curious cargo you are shipping cargo uh and you have these basically like uh trucks that come into your factory and you've got this like network of pipes if you if you haven't played pipeline think of the old um like what Windows whatever Windows 98 game piped with pipe dream pipe dream yeah with the little like green goo going through the Slime going through all the pipes great so there's that kind of thing going on where you're taking tiles you can stash them on your board to save them in your reserve you can put them on the board to connect this little network of pipes there's pipes of different colors there's a regular mode that has two colors and there's a hard mode which we never even tried that has a third color of pipes that makes it even more of this like mind-bending puzzle but you're basically getting Goods that come into your Factory and then they got to go through these network of pipes and then spill out to uh it's not directly into the trucks as it goes into something else first which then right here goes uh yeah I'm pretty sure it goes like well yeah there's I know there's tracks on both sides ones for each one that's what it is right and then you receive them on one end you should go to the other side to ship them right yeah so what I'm going to say before I get into any like any further into this is this game more than almost any game I've played requires like Precision uh planning uh like accurate order of your operations um it's such a thinky game the order

that you do things is so important um if you have like one of your trucks like there's all these numbered slots one through ten or something on your board and you have to like there's these requirements with like everything has to be perfect if you end up one short it could mean that your whole turn was a complete waste of time that everything you did amounted to nothing because these first six steps got you all these things and then that last step oh you miscalculated slightly so now your truck doesn't get to go where it doesn't get to deliver the things which means that all these pipes for a waste so the pressure at the start of your turn feels like I have to get everything right otherwise why we've been playing this game if I accomplish nothing on my turn like it can be so frustrating but there's very little of this game that's done simultaneously so I remember every time I was like trying to connect my pipes I look up and I see you looking at me and like you weren't rushing me or anything like you're you're being great about it but I just feel that like okay I'm holding up the game but there's no way I'm gonna be able to connect these pipes I'm like I just want to keep things going but if I end my turn I know this is a disaster so I may as well just forfeit the game if I'm gonna end my turn like it felt like to play the game and have a chance of winning I was gonna have to grind it down to such a halt and experience such a level of analysis paralysis that isn't isn't conducive to a good game experience for me right and so but I want to highlight quickly the things I liked about this game because first off like the I the fact that it's such a tight experience and the how tied you are to what the other player is doing and the fact that their goods are coming to your factoring you have to have the open spots to receive their goods and have everything lined up with the pipe like it's such an impressive

design like if again going back to the note I made at the start of the video if I was like a teacher teaching game design class and someone brought me this like I'd be blown away and that's why I was so interested to try it but it's I just don't find myself having fun while playing it when everything is so precise but I love the scoring conditions how in order to win you need to what is it you need to I think ship a certain number of goods you have to shift you like you cannot win unless you've shipped at least two goods or something like that there's a threshold you have to hit otherwise you can't be considered for for victory right but then even and then after you've met those two mandatory thresholds to be eligible for victory you can also gain these Stars which if you both meet the requirement to be eligible for victory then it comes down to it has the most stars but you could both fail and nobody could win which I don't know if I've played another two-player game that has uh you both lose type of scenario because it makes it so that you can't just block the other player you have to do you have to balance doing a good job with your own Factory while doing better than them and getting them in their getting in their way so yeah everything like a lot of it sounded like it should appeal to me but that type of required Perfection on a spatial puzzle is just like I want my spatial puzzles to be a little more free and a little less like restrictive and just frustrating so yeah and I'll say that like the like I I know I like this more than you but I wouldn't even go so far as to say that it's like like I haven't I haven't wanted to play it since it's been here or whatever like it's not you might want to get to the table I I think that the toughest thing is that not only are you placing tiles in the grid you can place tiles on top

of each other right and so that like it would be one thing to be like how do how do I how do I maneuver my or to you know place the pipes in the right way to funnel things but then you can also put pipes on top of pipes that cover up old ones and make new connections and so every tile can always go on pretty much every spot on the board even as you fill it up yeah so that makes it so that there's like it's just very prone to analysis paralysis and not just that I also think that like the optimal way to probably experience curious cargo is to play it lots and on each one purposely like not get hung up saying like Okay what's the best move just play and just learn through trial and error because then the games go with the the proper 30 to 60 minutes but then you have to be willing to play like lots of games of curious cargo and like so if you guys I think with the same person exactly you do not want to play this with someone who hasn't played it before if you've played a bunch so I think like if you're if you like this style game if you like a lot of what it's doing and you're willing to just like play a whole bunch and then for those first like I would say like four or five plays not really focus almost at all on like am I making the most optimal decision or was there a better play and just accept it or some leverage and see what happens yeah like it's almost like accepting that you're gonna make bad plays because hopefully every game you play you you make better and better plays and you make less of these mistakes as you're learning like oh actually I remember this piece I remember that if I want to connect to this spot it's an official way to do this and then change it to this bought later like you start to like learn some of those but I never even

learned that from the games I played so like you'd have to really be committed to curious cargo yeah I was gonna say for me it's A Hard Sell to do that level of like yeah letting like it would almost be like if in castles a burgundy you were taking tiles into your possession and then just throwing them away without placing right it's like well then why are we taking turns if I'm not actually progressing in the game from just taking things and then not using them but like I hear you I think yeah anyways it's it's a game that has broken my brain has frustrated me and has actually made me not want to play pipeline anymore but I know there's a lot of people who are gonna love this game and again it's a really impressive design I don't know how this was put together and how it all works it does and remember you you like boa and you don't like Mercado delisho so maybe it'll be the same thing you'll like pipeline but you don't like crazy it could be yeah it could be honestly so who knows we'll see but um yeah I understand if you like these kind of games if you really like that really intense brain burning spatial puzzle type stuff where Perfection is like Paramount to the game you might want check out curious cargo but uh it's not for me cool all right time to not only disappoint you but I'm pretty sure this is going to be the one that I'm gonna get the most dislikes uh ever thumbs down on a video and probably comments being like how did you possibly put this on here I will say again I will stress I am open I am open to being wrong about this but I just think that this is going to be a bit of a mismatch for me personally but I completely understand why people like this game my pick is lahav oh okay okay so I will say this is another one even way more so than the

Estates that I went into with really high expectations one because Ube games and and how well they land for me and us how much I love them and beastro would be my favorite game of all time and just everything I heard about lahave it and just I was expecting to love it in the same way I love or enjoy most Ube games I know what it is about lahav that I don't like and I think this is a hundred percent just my personal preference is that I felt like hey why did you give him a brief overview what you're doing sure sure is a classic or not yeah I guess classic Ube uh big box like um you know I was gonna I guess work is it a worker place it's kind of it's debated whether it's work replacement because you have one single worker and they can stay in the same spot but I think it's still it's but it's an economic game that has aspects of work replacement I would say exactly so you have this like uh River or like like stream of water or whatever it's called in the game that is going to have different resources uh I think every round it's the random place in different spots which you're gonna start the game you determine what order they're gonna come out in and then as throughout the game they're populating at the same concept they're accumulating action space is similar to Agricola but there's an order that they happen in every round yeah and you're you're going to be collect I'm going to probably do this a disservice of explain I mean you're gonna have to jump in but like essentially I've played it more recently yeah it's all good essentially you're it's like you're collecting all different types of resources a ton of different resources in the game you're also having access to all these different special buildings and I guess non-special some of them belong to the town and some of

them belong to the players yes exactly and uh and at its hard what you're doing is finding the most efficient way to gather and convert these resources to maximize the amount of points you're getting using utilizing the buildings utilizing which spots you're you're going to with your workers and what you're choosing to do with them so there's a lot of decision making uh and like that's a really really like very quick overview but it is the aspect of it that I feel like when I pull it when I played it it just felt like I was playing a really long resource conversion game and and maybe that like with the way like it's an economic game and it does involve resources a lot I'm more forgiving of that and I think I can I would even go so far as to say I enjoy that type of resource conversion game when it's a short game and I'll use furnace as an example again just because that is one of the quicker resource conversion games I can think of off the top of my head where that game plays in like on the box I think it says like 30 to 40 minutes I'm sure you can go up upwards of an hour um where a lot of what you're doing is how do what resource am I going to collect how am I going to collect them in order to convert to points Whoever has the most points wins I know that's probably me boiling lahave down like and just taking all the stuff out and just saying this is what it is but it just felt like I mean our game took like three hours I would say or close to two and a half something like that yeah it was our first time playing yes but yeah but it just felt like at some point I realized that all I was really doing by the end of it was or like like ultimately was just how do I convert

these resources to points and yeah a lot of games I love have that but for some reason that just felt like the bulk of what I was doing in the hub and I didn't like it in that long of a game I felt like I wanted more variety and I wanted more going on and the thing I was most excited about going in and even as I was playing that and I think it's almost one of the things I like and dislike is the buildings I think that the the buildings are such a cool mechanic but at the same time and when we played so many of the special buildings I would say didn't feel special like and maybe it's just like it just felt like there were so many buildings that like we didn't use and didn't have a purpose or we did use and I'm like or I got and I'm like actually I'm just gonna sell this like I don't really have it like it felt like for something like special buildings that I again maybe it's maybe it's playing at two players I don't know but it just felt like I was expecting more out of the special buildings than I actually got and so I think it was a combination of the thing I was most excited about feeling a little bit lack not lackluster but a little bit let down by it and then the fact that like that long of a resource conversion Style game just isn't something that's going to land with me personally compared to you know I don't know I'm trying to think if there's another uvae game that is that heavy on resource conversion like I I don't I didn't feel that way about it I didn't feel that way about these Frozen obviously I think his heaviest resource conversion game I think is or at labora which we have okay yeah so when we get to that one maybe yeah I think that's his heaviest one yeah so I think that's why like I I know people love this game and it's obviously like this is not a new game uh but for me I just realized that if a game's gonna rely that heavily on just how like efficiently can you gather and then convert resources to

points um if it's gonna be that long I'm probably not going to have a great time I think for me I'd rather a game like that be maxing out at like hour and a half hour 45 like I think that's probably like my top end for me being able to stomach that kind of being the main Crux of what you're doing right so one thing I want to say about the buildings real quick before I forget is that I think they should have called them unique buildings rather than special because sometimes the ability on them isn't particularly exciting it doesn't feel like it's special because you're like oh well that just like allows me to convert a resource into something or go here and get a lot of this resource I think it's they're more unique because they allow you to either get a large quantity of something or combine or combo with something else that allows you to uh basically do something that wouldn't have been possible otherwise in the game so it might not be an exciting play but it's like if I have a pile of this one resource that might be the one building that allows me to convert it efficiently into this other one resource or whatever yeah but what I want to ask you was if it was like is it mostly because of the length and compared to the other games we've talked about in this video would you give this one more like leeway way or more like would you be more open to trying this one again because of how long it is and because of how many of the cards we haven't seen and because how much there is still to discuss like I think I guess like playing Target already is like it feels like we've seen a lot of others to see La Habra feels like you I played it twice and I feel like I've really scratched the surface of that game I would want to play it again that I would almost want to play the short version of it I know there's like two versions just to like see if that helps at all for me it's just like with there's tons to set up there's tons

of rules I'd have to remember like it is a pretty involved game like like most of the big games like that's something that's not a criticism I thought the rules were relatively I found them from the building I guess like the rules sorry like it's almost the same thing as like Feast Frozen Feast Frozen rules are simple it's how many action spaces there are looking at that for me it was having to like look at all the buildings that are available or look at how I'm going to corporate resource and think like how am I going to do this like that amount of thinking about resource generation specifically I I was interested and really into the game for like I would say like the first half and by the end even when we were against those last few turns that should have failed exciting kind of were about like how do I like on these last few turns do everything I want to do and I can't do everything which is usually a feeling I love I just felt like it was mostly just coming down to me math you know like yeah I can convert this these fish and I'll do it this way and that's 18 and I do it this way and that's 17 okay this makes more sense and I just like I was like uh like honestly I'm starting to not care if I even make the most efficient play at the end because it was just like I don't know I just found that you don't know and also if you were gonna win by 50 or 60 does the difference of five or six points here right you don't know if this so yeah I have to agree with you on that the end of the game to me was the least interesting part both times I've played and because there's so much that's up in the air during the game for the first at least two thirds or three quarters in my opinion in terms of what you can do or having to Pivot and then when you know because you can see how many turns you have left at the end of the game and sometimes you look and you see okay I have two turns I have three turns and you know you have to go to that shipping line spot to ship all those goods so the end is very much uh how can I get rid of all these goods and convert all this

stuff into points so I'm not left over with a bunch of stuff that I didn't use so it definitely feels a bit mathy at the end especially because in those like I think we each probably got at least a third maybe half of our points in the final like three four turns because you're just like piles of goods and trying to think do I buy another ship real quick to ship more Goods so it is very mathy at the end and I also don't really love that part of it yeah but um one thing I'm gonna so I'm gonna I'm gonna put this to you this way yeah yeah I think Feast for Odin is just as much of a resource conversion game as La Havre I think uve has just been clever about the way he sort of convinced like the way he hides it because the ultimate resource in A Feast for Odin is tiles polyamino tiles that you use to cover your board because without those you pretty much can't win the game like you're starting board you start with a negative 81 I think and if you're playing against good players I don't think it's possible to win without also taking one of those islands or maybe a bunch of the sheds or something like you can't win with just a starting board and cards or whatever you can't so in order to take your starting board that has minus 81 spots plus some other boards you have like the whole game is taking tiles so you're either taking wood to then convert some of the spots just convert resources to red tiles or orange tiles or then you're converting it to a ship which then you use your ship and go to spot with two workers and that is being converted into gaining Goods that go where then you're upgrading your goods to better Goods or then so to me I think Feast rodent is it's obviously they're not Resort they're not all wood so it's not a pile of resources and you don't like them all

the same way but so many of the spaces have an arrow saying like turn this into this turn this into this and to me the whole game is about how do I ramp up this engine so that I can gain as many of these tiles how do I convert as many things to as many tiles to cover as much yeah space I won't I won't do the just and this is mostly for my benefit because I talk about these Road in every video but but I think in general tons of board games that we that I enjoy and love and that we play it could be boiled down to me like technically a lot of what we're doing to get our points anyways is resource conversion like I I know that but I think that I guess maybe it is what I don't like about lahob is that it's like it doesn't try to really pretend to be anything else or it doesn't really find an interesting way to bake some other elements and whether it's like roll and dice to go now and I am doing this road comparison uh rolling dice to go pillaging or whether it's um you know I'm gonna do I get a shed or do I get this and how do I utilize it like maybe it's that I need more paint on it to kind of like hide what is going on its core whereas I felt like lahave didn't you know pull any punches of basically just saying like yeah whoever can most efficiently convert the resources will get the most points for sure and to me I just like I felt disengaged by that I guess and and at the length like the thing is I would love to go back and explore more but the idea of being like okay but if it's going to be another three-hour experience like I could play two games I don't think it would be three hours but I hear anything for me if it's gonna consistently take two and a half to three hours then over time I think it's a game I'm gonna kind of cool on a

little bit too but if I can get it to be quicker um anyways I I think I think the economic aspect of I think when the game of you and I played we didn't take any loans I played it a second time and I tried taking a loan to basically I'm having to use money throws around to pay off the loan but it allowed me to get a better building early on and I sold I think like 14 buildings throughout the game so I played it very differently the second time yeah and it made me want to play the game even more knowing like wow that felt way different than the first play based on just the economy stuff that was happening throughout so anyways I feel like we've talked yeah about live right here and I'll get i'll get lots of flack for it it's fine how do I expected it be covered at some point along the channel and some type of review in the future anyways but uh okay we'll have all right and these are like new games that I was super excited to try recently okay well I guess uh I guess I gotta pick some of the dude please no um I appreciate your honesty I appreciate you highlighting the good things as well about these games Okay so the last game I've got here uh is one I've only played on BGA I've I can't remember if I've played it once or twice I think it's twice but I guess you guys can check my BJ account to verify this is space base so this is a what is it actually two to six or three to six players I think I think goes up to six I think so too um very dice based game uh I haven't actually played Machi Coral but I've always heard it compared to machikoro a lot of people say it's a better version of machikoro um but it basically it's most of the game if not all of it is done through simultaneous play where basically at the start of the round one player will roll dice and those values that are rolled

are going to basically everybody every player at the table based on which um bases they have I guess or uh you know there's ships no their bases of course oh no it's your space base but you're calling ships at your base I can't even remember what are they based on the cards again remember it's been a while now since I played it but yeah um so each of the ones that you acquire on your board is going to have a number that corresponds to one of the values from the date like two through twelve on the dice basic thing you're getting these things and putting them on your board and then when someone rolls the dice you check do I collect based on the cards if I have them in that spot so there's this thing going around the table where you're always engaged like there's something happening all the time and it's not your turn and you get an influx of you can either get points or basically the currency so points obviously are just kept as points to the end and your currency you can use to again buy uh more more ships or bases whatever and acquire them so the main player interaction from the game comes in obviously getting um benefits off of the other players dice rolls as well as the cards that you're buying from the center of the table are available to everyone so when I heard about this game and I remember thinking like if you've spoken about this on the channel before if you haven't seen it like um I'm not a huge fan of dice based games we did a video on this before I thought I was gonna like space space a bit more because of the yeah the simultaneous play that I love so much in games like race for the Galaxy um and I like games where there's like a market of things to look at and you're trying to decide how much money and what's the value is this going to come through whatever that kind of thing but there's a few things that kind of just uh just ruin the experience for me the first and I'm going to say the main one probably is a similar issue I had

with quacks of weatherenberg when we talked about it or we disagree on quax equivalent video which is that you can buy there are plenty of things that you might buy during the game that might never come into play at all um because if the values of those dice don't get rolled you're just not going to get the rewards so and there's a decent amount of text on a lot of these cards like some of them you look at a value to a card and you're like okay you're reading there's a couple sentences worth and you decide you compare it with these other ones and you spend with whatever time and you're like okay I'm gonna get that and then you know 10-15 minutes later the game ends and no two is rolled and the time you spent making that decision of which one am I getting is completely irrelevant you don't even get to use the the card I don't like that I wish it's not that I don't like Randomness in games it's just that I don't like decisions that can sometimes feel entirely trivial when you look back and say well that decision I made was a waste of time because it didn't factor in at all so if the game had something where let's say you roll the dice and maybe on your turn you get a benefit maybe on the active player's turn they also get to like like spend a certain amount of money trigger one so maybe you start at the middle value like maybe if you you're seven you want to trigger your seven it's free but maybe the uh six and the eight cost one gold and then the five and the nine cost or whatever and maybe you do this we're increasing cost so that like if I bought that two or three I can acknowledge yes it's unlikely I'm probably not gonna roll it but if it's really important to me I can use my gold to make sure that I get to use that even if it just is once there might still have been bad luck I might have still thought hey odds are I should have rolled that three or four times but at

least I can be upset with myself for saying I didn't have a contingency plan I didn't get the money that I needed to ensure that I was going to trigger that rather than just saying I got unlucky and that card I bought didn't even come into play at all yeah the other thing is that the game is like even just on BGA it is like a hot mess on the table there's so many things everywhere it's like every player has up to 12 I guess 11 because 2 through 12 slots on their board then you've got this kind of like piles and piles of cards in front of you there's just like blocks of text and icons everywhere like it just feels like a game that is I think people that have like um a short attention span or who feel like they get like check out when it's not their turn or that kind of thing I think the game is going to go well with a lot of people like that because if you want to feel involved or a sense of progression you're always getting things people are wearing dice you're getting something here then you're spending it to buy new things to then get more there's this ramp up sense that goes on throughout the game but I just feel like because everything's happening simultaneous I don't really have time to like look at what other players are doing and be like okay well all these players have these cards that are good with sixes so I should probably also get cards that are sixes because maybe you know like I can't really pay attention what's going on when it's all simultaneous and there's just so much that I just felt like I just kind of bounced off of it yeah and I haven't played spaces but I've played like four or five games with machucar which I'm not gonna think about that might be one of the games that neither of us owns that I play the most of for some reason it's been a long time now since I played it but uh that's all been at like board game cafes um but machikoro is one that I enjoyed um but I think it's it's it definitely

is one of those games where you go if you're gonna go in and get the most maximum enjoyment out of game like magikar or space space or even you could probably lump in class quite Limburg here you kind of have to like be in the right mood for it and like No And depends who you're playing with and you have to really be like not looking for an experience where the best decisions you make are going to influence whether or not you women like you're kind of just making decisions and like yeah am I getting lucky I might you're right like you you can match your car you can buy certain buildings and if the die never rolls that way you're like man like why isn't it like why am I not getting my roles you have to like like I'm not even I'm not always wanting to play a game like that but I think I I definitely have more tolerance than you I know that when it comes to those type of games where if like say I was dating someone who like loved playing that game I could I could go back and play it and and find like hey that was fun or like oh like I got really lucky that game or whatever and be okay with it um but I probably even myself would wear a thin after hour I'm like okay I've just had three games of space base in a row and it feels like every decision I make didn't matter because the diet didn't go yeah or whatever right so I totally get I think I think this like quacks of weidenberg I think we saw in the comments of that video and just people weighing in it was very divisive like there there was lots of people who uh were like oh that's a super fun gameplay with my kids I love it or whatever and then some people being like yeah I think I agree with Carl I don't like it for these reasons so like I think it just Falls in that category of like it's not gonna be for everyone and sometimes won't even be for you at different points depending how you're feeling what kind of game you're looking for and I could see similar to quacks I could see it being a great family game especially to balance out skill levels

between like parents and kids kind of thing and everyone's involved and engaged but um it also I think ultimately boiled down to feeling almost like a shopping game too and it's like you shop and then you wait and see if your purchase is paid off yeah and then now you have enough money okay you shop and buy a thing and then you kind of roll some dice wait to see if you collect another pair of things and then you do some shopping and then it just kind of Loops like that until someone has the most points and wins so I don't know if this is one again I'm open to trying again I don't know if this is one that some people would say maybe I might enjoy more in person some people say that BJ has a great implementation so if you're a fan of space based maybe let me know in the comments below this is one I would consider trying again but uh so far I just really didn't enjoy my time with it I think it's fair and I think that's it that's all five games and you know what I think that now that I haven't seen the full list I think these are this really does fit the theme of the video of like we don't like them but I can see for every single one obviously they're having you the ones I picked why why people do like them why you might like why you might like them even though we're giving our opinion here I mean obviously any game can land with anyone and not allow someone like the whole the great thing about loving like a hobby or whatever but um I just like I more these more than any of them I can recognize as I'm saying why I don't like something I know why you do like this or why Brayden likes it or why someone else who plays this why they're gonna be like oh my God I love this I'm gonna be like yeah I know that's awesome it just like it's just not something for me or it's just not something for you or whatever yeah but they're all well-designed games that like yeah if they sound even mildly interesting to you you should at least give them each a shot yeah and then tell us in the comments uh what you what your Discovery was if you agree with us after playing those games or if you're like yo

you're 100 wrong I'm one I'm in the camp of one of the ones who likes it we're always curious to hear those and have like little discussions in the comments yeah let us know which ones you guys have there's games that weren't covered in this video what are games that you find that you really don't like but you totally understand why other people do or games that you really respect just don't want to play yourself let us know other than that thanks so much for watching and we will see you next time

Progress saved