Yokohama - Old VS New VS Duel. A Board Game Review.
Transcript
We'll take you to Japan, in particular Yokohama, in particular the board game Yokohama. This is not a travel video. This is a Yokohama board game video where we are going to review and compare the Yokohama original edition, which we purchased purchased many many years ago and already looked discolored, and Yokohama the new edition and Yokohama dual. And which one is our favorite? And with the premium tokens of Yokohama. Yokohama, it can be used for any edition. And uh well, sort of the dual, but we'll we'll get to that later. Yep, this is a Yokohama-tastic review. Um I love it. Why did you start with that? This is a game that's been out for 10 years, so it won't be new to many of you. Uh but it is relatively new to us, so I'm going to talk through the game, talk through uh this old version and the new release from last year, and the dual, which was new. Yep. So, first of all, simply talk about a review of the game Yokohama, the uh the main version of the game, and these are the new components that you can see on the table here. It is a game of modular boards that are laid out in this kind of pyramid shape, and there's all of these side boards that are connected to certain actions, and you need to plan out your actions, and you can get in the way of other players, but the more you plan, the stronger the actions you'll take.
And so, the core game is that every turn, you'll either place three of your assistants on different spaces, or place two on the same space, and then your president is going to go out walking. So, let me just uh pop some things down. Give examples, yep. Uh your president is going to go for a wander, and presidents need doors to be opened for them by assistants. So, other than the canal, they can only walk through spaces and into spaces where your where you have assistants. And then once you get to the destination, you'll take the action, and the strength will be based on how many pieces you have there. Now, there's a little bit of interaction. If you want to put an assistant down where someone else's president is, you have to pay them a coin. Uh if you want to move your president where someone else's president is, or even through, uh you have to pay them a coin.
And then the core of the game is trying to find ways to gain victory points. So, there's a big order fulfillment element. You can use these spaces to collect resources that you'll cash in for these orders. Uh there are technologies, which might give you ways of gaining points, or they might give you upgrades. There are ways of There are other ways to trade in resources for points, so you can cash them in for import goods, which you then go and uh import and score over on the import board. You can cash them in for faith points at the church, and you can score some points there. And then on top of that, there's an engine building element to the game. Uh it's a slow engine build. You're not going to to roll really heavily, uh but what will happen is, uh say here, you would be gaining an action at strength three, but if you ever take an action somewhere at strength four, then you can put a building down. And that building counts as one extra power every time you go there again later in the game.
Uh this assistance come off the board after you've taken an action somewhere as well. That's how you get them back and continue to build. So, you get the these pieces. Uh the actions get stronger. You need to unlock more pieces from your board so you can place them down, give yourself some more flexibility.
With uh where's that with these actions, or sometimes bonuses? Yep. And then there's also some things that you're racing to achieve. And you'll slowly put your assistants over to those when you do them. So, there's lots of different ways of getting money uh sorry, of getting points. Uh you can try to find foreign agents who can give you some extra actions if you get pairs of matching uh country flags. And then you just play through that until one of the end game triggers occurs. Mhm. Count up uh any extra final scores. There are some majorities on some of these boards. And whoever has the most points will win. So, we managed to avoid this game for about 10 for for 10 years of its existence.
Avoid? Like people would say, "What? You have not played Yokohama?" I'm like, "I know. There are so many great games, you know?" And just like it's games in our libraries are competing with each other, literally.
Yeah. But we've played it now. So, what do you think? It is a great game. I can see why I would say that this is a classic because the mechanics is quite unique when you need to build up slowly your the strength for your actions. You need to strategize where you place your agents. Uh assistant assistants each round you have to unlock and you have to have enough assistants so that you can place three because if you, you know, spread it around every way, I mean, you need assistant each way you go through a a space, but if it's like spread around and you're not doing it and it's just a waste of assistant. So, that balance off and then you need to, you know, let go of your assistant forever if you achieve some goals. It's a lot of good points. And then all the while you need to focus on getting the points, which is order fulfillment, the church board, and uh the goods, um and so on.
It is a I think this is a I don't know any other games that feels like this. Yeah, I enjoyed it as well. I think it is you you get to like the interaction is low to medium because you can early on you're just kind of racing to get to some of the better things. So it it only costs you a coin if you want to go where someone else is. So
could be pretty tight.
coins can be tight. So occasionally your plan to get a little bit disrupted there. But then as the game goes on you've got a few big majorities where getting in somewhere first becomes quite important and that's where getting those extra actions and finding the combos to make that work. Uh they become very timing timing critical uh big moves. And I I like it's actually quite a short game I think.
It is actually, yeah. I do like that it has those timing critical big moves. Yeah, you get in there quickly you can be the one who gets the extra crate which could be worth five points. They're all little bits of points cuz it's an accumulative kind of game. I think it plays quite simply which is really nice. Yeah, it's a simple matter of put two tokens or three tokens down, move and get an action which is in most cases is quite simple.
Yep. That is an old school kind of feel. You know, this is a 2016 game. Games have gotten a lot more complicated since 2016 and one of the things that struck me about yeah, sometimes it's confirmation bias cuz I already know it's an older game.
Yeah. But I look at this and I look at you know, you get all there's all these bonuses for placing houses on tiles at given times and there's only about five different icons that you can get from it. So you know what you're getting into. You know what you're trying to achieve. I feel like there'd be 20 different icons and they'd do a whole lot of different things if this were a a more modern game.
Modern, yeah. I actually agree with that. Like it's simplicity is great. Now one downside of this new reprint is that the size of the text and this might be Stella only problems, especially the technology technology cards. So, for me it is quite small. I don't know if it's meant to be standard size cards or not, but that's the only thing that I had some difficulties reading. It's very small. That's it. Now, these are these are all components that come with the new version as you see it. There was also a premium release of tokens that came out at the same time. So, they are these are the resources and they're just wooden versions of the resources. Very nice these FCM coins here.
not quite metal, it's just like plastic I think, but it looks quite heavier or is it I think it's metal, but it's a dull kind of metal, so it doesn't doesn't clink too much. Yeah, so all these are compatible with the original Yokohama. It is mostly compatible with Yokohama dual. This is the exception and we'll tell you about it later. Yes. So, let's just compare with the old Yokohama before we get to the Yokohama dual, shall we? Yeah, so there's a few things that have changed for components. We had a a more classic kind of pawn back in the past, now it's this little assistant shape or this screen printed
person shaped screen printed presidents. Yeah. And then in the original version we had cubes instead of assistants. That's actually I don't mind because the size is more significant. I mean, this is I don't know, like when you look through the board quickly and then trying to decide what's your assistants, what's not. That looks more different anyways. Yeah, I'd I'd I'd go one step further on that. I think this is a clear example where cubes cubes weren't just fine, cubes were perfect. Um, now we've got these we've got these they didn't need to look like people cuz they fall all over the place and people just people aren't going to stack them up because they take some effort to do. Okay. And when you're looking out over the board, a cube looks the same size from whatever direction you're looking at. So that uniformity really helps.
Okay. Yeah. I think there's a few too many games out there that should use they use a thing-shaped piece when a cube is not just fine but better. Okay. Um so, you know, that was kind of the case here, I thought. Mhm. Uh there was a scoreboard back in the old days where you put the objectives. Uh now you are tracking on your own player board.
Your own score on your player board with some more of these assistants that uh slot into these spaces as you count them up. I don't like that so much either. I prefer the
either way. Yeah, I feel like it's easier to uh not forget to count your score if it's right in front of you, which is good. But then you can't see everyone you can't see who's ahead at a glance. Yeah. Yeah. Uh so, you know, to each their own on that. Yeah, it's double layer board, which is like these days almost every game has got double layer board. Yep. We do have these nice wooden houses. That's an improvement on the cardboard pieces that didn't go on the double layer that went on the non-double layer board in the previous game. Yeah. Uh and these separable pieces as well. Uh you could randomize the benefits on the old boards. Now it's done with these separable pieces, which is kind of cool except I mean you could argue that you have to shuffle the bigger canal board
Mhm. uh with the small boards and it's like I can feel which one is different but it's pretty easy to
Yes. pretty easy to randomize. Let's have a look at have a look at some of the boards from the older fashion. So, basically the game play are the same. Uh the obviously it's more updated, you know, components of artwork. And I would say that this is a reprint basically with different components. Like this has got some, you know, Japanese. I assume that's Yeah, that's Japanese writing. And this is the components compared to let's say that board. Yeah. So it's almost the same. Um colors are slightly different. And yeah, it's like it's just different artwork mainly and some different components. Yeah, it is it is a pure reprint. If you do own the Tasty Minstrel orange version, you don't need to add the Synapses version. I do prefer the art overall. I like the This gives a nice kind of Yeah, warm pastel color and that is a preference to me. I think the orange box pops off the shelf more, but this one looks nicer on the table. Yep.
Now let's get to the two-player Yokohama. Does the dual version of Yokohama still feel the same? So this is a This is Synapses release here. This is by the same designer. Yep. And now we'll have a look at how this plays differently. So immediately you'll see the same sorts of action areas and the same sorts of power, but it's no longer a movement puzzle. It's now a essentially a worker placement game. There's eight spaces that can only be gone to by one player and then two that can be used multiple times. Uh you get four actions per round and you use these power cards here. And to kind of replicate the way that the original game works where you have to build up power gradually, in this game round by round you have to place your workers in order from weakest to strongest. So on your first turn you'll take your one power guy, put him in a location, resolve that.
Mhm. And then uh I'll do the same.
same. And then, your turn again.
Then, I'll go the two. Now, you can as you get to fours, you'll be able to build your buildings again. And you can also bolster the power with these bonus power cards. So, you can get ones and twos, and you can play a single one with each card play, if you wish. And so, that's going to help you to try to build up your actions and and get the things done that you want.
And this is like worker placement, so only one player can go to one place as standard rules, except these two. Yeah. Uh at the So, the engine building, it's still putting houses down. One of the few actions which is no longer in the game is the unlocking stuff action. Now, you simply pay the cost for what you're building as you build it.
Yes. Uh at the end of each round, you get to pay to upgrade one of these cards to be one power stronger, as long as you've got the money left behind. So, that I suppose represents getting more assistance out of the game. And there's a small change to the foreign agent mechanism, where instead of trying to get a pair of matching flags, and that flags flag scoring is out of the game. Now, it's based on these four achievements, essentially. So, race to get three orders, race to get three technologies, two church cards, two sold goods. Yeah. And once you get them, you get one of the foreign agents, and again, that can be used as an extra action anywhere that can go on top of an existing worker at a strength of three. So, that kind of has the same overall vibe as the original game. After four rounds, you add up points. Uh all the points are scored at the end, but it's really going to come from very similar range of things, like completing orders, technologies with scores on them, uh the church cards, and having more of them than your opponent. So, it's still got those majorities.
Uh but, everything else feels very familiar. Yeah. And just quickly on the things that I was going to say, it's almost compatible, the upgraded components. It's The only thing that is not compatible is this import goods. So, flip side it's the same, while in here there's a mechanic way you get it, you flip it, one point, four points, and you can't flip the um the upgraded goods. That's basically it. Yeah, so that's a bit of a I don't know if it's a miss on the components. I don't know if it's supposed to be fully compatible, but that is how you uh count up the points at the end of the game rather than as you go along. It's because you flip them and score them. Yes. So, how does this two-player? Does that actually Because a two-player game, according to us, a good two-player has got this tight tug-of-war um that plays two players. So, how is How's this one compare, Taran?
Um I suppose there's a couple ways to look at it. So, when you compare this with base Yokohama, things probably are a little bit tight because one lot tighter because once someone has claimed one of these spaces, it's not going to be claimable again. And in order to get a certain space, you have to to get in there early, you have to get in with a weaker action. So, from that perspective, it is a little bit tighter than the original game. Mhm. However, it doesn't feel tight like many other duels that are out there on the market. I do feel like you've got enough different There's enough options for scoring points that players can kind of specialize on different things. Um often I think if one person's going for faith, the other can go for exports or techs, and it's not going to become that tight of a contest.
Yeah. And the foreign agents, once you get to the end of the game, give you enough ways of going into a place that someone has blocked. Yeah. So, there's a lot of tighter duels out there on the market, and if you do like that push and pull I don't know if this is going to scratch the itch. I know that I think we discussed this as well between us that the assistant mechanics where you've planned ahead where you want to put assistant and then the opponents, and this is related to what you say as well, I guess, the opponents can sort of see where you think the opponents are going to go where they start the assistant putting more and more assistants in that one spot. There's nothing of that here. I like that mechanics in the original Yokohama, and I kind of like miss that here in the duel, right? Yeah, I agree. I think that was what That was what made Yokohama fun.
And having taken that away and put a different action selection mechanism on it, which I mean most duels do that. Mhm. Um but the action selection here is It's not as interesting as the movement and color.
um very unique, yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think it's competing with its own. Um if you don't compare to that, then it might be okay. It might be quite tight, but because you automatically compare with the original Yokohama, of course, and that particular mechanics is what Yokohama Yokohama, I think. Out of the three, which one is your favorite? Including the cubes in the in the original Yokohama. I mean, look, it it's hard to compare the first and second Yokohamas. They are component preferences.
Synapses one looks great on the table. Yeah. Um Tasty Minstrel's probably was a little bit more functional in terms of the components, but yes, I would be especially because the Euro is not that long as well. Takes a while to set up, but it is not a very long game. It's It's your mid weight. It's not going to take your whole night. And so, I think I would play that over the duel. Mhm. I think even at two players, I would have more fun planning my movements and doing that at two players than I would with the duel. Okay. So, that's what we think. Have you played any of the Yokohamas? Is it one of your favorite games? Please let us know in the comments and which one do you think is the most interesting? And thank you so much for watching and have a great day. Bye.