The design process of one of the world's best designers, Corey Konieczka
Transcript
what's up my friends and welcome to the board game Design Lab today got a little something different for you it's not a specific Topic in game design I'm actually talking to Corey kesa about Corey kesa talking about his personal game design process how does he bring a game to life and if you're asking the question well who is Cory kesa well I want to just read you a few numbers really quick number five number 10 number 66 number 95 number 108 number 130 number 183 number 198 and those numbers correspond to Cory's games just a few just a handful of Cory's games in the top 200 games ranked on Board Game Geek he's worked on games like Twilight Imperium several different Star Wars games battl Star Galactica eldrich horror forbidden Stars descent Journeys in the dark Rune Wars manions of Madness Starcraft the list just goes on and on and on and in this episode from way back in 2020 we just dive into how does he make a game happen how does he prototype how does he come up with ideas how does he know when to walk away from a design and move on to something else we also get into what it's like to work on licensed IPS such as Star Wars and all the different challenges that go into that we get into his pathway into the gaming industry and a whole lot more and so if you're a designer I think you're going to enjoy
this episode because it is just a master class in game design and what does it look like for a master of the craft a person that has just had so much success over the years how how does he bring a game to life and then what can we all take away from it one of the greatest designers in my opinion on the planet Cory welcome to the show hey thanks that's very flattering yeah man I mean you've designed just some of the best games of all time so many games of yours are in the top 100 top 200 on on BGG uh some some of my favorite games you've designed is I'm just really excited to just sit and chat and get your uh ideas your thoughts your opinions you know how your design process works you know what what you've been through what you've seen how you've overcome different challenges and whatnot I mean just some of the games that that are listed in your profile you got Twilight Imperium fourth edition Battle Star Galactica descent eldr horror Mansions of Madness star War Rebellion Star Wars Imperial assault Star Wars outer rim spacehulk Death Angel Starcraft Gears of War discover lands on I mean just it goes on and on and on and you've designed so many amazing games and I'm just pumped to to get a little behind the scenes look at your process how in the world you come up with these ideas how do you overcome you know challenges and whatnot but before we get into all of that who are you how'd you get into game design all that kind of thing sure yeah I mean I've been playing games as long as I can remember and not just that I've
also just as a hobby been designing them I mean even as a kid like me and my brothers we would make up our own little games we' make up our own little Sports just kind of always be dabbling in that sort of thing um and As I Grew Older like in um I would say even in high school like me and my friends we had like a a madeup ccg that we made that would play at lunch um that we were continually like evolving and playing and so it it's always just kind of been a part of my life just as like what I did to um entertain myself some people read some people watch movies I do those things but I also kind of feel like designing games in my spare time um and so as I got older and I was um kind of graduating college I was hanging out with my friends and designing some games on the side that we just play when we would get together and um as luck would have it I came across a posting on Fantasy Flight games website that they were looking for game designers um and I had at the time just picked up Twilight Imperium Third Edition and like it had become my obsession and so when I saw this posting on their website I'm like whoa that's cool I wonder if I could turn this h into a job and so I um wrote up a resume and
sent it to FFG and I sent along with it a um a fan-made expansion for Twilight Imperium that me and one of my friends were working on and I mean this could have been a disaster like you're sending a fan-made game design idea to uh little did I know at the time the um founder of the company who had created the game Twilight Imperium and so it it was going to receive some critiques one way or another right um and apparently it it must have um impressed him in some way because they called me and flew me out there for an interview and this was in I want to say 2008 is that right 2006 somewhere around there um and yeah I guess the interview went well because they called me back and told me I got the job so I've been doing it ever since yeah I'd say it went pretty well uh I think it has gone also well for them as as many games as you've been able to work on and have your hand in you've made them a few dollars over the last several years and so tell me about working for FFG uh because I know a lot of people especially you know a lot of people listen to this they they think gosh I want to be in the industry I want to work full-time as a designer you know so they're looking at a guy like you and saying okay I want to I want to travel that path so tell me a little bit more what it's like to work for a maor major publisher a major company uh you don't have to go into the nitty-gritty details all that kind of thing but just kind of give me the overall overview of what it's like yeah I mean it evolved a lot
over the years when I was hired at FFG um there were somewhere in the realm of 20 employees and there were four other people that were hired the same day that I was and so they had just added like a fifth of their Workforce to the um to the company so it's kind of a big deal um and there were um a handful of other designers and developers there there was Kevin Wilson who's great um John good enough worked there and so I was I was game designer number three that was kind of joining the team now I say game designer number three but there was also of course Christian the founder of the company who like he's the guy who designed Twilight Imperium and designed a fair number of their games especially early on um and he was kind of the Visionary behind um a fair number of the projects but it was um I mean I was just kind of like thrown into the deep end like hey we're working on this World of Warcraft game and we're nearing the end of development we need somebody to design some new bosses for it and so that was kind of the first job that I had as a professional game designer was designing bosses for a game that was mostly um mostly finished in its design it just needed more content and so I kind of started out by just designing some content and then later on I I think my second project was okay now we've got this game um Warrior nights no
that wasn't my second one I think my second was probably britania and Britannia was more of here's this popular game this older game that we want to bring back and I was doing zero game design on that one my job was to just um kind of help produce this game and make it um more accessible and so a lot of what I did there was like working with the rules and getting all the parts to come together helping like get the art and the and the graphics and that sort of stuff so I mean throughout my tenur FFG I kind of saw all the different parts of what goes into making a game and when you're a small company you wear a lot of hats I mean we didn't have an art um department at the time we had a graphic design team and they did the graphics but um we didn't have a sculpting team and so like a lot of these things was just kind of like all right this is on the designer to do um and so was a lot of I mean a lot of learning by doing which I think is a lot of what um game designer starting out today have have to do as well yeah for sure and it changed so much in really really a short amount of time you know roughly 10 years or so to be drastically different so tell me kind of more about how how things are now like when they assign a game like a game idea comes in like how does that begin you know does the founder say hey we just got the license to this new IP and
so we're gonna make a game about it or does somebody from the inside kind of come up with ideas and pitch different things or you know some kind of amalgamation of both those things like how does it work especially in the early stages of you know kind of developing an idea that's going to be a game sure like I'm sure it varies from company to company but at FFG I mean both of those things you mentioned happened um there were situations where hey we just got this IP for Battlestar Galactica and we want to make a game for it and so then my boss would approach me and say hey Corey do you want to work on this let's discuss what this game could be and that would start with like a brainstorming meeting of us just like drawing out our wild ideas of like what types of um gameplay moments do you want this to capture what's the focus of it is the game about being individual characters or is it a more epic game where we're controlling fleets of ships like anytime that you're um starting design on a game you've got to decide what the scope of it is right you've got to decide like who who are you as the player and what are you trying to do and so um regardless of where the idea for the game came from the um first step in the process was always to decide those two things um and we would call that a vision meeting um which was just us sitting down and discussing and agreeing on the basic parameters and um after we had decided on those things we would move on to like all right all right this
sounds like a good idea for a game now Corey run off and make a playable prototype and um and see how see if it's any fun so that's that's that's where it would go gotcha now tell me about kind of how things are are structured there like do they have like a lead designer that then gets assigned you know kind of sub designers to kind of help out with a project especially I guess bigger games you need more people things like that tell me kind of how the hierarchy works because I feel like this is something a lot of people are curious about most most people listen to this show are designing as a hobby right it's just them and maybe their cat that are designing game and they're trying to do everything and figure it out out but like tell me kind of how things work at a you know bigger company like FFG um I I mean like I said it changed over the years um when I started there um Christian the the owner of the company was basically the one who had the final say who's also a game designer himself and so um he would play every game and he would provide his critiques and he would like draw a line in the sand say no we can't do this or yes we can do that so he was he was the um The Guiding Light as it would be um and later that role changed it evolved um for a fair number of years I was the the lead game designer there at FFG and so it became my job to not only design my own games but to spend half my time um kind of guiding the other teams so I would play
every game that every other team was working on whether it was a Miniatures game or card game or board game and I would provide critiques and um suggestions and occasionally have to blow something up if I thought it wasn't good enough um and and so that was that was like I said half of my job while I was there at the end and um now that position is um being led by Nate French who's a brilliant designer who's done um a lot of stuff for FFG he's done um one of the most popular ones is Lord of the Rings um the lcg he's also worked on Marvel he he's done a lot of card games specifically but very bright guy and he's uh he's kind of that in that role now helping the um the other designers kind of um tune up their designs and and flesh them out but um but on a day-to-day basis for the designers it's it's the team size can vary depending upon the size and scope the project it can sometimes be a single person designing a game and then like showing it to lead game designer it could be a team of designers or a designer and a developer or designers and producers so I mean it there's no one-size fits all solution for um what a team looks like
on a project at a company like that gotcha and that makes a lot of sense you know depending on is this a small card game or is this a $100 tons of mini Miniatures you know 3-hour epic experience so it makes a lot of sense now what was the first game that you really had a hand in that you could say okay this is this is a game that's mine I'm not just making bosses I'm not just making content what was the first one that I that I was the only designer on or was either that or just like one of the you know the first games you really felt like I have a at least a giant part in the game design of this particular game sure I would probably say that was the new edition of warrior Knights that we did and um Warrior knights was another um game from I think it was the 80s um it was a Games Workshop game I believe and we were trying to reimagine it for um the Modern Age I say modern but this was probably 12 years ago um and so my job was to kind of look at this older game and like remove as much of it that I thought we needed to remove and um inject new life into it and so like I designed like basically new systems for for a lot of it while keeping the heart of the game so I came up with like a new combat system I came up with like this new action system and that was really the first time where I
felt like I was able to prove to my boss that I could not just design content but that I could design systems and so um like the main Action System in that game is that everybody has a handful of different actions that they can do and they're represented on these cards and each round you choose which actions you want to do and you put the cards face down into a pile and then the pile gets shuffled up and then the cards get drawn out one at a time and everybody gets to do whatever the action is on the card um but cards also had secondary effects where after you would resolve the action it would be placed in one of the tracks that could like trigger a lot of the um cleanup and Status um status phases that you usually need in the game so it was it was kind of a way to deconstruct like a really rigid um round structure where a lot of times it's like all right here's the start of the turn you've got like the refresh phase and then you've got the activation phase and you got this phase and that phase well we just kind of like removed all those things and made them come out organically um and I feel like that was the first time when I was really able to um like I said get in there and try to design something that was new even though like at least 50% of it was an existing game that I was um fiddling with yeah for sure and Warrior Knights this is a game I came into contact with
early on in my kind of gaming experience this is several years ago and I was so impressed by all the different systems that come together to work in this really cool way I love the the abstract nature of some of it like you know you send ships off and do different things it's kind of like away from the board it's just little tokens moveing on a map but then you also had like you know dudes on the map actively engaged in battle so it's a really cool mixture of abstract and not so abstract and I think it was just a really cool design that you you came up with now fast forward a little bit and you kind of get to do something similar working on Twilight Imperium fourth edition where you're taking a game that that's been around but now this one's a little more belov than Warrior Knights this one's got a little bit more of a built-in audience and so tell me about you know working on that tell me some of the similarities maybe some things you learn from working on you know older games already and then doing it on a new version of a such a beloved game it's like I don't want to screw this up you know I can imagine a little bit pressure on that one so tell me about it yeah and I mean to be fair with Warrior Knights like I did design those systems but like things like the way that armies worked in that game the way that Expeditions worked these were all things that were designed by other people and so I definitely can't um claim credit for like how fun that game is I can I could say that it was the first time I was able to flex my um Creative Design chops but I don't want to belittle the the work that all the other designers did um but I mean to relate that to Twilight Imperium it was um the the fourth edition was a very
tricky project that was kind of simmering in the background for years now like I said the Third Edition was one of the main reasons why I got a job at FFG and I was fortunate enough to um be the designer of the expansions for Twilight Imperium Third Edition and so like some of the ideas that I had come up with even before I worked at Fantasy fly games ended up making their way into an expansion which was which was really cool and like I was very like um star struck by the idea that I would actually get to make content for a game that I loved so much as a fan um did they actually take on the the expansion you sit in with your resume did they actually take that on and it become an expansion later or something totally different so um so Christian wanted to do an expansion he had some ideas floating around his head and I had some ideas too from like the fan-made stuff that I had made and so um we collaborated together on that and I um ended up taking like his ideas I took my ideas we came up with new ideas and all of those kind of like came together to um the Twilight Imperium Third Edition expansions some of it was things that we resurrected from second edition that had never made it into Third Edition so it was it was just this hodgepodge of like all the best ideas that we had been sitting on for years and we kind of brought them together into into an expansion awesome and then so let's go fourth edition so the fourth edition was like okay now I've had my hand in
working on a third edition or I guess two Third Edition expansions and now we've got um a huge fan base for Twilight Imperium and we're looking back we're like okay people have playing this game for 10 years now what do they want out of a fourth edition what do we want out of a fourth edition what can we even do like to improve upon the previous one and uh so we brought in um danne belri who's a um developer designer at FFG who honestly has played more Twilight Imperium their Edition games than I have and probably more than a lot of people in the world is just crazy um knew the ins and outs of that game and he had that perspective of like of what it's like as a gamer where I've just been in that world so long as like designing and tinkering with stuff that it was good to have like the different perspectives of what he liked as a fan what I liked as a designer and what we thought the audience wanted and so at the same time we're working with Christian who's the designer of first edition he's the one who created the universe and so there were lots of just um meetings and brainstorming sessions of like well let's let's pick and choose like what we think the most important things are let's play a game of Twilight Imperium third edition with no expansion
content in it and see how we feel about it let's play a game of Twilight Imperium Third Edition with our favorite expansion content in it and see what we feel about that and so um some of it was just kind of picking and choosing our favorite aspects of Third Edition that exist and some of it was just us kind of turning a critical eye towards the game and saying well you know what if we had to be perfectly honest we're not 100% happy with the way that the trade system works like it's fine it's okay but if we were to kind of remove that system from the game and design something else in its place how would we do that um and so we just kind of went through the game system by system and had those discussions and then danne was creating prototypes he was creating content for it so a lot of my involvement in fourth edition was very much kind of directing the vision of it knowing having worked with Christian for so long having worked with Chris for over a decade and kind of knowing his sensibilities knowing not only what he loved about game design but what he loved about the Twilight Imperium universe and so I was kind of in between Christian the creator of the game and danne the designer developer fourth edition and kind of steering both of them and um trying to make sure that this game
wasn't um it it could somehow appeal to fans of Third Edition but also not be um not have so much in it that it would turn away new fans and I think that miraculously we found that happy medium um and it just took a lot of hard work and a lot of play testing yeah for sure now as far as play testing in you know Third Edition especially it's like all right today we're going to play Twilight Imperium and I when I mean today I mean today you know I can see how that would be an interesting challenge every day you come to work all right guys we're going to do this and this is going to be our whole work day and but yeah you definitely yeah you definitely pulled it off with fourth edition fourth edition it's it's it's a really great great game now let's kind of switch gears go ahead I was just gonna say with the um with Third Edition when I was working on the expansions we had a uh a group of local players that used to come into the Fantasy Flight Game Center and they would they would play Twilight and pum every week it was like every Wednesday night they would play Twilight Imperium and so I just kind of got to know these guys and had them sign some ndas and I said hey guys we're working on expansion what do you think of me hijacking hijacking your group for the next six months and US playing this stuff and that's how we got a lot of um lot of our early testing for that game done or that expansion done yeah that's a great great way to do it now let's switch gears a little bit
let's talk about the first game that you really felt like was yours right wasn't based on something else maybe based on an IP you know that that's fun but like something that's you know uniquely a Cory kesa game you had the kind of the 100% you know design of it tell me about that game oh boy I think so this might not technically be the first game that I had 100% control over the design like from scratch but the one that immediately comes to mind would be Battle Star Galactica the board game well that's a a pretty good one to come to mind sir so yeah let's dive into that one tell me about the beginning stages especially so you had an idea about what you're going for but walk me through the design process especially early on sure so like I mentioned earlier that one very much started as a discussion of hey this is an IP we have what kind of game can we make out of this and so the first um memory that I have of it was me and Christian sitting on an airplane we were flying to a business meeting for something unrelated to this and we had two or three hours of uninterrupted time when we were just sitting on the plane and we're just talking about Battlestar Galactica and what was cool about it and what we would want out of a game and so he was the one who who pitched the idea of it being like a a a a a game where you didn't know who you could trust where there's potentially someone who
working against you to represent kind of the sylon aspect of it and we talked about the idea that like yes Everybody Plays a different character this is there's there's so many likable and unlikable characters in that show that people just want to kind of role play um and so we just kind of spitballed some ideas about like what sort of things you might be able to do probably jotted some notes down on a on a napkin and Drew like some pictures of stuff um and I just kind of took that whole discussion and wrote it up into like a pitch of what this game could potentially be um and like it was just such a such an inspiration the IP that I felt like there was almost a fully formed idea after this one discussion in my head about what what this could be and so as soon as I got back in the office and I had wrapped up work on whatever project I had going on at the time I just threw together a prototype as fast as I can and that's that's something that I always try with my process I always try to um once I have an idea for a game and I've kind of jotted some stuff down so I don't forget it it's like go from that step to something playable in as short a period of time as you can usually in like under a week I can do it sometimes I can do it in a day it depends upon the size of the game um and then I had something
playable and I sat down and we tried it and yeah it was clunky there were parts of it that didn't work but it was pretty Apparent from even the first play that like we had something we had we had captured something unique um and I think what that that heart that we found was the the social Dynamic of the game and it was very unlike anything else I had worked on previously um because I mean the the main emotion in that game is paranoia and so um once we had discovered like that that was the heart of the game then it was my job to like all right reinforce every mechanic that um contributes to that to that heart of the game and remove every mechanic that does not and isn't crucial to the um to the underlying game mechanics and so it's a lot of kind of adding to certain parts of the game design and um and reducing because uh one thing especially as I as I get older in my years of designing games I I don't want my games to be so overwhelming that people are just bombarded with uh hodge podge of different mechanics and different things that they have to remember I want them to be able to get to the fun as fast as possible yeah that's a really really
good point and especially if you if you find something that is super fun about a game then how in the world do you keep you know pointing back to it over and over again and cutting away all the other stuff actually my brain always goes back to sports and football we had a back when I was playing JV ball in high school we we were playing this game and they they could not stop the run this other team they could not do it and so we ran the ball over and over and over again we'd run option left we'd run option right option left option right all the way down the field score and didn't do it again in and the quarterback was getting so frustrated because he wanted to throw the ball he's like coach can I can I throw the can I throw a slant can I do anything and uh and the coach was like no man they they can't stop it so we're just going to keep doing it and the quarterback said coach they they know what play We're going to run and the coach said yeah but they don't know if we're going left or right like well that's so he just kept on doing it and so I think with Battle Star Galactic like you're saying everything points towards that feeling of I think you're a traitor and you know and just over and over and over again that feeling of gosh I don't think you're on my team even if they are you don't you don't think they are necessarily and so it's so cool how that game you know plays into that just paranoid atmosphere that experience but tell me a little more about your prototyping process so you're able to you know prototype a game pretty early what does that look like is it just super simple like note cards and things like that at first or or kind of tell me about your process now sure so um I actually went to school for graphic design and so um I'm luckily able to use those skills in my day-to-day life um I can't make anything as pretty as like a published game can be but um I always
have an eye towards like the user interface and kind of what cards look like where the information is and so even in my early prototypes um I've got cards laid out in a format where it's like here's where I want the information um here's what I want people looking at my my game boards are usually just like a white sheet of paper with a bunch of boxes on it and any text that we need and so I'm like all right we're going to have the Battle Star Galactica it's going to be in the center of the board so I'll just like put a big circle there or I'll find a picture from the Internet or something that slap it down and then I'll put some boxes that are the spaces you can move on so I mean it's not pretty but it's got all the functional Parts there it's got the numbers it's got the text it's got the colors kind of in the positions and ways that I want them to be and then as we start playing with that I can move stuff around and say ah everyone's kind of not able to find this icon on the card maybe we should make it bigger move it and so those sorts of things I've got my eye on very early in a prototype yeah very cool and so tell me about how the Prototype will will change as you because I assume you play it one time and you realize wow okay this whole system over here is garbage I need to replace that so tell me kind of how the prototyping uh stage evolves as you get more and more into the kind of the middle of the game design sure so I mean I'll I'll leave a play test with a note book just filled with things that I want to change and I'll take those notes and I'll turn them into like
action items I'm like okay here's the 15 things that I need to change on cards or here's this one system that isn't working in the game and so then I'll brainstorm like ideas for a way of replacing that system and then I'll decide okay well if I make that change here's the 10 cards that refer to that so I need to redesign those two and so the way my process will work is that say say it's Monday I sit down I've got like my list of systems and things that I want to change I'll figure out what mechanics those impact I'll print out those mechanics and then cut them out sleeve them and a day or two later I I have a playable prototype that I can try again that has anywhere from five to 50% of the game completely gutted and replaced with something else yeah awesome and so it sounds like you're the kind of guy that starts with theme you start with EXP experience and then you start trying to figure out you know adding mechanisms that kind of bring out the theme so tell me about that what would be your advice to somebody who's also a theme first designer as far as figuring out the mechanisms that go along with the theme that actually enhance the enhance the theme and kind of bring it to life yeah I mean it's that's that's tricky like it's it's one of those things that is almost so spontaneous that it's hard to describe like I will sit down and I will think about I mean using Battle Star as an example again I'm like all right this is about
paranoia um we we want there to be an objective to the game so our objective is we're trying to get to Cobalt or we're trying to get to earth like our our goal is to reach this certain place and so what is a way to represent that in the game and then I'll just make like a a list of like well here's we could have like a track that you're moving down or we could have like cards that you're collecting that show like where you've traveled to or maybe their numbers and so I'll just kind of like write down a bunch of different like ways of potentially doing this and then I'll think back to kind of the the core tenants of the game and so with paranoia being the core attendent of Battle Star Galactic I'm like all right so you're trying to travel to this place is there any way we can introduce paranoia into that and so that's an example where all right well what if when every time we traveled whoever um in charge or in charge of the ship gets to decide where we're going to go to so we're like okay well they draw two cards and they get to choose where we're going to go and you know what nobody else gets to see the other card the other card goes on the bottom of the deck maybe it was better maybe it was worse but it's just another way for people to be paranoid about what they haven't seen and so there's there's just a very brief example of like here's something that the game needs to do and take a bunch of ideas and find a way to make that core tenant that core emotion of the game um tied into that mechanic
somehow yeah gotcha all right let's switch gears just a little bit let's talk about another one of your games one of my favorite games let's talk about eldrich horror tell me kind of about the design process and that one maybe some of the obstacles you ran in into and that one had to overcome and and figure out ways around sure I mean Elder horror was a game where um we knew that we were building off of a very beloved game being Arkham Horror the second edition that Richard lanus and Kevin Wilson made and there are so many things that people love about that game even today I mean people still play it and it's over a decade old which is a long time for for a board game um and so I basically had a game that existed and Elder Tor was kind of like making a second edition of that game with a different scope and so this was something that um that Christian had had been hoping to do for a long time he's like I would love to take the game Arkham Horror and make it like this globe trotting game where you're just flying around the world like fighting monsters closing Gates doing all the things that you'd expect from Arkham and so um much like working on Twilight and pyramid Third Edition my design um was okay let's find the things that people like about the previous edition of game let's find the things that people love about Arkham Horror and so it's like well these encounter cards that are brok up three parts people love that um
there's the resolution system that uses skills and d6s like it's fine people love that there's um but then we had to take a look at well we're also changing things we we're changing the scope of the game like can you have a game like Elder T where you're traveling the world does it make sense for you to have dollar bills that you're exchanging to buy stuff with and we're like well no I mean each country in the world has its own currency so that doesn't really works so we need to change that system and so um I had originally replaced it with some sort of generic currency system I don't even remember what it was and um early on in the design I had um Nikki valin come in and she was kind of my my co-designer on that game not kind of she was my co-designer on that game she came in and she asked a lot of those hard question she said well why do you even need money in here like it's an extra token like we don't need to perfectly replicate what was in Arkham second edition and so we brainstorm like okay well what alternate ways can you have of of gaining equipment and buying stuff you can't see my air quotes but I'm making them air quotes buying stuff um and so we came up with the idea that what if one of your stats is your basically your charisma and your your ability to convince people to help you um and so that's that was
one main system that we changed there but the The Guiding Light with that particular game as we were designing it was keeping the things that people liked about Arkham Horror but making it as um not as accessible as possible but make it as easy to play as possible we wanted it to be a game where the mechanics could disappear into the background and they just kind of become something that is easy to remember and that you know how to do and because the mechanics become so invisible you can focus on this story that you're having and you can focus on this character and and what they're going through and so it's a lot of just reducing reducing reducing making it as simple as possible but reinforcing like the focus on theme the focus on story and so one of my favorite um design um Mechanics for Elder Tor is the um on the back of the character cards when a character dies or goes insane they're um you tip over their character on the board and somebody else can and you get a new character to replace the person that you lost but now you can go visit that character and you can visit their space to try to recover like all their items and allies and stuff and each character has a personal story um that you encounter when you go
and um encounter that defeated character so for example there's um Ashan Pete and he's um what he's best known for is the fact that he's got his loyal dog Duke that's that's always with him that he loves and so if you were to go visit him after he's gone insane to try to recover all of his items and whatnot he's you you learn that unfortunately Duke has passed away and he's hallucinating and he thinks Duke is still around and so it's this very kind of sad personal story that you get about this character and you can try to influence him to to give you his equipment and stuff so that you can continue the journey for him but you also get this very kind of personal take on it that I mean at its basist element it's just like a couple of lines of texts that we wrote but it makes this very simple mechanic of trying to get his items into something that's very flavorful and interesting and kind of sucks you into the world yeah and I think elor is a great example of exactly what you're talking about as far as making the mechanisms of the game go to the background so that the theme can really be what's the most important thing and that people are experiencing all right switch gears just a little bit let's talk about IPS you've worked on so many different intellectual properties TV shows video games movies all sorts of stuff lots of Star Wars games as well and so what's it like to work on these these IPS where you have
you know potentially a billion dollar multi-billion dollar Corporation looking over your shoulder to making you know making sure that you're doing everything the way that they you know kind of want you to and it makes sense and that kind of thing tell me about what that's like and and just kind of the how the design process maybe changes when you're working on something like a Star Wars game sure I mean the the biggest advantage and disadvantage of working on a licensed game is that you already have a lot of things decided for you there's a way that things work in the universe whether it's Battle Star Galactica or Twilight Imperia sorry I guess Twilight per one but we're talking about licensing Battle Star Galactica or or Star Wars or World of Warcraft like there are things written in stone that are immovable objects this this is what the universe is like this is what these particular factions of characters are like here's how um the currency system in the world works all these sorts of things and like I said it's good and bad the good element is that all these things are decided for you you don't need to figure out how the world works you know how the world works it's your job as a designer now to make how the world Works come through in your game and feel very natural and work with the mechanics um you're not allowed to change these things and I guess that is potentially an issue if you're say designing the game and you're like man you know what
really make this game Sing is that if there was a way that anybody could um use any weapon and then maybe the IP in the IP they said say well actually only certain types of characters can use certain weapons and you're like okay well looks like I can't do that um but personally those issues arise so infrequently and it might just be because I design like usually as a theme first guy where I find that it's easiest to just take inspiration from it and be like oh okay so in their Universe certain characters have to use certain weapons or whatever let's make that interesting let's make that kind of one of the key constraints for characters in the game um and so I mean working with a license that exists is personally inspiring I mean I've been very fortunate to work on a bunch of like IPS that I love and so maybe that's why it feels that way to me um and I've never really had an issue with um working with a licenser I mean they they would see the games that our company has put out and they would say hey you guys know what you're doing when it comes to designing games prove to me that you understand the IP and of course we're going to have to approve it make sure that you're you're doing things correctly um but we trust that you guys
are going to make a great game and so um a licenser in my opinion acts more like a resource for you act more like a person to say like um someone you can lean on and say hey like this we want to do this in the world do you have um a suggestion or do you see a way that we could maybe make this work in your universe and so it's it's very much a a a positive relationship it's not a a world where there's just somebody standing in your way and stopping you from crossing a bridge it's no we want to make an awesome product you want to make an product let's do it together yeah very cool all right let me ask you this as far as you know working with a license and things like that a lot of times you're on some pretty strict deadlines you know especially working for a company like FFG it's big they've got certain dates they want to hit with releasing games and expansions and things like that and so tell me about the process of having to like walk away from a game design or just getting to a point you're like this is not working and maybe having to scrap it you know maybe all of it maybe half of it something like that tell me about your process for basically knowing when to to just drastically change a game walk away from it maybe try something completely different sure I mean that's changed a lot for me over the years and I think that it's it's a very important thing to learn like when to just step away from a game design because it's not working um early on my career that was something that never really like occurred to me
I'm like no you can make any game fun you just need to bang your head against it hard enough but that's not true I mean I've worked on a fair number of games where I work on it for months and months and months and I play it with my boss and he's like you know what this just isn't working like what are we gonna do I think we should just cancel this project and move on to something new and it's as a designer it's it was one of the hardest things for me to hear and years later I found myself in the position where I had to be the one to give that news to other people and it was also a very challenging conversation with people but I don't know like I I I I started viewing it as a very healthy thing like if you're a designer if design is in your blood then you you love doing it you love the experience of it you love the challenge of it and you probably have more ideas than you could ever turn into games and so so more recently my take on it is like I will Design 10 games knowing that nine of them probably won't be any fun in fact 10 of them might not be any fun I don't care I just have this idea that like hey this might be a fun idea and I'll throw together a prototype in a couple of days I'll play it with some
friends and we'll say yeah no that was awful that was really bad like I wish that we had chosen to play a game that was already published instead of this um and that's fine that's my expectation going into it but occasionally You'll Play it and you'll be like oo there's something to this like sure like these things didn't work at all but I feel like there's something unique here that that maybe hasn't been seen before in a game design so this feels like it warrants more attention and then knowing that I'm planning to throw away 90% of the stuff I work on it makes it a lot easier for me to be free to experiment with stuff and to be free to um just try crazy stuff and when I find something that's fun like turn that into something that I'm willing to dedicate more time to and refine and and talk more about yeah that makes a lot of sense it's kind of like back in the day you know old school times when you didn't know how many kids were going to live so you just have 12 of them you know and we'll see how many turn out you know and maybe it's all 12 maybe it's two but I think if you go into game design with the same kind of mentality like you know I don't have any idea how many of these are going to turn out maybe none of them just kind of set that expectation early on it helps out a lot that way you know if it doesn't work out well that you know it's the way it goes interesting story oh sorry I heard an interesting story and I can't verify
whether this is true or not but um I heard that in the early days of Atari the video game company um they would have this event I don't know how frequently they would do it but they would have the the programmers and designers they would throw together their games they would load them into a bunch of arcade cabinets and they would have this night where they would give everybody a bucket of quarters and they would just play these prototypes and um at the end of the night they would after everybody's gone home they would open up the machines and they would see which machines got the most quarters because that was an indication to them that these were games that people like wanted to keep playing and they didn't want to stop and so those were the ones that they decided to like turn into real games or at least continue development on and the other ones it would just kind of like throw away they're like ah people weren't interested in this one let's try something new yeah that's a really really great way to do it so let's kind of keep talking about this process of basically being in the middle when the game design becomes a bit of a grind when you're coming to work and you're playing Twilight Imperium and it's going to take eight hours of your day you know that kind of thing tell me about your best advice when the game design maybe isn't as fun as the early stages when it's all brand new and fresh and got all these ideas brainstorming and flying around tell me you know basically your best idea for the grind portion as you're trying to get the game done sure um well
personally I've learned that I'm a very manic depressive game designer and by that I mean I will sit down I'll play the game with some people and I'll walk away from it and I'll feel like this is the most brilliant game that anybody's ever done uh we're gonna sell these like hot cakes and then I'll play the exact same game two days later maybe even with the same people and I'll walk away from him going oh my gosh this game is awful nobody's gonna buy this game like it's just like nothing's working everybody was bored the whole time like what happened and um it's it's it could be a struggle like you're you're going to reach those points in any game you're working on whether it's the the discouraging news that you get or whether it's just the grind like you need to find a way to muscle through those things you need to either just buckle down and say you know what things will change and if I just work hard enough and I kind of tackle it one step at a time it'll get better or like we talked about earlier maybe it's that well maybe there is a problem and you just need to kind of work on a side project for like a day to just kind of clear your mind of it and then the next day you can come back to it fresh and you won't feel like so overwhelmed by the world and overwhelmed by everything you still need to do um but ultimately the the main way that I make
it through kind of that middle part and the end of a game design is just I just make lots of lists I make lots of lists of here's every little thing that I want to do partially so I don't forget but partially also to just make sure that I'm making a little bit of progress every day and that I'm checking a little thing a little box I've I've I'm one step closer to this game actually being in the world and I mean it's it's a little different when you've got a a deadline right and you're like well I need I've got these 50 things that I need to do this week like okay there's that happens sometimes but for the most part I think as long as you can break it up in a small enough chunks and to just focus on like all right I'm gonna do this one thing and after you finish that one thing move on to what's thing number two and what's thing number three and just the more you do it the better you get at it yeah absolutely and it's kind of that old adage doesn't matter necessarily how slowly you go as long as you don't stop and just you know keep finding ways to move one Step Ahead at a time let's keep let's keep traveling down this road what does it look like for you when you're kind of past that now of the games basically done you know effectively done but now you're polishing it up you're polishing the the rules you're polishing the different aspects of it you're trying of tweaking the thing you're making it balance that kind of thing tell me your best advice for that stage of kind of the getting it ready for print um I mean there's there's a lot of important things there the most
important one is just attention to detail um the last thing you want is to publish a game print however many copies of it and find there to be some drastic issue with it that you just that that you were just staring at the game so closely that you didn't see and sometimes that involves like getting other people involved whether it's proof readers editors other designers to look at your work um but when you're when you're getting near the finish line it's it's important to not kind of give into the fatigue and to not say h I'm so tired of looking at this like I just can't look at it anymore we we'll just it must be good enough it's like no you need to kind of grit your teeth and print out your cards for the 100th time and find a quiet place to sit down and read those words as if you've read them you're reading them for the first time today um when I worked at FFG we had um this great practice that we called card Council and we like to do it with every game we worked on whether it was a board game a card game minis game whatever it was um and what it would be is would the designer and the producer and they would grab some other people that were like they probably play tested the game but they weren't on the team and they would bring them into a room and they would spend however many days it took to just
read through every card they would either print them out or we would like throw them up on the on that TV screen in the conference room and we would all look up at that one card would focus all our attention on let's read this one card together and see if there's any issues that we haven't thought of and we say oh yeah no that card looks good and then we move on to the second card and then the third card and then the fourth card and that was kind of our last like sanity check of not only like the mechanics of the game but also so like the wording that we're using on everything and it was it was just a way to kind of put that last layer of polish on it to to make it feel that much more professional yeah that's a really really good system and I totally agree if you have a friend especially that has you know really good attention to detail because I've noticed a lot of designers I talk to they're Visionaries more than they are like nitty-gritty detail oriented people and so if you can surround yourself with with folks that really notice little grammar mistakes little errors in different things it's really really helpful if you can bring them on to kind of go through that last stage and making sure it all looks good before you print several thousand of them and it's hard to undo that especially if it's a problem in the rule book or you know especially if it's something for how the game plays now let me ask let me ask you this you know before we we got recording you mentioned that you've now moved over you're doing something different you're not working at Fantasy Flight anymore now you're working for asmo day kind of as as your own basically uh design studio and it's
going to be very very different structure different setup so tell me a little bit more about that and tell me maybe some of the challenges you're running into now you know going from having a big team and now you're kind of going more you know solo designs and things like that tell me about what's going on sure so um uh Fantasy Flight is is an asthma Day game studio and so um I had been talking with them for a while about trying to do some more different types of games um some more experimental type stuff and um we eventually came up with the idea of me spinning off into my own studio and so I still kind of work for the same um bosses and I work with a lot of the same people in sales and production that that I used to um but I went from being one person in a I don't know 60 to 80 person Studio to a um basically a oneman studio where I freelance out my graphic design and my art and almost it was almost a return to um where IID started FFG where I kind of had to wear a lot of different hats um and so I took all that experience that I had from doing that stuff and now I'm using it to um to run my my small little studio uh it's called unexpected games and um my goal is to do games that can
kind of stand out in a very crowded industry um and so um it's changed a lot of kind of what I approach in my my day-to-day um design and and just what my workflow is like um and so like I mentioned when I was at FFG I would spend about half my time designing my games so I would spend half my time kind of um uh overseeing the other game designs that were going on in various capacities and so now I'm spending my time focused on whatever project I'm working on right now like okay here's my my goal at the start of this was all right I'm going to spend four days a week focusing on the product that I need to get done the product that has a deadline for um that I can see months in advance I'm going to chip away at that and I'm going to spend SP one day a week designing something new and what that is I don't care um and so basically what I've been doing is as I kind of come up with ideas or I've got documents and documents of different ideas that I've had over the years that I've just never had an opportunity to pursue and um when that day a week would come up I would set aside what I'm working on I would say all right let's pick from this list whatever looks the most inspiring to me to and let's let's make a prototype or
let's make part of a prototype and find find time to play it um and so that's that's kind of been my goal for the last uh eight months or so and my schedule has changed a little bit it hasn't been it the perfectly four days a week working on that thing one day of week um doing um new game designs sometimes it's two days doing new game designs it it really has vared depending upon um how much time I need to dedicate to my current project but as a designer it's been very different because if you don't set aside that time to like try to do something new and try to like build something from scratch then you're just going to become overwhelmed with all the stuff you have to do you're just going to be like stuck with the here's the here's the deadline I have looming here's the here's the I mean if you're if you're designing for fun just um You probably have your day job that you need to worry about and so it's it's kind of a very similar thing where if you can find if you can dedicate yourself to um making yourself create something new then you can um you can make sure that you do it that you that you get a new idea you get a new prototype every week or every month or however often you want to do it um
and so my my goal in all of this is that most of these will fail most of them will be terrible but um since I'm kind of running the studio now I need to be looking forward I need to like be researching what the next big thing my studio could be doing is and so um that that has been one way to do that but also since I don't have a whole um bunch of game designers and developers and producers surrounding me I also have to think very differently about scope um I I I can't necessarily plan to do like I want to do a $150 game like Twilight Imperium like if I wanted to I could do that but it's probably going to take me three times as long as as another project and so it's it's given me the freedom to explore different different types of games that um I haven't gotten to do in the past and that's been exciting and it's been fun and and um I'm really looking forward to doing more of it yeah that's awesome and you bring bring up a great point and something I've definitely found in my own experience is there's never a shortage of things that I have to do and so if I don't schedule you know these other things that I want to do it's never going to happen because my my life will get filled up with with whether it's day job stuff family stuff just life stuff Stu and so scheduling is become my best friend it's like all right you know
Tuesday night this is what I'm doing from this time to this time I'm going to schedule and scheduling out okay I'm going to work on some new ideas I'm gonna you know I've been jotting down little notes here and there and on Tuesday night from 6:00 to 800m I'm going to work on these things and once what I figured out is what gets scheduled gets done and so I think that's really good advice but you know tell me a little bit more about what you're excited about you know as you're look into the future unexpected games I'm pumped I can't wait to see what you come up with tell me just in general what you're really excited about maybe some some uh ways you think the the market can go the industry can move you don't have to get too need to you know into the details or the Weeds about it but just kind of overall what are you most excited about sure I mean like I mentioned it's there's thousands of games that come out every single year and so if you don't make a conscious effort to do something different something that's never been seen before then you might just get lost in the noise and so I mean I've designed over a dozen different games and I've tucked touched on a lot of different genres and a lot of different types of games and so for me it's it's been very much about like making games that are different from what I've gotten to do in the past and that I don't know this might feel sound a little hokey but I sometimes think of it as an art right and I'm an artist and an artist doesn't
want to like paint the same painting that they've painted a dozen times before they want to try something new and they want to grow as an individual and they want to prove that they are more than what has already been seen out of them and so uh that's what makes me the most excited is just that like there are some cool things out there that that we can do as designers that haven't been seen before like the perfect game does not exist like because everybody's definition of that is different and there are so many different genres of games and there are even more genres that haven't been invented yet that are just waiting for you to invent and so get out there and and do it yeah absolutely well as we close this thing out give me your best advice to game designers in general you know you've been doing this a long time especially compared to most people that listen to this show who are either just getting started or only been doing it for a few years or so so give me your best advice just to game designers out there listening what would you tell them so the most important thing as a game designer like if you're if you're looking to either join a company that publish it games or you want to do it um by yourself on Kickstarter or something most important thing is just make games like make them make lots of games try lots of different stuff and just become better at it like the first
thing that you work on is not going to be perfect the first thing that you work on is not going to be the next Gloom Haven or the next Twilight Imperium or the next whatever like maybe you'll come up with the brilliant idea but just keep trying just keep at it and whenever people would apply for a game design job at Fantasy Flight games I always tell them that they're like how do I how do I land this job how do I get into the industry how do I do it and I say you don't need my permission like you can you can be designing games right now and if you keep doing that and you're that passionate about it like you can turn it into a job and you can prove to yourself maybe it starts out as just you playing games with your friends like it did for me and like you're able to maybe sell some games to a publisher but just start small and just do the work and keep trying and don't give up awesome Cory really appreciate your time really appreciate you coming on the show Good Luck with unexpected games and all the the cool stuff that you're getting to work on and everything else got going on right now thank you thanks for having me
on